Mercedes-Benz: A Greener Luxury SedanStephanie DalquistSeward MatwickBill Nickerson13 May 2002
Mercedes-Benz StrategyManufacture world-class luxury carsMaintain industry leadership in technology and designMaximize profits, delivering consumer and environmental benefitsResource management value systemFree market: get the prices rightTechnology is the answer: improved efficiency, recyclability Earth as a closed system
Impact on Design Goals Profitability firstA corporation, above allDeliberate material selectionAim to meet new EU mandatesImprove fuel efficiencyEPS to confirm design choicesBalance the competing mandates while still achieving profitability
The New Mercedes-Benz: MaterialsAluminum RoofSteel QPISMC QPOSMC Floor
Production 50,000BIW Cost $199681% recyclable22.9 mpg
Base Case ComparisonNew ModelChangeCost$1996-$353Weight2748 lbs-241.2 lbsRecyclability81%+6.3%ELI10324-561.33Fuel efficiency22.8 MPG+1.3 MPG
Change in BIW Profit by Case Number
Chart1
534.6497367871
517.0463552862
488.2252421586
452.0568192064
433.9993439364
398.6490697707
397.8309209841
381.0456882699
352.2245751422
316.05615219
297.99867692
261.8302539678
27.917761167
16.8801993348
4.1148042426
-8.2506617852
-13.4885772582
-26.3081370552
-62.4765600074
-68.0905182358
-80.4559842636
-85.6938997367
-98.5134595337
-108.0829058493
-131.8858627737
-134.6818824859
-144.2513288015
-149.4892442746
-162.3088040716
-177.1507421439
-180.2882283278
-198.4772270238
-204.0911852522
-216.45665128
-221.6945667531
-234.51412655
-241.685647184
-270.6825495022
-295.9115454062
-527.4204959685
-573.3903595572
-627.6162577795
-707.6856746884
-772.2508884644
-779.8909971668
-826.4767866867
-844.4562109429
-898.6821091651
-1057.955428513
-1103.9556008377
-1130.1607509914
-1158.1814990599
-1176.1609233161
-1230.3868215384
Case number
Change in profit ($)
BIW Model
TAURUS SEDAN BIWRevised:21-Apr-95BIW Assembly Line CalculationsCOST MODEL SUMMARIESCOST MODEL SUMMARIESCOST MODEL SUMMARIESCOST MODEL SUMMARIESRaw Material Costs
Parts Database0-volumeDESIGN BASIS INFORMATIONANALYSIS RESULTS1-1-1-1-1-2-2-2-2-2-3-3-3-3-3-4-4-4-4-4-Scrap
Material (0=aluminum;1=steel;2=SMC)1-stiffnessSTEEL BASIS DATAPartPartMaterialAssembly Complexity CalculationsPart #1: Roof PanelPart #2: Quarter Panel InnerPart #3: Quarter Panel OuterPart #4: Rear Floor PanAluminum Sheet$1.500.3
Part Type2-bucklingSteelPartSteelSteel TypePartMass ofMaterialTotalCost ofCost ofMaterial:0(0-Aluminum; 1-Steel; 2-SMC)Material:1(0-Aluminum; 1-Steel; 2-SMC)Material:2(0-Aluminum; 1-Steel; 2-SMC)Material:0(0-Aluminum; 1-Steel; 2-SMC)Steel Sheet$0.330.05
PART DESCRIPTIONMAT#/car(Cost)DesignSpecThicknessArea (in)Weight (lb)CostMassAll PartsCostCostAll PartsAll PartsAlStSMC1234Part CountsBase CountActual CountPart Weight:15.6lbsPart Weight:9.57lbsPart Weight:11lbsPart Weight:21.01lbsSMC$0.800
Ext frt body pillar l.h.011|0000.580$0.3250|0.1980.198$0.298$0.496$0.298$0.4960.1980.198418000Class 1148148Material Cost$1.500.3Material Cost$0.330.05Material Cost$0.800Material Cost$1.500.3
Housing asy rear bumper isolator021|0001.860$0.3250|0.6361.273$0.954$1.591$1.909$3.1821.2731.272612000Class 222
Bracket spare wheel mounting011|0000.100$0.3250|0.0340.034$0.051$0.086$0.051$0.0860.0340.03421000Class 387per pieceper yearpercentper pieceper yearpercentper pieceper yearpercentper pieceper yearpercent
Reinf asy frt floor pan seat track inr021|0000.090$0.3250|0.0310.062$0.046$0.077$0.092$0.1540.0620.061578000Class 41010VARIABLE COST ELEMENTS---VARIABLE COST ELEMENTS---VARIABLE COST ELEMENTS---VARIABLE COST ELEMENTS---
Bracket rear susp arm mount front021|0007.250$0.3250|2.4804.960$3.720$6.201$7.441$12.4014.9604.96045000168167Material Cost$27.80$1,390,05860.54%Material Cost$6.49$324,5676.47%Material Cost$14.99$449,80160.94%Material Cost$44.09$2,204,53347.49%
Reinf asy frt st shldr strp gid021|0000.580$0.3340|0.1980.397$0.298$0.496$0.595$0.9920.3970.396836000Labor Cost$1.84$92,1694.01%Labor Cost$3.26$163,0273.25%Labor Cost$1.01$30,3064.11%Labor Cost$2.71$135,4292.92%
Washer rear susp support041|0007.250$0.3250|2.4809.921$3.720$6.201$14.881$24.8029.9219.9209000Consolidation Credit: SMC15.0%Energy Cost$0.12$6,2450.27%Energy Cost$0.26$12,8760.26%Energy Cost$1.00$29,9214.05%Energy Cost$0.21$10,2840.22%
Hinge asy l/c door021|0002.430$0.3250|0.8311.663$1.247$2.078$2.494$4.1571.6631.662606000------------
Reinf front side member tie down hole021|0000.450$0.3250|0.1540.308$0.231$0.385$0.462$0.7700.3080.30789000Material Complexity CalculationsTotal Variable Cost ===>$29.77$1,488,47364.83%Total Variable Cost ===>$10.01$500,4709.97%Total Variable Cost ===>$17.00$510,02969.10%Total Variable Cost ===>$47.00$2,350,24550.63%
Reinf front side member at frame mtg021|0000.200$0.3250|0.0680.137$0.103$0.171$0.205$0.3420.1370.13684000000
Reinf front fender upper021|0004.000$0.3250|1.3682.737$2.053$3.421$4.105$6.8422.7372.7368000Class 10100FIXED COSTSper pieceper yearpercentinvestmentFIXED COSTSper pieceper yearpercentinvestmentFIXED COSTSper pieceper yearpercentinvestmentFIXED COSTSper pieceper yearpercentinvestment
Reinf rear seat belt anc021|0000.060$0.3250|0.0210.041$0.031$0.051$0.062$0.1030.0410.041052000Class 21110----------------
Support asy muffler o/let pipe rear011|0000.350$0.3250|0.1200.120$0.180$0.299$0.180$0.2990.1200.119735000Class 32111Main Machine Cost$0.94$46,8042.04%$4,930,191Main Machine Cost$1.76$88,0581.75%$9,017,323Main Machine Cost$0.59$17,8372.42%$1,483,194Main Machine Cost$1.87$93,6492.02%$9,592,565
Bracket asy rear seat shoulder strap021|0000.400$0.3250|0.1370.274$0.205$0.342$0.411$0.6840.2740.27368000Class 40111Tooling Cost$5.51$275,48312.00%$1,101,933Tooling Cost$38.73$1,936,40738.58%$7,745,627Tooling Cost$3.17$95,00012.87%$380,000Tooling Cost$14.85$742,72616.00%$2,970,905
Supt prkg brk cbl011|0000.180$0.3250|0.0620.062$0.092$0.154$0.092$0.1540.0620.061578000Fixed Overhead Cost$3.51$175,5777.65%Fixed Overhead Cost$20.49$1,024,55520.41%Fixed Overhead Cost$1.64$49,1776.66%Fixed Overhead Cost$10.33$516,51211.13%
Plate door upper hinge anchor on bdy041|0000.080$0.3250|0.0270.109$0.041$0.068$0.164$0.2740.1090.109472000Mixed Assembly PremiumsBuilding Cost$0.02$1,2140.05%$282,105Building Cost$0.03$1,6630.03%$370,328Building Cost$0.03$8820.12%$146,658Building Cost$0.03$1,6100.03%$356,216
Bracket rear suspension trk bar021|0003.660$0.3250|1.2522.504$1.878$3.130$3.756$6.2602.5042.504172000CapitalLaborLineRateAuxiliary Equipment Cost$0.19$9,3610.41%$986,038Auxiliary Equipment Cost$0.35$17,6120.35%$1,803,465Auxiliary Equipment Cost$0.09$2,6760.36%$222,479Auxiliary Equipment Cost$0.37$18,7300.40%$1,918,513
Plate front door lock strider anchor021|0000.060$0.3250|0.0210.041$0.031$0.051$0.062$0.1030.0410.0410520001SMC65Maintenance Cost$3.38$168,7867.35%Maintenance Cost$17.67$883,55917.60%Maintenance Cost$0.80$24,1113.27%Maintenance Cost$12.38$619,03513.33%
Plate lugg compt door lock stkr anchor011|0000.090$0.3250|0.0310.031$0.046$0.077$0.046$0.0770.0310.03078900010Steel75Cost of Capital$2.61$130,3945.68%Cost of Capital$11.34$567,14811.30%Cost of Capital$1.28$38,3435.20%Cost of Capital$5.99$299,7416.46%
Plate front suspension housing reinf021|0000.360$0.3250|0.1230.246$0.185$0.308$0.369$0.6160.2460.24631200011St-SMC65----------------
Bracket fuel tank support front021|0001.550$0.3250|0.5301.061$0.795$1.326$1.591$2.6511.0611.06051000100Aluminum70Total Fixed Cost ===>$16.15$807,61835.17%Total Fixed Cost ===>$90.38$4,519,00390.03%Total Fixed Cost ===>$7.60$228,02530.90%Total Fixed Cost ===>$45.84$2,292,00349.37%
Reinf cowl top panel side r.h.021|10.0644.120.750$0.3250|0.4360.872$0.654$1.090$1.309$2.1810.8720.87238476000101Al-SMC65
Reinf front body pillar at belt021|10.0658.831.000$0.4020|0.5821.163$0.872$1.454$1.745$2.9081.1631.16324559000110Al-Steel70============
Reinf asy seat belt anc to floor021|10.0963.611.640$0.3250|0.9431.887$1.415$2.358$2.830$4.7171.8871.886640795000111All 365Total Part Cost ===>$45.92$2,296,091100%Total Part Cost ===>$100.39$5,019,473100%Total Part Cost ===>$24.60$738,054100%Total Part Cost ===>$92.84$4,642,248100%
Reinf asy rr flr side member tie dwn021|10.0998.560.240$0.3250|0.1400.279$0.209$0.349$0.419$0.6980.2790.279273852000============
Reinf asy rear bumper mounting to qtr021|10.0311.350.900$0.3250|0.0560.112$0.084$0.140$0.168$0.2810.1120.112211775000Capital Cost1-1-1-1-1-2-2-2-2-2-3-3-3-3-3-4-4-4-4-4-
Reinf assy cowl top outer011|10.08172.023.850$0.3250|2.2682.268$3.401$5.669$3.401$5.6692.2682.26756764000Steel Line1.25E+08=====
Reinf dash PNL at brk mstr cyl011|10.04150.821.880$0.3250|0.9940.994$1.491$2.485$1.491$2.4850.9940.99405462000Factor5.58E+07Body Fabrication Line Inputs(NOTE: Labor assumed NOT dedicated)
Panel w/wiper mounting011|10.04440.234.500$0.3250|2.9022.902$4.352$7.254$4.352$7.2542.9022.90155593000Line Rate65
Reinf rr dr lock striker anchor plate021|10.0414.780.180$0.3250|0.0970.195$0.146$0.244$0.292$0.4870.1950.19482996000Capital1.43E+08Annual Production50,000bodies/year
Reinf rad supt at hood latch011|10.0514.710.200$0.3250|0.1210.121$0.182$0.303$0.182$0.3030.1210.1211920125000Labor Wage$15.00/hr
Support package tray side021|10.028181.531.440$0.3340|0.8381.675$1.256$2.094$2.513$4.1881.6751.675049922000Labor RequirementsSteel BasisBenefits100.0%of wage
Seal asy qtr panel to w/house011|10.0344.120.350$0.3250|0.2180.218$0.327$0.545$0.327$0.5450.2180.21809619000Class 10.750.81Overhead150.0%of wage & benefits
Retainer rear seat cushion021|10.0416.810.200$0.3250|0.1110.222$0.166$0.277$0.332$0.5540.2220.22158942000Class 20.750.81
Reinf w/wiper motor mounting011|10.0521.040.310$0.3250|0.1730.173$0.260$0.433$0.260$0.4330.1730.1733433000Class 30.750.81Opportunity Cost of Capital15.00%/yr
Reinf front door hinge lower on bdy021|10.0652.950.900$0.2760|0.5231.047$0.785$1.309$1.570$2.6171.0471.04698035000Class 40.750.81Amortization Period (product life)5years
Reinf rad supt bmpr opng r.h.021|10.0719.890.400$0.3250|0.2290.459$0.344$0.574$0.688$1.1470.4590.4588324650003.003.22=====
Reinf front door hinge upper on bdy021|10.0658.240.990$0.2760|0.5761.152$0.864$1.439$1.727$2.8791.1521.15157952000
Reinf frt crs mbr at dash021|10.08104.952.230$0.3250|1.3832.767$2.075$3.459$4.150$6.9172.7672.7669018000Labor Wage15MODEL RESULTS
Reinf front suspension mounting021|10.0591.921.250$0.3250|0.7571.515$1.136$1.893$2.272$3.7871.5151.5146118000Benefits1
Reinf front floor pan seat track021|10.06767.441.280$0.3805|0.7451.489$1.117$1.861$2.234$3.7231.4891.489065084000Overhead1.5Body-In-White Part Fabrication Estimates
Reinf front fender apron horn mtg011|10.053.270.050$0.3250|0.0270.027$0.040$0.067$0.040$0.0670.0270.0269407125000OCC0.15
Pillar front body lower021|10.04220.612.500$0.3340|1.4542.908$2.181$3.635$4.362$7.2702.9082.90808102000Period5Basis PartsMaterialWeightPart Cost
Apron front fender lower021|10.03242.532.130$0.3250|1.1992.398$1.798$2.997$3.597$5.9942.3982.397772845000Volume50000-----
Bracket cowl top vent screen011|10.0315.440.140$0.3250|0.0760.076$0.114$0.191$0.114$0.1910.0760.07632378000Part #1: Roof PanelAluminum15.6$45.92
Member rear shock ABS mounting021|10.08127.583.000$0.3250|1.6823.364$2.523$4.204$5.045$8.4093.3643.36351912000Labor$241.69Part #2: Quarter Panel InnerSteel9.57$100.39
Bracket w/wiper arm stop011|10.0324.710.210$0.3250|0.1220.122$0.183$0.305$0.183$0.3050.1220.1221477075000Capital$855.40Part #3: Quarter Panel OuterSMC11$24.60
Bracket package tray strainer to flr011|10.02319.950.130$0.3250|0.0760.076$0.113$0.189$0.113$0.1890.0760.0756070088000$1,097.09Part #4: Rear Floor PanAluminum21.01$92.84
Member front side outer rear021|10.1200.645.400$0.3250|3.3066.612$4.959$8.265$9.918$16.5306.6126.6120912000-----
Bracket lugg compt door lock striker011|10.0484.720.840$0.3250|0.5580.558$0.838$1.396$0.838$1.3960.5580.55838952000Total B-I-W Material Cost$470.16
Bracket hoodlift on body l.h.021|10.0518.330.270$0.3250|0.1510.302$0.227$0.378$0.453$0.7550.3020.302032575000Total B-I-W Fabrication Cost$1,031.30453
Extension front fender apron021|10.03133.711.250$0.3250|0.6611.322$0.991$1.652$1.983$3.3051.3221.321923915000Total B-I-W Weight324.724lbs515
Panel cowl side r.h.021|10.06170.192.800$0.3250|1.6833.365$2.524$4.206$5.048$8.4133.3653.36516687000
Bracket air cond cond mounting lower021|10.04920.170.280$0.3340|0.1630.326$0.244$0.407$0.489$0.8140.3260.3257041515000Mass Fractions - Materials
Bracket air cond cond mounting bracket021|10.04917.290.240$0.3340|0.1400.279$0.209$0.349$0.419$0.6980.2790.2791980555000Steel19.140lbs5.89%
Bracket asy rad support lower r.h.021|10.03730.530.320$0.4230|0.1860.372$0.279$0.465$0.558$0.9310.3720.3722629755000Aluminum261.927lbs80.66%
Bracket asy front for to frt fnd apr021|10.04129.270.340$0.3805|0.1980.395$0.297$0.494$0.593$0.9890.3950.3954830685000SMC43.656lbs13.44%
Reinf qtr w/house inner panel021|20.0470.600.800$0.3250|0.3850.771$0.578$0.964$1.156$1.9270.7710.770952000Mass Fractions - Part Types
Trough l/c door opening dr side021|20.03108.170.950$0.3250|0.4430.886$0.664$1.107$1.329$2.2150.8860.8859123000Type 1180.455lbs55.57%
Extension dash panel011|20.03308.862.800$0.3250|1.2651.265$1.897$3.162$1.897$3.1621.2651.2647817000Type 219.140lbs5.89%
Ext rear floor s/member rear021|20.06162.372.760$0.3250|1.3302.660$1.995$3.325$3.989$6.6492.6602.6596206000Type 343.656lbs13.44%
Reinf lower back panel011|20.028258.432.050$0.3340|0.9880.988$1.482$2.469$1.482$2.4690.9880.98771946000Type 481.472lbs25.09%
Reinf luggage compt door opening upper011|20.03612.684.860$0.3250|2.5092.509$3.763$6.272$3.763$6.2722.5092.5089246000
Frame back window upper011|20.028247.091.960$0.3340|0.9440.944$1.417$2.361$1.417$2.3610.9440.94437798000-----
Ext frt sd mbr rr021|20.056176.492.800$0.3340|1.3492.698$2.024$3.373$4.047$6.7452.6982.69817912000Body Line Cost Estimates
Reinf roof panel rear011|20.03172.711.370$0.3250|0.7070.707$1.061$1.768$1.061$1.7680.7070.70724745000Labor Cost$241.69
Reinf rad supt upr011|20.03311.463.000$0.3250|1.2751.275$1.913$3.189$1.913$3.1891.2751.2754287000Capital Cost$855.40
Strainer package tray to floor center011|20.03289.350.810$0.3250|0.3900.390$0.585$0.976$0.585$0.9760.3900.3902808000==
Reinf rr floor side member021|20.06161.782.750$0.3250|1.3252.650$1.987$3.312$3.975$6.6252.6502.6499564000Total BIW Assembly Cost$1,097.09
Reinf roof panel center011|20.03223.141.770$0.3250|0.9140.914$1.371$2.284$1.371$2.2840.9140.9137583000
Reinf front side outer rear member021|20.08154.373.280$0.3250|1.6863.371$2.529$4.214$5.057$8.4293.3713.3714408000BIW Part Fabrication Cost$1,031.30
Panel w/shield header011|20.032240.472.180$0.3250|1.0501.050$1.576$2.626$1.576$2.6261.0501.05037296000BIW Assembly Cost$1,097.09
Extension floor side inner member021|20.089170.544.300$0.3250|2.0724.144$3.108$5.180$6.215$10.3594.1444.14361038000==
Member front side outer front021|20.08827.3917.580$0.3250|9.03518.070$13.553$22.588$27.105$45.17518.07018.0701976000TOTAL$2,128.39
Member rear floor side021|20.056709.1211.250$0.3250|5.42110.841$8.131$13.551$16.262$27.10310.84110.84102656000=====
Apron front fender upper021|20.05313.274.260$0.3250|2.1384.276$3.207$5.345$6.414$10.6904.2764.2761355000
Panel cowl top inner011|20.06712.3811.100$0.3250|5.8345.834$8.752$14.586$8.752$14.5865.8345.8343922000
Rain roof side inner021|20.04280.783.500$0.3250|1.5333.066$2.300$3.833$4.599$7.6653.0663.0661176000
Mounding roof drip side021|20.0377.210.700$0.3250|0.3160.632$0.474$0.790$0.949$1.5810.6320.6323499000
Member rear floor cross011|20.056492.149.940$0.3250|3.7623.762$5.643$9.405$5.643$9.4053.7623.76191816000
Reinf center body pillar021|20.056127.332.020$0.3240|0.9731.947$1.460$2.433$2.920$4.8671.9471.94662104000
Pillar front body upper021|20.071198.864.000$0.3340|1.9273.855$2.891$4.818$5.782$9.6363.8553.85450338000
Member front floor cross rear011|20.04403.414.800$0.3250|2.2032.203$3.304$5.507$3.304$5.5072.2032.2026186000
Member front floor cross rear #1011|20.043467.915.700$0.3250|2.7462.746$4.120$6.866$4.120$6.8662.7462.746397745000
Reinf door opening front021|20.036409.854.180$0.3805|2.0144.028$3.021$5.035$6.042$10.0704.0284.0280058000
Member front floor side inner021|20.049462.245.500$0.4180|3.0926.183$4.638$7.729$9.275$15.4586.1836.18338448000
Support radiator213|10.03764.806.500$0.3340|4.3364.336$3.469$5.781$3.469$5.7814.336004.33607997780
Pillar center body inner223|10.05245.783.760$0.3240|2.3224.645$1.858$3.097$3.716$6.1934.645004.64488204740
Reinf rad supt lower213|10.04309.943.600$0.3340|2.3432.343$1.874$3.124$1.874$3.1242.343002.34296483320
Frame door opening223|10.032854.2616.810$0.3845|5.16610.332$4.133$6.888$8.266$13.77610.3320010.33232826180
Panel package tray014|10.031,222.839.700$0.3525|6.0456.045$9.067$20.149$9.067$20.1496.0450006.0447543975
Housing front suspension mounting024|10.05393.435.350$0.3525|3.2416.483$4.862$10.805$9.724$21.6096.4830006.482742825
PNL dash014|10.0282,133.0216.920$0.4080|9.8419.841$14.762$32.804$14.762$32.8049.8410009.841114374
Panel lower back014|10.0281,138.379.030$0.4080|5.2525.252$7.878$17.507$7.878$17.5075.2520005.252097669
Member front cross at dash014|10.08649.4913.800$0.3525|8.5628.562$12.842$28.539$12.842$28.5398.5620008.56157718
Pan front floor014|10.032,470.8821.000$0.4080|12.21412.214$18.321$40.714$18.321$40.71412.21400012.21417756
Panel qtr w/house inner024|10.03835.397.100$0.3525|4.1308.259$6.194$13.765$12.389$27.5308.2590008.259083235
Panel cowl top outer014|20.03929.527.900$0.3525|3.8063.806$5.710$12.688$5.710$12.6883.8060003.8063844
COST MODEL ESTIMATESMAT#/vehpart type (cost)pt. wt;lbtot.wt;lbtotal costMatl CostMatl/TotalStAl
Roof Panel01115.60015.600$45.922$27.80160%0.60.8bend15.600
Quarter Panel Inner1229.57019.140$200.779$12.9835%0.20.4cutout19.140
Quarter Panel Outer22311.00022.000$49.204$29.98760%0.250.4cl a draw22.000
Rear Floor Pan01421.01021.010$92.845$44.09145%0.50.7deep21.010
BIW Total Part Weight$324.724261.92719.14043.656180.45519.14043.65681.472
BIW Total Manufacturing Cost$1,031.303AlStSMC1234
BIW Total Material Cost$470.162
MATERIALS DATASpGrPriceModulus
Aluminum2.699$1.50010,500,000
Steel7.89$0.33030,000,000
SMC1.7438340933$0.8001,050,000
SpGr to lbs/in conversion0.0361244906
DESIGN CRITERIAAluminumSteelSMC
Equivalent Volume Criterion0.342110.221
Equivalent Stiffness Criterion1.6913
Equivalent Buckling Criterion1.416
Material Cost Calculation (Avg)Mat#Mat'l Price012
Part 10$1.5001.500100
Part 21$0.33000.330010
Part 32$0.800000.8001
Part 40$1.5001.500100
Analysis
Sensitivity AnalysisMaterial Choice:
Case #RoofQPIQPOFloor81Roof:QPIQPOFloor
100000120
21000AluminumSteelSMCAluminum
32000
40100
51100BIWBIWBIWBIWBIWBIWBIWBIWVehicle
62100CostWeightFerrousNon-ferrousNon recyclable% Ferrous% Non-fer% Non-recWeight
70010Case #Case #2128.3947601155324.723562185919.14261.927307065843.6562551202
810101612640.5610012466306.30.0306.30.00.0%100.0%0.0%2658.0
9201022460.2547304981499.2373.4125.80.074.8%25.2%0.0%2947.4
10011033237.0422417924306.90.0220.586.40.0%71.8%28.2%2658.9
11111042601.5719113884314.319.1295.20.06.1%93.9%0.0%2670.1
12211052421.2656406399507.3392.6114.80.077.4%22.6%0.0%2959.5
13002063542.6194307842413.9212.7114.886.451.4%27.7%20.9%2819.4
14102072704.7990980957349.176.1273.00.021.8%78.2%0.0%2722.2
15202082524.4928273472542.1449.692.50.082.9%17.1%0.0%3011.7
16012093301.2803386415349.776.1187.286.421.8%53.5%24.7%2723.1
171120102665.8100082375357.295.3261.90.026.7%73.3%0.0%2734.4
182120112485.503737489550.2468.781.50.085.2%14.8%0.0%3023.8
190001123606.8575276333456.7288.981.586.463.2%17.8%18.9%2883.7
201001132167.3838499737316.60.0273.043.70.0%86.2%13.8%2673.5
212001141987.0775792252509.6373.492.543.773.3%18.2%8.6%2962.9
220101152693.6073302306317.20.0187.2130.00.0%59.0%41.0%2674.4
231101162128.3947601155324.719.1261.943.75.9%80.7%13.4%2685.6
242101171948.088489367517.7392.681.543.775.8%15.7%8.4%2975.1
250011182999.1845192224424.3212.781.5130.050.1%19.2%30.7%2834.9
261011192565.5174003675364.4139.6224.80.038.3%61.7%0.0%2745.1
272011202385.211129619557.3513.044.30.092.0%8.0%0.0%3034.5
280111213161.9986409133365.0139.6139.086.438.2%38.1%23.7%2746.0
291111222526.5283105092372.5158.7213.70.042.6%57.4%0.0%2757.2
302111232346.2220397608565.4532.133.30.094.1%5.9%0.0%3046.7
310021243467.575829905472.0352.333.386.474.6%7.1%18.3%2906.5
321021252629.7554972166407.2215.7191.50.053.0%47.0%0.0%2809.4
332021262449.4492264681600.2589.111.10.098.2%1.8%0.0%3098.8
340121273226.2367377624407.8215.7105.786.452.9%25.9%21.2%2810.3
351121282590.7664073584415.3234.9180.50.056.5%43.5%0.0%2821.5
362121292349.2923759637608.3608.30.00.0100.0%0.0%0.0%3111.0
370002303531.8139267542514.8428.50.086.483.2%0.0%16.8%2970.8
381002312092.3402490946374.8139.6191.543.737.2%51.1%11.6%2760.7
392002321912.0339783461567.7513.011.143.790.4%1.9%7.7%3050.1
400102332618.5637293515375.4139.6105.7130.037.2%28.2%34.6%2761.6
411102342053.3511592364382.8158.7180.543.741.5%47.1%11.4%2772.8
422102351873.0448884879575.8532.10.043.792.4%0.0%7.6%3062.2
430012362924.1409183433482.4352.30.0130.073.0%0.0%27.0%2922.1
441012372560.6477197482344.60.0228.6116.00.0%66.3%33.7%2715.4
452012382380.3414489998537.5373.448.1116.069.5%9.0%21.6%3004.9
460112393087.3258310449345.20.0142.8202.40.0%41.4%58.6%2716.3
471112402539.28978589356.827.0213.7116.07.6%59.9%32.5%2733.7
482112412358.9835151415549.7400.533.3116.072.8%6.1%21.1%3023.1
490022423410.5341760367456.3220.633.3202.448.4%7.3%44.4%2883.0
501022432624.8858165973387.476.1195.3116.019.7%50.4%29.9%2779.7
512022442444.5795458489580.4449.614.9116.077.5%2.6%20.0%3069.1
520122453151.563927894388.076.1109.5202.419.6%28.2%52.2%2780.6
531122462603.5278827391399.6103.2180.5116.025.8%45.2%29.0%2798.0
542122472423.2216119906592.6476.60.0116.080.4%0.0%19.6%3087.4
483474.7722728858499.1296.80.0202.459.5%0.0%40.5%2947.3
492017.2431169224355.00.0195.3159.60.0%55.0%45.0%2731.0
501836.936846174547.9373.414.9159.668.2%2.7%29.1%3020.4
512543.9212282192355.60.0109.5246.00.0%30.8%69.2%2731.9
521995.8851830642367.127.0180.5159.67.4%49.2%43.5%2749.2
531815.5789123158560.1400.50.0159.671.5%0.0%28.5%3038.7
542867.1295732109466.7220.60.0246.047.3%0.0%52.7%2898.5
Analysis
306.2692434118
499.2238679865
306.8692937049
314.3492434118
507.3038679865
413.8830615899
349.1273070658
542.0819316405
349.7273573589
357.2073070658
550.1619316405
456.7411252439
316.6435621859
509.5981867607
317.243612479
324.7235621859
517.6781867607
424.257380364
364.3773117712
557.331936346
364.9773620644
372.4573117712
565.411936346
471.9911299494
407.2353754252
600.19
407.8354257184
415.3153754252
608.27
514.8491936034
374.7516305454
567.7062551202
375.3516808385
382.8316305454
575.7862551202
482.3654487235
344.5836305662
537.538255141
345.1836808593
356.7572461662
549.711870741
456.2910643443
387.4416942202
580.396318795
388.0417445133
399.6153098202
592.569934395
499.1491279983
354.9579493404
547.9125739151
355.5579996335
367.1315649404
560.0861895151
466.6653831185
Case
Weight (lbs)
Weight of BIW Vs Case
graphs
2640.5610012466
2460.2547304981
3237.0422417924
2601.5719113884
2421.2656406399
3542.6194307842
2704.7990980957
2524.4928273472
3301.2803386415
2665.8100082375
2485.503737489
3606.8575276333
2167.3838499737
1987.0775792252
2693.6073302306
2128.3947601155
1948.088489367
2999.1845192224
2565.5174003675
2385.211129619
3161.9986409133
2526.5283105092
2346.2220397608
3467.575829905
2629.7554972166
2449.4492264681
3226.2367377624
2590.7664073584
2349.2923759637
3531.8139267542
2092.3402490946
1912.0339783461
2618.5637293515
2053.3511592364
1873.0448884879
2924.1409183433
2560.6477197482
2380.3414489998
3087.3258310449
2539.28978589
2358.9835151415
3410.5341760367
2624.8858165973
2444.5795458489
3151.563927894
2603.5278827391
2423.2216119906
3474.7722728858
2017.2431169224
1836.936846174
2543.9212282192
1995.8851830642
1815.5789123158
2867.1295732109
Case #
Cost ($)
Cost of BIW Vs Case
sensitivity
306.2692434118499.2238679865306.8692937049314.3492434118507.3038679865413.8830615899349.1273070658542.0819316405349.7273573589357.2073070658550.1619316405456.7411252439316.6435621859509.5981867607317.243612479324.7235621859517.6781867607424.257380364364.3773117712557.331936346364.9773620644372.4573117712565.411936346471.9911299494407.2353754252600.19407.8354257184415.3153754252608.27514.8491936034374.7516305454567.7062551202375.3516808385382.8316305454575.7862551202482.3654487235344.5836305662537.538255141345.1836808593356.7572461662549.711870741456.2910643443387.4416942202580.396318795388.0417445133399.6153098202592.569934395499.1491279983354.9579493404547.9125739151355.5579996335367.1315649404560.0861895151466.6653831185
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
BIW Cost in $
BIW Weight in lbs
Cost and Weight of Each Case
answers
caseBIW savingscaseBIW and recycle savings
53533.7153534.6497367871
50512.3650517.0463552862
35476.2535488.2252421586
32437.2632452.0568192064
17401.2017433.9993439364
14362.2152398.6490697707
52353.4114397.8309209841
49332.0549381.0456882699
34295.9434352.2245751422
31256.9531316.05615219
16220.9016297.99867692
13181.9113261.8302539678
233.072327.917761167
290.002916.8801993348
41-9.69414.1148042426
38-31.0520-8.2506617852
20-35.9238-13.4885772582
5-71.975-26.3081370552
47-73.932-62.4765600074
44-95.2947-68.0905182358
26-100.1626-80.4559842636
2-110.9644-85.6938997367
11-136.2111-98.5134595337
8-175.2022-108.0829058493
22-177.2440-131.8858627737
40-190.008-134.6818824859
51-194.6319-144.2513288015
37-211.3637-149.4892442746
19-216.234-162.3088040716
28-241.4751-177.1507421439
4-252.2828-180.2882283278
46-254.241-198.4772270238
33-269.2746-204.0911852522
43-275.5925-216.45665128
25-280.4643-221.6945667531
1-291.2710-234.51412655
10-316.5233-241.685647184
15-344.317-270.6825495022
7-355.5115-295.9115454062
54-517.8454-527.4204959685
36-574.8536-573.3903595572
18-649.8918-627.6162577795
39-738.0339-707.6856746884
45-802.2721-772.2508884644
21-812.7145-779.8909971668
27-876.943-826.4767866867
3-887.7527-844.4562109429
9-951.999-898.6821091651
42-1061.2442-1057.955428513
24-1118.2824-1103.9556008377
48-1125.4848-1130.1607509914
30-1182.526-1158.1814990599
6-1193.3330-1176.1609233161
12-1257.5712-1230.3868215384
assuming recycle % receives 100% credit for weight savings from base case
including only profitable cases
savings includes BIW and recycling savings
caserecycle %Savings
1387.58261.83
1477.40397.83
1687.11298.00
1777.02434.00
2376.1127.92
2974.2016.88
3184.29316.10
3274.72452.10
3483.85352.20
3574.36488.20
4173.384.12
4981.56381.00
5072.16517.00
5280.91398.60
5371.63534.60
assuming recycle % receives 100% credit for weight savings from base case
including only profitable cases
savings includes BIW and recycling savings
caserecycle %mpgthese are positively correlated because saved weight helps both
1387.5823.1846314882
1477.4022.1070758687
1687.1123.1361290127
1777.0222.0653318843
2376.1121.8237033263
2974.2022.6133846281
3184.2922.8427940747
3274.7221.8122989728
3483.8522.7965106771
3574.3621.7722851957
4173.3821.9022524568
4981.5622.9574419141
5072.1621.9113117123
5280.9122.886716097
5371.6321.8502487766
answers
261.8302539678
397.8309209841
298
434
27.92
16.88
316.1
452.1
352.2
488.2
4.115
381
517
398.6
534.6
&A
Page &P
Recycle %
Savings ($)
Recycle % and Savings
recycle
23.1846314882
22.1070758687
23.1361290127
22.0653318843
21.8237033263
22.6133846281
22.8427940747
21.8122989728
22.7965106771
21.7722851957
21.9022524568
22.9574419141
21.9113117123
22.886716097
21.8502487766
&A
Page &P
Recycle %
MPG
Recycle % and MPG
Fuel
Case number
Change in profit ($)
compare
original choice is case 16
varying production volumes--still go with case 16
assuming we count our total savings. Based on BIW cost alone, we would choose otherwise.
caseBIW costBIW costBIW costcaseour total savings including 3/4 of fuelchanges in corporate profits per year
40k/yr50k/yr80k/yr40k/yr50k/yr60k/yr70k/yr80k/yr40k/yr50k/yr60k/yr70k/yr80k/yr
$$$$$$$$$$$$$
1041.381047.13837.04991.35807.544.17E+075.24E+075.02E+076.94E+076.46E+07
13115.63228732762640.56100124662010.21027765231424.84599.80441.55478.55522.571.70E+073.00E+072.65E+073.35E+074.18E+07
22896.63677845832460.25473049811837.9875758411286.45222.7257.4093.82137.403.46E+061.11E+073.44E+066.57E+061.10E+07
34141.18627673963237.04224179242411.9163604493-633.87-29.84-224.3246.1187.71-2.54E+07-1.49E+06-1.35E+073.23E+067.02E+06
43071.39560669742601.57191138841979.09257395214444.19613.90452.15486.65528.801.78E+073.07E+072.71E+073.41E+074.23E+07
52852.40009782812421.26564063991806.86987214085106.99238.0069.19103.11144.824.28E+061.19E+074.15E+067.22E+061.16E+07
63968.18471438443542.61943078422316.41621588626-775.01-649.56-847.54-170.65-130.94-3.10E+07-3.25E+07-5.09E+07-1.19E+07-1.05E+07
73063.17815421692704.79909809571967.70933771127352.87411.13425.40451.79440.641.41E+072.06E+072.55E+073.16E+073.53E+07
82844.18264534762524.49282734721795.4866358999820.7040.2747.4773.2861.708.28E+052.01E+062.85E+065.13E+064.94E+06
94088.73214362893301.28033864152369.41542050789-705.82-218.49-240.4519.375.80-2.82E+07-1.09E+07-1.44E+071.36E+064.64E+05
103018.94147358672665.81000823751936.591634010910372.50425.51436.28460.17447.151.49E+072.13E+072.62E+073.22E+073.58E+07
112799.94596471742485.5037374891764.36893219971141.4755.8059.5082.8169.351.66E+062.79E+063.57E+065.80E+065.55E+06
123915.73058127373606.85752763332273.915275945112-843.39-834.64-860.10-193.83-209.27-3.37E+07-4.17E+07-5.16E+07-1.36E+07-1.67E+07
132477.31496683382167.38384997371690.3369644626131021.961031.78826.38829.70801.254.09E+075.16E+074.96E+075.81E+076.41E+07
142258.31945796441987.07757922521518.114262651414685.10656.22443.75446.49417.612.74E+073.28E+072.66E+073.13E+073.34E+07
153417.24466681222693.60733023062044.83508068741548.88472.40220.52449.96413.591.96E+062.36E+071.32E+073.15E+073.31E+07
162433.07828620362128.39476011551659.2192607624161041.381045.94837.04837.87807.544.17E+075.23E+075.02E+075.87E+076.46E+07
172214.08277733421948.0884893671486.996558951217705.69671.57455.60455.84425.082.82E+073.36E+072.73E+073.19E+073.40E+07
183244.2431044572999.18451922241949.334936124718-91.38-146.44-401.82234.07195.83-3.66E+06-7.32E+06-2.41E+071.64E+071.57E+07
193039.58230608722565.51740036751928.746870820219322.53496.48343.41363.44425.671.29E+072.48E+072.06E+072.54E+073.41E+07
202820.58679721792385.2111296191756.52416900920-7.48127.78-32.36-12.9148.89-2.99E+056.39E+06-1.94E+06-9.03E+053.91E+06
214065.13629549923161.99864091332330.452953616921-736.15-133.13-322.43-68.97-9.16-2.94E+07-6.66E+06-1.93E+07-4.83E+06-7.33E+05
222995.34562545712526.52831050921897.6291671222342.26510.96354.39371.92432.281.37E+072.55E+072.13E+072.60E+073.46E+07
232776.35011658772346.22203976081725.40646530872313.38143.39-20.24-3.2956.635.35E+057.17E+06-1.21E+06-2.30E+054.53E+06
243892.1347331443467.5758299052234.952809054124-872.48-748.04-940.84-280.93-223.00-3.49E+07-3.74E+07-5.65E+07-1.97E+07-1.78E+07
252987.12817297652629.75549721661886.24593087925252.54309.79329.24338.66345.731.01E+071.55E+071.98E+072.37E+072.77E+07
262768.13266410722449.44922646811714.023229067826-71.54-52.97-40.60-31.76-25.12-2.86E+06-2.65E+06-2.44E+06-2.22E+06-2.01E+06
274012.68216238853226.23673776242287.952013675727-806.13-319.80-336.59-93.73-89.09-3.22E+07-1.60E+07-2.02E+07-6.56E+06-7.13E+06
282942.89149234642590.76640735841855.128227178828272.53324.54340.48347.40352.601.09E+071.62E+072.04E+072.43E+072.82E+07
292649.41056423882349.29237596371641.71425260942924.0424.0424.0424.0424.049.61E+051.20E+061.44E+061.68E+061.92E+06
303839.68060003333531.81392675422192.45186911330-939.06-931.31-951.60-302.29-299.53-3.76E+07-4.66E+07-5.71E+07-2.12E+07-2.40E+07
312401.26498559342092.34024909461608.873557630531920.14928.95728.72715.07704.833.68E+074.64E+074.37E+075.01E+075.64E+07
322182.2694767241912.03397834611436.650855819332591.58561.70354.41340.18329.502.37E+072.81E+072.13E+072.38E+072.64E+07
333341.19468557182618.56372935151963.371673855333-52.92369.60122.90335.36317.21-2.12E+061.85E+077.37E+062.35E+072.54E+07
342357.02830496322053.35115923641577.755853930334939.93943.49739.76723.62711.513.76E+074.72E+074.44E+075.07E+075.69E+07
352138.03279609391873.04488848791405.53315211935612.50577.37366.58349.85337.302.45E+072.89E+072.20E+072.45E+072.70E+07
363168.19312321662924.14091834331867.871529292636-188.42-244.48-494.68124.23104.21-7.54E+06-1.22E+07-2.97E+078.70E+068.34E+06
373059.88631176922560.64771974821949.722642838437345.48544.60369.63402.10447.951.38E+072.72E+072.22E+072.81E+073.58E+07
382840.89080289982380.34144899981777.49994102723812.66173.09-8.9522.9468.355.06E+058.65E+06-5.37E+051.61E+065.47E+06
394000.38430054743087.32583104492304.50490346339-628.16-15.22-236.5922.0560.03-2.51E+07-7.61E+05-1.42E+071.54E+064.80E+06
403014.2488651392539.289785891917.904556138140354.51529.35350.88399.18443.161.42E+072.65E+072.11E+072.79E+073.55E+07
412795.25335626972358.98351514151745.68185432694123.42159.57-25.9721.7665.309.37E+057.98E+06-1.56E+061.52E+065.22E+06
423825.98197219223410.53417603672208.304375900342-776.36-661.03-885.90-202.48-166.38-3.11E+07-3.31E+07-5.32E+07-1.42E+07-1.33E+07
433007.43217865852624.88581659731907.221702897243274.82357.25354.79376.65367.341.10E+071.79E+072.13E+072.64E+072.94E+07
442788.43666978912444.57954584891734.99900108644-51.97-8.23-17.763.52-6.23-2.08E+06-4.12E+05-1.07E+062.46E+05-4.98E+05
453947.93016743663151.5639278942262.003963521945-698.79-202.55-251.41-3.38-20.56-2.80E+07-1.01E+07-1.51E+07-2.37E+05-1.65E+06
462961.79473202832603.52788273911875.40361619746284.26342.41336.45374.14362.961.14E+071.71E+072.02E+072.62E+072.90E+07
472742.7992231592423.22161199061703.180914385747-40.86-21.40-34.432.69-8.93-1.63E+06-1.07E+06-2.07E+061.88E+05-7.15E+05
483773.52783908153474.77227288582165.803435959148-843.41-844.78-897.14-224.33-243.38-3.37E+07-4.22E+07-5.38E+07-1.57E+07-1.95E+07
492335.98258776182017.24311692241582.6603060368491028.511047.13814.76991.35774.144.11E+075.24E+074.89E+076.94E+076.19E+07
502116.98707889241836.9368461741410.437604225650697.17677.10437.66428.56396.022.79E+073.39E+072.63E+073.00E+073.17E+07
513276.480576542543.92122821921937.44256666155154.88487.32208.55426.19386.222.20E+062.44E+071.25E+072.98E+073.09E+07
522290.34514113161995.88518306421550.8422193366521037.641031.98796.11803.42769.454.15E+075.16E+074.78E+075.62E+076.16E+07
532071.34963226231815.57891231581378.619517525353708.01663.67420.73427.46393.052.83E+073.32E+072.52E+072.99E+073.14E+07
543102.07824818482867.12957321091841.242039098754-92.45-157.62-439.88202.54160.69-3.70E+06-7.88E+06-2.64E+071.42E+071.29E+07
original choice is case 16
varying aluminum prices--not sure what we would do. Case 49 might be better, but it has a lower recycling rate.
caseBIW costBIW costBIW costBIW costcaseour total savings including 3/4 of fuel
Al at $1.10Al at $1.50Al at $1.75Al at $2.00Al at $1.10Al at $1.50Al at $1.75Al at $2.00
$$$$$$$$
12493.96824517512640.56100124662743.67180593912876.65338769751746.39599.80496.69363.71
22403.87569307712460.25473049812526.79630904192591.50570783912279.09222.72156.1791.46
33275.32943648643237.04224179243461.36087386123368.29321913343-68.13-29.84-254.16-161.09
42464.83872923082601.57191138842698.52048238472825.33983044694750.63613.90516.95390.13
52374.74617713282421.26564063992481.64498548752540.19215058855284.52238.00177.62119.08
63496.09996727713542.61943078423602.99877563183661.54594073286-603.04-649.56-709.94-768.49
72556.73233169082704.79909809572765.56005512042856.19178921097559.20411.13350.37259.74
82466.63977959282524.49282734722548.68455822322571.0441093525898.1240.2716.08-6.28
93338.09352300213301.28033864153483.24912304243347.83162064689-255.30-218.49-400.46-265.04
102527.60281574652665.81000823752720.40873156592804.878231960310563.72425.51370.91286.44
112437.51026364852485.5037374892503.53323466882519.730552101811103.7955.8037.7721.57
123558.86405379283606.85752763333624.8870248133641.084342246112-786.64-834.64-852.67-868.86
132019.31708356882167.38384997372228.14480699832318.7765410889131179.841031.78971.02880.38
141929.22453147081987.07757922522011.26931010122033.628861230514714.07656.22632.03609.67
152730.42051459122693.60733023062875.57611463162740.158612235915435.59472.40290.43425.85
161990.18756762452128.39476011552182.99348344392267.4629838383161184.151045.94991.35906.88
171900.09501552651948.0884893671966.11798654681982.315303979817719.56671.57653.54637.34
182951.19104538192999.18451922243017.21401640223033.411333835218-98.45-146.44-164.47-180.67
192466.91811813652565.51740036752650.59870788022767.382972205619595.08496.48411.40294.62
202376.82556603842385.2111296192433.72321098312482.235292347120136.16127.7879.2730.76
213248.27930944773161.99864091333368.28777580233259.022803641421-219.41-133.13-339.42-230.15
222437.78860219222526.52831050922605.44738432582716.06941495522599.70510.96432.04321.42
232347.69605009422346.22203976082388.57188742862430.921735096523141.92143.39101.0458.69
243469.04984023843467.5758299053509.92567757293552.275525240824-749.52-748.04-790.39-832.74
252529.68220465222629.75549721662672.48695706152746.921373718925409.87309.79267.06192.63
262439.58965255422449.44922646812455.61146016432461.773693860526-43.11-52.97-59.13-65.30
273311.04339596343226.23673776243390.17602498363238.561205154827-404.60-319.80-483.74-332.12
282500.55268870792590.76640735842627.33563350712695.607816468328414.75324.54287.97219.70
292349.29237596372349.29237596372349.29237596372349.29237596372924.0424.0424.0424.04
303531.81392675423531.81392675423531.81392675423531.813926754230-931.31-931.31-931.31-931.31
311992.26695653022092.34024909462135.07170893952209.5061255969311029.02928.95886.21811.78
321902.17440443221912.03397834611918.19621204231924.358445738532571.56561.70555.54549.37
332703.37038755262618.56372935152782.50301657272630.888196743933284.79369.60205.66357.27
341963.13744058592053.35115923642089.9203853852158.1925683463341033.70943.49906.92838.65
351873.04488848791873.04488848791873.04488848791873.044888487935577.37577.37577.37577.37
362924.14091834332924.14091834332924.14091834332924.140918343336-244.48-244.48-244.48-244.48
372465.85482191722560.64771974822652.0730012612762.513291586337639.40544.60453.18342.74
382375.76226981922380.34144899982435.19750436382477.365611727938177.67173.09118.2376.07
393177.41288397943087.32583104493299.9589399343184.349993773139-105.30-15.22-227.85-112.24
402450.55007757292539.289785892618.20885970662728.830890335740618.09529.35450.43339.81
412360.45752547492358.98351514152401.33336280942443.683210477341158.10159.57117.2274.87
423412.00818637013410.53417603673452.88402370463495.233871372542-662.50-661.03-703.38-745.73
432528.6189084332624.88581659732673.96125044222742.051693099743453.52357.25308.18240.09
442438.52635633492444.57954584892457.08575354512456.904013241344-2.18-8.23-20.74-20.56
453240.17697049513151.5639278943321.84718911523163.888395286445-291.16-202.55-372.83-214.87
462513.31416408872603.52788273912640.09710888782708.369291849146432.62342.41305.84237.57
472423.22161199062423.22161199062423.22161199062423.221611990647-21.40-21.40-21.40-21.40
483474.77227288583474.77227288583474.77227288583474.772272885848-844.78-844.78-844.78-844.78
491920.97620875812017.24311692242066.31855076742134.4089934248491143.401047.13998.06929.97
501830.883656661836.9368461741849.44305387021849.261313566450683.15677.10664.59664.77
512632.53427082022543.92122821922714.20448944042556.245695611651398.71487.32317.04474.99
521905.67146441381995.88518306422032.45440921292100.7265921742521122.201031.98995.41927.14
531815.57891231581815.57891231581815.57891231581815.578912315853663.67663.67663.67663.67
542867.12957321092867.12957321092867.12957321092867.129573210954-157.62-157.62-157.62-157.62
original choice is case 16
varying fuel savings--
caseour total savings including 3/4 of fuel
base caseoptimisticbase case but
10-5 rule1st principleswith 5% DR
1599.80963.08759.10
2222.72289.38279.63
3-29.84332.53129.13
4613.90964.91768.79
5238.00292.10290.75
6-649.56-450.82-548.06
7411.13709.17547.19
840.2740.1375.18
9-218.4978.63-82.75
10425.51711.20557.22
1155.8043.0386.59
12-834.64-702.06-755.66
131031.781379.301185.42
14656.22706.74707.78
15472.40819.01625.72
161045.941381.181195.20
17671.57709.50718.97
18-146.4436.31-50.42
19496.48771.21624.34
20127.78103.79154.92
21-133.13140.68-5.59
22510.96773.32634.49
23143.39106.76166.43
24-748.04-639.09-677.02
25309.79518.77414.81
26-52.97-144.17-47.49
27-319.80-111.75-215.10
28324.54521.07425.28
2924.04-79.8625.46
30-931.31-888.96-882.45
31928.951187.791051.25
32561.70521.47583.58
33369.60627.52491.58
34943.491189.951061.48
35577.37524.48595.15
36-244.48-151.62-178.85
37544.60849.58683.11
38173.09180.05210.32
39-15.22288.84122.97
40529.35815.73661.31
41159.57147.51190.60
42-661.03-527.76-581.82
43357.25596.64472.78
44-8.23-68.357.23
45-202.5535.92-87.33
46342.41563.10451.47
47-21.40-100.62-12.08
48-844.78-777.99-787.83
491047.131336.261180.05
50677.10667.84709.04
51487.32775.53619.92
521031.981302.501158.37
53663.67635.37689.41
54-157.62-40.41-83.82
original choice is case 16
varying gas price--
caseour total savings including 3/4 of fuel
$4/gal$3.50/gal$3/gal
1599.80500.01400.23
2222.72187.07151.42
3-29.84-129.42-229.00
4613.90516.87419.84
5238.00204.96171.92
6-649.56-713.14-776.72
7411.13325.91240.68
840.2718.40-3.47
9-218.49-303.51-388.54
10425.51343.01260.50
1155.8036.5117.22
12-834.64-884.11-933.58
131031.78935.53839.29
14656.22623.92591.62
15472.40376.36280.32
161045.94952.45858.96
17671.57641.87612.17
18-146.44-206.59-266.74
19496.48416.39336.30
20127.78110.7893.77
21-133.13-213.02-292.91
22510.96433.58356.20
23143.39128.96114.52
24-748.04-792.53-837.02
25309.79244.01178.23
26-52.97-56.41-59.84
27-319.80-385.38-450.96
28324.54261.43198.33
2924.0423.1422.25
30-931.31-961.92-992.52
31928.95852.34775.72
32561.70547.99534.29
33369.60293.19216.78
34943.49869.58795.67
35577.37566.22555.08
36-244.48-285.60-326.71
37544.60457.84371.08
38173.09149.77126.45
39-15.22-101.77-188.33
40529.35446.70364.04
41159.57140.14120.71
42-661.03-710.64-760.26
43357.25284.88212.52
44-8.23-17.91-27.60
45-202.55-274.71-346.88
46342.41274.10205.79
47-21.40-27.23-33.07
48-844.78-880.45-916.12
491047.13963.87880.61
50677.10657.09637.08
51487.32404.26321.20
521031.98952.82873.65
53663.67647.54631.41
54-157.62-203.84-250.07
original choice is case 16
varying gas and Al together and to our disadvantage
caseour total savings including 3/4 of fuel
base casegas at $3.90gas at $3.853.84
Al at $1.60Al at $1.651.66
1599.80535.89528.7387005898520.5443036727
2222.72201.06180.1571863009175.9763845834
3-29.84-127.39-186.2461165813-198.0166060395
4613.90553.01547.3613308213539.4686002207
5238.00219.33199.9243903594196.0422820394
6-649.56-674.34-696.8007096473-701.2935926737
7411.13367.08369.8510221328363.6417678616
840.2738.3127.255223751625.044017366
9-218.49-296.19-345.1136586797-354.8990577942
10425.51384.47388.7439333805382.8356433972
1155.8056.8247.253497029345.3403838614
12-834.64-839.65-852.2347429345-854.751453822
131031.78985.52987.1904057336980.7608226828
14656.22652.18640.0770844634637.6572831239
15472.40392.50342.4682912972332.4626028678
161045.941002.701005.8793742151999.7512851737
17671.57670.51659.9009264961657.7796714425
18-146.44-153.59-167.2438833436-169.974153441
19496.48431.64434.0865319528427.8133290095
20127.78104.9793.570983264891.2904249613
21-133.13-231.62-280.8711591776-290.7205251192
22510.96449.12453.0732672715447.1007849172
23143.39123.56113.649660512111.6669865847
24-748.04-773.88-786.7995761636-789.3833517152
25309.79264.75277.1020538198272.809050145
26-52.97-56.12-57.7006050903-58.0158028002
27-319.80-398.49-437.8364640103-445.7056804842
28324.54282.49296.3461692543292.3532176488
2924.0423.8623.76690379523.7490162509
30-931.31-937.43-940.4910942618-941.1032236879
31928.95881.74893.0052745531888.4956723919
32561.70556.49553.8904455029553.3698497486
33369.60288.74248.3100477279240.2242703502
34943.49899.28912.0551543238907.84610874
35577.37575.14574.0232908162573.8004387418
36-244.48-252.70-256.815469465-257.6377419068
37544.60475.89476.399966684469.7396080675
38173.09146.48133.1794160517130.518728054
39-15.22-117.58-168.7636849048-179.00018291
40529.35466.46469.8852821003463.807306313
41159.57138.75128.3334650069126.2508254655
42-661.03-687.89-701.3231108104-704.0094221881
43357.25308.35318.7776215654314.0991190147
44-8.23-15.17-18.6394526598-19.3333585564
45-202.55-285.09-326.3665373672-334.6212299369
46342.41299.33312.6564876519308.5593457208
47-21.40-22.56-23.147844438-23.2645786557
48-844.78-851.91-855.4775298387-856.1909927508
491047.13996.051005.38965356481000.4933022427
50677.10668.09663.5922209227662.691843809
51487.32402.59360.230785038351.7582819036
521031.98986.73998.9715333996994.65731409
53663.67660.44658.8289893475658.5064458344
54-157.62-166.86-171.4828041551-172.4073176403
compare
3115.63228732762640.56100124662010.2102776523
2896.63677845832460.25473049811837.9875758411
4141.18627673963237.04224179242411.916360449
3071.39560669742601.57191138841979.0925739521
2852.40009782812421.26564063991806.8698721408
3968.18471438443542.61943078422316.4162158862
3063.17815421692704.79909809571967.7093377112
2844.18264534762524.49282734721795.4866358999
4088.73214362893301.28033864152369.4154205078
3018.94147358672665.81000823751936.5916340109
2799.94596471742485.5037374891764.3689321997
3915.73058127373606.85752763332273.9152759451
2477.31496683382167.38384997371690.3369644626
2258.31945796441987.07757922521518.1142626514
3417.24466681222693.60733023062044.8350806874
2433.07828620362128.39476011551659.2192607624
2214.08277733421948.0884893671486.9965589512
3244.2431044572999.18451922241949.3349361247
3039.58230608722565.51740036751928.7468708202
2820.58679721792385.2111296191756.524169009
4065.13629549923161.99864091332330.4529536169
2995.34562545712526.52831050921897.62916712
2776.35011658772346.22203976081725.4064653087
3892.1347331443467.5758299052234.9528090541
2987.12817297652629.75549721661886.245930879
2768.13266410722449.44922646811714.0232290678
4012.68216238853226.23673776242287.9520136757
2942.89149234642590.76640735841855.1282271788
2649.41056423882349.29237596371641.7142526094
3839.68060003333531.81392675422192.451869113
2401.26498559342092.34024909461608.8735576305
2182.2694767241912.03397834611436.6508558193
3341.19468557182618.56372935151963.3716738553
2357.02830496322053.35115923641577.7558539303
2138.03279609391873.04488848791405.533152119
3168.19312321662924.14091834331867.8715292926
3059.88631176922560.64771974821949.7226428384
2840.89080289982380.34144899981777.4999410272
4000.38430054743087.32583104492304.504903463
3014.2488651392539.289785891917.9045561381
2795.25335626972358.98351514151745.6818543269
3825.98197219223410.53417603672208.3043759003
3007.43217865852624.88581659731907.2217028972
2788.43666978912444.57954584891734.999001086
3947.93016743663151.5639278942262.0039635219
2961.79473202832603.52788273911875.403616197
2742.7992231592423.22161199061703.1809143857
3773.52783908153474.77227288582165.8034359591
2335.98258776182017.24311692241582.6603060368
2116.98707889241836.9368461741410.4376042256
3276.480576542543.92122821921937.4425666615
2290.34514113161995.88518306421550.8422193366
2071.34963226231815.57891231581378.6195175253
3102.07824818482867.12957321091841.2420390987
40K/yr
50K/yr
80K/yr
Materials Selection Case #
BIW Cost ($)
BIW Cost with Different Production Volumes
Inputs
424.8446225143599.7977203203441.5510289891478.5531635176522.5703205603
86.4513751638222.715234848957.403397365893.8235760169137.4042661516
-633.8685985938-29.8427519217-224.320057093446.113521544687.7050060674
444.18984877613.895355804452.1502706249486.6535524048528.796569886
106.9857690319238.002037945169.191806614103.1131325166144.8196830898
-775.0085367894-649.5614414643-847.5371404839-170.6536948821-130.9363499206
352.8720343289411.1329021751425.3988786907451.7902759669440.6445392053
20.697712596840.269342322147.470172685873.279614084661.6974104151
-705.8202658872-218.4866491749-240.451286499719.37155488595.8001456045
372.49807203425.5113491042436.2789317718460.1714762994447.1515999765
41.47217838155.796217334359.4986538582.809242500369.3528992694
-843.392922201-834.6380568357-860.1010880086-193.828379659-209.2739285018
1021.96428888431031.7772174693826.3760493645829.6958421063801.245979626
685.0964368778656.220127342443.7538130853446.4916499497417.6053205615
48.8804922182472.3996405248220.5235058164449.9573478369413.5937667137
1041.37843799721045.9437758102837.0442138575837.8651538507807.541151809
705.6896753945671.5657750867455.6010669821455.8400510979425.0795821483
-91.384206055-146.4438090955-401.8183376518234.0653713326195.8276506479
322.5349018441496.4816192888343.4109305033363.4442185681425.6740254818
-7.4781215054127.7793578184-32.356477119-12.905144931548.8881950742
-736.1501363646-133.1306700537-322.4319726798-68.9672405054-9.1631061116
342.2584190995510.9575457722354.3884631387371.922898455432.2785658072
13.3798808705143.3897694223-20.2444593631-3.291979924156.6272205201
-872.4836578537-748.0429428898-940.8426393638-280.9280402256-222.9980453932
252.5396646447309.7941521296329.2361311909338.6586820034345.7255951129
-71.5378888058-52.9726394418-40.5958065324-31.7552115972-25.1247653958
-806.125453252-319.798216901-336.5868516802-93.7328567582-89.0916161686
272.5305898126324.5374865255340.4810717388347.4047698028352.5975433508
24.035216955824.035216955824.035216955824.035216955824.0352169558
-939.0576378741-931.3091528701-951.5961814973-302.2923196113-299.5252185832
920.1398019351928.9463501589728.7211845998715.0721308779704.8349182686
591.5820717158561.6993818186354.4090701076340.1780605084329.5043809911
-52.9160595504369.5967083949122.8965762322335.361571789317.2106405368
939.928923816943.4878812677739.7643218606723.6164153902711.5050632195
612.4963526018577.3660719327366.5773663737349.847504026337.2996849473
-188.4153994363-244.481382838-494.6799088487124.2349536721104.2098828584
345.4819853731544.6023891189369.6250370521402.0985500285447.9493426745
12.658570393173.089736018-8.952762200722.938794898368.3531206363
-628.1564960538-15.2162148265-236.59276165722.048923340960.0265894011
354.5110711241529.3519620979350.8762161831399.1824154109443.1590684956
23.4214052754159.5730581284-25.967833938321.756409412165.2965955888
-776.3580480263-661.028440146-885.9033808244-202.4802898626-166.3767633638
274.8240292276357.2522030136354.7875187936376.6502945176367.3381933595
-51.969799875-8.2308642098-17.76069458183.520125265-6.2284428012
-698.794200089-202.5461488215-251.4100278052-3.3790800597-20.5643078036
284.2619987917342.4106598058336.4475817378374.1430437133362.9568029937
-40.8562540664-21.3968311731-34.42505539312.6884507051-8.9342569225
-843.412964078-844.7755861574-897.1378589891-224.3255052796-243.384872585
1028.51068401921047.1319665834814.7608364359991.3450524817774.1366541148
697.1658331849677.0978776283437.6616013288428.5570299932396.0189962224
54.8771720074487.3183320531208.5480071419426.1935637052386.2188702565
1037.64009643881031.9818662311796.1123422356803.4224130287769.4467066045
708.0146103733663.6671420447420.7324718973427.4605868131393.0484134809
-92.4455885753-157.6151018766-439.8838206357202.5431418914160.6943088813
40K/yr
50K/yr
60k/yr
70k/yr
80k/yr
Materials Selection Case #
Change in Profit per Vehicle ($)
Change in Profit with Production Changes
Roof Stamp
2493.96824517512640.56100124662743.67180593912876.6533876975
2403.87569307712460.25473049812526.79630904192591.5057078391
3275.32943648643237.04224179243461.36087386123368.2932191334
2464.83872923082601.57191138842698.52048238472825.3398304469
2374.74617713282421.26564063992481.64498548752540.1921505885
3496.09996727713542.61943078423602.99877563183661.5459407328
2556.73233169082704.79909809572765.56005512042856.1917892109
2466.63977959282524.49282734722548.68455822322571.0441093525
3338.09352300213301.28033864153483.24912304243347.8316206468
2527.60281574652665.81000823752720.40873156592804.8782319603
2437.51026364852485.5037374892503.53323466882519.7305521018
3558.86405379283606.85752763333624.8870248133641.0843422461
2019.31708356882167.38384997372228.14480699832318.7765410889
1929.22453147081987.07757922522011.26931010122033.6288612305
2730.42051459122693.60733023062875.57611463162740.1586122359
1990.18756762452128.39476011552182.99348344392267.4629838383
1900.09501552651948.0884893671966.11798654681982.3153039798
2951.19104538192999.18451922243017.21401640223033.4113338352
2466.91811813652565.51740036752650.59870788022767.3829722056
2376.82556603842385.2111296192433.72321098312482.2352923471
3248.27930944773161.99864091333368.28777580233259.0228036414
2437.78860219222526.52831050922605.44738432582716.069414955
2347.69605009422346.22203976082388.57188742862430.9217350965
3469.04984023843467.5758299053509.92567757293552.2755252408
2529.68220465222629.75549721662672.48695706152746.9213737189
2439.58965255422449.44922646812455.61146016432461.7736938605
3311.04339596343226.23673776243390.17602498363238.5612051548
2500.55268870792590.76640735842627.33563350712695.6078164683
2349.29237596372349.29237596372349.29237596372349.2923759637
3531.81392675423531.81392675423531.81392675423531.8139267542
1992.26695653022092.34024909462135.07170893952209.5061255969
1902.17440443221912.03397834611918.19621204231924.3584457385
2703.37038755262618.56372935152782.50301657272630.8881967439
1963.13744058592053.35115923642089.9203853852158.1925683463
1873.04488848791873.04488848791873.04488848791873.0448884879
2924.14091834332924.14091834332924.14091834332924.1409183433
2465.85482191722560.64771974822652.0730012612762.5132915863
2375.76226981922380.34144899982435.19750436382477.3656117279
3177.41288397943087.32583104493299.9589399343184.3499937731
2450.55007757292539.289785892618.20885970662728.8308903357
2360.45752547492358.98351514152401.33336280942443.6832104773
3412.00818637013410.53417603673452.88402370463495.2338713725
2528.6189084332624.88581659732673.96125044222742.0516930997
2438.52635633492444.57954584892457.08575354512456.9040132413
3240.17697049513151.5639278943321.84718911523163.8883952864
2513.31416408872603.52788273912640.09710888782708.3692918491
2423.22161199062423.22161199062423.22161199062423.2216119906
3474.77227288583474.77227288583474.77227288583474.7722728858
1920.97620875812017.24311692242066.31855076742134.4089934248
1830.883656661836.9368461741849.44305387021849.2613135664
2632.53427082022543.92122821922714.20448944042556.2456956116
1905.67146441381995.88518306422032.45440921292100.7265921742
1815.57891231581815.57891231581815.57891231581815.5789123158
2867.12957321092867.12957321092867.12957321092867.1295732109
Al at $1.10
Al at $1.50
Al at $1.75
Al at $2.00
Materials Selection Case #
BIW Cost ($)
BIW Costs with Changing Al Prices
Floor Stamp
746.3904763918599.7977203203496.6869156277363.7053338693
279.0942722699222.7152348489156.17365630591.4642575078
-68.1299466157-29.8427519217-254.1613839905-161.0937292627
750.6285379616613.895355804516.9467848077390.1274367454
284.5215014521238.0020379451177.6226930974119.0755279964
-603.0419779572-649.5614414643-709.9407863119-768.4879514129
559.1996685799411.1329021751350.3719451504259.7402110599
98.122390076540.269342322116.0776114461-6.2819396832
-255.2998335355-218.4866491749-400.4554335758-265.0379311801
563.7185415951425.5113491042370.9126257757286.4431253814
103.789691174855.796217334337.766720154521.5694027214
-786.6445829952-834.6380568357-852.6675540155-868.8648714486
1179.84398387421031.7772174693971.0162604446880.3845263541
714.0731750964656.220127342632.028396466609.6688453367
435.5864561642472.3996405248290.4308561238425.8483585195
1184.15096830111045.9437758102991.3450524817906.8755520874
719.5592489272671.5657750867653.5362779069637.3389604738
-98.450335255-146.4438090955-164.4733062753-180.6706237083
595.0809015198496.4816192888411.400311776294.6160474507
136.1649213989127.779357818479.267276454330.7551950903
-219.4113385882-133.1306700537-339.4198049428-230.1548327819
599.6972540893510.9575457722432.0384719556321.4164413265
141.9157590889143.3897694223101.039921754458.6900740866
-749.5169532232-748.0429428898-790.3927905577-832.7426382256
409.867444694309.7941521296267.0626922847192.6282756273
-43.1130655278-52.9726394418-59.134873138-65.2971068342
-404.604875102-319.798216901-483.7375041222-332.1226842934
414.751205176324.5374865255287.9682603768219.6960774156
24.035216955824.035216955824.035216955824.0352169558
-931.3091528701-931.3091528701-931.3091528701-931.3091528701
1029.0196427232928.9463501589886.214890314811.7804736565
571.5589557325561.6993818186555.5371481224549.3749144262
284.7900501938369.5967083949205.6574211737357.2722410025
1033.7015999182943.4878812677906.918655119838.6464721578
577.3660719327577.3660719327577.3660719327577.3660719327
-244.481382838-244.481382838-244.481382838-244.481382838
639.3952869499544.6023891189453.1771076062342.7368172808
177.6689151985173.089736018118.233680653976.0655732899
-105.303267761-15.2162148265-227.8493237156-112.2403775547
618.091670415529.3519620979450.4328882814339.8108576522
158.099047795159.5730581284117.223210460574.8733627926
-662.5024504793-661.028440146-703.3782878138-745.7281354817
453.519111178357.2522030136308.1767691687240.0863265113
-2.1776746959-8.2308642098-20.737071906-20.5553316022
-291.1591914226-202.5461488215-372.8294100427-214.8706162139
432.6243784563342.4106598058305.8414336571237.5692506958
-21.3968311731-21.3968311731-21.3968311731-21.3968311731
-844.7755861574-844.7755861574-844.7755861574-844.7755861574
1143.39887474781047.1319665834998.0565327385929.9660900811
683.1510671422677.0978776283664.5916699321664.7734102359
398.705289452487.3183320531317.0350708319474.9938646607
1122.19558488151031.9818662311995.4126400824927.1404571211
663.6671420447663.6671420447663.6671420447663.6671420447
-157.6151018766-157.6151018766-157.6151018766-157.6151018766
Al at $1.10
Al at $1.50
Al at $1.75
Al at $2.00
Materials Selection Case #
Change in Profit per Vehicle ($)
Change in Profit with Changing Al Prices
OuterQ Stamp
16993784.90057329989886.016014626493061.739347233498721.446231341805625.6448216
3458055.0065507211135761.74244393444203.841946986567650.3211846610992341.2921284
-25354743.9437531-1492137.59608441-13459203.42560173227946.508119827016400.48539202
17767593.950801330694767.790201327129016.237492134065748.668334642303725.5908832
4279430.761277311900101.89725334151508.396839417217919.2761600111585574.6471867
-31000341.4715775-32478072.0732136-50852228.4290356-11945758.641744-10474907.9936516
14114881.373157320556645.10875425523932.721441731625319.317680935251563.1364262
827908.5038720392013467.116104512848210.361147025129572.985924044935792.8332072
-28232810.6354868-10924332.4587425-14427077.18998421356008.84201294464011.648360711
14899922.881201221275567.455210126176735.9063132212003.340961535772127.9981191
1658887.135240122789810.866715913569919.231001695796646.975022025548231.94154849
-33735716.888042-41731902.8417852-51606065.2805143-13567986.5761297-16741914.2801445
40878571.555371351588860.873464549582562.961872958078708.947441364099678.3700833
27403857.475112732811006.367098326625228.785118231254415.49648133408425.6449175
1955219.6887298723619982.026238613231410.348985831497014.3485833087501.3370925
41655137.51988652297188.790509150222652.831447558650560.769545764603292.1447177
28227587.015781533578288.754335527336064.018923931908803.576855134006366.5718601
-3655368.24220112-7322190.45477388-24109100.259108116384575.993279615666212.0518356
12901396.073764624824080.9644420604655.830196425441095.299769734053922.0385431
-299124.8602164476388967.89092074-1941388.62714202-903360.145204833911055.60593239
-29446005.4545838-6656533.50268685-19345918.3607859-4827706.83538077-733048.488931017
13690336.763979625547877.288610121263307.788321426034602.891849834582285.2645782
535195.2348183457169488.47111553-1214667.56178729-230438.5946901024530177.64160709
-34899346.3141481-37402147.144491-56450558.3618298-19664962.8157895-17839843.6314546
10101586.585789515489707.606480219754167.871451723706107.740240327658047.609029
-2861515.55223078-2648631.97208813-2435748.39194548-2222864.81180283-2009981.23166018
-32245018.13008-15989910.8450482-20195211.1008123-6561299.97307216-7127329.29348749
10901223.59250616226874.32627720428864.30432924318333.88619828207803.468067
961408.6782305841201760.847788231442113.017345881682465.186903521922817.35646117
-37562305.514965-46565457.6435032-57095770.8898372-21160462.372792-23962017.4866524
36805592.077405346447317.507942843723271.075985650055049.161453756386793.4614895
23663282.868630528084969.090931321264544.206456623812464.235590126360350.4792913
-2116642.3820148118479835.41974367373794.5739304623475310.025229825376851.2429413
37597156.952638647174394.063385744385859.311638250653149.077315956920405.0575613
24499854.104073428868303.596636321994641.982423624489325.281819226983974.7957824
-7536615.97745013-12224069.1418993-29680794.53091998696446.757046878336790.62867585
13819279.414923827230119.455947422177502.223126828146898.501992735835947.4139621
506342.8157207398654486.80090075-537165.7320444471605715.64287985468249.65090755
-25126259.8421525-760810.741324701-14195565.6994181543424.633862324802127.15209074
14180442.844962526467598.104897121052572.970987527942769.078764435452725.4796447
936856.2110147427978652.90641952-1558070.036300881522948.658848145223727.64710067
-31054321.9210519-33051422.0072976-53154202.8494644-14173620.2903827-13310141.0691028
10992961.16910317862610.150680521287251.127613726365520.616233529387055.4687567
-2078791.99499898-411543.210489881-1065641.67490598246408.76854735-498275.424095831
-27951768.0035614-10127307.4410767-15084601.6683132-236535.604176021-1645144.62429082
11370479.951669317120532.990289720186854.904265826190013.059928429036544.2394945
-1634250.16265401-1069841.55865737-2065503.32358595188191.549354904-714740.55380074
-33736518.563119-42238779.3078725-53828271.5393471-15702785.3695731-19470789.8068011
41140427.360767852356598.329171648885650.186155569394153.673719461930932.329184
27886633.327394933854893.881412626259696.079729429998992.09952431681519.6977897
2195086.8802953924365916.602654312512880.428516529833549.459360630897509.6205203
41505603.857552451599093.311553647766740.534134956239568.91201161555736.5283582
28320584.414931833183357.10223525243948.313837429922241.076917531443873.0784686
-3697823.5430134-7880755.09383038-26393029.238144114178019.932399112855544.7105079
40K/yr
50K/yr
60k/yr
70k/yr
80k/yr
Materials Selection Case #
Change to Yearly Profit
Changes to Yearly Profits with Production Volume
InnerQ Stamp
BIW costvehicle weightfuel costrecycle cost
$lb$$
base case2349.2923759637311115020.05292505599.63
BIW andfuel savingssavings to ussavings to ustotal savings
recycle$including 1/2including 3/4recycle %to society
savingsof fuel savingsof fuel savings$
$$$
best choice probably option 16
+ good- good+ good+ good
1-291.2686252829-453.04613488241064.366596458892.79-198.481064.37333.71599.8089.66865.89
2-110.9623545344-163.6141980202380.255726475148.49-62.48380.26127.65222.7279.23317.78
3-887.7498658287-452.14605944271062.1787130261.27-826.481062.18-295.39-29.8486.70235.70
4-252.2795354247-440.92613488241034.938879834189.97-162.311034.94355.16613.9089.18872.63
5-71.9732646762-151.4941980202352.41356666745.67-26.31352.41149.90238.0078.84326.11
6-1193.3270548204-291.6254076152678.160076794235.15-1158.18678.16-819.10-649.5680.82-480.02
7-355.506722132-388.7590394014909.087268903184.82-270.68909.09183.86411.1387.15638.40
8-175.2004513835-99.3271025393233.26829974440.52-134.68233.27-18.0540.2777.1998.59
9-951.9879626778-387.8589639617906.92727998753.31-898.68906.93-445.22-218.4984.278.25
10-316.5176322738-376.6390394014880.03396753982.00-234.51880.03205.50425.5186.69645.52
11-136.2113615253-87.2071025392205.74623582437.70-98.51205.754.3655.8076.81107.23
12-1257.5651516696-227.3383121342527.665019603627.18-1230.39527.67-966.55-834.6478.65-702.72
13181.90852599-437.48465672111026.595951335379.92261.831026.60775.131031.7887.581288.43
14362.2147967385-148.052719859344.518941810435.62397.83344.52570.09656.2277.40742.35
15-344.3149542669-436.58458128141024.414914574648.40-295.911024.41216.30472.4084.63728.50
16220.8976158482-425.3646567211997.260131853677.10298.00997.26796.631045.9487.111295.26
17401.2038865967-135.932719859316.755241533832.80434.00316.76592.38671.5777.02750.75
18-649.8921432587-276.0639294539641.56326491222.28-627.62641.56-306.83-146.4478.9013.95
19-216.2250244038-365.8840323431854.310597453871.97-144.25854.31282.90496.4886.29710.06
20-35.9187536553-76.452095481181.373359471527.67-8.25181.3782.44127.7876.48173.12
21-812.7062649496-364.9839569034852.160291214240.46-772.25852.16-346.17-133.1383.4379.91
22-177.2359345455-353.7640323431825.387268828769.15-108.08825.39304.61510.9685.84717.30
233.0703362029-64.332095481153.962677673724.8527.92153.96104.90143.3976.11181.88
24-1118.2834539414-204.4633050759474.550210597114.33-1103.96474.55-866.68-748.0477.90-629.41
25-280.4631212529-301.5969368621701.667737879564.01-216.46701.67134.38309.7983.94485.21
26-100.1568505044-12.16536.644459762519.70-80.4636.64-62.13-52.9774.55-43.81
27-876.9443617987-300.6968614224699.543992055932.49-844.46699.54-494.68-319.8081.14-144.91
28-241.4740313947-289.4769368621673.100953137861.19-180.29673.10156.26324.5483.51492.81
290-0.0459.540023494716.8816.889.5421.6524.0474.2026.42
30-1182.5215507905-140.1762095949326.46902726146.36-1176.16326.47-1012.93-931.3175.86-849.69
31256.9521268691-350.3225541819817.186930625159.10316.06817.19724.65928.9584.291133.24
32437.2583976176-60.8906173197146.19008348314.80452.06146.19525.15561.7074.72598.25
33-269.2713533878-349.4224787422815.043140771827.59-241.69815.04165.84369.6081.44573.36
34295.9412167273-338.2025541819788.35107483456.28352.22788.35746.40943.4983.851140.58
35476.2474874758-48.7706173197118.854439698811.98488.23118.85547.65577.3774.36607.08
36-574.8485423796-188.9018269147438.54530229231.46-573.39438.55-354.12-244.4876.06-134.85
37-211.3553437845-395.5745541507925.455511191461.87-149.49925.46313.24544.6083.57775.97
38-31.0490730361-106.1426172885248.771084368317.56-13.49248.77110.90173.0973.93235.28
39-738.0334550812-394.674478711923.292613149230.35-707.69923.29-246.04-15.2280.68215.61
40-189.9974099263-377.3141307507881.650433162258.11-131.89881.65308.94529.3582.90749.76
41-9.6911391778-87.8821938885207.277671847713.814.11207.28107.75159.5773.38211.39
42-1061.241800073-228.0134034835529.23598448943.29-1057.96529.24-793.34-661.0375.05-528.72
43-275.5934406336-331.2874586697771.929026355653.90-221.69771.93164.27357.2581.26550.23
44-95.2871698852-41.8555218075103.28404736929.59-85.69103.28-34.05-8.2372.0317.59
45-802.2715519304-330.38738323769.793131127122.38-779.89769.79-394.99-202.5578.43-10.10
46-254.2355067754-313.0270352697728.66912674450.14-204.09728.67160.24342.4180.62524.58
47-73.9292360269-23.595098407562.25824941695.84-68.0962.26-36.96-21.4071.51-5.83
48-1125.4798969221-163.7263080025380.513553112-4.68-1130.16380.51-939.90-844.7873.06-749.65
49332.0492590413-380.0130759894888.115037751449.00381.05888.12825.101047.1381.561269.16
50512.3555297897-90.5811391273213.40202978944.69517.05213.40623.75677.1072.16730.45
51-194.6288522555-379.1130005497885.95876559617.48-177.15885.96265.83487.3278.68708.81
52353.4071928995-361.7526525894844.443728613845.24398.65844.44820.871031.9880.911243.09
53533.7134636479-72.3207157273172.02320701010.94534.65172.02620.66663.6771.63706.67
54-517.8371972472-212.4519253222493.0738587892-9.58-527.42493.07-280.88-157.6273.21-34.35
Roof SMC
vehiclevehiclevehicleaverage
casevehicle weightBIW weightferrousnonferrousnonrecycleAlCuIronStainlessGlassRubberrecyclingF revenueF revenueNF revenueNF revenuelandfill costlandfill costrecycletotal savingstotal savingstotal savingspercent oflb of vehicle
lblblblbcostper vehicleper vehicleper vehicleper vehicleper vehicleper vehiclecostin recyclingin recyclingin recyclingvehicle weighttaken by
per vehicleR-o-TregressionR-o-TregressionR-o-Tregression$cost fromcost fromcost fromrecycleddismantler
$$$$$$$base casebase casebase case
using R-o-Tregression%
base31116082179.5225706.5155.549.54593185134.5-88.9980.6180.6154.6354.63-36.62-36.629.63$$$
savings fromsavings fromsavings fromsavings fromsavings fromsavings fromsavings from
base casebase casebase casebase casebase casebase casebase case
$R-o-TregressionR-o-TregressionR-o-TregressionUR %0F and NF %1
$$$$$$UR %0.25
12657.95306.271476.39517.69663.88146.0446.56431.3029.1679.96126.298.75-14.17-24.54155.0462.02-15.184.91134.4451.1592.7989.7426.76020830167.581.3
22947.39499.221910.37345.90691.12152.0348.47448.9930.3683.24131.473.275.36-9.3585.4625.48-18.391.8675.7121.2648.4979.2444.267946161868.982.4
32658.85306.871476.58431.92750.35146.0646.57431.3529.1679.97126.308.80-14.16-25.59120.3044.65-19.86-0.4095.0927.4661.2786.7426.814653864364.678.8
42670.07314.351498.06506.99665.02146.2946.64432.0429.2180.09126.508.50-13.19-23.79150.7059.78-15.324.76130.6949.2589.9789.2427.49334710167.681.3
52959.51507.301932.04335.21692.26152.2848.55449.7330.4183.37131.683.026.33-8.6081.1323.24-18.521.7171.9619.3745.6778.8445.001084961868.982.5
62819.37413.881722.91331.01765.46149.3847.63441.1729.8381.79129.175.72-3.08-16.9979.4323.24-21.64-2.1360.449.8535.1580.8436.524548093465.679.6
72722.24349.131565.98486.33669.93147.3746.99435.2329.4380.69127.447.59-10.14-21.38142.3455.28-15.894.27123.8945.7684.8287.2430.648934706667.981.5
83011.67542.081999.96314.55697.17153.3648.90452.9230.6283.97132.622.119.39-6.1972.7718.74-19.101.2365.1615.8840.5277.2448.156672567469.282.6
92723.14349.731566.17400.57756.40147.3946.99435.2829.4380.70127.457.64-10.13-22.43107.6037.91-20.57-1.0484.5422.0753.3184.3430.7033802765.079.2
102734.36357.211587.66475.63671.07147.6247.07435.9729.4880.82127.657.33-9.16-20.63138.0053.04-16.034.13120.1443.8682.0086.7431.382073506667.981.6
113023.79550.162021.64303.85698.31153.6148.98453.6630.6784.10132.831.8510.37-5.4568.4316.50-19.241.0861.4113.9837.7076.8448.889811367469.282.7
122883.66456.741812.50299.65771.51150.7148.05445.1030.0982.52130.334.560.96-13.8366.7316.50-22.35-2.7649.904.4627.1878.7440.41327449965.979.9
132673.52316.641479.64484.87709.00146.3646.67432.2529.2380.13126.568.64-14.02-24.90141.7555.28-17.712.18118.6541.2079.9287.6427.701522114966.180.1
142962.95509.601913.62313.09736.24152.3548.58449.9430.4283.41131.743.165.51-9.7172.1718.74-20.92-0.8759.9211.3135.6277.4445.209259975767.681.4
152674.42317.241479.83399.11795.48146.3846.67432.3129.2380.14126.588.69-14.01-25.95107.0137.91-22.39-3.1379.3017.5148.4084.6427.755967678363.277.7
162685.64324.721501.32474.17710.14146.6146.75432.9929.2880.27126.788.38-13.05-24.15137.4153.04-17.852.03114.9039.3077.1087.1428.434660914966.280.2
172975.07517.681935.30302.39737.38152.6048.66450.6930.4783.55131.962.906.48-8.9767.8416.50-21.05-1.0256.179.4232.8077.0445.942398775767.781.4
182834.94424.261726.16298.19810.58149.7047.73442.1229.8981.96129.455.61-2.93-17.3566.1416.50-24.17-4.8644.65-0.1022.2878.9437.465861907364.378.6
192745.12364.381634.21438.83672.08147.8447.14436.6329.5280.95127.856.90-7.07-19.09123.1045.52-16.153.83106.7837.1671.9786.3432.032643883668.081.6
203034.55557.332068.19267.04699.32153.8449.05454.3230.7284.23133.031.4212.46-3.9153.538.98-19.350.7848.057.2827.6776.5449.540381744469.382.7
212746.02364.981634.40353.06758.56147.8647.14436.6829.5280.96127.866.95-7.06-20.1588.3628.15-20.82-1.4867.4413.4840.4683.4432.087089446965.179.3
222757.24372.461655.88428.13673.22148.0947.22437.3729.5781.08128.066.65-6.09-18.34118.7743.28-16.283.69103.0435.2769.1585.8432.765782683668.081.7
233046.67565.412089.86256.35700.46154.0949.13455.0630.7784.36133.241.1713.44-3.1649.196.74-19.490.6444.315.3924.8576.1450.273520544469.382.8
242906.54471.991880.73252.15773.66151.1948.20446.5030.1982.77130.743.874.03-11.5447.496.74-22.60-3.2132.79-4.1314.3377.9441.79698367666.080.0
252809.40407.241723.80407.47678.13149.1747.56440.5629.7981.67129.005.73-3.04-15.94110.4038.78-16.863.2096.2431.7864.0183.9435.921370289268.381.9
263098.84600.192157.78235.69705.37155.1749.47458.2530.9884.95134.180.2616.49-0.7540.832.24-20.070.1537.511.8919.7074.6453.4291081569.582.9
272810.30407.841723.99321.71764.61149.1947.57440.6129.7981.68129.015.79-3.03-16.9975.6621.41-21.54-2.1256.898.0932.4981.1435.975815852665.579.6
282821.52415.321745.48396.77679.27149.4347.64441.3029.8481.81129.215.48-2.06-15.19106.0736.54-16.993.0592.4929.8861.1983.5436.654509089268.381.9
293110.96608.272179.46224.99706.51155.4249.55458.9931.0385.09134.390.0017.47-0.0036.490.00-20.20-0.0033.76-0.0016.8874.2454.1622469569.683.0
302970.82514.851970.32220.79779.71152.5248.63450.4330.4583.50131.892.718.06-8.3934.790.00-23.31-3.8422.24-9.526.3675.9445.685710081666.480.3
312760.68374.751637.46406.01717.20148.1747.24437.5829.5981.12128.126.79-6.92-19.46109.8138.78-18.681.1090.9927.2159.1084.3432.973957697566.680.5
323050.11567.712071.44234.23744.44154.1649.15455.2730.7884.40133.311.3112.61-4.2740.242.24-21.88-1.9532.27-2.6714.8074.7450.481695558368.081.7
332761.58375.351637.65320.25803.68148.1847.25437.6329.5981.13128.146.84-6.91-20.5175.0721.41-23.35-4.2151.653.5327.5981.4433.028403260963.878.2
342772.80382.831659.14395.31718.34148.4247.32438.3229.6481.26128.346.53-5.95-18.71105.4836.54-18.810.9687.2525.3256.2883.8433.707096497566.780.6
353062.23575.792093.12223.53745.58154.4149.23456.0130.8384.54133.521.0513.58-3.5235.900.00-22.02-2.0928.52-4.5611.9874.4451.214834358368.181.7
362922.10482.371883.98219.33818.78151.5148.31447.4530.2582.95131.013.764.17-11.9134.200.00-25.13-5.9417.00-14.081.4676.1442.738297489964.879.0
372715.43344.581488.41441.74785.27147.2346.94434.8129.4080.61127.318.29-13.63-25.33124.2846.29-22.08-2.3996.8626.8761.8783.6430.236664219464.078.3
383004.86537.541922.39269.96812.50153.2248.85452.5130.5983.89132.502.825.90-10.1454.719.75-25.29-5.4438.13-3.0117.5673.9447.744402080265.779.7
392716.33345.181488.60355.98871.74147.2546.95434.8729.4080.62127.338.35-13.62-26.3889.5528.92-26.76-7.7057.513.1830.3580.7430.291109782861.175.9
402733.69356.761519.28427.42786.99147.6147.06435.9329.4780.82127.647.92-12.24-24.26118.4843.28-22.28-2.6091.8824.3458.1182.9431.341237230964.178.4
413023.12549.711953.25255.64814.22153.6048.97453.6230.6784.10132.822.447.29-9.0748.916.74-25.49-5.6533.15-5.5413.8173.4448.848975091765.879.8
422882.99456.291744.12251.44887.43150.7048.05445.0630.0982.51130.315.15-2.12-17.4647.216.74-28.60-9.4921.63-15.063.2975.1440.372438223362.376.9
432779.71387.441578.01410.39791.32148.5647.37438.7429.6681.34128.467.13-9.60-22.17111.5839.55-22.79-3.0386.3221.4853.9081.3434.125390625164.478.6
443069.14580.402011.99238.60818.55154.5549.28456.4430.8684.62133.651.659.93-6.9942.013.01-26.00-6.0727.59-8.409.5972.0451.633128485966.080.0
452780.61388.041578.20324.62877.79148.5847.37438.8029.6781.35128.487.18-9.59-23.2376.8522.18-27.47-8.3446.97-2.2122.3878.4434.179836188461.676.3
462797.97399.621608.87396.07793.04148.9447.49439.8629.7481.54128.796.76-8.21-21.10105.7836.54-23.00-3.2481.3318.9650.1480.6435.229963636564.578.7
473087.40592.572042.85224.29820.27154.9349.40457.5530.9484.82133.971.2811.32-5.9236.210.00-26.20-6.2922.60-10.935.8471.5452.737701497366.180.1
482947.27499.151833.71220.09893.47152.0348.47448.9930.3683.24131.463.981.91-14.3034.510.00-29.32-10.1311.09-20.45-4.6873.1444.261164628962.777.3
492730.99354.961491.67408.93830.39147.5547.05435.7629.4680.78127.598.18-13.48-25.69110.9939.55-24.61-5.1281.0716.9249.0081.6431.177978033462.677.2
503020.42547.911925.65237.14857.62153.5448.96453.4630.6684.07132.772.706.05-10.5141.423.01-27.82-8.1722.34-12.964.6972.2448.685715894264.478.7
512731.89355.561491.86323.16916.86147.5747.05435.8229.4780.80127.618.23-13.47-26.7576.2522.18-29.29-10.4341.73-6.7717.4878.7431.232423596759.874.8
522749.25367.131522.53394.61832.11147.9347.17436.8829.5480.99127.927.81-12.09-24.62105.1936.54-24.81-5.3376.0914.3945.2480.9432.282551044962.877.3
533038.68560.091956.51222.83859.34153.9249.08454.5730.7384.27133.102.337.44-9.4435.620.00-28.02-8.3817.36-15.490.9471.6449.790288905764.578.8
542898.55466.671747.38218.63932.55151.0248.15446.0130.1682.68130.595.03-1.98-17.8233.920.00-31.13-12.225.84-25.01-9.5873.2441.313752037361.075.9
Floor SMC
assume base case car gets21.6mpg
assume gas costs4.00$/gallonbase case fuel cost
assume car drives12000.0miles per year for ten years15020.12222.22020.21836.51669.61517.81379.81254.41140.41036.7942.4
assume interest rate is10.0% annually
DiscountedDiscountedDiscountedDiscountedDiscountedDiscountedDiscountedDiscountedDiscountedDiscounted
Total DiscountedSaved FuelSaved FuelSaved FuelSaved FuelSaved FuelSaved FuelSaved FuelSaved FuelSaved FuelSaved Fuel
CaseBIW CostBIW WeightCar WeightFuel EconFuel EconFuel EconFuel EconCostCostCostCostCostCostCostCostCostCostCost
$lbslbs1st princ10-5 ruleDeLuchiused inSavings OverYearYearYearYearYearYearYearYearYearYear
mpgmpgmpgcalcsVehicle12345678910
mpgLifetime$$$$$$$$$$
(now set to 10-5 rule)$
12640.56306.272657.9524.123.2???23.21064.4157.5143.2130.1118.3107.697.888.980.873.566.8
22460.25499.222947.3922.322.222.2380.356.351.146.542.338.434.931.828.926.223.9
33237.04306.872658.8524.123.223.21062.2157.1142.9129.9118.1107.397.688.780.673.366.6
42601.57314.352670.0724.023.223.21034.9153.1139.2126.5115.0104.695.186.478.671.464.9
52421.27507.302959.5122.222.122.1352.452.147.443.139.235.632.429.426.824.322.1
63542.62413.882819.3723.022.622.6678.2100.391.282.975.468.562.356.651.546.842.6
72704.80349.132722.2423.723.023.0909.1134.5122.3111.2101.191.983.575.969.062.757.0
82524.49542.083011.6721.921.921.9233.334.531.428.525.923.621.419.517.716.114.6
93301.28349.732723.1423.723.023.0906.9134.2122.0110.9100.891.683.375.768.962.656.9
102665.81357.212734.3623.622.922.9880.0130.2118.4107.697.888.980.873.566.860.755.2
112485.50550.163023.7921.921.921.9205.730.427.725.222.920.818.917.215.614.212.9
123606.86456.742883.6622.722.422.4527.778.171.064.558.753.348.544.140.136.433.1
132167.38316.642673.5224.023.223.21026.6151.9138.1125.5114.1103.794.385.777.970.964.4
141987.08509.602962.9522.222.122.1344.551.046.342.138.334.831.628.826.223.821.6
152693.61317.242674.4224.023.223.21024.4151.6137.8125.3113.9103.594.185.677.870.764.3
162128.39324.722685.6423.923.123.1997.3147.5134.1121.9110.9100.891.683.375.768.862.6
171948.09517.682975.0722.122.122.1316.846.942.638.735.232.029.126.524.021.919.9
182999.18424.262834.9423.022.622.6641.694.986.378.471.364.858.953.648.744.340.3
192565.52364.382745.1223.522.922.9854.3126.4114.9104.595.086.378.571.364.959.053.6
202385.21557.333034.5521.821.921.9181.426.824.422.220.218.316.715.113.812.511.4
213162.00364.982746.0223.522.922.9852.2126.1114.6104.294.786.178.371.264.758.853.5
222526.53372.462757.2423.422.922.9825.4122.1111.0100.991.783.475.868.962.757.051.8
232346.22565.413046.6721.821.821.8154.022.820.718.817.115.614.112.911.710.69.7
243467.58471.992906.5422.522.322.3474.670.263.858.052.748.043.639.636.032.829.8
252629.76407.242809.4023.122.722.7701.7103.894.485.878.070.964.558.653.348.444.0
262449.45600.193098.8421.521.721.736.65.44.94.54.13.73.43.12.82.52.3
273226.24407.842810.3023.122.722.7699.5103.594.185.577.870.764.358.453.148.343.9
282590.77415.322821.5223.022.622.6673.199.690.582.374.868.061.856.251.146.542.2
292349.29608.273110.9621.421.621.69.51.41.31.21.11.00.90.80.70.70.6
303531.81514.852970.8222.222.122.1326.548.343.939.936.333.030.027.324.822.520.5
312092.34374.752760.6823.422.822.8817.2120.9109.999.990.882.675.168.262.056.451.3
321912.03567.713050.1121.721.821.8146.221.619.717.916.314.813.412.211.110.19.2
332618.56375.352761.5823.422.822.8815.0120.6109.699.790.682.474.968.161.956.351.1
342053.35382.832772.8023.322.822.8788.4116.6106.096.487.679.772.465.859.954.449.5
351873.04575.793062.2321.721.821.8118.917.616.014.513.212.010.99.99.08.27.5
362924.14482.372922.1022.422.222.2438.564.959.053.648.744.340.336.633.330.327.5
372560.65344.582715.4323.723.023.0925.5136.9124.5113.2102.993.585.077.370.363.958.1
382380.34537.543004.8622.022.022.0248.836.833.530.427.725.122.920.818.917.215.6
393087.33345.182716.3323.723.023.0923.3136.6124.2112.9102.693.384.877.170.163.757.9
402539.29356.762733.6923.622.922.9881.7130.4118.6107.898.089.181.073.666.960.955.3
412358.98549.713023.1221.921.921.9207.330.727.925.323.020.919.017.315.714.313.0
423410.53456.292882.9922.722.422.4529.278.371.264.758.853.548.644.240.236.533.2
432624.89387.442779.7123.322.822.8771.9114.2103.894.485.878.070.964.558.653.348.4
442444.58580.403069.1421.621.721.7103.315.313.912.611.510.49.58.67.87.16.5
453151.56388.042780.6123.322.822.8769.8113.9103.594.185.677.870.764.358.453.148.3
462603.53399.622797.9723.222.722.7728.7107.898.089.181.073.666.960.955.350.345.7
472423.22592.573087.4021.521.721.762.39.28.47.66.96.35.75.24.74.33.9
483474.77499.152947.2722.322.222.2380.556.351.246.542.338.535.031.828.926.323.9
492017.24354.962730.9923.623.023.0888.1131.4119.5108.698.789.781.674.267.461.355.7
501836.94547.913020.4221.921.921.9213.431.628.726.123.721.619.617.816.214.713.4
512543.92355.562731.8923.623.023.0886.0131.1119.2108.398.589.581.474.067.361.155.6
521995.89367.132749.2523.522.922.9844.4124.9113.6103.393.985.377.670.564.158.353.0
531815.58560.093038.6821.821.921.9172.025.523.121.019.117.415.814.413.111.910.8
542867.13466.672898.5522.622.322.3493.173.066.360.354.849.845.341.237.434.030.9
OuterQ SMC
caseBIW Cost in $BIW cost in $BIW weight in lb
at 150k/yrat 50k/yr
11486.49842356732640.5610012466306.2692434118
21345.60143182842460.2547304981499.2238679865
31710.188252863237.0422417924306.8692937049
41461.5029091012601.5719113884314.3492434118