+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new...

Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new...

Date post: 25-Dec-2015
Category:
Upload: amie-parrish
View: 225 times
Download: 1 times
Share this document with a friend
Popular Tags:
99
Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and treatment population Dawn Bales, Helene Andrea, Maaike Smits, Joost Hutsebaut Psychotherapeutic Center de Viersprong, Viersprong Institute for Studies on Personality Disorders (VISPD) The Netherlands Dedicated to Ab van Wezep †
Transcript
Page 1: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder:

A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and

treatment population

Dawn Bales, Helene Andrea, Maaike Smits, Joost Hutsebaut Psychotherapeutic Center de Viersprong,

Viersprong Institute for Studies on Personality Disorders (VISPD)

The Netherlands

Dedicated to Ab van Wezep †

Borderline Congres – Berlin, July 2th 2010

Page 2: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Research teamDe Viersprong – Roel Verheul, Dawn Bales, Maaike Smits, Helene Andrea,

Joost Hutsebaut, Katharina Koch, Fieke v/d MeerErasmus University Rotterdam – Reinier Timman, Jan van Busschbach

Tilburg University – Marieke Spreeuwenberg

&

MBT Staff(De Viersprong, Bergen op Zoom, The Netherlands)

Internet:

www.vispd.nl / presentations

Email [email protected]

Page 3: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Does MBT work?

A summary of the evidence

Dawn Bales

Page 4: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Content Mentalization-Based Treatment (MBT)

A summary of the evidence & new evidence

Does MBT work? Are the effects lasting? What does it cost? Does MBT work in another dosage? Does MBT work for another population?

• Double diagnosed patients• Adolescents

New developments

Page 5: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Mentalization-based Treatment

Psychoanalytically oriented; based on attachment theory Developed in the UK by Bateman & Fonagy Evidence-based DH and IOP treatment for patients with

severe BPD Maximum duration of 18 months Focus: increasing patient’s capacity to mentalize

Page 6: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Essential features of the program

Highly structured Consistent and reliable Intensive Theoretically coherent: all aspects aimed at enhancing

mentalizing capacity Flexible Relationship focus Outreaching Individualized treatment plan Individualized follow-up

Page 7: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Goals To engage the patient in treatment

To reduce general psychiatric symptoms, particularly depression and anxiety

To decrease the number of self-destructive acts and suicide attempts

To improve social and interpersonal functioning

To prevent reliance on prolonged hospital stays

Page 8: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

A summary of the evidence 1. Does MBT work?

RCT Day-hospital vs TAU (1999 UK, 20.. NL) Partial Replication Study (2010 NL)

2. Are the effects lasting? 18 month Follow-up (2001 UK, 2011 NL) Long term follow-up (2009 UK)

3. MBT vs. other psychotherapy? (2010 ? NL)

4. What does MBT cost? (2003 UK, 2011? NL)

5. Does MBT work in another dosage? RCT IOP (2009 UK) Start RCT Dosis (2010 NL)

6. Does MBT work for another population? • Double diagnosed patients• Adolescents

Page 9: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Does MBT work?MBT De Viersprong

•First study manualized DH MBT outside UK

• Research question: What is the applicability and treatment outcome of day hospital Mentalization Based Treatment for severe BPD patients in the Netherlands?

• Naturalistic setting N=45 severe borderline patients with high comorbidity on both axis I and II

Bales et al., submitted, 2010

Page 10: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Example patient Because of anonimisity reasons, this information has been deleted

Page 11: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Treatment outcome 0-18 months UK & NL

Effectsize NL 1.26

Submitted for publicaton – do not quote

Page 12: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Treatment outcome 0-18 months UK & NL

Effectsize NL 1.23

Submitted for publicaton – do not quote

Page 13: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Treatment outcome 0-18 months UK & NL

Effectsize NL 1.36

Submitted for publicaton – do not quote

Page 14: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Treatment outcome 0-18 months UK & NL

Submitted for publicaton – do not quote

Page 15: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Effectsizes 1.23– 1.74

very large

SIPP: Verheul et al, 2008

Results Personality pathology

Page 16: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Results and conclusion DH MBT

Low dropout rate (n=4; 8.9%) despite limited exclusion criteria

Significant improvement on all outcome measures with effect sizes ranging from large to very large

Not only symptomatic improvement but also improvement in interpersonal and personality functioning

Results comparable to results of Bateman & Fonagy (1999)

Bales et al., submitted, 2010

Page 17: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

A summary of the evidence 1. Does MBT work?

RCT Day-hospital vs TAU (1999 UK, 20.. NL) Partial Replication Study (2010 NL)

2. Are the effects lasting? 18 month Follow-up (2001 UK, 2011 NL) Long term follow-up (2009 UK)

3. MBT vs. other psychotherapy? (2010 ? NL)

4. What does MBT cost? (2003 UK, 2011? NL)

5. Does MBT work in another dosage? RCT IOP (2009 UK) Start RCT Dosis (2010 NL)

6. Does MBT work for another population? • Double diagnosed patients• Adolescents

Page 18: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Are the effects lasting?

18 month Follow-up UK 2001:

MBT patients maintained and even showed additional improvement of symptomatic and clinical gains during 18 months follow-up

18 month Follow-up Netherlands

Preliminary results analyzed June 2010

N= 61

Highly comorbid borderline patients

Page 19: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

18 month follow-up UK and NL

Preliminary results 2010 – do not quote

Page 20: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

18 month follow-up UK and NL

Preliminary results 2010 – do not quote

Page 21: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

18 month follow-up UK and NLEffectsize NL

18-36 months

1.49

Preliminary results 2010 – do not quote

Page 22: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

18 month follow-up UK and NL

Preliminary results 2010 – do not quote

Page 23: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

18 month follow-up UK and NL

Cutoff BPDSI

Effectsize NL

18-36 months

1.98

Preliminary results 2010 – do not quote

Page 24: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Effectsizes 1.15-2.14

very large

SIPP: Verheul et al, 2008

Results Personality pathology

18-36 months

Page 25: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Conclusions 18 month FU NL

Results comparable to results of Bateman & Fonagy (1999):

Continuing decline in depression, symptom distress, minimal acts of suicide attempts and self harm throughout follow-up period

Also: continuing improvement in personality functioning and specific borderline symptoms

Preliminary results 2010 – do not quote

Page 26: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Patient example: follow-up

Page 27: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Are the effects lasting?8 year follow-up UK

Study: the effect of MBT-PH vs. TAU • N=41 patients from original trial• 8 years after entry in to RCT, 5 years

after all MBT treatment was complete

Method: • interviews (research psychologists blind

to original group allocation)• structured review medical notes

Bateman & Fonagy (2008) Am J Psychiatry

Page 28: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Zanarini Rating Scale for BPD : mean (SD)

MBT-PH (n = 22)

TAU (n=15)

Significance

Positive criteria n (%) 3 (13.6) 13 (86.7) χ2 = 16.5 p=.000004

Total mean (SD) 5.5 (5.2) 15.1 (5.3) F1,35 = 29.7 p=.000004

Affect mean (SD) 1.6 (2.0) 3.7 (2.0) F1,35 = 9.7p=.004

Cognitive mean (SD) 1.1 (1.4) 2.5 (2.0) F1,35 = 6.9 p=.02

Impulsivity mean (SD) 1.6 (1.8) 4.1 (2.3) F1,35 = 13.9 p=.001

Interpersonal mean (SD)

1.5 (1.7) 4.7 (2.3) F1,35 = 23.2p=.00003

Bateman & Fonagy (2008) Am J Psychiatry

Page 29: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Suicide attempts : mean (SD)

MBT-PH TAU Significance

Total N

mean (SD)

.05 (0.9) 0.52 (.48)

U = 73

Z= 3.9

p = .00004

Any attempt N (%)

5 (23) 14 (74) χ2 = 8.7

df- =1

P =.003

Bateman & Fonagy (2008) Am J Psychiatry

Page 30: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Global Assessment of Function

MBT-PH TAU Significance

Mean (SD) 58.3 (10.5) 51.8 (5.7)

F1,35 = 5.4 p=.03

Number (%) > 60

10 (45.5) 2 (10.5) χ2 = 6.5

df = 1

p = .02

Bateman & Fonagy (2008) Am J Psychiatry

Page 31: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Conclusions from long term follow-up

MBT-PH group continued to do well 5 years after all MBT treatment had ceased

TAU did badly within services despite significant input

TAU is not necessarily ineffective in its components but package or organization is not facilitating possible natural recovery

BUT Small sample, allegiance effects (despite attempts being

made to blind the data collection) limit the conclusions. GAF scores continue to indicate deficits. Suggests less

focus during treatment on symptomatic problems greater concentration on improving general social adaptation

Bateman & Fonagy (2008) Am J Psychiatry

Page 32: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

A summary of the evidence 1. Does MBT work?

RCT Day-hospital vs TAU (1999 UK, 20.. NL) Partial Replication Study (2010 NL)

2. Are the effects lasting? 18 month Follow-up (2001 UK, 2011 NL) Long term follow-up (2009 UK)

3. MBT vs. other psychotherapy? (2010 ? NL)

4. What does MBT cost? (2003 UK, 2011? NL)

5. Does MBT work in another dosage? RCT IOP (2009 UK) Start RCT Dosis (2010 NL)

6. Does MBT work for another population? • Double diagnosed patients• Adolescents

Page 33: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Matched samples: Matched samples:

Patient characteristics and treatment outcome for Patient characteristics and treatment outcome for MBT versus MBT versus

3 other psychotherapeutic treatment settings3 other psychotherapeutic treatment settings

Helene Andrea

Page 34: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Background

UK results: MBT superior to standard psychiatric care(Bateman & Fonagy 1999, 2001, 2008)

As yet no direct comparison between MBT andother psychotherapeutic programs

Study aim: What is the effectiveness of day hospital MBT when Study aim: What is the effectiveness of day hospital MBT when compared to other psychotherapeutic treatment settings?compared to other psychotherapeutic treatment settings?

SCEPTRE: Direct comparison MBT and- Outpatient, day hospital and inpatient psychotherapy - Matched-control design

Page 35: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Matched control study: Patient sample

SCEPTRE:

N=923 patients with personality pathology

Referred to psychotherapy in the Netherlands

N=214 BPD patients

N=39 MBT N=175 other treatment setting

Assignment not random -> Selection biasAssignment not random -> Selection bias

Page 36: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Correction for selection bias(baseline group differences)

Propensity score A sophisticated co-variance analysis Combines several

co-variates in 1 score

If successful “Imitation” of random

assignment Applicable in

non-randomised studies

Page 37: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

MBT (n=39) vs. SCEPTRE (n=175): Baseline differences

Severity personalitypathology (SIPP):- Identity integration- Relational functioning- Responsibility- Self control- Social concordance

Personality disorders (SIDP-IV interview):- Number cluster C PDs- Number PDNOS- Number BPD criteria

Psychiatric symptoms (SCL) Quality of life (EQ-5D) Social rol (OQ-45)

Treatment history(outpatient / day hospital / inpatient)

Sexe Age Educational level Living situation (partner y/n) Care responsibility for

children

Combined in 1 score = Propensity ScoreCombined in 1 score = Propensity Score

Page 38: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

MBT: for 31% PS too high (= too severe) -> Matching not possibleMBT: for 31% PS too high (= too severe) -> Matching not possible

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0

Propensity Score

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

Fre

quen

cy

Mean = 0,1241811Std. Dev. = 0,13505588N = 175

SCEPTRE

0,00 0,20 0,40 0,60 0,80 1,00

Propensity Score

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

Fre

quen

cy

Mean = 0,4427772Std. Dev. = 0,29641958N = 39

MBT

MBT versus SCEPTRE before matching

Page 39: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Matches for n=21 MBT:

N=21 SCEPTRE

Setting Mean Teatment

Duration

Inpatient(47%)

11.7 Months(sd 8.7)

Day hospital

(29%)

10.2 months(sd 6.6)

Outpatient

(24%)

24.2 months(sd 15.5)

Page 40: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Effectiveness analysis

For the MBT and SCEPTRE matches(hence, without the “more severe MBT-patients”)

Mixed model Between effect: Group comparison Within effect: Time dependency Main outcome: GSI change score (SCL)

- Change score = Time of follow-up measurement – Baseline- Negative score = improvement

Page 41: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

(Preliminary) effectiveness results

In favor of effectiveness MBTIn favor of effectiveness MBT

Page 42: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Conclusions

Treatment groups31% of MBT patients could not be matched;A considerable amount of MBT patients are likely

excluded from other psychotherapeutic treatments

Treatment outcome (Preliminary) evidence in favour of MBT when

compared to other psychotherapeutic treatments In line with results of Bateman &

Fonagy (1999, 2001, 2008)

Page 43: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Limitations

N is relatively small;

Several relevant severity variables are missing;e.g. substance use disorders, GAF, self-harm, suicidality

Relatively large amount of missings in the MBT group;

Different treatment setting and durations- subgroup analysis

Page 44: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

A summary of the evidence 1. Does MBT work?

RCT Day-hospital vs TAU (1999 UK, 20.. NL) Partial Replication Study (2010 NL)

2. Are the effects lasting? 18 month Follow-up (2001 UK, 2011 NL) Long term follow-up (2009 UK)

3. MBT vs. other psychotherapy? (2010 ? NL)

4. What does MBT cost? (2003 UK, 2011? NL)

5. Does MBT work in another dosage? RCT IOP (2009 UK) Start RCT Dosis (2010 NL)

6. Does MBT work for another population? • Double diagnosed patients• Adolescents

Page 45: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

What does MBT cost?

Does MBT work in other dosages?- Intensive Outpatient MBT

- Patients with substance use disorders

Maaike Smits

Page 46: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Total Annual Health Care Utilization Costs

Cost-effectiveness Bateman & Fonagy, UK 2003

Significantly lower cost during treatment compared to 6-month pretreatment costs for both MBT and General Care Group

During FU period: annual cost of MBT 1/5 of anual General Care costs

Page 47: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

A summary of the evidence 1. Does MBT work?

RCT Day-hospital vs TAU (1999 UK, 20.. NL) Partial Replication Study (2010 NL)

2. Are the effects lasting? 18 month Follow-up (2001 UK, 2011 NL) Long term follow-up (2009 UK)

3. MBT vs. other psychotherapy? (2010 ? NL)

4. What does MBT cost? (2003 UK, 2011? NL)

5. Does MBT work in another dosage? RCT IOP (2009 UK) Start RCT Dosis (2010 NL)

6. Does MBT work for another population? • Double diagnosed patients• Adolescents

Page 48: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Design of intensive out-patient MBT randomized controlled trial

RCT IOP-MBT vs. SCM groups (N = 134)

Random allocation (minimisation for age, gender, antisocial PD)

Individual (50 mins) + Group (1.5 hrs) weekly for 18 months

Assessments at admission, 6 months, 12 months, 18 months

Medication followed protocol

IOP vs. SCM Bateman & Fonagy (2009) Am J Psychiatry

Page 49: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Therapy

MBT - weekly Support and structure Challenge Basic mentalizing Interpretive mentalizing Mentalizing the

transference Medication review Crisis management

SCM - weekly Support and structure Challenge Advocacy Social support work Problem solving Medication review Crisis management

IOP vs. SCM Bateman & Fonagy (2009) Am J Psychiatry

Page 50: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Percent of Sample Who Had Attempted Suicide, Self-harmed, or were Hospitalized in Last Six Months

0

20

40

60

80

100

Per

cen

t w

ith

In

cid

ent

Baseline Six Months TwelveMonths

EighteenMonths

SCM MBT

n.s.p<.02

p<.0002

IOP vs. SCM Bateman & Fonagy (2009) Am J Psychiatry

Page 51: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Percent who had made life threatening suicide attempt

0

20

40

60

80

Per

cen

t w

ho

att

emp

t

Baseline Six Months TwelveMonths

EighteenMonths

SCM MBT

n.s.

n.s.

n.s.

p<.0004

IOP vs. SCM Bateman & Fonagy (2009) Am J Psychiatry

Page 52: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Percent of who seriously self harmed

0

20

40

60

80

Per

cen

t W

ho

Sel

f-H

arm

Baseline Six Months TwelveMonths

EighteenMonths

SCM MBTn.s. p <.08

p<.05

p<.05

IOP vs. SCM Bateman & Fonagy (2009) Am J Psychiatry

Page 53: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Average Beck Depression Scores

10

15

20

25

30

35

6 months prior totreatment

6 months 12 months End of treatment 18months

Mean

Dep

ressio

n (

BD

I) s

co

res

SCM MBT

IOP vs. SCM Bateman & Fonagy (2009) Am J Psychiatry

Page 54: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Average Interpersonal Problems Scores

1

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

2

2.2

2.4

6 months prior totreatment

6 months 12 months End of treatment18 months

Mean

To

tal

Inte

rpers

on

al

Pro

ble

ms (

IIP

) sco

res

SCM MBT

IOP vs. SCM Bateman & Fonagy (2009) Am J Psychiatry

Page 55: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Conclusions Both groups showed improvement over 18 months

BUT DIFFERENT RATES OF CHANGE

MBT-OP was superior to SCM-OP – differences started to emerge after 6 months suicide attempts and severe incidents of self harm self-reported measures of psychiatric symptoms and

social adjustment

Rate of improvement in both groups was higher than spontaneous remission of symptoms of BPD estimated from follow-along studies

Results support emphasis on highly structured treatment approaches

IOP vs. SCM Bateman & Fonagy (2009) Am J Psychiatry

Page 56: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

IOP in the Netherlands

Two times group psychotherapy, 75 min per week

One individual contact per week

Maximum duration 18 months

RCT IOP versus Day hospital treatment Minimal a priori exclusion criteria

Page 57: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

A summary of the evidence 1. Does MBT work?

RCT Day-hospital vs TAU (1999 UK, 20.. NL) Partial Replication Study (2010 NL)

2. Are the effects lasting? 18 month Follow-up (2001 UK, 2011 NL) Long term follow-up (2009 UK)

3. MBT vs. other psychotherapy? (2010 ? NL)

4. What does MBT cost? (2003 UK, 2011? NL)

5. Does MBT work in another dosage? RCT IOP (2009 UK) Start RCT Dosis (2010 NL)

6. Does MBT work for another population? • Double diagnosed patients• Adolescents

Page 58: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Substance abuse among MBT patients : Prevalence and relation to treatment outcome

57%-67% BPD patients addiction problems -> MBT? Worse treatment prognosis

What is the prevalence of substance abuse among

MBT-patients?

Additional explorative analysis:Is substance abuse related to MBT treatment outcome?

N= 39 Substance abuse measuremunt:CIDI N=24

Substance use disorders study, Bales et al. (manuscript 2010)

Page 59: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

CIDI-SAM

Abuse / dependence

Total population

(N = 24)

79.2%

(N = 19)

Results: Prevalence substance disorders

No substance

Diagnosis

21%(N = 5)

1

diagnosis

13%

(N = 3)

2

diagnoses

21%

(N = 5)

3-5

diagnoses

29%

(N = 7)

6-7

diagnoses

17%

(N = 4)Specific prevalences:

1. Alcohol 67% (N = 16)

2. Cannabis 58% (N = 14)

3. Cocaine 42% (N = 10)

Mean = 2.8 diagnosis

Median = 2 diagnosis

Substance use disorders study, Bales et al. (manuscript 2010)

Page 60: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Interaction time * Lifetime substance abuse

Pattern for 50% of the outcome measures:

SCL-90, BDI, OQ Symptom distress, OQ interpersonal relations,

OQ social concordance, SIPP identity integration and

Quality of life.

Substance use disorders study, Bales et al. (manuscript 2010)

Page 61: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

New comparison subgroups

N = 5 no lifetime substance abuse

N = 19 lifetime substance abuse

Diagnosis starttreatment?

Yes: N = 13 No: N = 6

Diagnosis start treatmentDiagnosis start treatmentYes: N = 13

No: N = 11 (n = 5 + n = 6)

Substance use disorders study, Bales et al. (manuscript 2010)

Page 62: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Interaction time * substance abuse start treatment

Pattern:

- No significant interaction effect

- Improvement substance abusers start treatment (n=13) resembles improvement non abusers start treatment (n=11)

Substance use disorders study, Bales et al. (manuscript 2010)

Page 63: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

SummaryLifetime substance abuse: 19 lifetime-abusers versus 5 non lifetime- abusers Tendency towards stronger improvement for

small group without lifetime substance abuse

Substance abuse start treatment: 13 abusers versus 11 non abusers No difference in improvement over time

(Preliminary) Conclusions Very high prevalence (79%) lifetime substance abuse

diagnosis among MBT patients Significant improvement possible for DD patients

(severe BPD and substance use disorders)

Substance use disorders study, Bales et al. (manuscript 2010)

Page 64: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

BPD and addiction: Patient examples

Page 65: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

New Developments: MBT-DD

MBT-PH and IOP: parallel low-frequent out-patient contact in addiction-center

Plan: integrated MBT- DD treatment

Program: inpatient detox 5 days a week day-hospital (PH) outpatient treatment

Including system-oriented interventions Research

Page 66: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

A summary of the evidence 1. Does MBT work?

RCT Day-hospital vs TAU (1999 UK, 20.. NL) Partial Replication Study (2010 NL)

2. Are the effects lasting? 18 month Follow-up (2001 UK, 2011 NL) Long term follow-up (2009 UK)

3. MBT vs. other psychotherapy? (2010 ? NL)

4. What does MBT cost? (2003 UK, 2011? NL)

5. Does MBT work in another dosage? RCT IOP (2009 UK) Start RCT Dosis (2010 NL)

6. Does MBT work for another population? • Double diagnosed patients• Adolescents

Page 67: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Mentalization-based Treatment for severe personality

disorders in adolescents

Joost Hutsebaut

Page 68: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

PDs in adolescence: some facts

PDs are underdiagnosed in adolescence

Adolescents with PDs suffer even more than adults with PDs

Adolescents with PDs cost society annually € 14479,- (Feenstra et al., in prep)

There are no treatment guidelines/evidence based treatments for (severe) PDs in adolescents

Page 69: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Innovative/experimental treatment program: MBT-A

What? A treatment program aiming to improve mentalizing capacities in adolescents and their parents

For whom? For adolescents suffering from severe borderline PDs (and their families)

Based on: Mentalization-based treatment (Bateman and Fonagy)

Page 70: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

MBT-A versus MBT: double innovation

Adaptation of an adult model for adolescents Developmentally specific (Multi)systemic approach

Adaptation of an outpatient model to an inpatient setting Pedagogics in line with MBT (limit setting) Dosage of intensity of attachment

Described in an unpublished manual

Page 71: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Developmental aspects of mentalizing in adolescence

Adolescence has a double impact on the ability to mentalize

Impact of developmental changes (biological, emotional, cognitive, social,…) on the ability to mentalize

• Cognitive development enhances abilities to mentalize about others by enhancing the ability to take different perspectives, think in a more abstract way etc

Impact of developmental tasks on the ability to mentalize• The need to ‘separate’ from parents reduces the ability to mentalize (at

some times) about parents (and vice versa)

Page 72: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

(Multi-)systemic perspective

Adolescents often are closely connected to their family of origin and experience attachment reactions of their parents

• Reactions of parents are often antecedents of failure in mentalizing (and v.v.)

• Parents have lost their ability to mentalize about their child

• Parents and children are absorbed in unmentalizing interactions (excessive control, closing their eyes for problems)

Adolescents are embedded in multiple systems influencing them (school, peer group, neighborhood, justice)

Page 73: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Adaptations to the original model

(By far) Most aspects remain unchanged Treatment principles: highly structured, coherent,

consistent, focus on affect, focus on relationships, focus on here and now, outreaching,…

Clinical processes: group and individual therapy, signal plan, treatment evaluations, treatment goals,…

(MBT is a very adolescent-friendly model)

Page 74: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Adaptations to the original MBT-model

Some aspects (probably) remain unchanged, but deserve special attention Therapeutic attitude:

• open, transparant

• playful, use of humor

• flexible concerning the therapeutic frame

• casual, ‘real’

Interventions: • affect-focused (what do I feel)

• identity-focused (what do I feel)

• maybe less focused on mentalizing about others

Page 75: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Adaptations to the original MBT-model

Some aspects are new Including Mentalization-based Family Therapy

(MBFT) (trial version)

Including developmental tasks in the treatment plan

• An important goal is also to resume a healthy developmental trajectory

• Including an analysis of mental states interfering with specific developmental tasks

• Including a phasing of developmental tasks

Page 76: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Outcome monitoring: drop out

42,9

8,69

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

50

Drop Out %

Historic data 2006-2008

MBT-A

Not yet published – do not quote

Page 77: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Outcome Monitoring: symptom index

Brief Symptom inventory

0,8

1

1,2

1,4

1,6

1,8

Start treatment End Treatment

MBT-A

KPA

Not yet published – do not quote

Page 78: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Outcome Monitoring: level of personality problems

2

3

4

5

6

Start behandeling Einde behandeling

SIPP Self control

MBT-A

KPA2

2,53

3,54

4,5

Start behandeling Einde behandeling

SIPP Identity Integration

4,5

5

5,5

6

6,5

Start behandeling Einde behandeling

SIPP Social concordance

3

3,5

4

4,5

Start behandeling Einde behandeling

SIPP Relational capacities

2

2,5

3

3,5

4

4,5

5

Start behandeling Einde behandeling

SIPP Responsability

Not yet published –

Do not quote

Page 79: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Implementation was not a success over the whole line… (not at all, in fact…)

Two major negative consequences Extreme levels of arousal in the patient groups Leading to much acting out, crises, high stress

Extreme burden for staff (mainly nurses) Leading to temporarily high illness and drop

out of staff members

Page 80: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Causes of implementation problems

Related to institution Traditional therapeutic community for neurotic patients MBT-A arose from the ‘ashes’ of such a TC program MBT-A arose from conflicts between team members of this TC

Related to the start of the program Staff was not selected, but personnel was re-trained Group had to adapt to a new program

Related to team Existing split between nurses and psychotherapists Team members with highly similar personality profile Abscence of experience in MBT at the start

Page 81: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Causes of implementation problems

Related to training Basic training without continuous monitoring/supervision

Related to adolescent population Strong peer bonding against staff Parents blaming the therapists/institution

Related to inpatient setting Too much (attachment, peer bonding) leading to high

arousal Extremely difficult to maintain a consistent and coherent

apporach, leading to unreliability

Page 82: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Preliminary conclusions MBT is a promising approach for the treatment of severely

personality disordered adolescents It not only reduces symptoms, but also improves core components

of personality functioning

MBT does not need huge adaptations for adolescents, with exception of the addition of MBFT and attention for developmental tasks

Implementation of MBT is a difficult process (more general: implementation of a new treatment model in a complex population is difficult)

An inpatient setting might be possible for milder PD adolescents, but is riskful for low level BPD (i.p. with strong antisocial traits)

Page 83: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Future developments

Reorganisation of the program: Intensive outpatient instead of inpatient Restricted age range (16-18) Developing an adapted version of MBFT

• Integrated within MBT-a (one-team model)• CEM for parents including focus on parental

skills

Development of a quality monitoring system

Page 84: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Content

Mentalization-Based Treatment (MBT)

A summary of the evidence & new evidence

New Developments MBT-Double diagnosis (MBT-DD) MBT-Caregivers (MBT-C) MBFT MBT quality assurance and improvement system Other new developments

Page 85: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

New developments:- MBT Caregivers

- MBFT

MBT quality assurance and improvement system

Other new developments

Dawn Bales

Page 86: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

MBT UnitMBT QA/QI

Supervisor team 2

Day-HospitalGroup 1

Day-HospitalGroup 2

Pre-Treatment

CEMCEM-ACEM-C

- children-- adolesc.

Post-treatment

IOP 1

MBT-CMBFT

IOP 2

MBT-CMBFT

IOP 3

MBT-CMBFT

MBT-A

MBT-A

Supervisor team 3Supervisor team 1

Page 87: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Objectives of MBFT

Help families shift from non-mentalizing to mentalization-based discussions and interactions, building a basis of trust and attachment between children and parents.

Promote parents’sense of competence in helping their children develop the skill of mentalizing.

Practice the skills of mentalizing, communication and problem solving in the specific areas in which mentalizing has been inhibited.

Initiate activities and contexts within the family, with peers, in school, and in the community which reinforce mentalizing, communication skills and mutually supportive solutions to problems

Page 88: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

MBT for caregivers: MBT-C A mentalizing parental program for high-risk parents

and their children

Population: caregivers with severe BPD and their children up to four years

Goal: promoting reflective parenting by enhancing the caregiver’s mentalizing with respect to him/herself, the child and the relationship

The interventions on caregiver-child interactions are based on principles from Minding the baby (Slade)

Page 89: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Plan MBT-C

Program: Course explicit mentalizing (8-10 group sessions) Course explicit mentalizing for caregivers (6-8 group

sessions) IOP MBT (1 group psychotherapy and 1 individual

session, with primary focus on their BPD) Interventions on caregiver-child interaction: home-

visitations and routine videotaping of caregiver-child interactions

Research: MBT-C versus TAU Hypothesis: enhancing the caregiver’s mentalizing

capacity results in less psychopathology in the children

Page 90: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Content

Mentalization-Based Treatment (MBT)

A summary of the evidence & new evidence

New Developments MBT-Double diagnosis (MBT-DD) MBFT MBT-Caregivers (MBT-C) MBT quality assurance and improvement system Other new developments

Page 91: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Borderline Task Force (NL)

Prominant researchers and clinicians from different evidence-based BPD treatment programs (MBT, TFP, SFT en DBT).

Mission:Jointly contributing to more (cost)effective BPD

treatment programs andTo increase the amount of BPD patients

receiving evidence-based (cost)effective BPD treatment.

Page 92: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

In company MBT Training2x half day Teammanager

/project leader

Kick off Team Optional

2-day basic training Team

3rd day basictraining Team

Training on-the-job 5 days 3 therapists

First day extra training Team

Second day extra training Team

Teamsupervision Team

Individual supervision ; 8x 1 x p 6 weeks

All therapists

Individual supervision : 6 x 1 x p 2 months

ST

Page 93: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Training MBTNr. Phase

trainingResult

Implementation. MBT

Resultprogram

Problem

1. Finished - +_ Reorganisation, cut-backs, no evidence-based program

2. Finished - + Goal was to add certain components facilitating mentalizing

3. Finished + - +- splitting, reorganization, new start

4. Finished + -; ended splitting,, reorganisation

5. Finished + - Small, vulnerable team, working on recovery

6. Finished ended Implementation problems; problems in team, not enough expertise, adherence low, splitting

7. Middle phase

± Small, vulnerable team, no support from management

8. Finished ± Complex organization, low adherence,

Page 94: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Framework for MBT:Succes factors Multi System

Therapy (MST)? Evidence-based product

MST program development and support

Consultation, training and boostersessions

Quality assurance and improvement system

Research supporting QA/QI linkages with outcome

Page 95: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Components of QA/QI system

Training Manualized training, supervision on site, consultation and booster

training

Implementation measurement and reporting Therapist adherence measure, program adherence measure,

supervisor adherence measure and consultant adherence measure Outcome measurement

Organisational support Organisational manual Pre-implementation program development process, Ongoing organizational support

Page 96: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Quality assurance and Improvement System (MST model)

Organization

Therapist & program

Manualized Manualized

Supervisory Adherence Measure

Therapist Adherence Measure

Implementation program

MBT Expert/consultantMBT Expertisecenter

ManualizedManualized

Supervisor Patiënt

Page 97: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Other new MBT Developments

MBT for ASPD

Children/parents (MBKT, NPi, NL)

Eating disorders RCT MBT with eating disorders (UK) Phd on MBT with Severe eating disorders (GGZ-MB, NL)

Severe psychosomatic disorders (Eikenboom, NL)

Page 98: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

Conclusions

A summary of the evidence MBT does work for severe borderline patients The effects are lasting MBT shows considerable health care cost savings

after treatment MBT-IOP also seems effective MBT is also promising for addiction and

adolescents

Internationally many new developments

Page 99: Mentalization-based Treatment for borderline personality disorder: A summary of the evidence, new evidence & recent developments in different dosages and.

www.deviersprong.nlwww.vispd.nl/presentations

[email protected]

[email protected]

[email protected]

[email protected]


Recommended