+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Muslim Family Law Reforms in Jurisdiction Other Than the Indian Sub-Continent

Muslim Family Law Reforms in Jurisdiction Other Than the Indian Sub-Continent

Date post: 02-Jun-2018
Category:
Upload: adv-anwar-hossain
View: 223 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend

of 21

Transcript
  • 8/11/2019 Muslim Family Law Reforms in Jurisdiction Other Than the Indian Sub-Continent

    1/21

    qwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyui

    opasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopadfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmq

    wertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqweryuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopadfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmrtyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnm

    qwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnmqwertyui

    Muslim Family Law Reforms in Jurisdiction other thanthe Indian Sub-Continent

    Collected by BdLawSource.Com

  • 8/11/2019 Muslim Family Law Reforms in Jurisdiction Other Than the Indian Sub-Continent

    2/21

  • 8/11/2019 Muslim Family Law Reforms in Jurisdiction Other Than the Indian Sub-Continent

    3/21

    3

    www.bdlawsource.com

    communities in terms of cultural patterns" sociolo$ical trends" demo$raphic factors"

    economic de#elopment and political stability.

    0enerally spea,in$" !*L is applied today in almost all predominately Islamic

    countries. /#en where !*L is not enforced by official state courts" its principles areinformally obser#ed by !uslims as a matter of reli$ious obli$ation and #ital concern.

    4hether formally or informally" !*L $o#erns matters of marria$e" matrimonial

    relations and maintenance" di#orce" paternity and custody of children" inheritance

    and related matters for more than a billion !uslims throu$hout the world. In this

    sense" one can say that the broad principles of !*L" and their basic assumptions and

    rationale" constitute the most widely applied system of family law in the world today.

    But that does not mean" howe#er" that the same !*L principles apply e#erywhere. As

    already noted" there are si$nificant differences amon$ the #arious schools of Islamic

    +urisprudence which pre#ail in different Islamic countries. Besides the ob#ious

    differences between Sunni and Shia communities which sometimes coexist within the

    same country" different schools and opinions may be followed the !uslim public

    within the same country . !oreo#er" +udicial practice may not necessarily be in

    accordance with the school obser#ed by the ma+ority of the !uslim population in the

    country.

    !oreo#er" a #ariety of social conditions or customary practices sometimes ha#e the

    effect of reformin$ the consequences of strictly le$al enforcement of !*L in different

    countries and communities. *or example" there are indications that distribution of

    shares in inheritance" especially for women" is sometimes indefinitely postponed to

    a#oid fra$mentation of the estate of the deceased" while by Sharia principles an

    informal arran$ement for sharin$ benefits is supposed to achie#e similar results.

    Some of these practical modifications or adaptations of !*L may in fact be more

    beneficial or detrimental to women and children than strict application of the law. Butthe problem is that the current state of ,nowled$e in the field does not permit well5

    informed #erification of such claims. !oreo#er" it seems clear that i$norance"

    misunderstandin$" bias" ulterior moti#es or wider political a$endas by all sides are

    obstructin$ positi#e reform initiati#es in many Islamic societies. At present !*L has

    become the contested $round between conser#ati#e and fundamentalist $roups" on

    the one hand" and modernist and liberal $roups" on the other.

    www.bdlawsource.com

  • 8/11/2019 Muslim Family Law Reforms in Jurisdiction Other Than the Indian Sub-Continent

    4/21

    4

    www.bdlawsource.com

    O"J#CTI$#

    The ob+ecti#e of the research is to #erify" understand and document the precise scope

    and nature of the application of !*L in a sample cross5section of Islamic countries

    and communities around the world. It is also to promote positi#e and sustainable

    !uslim *amily Law reform in different parts of the world. In particular" the research

    see,s to explore possibilities of $eneratin$ internal theolo$ical" le$al as well as

    political support for !uslim *amily Law &!*L) reforms. It is from this perspecti#e to

    expect that certain aspects of !*L ha#e not ,ept pace with the de#elopment of the

    societies they are supposed to ser#e. !oreo#er" the ob+ect is not simply to identify

    such problems or critici6e aspects of the theory and practice of !*L from the point of

    #iew of the human ri$hts of women and children. 7ather" the declared and explicit

    ob+ecti#e of this research is actual en$a$ement in theolo$ical" le$al and political

    debates about what !*L reforms ha#e made and how it is practicin$.

    M#T%OOLO&'

    The research is based on library research" boo,s" publications" +ournals" concerned

    scholars" policy ma,ers" and social +ustice $roups and womens and human ri$hts

    acti#ists.

    M!SLIM F(MIL' L() ISS!#S (N ITS R#FORMS

    Islam8s contributions to this sub+ect are a li#in$ tribute to the stren$th of the *aith to

    protect and enhance the status of the *amily as the crucial nucleus of our

    ci#ili6ation8s ci#ic life. The 1uran contains many direct commands for the purpose of

    ,eepin$ the *amily in tact. Such mandates apply re$ardless of $eo$raphy or ethnicspecificity as suchinstructions are bindin$ on e#eryone.* This research is to produce

    a concise" brief document that indicates best practices and reforms in the application

    and implementation of family law in !uslim countries. Thereby" the positi#e

    de#elopments that are occurrin$ in the !uslim world8s le$islati#e and +udicial practice

    better ,nown and a#ailable to other states and practitioners that are $rapplin$ with

    the same issues. This document is not meant to be either prescripti#e or an

    exhausti#e record of all family law in all !uslim countries.

    1

    www.bdlawsource.com

  • 8/11/2019 Muslim Family Law Reforms in Jurisdiction Other Than the Indian Sub-Continent

    5/21

    5

    www.bdlawsource.com

    The literature re+iewedthe laws and family codes of Al$eria" /$ypt" Indonesia"

    Iran" 9ordan" Lebanon" !alaysia" !orocco" Syria" Tunisia" and Tur,ey. 7eferenced

    statistics and comparable data often extend beyond these countries we ha#e

    indicated the scope of those statistics when used" indicatin$ whether comparisons are

    with the entire !iddle /ast and ;orth Africa &!/;A) re$ion" the Arab 4orld" or

    countries with !uslim ma+ority populations more broadly.

    The 7A;< Corporation and the 4oodrow 4ilson International Center for Scholars

    be$an collaboration on this pro+ect in !arch =>>? under the +oint leadership of 3aleh

    /sfandiari"

  • 8/11/2019 Muslim Family Law Reforms in Jurisdiction Other Than the Indian Sub-Continent

    6/21

    6

    www.bdlawsource.com

    MINIM!M M(RRI( (

    The 1uran does not define the minimum marria$e a$e precisely" merely mentionin$

    puberty as the permissible minimum. This has led to considerable di#er$ence of

    le$islati#e #iews on the proper minimum marria$e a$e" particularly in the last

    century. !inimum marria$e a$e continues to #ary amon$ !uslim countries &see table

    ). The most ad#anced countries ha#e established equity of marria$e a$e for men

    and women &as in the countries in bold in the table).!inimum marria$e a$e laws

    must be enforceable and consent must be required.

    Table *, Minimum Marriae (e. Summary

    Minimum Marriae (e. Summary

    Country (e in 'ears

    Male Female

    Al$eria&a) = -

    /$ypt&a) -

    Indonesia&a)

    Iran&a ) ?

    Jordan/b) *0 &) *0 &?)

    Lebanon&c) - D

    !alaysia&a) -

    Morocco *0 *0

    Syria&a) - D

    Tunisia => D

    Tur1ey/a ) *2 *2

    www.bdlawsource.com

  • 8/11/2019 Muslim Family Law Reforms in Jurisdiction Other Than the Indian Sub-Continent

    7/21

    7

    www.bdlawsource.com

    a. 7eli$ious or ci#il courts may ma,e exceptions to allow minors to marry.b. The royal decree risin$ the minimum marria$e a$e to - has not yet beenwritten into law.c. /xceptions exist for reli$ious minorities.

    d. Law unenforceable &minors can be penali6ed" but undera$e marria$esremain le$ally #alid).;ote: Countries listed in bold ha#e a$e requirement parity for men and women.

    M(RRI( R#&ISTR(TION

    There is no need for re$istration in a !uslim marria$e as it is not obli$atory in the

    1uran or in the Sunnah. En the other hand there is no prohibited sanction a$ainst

    re$istration of marria$e. Thus re$istration is not a requisite of a #alid marria$e but

    pro#ides a le$al restriction for #arious ,inds of protection" includin$ pre#ention of

    denial of the marria$e. !arria$e re$istration continues to #ary amon$ !uslim

    countries.

    Ira3.obli$atory court re$istration.

    Morocco.obli$atory court re$istration.

    Tunisia.obli$atory under Ci#il Status Act ?D" only formal document shall pro#e

    existence of marria$e unre$istered marria$e deemed #oid with three effects:

    establishment of paternity immediate onset of idda from date of #oidance

    declaration and creation of prohibited de$ree on basis of affinity.

    Seneal.obli$atory if marria$e contracted under one of customary le$al re$imes

    reco$ni6ed in Sene$alese law" parties must inform officer of ci#il status one month

    prior to marria$e non5re$istration is punishable by fine but does not determine

    #alidity.

    www.bdlawsource.com

  • 8/11/2019 Muslim Family Law Reforms in Jurisdiction Other Than the Indian Sub-Continent

    8/21

    8

    www.bdlawsource.com

    4OL'&(M'

    Islamic countries are addressin$ the issue of poly$amy in different ways. Ene $roup

    of countries" includin$ Tunisia" Tur,ey" and in part Lebanon" simply bans the practice

    outri$ht. A second $roup restricts the practice" applyin$ conditions that" in some

    cases" are quite ri$orous to deter a fri#olous exercise of multiple marria$es.

    *,The most common conditions that countries that restrict poly$amy place on the

    practice are the followin$:

    a) The prior wife or wi#es must be informed of the man8s intention to marry an

    additional wife.

    b) The prior wife or wi#es must consent.

    c) The husband must pro#e the poly$amous marria$e to be +ust and necessary(&clearly mentioned $rounds for this include a wife who is sterile" physically unfit for

    con+u$al relations" insane" or physically infirm or a wife who refuses sexual relations).

    d) The husband must $i#e assurance that the new marria$e will not affect the li#es of

    pre#ious wi#es and their children.

    5,The condition that a second or subsequent marria$e be +ust and necessary could

    be a potent tool for re$ulation" but its ambi$uity is cause for concern because it could

    also be used to +ustify poly$amy on the sli$htest $rounds. In some cases" for

    example" authorities may accept the wife8s 'failure( to produce a male heir as

    sufficient $rounds for $rantin$ permission for poly$amy &Ban$ladesh" 2a,istan). To

    counter this" courts in Sin$apore encoura$e adoption in such cases" rather than a

    second marria$e.=

    6,Accordin$ to the laws of the countries that restrict the practice of poly$amy" wi#es

    in a poly$amous marria$e ha#e to be treated equitably" and this includes pro#ision

    for separate li#in$ arran$ements if there has been such an a$reement durin$ the

    www.bdlawsource.com

  • 8/11/2019 Muslim Family Law Reforms in Jurisdiction Other Than the Indian Sub-Continent

    9/21

    9

    www.bdlawsource.com

    marria$e. In the e#ent of a #iolation of these procedures" the wife or wi#es can ta,e

    the husband to court.

    ='%nowin$ our 7i$hts: 4omen" family" laws and customs in the !uslim 4orld"(

    4omen li#in$ under !uslim Laws" =>>" p. =>>" London" F%

    2oly$amy rule is to #ary amon$ !uslim countries.

    Tunisia. A 2ersonal Status Code was adopted in Tunisia shortly after independence

    in ?" which other laws" prohibits poly$amy. Fnder Article - of the 2ersonal

    Status Code" any man who contracts a poly$amous marria$e is punishable with one

    year of imprisonment" a fine of =G>">>> Tunisian francs" or both.

    Tur1ey. In =>>" Tur,ey completed a sweepin$ o#erhaul of its Ci#il Code" with one

    outcome bein$ a ban on poly$amy.

    Table 5. 4olyamy. Summary

    4olyamy. Summary

    Country Status of 4olyamy

    Al$eria Allows up to four wi#es current wi#es may sue for di#orce ifnot informed.

    /$ypt Allows up to four wi#es must inform prior wi#es" who maydi#orce if they can pro#e harm from additional marria$e.

    Indonesia Basis of marria$e is considered mono$amy" but !arria$e Lawdoes not prohibit poly$amy for those whose reli$ions allow it.

    9ordan ;o constraints aside from the classical in+unctions that a manmust treat all co5wi#es equitably and pro#ide them withseparate dwellin$s

    Lebanon Lebanon reco$ni6es different $roups that are eachaccorded their own reli$ious law. The

  • 8/11/2019 Muslim Family Law Reforms in Jurisdiction Other Than the Indian Sub-Continent

    10/21

    10

    www.bdlawsource.com

    F.S. >G.

    Lebanon.7 In Lebanon" accordin$ to the G- Law 2ertainin$ to 2ersonal Status for

    the )" poly$amy is prohibited. Article of the - Ci#il

    !arria$e Law" proposed by acti#ists but not yet passed" would outlaw poly$yny.?

    Malaysia. Contractin$ a poly$amous marria$e requires the permission of a Shariah

    court. A husband must +ustify in writin$ why the additional marria$e is necessary and

    +ust and must con#ince the court that he can treat all wi#es equally. *ailure to follow

    required procedures is liable to months8 imprisonment and a fine.

    Indonesia. Fnder a > policy" poly$amy is permitted only throu$h an application

    to the court and requires appro#al of the prior wife or wi#es" a necessity for the

    marria$e &current wife suffers from an incurable disease or is infertile" etc.)" and a

    $uarantee that husband will treat all wi#es and children +ustly.D

    Ira3. Enly permitted by +udicial permission" to be $ranted on two conditions:

    financial ability and lawful benefit permission not to be $ranted if +ud$e fears

    unequal treatment of co5wi#es IL2S pro#ides penalties of imprisonment andHor fines

    for non5compliance.

    Morocco.Enly permitted by +udicial permission" to be $ranted on two conditions:

    financial ability and lawful benefit permission not to be $ranted if +ud$e fears

    unequal treatment of co5wi#es IL2S pro#ides penalties of imprisonment andHor fines

    for non5compliance.

    G In 9ordan" only certain sects ban poly$amy.

    ? %nowin$ our 7i$hts: 4omen" family" laws and customs in the !uslim 4orld"(

    4omen li#in$ under !uslim Laws"

    =>>" p. =>?" London: F%

    Ibid.

    D Ibid.

    &!(RI(N 4#RMISSION (N )OM#N8S CONS#NT

    A widespread problem in many !uslim countries" especially in those mar,ed by

    po#erty" feudal structures" andHor lar$e $aps in the status of social $roups" is the

    con#eyin$ or sellin$ of youn$ women for economic $ain or under political and otherpressures. There is no unified position within the Islamic world on the le$al role of

    www.bdlawsource.com

  • 8/11/2019 Muslim Family Law Reforms in Jurisdiction Other Than the Indian Sub-Continent

    11/21

    11

    www.bdlawsource.com

    parents or a $uardian &wali) in contractin$ or a$reein$ to a marria$e or on the ri$hts

    of women to determine their own spouses" either within ci#il le$al +urisprudence or

    under the sharia law.

    3owe#er" there is also no Islamic +ustification for forcin$ any woman to marry a$ainsther will or for pre#entin$ a mature woman from marryin$ as she chooses.

    ;onetheless" the actual practice throu$hout the !uslim world often excludes women

    from ha#in$ any #oice in the choice of their marria$e partners" e#en thou$h$i#en

    the enormous power !uslim society $enerally $rants to husbands and their families

    that decision will be of monumental importance to their prospects of happiness.

    !inimum consent of marria$e of the $uardian and women continues to #ary amon$

    !uslim countries.

    Iran.!any le$al codes require the consent of the bride but undermine this with

    other pro#isions. *or example" Iranian law stipulates that the official conductin$ the

    marria$e read the conditions of the contract to both parties and that they separately

    si$n each condition to indicate acceptance. 3owe#er" accordin$ to a =>>G F.S. State

    >?

    Morocco. 7ecent reforms to the *amily Law code uni#ersally require women8s

    consent. The extensi#e reforms to the Moudawwana in =>>G ma,e Morocco a model

    case. Fnder !orocco8s new law" women become their own $uardians on reachin$

    ma+ority" may conduct their own marria$es" and may not be coerced into marria$e

    under any circumstances. 4hile si$nificant challen$es in implementation remain"

    !orocco8s exemplary family law code $rants !oroccan women ri$hts of consent in

    marria$e that are a true model for the Islamic world.

    www.bdlawsource.com

  • 8/11/2019 Muslim Family Law Reforms in Jurisdiction Other Than the Indian Sub-Continent

    12/21

    12

    www.bdlawsource.com

    Ira3. 2rior to ?" 'marria$e contracts concluded by coercion( were considered #oid

    so lon$ as they had not been consummated.>

    (leria.*orced marria$e is not permitted" but perpetrators face no penalties. !any

    youn$ women face family and community pressures to marry a$ainst their will and

    ha#e no or only limited channels throu$h which to #oice dissent. Social support

    networ,s that mi$ht aid the woman in such cases" as well as the bac,in$ of an

    accessible formal or informal +ustice system" are $enerally lac,in$.

    Indonesia. 7equire the bride8s consent &or at least her lac, of ob+ection)" but

    pro#ide no realistic way for her to ma,e such an ob+ection ,nown and no clear

    mechanism for escapin$ an ille$al marria$e &e.$." annulment).

    Malaysia.It is ille$al to pre#ent a woman of or a man of - and abo#e from

    contractin$ a #alid marria$e. >G" accessed April=>>?

    > /mory Fni#ersity Law School.

    Knowing Our Rights" p.

    = Knowing Our Rights" p.D=

    Table 6. &uardian 4ermission. Summary

    &uardian 4ermission. SummaryCountry )ali9&uardian:

    Must Consent /Can 4re+ent

    Marriae;

    Can Com

  • 8/11/2019 Muslim Family Law Reforms in Jurisdiction Other Than the Indian Sub-Continent

    13/21

    13

    www.bdlawsource.com

    Syria under Da under D aTunisia c no under => a noTur1ey c no no no

    RI&%T OF I$ORC#

    In many countries in the Islamic world" men ha#e possessed a unilateral and

    unconditional ri$ht to di#orce. In these same countries" women are often not only not

    afforded that ri$ht but" if they are allowed the ri$ht of di#orce at all" must resort to

    the courts to di#orce their spouses" where they confront innumerable social" le$al"

    and bureaucratic obstacles. In many Islamic countries" women are often at a massi#e

    disad#anta$e compared to men in such matters as financial support" child custody"

    child #isitation and child $uardianship" and subsequent remarria$e. In Tunisia"

    !alaysia" Iran" and @emen" the law requires that all di#orces be settled in a court of

    law. 4hile laws #ary considerably in the de$ree to which women may see, di#orce

    and on what $rounds men may see, di#orce" most of these countries mandate that

    the procedure be conducted in a court of law. *or instance"

    Iran.3ere talaq is reco$ni6ed" the husband can di#orce his wife without citin$ any

    reasons. 3owe#er" di#orce is permissible only throu$h the courts and any

    independent pronouncement of talaq made on the part of the husband is considered

    immaterial before the court of law. !oreo#er" the re$istrar can only re$ister a di#orce

    after permission has been issued from a court and after any mahr" maintenance"

    andHor wa$es for housewor, ha#e been paid to the wife. The law is interpreted to

    mean that no court can pre#ent a man from di#orcin$ his wife howe#er" all her

    financial ri$hts must be settled prior to the separation.

    Tunisia, Fnder Article of the 2ersonal Status Code" di#orce by mutual consent &or

    Mubarat) is reco$ni6ed.

  • 8/11/2019 Muslim Family Law Reforms in Jurisdiction Other Than the Indian Sub-Continent

    14/21

    14

    www.bdlawsource.com

    Syria. Syrian law of 2ersonal Statute &?) put the husband8s moti#e for di#orcin$

    his wife under +udicial scrutiny by financially punishin$ arbitrary use of talaq. The

    Syrian Law of 2ersonal Statute pro#ides that" when a husband di#orces his wife

    without adequate cause" he must pay her financial compensation to the equi#alent of

    one year8s maintenance.

    Indonesia, Fnder the !arria$e Law" all di#orces must $o throu$h the court. A

    husband married under !uslim laws must pro#ide the reli$ious court with a written

    notification of his intention to di#orce" which must include his reasons for wishin$ to

    do so. If the reasons accord with one of the ei$ht $rounds a#ailable to husbands and

    wi#es" both parties are called separately for reconciliation meetin$s with counselors.

    If reconciliation fails" the court will call the parties to witness the di#orce.(G.

    Indonesian di#orce codes 'do not distin$uish between husband and wife.(

    Table 7, Riht to i+orce. Summary

    Riht to i+orce. SummaryCountry Rihts of i+orceAl$eria Talaq is not reco$ni6ed.

  • 8/11/2019 Muslim Family Law Reforms in Jurisdiction Other Than the Indian Sub-Continent

    15/21

    15

    www.bdlawsource.com

    repudiated wife has ri$ht to continue residin$ in marital home without husband for

    three years" so lon$ as she was not disobedient" did not a$ree to or request di#orce"

    and does not own house or flat of her own.

    Morocco :4ost-i+orce Maintenance9Financial (rranements: husband obli$edto maintain di#orce &e#en if nashi6a) durin$ iddat - le$islation pro#ides that

    repudiated wife has ri$ht to continue residin$ in marital home without husband for

    three years" so lon$ as she was not disobedient" did not a$ree to or request di#orce"

    and does not own house or flat of her own .

    Tunisia. 4ost-i+orce Maintenance9Financial (rranements: husband obli$ed

    to pro#ide maintenance durin$ iddat or" if there is an infant" until the child is weaned

    if di#orce was husband8s will" +ud$e may determine what financial compensation is

    due to wife &or #ice #ersa if di#orce was at request of wife).

    Seneal: 4ost-i+orce Maintenance9Financial (rranements: in case husband

    sou$ht di#orce on $rounds of incompatibility or incurable illness of wife" obli$ation to

    maintain is transformed to obli$ation to pay alimony in case di#orce is +ud$ed to be

    exclusi#e fault of one party" +ud$e may $rant other party compensation.

    C%IL C!STO' (N M(INT#N(NC#

    !uslim countries often restrict the ri$hts of mothers to raise or e#en to ha#e theri$ht to #isit their own children in the e#ent of a di#orce. Instead" these countries cite

    a 'natural ri$ht( of fathers to ha#e $uardianship o#er their children custody defaults

    to the father after a child reaches particular &often #ery youn$) a$e. 2aternal

    $randfathers or other male relati#es of the father ha#e preference in the e#ent of his

    death" irrespecti#e of the wishes or needs of the child. Loss of their children is a

    powerful threat" ,eepin$ women in otherwise unendurable marria$es.

    Table =, Rihts In+ol+in Children. SummaryRihts In+ol+in Children. SummaryCountry Mother8s Riht to : Father8s

    rihtto :

    Custody of : ChildSu

  • 8/11/2019 Muslim Family Law Reforms in Jurisdiction Other Than the Indian Sub-Continent

    16/21

    16

    www.bdlawsource.com

    Iran b D9ordan a 2uberty Classical law

    e@es

    Lebanon a D d d Classical law

  • 8/11/2019 Muslim Family Law Reforms in Jurisdiction Other Than the Indian Sub-Continent

    17/21

    17

    www.bdlawsource.com

    Ether Islamic countries" such as #y>=. p. D.

    !any Islamic countries deny women custody of their children alto$ether in the e#ent

    that she renounces Islam" commits acts of 'immorality( or adultery" or $eo$raphically

    mo#es too far away from the father.D

    Morocco. The !oroccan family code in its re#ised form contains lan$ua$e

    $uaranteein$ a women8s ri$ht to custodianship re$ardless of her proximity to the

    father or marital status. It also ma,es a distinction between money paid as

    restitution or compensation to the mother and the sum required to maintain the

    same quality of life of the child" ensurin$ that one alimony payment will not ta,e the

    place of parental obli$ation of continued support.-

    D Knowing Our Rights" p. .

    - L8Association

  • 8/11/2019 Muslim Family Law Reforms in Jurisdiction Other Than the Indian Sub-Continent

    18/21

    18

    www.bdlawsource.com

    deceased to completely exclude collateral male a$nates amendments also

    adopt Shii system of classifyin$ heirs for inheritance" thou$h Sunni principles still

    $o#ern di#ision of estates amon$ heirs.

    Tunisia: Boo, of TL2S on succession introduced obli$atory bequests in fa#or oforphaned $randchildren throu$h sons or dau$hters" limited to first $eneration of

    $randchildren and to maximum of one5third of estate introduced and extended

    doctrine of radd &return) to allow sur#i#in$ spouse to share in residue of deceased

    partners estate also pro#ision that if deceased has only sur#i#in$ dau$hters" estate

    shall $o to children and not to paternal uncles.

    Seneal: 0o#erned by classical law as outlined in Section III on !uslim succession

    in Boo, MII of *amily Code includes pro#ision for only $randdau$hters throu$h

    predeceased sons not standin$ to inherit as residuary heirs from anyone else to

    recei#e one5sixth of estate.

    Conclusion

    Throu$hout the history of Islamic faith" it has been a deeply cherished ob+ecti#e to

    emphasi6e on en#elopin$ the entirety of a person8s life with its normati#e structure of

    rules of conduct and precepts. Amon$st the ma+or norms of such expected beha#ior

    are those that are de#ised to apply to the institution of the *amily. Islam has also a

    considerable amount of substanti#e rules that $o#ern the matter of human ri$hts.

    The thrust of Islamic +urisprudence and Shari Na seems to clearly accommodate the

    basic necessary rules that create for the flourishin$ of the *amily.

    The e#olution of these norms and concepts in the international le$al field has been

    such that" in respect of crucial details" there is a #isible tendency to ha#e the ri$hts

    of the *amily $i#e up some of its historical and inherent hierarchal position and status

    in the society to specific and newly de#eloped 'rules( in the broader field of human

    ri$hts. The problem that we are thus faced with is simple. Some of the !uslim *amily

    Law reforms that are currently ad#ocated by a si6eable se$ment of liberal based

    ideolo$ues are such that the aim to denude the #ery foundations of the institution of

    the family as to ad#ersely affect its well5bein$ and character.

    Fndeniably the positi#e role that *aith and 7eli$ion play in the public life of any

    community is tremendously immense. /#en amon$st the most 'pro$ressi#e societies(

    www.bdlawsource.com

  • 8/11/2019 Muslim Family Law Reforms in Jurisdiction Other Than the Indian Sub-Continent

    19/21

    19

    www.bdlawsource.com

    of modern times the rele#ance of *aith can ne#er be exa$$erated. 0i#en the peculiar

    political and societal realities of this millennium" in the Third 4orld context Islam8s

    si$nificance needs to be specially noted. The perennial support that *amily as an

    institution has e#inced from confines of doctrinaire Islam is by itself comprehensi#e

    both le$ally and sociolo$icallyO An understandin$ of this fact would pro#ide us with a

    true $limpse of the rationale why !uslim countries are always ad#ocatin$ the

    continued historical continuity of the *amily as the core and fundamental $roup unit

    of our ci#ili6ations" re$ardless of the nature of 7eli$ion of the concerned communities

    These are a few prominent areas within the !uslim *amily laws requirin$ attention of

    scholars" experts" reli$ious leaders and $o#ernments for underta,in$ 'reforms(. The

    'reform( mo#ement that is needed has to be well coordinated and of course led by

    profound scholarship. Anythin$ less than quality would be self defeatin$. So this

    reform mo#ement has to be underta,en with lot of plannin$" and a determined yet

    sincere effort to ha#e the ,ind of ima$ination that achie#es dynamic ad#ances

    without creatin$ the expected opposition from ad#ersary ideolo$ies.

    This research is therefore inte$ral to understandin$ the actual practice of !*L with a

    #iew to implementin$ effecti#e reforms. Enly detailed and systematic study of how

    !*L affects the daily li#es and social relationships of actual men" women and

    children" of how people ad+ust to and cope with the consequences of the applicationof the law will $i#e the insi$hts which is need for de#isin$ and implementin$ reform

    initiati#es. Such studies are also testin$ the rele#ance and efficacy of reform

    initiati#es already attempted in different parts of the world.

    www.bdlawsource.com

  • 8/11/2019 Muslim Family Law Reforms in Jurisdiction Other Than the Indian Sub-Continent

    20/21

    20

    www.bdlawsource.com

    &LOSS(R' OF ISL(MIC T#RMS

    fi3hIslamic +urisprudence and le$al rulin$s. #iqh typically refers to the le$al rulin$s

    of the four madhahib.

    hadiththe 'traditions"( parables from the life of the prophet !uhammad" indicatin$

    what he said" did" and appro#ed of in others around him. Alon$ with the 1ur8an" the

    hadith form the main basis for Islamic law.

    8iddaa waitin$ period after a woman di#orces" usually about three months &but

    lon$er if she is pre$nant).

    i>barforced marria$e" arran$ed by the bride8s wali.

    1hul8a means by which a woman may obtain a di#orce throu$h payments to her

    husband &usually repayment of some or all of her mahr).

    madhhab &pl. madhahib)P schools of thou$ht on Islamic law. There are four

    madhahib in Sunni Islam: 3anafi" !ali,i" Shafi8i" and 3anbali. Shi8a reli$ious law is

    sometimes referred to as a fifth madhhab" 9a8fari.

    mahrthe dowry paid by a $room to his bride at the time of marria$e.

    mata8acompensation paid by the husband to the wife after talaq or if fault for the

    di#orce lies with the husband.

    moudawwanathe !oroccan code of family law.

    mubaratsee $hul.

    shari8acanonical Islamic law drawn from the 1ur8an and the hadith.

    tala3repudiation of marria$e &Islamic di#orce). Talaq can mean di#orce in any

    form. A particular Islamic di#orce" called tri%le talaq" whereby a husband proclaims

    'talaq( to his wife three times to di#orce her" is particularly contro#ersial. If a

    husband dele$ates his ri$ht to talaq" to his wife or to a third party" this is called talaq

    tafwid. The dele$ation can occur at the time of marria$e or in a subsequent

    a$reement.

    ta8li3conditional di#orce" with the conditions usually set at the time of marria$e.

    walile$al $uardian. The wali must be male and is typically the father &or the

    $randfather if the father is deceased) howe#er" the wali may be any male relati#e.

    "I"LIO&R(4%'

    ?nowin our Rihts. 4omen" family" laws and customs in the !uslim 4orld"(

    4omen li#in$ under !uslim Laws" =>>" p. =>>" London" F%!,S, e>G

    www.bdlawsource.com

  • 8/11/2019 Muslim Family Law Reforms in Jurisdiction Other Than the Indian Sub-Continent

    21/21

    21

    www.bdlawsource.com

    ?nowin our Rihts: 4omen" family" laws and customs in the !uslim 4orld"(

    4omen li#in$ under !uslim Laws" =>>" p. =>?" London: F%

    !,S, e>?

    http://www.law.emory.edu/IFL/legal/syria.htmhttp://www.seelineproject/http://www.law.emory.edu/IFL/legal/syria.htmhttp://www.seelineproject/

Recommended