Catalysis Center for Energy Innovation
Modern catalytic technologies for converting biomass to fuels
An supported by the
,,
Presented by Dion Vlachos, Director
www.efrc.udel.eduwww.efrc.udel.edu
Catalysis Center for Energy Innovation
Objectives and ApproachObjectives and ApproachObjectives and ApproachObjectives and Approach
ObjectivesD l h bli i l di i d di ll Develop the enabling science leading to improved or radically new (heterogeneous) catalytic technologies for viable and economic operation of biorefineries from various (lignocellulosic) biomass feed stocksfeed stocks
Develop technology and enable technology transfer
Educate the workforce needed to further develop and implement Educate the workforce needed to further develop and implement these new technologies, which in turn will lead to further sustainable economic growth and reduced energy dependence of the U.S.
ApproachDevelop paradigms for major technologies of biorefineries by picking prototype platforms
www.efrc.udel.eduwww.efrc.udel.edu
picking prototype platforms
Catalysis Center for Energy Innovation
R h ThR h ThResearch ThrustsResearch Thrusts
Hierarchical MultiscaleMaterials
Multiscale Modeling
Characterization Techniques
Crosscutting Research
Thrust
Chemicals Catalytic Degradation/ Direct Carbon FCsTechnological
Platform
ReformingHH22 y g
Oil UpgradePlatform
ChemicalsChemicals FuelsFuels ElectricityElectricity
Reaction Pathways, Kinetics, Structure-Property RelationshipsScience
Process Innovation OptimizationProcessing
www.efrc.udel.eduwww.efrc.udel.edu
Process Innovation, OptimizationProcessing
Catalysis Center for Energy Innovation
R h ThR h ThResearch ThrustsResearch Thrusts
Hierarchical MultiscaleMaterials
Multiscale Modeling
Characterization Techniques
Crosscutting Research
Thrust
Chemicals Catalytic Degradation/ Direct Carbon FCsTechnological
Platform
ReformingHH22 y g
Oil UpgradePlatform
ChemicalsChemicals FuelsFuels ElectricityElectricityCO+2H2/FT
Reaction Pathways, Kinetics, Structure-Property RelationshipsScience
Process Innovation OptimizationProcessing
www.efrc.udel.eduwww.efrc.udel.edu
Process Innovation, OptimizationProcessing
Catalysis Center for Energy Innovation
ThermochemicalThermochemical transformation of transformation of lignocellulosic biomasslignocellulosic biomass
Traditional paths entail high temperatures and suffer from Traditional paths entail high temperatures and suffer from carbonCPOX forms no carbon
il F l
Cat. upgrade
Pyrolysis
OilCharTar
Fuel
Biomass
y yHigh T Syngas
CharGasification MethanolSynfuel
www.efrc.udel.eduwww.efrc.udel.edu
Catalysis Center for Energy Innovation
ThermochemicalThermochemical transformation of transformation of lignocellulosic biomasslignocellulosic biomass
Traditional paths entail high temperatures and suffer from Traditional paths entail high temperatures and suffer from carbonCPOX forms no carbon
il F l
Cat. upgrade
Pyrolysis
OilCharTar
Fuel
Biomass
y yHigh T Syngas
CharGasification MethanolSynfuel
CPOX SyngasVery high T
www.efrc.udel.eduwww.efrc.udel.edu
Catalysis Center for Energy Innovation
ThermochemicalThermochemical transformation of transformation of lignocellulosic biomasslignocellulosic biomass
Sugar conversion via fermentation established Oil Fuel
Cat. upgradefermentation established
Low rates, expensive enzymes Pyrolysis
Hi h T
OilCharTar
Fuel
Biomass
High T SyngasChar
GasificationMethanolSynfuel
CPOX S ngasVery high T CPOX SyngasVery high T
Ethanol, butanolBiological,Enzymes
drol
ysis
Chemicals
Hyd Sugars
www.efrc.udel.eduwww.efrc.udel.edu
Catalysis Center for Energy Innovation
ThermochemicalThermochemical transformation of transformation of lignocellulosic biomasslignocellulosic biomass
Thermochemical route exhibits faster rates and Oil Fuel
Cat. upgradeexhibits faster rates and could be tuned
PyrolysisHi h T
OilCharTar
Fuel
Biomass
High T SyngasChar
GasificationMethanolSynfuel
CPOX S ngasVery high T CPOX SyngasVery high T
Ethanol, butanolBiological,Enzymes
drol
ysis
Chemicals
Hyd Fuels:
SyngasH2Alkanes
Transportation fuelsEthyl levulinateDimethylfuran
Sugars
Thermochemical
www.efrc.udel.eduwww.efrc.udel.edu
Alkanes HMFFurfural
yγ-valerolactone
Thermochemical
Catalysis Center for Energy Innovation
l i l i / il i l i / i il dil d
Overarching Goal: Develop the science-based to
Catalytic Fast Pyrolysis/BioCatalytic Fast Pyrolysis/Bio--Oil UpgradeOil Upgrade
Overarching Goal: Develop the science based to enable the conversion of cellulose to fuels
Develop an understanding of the catalytic fastDevelop an understanding of the catalytic fast pyrolysisDevelop and characterize suitable catalystsDevelop and characterize suitable catalystsDevelop models for diffusion and reaction inside and outside microporous materialsand outside microporous materialsPerform kinetic studies
www.efrc.udel.eduwww.efrc.udel.edu
Catalysis Center for Energy Innovation
Catalytic Fast Pyrolysis Catalytic Fast Pyrolysis
G. Huber/UMass
Catalytic Fast Pyrolysis Catalytic Fast Pyrolysis Solid biomass converted into aromatics in a single reactor at h t id tishort residence times:
Liquid fuel that fits into existing infrastructureL t l bl lit Low cost, recyclable zeolite catalystsChallenge is controlling chemistrychemistry
www.efrc.udel.eduwww.efrc.udel.edu
Carlson et al., Green Gasoline by Catalytic Fast Pyrolysis of Solid Biomass-derived Compounds, ChemSusChem, 1, 397-400 (2008)
Catalysis Center for Energy Innovation
Catalytic Fast Pyrolysis: Overall yieldsCatalytic Fast Pyrolysis: Overall yieldsCatalytic Fast Pyrolysis: Overall yieldsCatalytic Fast Pyrolysis: Overall yields
90%
100% UndefinedCoke
60%
70%
80%
eld
(%)
CokeCO2COAromatics
Reaction Conditions: Temperature 600oC; ZSM-5; Catalyst/Feed 30%
40%
50%
Car
bon
Yie
; y /Ratio 19
0%
10%
20%
Maximum Yield:
0%Xylitol Glucose Cellobiose Cellulose
www.efrc.udel.eduwww.efrc.udel.eduCarlson, Vispute, and Huber, Green Gasoline by Catalytic Fast Pyrolysis, ChemSusChem.
C6O6H12 → 12/22 C7H8 (63 % Yield) + 48/22 CO (36 % Yield) + 84/22 H2O
Catalysis Center for Energy Innovation
Cellulose Pyrolysis in TGA at fast Cellulose Pyrolysis in TGA at fast heatingheating
G. Huber/UMass
y yy y ggon
(α
)
• Cellulose can be 100% pyrolyzed
onve
rsio • Cellulose pyrolysis to
anhydrosugars is endothermic
Ki i d h f ff
⎛ ⎞ulos
e Co • Kinetics and heat transfer effects
both need to be taken into account
( ) ( ) 01 , exp As
s
d Ek k T kdt RTα α
⎛ ⎞= − = −⎜ ⎟
⎝ ⎠Cellu
Cellulose pyrolysis at three different heating ates in TGA
( ) ( ) Hdtdm
dtdT
cmTThA spser Δ+−=−
αα 00 1
Energy Balance
www.efrc.udel.eduwww.efrc.udel.edu
heating rates in TGALin et al., Kinetics and Mechanism of Cellulose Pyrolysis, J. Phys. Chem. C (2009) 113, 20097-20107
Catalysis Center for Energy Innovation
Cellulose Pyrolysis ChemistryCellulose Pyrolysis Chemistry
G. Huber/UMass
OO
OHHOO
HO
O
OHHOO
HO
OHO OH
O
OH
Anhydro oligosaccharidesO
OH
Cellulose
O
n
Anhydro-oligosaccharidesn = 0: Cellobiosan (DP2)n = 1: Cellotriosan (DP3)....n = 7: Septaosan (DP7)
O
OH
OHOO
OHOH
OH
OO
HOOH
OH
HO
O
O
OH
O
O
HOOH
O
HOOO OH
OHHO
LGA
AGF
H2O
2H2O
Rearrangement
O
O
O LGO
DGP
dehydrationfragmentationand retro-aldol
CO, CO2, H2O
H2O 2H2O
Cellulose pyrolysis to anhydro-O
OO
OHO
HO OH
O
HO O
OH
OHOHO
O
dehydration
CO, CO2, H2O
py y ysugarsComplicated gas chemistryCoke can form from gas reactions
www.efrc.udel.eduwww.efrc.udel.edu
CharCoke can form from gas reactions
Lin et al., Kinetics and Mechanism of Cellulose Pyrolysis, J. Phys. Chem. C (2009) 113, 20097-20107
Catalysis Center for Energy Innovation
Gasoline Range AromaticsGasoline Range Aromatics
G. Huber/UMass
45
50
Glucose C ll bi
• Octane number of aromatics is 110
30
35
40
y (%
)
CellobioseCelluloseXylitol
• Aromatics can be blended at 25% level in gasoline
15
20
25
Sel
ectiv
ity
• Aromatics can be hydrogenated to other fuels
0
5
10other fuels
• BTX is more valuable than
li0Benzene Toluene Xylenes, Ethyl-
benzeneMethyl-ethyl-
benzene,trimethyl-benzene
Indanes Napthalenesgasoline
www.efrc.udel.eduwww.efrc.udel.edu
Catalysis Center for Energy Innovation
Reaction MechanismReaction Mechanism
G. Huber/UMass
Reaction MechanismReaction MechanismCoke
OHO
OH
O
HO
O
OH OO
H2O CO, CO2, H2O
OH
OH
O
OH
OHO
HO O
OHO
cellulose
Pyrolysis acid catalyzeddehydration
anhydro sugarsDehydratedProducts
OH
OH
OO
H
acid catalyzedoligimerization,decarboxylation,decarbonilation
AromaticsHydrocarbonPool
Desired Chemistry:Pyrolysis (homogeneous)Dehydration (heterogeneous & homogeneous)Oligomerization & decarbonylation (heterogeneous)
Undesired Chemistry:
Olef ins
www.efrc.udel.eduwww.efrc.udel.edu
Undesired Chemistry:Homogeneous and Heterogeneous coke formation
Catalysis Center for Energy Innovation
Effect of Heating Rate on Catalytic Fast Effect of Heating Rate on Catalytic Fast
G. Huber/UMass
Effect of Heating Rate on Catalytic Fast Effect of Heating Rate on Catalytic Fast PyrolysisPyrolysis
40
45Aromatics Carbon monoxideCarbon dioxide coke
25
30
35
ield
(%)
15
20
Car
bon
yi
0
5
10
Reaction Conditions: Temperature 600oC; ZSM-5; F d Gl C t l t t F d R ti 19
01 10 100 1000
Nominal heating rate (°C s-1)
www.efrc.udel.eduwww.efrc.udel.edu
Feed: Glucose; Catalyst to Feed Ratio 19C6O6H12 → 12/22 C7H8 (63 % Yield) + 48/22 CO (36 % Yield) + 84/22 H2O
Catalysis Center for Energy Innovation
Catalytic Partial Oxidation (CPOX)
Fuel and O2 enter at the top
y ( )
Valuable chemicals produced: syngas (H2 & CO), olefins, oxygenates, etc.
R t th llRuns auto-thermally
Short contact times Short contact times (Milliseconds)
www.efrc.udel.eduwww.efrc.udel.eduDauenhauer (UMass) and Schmidt (UMN)
Catalysis Center for Energy Innovation
CPOX of Cellulose
www.efrc.udel.eduwww.efrc.udel.edu3 mm
Dauenhauer (UMass) and Schmidt (UMN)
Catalysis Center for Energy Innovation
Catalytic Reforming of Cellulose
1200
y g
1000
T10
T
800
T30
T(oC)
400
600( )
No Carbon
Al t
200
400
0 6 0 7 0 8 0 9 1
Carbon
Always operate predicting no carbon
www.efrc.udel.eduwww.efrc.udel.edu
0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1C/O
P.J. Dauenhauer, B.J. Dreyer, N.J. Degenstein, L.D. Schmidt, Angewandte ChemieDauenhauer (UMass) and Schmidt (UMN)
Catalysis Center for Energy Innovation
Catalytic Reforming of Cellulosey g
Produce equilibrium qsynthesis gas
Higher C/O = more H2 + CO
Less than 1% methane
At C/O < 1.0, no oxygenates
www.efrc.udel.eduwww.efrc.udel.eduP.J. Dauenhauer, B.J. Dreyer, N.J. Degenstein, L.D. Schmidt, Angewandte ChemieDauenhauer (UMass) and Schmidt (UMN)
Catalysis Center for Energy Innovation
Comparison of CPOX to Gasificationp
Faster – 10 to 100XPossibly smaller (portable); Faster more flexible start up• Possibly smaller (portable); Faster, more flexible start-up
Cleaner – Catalyst breaks down volatile organics• Possibly eliminates downstream clean up stages• Possibly eliminates downstream clean-up stages
Provides WGS capabilities• Can add steam to adjust H2/CO ratio for desired outputCan add steam to adjust H2/CO ratio for desired output• Possibly eliminates separate shift stage
Remaining IssuesRemaining Issues• Ash handling• Mechanism / Modeling
www.efrc.udel.eduwww.efrc.udel.edu
g• Bio-oill upgrade
Dauenhauer (UMass) and Schmidt (UMN)