Common borders. Common solutions.
Black Sea Basin ENPI CBC Programme 2007-2013
Tulcea, 17 September, Hotel Delta
Agenda
TIME EVENT/FACILITATOR/
TRAINER OBJECTIVE / CONTENT
10.00-10.10
Introduction
Facilitators
JMA
Ecosfera
Welcoming remarks
Outline and schedule of the event
10.10-10.25
Session 1
Guidelines for Grant Applicants
Facilitator
JMA
Objectives
To introduce the format of the Guidelines for Grant Applicants and what potential applicants/partners need to do to apply for projects under the open Call for Proposals
Content
Presentation of the format of the Guidelines for Grant Applicants for the current call
Expected outputs/outcomes
Awareness of the expected content of the Guidelines for Grant Applicants
An understanding of CBC projects
10.25-
10.40
Session 2
Grant Application Form
(Annex A)
Facilitator
JMA
Objectives
To make the participants familiar with the structure of the Grant Application Form
Content
Presentation of the format of the Grant Application Form and the connection to upcoming sessions
Expected outputs/outcomes
Awareness of the Grant Application Form and understanding of its structure and logic
10.40-
11.10
Questions and Answers
Content
Questions and Answers
11.10-
11.30
Coffee break
11.30-13.00
Session 3
Developing project proposals
(Annex C)
Facilitator
Ecosfera
Introduction of participants
Expectations
Objectives
To clarify the key components of a project and how they should be presented on the application form including the Logical Framework and Groups of Activities
An understanding of the benefits of using the Logical Framework and Group of Activities in planning, implementing and evaluating projects
Common borders. Common solutions.
TIME EVENT/FACILITATOR/
TRAINER OBJECTIVE / CONTENT
Content Description of the main components of a project outline, including:
overall objective, specific objectives, expected results, activities,
means, assumptions and risks
Development of a Logical Framework and Group of Activities as tools for project preparation, project implementation, monitoring and evaluation
Expected outputs/outcomes
An understanding of the links between activities and specific project objectives and overall objective
An understanding of the difference between specific project objectives and its overall objective i.e. the relevance of the project
An understanding of the logic of project intervention
Completed Logical Framework with objectives, activities, results and assumptions
Completed Group of Activities
13.00-14.00
Lunch
14.00-14.30
Continuation of the previous session
14.30-16.00
Session 4
Preparing the project budget
(Annex B)
Facilitator
Ecosfera
Objectives
To help participants understand what are eligible costs, the required budget lines and their correlation with activities
Content
The rules for separate budget lines
How to develop a project budget starting from the budget based on activities
Expected outputs/outcomes
An understanding of:
o the separate budget lines
o how to develop a budget starting from planned activities
o eligible and non-eligible costs
Completed Budget
16.00-16.30
Conclusion
Facilitators
JMA
Ecosfera
Content
Questions and Answers
Conclusions - Summary of what was covered
Evaluation of the workshop
Closing remarks
1Application packageApplication package
Guidelines for Grant Applicants Guidelines for Grant Applicants 1/31/3
Sets out the rules for this Call for Proposals
Documents to fill in:
Annex A: Grant Application Form (Word format)
Annex B: Budget (Excel format)
Annex C: Logical Framework (Excel format)
Annex D: Legal Entity Sheet (pdf format)
Annex E*: Financial Identification Form (pdf format)
Documents for information:
Annex F*: Standard Grant Contract
Annex G: Eligibility of Expenditure
Annex H*: Standard Contribution Agreement
Annex I*: Partnership Agreement
Guidelines for Grant Applicants Guidelines for Grant Applicants 2/32/3
2Eligibility of applicants and partners Eligibility of applicants and partners 1/21/2
represent one of the following legal entities:
a. national, regional or local public authority;
b. body governed by public law;
c. association formed by one or several national, regional or local
public authorities or one or several bodies governed by public
law, as defined under paragraphs a-b
d. other non-profit organisation, other than legal entities
defined under paragraph c;
e. public undertaking operating in the water, energy and transport services sectors
be directly responsible for the preparation and management of the action with their partners, not acting as an intermediary and
be located in the eligible area of the programme or
be organizations whose headquarters are registered and located outside the programme area in actions implemented in the eligible area - but in one of the ten participating countries conditions:
have local/regional subsidiary/branch offices established in the eligible area:
i. in case of a subsidiary (legal personality) - subsidiary shall be Applicant;
ii. in case of a branch (without legal personality) - central organization shall be Applicant;
have no local/regional subsidiary/branch offices established in the eligible area, but:
are located at central/national/regional level,
have exclusive competences in a field of activity and/or geographical area and
demonstrate that their areas of legal competences established by legal acts extend to the eligible area of the programme and
the proposed Action is for the full benefit of the eligible area of the programme.
Eligibility of applicants and partners Eligibility of applicants and partners 2/22/2
public administrations and their institutions
decentralised and/or local governmental public services
development agencies
public undertakings
chambers of commerce
agricultural, forestry and fishery authorities
tourism public authorities
urban and rural development institutions
ports, rails and roads management authorities
operators and service providers on electronic communication
Potential applicants and partnersPotential applicants and partners environmental protection
agencies and similar institutions
waste, water and wastewater management bodies
natural protected areas and reservations administrations
emergency situations institutions
protection against floods bodies
cultural institutions and operators
educational institutions,
research and training institutions
NGOs
Euroregions
3Eligibility of partnershipsEligibility of partnerships
one or several partners from EU Member States (BG, GR, RO) and
one or several partners from Partner Countries (AM, AZ, GE, MD, RU, UA) and/or
Turkey.
For Turkey - at least one partner from a MS and one partner from a PC.
Recommended number of partners - between 3 and 10 partners.
Priority to projects involving min. 3 partners from min. 3 different countries.
ResponsibilitiesResponsibilities 1/3
Beneficiary (Lead Partner): Applicant;
Signs a Partnership Agreement with each partner - laying down arrangements for their relations - as a prior condition for concluding the Grant Contract with JMA;
Signs the Grant Contract with JMA;
Ensures coordination of the implementation of the Action;
Transfers the ENPI contribution to project partners;
Claims the reimbursement of expenses from JMA and transfer thesereimbursements to the partners;
Ensures that the expenditure presented by project partners has been paid for the purpose of implementing the operation and corresponds to the activities agreed between the partners;
Ensures the sound financial management of the whole project; it shall contract auditors or use the designated controllers for the verification of expenditure in accordance with programme procedures (PRAG);
Organizes the recovery of amounts unduly spent;
Provides the JMA with all data relevant for monitoring indicators;
Records and store project documents.
ResponsibilitiesResponsibilities 2/3
Participation of Turkish partner (s) Turkish partners shall appoint an IPA Financial Lead Beneficiary (IPA FLB) among themselves
IPA FLB shall cooperate closely with the ENPI
Beneficiary for a successful implementation of the
joint project and with the aim of ensuring single
operational reporting of the project
ENPI Grant Contract
ENPI Beneficiary JMA
IPA FLB CFCU in Turkey
IPA Grant Contract
4IPA LeadBeneficiary
ENPI Beneficiary
ENPI Partner 1
IPA partner 1
ENPIPartner 2
JMA
IPA partner 1
CFCU
JMC
EC Delegation
ResponsibilitiesResponsibilities 3/3
Partners: Sign a Partnership Agreement with the Applicant as a prior
condition for concluding the Grant Contract with JMA;
Ensure the implementation of the project activities under their responsibility;
Cooperate with the partners in the implementation of the project, reporting and monitoring;
Provide financial and progress reports to the auditors/controllers for the verification of expenditure per each of the reporting periods and ensure full cooperation and assistance for the timely and accurate performance of verification;
Assume responsibility in the event of any irregularity in the expenditure they have declared and repay the Beneficiary the amounts unduly received.
Who else may be involved in Who else may be involved in
implementing the projectimplementing the project
Associates Do not meet the eligibility criteria
Should be mentioned in the application form
May not receive funding (except per diem and travel)
May play a real role in the action
Subcontractors For works, supplies, services
Should not be mentioned in the application form (tendering procedure)
5BeneficiaryBeneficiary capacitycapacity
Beneficiary should have:
Appropriate project management experience
and track record
Sufficient financial capacity
Appropriate human resources
Able to ensure that results are sustained and
project records are kept
Capacity of partnersCapacity of partners
Partners should be able to:
Receive and and properly use funds
Finance activities
Implement the required activities
Provide required reports and keep required
documentation
Tools for building partnershipsTools for building partnerships
"Finding Partners" tools on RCBIs website onwww.rcbi.info Find partners in the Partner Countries
Find Partners in EU Member States and Turkey
Register to be included in the Partner Countries database
"Partner Search" tool on www.blacksea-cbc.net Search for partners in all participating countries
Register to be included in the database
by country, by Priority and by Measure
Submitting project ideas on www.blacksea-cbc.net only those project ideas explicitly mentioned as to be
published will be posted in order to facilitate partnerships
6Eligible actionsEligible actions
Types of actions (projects): Integrated projects with different activities in several countries that
jointly achieve a certain objective having a cross-border impact;
Symmetrical projects with the similar activities in all countries participating in the project;
Projects implemented mainly or entirely in a single participating-country but having a cross-border impact.
Priority - integrated projects.
Only 10% available for projects implemented mainly or entirely in a single participating-country, but having a cross-border impact.
Cross-border impact: Joint development Joint implementation
Joint staffing
Joint financing
Minimum requirement: 2 conditions out of 4.
Indicative activities (1/3)Priority 1 Support to the promotion of traditional products from Black Sea agriculture
on the international market;
Development of cooperation networks aimed at promoting the use of information and communication technologies in local/regional economic initiatives;
Pre-feasibility studies for small-scale transport infrastructures for a better integration of less developed areas and tourist destinations in the Basin;
Common initiatives for promoting transit transportation infrastructures in the region aimed at increasing freight and passenger transportation efficiency.
Creation of cross-border tourism products and common service standards(thematic routes, quality systems etc).
Training for staff of local bodies and institutions supporting SMEs, especially for the improvement of capacity to operate in interregional initiatives (e.g. marketing plans, product development and small business management);
Networks for the promotion of innovative urban and rural planning and management methodologies for urban development and rehabilitation;
Establishment of a Black Sea Basin network for capacity building for local and regional administrators through the exchange of good practices and innovations for local development.
Priority 2 Establishment or strengthening of networks for the development in
partnership of methodologies and capabilities of the responsible rescue authorities in view of the response to oil spills on the coastal area and the mitigation of marine pollution;
Support to the development in partnership of contingency plans in order to ensure the ability of the Black Sea coastal authorities to respond to pollution;
Preparation/promotion or implementation of scientific studies in the fields of monitoring, control and protection of the maritime system and of rivers in the area.
Development of concepts for coordination and cooperation in case of natural or man-made disasters
The establishment or strengthening of networks for joint development of planning and management methodologies and the creation of databases for the natural protected areas of the Black Sea Basin;
Support to information and educational activities, including awareness-raising campaigns, in the field of wastewater and solid waste management, water saving and waste recycling;
Partnerships for innovation in waste management in regions with significant seasonal tourism flows that are concentrated in particular areas;
Partnerships of authorities for the exchange of good practices and governance tools in the sectors of solid waste and wastewater management- based on EU approaches.
Indicative activities (2/3)
7Priority 3 Establishment of partnerships for the promotion of cultural heritage
values;
Establishing networks of cultural institutions in the Black Sea Basin for strengthening regional identity;
The creation of networks of cultural centres, sharing cultural values from all regions
The establishment of partnerships for the exchange of experiences with traditional popular culture through the promotion of common cultural events in the Black Sea Basin.
Partnerships for the exchange of students and academics for the establishment of channels of cultural integration in the Black Sea Basin;
Partnerships among universities, high schools and research centresaimed at the design and development of special educational programmesbased on topics of common interest in the Black Sea Basin;
Networks for the exchange of experience in adapting education and vocational training systems to the needs of a market economy, based on common approaches.
Indicative activities (3/3)
Number of Number of
applications and grants per Applicantapplications and grants per Applicant
An Applicant may submit more than one application under this
Call for Proposals.
An Applicant may not be awarded more than three grants under
this Call for Proposals, one grant per each priority.
An Applicant may at the same time be partner in another
application.
Partners may take part in more than one application
Eligibility of costsEligibility of costs
Eligible direct costs
Contingency reserve (max 2%)
Eligible indirect costs (max 7% flat-rate)
Contributions in kind - not eligible
Ineligible costs
Annex G: Eligibility of expenditure
8Annexes and supporting documentsAnnexes and supporting documents
Applicant / IPA FLB:
1. Declaration by the Applicant (in Annex A)
2. Legal Entity Sheet (Annex D)3. Financial Iden. Form (Annex E)4. Statutes or Art. of Association5. Registration Acts6. Latest accounts7. External Audit Report8. Certification9. Ad-hoc declaration
Partner:
1. Partnership Statement
(in Annex A)
2. Legal Entity Sheet (Annex D)
4. Statutes or Art. of Association
5. Registration Acts
6. Latest accounts
7. Certification
8. Ad-hoc declaration
Supporting documentsSupporting documents Statutes or Articles of Association
all partners unofficial translations of relevant parts proving their eligibility not applying to public authorities
Registration Acts all partners unofficial translations of extracts from national Registers of organizations not applying to public authorities
Latest accounts all partners for the last financial year full unofficial translation not applying to public authorities
External Audit Report Applicant and IPA FLB where the grant requested exceeds EUR 500,000 for the last financial year full unofficial translation not applying to public authorities and bodies governed by public law
Certification proving payment of debts* all partners full unofficial translation before contract signature
Ad-hoc declaration international organizations
Where and how Where and how
to send the applicationsto send the applications
One original and 3 copies (A4 size) Also in electronic format (CD-Rom) in a unique file (pdf) In a sealed envelope by registered mail, private courier service
or by hand-delivery
Postal address Ministry of Regional Development and HousingGeneral Directorate for European Territorial CooperationDirectorate for International Territorial CooperationBulevardul Libertatii nr. 12, 040129 Bucuresti, sector 5, Romania
9Useful informationUseful information
Contact person:
Ms. Sorina Canea, Programme Manager
Directorate for International Territorial Cooperation
Ministry of Regional Development and Housing
www.blacksea-cbc.net
1Grant Application FormGrant Application Form(Annex A)(Annex A)
Grant Application FormGrant Application Form
I. The Action Description of the Action
Budget for the Action
Experience of similar actionsII. Applicant
III. IPA FLB
IV. Partners of the ApplicantV. Associates
VI. ChecklistVII. Declaration by the Aplicant
VIII. Declaration by the IPA FLB
IX. Indicators of the programme
I.I. The Action The Action 1/5
1. DESCRIPTION OF THE ACTION
1.1. Title of the Action and acronym1.2. Locations of the Action
1.3. Priority and Measure concerned
1.4. Type of Action Type of project
Criteria
1.5. Cost of the Action and amount requested from JMA
,% (cannot be more than 90%)
,% (cannot be more than 90%)
ENPI funds: EUR ......
IPA partners: EUR ......
Total grant: EUR ......
ENPI partners: EUR .....
IPA partners: EUR ......
Total funds: EUR ......
% of JMA co-financing / total eligible cost of the Action
(B/Ax100)
Amount requested
from JMA (B)
Total eligible cost of the Action
(A)
2I.I. The Action The Action 2/5
1.6. Summary
1.7. Objectives
1.8. Relevance of the Action Problems and their interrelations
Target groups and final beneficiaries
Specific problems and perceived needs and constraints of target groups
Relevance to needs and constrains and how it will provide desired
solutions
Relevance to the chosen objective and priority
Demonstrate type of the project
Demonstrate direct cross-border impact
Integration of Community horizontal policies
Links to policies and initiatives in the region
Complementarity and synergies with other actions and avoidance of
duplication
Building on results
I.I. The Action The Action 3/5
1.9. Description of the Action and its effectiveness
Expected outputs and results
Proposed activities and their effectiveness:
Group of Activities 1
Group of Activities 2
Group of Activities 3 Visibility of the Action
Group of Activities 4 Management and coordination of the
Action
I.I. The Action The Action 4/5
1.10. Methodology Method of implementation and reasons
Partners level of involvement and participation and reasons
Organisational structure and team
Main means
Justification for participation of partners outside the programme area
Attitudes of stakeholders and how it shall address them
Procedures for follow-up and evaluation
1.11. Duration and indicative action plan for implementing the Action
3I.I. The Action The Action 5/5
1.12. Sustainability Main preconditions and assumptions
Risk analysis and possible contingency plans
Secured sustainability:
Financial sustainability
Institutional level
Policy level
Environmental sustainability
Springboard or multiplier effects
1.13. Logical framework (Annex C)
2. BUDGET FOR THE ACTION (Annex B)
3. EXPERIENCE OF SIMILAR ACTIONS
II.II. Applicant / Applicant / III.III. IPA FLBIPA FLB
1. Identity2. Profile legal status
3. Capacity to manage and implement actions
3.1. Experience in project management
3.2. Resources
3.2.1. Financial data
3.2.2. Financing sources
3.2.3. Number of staff
IV.IV. PartnersPartners
1. Description2. Partnership StatementPartner/IPA FLB:
Legal status
Acceptance of obligations
Sufficient capacity
Partnership Agreement before Grant Contract
Statement of financial commitment
V.V. AssociatesAssociates
1. Description
4VII.VII. Declaration by ApplicantDeclaration by ApplicantLegal status
Sources of financing and professional competence
Bank account for the Action
Acceptance of obligations foreseen in Partnership Statement
Acceptance of contractual conditions
VIII.VIII. Declaration by IPA FLBDeclaration by IPA FLBLegal status
Sources of financing and professional competence
Acceptance of obligations foreseen in Partnership Statement
Acceptance of contractual conditions
IX.IX. Indicators of the programmeIndicators of the programme
Output indicators
Result indicators
VI.VI. ChecklistChecklist
Administrative
Eligibility
Evaluation and selectionEvaluation and selection
STEP 1: ADMINISTRATIVE CHECK
Submission deadline has been respected
Grant Application Form satisfies all the criteria specified in the
Checklist
STEP 2: VERIFICATION OF ELIGIBILITY Declaration by the Applicant cross-checked with the annexes and
supporting documents;
Eligibility of Applicant, partners and Action verified according to
criteria
STEP 3: EVALUATION
Selection criteria
Award criteria
Additional criteria
5Evaluation and selectionEvaluation and selection
STEP 1: ADMINISTRATIVE CHECK done by the JMA, JTS
STEP 2: VERIFICATION OF ELIGIBILITY- done by the JMA, JTS
STEP 3: EVALUATION3.1 independent experts (assessors)- 2 experts per application
3.2 Selection Committee- Chair: JMA- non voting member- Secretary: JTS- non voting member
- 5 voting members - nominated by JMC- observers- nominated by JMC, EC
List of proposed applications for selection
JMC decision on selected applications
65100Maximum total score
-56. Priority for the programme
Additional criteria
-105. Budget and cost-effectiveness
-154. Sustainability
-253. Methodology
20252. Relevance
Award criteria
12201. Technical, financial and operational capacity of the
partnership
Selection criteria
Minimum
score
Maximum
scoreSection
Evaluation GridEvaluation Grid-- for step 3for step 3
Other annexes Other annexes 1/31/3
Documents to fill in:
Annex B: Budget (Excel format)
Annex C: Logical Framework (Excel format)
Annex D: Legal Entity Sheet (pdf format)
Annex E*: Financial Identification Form (pdf format)
6Documents for information (1/2):
Annex F*: Standard Grant Contract
Annex I: Description of the Action
Annex II: General Conditions
Annex III: Budget for the Action
Annex IV: Contract-award procedures
Annex V: Standard request for payment and financial identification form
Annex VI: Model narrative (progress) and financial report
Annex VII: Model report of factual findings and ToRs for expenditure verification
Model report of factual findings and ToRs for a consolidated expenditure verification
[Annex VIII: Model financial guarantee]
Other annexesOther annexes 2/32/3
Documents for information (2/2):
Annex G: Eligibility of ExpenditureHuman resources
Travel
Equipment and supplies
Offices
Subcontracted services
Other
Contingency reserve (max 2%)
Administrative costs (max 7% flat rate)
Annex H*: Standard Contribution Agreement (IO)
Annex I*: Partnership Agreement
PA between ENPI Beneficiary and ENPI Partner
PA between ENPI Beneficiary and IPA FLB
Other annexesOther annexes 3/33/3
Useful informationUseful information
Contact person:
Ms. Sorina Canea, Programme Manager
Directorate for International Territorial Cooperation
Ministry of Regional Development and Housing
www.blacksea-cbc.net
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
1
Joint Operational ProgrammeBlack Sea 2007-2013
Logical Framework(Annex C)
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
2
Definition
Main tool used in planning a project, that helps the creation of an intervention logic between activities, results, specific and general objective
Allow to: Ask questions (who, when, how, how much) Identify the weaknesses Take the right decisions on time
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
3
Structure 4 rows and 4 columns
Vertical logic Identifies what project want to do Clarifies cause effect relation Specifies the presumptions and risks
Horizontal logic Helps measuring the effects obtained therough the indicators
(by using means and resources)
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
4
Filing in
GENERAL OBJECTIVE
VERIFICATION SOURCEINDICATORS
ASSUMPTIONSPECIFIC
OBJECTIVEVERIFICATION
SOURCEINDICATORS
ASSUMPTIONRESULTSVERIFICATION
SOURCE
ASSUMPTIONVERIFICATION
SOURCEMEANS
1
2
3
1110
98
5
13 6
7
ACTIVITIES4
INDICATORS12
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
5
Intervention logicIF THEN relationship
IF resources are provided, THEN activities can be undertaken;
IF activities are undertaken, THEN results can be produced,
IF results are produced, THEN specific objective will be obtained;
IF the specific objective is achieved, THEN this will contribute to the general objective
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
6
Hypothesis
GENERAL OBJECTIVEGENERAL OBJECTIVE
SPECIFIC OBJECTIVESSPECIFIC OBJECTIVES
RESULTSRESULTS
ACTIVITIESACTIVITIES
ASSUMTIONSASSUMTIONS
ASSUMTIONSASSUMTIONS
ASSUMTIONSASSUMTIONS
+
+
+
Relationship
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
7
Indicators
Describe the general objective, specific objective (s) and results according to: Quantity (100 teachers teach in the high
school) Quality (100 teachers teach in the high
school geography) Time (100 teachers teach in the high school
geography starting with 15 September 2006)
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
8
Role of Indicators
They answer to: How we will measure the contribution in
order to reach the general objective
How we will know that the specific objectives (aims) were fulfilled
How we will know that results were achieved
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
9
Types of Indicators
Output indicators (of achievement the activities) Result indicators Impact indicators
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
10
Output Indicators
Relate to activity. They are often measured in physical or monetary units (e.g. number of km of a road built, number of firms having received financial support, number of training places provided etc.)
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
11
Result Indicators
Rpresent the direct and immediate effectsgenerated by a programme.
They provide information on the changes that affect the behavior (or performance) of direct beneficiaries.
These indicators may also be of a physical (reduction in journey time, number of successful trainees, number of roads accidents, etc.) or financial nature (induced investment by the private sector, decrease in transportation cost etc.).
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
12
Impact Indicators
Represent the consequences of the programme beyond the immediate effects on its direct beneficiaries.
Two notions of impact may be defined, depending on whether these are effects occurring after a certain lapse of time (specificimpacts) but are directly linked to the action taken, or longer- term effects affecting a larger population (global impacts).
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
13
An indicator should be SMART Specific to the objective it is supposed to
measure Measurable (either quantitatively or qualitatively) Available at an acceptable cost Relevant to the information needs of managers Time- bound so we know when we can expect
the objective/target to be achieved
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
14
Sources of Verification
Respond to: HOW should information be collected; WHO collects and provides information WHEN and HOW OFTEN information have to
be collected SoV will be specified with the indicators
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
15
Mistakes
To be avoided: Is the specific objective a CONSEQUENCE of
the results and not merely a SUM of results? Are results DIFFERENT from activities? Are specific objectives DIFFERENT from
results or activities? Are there RELEVANT assumptions set?
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
1
Joint Operational ProgrammeBlack Sea 2007-2013
Budget(Annex B)
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
2
Compulsory components of the Budget
sheet 1- Overall Budget sheet 2- Distribution per partners sheet 3- Distribution per activities sheet 4- Sources of funding
Buget (xls) Justification made in the grant application form
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
3
General rules
Budget should cover ALL eligible project costs, not just programme contribution
UE funds cover a certain percentage of the total eligible costs and NOT a part of the action
Budget should be realistic and cost-effective Actual costs should be supported by documentation
(except for administrative costs - 7% flat rate) Project and implementing organisations cannot make a
profit! Budget is set up in Euro Budget is an annex to the contract
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Eligible direct costs
Only costs necessary for project implementation, and actually incurred during implementation
1. Human resources
2. Travel3. Equipment and supplies4. Offices5. Subcontracted services6. Other
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Ineligible costs Contribution in kind Debts and provisions for losses or debts Interest owed Items already financed in another framework Purchases of land or buildings (with exceptions) Currency exchange losses Taxes, including recoverable VAT Credits (loans) to third parties Fines and penalties
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
How to prepare the project budget?
Take a look at your list of activities Develop your own separate excel sheet with a
preliminary budget for each activity i.e. all costs, for each partner, of the preparation and implementation of the activity
Enter the data from the preliminary budget into the Budget (Annex B)
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
7
Overall budget 1
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
8
Overall budget 22. Travel7
2.1 Travel Per travel 0,00
2.2 Per diem8 Per day 0,00
2.3 Other travel expenditures Per day 0,00
Subtotal Travel 0,00
3. Equipment and supplies9
3.1 Purchase of vehicles Per vehicle 0,00
3.2 Rent of vehicles Per month 0,00
3.3 Computer hardware/software Per item 0,00
3.4 Machines, tools, spare parts/equipment (please specify) Per item 0,00
3.5 Other (please specify) - please add as many rows as you need
0,00
Subtotal Equipment and supplies 0,00
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
9
Overall budget 34. Offices10
4.1 Vehicle costs Per month 0,00
4.2 Office rent Per month 0,00
4.3 Furniture and office supplies Per month 0,00
4.4 Other services (tel/fax, electricity/heating, maintenance)
Per month 0,00
Subtotal Offices 0,00
5. Subcontracted services11
5.1 External experts (please specify) - please add as many rows as you need
Per expert 0,00
5.2 Publications, study, research Per publication 0,00
5.3 Costs for expenditure verification12 Per service 0,00
5.4 Evaluation costs Per service 0,00
5.5 Translation, interpreters Per page/Per day 0,00
5.6 Financial services (bank guarantee costs etc.) Per service 0,00
5.7 Costs of conferences/seminars Per seminar 0,00
5.8 Visibility actions13 Per action 0,00
5.9 Other (please specify) - please add as many rows as you need
0,00
Subtotal Subcontracted services 0,00
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
10
Overall budget 46. Other
(please specify) 0,00
(please specify) - please add as many rows as you need ` 0,00
Subtotal Other 0,00
7. Subtotal direct eligible costs of the Action (1-6) 0,00
8. Provision for contingency reserve (maximum 2% of 7.Subtotal direct
eligible costs of the Action)14 0,00
9. Total direct eligible costs of the Action (7+8) 0,00
10. Administrative costs (maximum 7% of 9. Total direct eligible costs
of the Action)15 0,00
11. Total eligible costs (9+10) 0,00
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Distribution per Partners
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
11
TOTAL
Applicant/ /IPA
Financial LB
Partner 1 Partner 2 Partner 317 %
1. Human resources 0,00
2. Travel 0,00
3. Equipment and supplies 0,00
4. Offices 0,00
5. Subcontracted services 0,00
6. Other 0,00
7. SUBTOTAL DIRECT ELIGIBLE COSTS (1-6)
0,00 0,00 0,00 0,00 0,00
8. Provision for contingency reserve (maximum 2% of 7. Subtotal direct eligible costs of the Action)
0,00
9. TOTAL DIRECT ELIGIBLE COSTS (7+8)
0,00 0,00 0,00 0,00 0,00
10. Administrative costs (maximum 7% of 9. Total direct eligible costs of the Action)
0,00
11. TOTAL ELIGIBLE COSTS (9+10)
0,00 0,00 0,00 0,00 0,00
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Distribution per activities
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
12
Annex B. Table 3 - Budget - Expected distribution per Group of Activities, partners18 and cost categories
Partners 1 2 3 4 5. 6. 7. 8. 9 10. 11.
GA 1
Applicant/IPA Fin LB 0,00
Partner 1 0,00
Partner 2 0,00
Partner 319 0,00
GA 1 TOTAL 0,00
GA 2
Applicant/IPA Fin LB 0,00
Partner 1 0,00
Partner 2 0,00
Partner 319 0,00
GA 2 TOTAL 0,00
GA 3
Applicant/IPA Fin LB 0,00
Partner 1 0,00
Partner 2 0,00
Partner 319 0,00
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
13
Annex B. Budget for the Action1Expenses Unit # of units
1. Human Resources1.1 Salaries (gross amounts, local staff)4 1.1.1 Technical 0
Project co-ordinator Per month 10 1000 10 000Training manager Per month 9 800 7 200Lecturers (3 people X 6 months full time) Per month 18 1200 21 600
1.1.2 Administrative/ support staffProject secretary (10 months X 50% of the time) Per month 5 500 2 500
1.2 Salaries (gross amounts, expat/int. staff) 01.3 Per diems for missions/travel5 1.3.1 Abroad (staff assigned to the Action) Per diem 0 1.3.2 Local (staff assigned to the Action) Per diem 0 1.3.3 Seminar/conference participants Per diem 0
Stipend (100 days X 90 participants) Per day 900 8 7 200Subtotal Human Resources 41 300
2. Travel62.1. International travel Per flight2.2 Local transportation Local travel in the project area Per month 10 200 2 000Subtotal Travel 0
3. Equipment and supplies73.1 Purchase or rent of vehicles Per vehicle 03.2 Furniture, computer equipment 0Computers unit 15 1300 19 5003.3 Spare parts/equipment for machines, tools 03.4 Other (please specify) 0Subtotal Equipment and supplies 19 500
4. Local office/Action costs84.1 Vehicle costs Per month 04.2 Office rent Per month 04.3 Consumables - office supplies Per month 04.4 Other services (tel/fax, electricity/heating, maintenance) Per month 0Subtotal Local office/Action costs 0
5. Other costs, services9
5.1 Publications10 05.2 Studies, research10 05.3 Auditing costs 05.4 Evaluation costs 05.5 Translation, interpreters 05.6 Financial services (bank guarantee costs etc.) 05.7 Costs of conferences/seminars10 05.8 Visibility actionsSubtotal Other costs, services 0
6. Other 0Subtotal Other 0
7. Subtotal direct costs of the Action (1-6) 60 8008. Administrative costs (maximum 7% of 7, total direct eligible costs of the Action) 4 2569. Total eligible costs of the Action (7+ 8) 65 056
Costs (in EUR)3
Unit rate (in EUR)
Budget for the action
What are the project costs?
Sources of funding
Expected sources of funding Amount PercentageEUR of total
%
Applicant's financial contribution 5 000 7.69%
Commission contribution sought in this application 56 000 86.08%
Contributions from other organisations:Name ConditionsTraining association 4 056 6.23%
TOTAL CONTRIBUTIONS
Direct revenue from the ActionOVERALL TOTAL 65 056 100.00%
Contribution(s) from other European Institutions or EU Member StatesWho cover the
costs?
Totals must be
equal!
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
14
1. Human resourcesCategories:
Technical staff responsible with the main activities of the projectproject manager, experts nedeed for specific activities
Administrative / support staff hepls the technical staff in implementing the project secretary, accountant, etc
If staff is not working full time, percentage will be provided Staff salaries must be almost equal with those currently applied by
the beneficiary and partners Salaries include statutory deductions Check (National Authorities) whether salaries for civil servants are
eligible costs: If civil servants salaries are eligible, they should be included here If civil servants salaries are not eligible, you may include them as your
co-financing
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
15
Unit No. of units
Unit rate(Euro)
Cost (Euro)
1. Human resources
1.1 Technical staff
Senior marketing expert (50% of the time) Per month
4 900 3600
Junior marketing expert (50% of the time) Per month
8 450 3600
Experts in the field Per month
8 700 5600
1.2 Administrative and support staffTechnical assistant Per
month8 500 4000
1. Human resources
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Travel per travelPer diem - per day Cover accommodation, meals, local travel and
miscellaneous Are calculated Must not exceed the rates published by the European
Commission at the time of signing the grant contract Be careful at national legislationOther travel expenditures - per day
2. Travel
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
10015Per day 1500ex. Study Tour in Bulgaria (5 people x 3 days)
2.2 Per diem
20004005Per travelex. Bucharest Thessaloniki (5 people round trip)
Unit rateNo. of units
Unit Costs 2.1 Travel
Subtotal Travel
Per day2.3 Other travel expenditures
2. Travel
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
18
3. Equipment and supplies
Purchase (new) or rental (new or used): Computers hardware / software Furniture, office equipment Vehicles Tools, spare parts etc.
Have to be justified, needed for the project implementation
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
19
4. Offices
Directly allocated for premises rented esspeciallyfor implementing the project
Vehicle costs Office rent Office supplies Other services (heating, electricity, maintenance,
etc)
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
20
5. Subcontracted services If there is no necessary expertise, external expertise
may be contracted - these costs should be included here(if the members of the team are directly employed -
work contract or similar - these costs should be included in Human resources budget line)
Organisations of meeting and events Information and publicity costs Expenditure verification costs Financial services
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
21
5.1 External experts
Unit No. of units
Unit rate(Euro)
Cost (Euro)
5. Subcontracted services
5.2 Publications, studies, researchTouristic guide Per copy 500 2 1000Field research Per interview 100 10 1000
5. Subcontracted services
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
22
6. Other costs
Will be specified Costs needed for the project but not included in
the previous headings
Costs according the national legislation
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
23
7. Subtotal direct eligible costs
Budget headings 1 6:
1. Human resources
2. Travel3. Equipment and supplies4. Offices5. Subcontracted services6. Other costs
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
24
8. Contingency reserve
Maxim 2% of subtotal direct eligible costs (heading 7)
May only be used with the prior writtenauthorisation of the Joint Managing Authority (for ENPI) and CFCU in Turkey (for IPA)
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
25
9. Total direct eligible costsBudget headings 1 8:
1. Human resources
2. Travel3. Equipment and supplies4. Offices5. Subcontracted services6. Other costs7. Subtotal direct eligible costs8. Contingency reserve
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
26
10. Administrative costsEligible indirect costs, overheads Incurred by the Beneficiary for the main office of the
project Maxim 7% of Total direct eligible costs (Heading 9)
Costs for renting and maintenance Postal / telephone services Heating, energy, water, electricity Other costs not included in the previous headings No documents needed, but method of calculation is
required
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
27
11. Total eligible costsBudget headings 1 10:
1. Human resources 2. Travel3. Equipment and supplies4. Offices5. Subcontracted services6. Other costs7. Subtotal direct eligible costs8. Contingency reserve9. Total direct eligible costs10. Administrative costs
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
28
Budget example
9. Total direct eligible costs
Expenses Costs1. Human Resources 603002. Travel 38003. Equipment and supplies 112504. Offices 05. Subcontractating services 63506. Other 40107. Subtotal direct eligible
costs 857108. Contingency (2%) 100
10. Administrative costs (7%) 428111. Total eligible costs 90091
Administrative costs must be no more than 7% of total direct costs
In this case less than5999,7 (85,710x0.07)
Contingency reservemustnot exceed 2% of subtotal direct costs
In this case less than1714,2 (85,710x0.02)
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Project financed under PHARE Economic and Social Cohesion sub-programme "Training at national and regional levels for enhancing the absorption capacity for the Operational Programmes managed by the Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing", Romania / RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
29
Frequently errors
Some activities are not budgeted (publications, transport)
Some compulsory activities are not budgeted (audit, project visibility, publicity etc.)
Some activities are budgeted under a wrong(sub)heading
Consultant:Consortium in cooperation with Ecosfera, Archidata and Informest
Amending the Budget
Budget can not be increased during the implementation period
Project Beneficiary may amend the budget during implementation: When transfer between items within the same main
heading (except contingency and administrative costs) When transfer between headings
RO2006/018-147.04.01.05.01
ETC / ROP Training Project
Black Sea
Exercise
Aim: 1. Developing project proposals: objectives, results, activities (Logical Framework and
Groups of Activities) 2. Preparing the projects Budget
Number of participants: 50
Division into groups: 10 groups x 5 participants
Allocated time: 120 min - for developing project proposals: objectives, results, activities (Logical Framework and Groups of Activities)
90 min - for preparing the projects Budget
Needed Materials:
- Guidelines for Grant Applicants - Grant Application Form (Annex A) - Budget template (Annex B) - Logical Framework (Annex C) - Eligibility of Expenditure (Annex G)
Method used:
Participants will be asked to form 10 groups of 5 participants. The 10 groups will be divided on the 3 Priorities of the programme (socio-economic, environment, people to people). It is anticipated that there will be 3 groups on Priority 1, 3 groups on Priority 2 and 4 groups on Priority 3). Accordingly, each group will be invited to:
fulfill the Logical Framework stating the general objective, specific objectives, results and activities of a proposed project;
group the activities in Groups of Activities.
Based on the proposed activities, participants will prepare the Budget of their project. Presentations, at least one project per PA, will be made by participants. Assistance will be given by facilitators from JMA and Ecosfera.
2009 Page 1 of 43 090610 Guidelines for Grant Applicants
Romanian Ministry of Regional Development and Housing Directorate for International Territorial Cooperation
Joint Managing Authority of the
Joint Operational Programme BLACK SEA 2007-2013
GUIDELINES FOR GRANT APPLICANTS
Reference: 1st Call for Proposals
Deadline for submission of proposals: 12th of October 2009
June 2009
2009 Page 2 of 43 090610 Guidelines for Grant Applicants
Notice
This is an open Call for Proposals, where all documents are submitted at one stage. Each application (Grant Application Form, requested annexes and supporting documents) will be evaluated by the Selection Committee. This Call for Proposals is launched under suspension clause linked to the signing of the Financing Agreements between the European Commission and participant countries.
The actual award and signature of contracts following this Call for Proposals is therefore conditional to the conclusion of the Financing Agreements before 31st of December 2009. The selected applications including (a) partner(s) from (a) country(ies) which had not signed the Financing Agreement(s) with EC within the above mentioned deadline will be rejected.
2009 Page 3 of 43 090610 Guidelines for Grant Applicants
Table of contents
GLOSARRY OF ACRONYMS.4
1. JOINT OPERATIONAL PROGRAMME "BLACK SEA 2007-2013" .......................... 5
1.1 Background.....................................................................................................................5
1.2 Legal framework............................................................................................................5
1.3 Objectives of the programme and priority issues....................................................................6
1.4 Financial allocation provided by the Joint Managing Authority ................................................ 10
2. RULES FOR THIS CALL FOR PROPOSALS ................................................ 12
2.1 Eligibility criteria ........................................................................................................... 12 2.1.1 Eligibility of Applicants and partners: who may apply .................................................. 12 2.1.2 Eligibility of partnerships..................................................................................... 19 2.1.3 Eligible actions: actions for which an application may be submitted ................................ 21 2.1.4 Eligibility of costs: costs which may be taken into consideration for the grant.................... 26
2.2 How to apply, and the procedures to follow ........................................................................ 29 2.2.1 Grant Application Form....................................................................................... 29 2.2.2 Annexes and supporting documents ........................................................................ 31 2.2.3 Where and how to send the applications .................................................................. 34 2.2.4 Deadline for submission of applications ................................................................... 34 2.2.5 Further information for the applications .................................................................. 35
2.3 Evaluation and selection of applications ............................................................................. 36
2.4 Notification of the Joint Monitoring Committees decision ..................................................... 41 2.4.1 Content of the decision ....................................................................................... 41 2.4.2 Indicative time table........................................................................................... 41
2.5 Conditions applicable to implementation of the Action following JMC's decision to award a grant 42
3. LIST OF ANNEXES........................................................................... 43
2009 Page 4 of 43 090610 Guidelines for Grant Applicants
GLOSSARY OF ACRONYMS
CBC Cross-Border Cooperation
CFCU Central Finance and Contracts Unit
EC European Commission
e.g. for example
ENPI European Neighbourhood and Partnership Instrument
EU European Union
IPA Instrument for Pre-Accession Assistance
JMA Joint Managing Authority
JMC Joint Monitoring Committee
JOP Joint Operational Programme
NGO Non Governmental Organisation
NUTS Nomenclature of Territorial Units for Statistics
OJ Official Journal of the European Union
pdf Portable Document Format (Adobe Acrobat or PDF Creator softwares)
PRAG Practical Guide to Contract procedures for EC external actions 2008
SC Selection Committee
TA Technical Assistance
VAT Value Added Tax
xls Microsoft Office Excel Format
2009 Page 5 of 43 090610 Guidelines for Grant Applicants
1. JOINT OPERATIONAL PROGRAMME BLACK SEA 2007-2013
1.1 BACKGROUND
The Joint Operational Programme Black Sea 2007-2013 (hereafter JOP Black Sea or Programme) is one of three maritime basin programmes established in the framework of the European Neighbourhood and Partnership Instrument Cross-Border Cooperation: Strategy Paper 2007-2013 (ENPI CBC Strategy Paper) and one of the most complex, even if with a limited financial allocation. The Programme eligible area occupies a territory of 834,719 sq. km. and includes a population of 74.2 million people. It involves ten countries, some of them including their whole national territory (Armenia, Azerbaijan, Georgia and R. Moldova), while some others including those regions closest to the Basin (Bulgaria, Greece, Romania, Russia, Turkey and Ukraine). The ten countries include four states (Greece, Armenia, Azerbaijan and R. Moldova) that are not physically on the coast of the Black Sea, but clearly integrated or connected to the Black Sea Basin in terms of historical, economic, cultural, social and environmental factors. The other six countries (Bulgaria, Romania, Russia, Turkey, Georgia and Ukraine) have direct access to the Black Sea. According to the ENPI CBC Strategy Paper, joint ownership of the process, based on the awareness of shared values and common interests, is essential. The EU does not seek to impose priorities or conditions on its partners. Therefore a partnership for programming has been promoted, involving all participating countries, and with the support of the European Commission (EC) through Technical Assistance (TA) projects, for both EU Member States and partner countries in the programme partnership. Equal participation of each participating country has been promoted during the programming process and in the institutional architecture for programme implementation. The Joint Managing Authority (JMA) has been established in Romania within the Ministry for European Integration, subsequent Ministry of Development, Public Works and Housing, now Ministry of Regional Development and Housing.
1.2 Legal Framework
European Union legislation
Regulation (EC) No.1638/2006 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 24 October 2006 laying down general provisions establishing a European Neighbourhood and Partnership Instrument (ENPI);
Commission Regulation (EC) No.951/2007 of 9 August 2007 laying down implementing rules for cross-border co-operation programmes financed under Regulation (EC) No.1638/2006 of the European Parliament and of the Council laying down general provisions establishing a European Neighbourhood and Partnership Instrument (ENPI);
Council Regulation (EC) No.1085/2006 of 17 July 2006 establishing an Instrument for Pre-Accession Assistance (IPA);
2009 Page 6 of 43 090610 Guidelines for Grant Applicants
Commission Regulation (EC) No.718/2007 of 12 June 2007 implementing Council Regulation (EC) No.1085/2006 establishing an Instrument for Pre-accession Assistance (IPA);
Council Regulation (EC, Euratom) No.1605/2002 of 25 June 2002 on the Financial Regulation applicable to the general budget of the European Communities;
Commission Regulation (EC, Euratom) No.2342/2002 of 23 December 2002 laying down detailed rules for the implementation of Council Regulation (EC, Euratom) No.1605/2002 on the Financial Regulation applicable to the general budget of the European communities;
Commission Decision No.7406/2008 of 27th of November 2008 adopting the Joint Operational Programme Black Sea 2007-2013;
Practical Guide to Contract procedures for EC external actions 2008 (PRAG)1.
In carrying out their activities related to award of works, supply and service contracts, all Beneficiaries and partners will have to follow the rules for selection and award of contracts referred to in Annex IV of the Standard Grant Contract. Exceptionally, where a Beneficiary or a partner established in a Member State is a contracting authority and/or a contracting entity as defined by the Community Directives applicable to procurement procedures2, it must apply the relevant provisions of those texts, as transposed in its national legislation3.
1.3 OBJECTIVES OF THE PROGRAMME AND PRIORITY ISSUES
The global objective of the programme, also covered by this Call for Proposals, is to achieve stronger regional partnerships and cooperation. By doing so, the programme aims to contribute to its key wider objective: a stronger and more sustainable economic and social development of the regions of the Black Sea Basin. The programmes 3 specific objectives, also covered by this Call for Proposals, are:
1. Promoting economic and social development in the Black Sea Basin areas 2. Working together to address common challenges 3. Promoting local, people-to-people type actions
These three specific objectives will be pursued by means of 3 priorities, which together form the programmes approach to achieve these objectives:
1 http://ec.europa.eu/europeaid/work/procedures/implementation/grants/index_en.htm 2 Directive 2004/18/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 31 March 2004 on the coordination of procedures for the award of public works contracts, public supply contracts and public service contracts (http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:L:2004:134:0114:0240:EN:PDF). 3 For Bulgaria: Public Procurement Law, published, SG No. 28/06.04.2004 with further amendments; Rules for the implementation of the Public Procurement Law; Ordinance for the Award of Small Public Contracts; Council of Ministers Decree No. 55/2007 laying down the provisions for the award of service, supply and works contracts by EU Structural Funds and PHARE Programme grant beneficiaries. For Greece: Law 3263/2004 Tendering of Public Works; Law 3316/2005 Public contracts for studies and services (infrastructure projects); Law 2286/1995 Public Procurement Law; Presidential Decree 118/2007 Public Procurement Regulation; Presidential Decree 60/2007 Adaptation of the Greek legislation to Directive 2004/18/EC (on public procurement for works, supplies and services); Presidential Decree 59/2007 Adaptation of the Greek legislation to Directive 2004/17/EC. For Romania: Governmental Emergency Ordinance no. 34/2006 regarding the award of the public procurement contracts, public works concession contracts and services concession contracts, with further amendments.
2009 Page 7 of 43 090610 Guidelines for Grant Applicants
1. Supporting cross border partnerships for economic development based on combined resources
2. Sharing resources and competencies for environmental protection and conservation 3. Supporting cultural and educational initiatives for the establishment of a common cultural
environment in the Basin The three priorities will be implemented through a total of 7 measures at operational level, as described below.
Objective 1 Promoting economic and social development in the border areas
The key area of intervention for the promotion of economic development is the development of initiatives based on local resources, starting from those of rural development, tourism, traditional manufacturing, with a strong focus on the promotion of SMEs and the promotion of administrative capacity at local level. Priority 1 - Supporting cross border partnerships for economic and social development based on combined resources Objective 1 will be achieved through Priority 1, which concentrates action in those fields with the richest potential: promotion of SME development through the support to initiatives aiming at the creation of a stimulating business environment, rural development and tourism. The focus of the activities supported by this priority will be on the promotion of accessibility, innovation, entrepreneurial capacity and administrative capacity. The transnational partnerships will promote the transfer of good practice and the spread of innovations among similar entrepreneurial initiatives.
Measure 1.1: Strengthening accessibility and connectivity for new intra regional information, communication, transport and trade links
The measure aims at supporting local development through improving links and connections in various dimensions between the regions of the programme area. This includes trade links supporting the accessibility to other markets of local traditional products.
The indicative list of activities is presented in Section 2.1.3.
Measure 1.2: Creation of tourism networks in order to promote joint tourism development initiatives and traditional products
This measure aims at promoting the development of common activities in the tourism sector, based on an integrated conservation and exploitation of Black Sea resources, in all partner regions. It targets the establishment of partnerships for exchange of experience and good practices in improving the standards of services in the area and for the development of common tourism products specific for the area. The indicative list of activities is presented in Section 2.1.3.
Measure 1.3 Creation of administrative capacity for the design and implementation of local and regional development policies
This measure aims to increase the institutional capacity to promote economic and social development through the establishment of international partnerships for the exchange of best practices and know how in this area. The creation of a favourable environment for business at local level is a critical factor for development. The integration and networking of local administration or agencies in the area will promote capacity building and the exchange of methodologies and approaches to common problems.
2009 Page 8 of 43 090610 Guidelines for Grant Applicants
The indicative list of activities is presented in Section 2.1.3.
Objective 2: Working together to address common challenges
The challenges related to environmental protection and promotion appear to be the most relevant for the partner regions in the Black Sea Basin. International partnerships and networks, promoting integration of instruments, methodologies and activities in this field will particularly address the real cross-border nature of these environmental challenges. Priority 2: Sharing resources and competencies for environmental protection and conservation Objective 2 will be addressed by Priority 2. The central focus of this priority will be the environmental protection and conservation. The challenges related to the environment should be addressed by paying close attention to the technical and political instruments available to the programme and partners. The main areas of intervention are the protection of the maritime environment, the natural areas on the coasts and also the inland areas, and waste treatment technologies and management. This priority will promote innovation and exchange of good practices in the fields of scientific, technical and administrative competencies and capacities for environmental protection and conservation. In order to guarantee coherence with the DABLAS, projects aimed at supporting co-operation for the protection of water and water-related ecosystems in the Danube and Black Sea Region should indicate how synergy with DABLAS initiatives would be attained. The same goes for coherence with the BSEC (for environmental protection-related projects), as well as for coherence with the Convention on the Protection of the Black Sea against Pollution (for pollution-related projects). Under all three measures of this priority, networking activities play an important role for the exchange and implementation of appropriate solutions to environmental common challenges. The selection process of projects will take into account that programme support to networking should be used for long lasting and visible assistance projects. Networking needs to be firmly in the framework of existing environmental initiatives or the Black Sea Convention. In any case, the aim is not to create new institutions, but rather to strengthen and expand cooperation between existing institutions.
Measure 2.1 Strengthening the joint knowledge and information base needed to address common challenges in the environmental protection of river and maritime systems
This measure aims at the promotion of stronger integration and development of research, innovation, awareness and scientific partnerships in the fields of monitoring, control and protection of maritime systems and rivers in the Black Sea Basin. The indicative list of activities is presented in Section 2.1.3.
Measure 2.2 Promoting research and innovation in the field of conservation and environmental protection of protected natural areas
This measure focuses on the sustainable development of natural protected areas in the partner regions. The aim of the measure will be achieved through various activities in the fields of management, research and economic initiatives. The indicative list of activities is presented in Section 2.1.3.
2009 Page 9 of 43 090610 Guidelines for Grant Applicants
Measure 2.3 Promotion of cooperation initiatives aimed at innovation in technologies and management of Waste and Wastewater Management systems
This measure addresses one of the main challenges for all Black Sea partner regions: the management of waste, including both wastewater and solid waste. Current waste management has a high impact on public health, the quality of drinking water and the Black Sea environment. The indicative list of activities is presented in Section 2.1.3.
Objective 3 Promoting local, people-to-people type actions
The promotion of people-to-people initiatives in the Black Sea Basin is especially challenging because of the large number of countries the extremely large geographical area and the historical and geopolitical background of the region. The activities that will be pursued under this objective can also generate strong synergies with the activities promoted under the priorities of Objective 1 and 2, which are all connected to human resources development, governance capability and stronger integration of communities in the Basin.
Priority 3: Supporting cultural and educational initiatives for the establishment of a common cultural environment in the Basin
Objective 3 will be pursued by Priority 3. The main focus of the priority will be to promote the integration and networking in terms of the rich cultural heritage and current cultural life in the partner countries. The main areas of activity that could contribute to the objective are those involving young generation, cultural and educational institutions. Both areas are the most promising in the long term, not the least in terms of the impact on local development based on mobilization of local resources. The educational institutions and cultural associations will be the main instrument for this strategy. Networking among cultural institutions will be promoted especially through the exchange of experiences and the sharing of cultural heritage and traditions. This is aimed at the establishment of a common cultural environment for the Black Sea Basin community, which in turn will contribute to the reduction of the negative impact of borders on reciprocal understanding and friendship.
Measure 3.1 Promoting cultural networking and educational exchange in the Black Sea Basin communities
This measure aims to create stronger social and cultural relations among communities around the Black Sea Basin, in order to promote good relations between the communities and stronger and better-integrated educational institutions in the Black Sea Basin, in order to support social and economic development. It focuses on the promotion of mutual understanding between neighbours and respect for cultural diversity. The activities foreseen are various, involving cultural institutions and NGOs active in cultural and social promotion or inter-ethnic relations. The improvement of the connection of educational institutions in the Black Sea Basin will contribute to the reduction of gaps among regions in terms of education. The indicative list of activities is presented in Section 2.1.3.
2009 Page 10 of 43 090610 Guidelines for Grant Applicants
1.4 FINANCIAL ALLOCATION PROVIDED BY THE JOINT MONITORING COMMITTEE
The indicative amount made available under this Call for Proposals is EUR 3,311,369 (ENPI contribution). The Joint Monitoring Committee reserves the right not to award all available funds.
Indicative allocation of ENPI funds by priority distribution:
ENPI EC Funding National
co-financing4 National
co-financing rate Total funding (EC + national)
Priority 1 1,169,318 116,932 10% 1,286,249 Priority 2 1,328,770 132,877 10% 1,461,647 Priority 3 813,281 81,328 10% 894,610 TOTAL 3,311,369 331,137 10% 3,642,506
For actions (projects) involving also Turkish partners, the indicative amount made available under this Call for Proposals is EUR 1,339,401 (IPA contribution). The Central Finance and Contracts Unit (CFCU) in Turkey reserves the right not to award all available funds.
Indicative allocation of IPA funds by priority distribution:
IPA EC Funding National
co-financing5 National
co-financing rate Total funding (EC + national)
Priority 1 472,972 52,552 10% 525,524 Priority 2 537,468 59,719 10% 597,187 Priority 3 328,961 36,551 10% 365,512 TOTAL 1,339,401 148,822 10% 1,488,223
Adjustments to the joint operational programme financial table which merely involve the transfer from one priority to another of no more than 20 % of the Community funds initially allocated to each priority may be made directly by the Joint Managing Authority, with the prior approval of the Joint Monitoring Committee6. Co-financing
No grant may exceed 90% of the total eligible costs of the Action. See also Section 2.1.4.
The rate of co-financing is 10% of the total eligible costs of the Action and it is requested for each approved proposal. Each participating country shall decide on its own co-financing system (from national or regional/local level or directly from the Beneficiary). Co-financing is to be provided by the Beneficiaries in order to demonstrate local commitment. No resources, which have been assisted by other EC contribution, may be taken into account as own contribution7.
Furthermore, proposals financed by other EU sources can not be submitted. Contribution in kind is not allowed8.
4 Calculated as 10% of EC funding, according with ENPI rules. 5 Calculated as 10% of Total funding (EC + national), according with IPA rules. 6 Regulation (EC) No 951/2007, art. 7.1. 7 Regulation (EC) No 951/2007, art.19(1). 8 Please see Section 2.1.4.
2009 Page 11 of 43 090610 Guidelines for Grant Applicants
Size of grants
Any EU grant contribution awarded under this Call for Proposals must fall between the following minimum and maximum amounts:
Type of actions (projects) Minimum amount Maximum amount Priorities 1 & 2 EUR 100,000 EUR 700,000 Priority 3 EUR 50,000 EUR 250,000 Projects implemented mainly or entirely in a single participating-country but having a cross-border impact
EUR 50,000
EUR 250,000
Payments
For actions with an implementation period not exceeding 12 months and where the financing is between Eur 50,000 and Eur 100,000, payments will take the form of pre-financing payment (80% of the grant) and forecast final payment (20% of the grant). For actions with an implementation period not exceeding 24 months and where the financing is over Eur 100,000 up to Eur 700,000, payments will take the form of first instalment of pre-financing (30% of the grant), forecast second instalment pre-financing (50% of the grant) and forecast final payment (20% of the grant). Forecast second instalment of pre-financing will be made only if the Beneficiary proves that 70% of the first instalment of pre-financing is spent9.
Grants Duration
of the actions (First instalment of)
Pre-financing
Forecast second instalment of pre-financing
Forecast final payment
Eur 50,000 up to Eur 100,000
max 12 months 80 % - 20 %
over Eur 100,000 up to Eur 700,000
max 24 months 30 % 50 % 20 %
9 As provided in Article 15(1) of the General Conditions of the Grant Contract (Annex F of these Guidelines).
2009 Page 12 of 43 090610 Guidelines for Grant Applicants
2. RULES FOR THIS CALL FOR PROPOSALS
These guidelines set out the rules for the submission, selection and implementation of actions (projects) financed under this Call for Proposals, in conformity with the provisions of the Practical Guide to contract procedures for EC external actions (PRAG), which is applicable to the present Call for Proposals (available on the Internet at this address: http://ec.europa.eu/europeaid/work/procedures/implementation/practical_guide/index_en.htm).
2.1 ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA
There are three sets of eligibility criteria, relating to: Applicant(s)10 which may request a grant (2.1.1), and their partners (2.1.2), actions (projects) for which a grant may be awarded (2.1.3), types of cost which may be taken into account in setting the amount of the grant (2.1.4).
2.1.1 Eligibility of Applicants and partners: who may apply
(1) In order to be eligible for a grant, Applicants and partners must:
represent one of the following legal entities11:
a. national, regional or local public authority;
b. body governed by public law12, other than legal entities