+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2....

Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2....

Date post: 21-Jan-2016
Category:
Upload: darren-hampton
View: 219 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
52
Moduli stabilization, SUS Moduli stabilization, SUS Y breaking and the Higgs Y breaking and the Higgs sector sector Tat Tat suo Kobayashi suo Kobayashi 1. 1. Introduction Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 2. KKLT scenario 3 3 Generalized KKLT scenario Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage mediation 4. TeV scale mirage mediation 5. Summary 5. Summary based on based on Choi, Jeong, T.K., Okumura, hep-ph/0508029, 06 Choi, Jeong, T.K., Okumura, hep-ph/0508029, 06 12258 12258 Abe, Higaki, T.K., hep-th/0511160, 0512232, 07 Abe, Higaki, T.K., hep-th/0511160, 0512232, 07 07.2671 07.2671 Abe, Higaki, T.K., Omura, hep-th/0612035 Abe, Higaki, T.K., Omura, hep-th/0612035 Abe, T.K., Omura, hep-ph/0703044 Abe, T.K., Omura, hep-ph/0703044 Abe, Kim, T.K., Shimizu, 0706.4349[hep-ph] Abe, Kim, T.K., Shimizu, 0706.4349[hep-ph]
Transcript
Page 1: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

Moduli stabilization, SUSY breakinModuli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector g and the Higgs sector                   Tatsuo KobTatsuo Kobayashiayashi1.1. IntroductionIntroduction2. KKLT scenario2. KKLT scenario33 .. Generalized KKLT scenarioGeneralized KKLT scenario4. TeV scale mirage mediation4. TeV scale mirage mediation5. Summary5. Summary based on based on     Choi, Jeong, T.K., Okumura, hep-ph/0508029, 0612258Choi, Jeong, T.K., Okumura, hep-ph/0508029, 0612258 Abe, Higaki, T.K., hep-th/0511160, 0512232, 0707.2671Abe, Higaki, T.K., hep-th/0511160, 0512232, 0707.2671 Abe, Higaki, T.K., Omura, hep-th/0612035Abe, Higaki, T.K., Omura, hep-th/0612035 Abe, T.K., Omura, hep-ph/0703044Abe, T.K., Omura, hep-ph/0703044 Abe, Kim, T.K., Shimizu, 0706.4349[hep-ph]Abe, Kim, T.K., Shimizu, 0706.4349[hep-ph]

Page 2: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

1. Introduction1. IntroductionMotivation for low-energy SUSYMotivation for low-energy SUSY the hierarchy problem, naturalness problemthe hierarchy problem, naturalness problem gauge coupling unificationgauge coupling unification dark matterdark matter SUSY should be broken and SUSY should be broken and superpartners should have larger masses.superpartners should have larger masses. Phenomenological aspects depend on Phenomenological aspects depend on a pattern of SUSY breaking terms, a pattern of SUSY breaking terms, gaugino masses, sfermion masses, etc.gaugino masses, sfermion masses, etc. Such a pattern is determined by how SUSY Such a pattern is determined by how SUSY breaking is mediated to the visible sector.breaking is mediated to the visible sector.

Page 3: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

SUSY breaking mediationSUSY breaking mediationSeveral mediation mechanisms of SUSY breakingSeveral mediation mechanisms of SUSY breaking Supergravity mediation (mSUGRA)Supergravity mediation (mSUGRA) (moduli-dilaton mediation)(moduli-dilaton mediation) Gauge mediationGauge mediation Anomaly mediationAnomaly mediation New type of mechanismNew type of mechanism Mirage mediation Mirage mediation This talk covers theoretical side and This talk covers theoretical side and discusses some phenomenological aspects.discusses some phenomenological aspects. Mirage mediation can be realized in Mirage mediation can be realized in string-derived supergravity.string-derived supergravity. TeV scale mirage is quite interesting, and TeV scale mirage is quite interesting, and leads to a unique pattern of s-spectrum.leads to a unique pattern of s-spectrum.

Page 4: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

String phenomenologyString phenomenologySuperstring theory is a promising candidate Superstring theory is a promising candidate for unified theory including gravity.for unified theory including gravity.Superstring theory has several moduli fieldsSuperstring theory has several moduli fields including the dilaton. including the dilaton. Moduli correspond to the size and shape Moduli correspond to the size and shape of compact space. of compact space. VEVs of moduli fields VEVs of moduli fields couplings in low-energy effective theory, couplings in low-energy effective theory, e.g. gauge and Yukawa couplings e.g. gauge and Yukawa couplings Thus, it is important to stabilize moduli VEVs Thus, it is important to stabilize moduli VEVs at realistic values from the viewpoint of at realistic values from the viewpoint of particle physics as well as cosmologyparticle physics as well as cosmologyActually, lots of works have been done so far.Actually, lots of works have been done so far.

Page 5: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

Moduli stabilization and SUSY breakingModuli stabilization and SUSY breakingLow-energy effective theory = supergravityLow-energy effective theory = supergravityModuli-stabilizing potential may break SUSY.Moduli-stabilizing potential may break SUSY. When When

Moduli-mediated SUSY breaking is dominant unless couplings Moduli-mediated SUSY breaking is dominant unless couplings between the visible sector and moduli fields are suppressed between the visible sector and moduli fields are suppressed by some reason. by some reason. This is the conventional approach.This is the conventional approach.Gaugino masses and sfermion masses are comparable Gaugino masses and sfermion masses are comparable with the gravitino mass. with the gravitino mass. (Ratios are fixed by supergravity Lagrangian.)(Ratios are fixed by supergravity Lagrangian.)For example, when gauge kinetic functions and Kahler For example, when gauge kinetic functions and Kahler metric are universal, that leads to the spectrum of mSUGRA.metric are universal, that leads to the spectrum of mSUGRA.

)(/ 2/3mOMF

Page 6: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

Moduli stabilization and SUSY breakingModuli stabilization and SUSY breaking

The magnitude of moduli F-components depend on The magnitude of moduli F-components depend on moduli stabilization mechanism.moduli stabilization mechanism.

When F/M is smaller than the gravitino mass, When F/M is smaller than the gravitino mass, another contribution is also important or rather dominant.another contribution is also important or rather dominant.   

⇒⇒    Different spectrum of s-particlesDifferent spectrum of s-particles

)(/ 2/3mOMF

Page 7: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

KKLT scenarioKKLT scenario Kachru, Kallosh, Linde, Trivedi, ‘03Kachru, Kallosh, Linde, Trivedi, ‘03They have proposed a new scenario for moduli stabilization They have proposed a new scenario for moduli stabilization leading to de Sitter (or Minkowski) vacua, leading to de Sitter (or Minkowski) vacua, where all of moduli are stabilized.where all of moduli are stabilized.

Soft SUSY breaking termsSoft SUSY breaking terms Choi, Falkowski, Nilles, Olechowski, Pokorski ’04, CFNO ‘05Choi, Falkowski, Nilles, Olechowski, Pokorski ’04, CFNO ‘05 a unique patter of soft SUSY breaking termsa unique patter of soft SUSY breaking terms Modulus med. and anomaly med. are comparable.Modulus med. and anomaly med. are comparable.            Mirage (unification) scale Mirage (unification) scale Mirage Mediation Mirage Mediation Choi, Jeong, Okumura, ‘05Choi, Jeong, Okumura, ‘05

little SUSY hierarchy (TeV scale mirage mediation)little SUSY hierarchy (TeV scale mirage mediation) Choi, Jeong, T.K., Okumura, ’05, ‘06Choi, Jeong, T.K., Okumura, ’05, ‘06

Page 8: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

More about moduli stabilizationMore about moduli stabilizationa generic KKLT scenario a generic KKLT scenario with moduli-mixing superpotentialwith moduli-mixing superpotential ⇒ ⇒    various mirage scalevarious mirage scale Abe, Higaki, T.K., ’05 Abe, Higaki, T.K., ’05 Choi, Jeong, ’06Choi, Jeong, ’06 Choi, Jeong, T.K., Okumura, ‘06Choi, Jeong, T.K., Okumura, ‘06F-term uplifting F-term uplifting Dudas, Papineau, Pokorski, ’06Dudas, Papineau, Pokorski, ’06 Abe, Higaki, T.K., Omura, ’06Abe, Higaki, T.K., Omura, ’06 Kallosh, Linde, ’06Kallosh, Linde, ’06                             Abe, Higaki, T.K, ‘07Abe, Higaki, T.K, ‘07

  

Page 9: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

2. KKLT scenario2. KKLT scenarioThis scenario consists of three steps in type IIB.This scenario consists of three steps in type IIB.1)1) Flux compactificationFlux compactification Giddings, Kachru, Polchinski, ‘01Giddings, Kachru, Polchinski, ‘01The dilaton S and complex structure moduli U areThe dilaton S and complex structure moduli U are assumed to be stabilized by assumed to be stabilized by the flux-induced superpotentialthe flux-induced superpotential

while the Kaher moduli T remain not stabilized.while the Kaher moduli T remain not stabilized. (It is stabilized in the next step.)(It is stabilized in the next step.)

),( USW flux

Page 10: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

2) Non-perturbative effect2) Non-perturbative effectWe add T-dependent superpotential induced byWe add T-dependent superpotential induced by e.g. gaugino condensation on D7.e.g. gaugino condensation on D7.

Scalar potentialScalar potential

T is stabilized at DT is stabilized at DTTW=0W=0 SUSY Anti de Sitter vacuum V < 0 SUSY Anti de Sitter vacuum V < 0

     Unit :Unit :

)1(,),( OAAeUSWW aTflux

)ln(3 TTK

TTT

TTTT

KF

WWKWD

WKWDWDeV

]||3)([ 2

1PM

Page 11: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

Stabilization of TStabilization of T

gravitino mass gravitino mass Scalar potentialScalar potential

T is stabilized at DT is stabilized at DTTW=0W=0 SUSY Anti de Sitter vacuum V < 0 SUSY Anti de Sitter vacuum V < 0

Moduli massModuli mass

aTflux AeW

)/ln(),10(

0

flux

aTaTfluxTT

WAaTOa

aAeAeWKWD

]||3)([ 2WKWDWDeV TTTT

KF

2/3

22/3

)(

3

maTm

mV

T

F

fluxWm 2/3

Page 12: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

3) Uplifting3) UpliftingWe add uplifting potential generated by We add uplifting potential generated by e.g. anti-D3 brane at the tip of warp throate.g. anti-D3 brane at the tip of warp throat

The value of D can be suppressed by the warp factor.The value of D can be suppressed by the warp factor.We fine-tune such that We fine-tune such that VVFF+V+VL L = 0 (or slightly positive)= 0 (or slightly positive) SUSY breaking de Sitter/Minkowski vacuumSUSY breaking de Sitter/Minkowski vacuumT is shifted slightly from the point DT is shifted slightly from the point DTTW=0W=0

mSnL eDTTDV p

216,)/(

,Re)(

,0 2/3

Ta

m

TT

FF

TT

14)/ln(Re 22/3 mMTa P

Page 13: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

Configuration in compact Configuration in compact spacespace

                               hidden sectorhidden sector non-perturbative effectnon-perturbative effect

T T anti D3 anti D3                        (SUSY breaking s(SUSY breaking s

ource)ource) visible sectorvisible sector                                                         

                

Page 14: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

UpliftingUplifting VV

SUSY breakingSUSY breaking

total potential total potential

                                                                           TT

before upliftingbefore uplifting

SUSY pointSUSY point

Page 15: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

Mirage mediationMirage mediation

If aT = O(1), moduli-mediation is dominant If aT = O(1), moduli-mediation is dominant However, when aT=O(10), moduli mediation and However, when aT=O(10), moduli mediation and anomaly mediation are comparable, that is, anomaly mediation are comparable, that is, Mirage mediation.Mirage mediation. Choi, Jeong, Okumura, ‘05Choi, Jeong, Okumura, ‘05

)10(Re,Re)(

2/3 OTaTa

m

TT

F T

Page 16: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

Mirage mediationMirage mediation

Mirage mediation Mirage mediation

= (modulus med.) + (Anomaly med.)= (modulus med.) + (Anomaly med.)

the mirage scale the mirage scale

0

2/32

2

0

2/32

2

2

2

0

2/32

2

2

2

0

2/32

2

022

2/32

2

0

2ln

8

)(1)(

16

)(ln

8

)(1)(

16

)()()(

16

1

)(

)(

16

M

mMgbMM

mgbMgb

MM

mgb

g

gMM

mgb

Mgg

M

mgb

MM

Xaaa

aaXaaa

aa

X

aa

Xa

Xa

a

Xaa

)2/exp( 02/3 MmMM Xmirage

Page 17: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

Mirage mediationMirage mediation

For scalar masses, we can obtain the same For scalar masses, we can obtain the same behavior.behavior. Scalar masses (Mx) = mixture of Scalar masses (Mx) = mixture of (modulus med.) and (Anomaly med.).(modulus med.) and (Anomaly med.).

However, at the mirage scale, However, at the mirage scale, RG effect and Anomaly med. are cancelled each RG effect and Anomaly med. are cancelled each

other.other.

Page 18: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

Scalar mass due to modulus Scalar mass due to modulus med.med.Kahler metricKahler metric

Scalar mass due to modulus mediation Scalar mass due to modulus mediation

metricKahler matter :

potentialKahler modulus:

)(3/

i

ni

K

Z

K

TTZe i

22 || Tii Fnm

Page 19: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

Soft SUSY breakingSoft SUSY breakingModulus med. and anomaly med. are comparable.Modulus med. and anomaly med. are comparable.It is useful to define the ratio, AM/modulus med.It is useful to define the ratio, AM/modulus med.

An interesting aspect is the mirage scale, where An interesting aspect is the mirage scale, where anomaly med. at the cut-off scale and RG effects anomaly med. at the cut-off scale and RG effects between the cut-off scale and the mirage scale between the cut-off scale and the mirage scale cancel each other.cancel each other.

Original KKLT Original KKLT α=1 α=1 Mirage scale = intermediate scaleMirage scale = intermediate scaleα=2 ⇒ TeV scale mirageα=2 ⇒ TeV scale mirage

)/ln( 2/30

2/3

mMM

m

P

2/2/3 )/(

PXmirage

v

MmMM

Tf

Page 20: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

example example

Suppose that the modulus mediation leads to Suppose that the modulus mediation leads to the s-spectrum of mSUGRA.the s-spectrum of mSUGRA.

α=0 ⇒α=0 ⇒    usual mSUGRA usual mSUGRA

α=2 ⇒ TeV scale mirageα=2 ⇒ TeV scale mirage

6:2:1:: 321 MMM

1:1:1:: 321 MMM

Page 21: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

3. Generalized KKLT 3. Generalized KKLT 3.1 questions and generalization3.1 questions and generalization Each step has further question and generalization. Each step has further question and generalization.

1) Are S and U stabilized really ? 1) Are S and U stabilized really ? What happens if they are not stabilized ?What happens if they are not stabilized ? Is two-step stabilization reliable ?Is two-step stabilization reliable ? If S and U have SUSY masses much larger If S and U have SUSY masses much larger than the gravitino mass, S and U are stabilized. than the gravitino mass, S and U are stabilized.

Abe, Higaki, T.K., ‘06Abe, Higaki, T.K., ‘06

Page 22: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

2) Moduli mixing superpotential2) Moduli mixing superpotentialIn several string models, gauge kinetic function f isIn several string models, gauge kinetic function f is obtained as a linear combination of two or moreobtained as a linear combination of two or more fields.fields.Weakly coupled hetero. /heterotic MWeakly coupled hetero. /heterotic M Similarly, Similarly, IIA intersecting D-branes/IIB magnetized D-branesIIA intersecting D-branes/IIB magnetized D-branes Lust, et. al. ’04Lust, et. al. ’04Gaugino condensation Gaugino condensation exp[-a f] exp[-a f]Moduli mixing superpotentialModuli mixing superpotentialWhat happens with moduli-mixing superpotential ?What happens with moduli-mixing superpotential ?

TSf

wTmSf

Page 23: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

3) F-term uplifting3) F-term upliftingCan anti-D3 brane (explicit breaking) be replaced Can anti-D3 brane (explicit breaking) be replaced by spontaneous SUSY breaking sector ?by spontaneous SUSY breaking sector ?

F-term uplifting F-term uplifting Gomez-Reino, Scrucca, ’06Gomez-Reino, Scrucca, ’06 Lebedev, Nilles, Ratz, ’06,Lebedev, Nilles, Ratz, ’06,

Dudas, Papineau, Pokorski,’06Dudas, Papineau, Pokorski,’06 Abe, Higaki, T.K., Omura, ’06Abe, Higaki, T.K., Omura, ’06 Kallosh, Linde, ’06Kallosh, Linde, ’06 Abe, Higaki, T.K., ‘07Abe, Higaki, T.K., ‘07Yes, that is possible in a simple model.Yes, that is possible in a simple model.

Page 24: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

3-2. moduli-mixing superpotential3-2. moduli-mixing superpotential In several string models, gauge kinetic function f isIn several string models, gauge kinetic function f is obtained as a linear combination of two or more obtained as a linear combination of two or more fields.fields.

IIA intersecting D-branes/IIB magnetized D-branesIIA intersecting D-branes/IIB magnetized D-branes Lust, et. al. ’04Lust, et. al. ’04Gaugino condensation Gaugino condensation W = exp[-a f] W = exp[-a f]Moduli mixing superpotentialModuli mixing superpotential

S is assumed to be stabilized already.S is assumed to be stabilized already.

wTmSf

Page 25: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

Moduli mixing Moduli mixing Abe, Higaki, T.K., ’05Abe, Higaki, T.K., ’05 Choi, Jeong, ‘06Choi, Jeong, ‘06Moduli mixing superpotential Moduli mixing superpotential

⇒⇒    change F-term of T after upliftingchange F-term of T after uplifting

Gauge kinetic function of the visible sector Gauge kinetic function of the visible sector ⇒ ⇒    change ratio of gaugino mass to F-termchange ratio of gaugino mass to F-termBoth change a value of αBoth change a value of α

)(81

2 nSkTeAcW

nSmTfv

Page 26: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

Our model Our model Choi, Jeong, T.K. Okumura, ‘06Choi, Jeong, T.K. Okumura, ‘06

m,n,k,p are discrete.m,n,k,p are discrete.S is replace by its VEV.S is replace by its VEV.We also add the same uplifting potential.We also add the same uplifting potential.

pSTf

eAeAW

TTK

v

nSkTmS

)(8

18

0

22

)ln(3

mkpnm /)(

Page 27: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

Generic results Generic results T is stabilized at the AdS SUSY point T is stabilized at the AdS SUSY point before uplifting.before uplifting.

After adding the uplifting potential, After adding the uplifting potential, the minimum shifts slightly and the F-term of T the minimum shifts slightly and the F-term of T becomes non-vanishing.becomes non-vanishing. The size of F-term depends on m and n.The size of F-term depends on m and n.That leads to a rich structure of SUSY breaking termThat leads to a rich structure of SUSY breaking term

s, e.g. different patterns of s-particle masses.s, e.g. different patterns of s-particle masses.

Page 28: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

Cosmological implications Cosmological implications Moduli fields are also important from Moduli fields are also important from the viewpoint of cosmology, e.g. inflation. the viewpoint of cosmology, e.g. inflation. Some moduli fields may be a candidate for Some moduli fields may be a candidate for inflaton.inflaton.  Moduli-mixing superpotential has interesting Moduli-mixing superpotential has interesting aspects for cosmology.aspects for cosmology.

Page 29: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

CosmologyCosmology

Original KKLTOriginal KKLT Height of bump is Height of bump is determined by determined by gravitino massgravitino mass

Overshooting problem Overshooting problem Brustein, Steinhardt, ‘93Brustein, Steinhardt, ‘93 Inflation ? Inflation ? destabilization due to finite temperature effectsdestabilization due to finite temperature effects Buchmuller, et. al. ‘04Buchmuller, et. al. ‘04

420

4220

ˆ)]/([

ˆ)(

TwTmSV

TgV

Page 30: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

Moduli mixing Moduli mixing Abe, Higaki, T.K., ‘05Abe, Higaki, T.K., ‘05

Racetrack modelRacetrack model The above problems may The above problems may be avoided. be avoided.

bbb NTwSmeCW /)(8 2

420

ˆ)]/([ TwTmSV

bbbbaa NTwSmNTwSm eeW /)(8/)(8 22

Page 31: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

3.2 F-term uplifting3.2 F-term uplifting Dudas, et. al. ’06, Dudas, et. al. ’06, Abe, Higaki, T.K., Omura ’06Abe, Higaki, T.K., Omura ’06 Kallosh, Linde, ‘06Kallosh, Linde, ‘06 Abe, Higaki, T.K., ‘07Abe, Higaki, T.K., ‘07 Can we realize uplifting by a spontaneous SUSY breaking ?Can we realize uplifting by a spontaneous SUSY breaking ?

If the potential minimum corresponds to If the potential minimum corresponds to non-vanishing Dnon-vanishing DXXW, F-term of X uplifts the vacuum energy.W, F-term of X uplifts the vacuum energy.

Any g(x) is OK, e.g. the Intriligator-Seiberg-Shih model.Any g(x) is OK, e.g. the Intriligator-Seiberg-Shih model.

)(XgAecW aT

Page 32: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

Simple modelSimple modelFor g(X), we use e.g. the ISS model.For g(X), we use e.g. the ISS model. Intriligator, Seiberg, Shih, ‘06Intriligator, Seiberg, Shih, ‘06 The ISS model itself is the global SUSY model.The ISS model itself is the global SUSY model.After integrating out heavy modes, we have After integrating out heavy modes, we have That breaks SUSY spontaneouslyThat breaks SUSY spontaneously

One-loop effective potential induces the mass term One-loop effective potential induces the mass term

XXg 2)(

22XmX

2XF

Page 33: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

Simple modelSimple modelOur modelOur model

When A=0, SUSY is broken.When A=0, SUSY is broken.

We can fine-tune c and μ such that V=0. We can fine-tune c and μ such that V=0.

When μ=0, T is stabilized at the SUSY point, When μ=0, T is stabilized at the SUSY point,

XAecW aT 2

0WDT

2XF

222

2

0

)/(3/213/

2

X

X

mc

cm

x

Page 34: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

Simple modelSimple modelAround the reference point, Around the reference point, we search the true minimum, where we search the true minimum, where We can do a similar analysis for different g(X).We can do a similar analysis for different g(X).

We can also analyze the T-X mixing caseWe can also analyze the T-X mixing case

0,0 WDxX T

cTbTaT CeBXeAewW 0

])/ln[/()/( 2/32/3 mMmOTTF PT

Page 35: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

Stringy origin for ISSStringy origin for ISSISS = dual of SU(N) theory with NISS = dual of SU(N) theory with Nff flavor quarks, flavor quarks, ⇒ ⇒    Stringy origin Stringy origin

Non-perturbative effectNon-perturbative effect

qmqW

aTcT

aTcS

AeeqCqwW

AeeqCqwW

0

0

XW 2

Page 36: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

F-term uplifting F-term uplifting Three sources of SUSY breakingThree sources of SUSY breaking   

Modulus mediation and anomaly mediation Modulus mediation and anomaly mediation are are

comparable.comparable.

)mediationanomaly (,, CTX FFF

2/32

2/3

)4/1( mMOF

mMF

PT

PX

Page 37: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

Spectra in F-term upliftingSpectra in F-term uplifting 1) When Fx is sequestered from the visible sector 1) When Fx is sequestered from the visible sector

like anti-D3 brane in the original KKLT, like anti-D3 brane in the original KKLT, modulus mediation and anomaly mediation are modulus mediation and anomaly mediation are comparable, i.e. mirage mediation.comparable, i.e. mirage mediation.

2) When contact terms between the visible matter 2) When contact terms between the visible matter fields and X are not suppressedfields and X are not suppressed sfermion masses ←sfermion masses ←    Fx Fx gaugino masses ←gaugino masses ←    mirage mediationmirage mediation

sfermion masses >> gaugino masses by O(10)sfermion masses >> gaugino masses by O(10)

Page 38: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

4.TeV-scale mirage mediation:4.TeV-scale mirage mediation: solution for the fine-tuning solution for the fine-tuning problemproblemTeV scale mirage mediation leads to the unique TeV scale mirage mediation leads to the unique pattern of s-particle spectrum, pattern of s-particle spectrum, gaugino masses degenerate around 1 TeVgaugino masses degenerate around 1 TeV sfermion masses degenerate around 1 TeV sfermion masses degenerate around 1 TeV

the little hierarchy between the stop massthe little hierarchy between the stop mass and the Higgs soft mass is naturally realized and the Higgs soft mass is naturally realized at TeV scale.at TeV scale.

In this type of models, there is no fine-tuning probleIn this type of models, there is no fine-tuning problem.m.

Page 39: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

4.1 the fine-tuning problem4.1 the fine-tuning problem Higgs sector Higgs sector

Supersymmetric mass terms in superpotentialSupersymmetric mass terms in superpotential

SUSY scalar potential = SUSY scalar potential = (F-term potential) + (D-term potential)(F-term potential) + (D-term potential)

Soft SUSY-breaking mass termsSoft SUSY-breaking mass terms

No quartic term in soft SUSY breaking termsNo quartic term in soft SUSY breaking terms

00202202 2 uduHudHdsoft HBHHmHmV

duHHW

Page 40: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

Higgs sector (Higgs sector ( fine-tuning) fine-tuning)

The Higgs potentialThe Higgs potential

Higgs VEVsHiggs VEVs

2222

2221

220202'2

002022

2021

,

8

1

2

HuHd

ud

udud

mmmm

HHgg

HBHHmHmV

GeVMgg

mMmgg

v

GeVvHHv

Z

HuZHu

du

91,74

2/,4

174,

2'2

222222'2

2

20202

Page 41: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

The lightest Higgs massThe lightest Higgs mass

RG effectRG effect

GeVmGeVm

mmvYMm

stoph

tstoptZh

500114

/ln4

3 22242

22

22

1816

22

22

30/ln10,10

/ln16

12

stopHu

stopt

Hu

mm

vGeV

vmY

m

Page 42: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

The fine-tuning problemThe fine-tuning problem

Fine-tuning Fine-tuning

GeVmGeVm

mmvYMm

stoph

tstoptZh

500114

/ln4

3 22242

22

22stopHu mm

222

222

500291

91,2

GeVMmM ZHuZ

)100(),100(

2

2

2

2

OO

a

M

M

a

mhu

Z

Za

Page 43: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

Favored pattern of mass parametersFavored pattern of mass parameters

If we can realize “naturally” the following If we can realize “naturally” the following little hierarchylittle hierarchy

that would be favorable from a simple that would be favorable from a simple

bottom-up viewpoint to avoid the fine-bottom-up viewpoint to avoid the fine-tuning tuning

problem. problem.

That is possible in the mirage mediation.That is possible in the mirage mediation.

2222 ||, ZHutstop MmAm

Page 44: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

4.2 TeV-scale mirage mediation4.2 TeV-scale mirage mediationBy choosing discrete values, n,m,p,k, we can obtain By choosing discrete values, n,m,p,k, we can obtain α=2 ⇒α=2 ⇒    Mirage scale = TeV scale Mirage scale = TeV scale If the modulus mediation leads to If the modulus mediation leads to

the little hierarchy between the stop massthe little hierarchy between the stop mass and the Higgs soft mass is naturally realized and the Higgs soft mass is naturally realized at TeV scale.at TeV scale. at higher loop levelat higher loop level

In this type of models, there is no fine-tuningIn this type of models, there is no fine-tuning    proproblem.blem.

0,2/ 222 uHstop mMm

))8/((,2/ 22222 MOmMmuHstop

Page 45: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

TeV-scale mirage mediationTeV-scale mirage mediationLow-energy spectra Low-energy spectra (I) (I) (II)(II)

They can relax the fine-tuning problem.They can relax the fine-tuning problem.They have unique patterns.They have unique patterns.It is interesting to study more their It is interesting to study more their

phenomenological aspects.phenomenological aspects.

ZstopZH MmMMmdu

22/1 8,

,

ZstopHZH MmMmMmdu

22/1 8,

Page 46: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

LSPLSP

TeV-scale mirageTeV-scale mirage

Higgsisno << bino, winoHiggsisno << bino, wino LSP = Higgsino-likeLSP = Higgsino-like Dark matter ???Dark matter ??? Thermal relic density is rather smallThermal relic density is rather small

ZstopZ MmMM 22/1 8,

Page 47: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

4.3 More about fine-tuning:4.3 More about fine-tuning: bottom-up approach bottom-up approach

Abe, T.K.,Omura, ‘07Abe, T.K.,Omura, ‘07Soft Higgs mass Soft Higgs mass

Cancellation between gluino mass and Cancellation between gluino mass and wino mass is important, but bino mass is not so wino mass is important, but bino mass is not so important.important.

gluino and wino masses are comparable at Mz.gluino and wino masses are comparable at Mz.

222

123

212113

2223

23

2

33690.0690.031.1

)214.00271.0168.0773.0(

00975.00135.00677.0

4333.0470.045.5)(2

UQH

tt

ZHu

mmm

AMMMA

MMMMM

MMMMMm

u

23 4MM

Page 48: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

fine-tuning:fine-tuning:    bottom-up approachbottom-up approach Abe, T.K.,Omura, ‘07Abe, T.K.,Omura, ‘07

r2 = M2/M3, r1= M1/M3 at Mxr2 = M2/M3, r1= M1/M3 at MxFavorable region r2=4 , -3 < r1 < 10Favorable region r2=4 , -3 < r1 < 10

Page 49: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

partial TeV scale mirage unificationpartial TeV scale mirage unification Abe, Kim, T.K.,Shimizu, ‘07Abe, Kim, T.K.,Shimizu, ‘07

Everything is the same as the previous one, Everything is the same as the previous one, except U(1) gauge kinetic function. except U(1) gauge kinetic function. We take U(1) gauge kinetic function different We take U(1) gauge kinetic function different from SU(3) and SU(2) ones such that they lead from SU(3) and SU(2) ones such that they lead to the gauge coupling unification. to the gauge coupling unification.

pSTf

eAeAW

TTK

v

nSkTmS

)(8

18

0

22

)ln(3

2/)( mkpnm

Page 50: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

Extended model Extended model LSP = mixture between higgsino and bino LSP = mixture between higgsino and bino

⇒ ⇒ different phenomenology, different phenomenology, e.g. dark mattere.g. dark matter     can lead to a right amount of thermal relic densican lead to a right amount of thermal relic densi

ty as a dark matter ty as a dark matter    Further study would be interestingFurther study would be interesting

Page 51: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

SummarySummaryWe have studied KKLT type models with We have studied KKLT type models with moduli-mixing superpotential.moduli-mixing superpotential.

Soft SUSY breaking terms in generalized modelsSoft SUSY breaking terms in generalized models have a rich structure. have a rich structure. in general mixture of modulus mediation and anomaly mediin general mixture of modulus mediation and anomaly medi

ation ation with a certain ratio, i.e. mirage mediationwith a certain ratio, i.e. mirage mediation sometimes modulus med. >> anomaly med. sometimes modulus med. >> anomaly med. or modulus med. << anomaly med.or modulus med. << anomaly med. further studyfurther study

TeV scale partial mirage model TeV scale partial mirage model also important, e.g. for the fine-tuning problemalso important, e.g. for the fine-tuning problem and dark matter physics and dark matter physics

Page 52: Moduli stabilization, SUSY breaking and the Higgs sector Tatsuo Kobayashi 1. Introduction 2. KKLT scenario 3 . Generalized KKLT scenario 4. TeV scale mirage.

SummarySummaryWe have also studied on the F-term uplifting scenario,We have also studied on the F-term uplifting scenario, that is, spontaneous SUSY breaking.that is, spontaneous SUSY breaking.

Soft SUSY breaking terms in generalized modelsSoft SUSY breaking terms in generalized models have a rich structure. have a rich structure. Sfermion masses would be heavier than gaugino masses. Sfermion masses would be heavier than gaugino masses. Sequestering is quite important.Sequestering is quite important. further study further study Abe, Higaki, T.K. Omura, in progressAbe, Higaki, T.K. Omura, in progress


Recommended