Microbial genomics for de-risking offshore
oil and gas exploration in Nova Scotia
Casey Hubert
Geomicrobiology Group
• marine oil spill bioremediation
• establishing environmental baselines
• seabed hydrocarbon seep microbiology
• deep biosphere microbial ecology
• extremophiles
• bacterial endospores
• oil reservoir microbiology
• food microbiology (coffee, sourdough)
Research Funding
Outline
1. original observations and interest in hydrocarbon seeps
2. using cold-adapted seabed microbes for prospecting
3. using dormant thermophilic bacterial spores for prospecting
Smeerenburgfjorden, Svalbard, 80° North
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
-5 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Temperature (°C)
Svalbard marine sediment incubated from -2 to +40°C
CO2
organicsSO4-2
H2S
SRB
su
lph
ate
red
uction
ra
te (
nm
olcm
-3h
-1)
Bo Barker Jørgensen, unpublished
Thermophilic Bacteria in Arctic Sedimentssu
lfa
te r
ed
uctio
n r
ate
(%
of
op
tim
um
)
incubation temperature (°C)
Svalbard
~0°C
in-situ Hubert et al 2009 Science 325: 1541
SRB
sulfate-reducing bacteria
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
Thermophilic Bacteria in Arctic Sediments
incubation temperature (°C)
Svalbard
~0°C
in-situ
samples pre-pasteurized at 80°C
SRB
sulfate-reducing bacteria
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
su
lfa
te r
ed
uctio
n r
ate
(%
of
op
tim
um
) Hubert et al 2009 Science 325: 1541
Flemming Mønsted Christensen, M.Sc. thesis, 2009
Desulfotomaculum endospores
genus Desulfotomaculum
• sulfate reducers
• endospore formers
• thermophiles
CO2
simple
organicsSO4
-2
H2S
SRB
“sulfate reduction”
Flemming Mønsted Christensen, M.Sc. thesis, 2009
se
dim
en
t d
ep
th (
cm
)
se
dim
en
t d
ep
ositio
n (
ye
ar)
estimated abundance (thermophiles cm-3)
• 105 per gram of sediment
• annual influx 108 m-2
• where are they coming from?
Desulfotomaculum endospores
in Arctic marine sediment
Caloranaerobacter (2)
Caminicella
Desulfotomaculum
oil reservoir
mid-oceanridge
✓ warm
✓ anoxic
✓ fluid flow
Thermospores… where are they coming from?
rRNA genephylogeny:
5%
bottom water current
sedimentation
petroleum reservoirHubert & Judd 2010
Handbook of Hydrocarbon and Lipid Microbiology (Springer) Johnson et al. (2006) Geofluids 6: 251-271
Hydrocarbon seeps Hydrothermal circulation
• widespread in the ocean
• fluid seepage from depth
• depth influences in situ T
• thermospores have many
rRNA gene database hits to
oil fields
• worldwide network of ocean ridges
• lateral (axis) influence on in situ T
• thermospores have some rRNA
gene database hits to mid ocean
ridge systems
seabed fluid flow ~ an unappreciated microbial dispersal vector?
Caloranaerobacter (2)
Caminicella
Desulfotomaculum
✓ warm
✓ anoxic
✓ fluid flow
Thermospores… where do they come from?
rRNA genephylogeny:
5%
seabed fluid flow ~ an unappreciated microbial dispersal vector?
oil reservoir
mid-oceanridge
oil reservoir
bottom water current
sedimentation
Microbiology-based prospecting
for seabed hydrocarbon seeps
Microbiology-based prospecting
for seabed hydrocarbon seeps
oil reservoir
bottom water current
sedimentation
Microbiology-based prospecting
for seabed hydrocarbon seeps
oil reservoir
bottom water current
sedimentation
O2 conc.
oil reservoir
bottom water current
sedimentation
Hypothesis: thermophilic spores [ ] and cold-adapted
oil-degrading bacteria [ ] have different distributions at seeps
detectable range?
oil reservoir
bottom water current
sedimentation
Prospecting advantage using dormant bacterial spores
compared to active bacteria, or hydrocarbons…?
oil reservoir
sedimentation
Prospecting advantage using dormant bacterial spores
compared to active bacteria, or hydrocarbons…?
bottom water current
oil reservoir
bottom water current
sedimentation
Multiple approaches to exploration risk assessment
Outline
1. original observations and interest in hydrocarbon seeps
2. using cold-adapted seabed microbes for prospecting
3. using dormant thermophilic bacterial spores for prospecting
• Scotian Slope, 2500 - 3500 m
• Eastern Gulf of Mexico 1000 - 3000 m
Nova Scotia Department of Energy’s Play Fairway Analysis
• $15M investment by NS interdisciplinary geoscience mapping
• >$2B in exploration commitments (Shell, BP, Statoil)
• Front-end science to characterize the deep seabed reduced risk
Canadian Coast Guard
Ship: Hudson
summer 2015 & 2016
Scotian Slope – Piston Coring
>60 sites sampled
• 1750 to 3450 m water depth
• 0 to 10 mbsf sediment depth
Geochemical analyses (APT)
• Organic carbon content
• Gas wetness
• Isotopes (δ13C, δD)
• Sulfate depth profiles (UofC)
Microbial analysis
• >400 samples
• bacterial community
composition
Distinct sulfate profiles for Sites M, J, E
Oye Adebayo
Hydrocarbons = sulfate reduction 0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
1000
0 20
Dep
th (
cm
)
Sulfate (mM)
Site M
Site J
Site E
Site N
Site H
SRB
sulfate-reducing bacteria
+
+
+
–
–
Geochem (APT)
Surface and Subsurface samples for DNA
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
1000
0 20
Dep
th (
cm
)
Sulfate (mM)
Surface: 0 cm & 20 cm
(trigger weight core and
piston core)
Subsurface: >20 cm
(only piston core)
subsurface (>20 cm) Atribacteria at 14 sites
A B C D E F I JH K L M N O0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Rel
ativ
e ab
unda
nce
(%)
Aerophobetes
Aminicenantes
Atribacteria
Atribacteria
Atribacteria
Atribacteria
Atribacteria
– – + + +– + –
– – – – + – – +– – – + – –
sulfate (U of C)
geochem (APT)
OTU_1
OTU_2
OTU_4984
OTU_58
OTU_9
7 dominant OTUs
Carmen Li
Deidra Stacey
G
7 dominant OTUs
OTU_2 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
Rel
ativ
e ab
unda
nce
(%)
Chloroflexi
Acidobacteria
Gammaproteobacteria
Alphaproteobacteria
Gammaproteobacteria
Aminicenantes
Atribacteria
A B C D E F I JH K L M N O
– – + + +– + –
– – – – + – – +– – – + – ––
sulfate (U of C)
geochem (APT)
Carmen Li
Deidra Stacey
subsurface (<20 cm) Atribacteria at 15 sites
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
Rel
ativ
e ab
unda
nce
(%)
Chloroflexi
Acidobacteria
Gammaproteobacteria
Alphaproteobacteria
Gammaproteobacteria
Aminicenantes
Atribacteria
subsurface (<20 cm) Atribacteria at 15 sites
A B C D E F I JH K L M N O
– – + + +– + –
– – – – + – – +– – – + – –
G
–
sulfate (U of C)
geochem (APT)
7 dominant OTUs
OTU_2
Carmen Li
Deidra Stacey
What is the functional role of uncultivated
Atribacteria? Metagenomics
O
N
OG
N
N
O
3 metagenomes
site 26 (O)
site 29 (OG)
site 44 (N)
• 58 draft genomes
from three samples
• 6 Atribacteria
preliminary evidence
reveals hydrocarbon
degradation genes in
5/6 Atribacteria
Xiyang Dong
Outline
1. original observations and interest in hydrocarbon seeps
2. using cold-adapted seabed microbes for prospecting
3. using dormant thermophilic bacterial spores for prospecting
seep-associated Atribacteria in
both Nova Scotia and Gulf of
Mexico sediments may be gas
or oil associated, and may be
capable of hydrocarbon
biodegradation
ongoing detailed analysis of
genomic and oil geochemistry
datasets
And! using genomics for exploration automatically
provides an environmental baseline
Deidra Stacey
optimizing conditions for baseline data collection
2 Nova Scotia cores × triplicate sediment aliquots
× 3 DNA extraction protocoss× 3 PCR primer pairs
Outline
1. original observations and interest in hydrocarbon seeps
2. using cold-adapted seabed microbes for prospecting
3. using dormant thermophilic bacterial spores for prospecting
Caloranaerobacter (2)
Caminicella
Desulfotomaculum
✓ warm
✓ anoxic
✓ fluid flow
Thermospores… where do they come from?
rRNA genephylogeny:
5%
Are spore-forming Firmicutes really prevalent in oil reservoirs?
Are spore-forming Firmicutes really prevalent in oil reservoirs?
Daniel Gittins
• ~75 studies with amplicon libraries from oil reservoirs
• only 12 from formation water (no water injection)
• therefore truly indigenous communities analysed
• Firmicutes indeed prevalent
• next step: expand the study to include produced water samples as well as formation waters
111 surface sediments heated to 50°C
Anirban
Chakraborty
71 oil-positive and 40 oil-negative
Thermophilic Bacteria in cold sediments
incubation temperature (°C)
Svalbard
~0°C
in-situHubert et al 2009 Science 325: 1541
SRB
sulfate-reducing bacteria
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
(% o
f o
ptim
um
)
su
lfate
red
ucti
on
rate
incubation time (hours at 50oC)
50°C
(nm
olcm
-3h
-1) DNA sequencing to characterize
the microbial community after
several days at 50°C
1-30 thermospore
OTUs per sediment
115 thermospores detected @ 50°CT
herm
osp
ore
OT
Us
site occupancy
top 12 oil-associated
thermospores in EGoM
• ≥80% detection in
oil-positive locations
oil-positive
oil-negative
top 12 oil-associated
thermospores in EGoM
• ≥80% detection in
oil-positive locations
oil-positive
oil-negative
top 12 oil-associated
thermospores in EGoM
• ≥80% detection in
oil-positive locations
oil-negative
Outline
1. original observations and interest in hydrocarbon seeps
2. using cold-adapted seabed microbes for prospecting
3. using dormant thermophilic bacterial spores for prospecting
Conclusion: mutually
exclusive strategies for
seep detection are showing
promising results
oil reservoir
bottom water current
sedimentation
other applications?
thermospores as messengers from the reservoir?