Monitoring Visitor Experience Aboard Expedition Cruises To
SINPR
P. T. Maher, PhD Cape Breton University
Sable Island Conference 2015
May 2, 2015 -- Halifax, NS
Outline
• Background
• Context
• Methods
• “Hurdles”
• Some Preliminary Results
• Conclusions
Sable Island Conference 2015 -- May 2, 2015 -- Halifax, NS 2
Background
• Parks Canada mandate: VE in relation to EI
• Critical in places with no permanent population
Sable Island Conference 2015 -- May 2, 2015 -- Halifax, NS 3
Context
• Expedition cruising – shuffle board and siestas replaced by well stocked libraries, lectures and zodiac landings
• Ships typically carry between 100-150 passengers • Passengers are generally of more advanced years –
baby boomers and newly or near retirement – well educated, well-travelled, in good health, have highly successful careers, and therefore have high levels of disposable income.
• Expedition cruising appeals to them because they are typically interested in “finding new unspoilt, previously unvisited locations with a strong natural or cultural appeal” (Ellis & Kriwoken, 2006, p.251).
Sable Island Conference 2015 -- May 2, 2015 -- Halifax, NS 4
Context
Experiences tend to follow the Lindblad pattern, named for the pioneering work of Lars-Eric Lindblad… “the Lindblad pattern of cruising emphasizes exploration and education. Experiences take three forms: using the ship as an observation platform (e.g., for whale watching), small boat cruising (e.g., along scenic coastlines, to view icebergs) and landings ashore. Throughout the cruises, both afloat and ashore, passengers are guided by experienced staff and naturalists, with lectures given enroute between destinations. The guides also ensure visitors behave in a way that causes minimal or no disturbance to the natural environment” (Crosbie and Splettstoesser, 2011, p. 106).
Sable Island Conference 2015 -- May 2, 2015 -- Halifax, NS 5
• 2 part survey
• Administered on the ship
• Distributed by the operator
• Voluntary completion
• Collected in a secure container
• Container collected by researcher
Methods
Sable Island Conference 2015 -- May 2, 2015 -- Halifax, NS 9
“Hurdles”
• Researcher off site
• Reliance on Adventure Canada
• Realities of expedition cruising
Sable Island Conference 2015 -- May 2, 2015 -- Halifax, NS 12
Preliminary Results
• 82 pre-trip responses, 91 post-trip, 64 respondent overlap (up to 118 pax/trip)
• From pre-trip: – 76 Canadian (including 39 ON, 15 NS, 8 BC, 7 AB) – Avg. income (n=60): $131,000 – Avg. age (n=79): 62 – Gender (n=81): 24 male, 57 female – Education: mostly university, less PhDs and MDs than
previous research – Well travelled: top 3 = Antarctic, Galapagos, Arctic – Majority knew it was a National Park
Sable Island Conference 2015 -- May 2, 2015 -- Halifax, NS 13
Preliminary Results
Purpose for the visit:
To experience this completely wild & off limits island. Also to see the horses
See all of the National parks
Whole package, remote island, location, horses, seals, other wildlife
Sable Island Conference 2015 -- May 2, 2015 -- Halifax, NS 14
Preliminary Results
Expectations:
Anything, as long as we see horses
Time to explore at my leisure
To experience something very special
Sable Island Conference 2015 -- May 2, 2015 -- Halifax, NS 15
Preliminary Results
Highlights:
• Horses
• Landscape
• People on site (both Zoe and PC staff mentioned frequently)
Lowlights:
• Not enough time on island
• Lack of “freedom to roam”
• Other visitors
Sable Island Conference 2015 -- May 2, 2015 -- Halifax, NS 16
Preliminary Results
Research:
• Heard about many topics
• Impacts seem well monitored
Visitation:
• Damage to vegetation - trampling
• Dune erosion
• Our visit in particular, no. Numerous visits of this size over time, yes. Visitor management will be a big part of moving forward
Sable Island Conference 2015 -- May 2, 2015 -- Halifax, NS 17
Preliminary Results
Management:
• I think Parks Canada has appropriate protocols in place, but they lack the man power to enforce them where large groups of people are concerned.
• …think it should maintain (focus on) ecological integrity of island over visitor experience and set a cap on yearly visitors. Hopefully all visitors will have to be with park staff & not roam freely.
• Sable should be treated like the Galapagos Islands, very controlled supervised visits, not a free for all
Sable Island Conference 2015 -- May 2, 2015 -- Halifax, NS 18
Preliminary Results
• Generally pre-trip information was accurate
• Generally trip was a success – Need time at main station
– Need more time with the horses
– Many visitors said trip greatly exceeded their expectations
• Time ashore was amazing, but obviously want more
• Time at sea – well spent (lectures, whale/bird sightings)
Sable Island Conference 2015 -- May 2, 2015 -- Halifax, NS 19
Conclusions • Visitors
satisfied, but…
• Visitation is a hot topic
• Baseline info is critical
• Full report coming soon - to help with 2016 season
Sable Island Conference 2015 -- May 2, 2015 -- Halifax, NS 20
Acknowledgements
• Internal RP Grant (#8753) • REB (#1314-145) • Thanks Jenna and Erin
• Research Permit (SINP-
2014-16319) • Thanks Jonathan, Heather
and Chris
• Thanks Shirley • Thanks to the crew of the
Sea Adventurer
Sable Island Conference 2015 -- May 2, 2015 -- Halifax, NS 21
Thanks for Listening
QUESTIONS
@DrPatMaher
http://drpatmaher.com