NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
MEMBRANE TECHNOLOGIES DEVELOPMENT IN FOOD
Lidietta Giorno
Institute on Membrane Technology, ITM-CNR
Via P. Bucci 17/C, 87030 Rende (CS), Italy,
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Guidelines• General remarks on food demand
• Membrane processes in food applications– Processes at a maturing stage
– processes at a developing stage
– processes at an emerging stage
• NanoMemPro Food Strategic and Business Research Agenda
• Conclusions
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Food demand
Consumer demand for different food products havesignificantly changed in advanced Countries due to:
•Increasing per capita incomes
•demographic shifts
•lifestyle changes
These Countries share a rising trend toward higherconsumption of:
Meat, Cheese, Fruits, Vegetables, Bottled drinks, Functional foods for special diet
General Remarks
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Consumers want food products that are convenient to useand still have all the qualities of a fresh product
•High quality food (mainatainance or improvement of flavor, color, texture)
•Safety (microbiologically and chemically, materials and methodologies used during processing and preservation do not introduce hazardous compounds)
•Stability (“fresh food” with medium- long-term conservation)
•Convenience (to make food into forms tha are convenient- ease to use)
•Waste prevention, minimization, valorization and recycling (to prevent isbetter than to clean it up)
•Formulation (new products starting from new and enabling raw materials and processing)
•Sustainability (to meet today’s needs without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs)
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
The changes in food consumption have importantimplications for food production, processing, retailsectors and environment through:
• Choise of diet
• Demand for food related services
• Way to purchase, store and prepare food
• Amount of organic and packaging wastesgenerated
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Where and how food is Produced, Processed, Packaged, Preserved, Distributed, Prepared and disposed of
also affects areas such as:
• Energy consumption (production, processing, preservation)
• Waste generation (food losses in the farm, through the retail chain; packaging for households goods, pre-packaged foods, and food packaging for transport and storage)
• Transportation (the direct-related food transport; changes in food shopping; location of hypermarkets outside large cities and small towns)
• GHG emissions (related to direct energy consumption for food preservation, preparation, food transport)
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Waste prevention vs waste minimization
Waste minimization (mass and energy)
Prevention
Reduction at source
Re-use of (by-) co-products
Quality improvements
Recycling
Preventive measures Waste management measures
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Raw materials
(abundant, non toxic, with right properties to be processed)
Technologies
(clean, safe, low energy consumption, preserve properties of products and co-products, allow new product formulation)
Maximize the mass utilization: every component of the raw material that enters the manufacturing process should become a valuable (saleable) product
Maximize energy utilization (every erg introduced should produce a derired material transformation)
Maximize recover and recycling (Recovey in food industry is mainly: oil refining, fuel or energy generation, spreading on land, composting or use of waste.
�Innovative technologies would make easier the recycling of co-products forfood application
Strategies to achieve challenges
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Membrane Technological benefits
�Products are of high quality
�Co-products are of high quality
�Concentration and separation carried out without use of heat
�Permit innovative process design
�Permit innovative formulation strategies
�Equipments need small space, are flexible and are easy to scale-up (they are enabling technologies and well respond to the process
intensification strategy for a sustainable growth)
�Operating costs are low
�The energy used is low (e.g. it can be decreased up to 90% compared to evaporation)
�Recognised among the Best Available Technologies (BAT)
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Membrane technology is recognised asan enabling technology that well respondsto the process intensification strategy for
a sustainable growth
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
• The capital costs are higher compared to evaporation • The increase in concentration might be lower
compared to evaporation(1)
• Relatively short life of the membrane(2)
• Membrane (bio)fouling(2-3)
Membrane Technology
General Drawbacks
Innovations to overcome or minimize drawbacks(1) Integration of RO and MC (MD, OD)(2) Design of new membrane modules and process
systems with optimized fluid dynamics and on-sitecleaning procedures
(3) Membrane materials (or functionalised surfaces) to avoid microrganisms attachment
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Major drivers for Membrane Processes implementation
• More stringent legislation towards Higherfood quality and waste prevention
• Raw material scarsity• State incentives to promote technological
innovation• Increasing confidence in and acceptance
of membrane technology• Public concern• Decreasing of investment costs
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Drivers to decrease cost
• Improvements in process desing• Improved Operation & Maintainance schedules• Greather membrane life• standardization of element dimensions
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Basic
Explora-tory
Development
Technicalservice
Gap
Emerging
Developing
Maturing
Academia Industry
Research effort
Tech
nolo
gy p
erfo
rman
ce
Biocatalytic membrane
reactor
SMBR for wastetreatment
Membrane operations in food industry
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Membrane filtration is state-of-the-arttechnology in food processing
In food industry membrane technology was dominated by the application in:–Treatment of whey and milk,
whey protein concentrationFollowed by:
–beverages, wine, beer, juices
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Membrane processes in food Maturing stage applications
Microfiltration• juice clarification: removal of suspended solids• clarification of cheese whey• defatting and reducing microbial load of milk• beer and wine clarification• color removal and particle removal in sugar industry
Ultrafiltration• juice clarification• fractionation of milk for cheese manufacture• fractionation of whey for whey protein concentrates• protein recovery in meat, fish and poultry industry• gelatin concentration• enzymatic depectinization + UF• starch recovery• high fructose corn syrup from corn starch• solvent recovery and particle removal in oil industry
Basic
Explora-tory
Development
Technicalservice
Gap
Emerging
Developing
Maturing
Academia Industry
Research effort
Tech
nolo
gy p
erfo
rman
ce
Biocatalytic membrane
reactor
SMBR for wastetreatment
Reverse Osmosis• fruit juice concentration• milk concentration • low- alcohol beer• recovery of soy wheyproteins• downstream processin corn refining• water recycling
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Membrane processes in foodDeveloping stage applications
Nanofiltration:• partial demineralization and concentration of whey• caustic/ acid cleaning recovery solution• brine cleaning in fish industry• skim milk modification• purification of dextrose syrup• filtration of bottle washing water and cooling water from disinfection process• solvent-based de-gumming and direct de-gumming• deacidification of vegetable oils• continuous cheese production• production of amino acids and oligosaccharides
Nanofiltration is a more recent operation but already at an advanced developing phase
Basic
Explora-tory
Development
Technicalservice
Gap
Emerging
Developing
Maturing
Academia Industry
Research effort
Tech
nolo
gy p
erfo
rman
ce
Biocatalytic membrane
reactor
SMBR for wastetreatment
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Membrane processes in foodMature technique, but with
limited application
Basic
Explora-tory
Development
Technicalservice
Gap
Emerging
Developing
Maturing
Academia Industry
Research effort
Tech
nolo
gy p
erfo
rman
ce
Biocatalytic membrane
reactor
SMBR for wastetreatment
Electrodialysis�partial demineralization �deacidification
Bipolar eletrodialysis is at an emerging stagein the food industry•convertion of salts into acids and bases•no disposal problem associated with chemicalregeneration (as in IEX)
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Membrane processes in foodExploratory/Developing stage applications
Basic
Explora-tory
Development
Technicalservice
Gap
Emerging
Developing
Maturing
Academia Industry
Research effort
Tech
nolo
gy p
erfo
rman
ce
Biocatalytic membrane
reactor
SMBR for wastetreatment
Membrane emulsification�new product formulation�food texture improvement�low fat-content foods
Membrane contactors� concentration over the RO limit� new production line design
Membrane crystallizer�new product formulation�valorization of co-products
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Membrane emulsification: worldwide patents application
64%8%
11%
11%2% 4%
Japan
Europe
United States of America
World Intellectual PropertyOrganisation (WIPO)
Republic of Korea
China
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Membrane emulsification
• Mid term achievements: • production of uniform micron-sized emulsion on a
large scale (droplet size > 1 micron)• understanding of droplet process formation • understanding of process parameters• emulsions containing labile molecules• modelling of emulsification process• scaleable processes• process compatible with aseptic and sterile
conditions, high temperature (for sterilization), cleaning agent
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Membrane emulsification
Long term achievements: • production of uniform micro-emulsions (droplet size <
50 nm)• inorganic membranes with pore size < 10 nm,
uniform pore size distribution, geometric pore location on the membrane surface, mechanically resistant.
• through understanding of droplet process formation • through understanding of process parameters• emulsions containing labile molecules• modelling of emulsification process• scaleable processes• process compatible with aseptic and sterile
conditions, high temperature (for sterilization), cleaning agent
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Packaging� Biocompatible / biodegradable films � Monitor and control environment� Detect and sensing harmful substances � Packaging easy to use and recyclable� Enhance the functional properties of packaging films by incorporation of nanoparticles (working also as photo-sensors, biosensors, controlled release, ..)
Membrane processes in foodEmerging/Exploratory applications
Basic
Explora-tory
Development
Technicalservice
Gap
Emerging
Developing
Maturing
Academia Industry
Research effort
Tech
nolo
gy p
erfo
rman
ce
Biocatalytic membrane
reactor
SMBR for wastetreatment
Brakes
The new material is permitted for use only after official manufacturer's test data ensures the agencies that the material is safe for use in food packaging.
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Membrane processes in foodEmerging/Exploratory applications
Membrane bioreactors(with membrane as a separation unit)
Biocatalytic membrane reactors (with membranes working as catalytic and separation unit)
�production of functional food ingredients�production of nutraceuticals�improvement of food processability�improve food quality�improve co-products quality�transform deteriorative components
Basic
Explora-tory
Development
Technicalservice
Gap
Emerging
Developing
Maturing
Academia Industry
Research effort
Tech
nolo
gy p
erfo
rman
ce
Biocatalytic membrane
reactor
SMBR for wastetreatment
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
The biocatalyst is continuously flushed along the membrane
The biocatalyst is segregated within the membrane module
The biocatalysts isentrapped within the membrane pores
The biocatalyst is gelified on themembrane
The biocatalyst isbound to themembrane
Physical Ionic Covalentadsorption binding binding
Support binding Cross-linking
The membrane serves asa separation unit
The membrane serves as catalytic and separation unit
+ ++ +
Basic
Explora-tory
Development
Technicalservice
Gap
Emerging
Developing
Maturing
Academia Industry
Research effort
Tech
nolo
gy p
erfo
rman
ce
Biocatalytic membrane
reactor
SMBR for wastetreatment
Membrane bioreactors
Exploratory stage Emerging stage
The biocatalyst is outside the Immersed module
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
MBR Applications in food-preparation of new liquid food (high nutritional milk and easy to digest)- hydrolysis of pectins in fruit pulp- hydrolysis of limonin- malolactic fermentation- vegetal oil processing (olive oil, palm oil, ..), e.g. hydrolysis of triglycerides- oil enrichment with stable lipophilic antibacterial, antioxydants, etc. via hydrolytic processes using oil components (e.g. glucosidases, oleuropein, etc. )- production of natural additives, nutriaceuticals (flavors, ..) by bioprocessing asalternative route to the chemical synthesis (products are natural-like and more pure -e.g. L-amino acids, L-carboxylic acids, etc.)- production of optically pure enantiomers- ester synthesis- biopolymer synthesis
Membrane processes in food:Emerging/Exploratory applications
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Hydrolysis of beta-D-galactosidic linkage of lactose milk (Industrial)ImmobilizedLactase
Production of penycillin (Industrial)Free (Ferm)Penicillin acylase
Production of aspartame (Industrial)imobilizedThermolysin®
Conversion of bitter naringin into no-bitter naringinin + glucoseFreeRamnosidase and β-glucosidase
Conversion of bitter limonin to deoxylimonin acidFreeAcinobacter sp.Corynebacterium f.
Hydrolysis of pectins to improve processability (likely used at industrial level)
Free or immobilizedPectic enzymes
Hydrolysis of oleuropein (to obtain aldehides as bactericides)Free or immobilizedB-glucosidase
Decomposition of hydrogen peroxyde (used as bactericide in raw milk)FreeCatalase
Production of hydrolysed vegetable proteins as flavorants, hydrolysis of prot. to stabilize wine (avoiding bentonite)
Free or immobilizedProteases
Hydrolysis of soluble glycerides releasing short chain fatty acidsFreeEsterases
Hydrolysis of insoluble glycerides at an oil/water interface Free or ImmobilizedLipases
Conversion of D-glucose to D-fructose (Industrial)ImmobilizedGlucose isomerase
ApplicationStatusEnzyme
Enzymes used in food industry
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Biocatalytic membrane reactors
Drivers• Need of more selective processes to achieve pure
products and minimize wastes• Biocatalysis is more selective and appropriate compared
to chemical synthesys for food processing and production • Enzyme heterogeneization increases catalytic stability
and allows continuous operations
Brakes• Trial-and-error approach• Time consuming experimental procedures• lack of demonstrative case-study to proof the robustness
of the technology (most data are proprietary)
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Patents on MBR applications
8%3%
10%
10%69%
Water
food
Pharmaceutical
Biotechnology
Biomedical
Worldwide distribution of patents on MBR
26%
37%5%
16%
5%11%
EU
ZA
KR
JP
CN
US+CA
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Nutraceutical and functional food ingredients production
• Membrane bioreactors in integratedprocesses for production of bioactivecompounds
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Integrated process for continuous bioconversion and separation of carboxylic acid
Feed(substrate, nutrients)
Fermentor
UF
Lactic acid
Retentate
sugar
Bleed
ED, NF, MBSX
Feed(substrate, nutrients)
Fermentor
UF
Lactic acid
Retentate
sugar
Bleed
ED, NF, MBSX
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Continuous Cofactor Regeneration for the Production of L-tert.-Leucine
Formic acid
FDH
NAD-PEG
LEUDH
L-amino acid
CO2
NADH2-
PEGalfa-chetoacid
CO2 L-amino acid
Ultrafiltration membrane
Wandrey C., ICCMR6, Germany (2004)
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Optimization of Integrated membrane processes
Factors affecting integrated membrane operation development
-to improve product quality
-to minimize wastes
-to design new technological routes able to produce co-products instead of by-products
-to approach zero discharge
Reduction of effluent emission and energy consumption
Cases studies of industrial interest
-Production of concentrated fruit juices
-Extraction and concentration of essential oil
-Treatment and valorization of food industry by-products
-Extraction, purification and bioconversion of olive fruit extracts
-Preparation of nutraceutical and functional food ingredients from a large variety of agricultural resources
-Production of fermented organic acids
-Fish oil separation and production of new foods
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Nanofiltration:• Concentration• Demineralization
Microfiltration:
• Clarification of cheese wheydefatting.• Cold sterilization of milk for medium-term conservation• Cycles with pastorizationfor long-term conservationof milk
Ultrafiltration:• Concentration to reduce
refrigeration andtrasportation costsMBR
DelactosizationProtein hydrolysis
Reverse osmosis:• Concentration
Electrodyalisis:• Partial
demineralization
Membrane operations in milk
and dairy
Integrated processes
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
�Ceramic membranes are more expensivethan polymeric ones in the short term
�In most cases they do become more effective in the long term
�They are more stable to cleaning solutions, temperature prohibitive for bacteria growth, and can be stems sterilized
�Longer life cycles
Interest towards ceramic membrane increased
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Nanofiltration,Osmotic distillation,Pervaporation:• Concentration• Aroma compounds recovery
Microfiltration:
Clarification
Ultrafiltration:Clarification
MBR
Reverse osmosis:Concentration
Electrodyalisis:Deacidification
Membrane Operation in Fruit
Juices and AlcoholicBeverages
Integrated processes
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
• Inability to have the same concentrationriched byevaporation becausehigh osmoticpressure limitation
RO Limitations
• Membrane and osmoticdistillation• integratedmembrane processes
Advances
•lower thermaldamage•Increase of aroma retention•Less energyconsumption•Lower equipmentcosts
RO Advantages
Advantages on membrane processes for fruitjuices concentration
B.Jiao, A. Cassano, E. Drioli, Journal of Food Engineering 63 (2004) 303.324
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Advantages and disadvantages of MD and OD applied to the concentration of fruit juice
• Production costs higherthan the thermalevaporation• High cost of membrane replacement
Economical aspect• Low investement cost
• New technology thatrequires an evaluation at industrial level, flexibility to be evaluated• Low evaporative capacity(3 l/ m 2h) with a long time of treatment
Technical aspects• Techniques suitable for heat-sensitive products• A 60% of dry matter can be reached in the concentratedproduct• Modularity, easy scale-up• Possibility to treat solutions with high level of suspen dedsolids• Possibility of using modules in series, the same unit c an concentrate several different products• Low temperature• Low operating pressures• No fouling problems, costant permeate flux in time• New technologies based on the use of conventional well- testedmaterials
DisadvatagesAdvantages
B.Jiao, A. Cassano, E. Drioli, Journal of Food Engineering 63 (2004) 303.324
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Membranes applications in brewing industry
After R. Reed, Membrane Technology, 101 (1998), 1998 , 5-8(4)
established (*)recent (**) potential (***)
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Rotating and Vibrating filtration for clarificationof rough beer
L. Fillaudeau et al, Investigation of rotating and vibrating filtration for clarification of rough beer, Journal of Food Engineering 80 (2007) 206–217
Dlatomaceous earth (Kleselguhr)Particles (yeast, colloids)Solutes (fine particles, macromolecules)
Dlatomaceous earth (Kleselguhr)Particles (yeast, colloids)Solutes (fine particles, macromolecules)
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
Membrane processes in integrated wine production systems
Reverseosmosis
Microfiltration
Reverse Osmosis + Diafiltration
Reverse Osmosis + NanofiltrationAfter Frank Lipnizki et al., Filtration & Separation, Volume 43, Issue 2, March 2006, 41
MBR(Potential)
5
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
� The roadmap has been designed as a 3 step process c haracterized by an intensive collaboration between industrialists and research institutes.
Means
Processsteps
Reconnaissance phase
Mappingphase
Accelerationphase
Objectives
Step 1 Step 2 Step 3
Identification of targets for innovation
Identification of technological paths
to innovation
Implementation of custom action
plans
With the assistance of ALCIMED, setting up of an in tensive collaboration between industrialists and NanoMemPro to structure
the forthcoming European R&D on membranes
The roadmap methodology2006 2007
Mo
du
lesP
rocess
Mem
bran
esS
tart up
drivers
To
pics d
iscussed
Bio reactors Innovative m
embrane based processes in food product
ion and processing
Integrated mem
brane processes
Roadm
ap Fo
od
-O
verview
Affinity m
embranes
Contactors
Strong industry imperatives : 1. Membrane technologies costs are too high, especially in comparison with other competitive technologies. 2. Time is a huge imperative in the food industry. As it is a consumer good industry, membrane technologies need to be developed quickly and implement quickly on production lines.
Development directions : 1. Developments should focus on existing membrane technologies to improve them & on operations that are already run in factories. 2. Sensors or packaging membranes could not impose
today easily as many other techniques do exist, work well and have a low cost of use.
Extern
al con
text
Packaging
Sensors
Mem
brane emulsification and encapsulation
Mo
delin
g
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
The common opinion about challenges and needs of membranes in food applications concerned the research development on:
• functionalized membranes – for immobilization of biomolecules, e.g. for the development of membrane
reactors, affinity UF, microstructured multifunctional systems – for creating surfaces able to repulse cells and biomolecules, e.g. to control
biofouling– for preparing intelligent packaging able to control the release of drugs when
necessary and/or to detect the presence of harmful substances
• formulation (microemulsion and encapsulation; need for inorganic membranes with very low pore size and pore size distribution)
• design of integrated membrane processes considering the raw material as well as the consumer demand and acceptance
• integration of biocatalysis with membrane operations• Integrated membrane systems to achieve zero discharge
NanoMemPro - WP 11.2 NanoMemFood Workshop, 20 March 2008, Paris (France)
ITM-CNR
The major objective during the last NoE period
To identify case studies of industrial interest and plan common actions to proof the processes robustness by building-up demonstration plants and running long term experiments at industrial infrastructures
� Each of the 22 subjects discussed was therefore tra nslated into a specific framework giving an exhaustive overview of what was told during the workshops.
Roadmap presentationInformation treatment
Subject discussed during workshops
Membrane Modules Process
�
Field of research 1
Field of research 2
Driver for membrane introduction in factories 1
Technological element impacted
Industrial implementation drivers
Not discussed
t
t t t
t t
Short term topic0-5 years
Mid term topic5-10 years
Long term topic>10 years
No timetable specified
GO option:Industrialists consider there is a room for improvement through research
NO GO option:industrialists are not interested in new research nor developments
x
x
Driver for membrane introduction in factories 2
� Then, for each workshop, all corresponding subject’ s frameworks were synthesized into a preliminary roadmap.
Roadmap presentationInformation treatment
Indicators measuring participants’ concern on the topics
Modules ProcessMembranesStart up driversTopics discussed
Subject 2
Subject 1
Issue 1
xxx.
..
External context
Industrial drivers facilitating membrane technology implementation in factories
Developments required a specific element of membrane technology
Key facts - non technical - linked to contextual issues: strategy, market
& policy drivers….
Issues & subjects discussed
Strong participation / remarks
Middle participation / remarks
Low participation / remarks
xxx.
..
x t
No Go R&D option mentioned by industrialists
Priority:Short termMid termLong term
ttt
tt t
� Other information was added, from a prospective exe rcise of NanoMemPro core partners on the development of membrane techno logies (summarized in a document entitled “Dreams”). In order to keep infor mation traceable, different colors were used for this contribution (red/pink fo r indicators and yellow/red for drivers)
Roadmap presentationInformation treatment
Modules ProcessMembranesStart up driversTopics discussed
Subject 2
Subject 1
Issue 1
xxx.
..
External context
xxx.
..
x t
Driver for membrane introduction in factories 1
Industrial-related academic prospects
t t tLong term topic>10 years
Timingsnot specified
Driver for membrane introduction in factories 2
Roadmap presentation Food
Innovative membrane based processes in food product ion and processing (1/3)
Membrane Modules Process
�
Bioreactors
Consider membranes and biocatalysts (e.g. enzymes, cells, etc.) all together and develop
generic methods to graft any kind of enzyme or to include them on the material
Increase process control of micro-reactors
Keep biocatalysts active and achieve a good conversion, stability and reproducibility
Target a total integration of many operations in 1 single membrane process
Convince industrialists that have had bad experiences with bioreactors and anticipate the technology fear within industrial conditions (i.e. proof the robustness of the technology by developing a sufficient number of established reference cases so as to convince decision makers of the potential of the
technology)
Achieve 2 different operations with good results for eacht
t t t
t t t
Insist on the cleaning facilitation linked to operations’ merging
Work on costs to push the technology
t
Move from trial-and error to a predictive approach (i.e. modeling both on a bulk and
microenvironment level)
Improve module design
Standardize manufacturing (e.g. dimension, connections, etc. so as to
increase adaptability to various plants)
Better understanding of catalyst included within the membrane material (i.e. structure/function related interactions between biocatalyst and
membrane; effects of microenvironment conditions on kinetics and transport properties)
Work on safe, low energy input, waste minimization, low environment impact properties of the technology
Roadmap presentation Food
Innovative membrane based processes in food product ion and processing (2/3)
Membrane Modules Process
�
Packaging
Contactors
Develop lower cost packaging membranes to compete with existing packaging solutions
Work on membranes able to work in a modified atmosphere, under UV and with antimicrobial protection (for the cheese industry for example)
Use of membrane contactors is already a reality. Possible use on proteins crystallization as a polish step to an operation of filtration
For membrane contactors, a strong action is needed to convince industrialists since competitive technologies are already working well.
t t
t
Develop multifunctional, stimuli responsive (bio) packaging, reusable and/or recyclable
t t
Low cost hydrophobic membranes with increased stability
Use of membrane contactors as a new product formulation and co-products valorization process, including highly
purified water
Use of membrane contactors to achieve highly concentrated liquid food with benefits
in fresh food shelf-life and lower cost for distribution (i.e. use MC as a post treatment
step after RO)
Innovative modules able to face highly concentrated
puree
t t
t
Proof of the suitability of membrane contactors as a new formulation process (e.g. concentrating liquid beverage up to an osmotic pressure able to increase shelf-life of fresh food, valorization of co-products via crystallization, production of highly purified water)
Innovative low cost modules with improved fluid dynamics and
higher membrane surface per unit volume
Membrane Modules Process
Sensors
Limited developments required since other sensors technologies work well and have many capacities: on line,
in-situ control…
Affinity membranes
x
Innovative membrane based processes in food product ion and processing (3/3)�
Development of biohybrid membrane systems as biosensors for food applications (e.g. packaging, food safety and quality
testing, etc.)
Functionalized micro structured membranes with controlled organization of functional components Modules with improved properties in
terms of paths and residence time
Development of continuous membrane separation process (instead of chromatographic
operation mode)
Proof of the suitability of affinity membranes for fractionation and purification
Work on large scale applications to facilitate membrane implementation and allow them to substitute ion exchange resins and other competitive technologies, such as preparative chromatography
Roadmap presentation Food
Roadmap presentation Food
Integrated membrane processes (1/2)
Membrane Modules
Process
�
Improve pore size distribution
Optimize pores to achieve a more precise fractionation of products in a limited ground surface � work on surface functionalization with proteins or
other compounds
Cope with issues of different texture of fluids treated during pre-concentration
Optimize pre filtration to preserve product texturation and the process continuation
t
Modules with standard properties (e.g. size, connectors, etc.)
Design of new configuration of membrane assembling to intensify processes
Develop innovative manufacturing/ processing lines able to move towards zero
discharge/emission
Integrate bioconversion and bio processing with membrane operations into productive and
separative cycles
t t t
t
Proof the robustness of integrated processes (hybrid membrane systems or together with
other systems) with selected reference cases (juice, milk, wine, production of potable water,
etc.)
t
Process
Roadmap presentation Food
Integrated membrane processes (2/2)�
Develop efficient cleaning procedures with limited water required and low costs in order to deal with the sterilization issue
Reduce development time to fit with industrial constraints and competitiveness needs
Strong need to have pilot plants to check results
Anticipate the evolution of membrane performance with time
Develop processes that allow meeting new regulations in terms of food safety, quality, waste minimization, environmental impact
Membrane emulsification and encapsulation
Membrane Modules Process
�
Inorganic membranes with pore size < 10 nm, uniform pore size distribution, geometric pore
location on the membrane surface, mechanically resistant
Membranes with controlled pore size distribution
Modules with standard properties (e.g. size, connectors, etc.)
Design of new configuration of membrane modules and operation
(e.g. rotating modules)
Modeling of emulsification and encapsulation processes, scalable
processes, processes compatible with aseptic and sterile conditions, high
temperature (for sterilization), cleaning agent
Through understanding of droplet process formation through understanding of process
parameters
t t t
t t
Innovative product formulations (e.g. having low fat content, with nutraceutical
properties, etc.)
Roadmap presentation Food
Production of uniform micro-emulsions on a large scale (droplet size < 50 nm)t t t
Production of controlled size distribution emulsions and capsules on a large scalet t