Date post: | 28-Jan-2016 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | jack-wilson |
View: | 15 times |
Download: | 0 times |
1AC 1NC
1AR 2NR
2AR 2NR 2AR
Judge Comments
1AC 1NC
Asian in the pursuit of the American Dream
yellow collar can never be white
stance against oppression
ignores the existence of asian oppression
chang
did not serve a single day in jail
panasian identityall asians are the same to whiteswar against an asian bodytopic is starting point
yomata
didn't know asians felt oppressed
debate space is often excluding asian bodymodel minority
chance for me to expose this racismjn is a means to say it exists
myth becomes a tool for oppression parametrisizing means he excludes other stuff
chang 2portrayal of asian as model minority
deny present day discrim
leads to other oppressionprimary
drewcow
jews link to the model minority; at worst our speech acts are on an equal level
chinese oppression/murer w/o going together; topics open to asians bc of this
never stand in solidarity if we assume a policy that helps some but harms others
hardpressed to explain why we can't emphasize with asians
rooting out silenced oppression aroun dour
this means we need to just deconstruct
protrayal as successful ; ignore or marginalize them as successful
we link into ableism in his analytic; certain/significiant number of regulations that exclude disabled bodies
tells a story about our society; poverty of latinos must be explained by the lack of work eithic by them
rob = structural oppression alliteration strategy 1. specificity outweigh
trying to solve for specific stuff
spanos
can still link more than a gamecocheck
db8 becomes beyond winning or losing
solution is deconstruction the myth
ojima 07 wont' solve, just a mindshift change
clarification of how we move in the world we need to do something further than that
world that is dynamically in the amking
work against other oppression
cause more bias
osijima 2
easier to see how broader forces shaped livesindividualism in america
mcdonald and german
narratives provide knowledgestats and facts become less apparent
internal link to fairnessstance against skew against asian
kwann debate is unfarresearch disparitieshostilities towards colour
debate is a site; operation of education that empowers us; school employes hegemonic discourse and reproduces order
under his role of the ballot my offense still functions
engage in an entire point of having a debate in the first place
instead of learning to operate we learn how to make the world----contienziation
turn/implicit racism against the asian population, he never solves
conversations and talk abot experience is important
narrative are good but topical narratives are better
alcove
brinkly 98 see policying makng args
separates debater from real world
im not linking in binaries; the ableism terms are fluid
dominant discourse precludes understanding how racism operates
roleplaying as policymakers upholds spectator mentality
debate round has no real impact on
1AR 2NR
asians seen as working so oppressed
nobody understands what it is
extend yomata--conceding it doesn't exist anyways
shouldn't disregard the fact oppression still happens in the system we have to talk about it
T f(x) as a disad and a turnturns on the aff is a reason we look to NC
extend this argument
you don't care about it; you don't care about it in the debate space; net harm to advocacy
role of the ballot means we have to have oppression as a whole; specificity allows us to consruct a coherent strategy; abstraction to get out of an issue; must debate policy; real world change means we need a specific group to actually liberate
why are jews par to fit? No warrant for this; jews can link to think ; net worse to this sovlency
if he wants me to go through articles after the round then jews can go through it; my performance is going to be equally as good as his; one fo the perspectives; only wy we can forward this movement
extend ojima --it's not a mindset shift its about how we can add perspetives through evidence and narratives in debate
we need real policy action; mindset change doesn't solve for everything
we are remaking the world; always better than your solvencybest solution in america because america refuses to look at it like this, it allows us to know the experience of other people; best way to solve
extend that there's implicit bias coming out of the system; he can never solve on the post-fiat layer
speech act are the same; who has the best post-fiat advocacy
anti-oppression strategies is key to solving problems of oppression
extensions of kwanna nd birnkley ?
2AR 2NR 2AR
extending narrative
yomoata, nobody understands asian oppressionsmy narrative is the only way we can introduce this perspectivejewish as model minority doesn't have a performance on this
you concede why his role of the ballot is about oppress as a whole; you excluding asian oppression is bad
solving for all bodies that's the drewcow evidence; why can't you be like these asian americans
narratives are key; instead of talking about facts and statistics, we are talking about what actually helps us, advantages of solvencywe don’t' talk about group activities, america only talks about individualismlook at this experience and see how it comes together with this experience; firs tplace we are going to solve them
Judge Comments
1NC 1AR
a link
defends cjs
ableism you vote off of my speech act as a whole
uscourts res is a starting point for my discussionindividual must not be disqualifiedexplicitly ableist vote for me for my performance, not jn
outweighs on abstraction
no attempt to include those
us2help smake sure that there's no affiliations
cedarsmedical purposes; ohters nee dhelponly way to be inclusivesocial inclusion is logically requisitediscussing people of different views
supercharged--taking a break and reviewing it
cedars 2higher education doesn't recognizeworld seems differentchange starts in the classroom
slippery slope
nannsocial stigmasdiscrimination hurts housing and jobs
alt - community oriented justice
fammused instead of prison or jailget rid of the CJs all together
debate is a speech acttied ot our bodiessupercharged by the fact that importanc is importancedoesn't solve for a liberation strategy
clearlyaustin texasneighbors and advise committee
rob = challenge ableism entire warrant is why oppression itself is badnot about abelism
beckett
I contextualize what affirming the res means in the first
systemic disability in pedagogy
should be part of a curiculumlegitimizing disabiling ideas otherwise
this is bad for debate because you aren't talking about it; he creates oppression olympics; you are just going backt ot he silence; you don't care about the silence
all warrants are way ableism is bad; if aa opp is bad you vote there
2NR
2AR 2NR 2AR
Judge Comments
1NC 1AR
1. no abuse--I disclosed an hour before the round
he just doesn't wanna engagehe was a bad method
kills lib potentialadvocacy is not topical; it’s a perforamnce
no where else to reveal the truth
2. no post-fiat null good cardstandards nowhere else we can have it
a. can't egnage in the aff
topical version of the aff could be cJs w/ model minority
could be a way he could've engaged in the topic
link fairness; can't engage
general consensus
topical version of the aff
k2 role of the judge
turns role of the ballot bc excludes me
disad to the methodim not reading fairness or educatiothis is a way I can't engage on the issueat the point in which his aff is non topical I can't engagethis is the only argument I could've else readexcludes stock ground
a. interp -- aff must be topical; must be predicated on facing perceived justice
b. using jury nullification being bad for him; not sufficient to be topical; its not part of the resolution
I have nowhere else to do this; debate is a space wher eyou have to answer to this shit
3. he says the implication is a disad to the aff so as long as aff wins solvency you vote aff
2NR
T outweighs because on high level
overview to the round--
could've engaged under the role of the ballot
kick the k it was conditional
the fact my interp says you must be topical and all offense must be on this solves it; he could've read a topical ac is a reaosn why his responses are predicated on the fairness or education; im only linking my standards into the rob; disad to the peformancehow laws could be unjustly applied to Asian Americans; so many laws/ there is a lot of lit on it; vote me up because im engaging in it
extend the violation--he reads one card but my advocacy says all offense must be predicated on it
debate space is good but you can do it through a topical ilnk; I only have an hour before the round; no wifi; would'n't have been enough to engage on the issue; should've read it for asian americans
not doing any work on line by line; engage in a topical version of the aff
extend that it impacts uner the rob so it’s a turn to the role of the ballot; if I can't engage or solve for it; there's a reason why his aff is going to be bad
destroys liegitimacy but a topical version is what should be read; undermines legitimacy of the movement; performances is terminal defense
t is a disad; risk of offense; advocacy is bad; read turns back to the role of the ballot means it solves
doing a lot of grandstanding but conceding internal warrant that only a topical version of this aff solves for abuse
2AR 2NR 2AR
not doing enough work on the prefiat layer
extend disclosure solve; he had lte; he also had his coach helping him; how jewish people were a part of the model minority
you are telling em to talk about; there's no topical advocacy; I looked for it' asian americans are not seen as oppressed, which is why people don’t' look at it; why lit exists for race
ht eproblem is implication fo T is disad but that's problematic because he's providing another solution on a prefiat layer
Judge Comments
1NC 1AR
2NR
2AR 2NR 2AR
Judge Comments
1NC 1AR
2NR
2AR 2NR 2AR
Judge Comments
1NC 1AR
2NR
2AR 2NR 2AR
Judge Comments
1AC 1NC
the only macros you need to know are:
ctrl + n = shift all cells down one
AFF ARGUMENT IS MADE HERE 1
2
3
when this opens, you may need to enable the macros
ctrl + j = make responses to an argument. To make additional responses, move down one cell. (demonstrated below)
click this cell and click "ctrl + J" so that a "1" appears in the column to the rightpush enter, and then push "ctrl + J" so that a "2" appearscontinuing pushing enter and then pushing "ctrl + J" for as many responses as are made
I guarantee that anyone with basic motor skills and reasoning skills can master this
1AR 2NR
2AR 2NR 2AR
Judge Comments
1NC 2AC 2NC/1NR 1AR
2NR 2AR Judge Comments
1NC 2AC 2NC/1NR 1AR
2NR 2AR Judge Comments
1NC 2AC 2NC/1NR 1AR
2NR 2AR Judge Comments
1NC 2AC 2NC/1NR 1AR
2NR 2AR Judge Comments
2NR 2AR Judge Comments