Prepared forKeith Niall, Defence Research & Development Canada
t #: FE2207XX
#: STI EW 030
itted on Octo
echni
XXX
0
ober 8, 2015
cal Insightss
DRDC-RDDC-2015-C235
The scientific or technical validity of this Contract Report is entirely the responsibility of the Contractor and the contents do not necessarily have the approval or endorsement of the Department of National Defence of Canada
Canadian Institute for Scientific and Technical Information100 Montreal Road, M-55, Ottawa, Ontario K1A 0R6
Prepared byErica Wiseman, Strategic Information Analyst, National Research Council
NRC KM employees make every effort to obtain information from reliable sources.However, we assume no responsibility or liability for any decisions based upon information presented.
on human optmetagroups: Ettional/Cognitivn Automation/s in the Ethicsm)s in the Physioltion (39) and Pes in the Compu41) and Interfas in the Automputer Interface(15), Institut R(9), Defence RB. (8), Universit7), Defence Re), Carleton Unidian institutionMcGill UniversiDefence ResearUniversity of CaUniversity of ToUniversity of Brinstitutions haifferent countrnada, five majons are presentr. Four additio
ional internatioons with membtion, betweennd Technologyonal collaboratir are in Abu Dh
man Opti
Page 4 of 32
1. Key Finding
imization in Cathics (225 publve Issues (202)./Robotics (147metagroup inc
logicalmetagrerception (36)utational/Cognaces (37)ation/Roboticses (23)Recherches ClinResearch and Dty of British Coesearch and Deiversity (Automns appear in thty (35)rch and Develoalgary (31)oronto (30)ritish Columbiaave collaborateries, mainly inor clusters of it. These are loonal smaller clu
onal institutionbers of the fiveQueen’s Unive, also appearsing institutionshabi, Australia
mization
gs
anada is fairly eications), Phys. A slightly low7).clude: Perform
roup include: C
nitivemetagrou
smetagroup in
niques MontreDevelopment Columbia (Ethicsevelopment Camation/Robotiche dataset, the
opment Canad
a (30)ed with roughlyUSA.institutions thaocated in Montusters (with on
ns have collabomain Canadia
ersity and the Kon the internas are in the USAand Korea.
n
evenly spreadsiological Issueer proportion
ance (94), Soci
Cognitive enhan
up include: Com
nclude: Robots
eal (PhysiologicCanada,(Physios)anada (Physiolcs)most prolific i
a (33)
y 200 internati
at share at leastreal, Ottawa, Tnly two institut
orated on at lean clusters. AnKorea Advanceational landscaA, three are in
October
between threes (223), andof publications
ial issues (58) a
ncement (44),
mputers (53),
s (43), Devices
cal)ological)
logical)
institutes are:
ional institutio
st two coToronto andions each) can
east two coadditionaled Institute ofape. Four of then Europe and th
r 2015
e of
s are
and
(36),
ons
n also
ehe
Scien
2 BA2.1 CoThe DRDCcommissioareas of eand SecurTechnologExcellenceparticularfocusing obring toge
T (Army) togethe Canadian rheir collaboraved for develNational Defecapability arelso includingr the IRDS anthe field.
mization havee enhancemeepresence; ane ethics of autnd communiti
ation from a bresting areas
ble 2. Client Prgical Issues
p wake cycleadian adjustmeogenic aidsntermeasuremical, biologicological and tostrial materialntsefficiency andd carriage andd assistanceskeleton and hman Behavior PDecontaminat
siologicalancement/adaextreme envirosical avatarsn/neuronal comrface (BNCI)roaches for humization
man Opti
ther with theresearchers ination networlopment by thence. The IRDas of interestindustry. Thed will facilitat
e occurred inent as a physind ethics, metonomous sysies in these fo
broad academare listed be
rovided MetagAut
ent
al,oxic(TIM)
d energysoldiers
umanPatternstion
ptationonments
mputer
man
mization
DRDC Officen the field ofrks. A new Inshe Assistant DDS will consistt and will brine results will bte four works
four directioological issueeaning amongstems. Far froour domains.
road search opendex, NTISere provided000 internations from 200. In order to pn with an ove
ion Reseae terms in theblications (96e concepts listalong with almained in qual decisions wfour main me
h the numberin the dataset
3. Metagroup
f exclusion wered irrelevant wereethodology
ate to the ethiics expand ourion that have oate to performo the body, thng or modificatate to cognitivechnological sutional aids to coools, logic engnhancement.ate to the usehuman capabild act at indefinssarily zoomorpany systems at
mization
on human optS, DTIC, and CAby the clientional publicat05 2015.a Theprovide someerview of the
arch Highe keywords, a6% of the datted in Table 2ll the terms wuestion, the awere made regetagroups by
r of publicatiot because a s
ps
removed. Subsee removed from
Scope Noical issues regar conceptual raonly been prommance enhancerough activitietions of humanve enhancemenupport. Theseognition such aines, computa
of robots, devlities. These enite distances.phic or anthropt once, as in a
n
timization waCANDID. In adto include intions which we findings disce context to tresearch high
hlightsabstracts andtaset) were cr2, followed bywithin them, wssociated titlegarding the gy the analyst,
ons in each. Tingle article c
equently, roughthe Canadian se
otesarding human oange to tools omised as of yetements througes, drugs, physin tissuent as a computinclude, but aas enhanced mtion by social n
vices and teleonable human oSuch systemspomorphic. Thswarm.
October
as conducteddition to thethe analysis.
was reduced tcussed in thisthe discussionhlights.
title fields wereated. Groupy an analysis owere reviewees and abstragroupings. Theand finalized
The total numcan categorize
ly 250 article titet. More inform
optimization.of humant.h physiologicaiological
tational issue,re not limited tmapping andnetworking, an
peration tooperators toare often, buthe goal may be
Human EnThe Humaspecificalland theirInterestinthe prefercomponeComputergrouped ioriented gTranshumbe foundemergentbiomedicavalues an
BiomechaThe 16 artprevalentexamine rgait paramthat lookeor runningPersonal Llifting to r
While vararticles stbody avatscaling ofassessmethat the crobot to f
ErgogenicErgogenicgroups. Mincludingfew.61 63 Osuch as prmuscle fu
tometri
ethics perspecerception ofnitive enhanciing psychosurment of injure
nhancement/an Enhancemly refer to huvariants (i.e.ngly, only 30 arred terms innt of humanr Interaction,n multiple grgroups in themanism, etc. Oin Carbrera’st technologiesal, transhumad different us
anicsticles in the bt being relatedrunning gait smeter selectioed at interdepg) with the exLift Augmentareduce muscu
rious other disood out. Thetars that respvisual feedbant of body pecommonly usefollow unnatu
c Aidsc aids in this dMany of thesecaffeine, creaOthers discusrecooling thenction post i
c Study
ctive, the artiethical issuesing substancergery, neuroeed soldiers an
/ Augmentatment/Augmenman optimizaaugmented carticles were cthe field. OfenhancemenDevices, Inteoups, we alsodataset incluOne particula2015 articles”. This articleanist and socises of techno
biomechanicsd to human gselection.53 Anon.54 A third lpendence of vxplicit intendation Deviceular effort and
sparate aspecfirst describeond to full boack on theseerception dured zero momural walking p
dataset are me studies lookatine, pseudossed the effecbody prior tonjury.64,65 So
on Hum
Page 14 of
icles exploreds. Some artices.49,50 Otherenhancementnd veterans b
iontation groupation by the tcognition, augcategorized if the 30 articlent. These articrfaces, Roboto find that twuding Social, Parly salient ca“Rethinking he provides anial paradigm alogy.52
group look agait. In one stnother investooked at phavarious featuto model and(PLAD) whichd compressio
cts of improved the develoody movememovements.ring active moent point (ZMpatterns but c
mostly relatedked at the levoephedrine, qctiveness of po exercise, orme articles w
man Opti
3
d the perceptles explored tarticles looket, transcraniaeyond the ab
was createdterms “humangmented humn this group,es, at least twcles also appets, and Biotecwo thirds of thPerformance,se in point ofhuman enhann overview ofand explores
at a variety oftudy, a constrtigated the nease modulatiores of multi jd optimize huh was designeon and shear f
ing human biopment of a “nts in all movThe proof ofovement in heMP) control mcan still be use
to the Athletel of ergogenquercetin, acuphysical activir the use of newere very spec
mization
tion of medicatheir percepted at the percl direct stimubilities of the
to pull togethn enhancememan, personapotentially suwo thirds discear in the Tecchnology grouhe articles are, Ethics, Militaf the overlapncement: Socf the enhancehow each pa
f human biomrained optimieuromuscularon during waloint leg extenuman motioned to be wornforces.57,58
iomechanics“virtual mirrovement planef concept wasealthy contro
method for hued for analys
tics/sports, Exnic benefit gaute taurine, aties that canear infrared lcific about qu
n
al professionation of the risceived ethicaulation and thnorm.50,3,51
her all the artent” or “humal enhancemeuggesting thacuss a technochnology, Comups. Becausee grouped in tary, Perceptiobetween thecial enhancemement debatearadigm invol
mechanical issization framer control featlking cycles.55
nsion (presum.56 Two articlen by workers d
were discussr” that displaes in real times demonstratols.59 The secoumanoid robois of bipedal
xercise and Dined from varnd beta alanbe viewed aslight therapyuantities requ
October
als’ and thesks associatedal issueshe therapeutic
ticles thatan augmentant, etc…).at these are nologicalmputers, Hume titles can bethe more socon, Learning,e two domainment ande from theves different
sues, the mosework was usetures involved5 Another artimably for wales discussedduring manua
ed, two speciys realistic fue and allows fed for theond study fouots causes thebalance.60
Diet & Supplemrious substanine, to names ergogenic aifor improvinguired for an
r 2015
d
c
tion”
not
man
cially
s can
sted tod iniclelkingaal
ificullfor
unde
mentncesaidsg
Scien
ergogenicdeciding tendurancrequired tprovide eacademiaclinique d
Automat
User ComThe grouphuman minterfacesInteractio(IGS). Thethe effector the varblindnessaugmente
Other artidiscussedinterfacereduce thset of prim
Virtual ReAccordingbiodfeedbIn the datspecificallimprovingfloor surfadynamic vduring he
this groupincreasedthe use oftelepreseprogrammexperienc
WearableTheWeararticle bypotentiallcomputersignificantreducing jfirst in regExtremityChallengeand exter
3.2 To1,034 Cantop Canadaffiliationauthor’s tmetagrouconsidereagents an
tometri
p explore variinteractivity,f vibrotacticlence activitiesming neuromoce can be succ
esrables group hPedersen, “Wy alter mobilrs have beent potential clijoint loading.gards to an exy (ETS MARSEes include hownal infrastruc
op Canadnadian researdian researchand total nutotal numberups. For examed a ‘cognitivend Simulation
c Study
ious ways to i,75 the use ofe displays46 an.39 Telepresenodulation devcessfully used
has only fiveWearable comity, interactivfound to faciinical benefit78 Two of thexoskeleton ty)79 and seconw to sense inpcture, and how
ian Reseachers appearers, with foumber of publof publicatio
mple, Racine’se enhancer’ fowhich each f
Fig
on Hum
Page 16 of
improve the qmixed realitynd identifyingnce has also bvices and thatd to accuratel
publications,mputers creatvity and beinglitate task comfor gait analy
e articles in thype robot namndly in regardput, how to pw to remain p
archersred in the datr or more pubications. Thens because aarticle “Geneor healthy indfall into one o
gure 3. Top Au
man Opti
3
quality of they visualizationg communicabeen found tot expert telemly program a
three of whicte a personalgness (existenmpletion andysis and interhis group discmed Motion As to user inteproduce outppowered.80
aset; of theseblications, aree combined tosingle publicerating geniudividuals” disof the four me
uthors, Areas o
mization
e telepresencen modalities,2
tion requiremo be an effecmentoring ofdevice.76
ch are from 2augmented rnce) in the actd encourage uvention in imuss the desigAssistive Roboerfaces implanut, how to co
e, 132 have ae presented iotal of publiccation may bes: How an Alzscusses Ethicsetagroups.
of Expertise
n
e experience23 reducing haments for colltive means oan individual
2014. Accordireality…[whictual world”.77
user effort,22
mproving walkn and challenotic Exoskelented underneommunicate b
t least two pun Figure 3 aloations in eache categorizedzheimer’s drus, Reaction Tim
October
throughaptic data tralaborative huf remotel with no prev
ing to a 2005h] could7 Wearableand to haveking stability anges of wearaeton for Supereath human sbetween devi
ublications. Tong with theih row exceedinto a numbe
ug becameme, Nootropi
r 2015
affic,45
uman
vious
andables,riorskin.ices
Therds theer of
ic
Scien
A completinformatio
3.3 CaThe datasin the dat
Figure 5 pedges (linboxes shosupportin
In
Cana
dian
Institu
tion
tometri
te list of all auon and areas
anadian Cset includes ataset are pres
presents the Ces) shows theows the totalng raw data fil
nstitut de Rech
Defence Resea
c Study
uthors with twof expertise
Collaboratotal of 352
sented in Figu
Canadian colle number of cnumber of pule are provide
herches CliniquQu
UniversUniv
University ofUniveUniv
arch and DeveM
on Hum
Page 17 of
wo or more pis included w
ationsinstitutions, 1ure 4 along wi
Figure 4. Top
aborations wco publicatioublications foed as Attachm
ues de Montreueen's UniversiUniversité Lavsité de Montreversity of OttawBritish Columbersity of Toronversity of Calgalopment CanadMcGill Universi
man Opti
3
publications, awith this repor
131 of whichith their total
p Canadian Inst
with at least twns between ior each instituments 4 and 5
0
alityvalealwabiantoarydaity
mization
along with thrt as Attachm
are Canadianl number of p
titutions
wo co publicanstitutions, wution. An ima5 with this rep
1415
10Number
n
heir completement 3.
n. The top Canpublications.
ations. The nuwhile the numge file of thisport.
518
2424
20of Publication
October
e contact
nadian institu
umber on thembers in the gs map and the
303031
3335
30ns
r 2015
utions
egreene
40
Scienttom
etric
S
Page
18of
3
Figure
5.CaStud
yon
H
anad
ianCo
llabo
ra
uman
Opt
ations
timization
OOctob
er20
15
Scien
In the topMichael’sTwo of thThe two psimulationpersonal t
In the topInternatioUBC’s coand motoreality (M
The largepurple onUniversitytime varyenhancempublicatiopublicatioreality anmodel duResearch
The red suUniversitycliniquesperformathree instMontréalduring nigcognitivethree co psports/athexploratiocoping str
The UniveCanada (DDRDC thaUniversityimages93 avehicles w
We also sEnergy’s (
tometri
p left green clHospital focuese are also cpublications bn training fortraits.82
p blue cluster,onal Collaborapublications wor propriocepMAR) that can
cluster in thene on the lefty, two of whicying delays85,8
ment technoloons on bilaterons with the Ld haptic interring image guInstitute.
ub cluster in ty. McGill’s code Montréalnce and noottitutions havehas two otheght shifts.30,90
enhancemenpublications whletics and anon using realrategies.92
ersité Laval isDRDC) and thet focus on dey of New Brunand one fromwhich can be
ee a four sep(brown, left) c
c Study
uster, the thrus on cognitivco publishedbetween the Ulaparoscopic
, the Universiation on Repawith Simon Ftion platformbe used for b
e middle incluincludes thech focus on p6 while the laogies (includiral teleoperatLondon Healtrfaces48 and auided epileps
this large cluspublications(IRCM) focustropic agentse another Caner co publicatThe IRCM ha
nts and look awith Ecole denother two cotime online s
part of the pe University oecision suppornswick, one frm 2014 whichused to enha
parate clusterco publicatio
on Hum
Page 19 of
ree co publicave enhancemwith the UnivUniversity ofc surgery81 an
ty of British Cair Discoverieraser Univers
m,83 and a visioboth human a
udes three suUniversity ofassive and nost one looks ang drugs andtion88,89 with Wh Sciences Ceanother on eny surgery.37 T
ster is comprwith the Union cognitiveto name a fenadian instituttions with Sacas three co puat nootropic aTechnologie
o publicationsspatiotempor
purple sub cluof New Brunsrt for the milirom 2006 ondiscusses a lance human c
s with only twns look at dev
man Opti
32
ations betweeent, nootropversity of CalgToronto andd ethical imp
Columbia’s (Ues (ICORD) focsity look at anon based locaand robot nav
b clusters asOttawa whicon passive inpat the ethicalimplants).87
Western Univentre, one alsnhanced visuaThis last articl
ised of Montversité de Moenhancemenw topics. Fivetion co publiscre Coeur Houblications wagents and poSuperieure os with the Unal topic mode
uster that inclswick. Universitary. DRDC aobject basedaunch and recapabilities an
wo membersvices and inte
mization
en the Univepic agents, andgary, one of wthe Universit
plications of n
UBC) two co pcus on Exosken affordable Balization systevigation.84
identified bych has three cput based tell consideratioCarleton Univversity. Westeso on bilateraalization of ae was also co
real based inontréal and tnt, ethics, soce of the 13 arshing with thospital on circith Dalhousieolicy implication exoskeletoniversité Lavaeling91 and an
udes Defencesité Laval haslso has two cd change detecovery systemnd mitigate ris
each. The Poerfaces, speci
n
rsity of Torond other knowwhich also looty Health Netneurosurgery
publications weleton and GaBCI controlledem using mo
y the differentco publicationleoperation sons regardingversity has anern Universityal teleoperatiosurgical fieldo published w
stitutions andhe Institut decial issues, corticles co pubem. The Univadian adjustme University oions. McGill Uon, robotics, ml, one on autonother on pai
e Research ans three co pubco publicationection in highm for autonosk.94
owertech Labsifically human
October
nto and St.wn specific druoks at policietwork look atto enhance
with theait & Walkingd arm exoskebile augment
t colors. Thens with Carletsystems undeg bodynother twoy has anotheon, augmentewith a 3D pa
with Robarts
d Dalhousiee recherchesgnitiveblished by theversité dements on sleen the ethics oUniversity hasmotion, trackonomous adain and social
nd Developmblications witns with theh resolutionmous underw
s.95,96 The Uniion, specificapital and Prined reality speke and Unived ethical accesciences (NB
presents the sas in Figure 5of co publicatwith a smallerame map wit
ternationset includes 2Canadian autg with the samco publication two co pubential opportonal collaboradian co publictor have beended as Attachis provided a
ent 12.
c Study
versity of Gully at competcess Margarecifically in regrsite du Quebptability of usICs) to enhan
same collaborand the thickions. This figur cluster in Brh labels on it
Figure 6
nal Collab21 internatiothors are collme institutionons. Only Harvblications withtunities for stating institutiocation landscan removed froments 9 andas Attachmen
on Hum
Page 20 of
elph and Univtency and capet Hospital’s (gards to advabec a Chicoutsing nanotechnce human pe
ration netwokness of the eure highlightsritish Columbare provided
. Geographic M
borationsonal institutioaborating witns in a repeatvard Universih Canadian inrengthening tons with twoape. Canadiaom Figure 7.10. A geograpt 11. A full lis
man Opti
32
versity of Wapacity building(orange, left)anced image gtimi’s (pink, bhnology, bioterformance.18
rks on a geogedges (lines cos that the majia. An imaged as Attachme
Map of Canadi
sns that haveth internationted fashion. Oty, USA and Ustitutions. Thties with foreor more Can
an collaboratiAn image filephic map of Cst of internati
mization
aterloo’s (yellg,97 and trainco publicatioguidance systottom left) cotechnology, in8,99
graphic map. Tonnecting thejority of the wfile of this ments 6, 7 and
ian Collaborati
co publishednal authors, tOnly 10 internUniversity ofhe 10 internateign researchenadian co pubions that do ne of this map aCanadian collonal collabor
n
ow, top) co ping dietitiansons focus on vtems.71,72 Theo publicationnformation sc
The clusters re circles) reprwork is centemap, an associ8.
ions
d with Canadithey are not fnational institQueensland,tional instituters. Figure 7blications andnot include anand the assocaborations wrators is prov
October
publications los.98 The Mounvirtual surgere University ofns look at theciences and
retain the samresents thered in Quebeiated color leg
an institutionfrequently cotutions have aAustralia, hations presentpresents the
d how they fitn internationciated raw da
with all otherided as
r 2015
ookntry andf
me
ec andgend
ns.
atve
e 10t intoalata
Scienttom
etric
S
Page
21of
3
Figure
7.InteStud
yon
H
erna
tiona
lCollabo
uman
Opt
ratio
ns
timization
OOctob
er20
15
Scien
Universitypublishedpublishedinterventi
Queen’s UKorea Adv
The UniveUniversitypublicatiorunning,53
UniversityEmirates omodel forand assisttracking o
DRDC haseffects ofaircrew d
Harvard Uwere alsobrain stimalso co puUniversity
4 COThis sciencollaboratworkshop
The resultEthical (23publicatiodataset, tethical issacross vartranscrantechnologunderstooTime, mo
tometri
y of British Cod in 2009, discd in 2014, focuion.78
University covanced Institu
ersity of Calgay, Munich, Geons with Florid3 the latter of
y of Ottawa hon U Biofeedr wearable sytive support rof bilateral sh
s two co publnight time flyuring operati
University, USo co publishedmulation.15,106
ublished withy exploring ho
ONCLUSIOtometric studtion networksps that are be
ts of this stud35), Physiologons in Automawo major tresues regardingrious stakehoial direct currgy to viewingod. Could thisre research, a
c Study
olumbia co pucusses ethicaluses on the im
published twute of Science
ary co publishermany on resda State Univf which was a
has two co pudback, a multistems designregarding streared autonom
ications withying on cognions known to
SA has three cd with the UnThe third artMcGill Univeow distraction
ONSdy was comms in the field oing planned t
dy show that Cgical (228) anation/Roboticends emergedg human optiolder domainsrent stimulatiit with cautios be the trendand an explor
on Hum
P
ublished twol issues relatempact of wea
wo articles one and Techno
hed two articsidual force eversity, USA also co publish
ublications witmedia ubiqued to continuess levels.103 Tmous systems
the Air Forcetive effectiveo impact slee
co publicationniversity of Lyicle is on sociersity. Harvarn can enhanc
missioned to pof human optto bring toget
Canadian resnd Computatiocs (153). Upod. The first is timization, fros. One recention noted a sonary realismd for other etration of the i
man Opti
age 22 of 3
articles withed to neurorearable sensing
computationology in 2010.
les each withenhancementre on constrahed with Corn
th New Yorkuitous biofeeduously monitoThe second ps for real tim
e Research Laeness of CF18p.105
ns with the Uon, France, aial coping strad University hce motor perf
provide an ovtimization. Thther Canadian
earch is fairlyonal/Cognitivon deeper reathat there is aom technologarticle on thehift from misas the risks,hical positioninternational
mization
Standford Unegenerative mg and feedbac
nal simulation.29,101
h Ruhr Univert in human mained optimiznell Universit
University ofdback systemor human phypresents a dese teleoperati
boratory, USA8 pilots,104 and
niversité Lavare on ethicalategies in thohas another cformance.107
erview of Canhis study willn experts in t
y evenly spreave (205), withading of rougha rich and congical, medicale public’s perunderstandinbenefits andns in the humliterature wo
n
niversity, USAmedicine.100 Tck devices for
n of bone rem
sity and the Tovement.56,10
zation in humty, USA.
Abu Dhabi, Um. The first is aysiology andsign to enhanon applicatio
A from 2006d the use of Z
al. Two of theissues relateose with chroco publication
nadian researassist DRDC ithe field.
ad between th only slightlyhly 200 abstrantinuing discuand social perception of thng and fear ofapplications
man enhancemould help ans
October
A. The first,he second,r gait analysis
modelling with
Technical02 Their two
man walking54
United Arababout a referconvey messnce stability aons.86
and 2007 onZopiclone by
e articles, whd to non invanic pain92 andn with McGill
rch activity anin facilitating
the metagrouy feweracts in theussion of theerspectives anhe use off an emergenare betterment debate?swer this ques
r 2015
s and
h the
and
renceagesand
the
ichasived isl
ndfour
ups of
nd
nt
?stion.
Scien
The seconparticulargroup webased grois highly indevelopmunificatio
WorkshopThere alrelandscapepotentiallface to faoccurringDefence aHuman Ophysical loideas by bis ideally e
This studylandscapestudy, it msame inteCanada is
Given theas possiblvariants aidentify extargeted sworking inmetagroufor extremtiming; auin these a
A final simthe fieldstelerobotfound in tabstractsalso revea
tometri
nd trend is thrly notable inre grouped inoup, with oventertwined bments from “bn of issues an
ps are an ideaeady exist a ne, particularlyy be good loace but also awithin relativand Security mptimization tocation for thbringing togetexplored at th
y was a first ae. The datasetmight be interernationally. Imore focuse
e scope of thee over the huand subtopicsxisting researsearching in sn the areas. Tups table provme environmeutonomous syand many oth
milar recommthat are morics, virtual rethese subtopibut we knowal more Canad
c Study
e convergencthe Human En a technologrlap betweenetween the twboth sides of tnd communiti
al way of buildnumber of coly located in Mcations for plllow others tove close proxmay want to co avoid excluhe Centre of Ether more thahe distributed
attempt to prot was a smallresting to appt might also bed on than the
e project, thisuman optimizthat are beinrch collaboratselected subtoThis might bevided by the cents; load carystems and trer subtopics.
endation wore closely relaality, wearabics did not new that these todian research
on Hum
P
ce of technoloEnhancement/gy based groun the two. Thiwo domains.the coin”. Thies in the fou
ding connectlaboration ne
Montreal, Torolanned workso join in the cimity betweeconsider deveding active reExcellence maan those in ad workshops.
ovide an oversubset of theply the groupbe interestinge internation
study used azation field. Tng researchedtions in Canadopics in ordeof particularclient, such asrriage and solrust, responsi
uld be to conated to improles, and enhaecessarily expools are usedhers and colla
man Opti
age 23 of 3
ogical and soct/Augmentatiup while anotis highlights tIt is thus fruiis supports thr main areas
ions betweenetworks withionto, Ottawashops as theyconversation.en Montreal aeloping a virtesearchers onay actually incsingle locatio
rview of the Ce much largerings to the lag to assess whal field.
a search stratehe logic was td. This approada. Subsequer to identify ainterest for ts: wound senldier; counteribility, privacy
nsider doing aving human panced vision tlicitly make cto improve p
aborations in
mization
cial issues in tion group. Twher two thirdhe fact that titful to explorhe argumentof human op
n researchersin the Canadiand Vancouv
y would allow. While the mand Toronto,ual network fn the other sicrease cross fon. Ultimately
Canadian humr internationarger set to sehether there
egy that attemthat this appach did resultent studies many additionathe more milising; self decrmeasure agey, etc. as very
additional, carperformanceto name a fewconnections toperformance.the field.
n
the research.wo thirds of thds were groupthe field of hure the issues,for an intere
ptimization re
s and topics wian human opver. These fow existing netwmajority of thethe Institutefor the Centrede of the coufertilization oy, this might b
man optimizaal dataset. Inee if the reseaare any parti
mpted to casroach shouldt in a useful smight consideal literature anitary orientedcontaminatioents; positiony limited litera
refully constror human caw. The researo human opt. Additional s
October
. This washe articles inped in a sociauman optimiztopics, reseast in facilitatiesearch.
within a field.ptimizationour cities coulworks to intee research isfor Researche of Excellencuntry. Forgoinof research anbe a question
tion researcha subsequentarch focus is tcular areas th
t the net as wcatch all theubset of datar doing morend researched subtopics inn aids; adaptn, navigation aature was fou
ructed, searchpabilities sucrch that wasimization in tearches migh
r 2015
thisalzationarch,ng a
dract
ce onng andn that
htthehat
wide
a to
rsn theationandund
hes inch as
theht
Scien
5 REF1. C
e2. R
abCa
3. Mn20
4. Oan
5. Dre
6. CFr
7. Ora
8. Wex
9. Fre
10. Fie
11. Cso
12. McoB
13. Hp
14. LamInD
15. Lepse
16. Lain42
17. VtrD(C
tometri
FERENCEabrera LY, Fitnhancementacine E, Martbout scienceare and Philo
McPherson GGraining and dettp://www.acirtual_Worldsadian_Forcesoukerche A, Rnvironments.ao F, Min G,
mechanism in014;25(11):29
Morbi A, Ahmaowered orthoabonte D, Boiovice users. I010;40(5):133rangier E, Duelationship. Te Negueruelapplications. Puchaine V, Goheory2008.Malysz P, Siroueleoperation013;6(4):484ecours A, Mayntelligent assiobotics and Aang IG, Kim IYuman proximumont M, Blaircadian adjusl Saddik A. ThMagazine. 200Widmer A, Huerception of ond Humans. 2isell Y, Smith
enaude J. Risktranshumani7 394.G, Sebalj D. Aevelopment ccademia.edu/s_in_TrainingsRen Y. A trust. Computer CoLin M, Luo C,mobile socia944 2955.adi M, Chan Aoses. IEEE Traissy P, MichauEEE Transact31 1342.fresne A, HamTravail Humaia C, BroschartPersonal and Uosselin CM. In
uspour S. Tasof mobile twi495.yer St Onge Bst device. In:Automation. 2Y. Computatiomal femur durais H, Roy J, Pstment in simhe potential o07;10(1):10 1Y. Effects of tobject softne2010;40(6):11S, Cooperstonments: Percernier H, Lapoiary simulatioernier F, Boivogame increas4).l M, Jannin P,y. IEEE Transa
on Hum
P
k and the quest perspective
business casecourses and v/15811507/Ag_and_Develo
t based securommunicatioYang LT. Mol networks. IE
ADC, Langloisansactions onud F. Comparions on Syste
mmes Adelé Sin. 2009;72(4)t M, Menon CUbiquitous Convestigation o
k performancin arm roboti
B, Gosselin C.proceedings2012.onal simulatioing bone remPaquet J. Contmulated nightof haptics tech7.the alignmeness. IEEE Trans146 1155.ock JR. Interaception, Techninte JF. Applyn based trainin E, Morin B,ses the effect
, Collins DL. Dactions on Vis
man Opti
age 25 of 3
estion of thees. Dialogue
e analysis forvirtual work gA_Business_Caopment_Cour
rity system foons. 2008;31(1biFuzzyTrust:EEE Transacti
R. Stability gControl Systerative analysisms, Man, and
S. A symbiotic):333 350.C, Del R. Milláomputing. 20of human rob
ce evaluationic manipulato
. Variable admfrom Procee
on of simultanmodeling. Jourtrolled patterwork. Journahnologies. IEE
nt between asactions on Sy
cting with augology, and Apying advancedning.2010., Robillard G.tiveness of str
DVV: A taxonosualization an
mization
acceptabilityCanadian Phi
r the implemegroups in thease_Analysis_rses_and_Vir
or ubiquitous18):4343 435: An efficientions on Parall
guaranteed asems Technolos of 3 D robod Cybernetics
c approach to
án J. Brain com011;15(5):527bot interactio
of asymmetrors. IEEE Tran
mittance contdings IEEE In
neous corticarnal of Biomerns of daytimal of BiologicaEE Instrument
haptic deviceystems, Man,
gmented floopplications: Sd user models
Using biofeeress managem
omy for mixednd Computer G
n
of human enilosophical Re
entation of viCanadian For_for_the_Imprtual_Work_G
and pervasiv51.fuzzy trust inlel and Distrib
ssist as needogy. 2014;22(t teleoperatios, Part B: Cybe
o the human
mputer interf7 537.on stability us
ric semiautonnsactions on H
trol of a fournternational
al and trabecuechanics. 2010e light exposal Rhythms. 2tation and M
e and visual d, and Cyberne
or surfaces. HuSpringer News and input te
edback whilement skills in
d reality visuaGraphics. 201
October
nhancement:eview.
rtual worlds irces. 2010:plementationGroups_in_th
e computing
nferencebuted Systems
ed controller(2):745 752.on interfacesernetics.
technology
faces for spac
sing Lyapunov
nomousHaptics.
degree of freConference o
ular bone cha0;43(2):294 3ure improve009;24(5):42
Measurement
isplay on theetics Part A:Sy
uman WalkinYork; 2013:3echnologies to
immersed insoldiers. PLo
alization in im12;18(2):332
r 2015
The
in
n_of_e_Ca
s.
r for
with
ce
v
eedomon
ange in301.
7 437.
ystems
ng in377 399.o
aoS
mage352.
Scien
37. WimSu
38. Kegu
39. C20
40. HA
41. Leauau
42. WIEIs
43. AIm20
44. PaPe72
45. SacoM
46. Ctevi
47. Dco
48. Pose20
49. JausEn
50. Sao
51. Wth
52. CPae
53. GJo
54. BJo
55. Dam
tometri
Wang A, Mirsamages with prurgery. 2011;ersten Oerteuided surgeryooperstock J.011;28(1):77epting DH. SoCM SIGCHI coeung CKS, Caruthorship netugmented coWang K, Liu XPEEE Internatiostanbul, Turkellison RS, Mamplications fo013;43(6):558arush A, Gauterceptual, Co2011:238 279akr N, GeorgaommunicatioMeasurement.ha J, Barghouelepresence aibrotactile feeehais F, Causountermeasuolushin IG, Taeparation for015;20(1):143aeger HF. A glse of pharmanvironmentalattler S, Forlinn Perspective
Wolbring G, Mherapeutic enabrera LY. Realgrave Macmnhancementutmann AK, Journal of Expeertram JEA. Cournal of Expeomingo A, Klmplitude in fl
c Study
attari SM, Parreoperative m;16(4):149 16l M, Jannin P,y. Computeriz. Multimodal86.oftware for syonference onrmichael CL, Ttworks. In: pgnition: direcP. Particle filteonal Symposiuey.cuda T, Jennior the use of n8 569.thier MS, Arsognitive, and P9.anas ND, Zhaon in Six DoF t. 2011;60(11)ut A, Kammerand teleactionedback. Presesse M, Trembures. Human Fakhmar A, Patbilateral tele3 154.lance at the tcological fatil Medicine. 20ni C, Racine Ées toward CogMartin A, Tynenhancement oethinking Hummillan; 2015:laura y cabreJacobi B, Butcerimental BioConstrained oerimental Bioimstra M, Nalexor carpi ra
on Hum
P
rrent AG, Petemodels for ep60., Collins DL. Tzed Medical Imtelepresence
ystematic andcreativity &Teh EW. Visuroceedings ofcting the futuering enhancum on Haptic
ngs S. Detectnight vision d
eneau L, TangPhysical Facto
o J. Human petelepresence):3534 3546.rl J, Steinbachn systems byence: Teleopelay S. MitigatFactors. 2011tel RV. Projeceoperation. IE
ip of a big icegue counterm007;78(5, Sup, Sauer C. Imgnitive Enhanedal J, Ball N,of veterans anman Enhancemhttp://www.era/?sf1=barccher MT, Bertology. 2006;20optimization iology. 2005;20kajima T, Lamdialis. Journa
man Opti
age 26 of 3
ers TM. Fusioilepsy surgica
The state of thmaging and Ge systems. IEE
d imaginativecognition. 20al analytics of the 6th interre of adaptived human trac Audio Visual
tion and discrdevices. IEEE T
g D. The Humors. Reviews o
erception bassystems. IEEE
h E, Saddik AEdisplaying diserators and Viion of conflic;53(5):448 46ction based foEEE/ASME Tra
eberg: Commmeasures in tpplement):B1pact of Contencement. PLoSYumakulov Snd soldiers wment: Social Epalgrave.comcode&st1=97tram JEA. Con09(4):622 632n human wal08(6):979 991m T, Hundza Sal of Motor Be
mization
on and visualizal planning an
he art of visuaGraphics. 201EE Signal Proc
e exploration.007: 253 254.f social networnational confve systems. 20acking on conl Environmen
rimination ofTransactions
man Factors ofof Human Fac
sed data reduE Transaction
E. Improving sstance informirtual Environcts with autom60.orce reflectioansactions on
entary on "rehe U.S. milita128 B130.extual FactorsS ONE. 2013;. Exploring di
with injuries.WEnhancementm/page/detail78113740223nstrained opt2.king: Cost mi1.SR. Walking pehavior. 2014
n
zation of intrand guidance.
alization in m13;37(2):98 1cessing Maga
. In: Proceedi
orks: miningference on Fo011:335 345.ntext aware rnts and Game
motion definon Human M
f Night Visionctors and Erg
uction for hapns on Instrum
spatial percepmation througnments. 2010mation: Use o
on algorithmsn Mechatronic
ecommendatiary". Aviation
s and Substan8(8).scourse surroWork. 2015;5t and Emergel/rethinking h3.timization in h
inimization an
hase modula4;46(1):49 57.
October
aoperative coComputer Aid
mixed reality im12.azine.
ngs of the 6th
and visualizinoundations of
obotic systemes (HAVE). 201
ned form:Machine Syste
n Goggles:gonomics. Vol
pticentation and
ption ingh visual and;19(5):430 44of cognitive
s with frequencs.
ions for the eSpace and
nce Character
ounding0(1):149 160ent Technologhuman
human runnin
nd gait plastic
tes H Reflex.
r 2015
orticalded
mage
h
ng cof
m. In:13;
ms.
l
d
49.
ncy
ethical
ristics
.gies.:
ng.
city.
Scien
56. Hm20
57. Are20
58. Ap20
59. RfuN
60. FiB
61. Ta20
62. Bpsmb
63. PepN
64. Mp
65. Laat20
66. GtoCo
67. Mp
68. KSt
69. FoeSc
70. Su20
71. Dsk20
72. DnIn
73. Wfo
tometri
ahn D, Herzomuscle action014;114(8):16bdoli E M, Ageduces EMG a006;21(5):456bdoli Eramakrinciple for an007;40(8):169oosink M, Roull body moveNeuroEngineerirmani F, Parkiomechanicalarnopolsky M010;57(SUPParroso O, Gouseudoephedr
medications toanned in spoelletier DM, Lerformance a
Nutrition and EMorrison SA, Crecooling. Jouarkin Kaiser Kttenuate stre015;50(1):45oulet EDB. Go be ingestedonditioning R
og W, Schwirtduring huma691 1702.gnew MJ, Stevamplitude of6 465.ki M, Stevenson on body pe94 1700.bitaille N, Mcements in a vring and Rehak EJ. Theoretil Engineering.MA. Caffeine aL. 2):1 8.udreault D, Crine and cathio healthy subjrt. Drug TestiLacerte G, Goand maximal oExercise MetaCheung S, Coturnal of AthleKA, Christou Ength loss afte50.lycerol inducbefore exerc
Research. 201Protein supploutcomes. Joueurnicht Naylnal of Psychone E. Stakeho: Unsuspected21(5):606 62R, WolfsbergeL. 1):A27 A32MJ, Chan H, Vigation and re2060 2064.MJ, Chan H, Ve effect of auTechniques.ashan A, Yatu
n: proceedings
on Hum
P
z A. Interdepn multi joint
venson JM. Aerector spina
on JM, Reid Srsonal lift aug
cFadyen BJ, evirtual mirror:abilitation. 20cal analysis o. 2013;135(4)and creatine u
arbó Banús Mine after therjects: Implicaing and Analyoulet EDB. Effeoxygen consuabolism. 2013tter JD. Imporetic Training.E, Tillman M,er strenuous
ed hyperhydrcise to maxim0;24(1):74 78lementation furnal of Nutrilor K, Xie B, Moactive Drugs.lder perspectd meaning of5.r S, Lama S, Z2.Vescan A, Wieduces task w
Vescan AD, Wugmented rea2013;27(2):45ulis J, Masches SPIE 8412, P
man Opti
age 27 of 3
endence of toleg extension
An on body peae during liftin
SA, Bryant TJ.gmentation d
t al. Real tim: Developmen015;12(1).of the state of).use in sport. A
M, et al. Deterrapeutic admiations for dopysis. 2012;4(5ects of querceumption: A m3;23(1):73 82rtance of airfl2014;49(5):6George S, Boresistance ex
ration: A metmize enduranc8.formilitary peition. 2013;14McIntyre RS. C. 2013;45(4):3tives and reacf ambivalence
Zarei Nia K. Th
tterick IJ, Irisworkload in tr
Witterick IJ, Irality on attent54 461.er P, Bruce I. DPhotonics No
mization
orque, joint an. European J
ersonal lift aung tasks. Clin
Mathematicdevice (PLAD)
e modulationnt and proof
f balance in b
Annals of Nut
rmination ofinistration ofping control a5):320 329.etin supplem
meta analysis.2.low for physi32 639.rsa PA. Nearxercise. Journa
thod for estimce performan
ersonnel: A re43(11):1820 1Cognitive Enh360 365.ctions to "acae and analogie
he evolution
h JC. Augmenrainees: A pre
ish JC. Surgeotion. Surgical
Digital implemrth. 2012.
n
angle, angularJournal of App
ugmentation dical Biomecha
al and empiri). Journal of B
n of visual feeof concept. J
bipedal walkin
trition and M
urinary concef pseudoephenalysis of the
mentation on eInternationa
ologic and er
infrared lightal of Athletic
mating the opce. Journal of
eview of the m1833.hancement in
ademic" cognes. Public Und
of neuroArm
nted image gueclinical trial.
ons blinded bl Endoscopy a
mentation of
October
r velocity andplied Physiolo
device (PLADanics.
ical proof ofBiomechanics.
edback on huournal of
ng. Journal of
Metabolism.
entrations ofedrine containese stimulant
enduranceal Journal of S
rgogenic effec
t therapy toTraining.
ptimal load off Strength an
mechanisms a
Canadian Me
itivederstanding o
. Neurosurge
uidance imprLaryngoscop
by enhancedand Other
a neural netw
r 2015
dogy.
D)
.
man
f
nings
Sport
cts of
f fluidd
and
edical
of
ery.
ovese.
work
Scien
74. PoauSu
75. AimM
76. MA
77. Pe20
78. Shman
79. RwR
80. Han
81. Zefo
82. Liq
83. ElcoN
84. Map20
85. Isva20
86. Isan
87. FrpC
88. PowCo
89. Pob
90. Cvi
91. Gsp
92. Vpof
tometri
othier DD, Huugmented reaurgery (Unitenimesh A, Pinmpacts of tecMIS Quarterly:Mendez I, Sonfeasibility stuedersen I. A s005;155(1 2)hull PB, Jirattmovement: And interventiahman MH, R
whole arm weobotica. 2014olz C, Grossmnnual confereendejas B, Bror laparoscopipsman N, Zenualitative stulnady AM, Zhontrolled armNeuroscience.Mohareri O, Rapplication in013;10(3).slam S, Liu XP,arying comm013;62(11):29slam S, Liu PX,nd nonpassivrize M. A debroceedings frhina.olushin IG, Li
with time delaontrol, Transaolushin IG, Liased force rehapdelaine S,igilance qualitirdhar Y, Gigupatiotemporaachon Presseain expressivf Pain. 2013;1
c Study
ughes C, Dilloality eyeweared States). 201nsonneault A,hnological an: Managemeng M, Chiassonudy using remsemiotics of h:183 200.igalachote Wreview on theon. Gait andRahman MJ, Carable roboti4;89(3).man T, Fitzmaence on Humydges R, Hampic surgery: Aner R, Bernstdy in appliedang X, Xiao Z
m exoskeleton2015;9(MARad AB. A visiohumanoid ro
, El Saddik A.unication del943 2953., El Saddik A,e input forcebate on the etromWorld Co
u PX, Lung CHy: Theory andactions of theu XP, Lung CHflection algor, Paquet J, Duty during simuère P, Dudekal topic modeeau E, Roy M,eness on vica14(11):1407 1
on Hum
P
n W, Ranalli Pr in the treatm12;146(6):966, Yang SB, Ohnd spatial envnt Information P, Bustamamote presenchuman action
W, Hunt MA, Ce clinical impaPosture. 2014Cristobal OL, Sic exoskeleton
urice G, Aguran factors in
mstra SJ, Cooksystematic reein M. Personneuroethics.G, et al. A sinn and motor p):14.on based locabot navigatio
Teleoperatioay. IEEE Tran
Dias J, Senevs under timethics of bodyongress on M
H, On GD. Posd experimente ASME. 2010H. Stability ofrithms. Automumont M. Effeulated night wk G. Autonomeling. InternatMartel MO,
arious brain re1415.
man Opti
age 28 of 3
PJ, Rutka JA. Tment of oscill6 971.W. An odyss
vironments onn Systems. 20nte L. Point oe. Neurosurgs for wearab
Cutkosky MR,act of wearab4;40(1):11 19Saad M, Kennn for rehabilit
r A. Implantedcomputing syk DA. State ofeview. Annalsnal identity, e. Bioethics. 20ngle session pproprioceptio
ation positionon. Internation
on systems wisactions on In
viratne L. Bilatvarying delayenhancemenedical Physics
sition error bats. Journal of0;132(3):1 11.bilateral telematica. 2012;ects of partiawork. Journamous adaptivetional Journalet al. The twoesponses reve
mization
The use of reopsia. Otolar
sey into virtuan intention to011;35(3):789of care progragery. 2013;72(le augmented
Delp SL. Quable sensing an9.né JP, Archamtation and to
d user interfaystems (CHI'1f the evidences of Surgery. 2enhancement009;23(6):375preliminary evon platform. F
ning system vinal Journal of
ith symmetricnstrumentati
teral shared ay. ISA Transacnt technologies and Biomed
ased schemeDynamic Syst.eoperators wi;48(6):1005 1l circadian ad
al of Sleep Rese explorationl of Robotics Ro sides of paiealed in chro
n
eal time imageryngology H
al worlds: Expo purchase vir9 810.amming for n(1):99 108.d reality inter
ntified self annd feedback f
mbault PS. Deo assist upper
aces. In: proce12). 2012; Ause on simulatio2013;257(4):5t and neurosu5 383.valuation of aFrontiers in H
ia augmentedf Humanoid R
c and unsymmion and Meas
autonomousctions. 2015;5es and regenedical Engineer
s for bilateratems, Measur
ith generalize1016.djustments onsearch. 2012;using realtimResearch. 201n communicaonic back pain
October
e stabilizationead and Neck
ploring thertual product
neuromodulat
rfaces. Semio
nd humanfor gait analys
evelopment olimb movem
eedings of thestin, USA.on based trai586 593.urgery: A
an affordableHuman
d reality: AnRobotics.
metric timesurement.
systems with54:218 228.eration. In:ring. 2013; Be
l teleoperatiorement and
ed projection
n sleep and21(4):380 38me online14;33(4):645ation: Effectsn patients. Jou
r 2015
n andk
s.
tion:
tica.
sis
f aments.
e
ning
BCI
h passive
eijing,
on
9.
657.ofurnal
Scien
93. HpSe
94. CdEn
95. Zam20
96. ZafoCJe
97. PaJo
98. Ofa
99. BNN
100. Gco
101. JatrEl
102. Seu
103. Au
104. PaTrrd
105. PaMht
106. BstR
107. HJo
tometri
ong G, Zhangroceedings frensing 2006:urrie J, Gillis Cock mechanisngineering. 2adeh MRD, Hmicrogrid cont011; College Sadeh MRD, Hor an islandedonference oneddah, Saudiant LP. Learnournal of AgriOsinga N, Kelleacilities. Canaeland J P, PatBICs for Purp
Nanoethics. 20runwell J, Illeollaboration bang IG, Kim IYrabecular archlements in Aneiberl W, Pownresolved issl Osman H, Eibiquitous bioaul MA, Grayraining. Defenddc.gc.ca/BASaul MA, Gray
Mirage Aircrewttp://pubs.drrunelin J, Levtimulation asagert (2013).emond C, Broournal of Neu
c Study
g Y, Lavigne Drom Annual CProspecting fCB, Carreterosms for AUV r014;38(2):21ajimiragha A,troller. In: proStation, TX, Uajimiragha A,d microgrid wn Innovative SArabia.ing and Innovicultural Educer H. Dieteticadian Journaltenaude J, Leposes of Hum011;5(3):295es J, Karkazis Kbetween scieY. Applicationhitecture in hnalysis and Dewer GA, Hahnues. Journal oid M, El Saddofeedback sysGW, Miller Jnse TechnicalSIS/pcandid/wGW, Miller Jw. Defense Terdc rddc.gc.cavasseur Morea cognitive aFrontiers in Hown RM, Roburoscience. 20
on Hum
P
DA. Object basonference offor Geospatiao JA, Dubay R,recovery. Tra3 226., Adamiak M,oceedings of 6USA., Adamiak M,
with energy stSmart Grid Te
vation Compecation and Exstudents' expof Dietetic Prgault GA, Boian Enhancem307.K. Advancingntists and ethof design spa
human proximesign. 2010;4D. Residual fof Electromyoik A. U biofeetems.MultimC. Cognitive El Reports: DRDwww/engpubC. Preliminaryechnical Repoa/BASIS/pcanau J, Fecteaund motor enhHuman Neurobertson EM. A010;30(2):650
man Opti
age 29 of 3
sed change df the Americaal Information, Jeans T, Watansactions of t
, Palizban A, A64th annual co
, Palizban A, Aorage systemechnologies
etence in Agrtension. 2012periences proractice and Ressy P, Parent
ment: Why Do
neuroregenehicists. Neuroace optimizatmal femur for6(4):311 319force enhanceography and Kedback: A mumedia Tools anEffectivenessDC TORONTOb/DDW?W%3y Assessmentort: DRDC TORdid/www/enS. Is it ethicahancer deviceoscience. 201A distraction c0 654.
mization
etection in hn Society forn Integration,tt GD. Dynamthe Canadian
Allan S. Desigonference fo
Allan S. New cms. In: proceeMiddle East (
icultural and2;18(3).oviding meal aesearch. 2013M. The Socia
oes the Debat
erative medicoethics. 2009;tion to bone rhigher comp
9.ement in humKinesiology. 2ultimedia basend Applicatioof CF18 Instr
O TR 2007 023DSYSNUM=5t of ZopicloneRONTO TR 20ngpub/DDW?Wal and safe toe for military3;7:874.can impair or
n
igh resolutionPhotogramm, ASPRS. 2006mics of two acn Society for M
n and implemr Protective R
control and adings of the I(ISGT Middle
Rural Develo
assistance in3;74(2):88 91al and Ethicalte Remain Mi
cine: A call for;2(1):13 20.remodeling sputational eff
mans: Current2015;25(4):57ed referenceons. 2014;72(3ructor Pilots D28. 2007. http527944&r=0.e (Imovane) u006 077. 2006W%3DSYSNUuse non invaservices? A r
enhance mo
October
n image. In:metry and Rem6.ctive autonomMechanical
mentation ofRelay Enginee
automation syEEE PESEast).2011;
opment. The
long term ca1.Acceptabilityred in Impass
r expanded
imulation oficiency. Finite
t evidence an71 580.model for3):3143 3168During Routinp://pubs.drdc
use in Camp6.UM=525469&asive brainreply to Sehm
tor performa
r 2015
mote
mous
aers.
ystem
are
y ofse?
e
nd
8.ne
&r=0.
m and
ance.
Scien
6 AP
6.1 At
6.2 M
6.2.1 STo addresseveral daDefense T
Filename1. HE – M
2. HE – R
3. HE – C
4. HE – CFinal.p
5. HE – CData.x
6. HE – GCollab
7. HE – GCollab
8. HE – GCollab
9. HE – CCollab
10. HE – CRaw D
11. HE – CGephi
12. HE – L
tometri
PENDICE
ttachmen
ethodolo
earchesss the key queatabases incluTechnical Info
Metagroup Me
Research Cluste
Canadian Autho
Canadian – Canpng
Canadian Canaxlsx
Geographic Maborations.pngGeographic Maborations LEG
Geographic Maborations – wit
Canadian Canaborations TG Fi
Canadian InterData.xlsxCanadian Inter.png
List of Internati
c Study
ES
nts
ogy
estions in thisuding Scopus,rmation Cent
mbership.xlsx
ers Final 100 –
ors Contact.xls
nadian Collabo
dian Collabora
ap of Canadian
ap of CanadianEND.ppt
ap of Canadianh labels.png
dian International.png
national Collab
national Collab
ional Collabora
on Hum
P
s project a bro, Inspec, Comter (DTIC), and
zoomed.png
sx
rations TG
ations – Raw
onal
borations –
borations
ators.xlsx
man Opti
age 30 of 3
oad search onpendex, Natiod CANadian D
DescriptioLists subjec
Shows the care not clusFigure 2.
Provides cowhen issueforeign aut
CollaboratioTouchGrap
Raw data uresearchers
Canadian coGephi. SamLegend forof Canada.
Canadian coGephi with
CollaboratioresearcherscollaboratioSame as FigRaw data uand internaWorld mapother countline reflectscountriesA list of all i
mization
n human optional TechnicaDefence Infor
onct groups in eac
clusters withinstered are not
ontact informats arose regardhors.
on map of Canh. Same as Fig
sed to create cs in TouchGrap
ollaborations ome as Figure 6.color coding in
ollaborations olabels on the m
on map of Cans. Only Canadiaon are presentgure 7.sed to create cational researcshowing collatries around ths the number o
international i
n
imization wasal Informationrmation Datab
ch of the four
n the subject grincluded in th
tion, area of exding affiliation.
nadian researchure 5.
collaboration mph.
overlaid on ma
n Canadian col
overlayed on mmap.
nadian and inteans with an intted. Created in
collaboration mchers in TouchGaborations betwhe world. The tof collaboratio
nstitutions in t
October
s conducted in Service (NTbase (CANDID
metagroups.
roups. Those te map. Same a
xpertise, and nIncludes some
hers. Created i
map of Canadia
ap of Canada in
laboration on
map of Canada
ernationalternationaln TouchGraph.
map of CanadiaGraph.ween Canada athickness of thns between
the dataset.
r 2015
inTIS),D).
hatas
notese
in
an
n
map
in
an
andhe
Scien
Due to exresulting imajority ofrom thessearch resbased onexclusionwere retaomissions
Table 4 lisvarious bofinal publ
6.2.2 AAll referencreation odata and
Keywordskeywordssubject anthrough asubject gr
4 DTIC Mul
tometri
xport challengin only 3 relevof records wese searches, 1sulted in a daaffiliation couand a list of 3
ained. Througs were made
sts the concepoolean operaications were
Analysisnces were doof various groprofile the ac
s, classificatios and naturalnalysis (hereaa variety of steroups. Keywo
tisearch site: h
c Study
ges, roughly 1vant Canadiaere American122 publicatioataset of closeuntry and aut300 titles forgh the groupiresulting in a
pts included itors dependie found in Sco
Optimize
ImproveIncreaseAugmentEnhanceOptimize
ownloaded intoupings, statisctivities of the
on codes, indelanguage proafter referredeps. First, theords (that had
http://multisea
on Hum
P
1000 articles wn records. A sand the recoons were prove to 15 000 inthor affiliatiopotential omng process rofinal subset o
in the search.ng on the datopus.
Table 4
Hum
HumCogSoldIndPerPerPiloAstAircTroSpeFligInfaMil
to VantagePostical analysee major playe
ex keywords,ocessing of titto as keywor
e table of metd at least five
arch.deepweba
man Opti
age 31 of 33
were manualsearch was alrds were notvided by the cnternational pns. This subse
