+ All Categories
Home > Documents > NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case....

NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case....

Date post: 10-Mar-2018
Category:
Upload: trinhhuong
View: 229 times
Download: 2 times
Share this document with a friend
54
p - Copy - RML51H2O NACA RESEARCH MEMORANDUM 00e CLASSFLCTON CHANGED TO 144z BY AUTHORITY A3 " c....... ON OF COMPARISON OF NACA 65-SERIES COMPRESSOR-BLADE PRESSURE DISTRIBUTIONS AND PERFORMANCE IN A ROTOR AND IN CASCADE By Willard R. Westphal and William R. Godwin Langley Aeronautical Laboratory Langley Field, Va. CH ANCE-VOUGH'!' AIE -, I^ A FT DALLAS, TEXAS CL_niis1TLE - This material contains information* ,n # ease of the United States within the meaning of the espionage laws, Title if, U.S -5, the raosntlss th U at n or revelaon of which any manner to unauthorized person is pro NATIONAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE FOR AERONAUTICS WASHINGTON November 16, 1951 https://ntrs.nasa.gov/search.jsp?R=19930086833 2018-05-14T04:53:48+00:00Z
Transcript
Page 1: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

p -

Copy - RML51H2O

NACA

RESEARCH MEMORANDUM 00e

CLASSFLCTON CHANGED TO 144z

BY AUTHORITY A3 " c....... ON OF

COMPARISON OF NACA 65-SERIES COMPRESSOR-BLADE

PRESSURE DISTRIBUTIONS AND PERFORMANCE

IN A ROTOR AND IN CASCADE

By Willard R. Westphal and William R. Godwin

Langley Aeronautical Laboratory Langley Field, Va.

CHANCE-VOUGH'!' AIE ­ , I^ AFT DALLAS, TEXAS

CL_niis1TLE -

This material contains information*,n # ease of the United States within the meaning of the espionage laws, Title if, U.S -5, the raosntlss th U at n or revelaon of which any manner to unauthorized person is pro

NATIONAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE FOR AERONAUTICS

WASHINGTON November 16, 1951

https://ntrs.nasa.gov/search.jsp?R=19930086833 2018-05-14T04:53:48+00:00Z

Page 2: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

C rt'T1-'-.--

NACA RM L51H20

NATIONAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE FOR AERONAUTICS

RESEARCH MH4ORANJM

COMPARISON OF NACA 65-SERIES COMPRESSOR-BLADE

PRESSURE DISTRIBUTIONS AND PERFORMANCE

IN A ROTOR AND IN CASCADE

By Willard H. Westphal and William R. Godwin

An investigation has been conducted to compare the performance of NACA 65-series compressor blades in two-dimensional cascade to that in an axial-flow ccinpresaor. The entering and leaving flow velocities, pressure rise, and the pressure distribution on the rotating blades were measured at three radial stations of a free-vortex rotor. The blade pressure distributions were obtained by the use of a mercury-seal pressure-transfer device. The data obtained were compared with similar data for the same blade sections obtained from a two-dimensional porous-wall cascade tunnel.

The comparison indicated that cascade data accurately predicted the turning angle and blade pressure distribution obtained in the com-pressor at design conditions. At other than design angle of attack, large differences, probably due to secondary flows, were observed near the inner case.

INTRODUCTION

A prime factor in the design of a turbomachine is the knbwledge of rotor-blade aerodynamic performance. However, blade profiles may be tested and evaluated much more easily In cascade than in a rotating machine bince models are simpler and compressor design parameters such as blade camber and solidity are more easily varied in the cascade. Also, the section characteristics such as lift, drag, and' pressure distribution are more easily measured in cascade. Unfortunately, flow through a two-dimensional cascade is somewhat different from that through a rotating machine since such three-dimensional phenomena as radial displacement of the main flow, centrifuging of the boundary layer, and the tip clear-ance leakage do not occur in cascades. A correlation is needed between

Page 3: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

2 ..J-.-1.LL NACA RM L51H20

the simpler two-dimensional cascade flows and the flows through rotating blade rows. One method of obtaining information for this correlation is to measure the pressure distributions and flow velocities on rotating blade rows. In reference 1, Weske presented pressure distributions measured on rotating blades, but' did not present cascade data for com-parison. In reference 2, Milhlemann presented flow velocity measurements ahead of and behind a rotor, along with blade wake distributions. As in the previous case, comparable cascade data were not presented so a correlation between rotor and cascade performances could not be attained.

The intent of the present investigation was to obtain a comparison between the flow about compressor blade sections in a compressor rotor and in two-dimensional cascade. An axial-flow compressor consisting of guide vanes and a rotor was used. The rotor blades were constructed with NACA 65- serie s 10-percent-thick airfoil sections, for which cascade data were available. The cascade data were obtained in porous wall cascades which closely approximate two-dimensional-flow conditions by removing the boundary layer from the walls enclosing the blade row. A more com-plete discussion of porous-wall cascades can be found in reference. 3. The porous-wall cascade data were taken from reference 1. In order to determine the manner in which the cascade and rotating blade flows differed, blade surface pressure distributions, and entering and leaving velocities were measured at three radial positions in the test compressor. The measurement of pressures on the rotating blades was made possible through the use of a pressure-transfer device (reference 5), which simultaneously transmitted 24 pressures from the rotor to the stationary manometer.

rm^t Os Of

c blade chord, inches

blade section lift coefficient

c normal-force coefficient

M Mach number

P static pressure, pounds per square foot

H total pressure, pounds per square foot

q dynamic pressure, pounds per square foot

r radius to any blade element, inches

Page 4: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

CO- -

NACA RM L51H20 1 3

R Reynolds number

t blade thickness, inches

U rotational velocity of rotor blade at any radius, feet per second

velocity of air relative to casing, feet per second

a. angle of attack; angle between entering air dnd chord line, degrees

inlet air angle; angle between entering air and axial direction, degrees

e turning angle; angle through which the air is turned by the blade element, degrees

a solidity, blade chord divided by gap between blades

41 yaw angle

Subscripts:

1. entering guide vanes

2. leaving guide vanes

3. entering rotor, relative to rotor

ax axial direction

Stations: -

I instrument station ahead of guide vanes -

II instrument station between guide vanes and rotor

III instrument station behind rotor

APPARATUS

General arrangement.- The 42-inch tip diameter axial-flow test com-pressor used in this investigation (fig. i) contained a single row of guide vanes and a single row of rotor blades. The guide vanes were installed during a previous testing program and were retained to

- '- ,-

Page 5: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

- - NACA RM L511120

establish a free-vortex flow ahead of the rotor. The entrance and test section of the compressor were enclosed in a frame building. Half the building was mounted on rails and. was rolled open to expose the bell-mouth inlet of the compressor. The rotor drive motor was a 1000-horsepower synchronous electric motor supplied by a variable-frequency converter. The general configuration was essentially as described in reference 5, with the exception that the ducting downstream of the first diffuser was replaced by a vane-type throttle valve.

Rotor blades. - A sketch of the rotor blades is shown in figure 2. The blades, 24 in all, were d.esigned to-straighten the free-vortex flow leaving the guide vanes int6 an axial flow. At a design inlet air angle

of 600 (the design angle of attack referred to in this paper will be for an air inlet angle of 600) from root to tip the quantity flow coef-ficient (Q,,41D3 ) became 1.32, and the axial velocity was, constant through the blading. NACA 65-series compressor blade sections were used. The blade cambers and angles of attack were determined from the design charts in reference 4 Three blades contained 24 static-pressure orifices each for pressure-distribution measurements. The orifices were located at the outboard, mean, and inboard sections. The outboard and inboard sections were located 1 inch from ends of the blades to avoid the wall boundary layer. The blades had a span of 6.5 inches and a constant

chord of 5.5 inches, thus an aspect ratio of 1.182. The blade clear-ance at the tip was about 0.030 inch. The blade sections tested are described in the following table:

Outboard Mean Inboard Design lift coefficient. 1.096 1.200 1.304'

1.050 1.183 1.355 Solidity ..........118.10 46.10 Blade angle. ..........

t/c..............10 .10 .10

The blade angle is measured between chord line and axis of rotation. Vector diagrams to scale for typical design conditions are shown in

figure 3.

Guide vanes. - The row of guide vanes contained 37 blades; each 'had a span of 6.5 inches and a constant chord of 4 inches. The guide vanes produced a free-vortex velocity profile at station 2 as shon by the turning-angle comparison in figure 14. The angles were measured in the uniform flow between adjacent guide-vane wakes. The prewhirl is against the direction of rotation of the rotor, contrary to conventional axial-flow compressor practice.

Pressure-transfer device.- The pressure-transfer device used in reference 3 was not completely satisfactory in that mercury escaped through the pressure leads causing erroneous readings. A transparent

Page 6: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

-

NACA RM L51H20 5

plastic model of one cell of the transfer device was built to determine the cause of the difficulty. By running this model at various speeds with various amounts of mercury, it was found that the mercury splashed only at low rotor speeds, or with too much mercury in the cell. This splashing was eliminated by introducing the mercury into the transfer device after the rotor was started and draining the transfer device before stopping the rotor. The 24-ceU transfer device was then modified so that the mercury could be introduced into each cell under pressure while the rotor was running and drained before stopping. As further protection against mercury entering the pressure leads, small glass reservoirs were connected to the leads between the transfer device and manometer board. After these changes were made, no further trouble was experienced with the transfer device.

Instrumentation and flow measurements.- Total pressure, static pres-sure, and flow direction were measured at three survey stations (fig. 1(b)) with instruments of the type shown in figure 5(b). At each of these stations, surveys could be made in a radial direction. In addition, the instrument between the guide vanes and the rotor could be traversed circumferentially as well as radially.

Survey instruments were calibrated in a 15-inch-diameter calibration tunnel and are accurate in yaw angle to ±0.2 of a degree and in static pressure to ±0.3 percent of the impact pressure when mounted in a uni-form stream. No correction to the total pressure was necessary. The static pressure indicated by the instrument was higher than true static pressure. A typical calibration curve is shown in figure 6.

In the course of the investigation, it was found that at certain angles of attack the wakes of the guide vanes impinged. on the instrument located behind the rotor (station III), causing erroneous readings. This source of error was minimized by installing another identical instrument in the same plane but one and one-half guide-vane spacings away circumferentially and considering the data from the instrument which indicated the higher total pressure to be correct.

METHOD OF TESTING

Blade pressure distribution, total pressure, static pressure, and flow direction ahead of and behind the rotor were measured at nine angles of attack, at the outboard, mean, and inboard sections at each of four speeds, 800, goo ., 1000, and 114O rpm. The angles of attack at the mean diameter were varied from 90 up to the stall point by throttling the discharge. All pressure measurements, including the blade pressure distribution at a given blade section, were recorded simultaneously by photographing a multiple-tub.e manometer board.

Page 7: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

6 SFProw NACA RN L511120

For the tuft investigation of the rotor blade passages, nylon tufts were mounted on the blades In rows normal to the flow direction. Five rows were spaced across the blade chord. Each row was mounted on a sepa-rate blade so that the air passing over a row of tufts was not affected by any preceding tufts. Tufts were also mounted on-the exposed surface of the rotor hub between two adjacent blades. The tufts were observed with the aid of a high-speed stroboscopic light. A contact mounted on the rotor shaft triggered the light at the same instant on each revo-lution of the shaft. The result, viewed through a port In the outer casing, was a stationary picture of the tufts on one blade as affected by the air stream. By shifting the contactor on the rotor shaft, the other rows of tufts were observed. Observations of the tufts were made over the range of angles of attack.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Blade section pressure distributions.- Blade' section pressure dis-tributions at the outboard, mean, and 'Inboard sections at varying quan-tity flow and constant speed are presented in figure 7. The quantity flOws and corresponding angles of attack for the three sections are pre-sented in these figures. As the mass flow is reduced from 0.018 slug per second, the pressure distributions at all three sections become peaked at the leading edge of the upper surface at the same rate. At a mass flow of 0.012 slug per second all three sections are close to the angle of attack at which they would stall. This is shown by the sharpness of the leading-edge pressure peaks, indicating a large adverse pressure gradient, conducive to separation. As the mass flow is increased above 0.018 slug per second, the pressure distributions at all three sections become peaked at the leading edge of the lower surface, indi-cating the approach of negative stall.

An interesting phenomenon shown In these plots is the point of nearly constant pressure coefficient (hence velocity ratio) at about the 20-percent-chord point on the upper surface at all angles of attack and all sections. Examination of pressure distributions obtained from compressor airfoils in low-speed cascade substantiates this phenomenon. The position of constant pressure coefficient or velocity ratio varies from one cascade arrangement to another, but for êny given cascade a particular point on the convex surface somewhere between 15 and 25 percent chord from the leading edge maintains the same velocity ratio as the inlet angle is varied. The phenomenon of having a point of constant velocity ratio has not been confirmed at high speed nor for blades other than the NACA 65-series. If this continues to exist under compressible-flow conditions, it would be possible to determine impact and static pressures in a multistage axial-flow compressor at desired radial stations by orifices located at the proper chordwise position of the stator blades and pitot tubes. ,

Page 8: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

NACA RM L711120 ' 7

Figure 8 shows the effect of rotor inlet Mach number M3 and

Reynolds number on the pressure distribution for three sections at design angle of attack. It can be seen that over the small range of speed covered by these tests there is little change in the pressure distributions.

The pressure distributions for the end points of the angle of attack, Mach number, and Reynolds number ranges over which the blades were tested are shown in figure 9. The distributions indicate a slight increase in the pressure peaks with Reynolds number for the extreme off-design condi-tions. Although tufts placed on the, blades indicated large radial flows in the boundary layer at the high angles of attack, the pressure distri-butions at all sections are very much alike.

Pressure distributions measured in the test compressor are compared with those obtained from interpolation of porous-wall cascade data in figure 10. The pressure distribution measured at the outboard section in the blower had a slightly higher peak velocity and greater area than measured in the cascade. This is consistent-with the greater turning angle measured in the compressor as is discussed in the turning-angle comparisons. At the mean and inboard sections, good agreement can be observed. The wave observed at the GO-percent-chord point in the convex-surface pressure distributions obtained in the cascade Is not present in compressor or theoretical distributions (reference 6). (In reference 6, Dr. Katzoff compared theoretical pressure distributions of the NACA 65-(12)10 blade profile at the design angle of attack at a stagger of Eo° for two solidities which bracket design conditions of the rotor at the mean section.)

The wave or bump in the porous-wall cascade pressure distributions is due to a small region of laminar separation which occurs at the transition point from laminar to turbulent flow. Laminar flow was possible because of the low turbulence and low Reynolds numbers (about 20,000) of the cascade tests. , This separation does not occur in the test blower because of its higher Reynolds numbers (about 700,000) and higher turbulence level due to the wakes from the guide vanes. At each section, the datum point shown on the trailing edge was obtained from the static pressure measured by the survey instrument behind the blades. The pressure rise measured in the compressor is less than that measured in the cascade tunnel because of the boundary-layer growth on the inner and outer casings. The boundary layer on the cascade walls is removed by surface suction and so a higher static-pressure rise is obtained.

Page 9: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

8 SFr _____ NCA IM L511120

Comparison of Turning Angles

in Compressor and Cascade

Plots of trning against angle of attack from both compressor . and cascade data are presented in figure 11. The angles are the true geo-metric (measured) air angles. Since the cascade tests were run at con-stant inlet air angles, the cascade data were interpolated to obtain turning-angle values at the same angles of attack and inlet angles, as the compressor. Interpolation between blade cambers and solid.ities was also necessary. In figure 12 the angles presented were obtained from a vector diagram having the measured tangential components and an axial velocity equal to the mean of the measured entering and leaving velocities. This method of correction, which is illustrated by the vector diagram in figure 13, is in common use for determining a, P ., and e when the axial velocity is not constant. Correcting the angles to a condition of - constant axial velocity reduced the scatter of the blower test points. Some of the scatter may be attributed to the wind gusts present as . the intake of the compressor was outdoors.

At the outboard section, the turning angles measured in the com-pressor were about 10 greater than predicted from cascade data and the trend was similar except at the lowest angles of attack (fig. 12(a)).

At the rotor-blade mean section, the turning angles measured are very close to those p

' redicted from cascade data except at high angles of

attack where the slop of the compressor turning-angle curve is higher and the turning angles are greater than in cascade (fig. 12(b)).

At the inboard section, the turning angle compares well with cas-cade data only near design conditions 0 60, a = 15.30 ). The slope of the compressor turning-angle curve is much greater than that of the c'ascade curve. To be certain that the high turning angles measured actually occurred and were not caused by instrument errors due to the effect of the guide vane wakes on the instruments at station III, the air angles were also measured by observing a tuft through a transparent port in the outer case. Figure 14 i 's a plot of the air angle relative to the axis of the rotor measured by the instrument against radial dis-tance. The angles measured by the tuft observations were essentially the same as those measured by the survey instrument. The rapid change in angle from a radius of 16.0 inches to the inner case indicates that the secondary effects due to the boundary layer extend beyond the inboard measuring station which is at a radius of 15.5 inches. No information is available on the effect of the case boundary layer on the blade pres-sure distribution or turning angle. An analysis of main stream and blade boundary-layer flow and their probable effect on the turning angle at the inboard section of the blade follows.

Page 10: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

C NACA BM L5 111 20 N 9

Considering the flow entering the rotor when the compressor is operating at design conditions, the tangential velocity components of the main flow are approximately equal in magnitude to the tangential velocity of the rotor although .they are in opposite directions. Thus the radial pressure gradient produced by the main flow is just sufficient to balance the centrifugal force of the boundary layer on the leading part of the blades, and the result is radial equilibrium of the boundary layer. At the rear part of the blade the main flow has zero tangential velocity and thus there is no radial pressure gradient and the boundary-layer flows toward the tip of the blade due to centrifugal force. At intermediate points from leading to trailing edge, the boundary-layer flows more and more toward the tip of the blade. This suggests that where the boundary layer is flowing toward the tip of the blade, the inboard boundary layer must be being thinned out. In the case of the inboard section at design angle of attack the normally thick inboard boundary layer has been thinned sufficiently to make the rotor per-formaiice comparable to two-dimensional cascade performance.

At angles of attack greater than design, the air flow entering the rotor has a lower tangential velocity than that of the rotor. At the trailing edge the tangential velocity of the main stream is increased to about 30 percent of the rotor tangential velocity at highest angles of attack. This causes a reduction in the radial pressure gradient over most of the blade and allows greater centrifuging of the boundary layer than at the design condition. Thus at the inboard section for higher angles of attack the boundary layer is thinned more than in the corre-sponding cascade. The main flow follows the camber line of the blade more closely and, consequently, the turning angle is increased propor-tionately higher than in cascade for a given increase in angle of attack. For angles of attack lower than design, the inverse is true. The air flow entering the rotor has higher tangential velocities than at design, and the radial pressure gradient is larger in the forward section of the blade passage. At the leading edge, the tangential velocity of the main flow is sufficient to cause the leading-edge boundary layer to flow toward the root of the blade. The result is a reduced net spanwise flow of the boundary layer. For low angles of attack at the inboard section, the boundary layer remains thicker than in the two-dimensional cascade and results in proportionately lower turning angles for the com-pressor.

The boundary-layer flow was observed by meansiof small nylon tufts glued to the blades and to the rotor hub between the blades and illuminated with a stroboscopic light. As shown in figure 15(a), the boundary layer on the rotor hub flows from the lower surface of one blade to the upper surface of the preceding blade, that is, from a region of high pressure to one of low pressure. This flow pattern remained unchanged. over the angle-of-attack range, except that the tufts in the region just above the trailing edge (marked x) pinwheeled at the highest angles of

Page 11: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

10 SFf NPLCA 1RM L51H20

attack as though in a stalled turbulent region. The radial flow in the boundary layer on the blade surfaces is indicated by the tufts as shown in figure 15(b). The directions of the tufts as shown are uncorrected for their own centrifugal effect, as the extent to which centrifugal force contributes to the tuft position is unknown. In figure 15(b) the flow was near the design condition. At higher angles of attack the tufts deviated more from the axial direction and at low angles the deviation was less.

Effect of Rotor Wakes on Instrument Accuracy

The survey instrument behind the rotor was in a flow of rapidly varying direction and velocity. As each blade wake passed the survey-instrument wake, it swept over the pressure tubes., The wake was composed of low-velocity' air and therefore has a different direction relative to the survey instrument than the main stream. This would result in the survey instrument yawing away from the main stream into the direction of the wakes, and could possibly account for some of the differences between cascade and compressor curves for a against e shown In figures 11 and 12. It would be desirable to make flow measurements of a rotor without guide vanes (to avoid guide-vane wakes) using a yaw instrument traveling with the rotor to determine the magnitude of this effect.

Since the wake and main stream velocities differ in both magnitude and direction, it appears that they would mix. This is not the case. Although the wake and free stream had different tangential velocities, they do not meet because of the difference In their axial velocities. As this concept has proved confusing to some people, the manner In which the particles travel Is now described.

In rotational coordinates, the main stream leaving the rotor and the rotor-blade wakes travel at different speeds in essentially the same direction as shown in figure 16(a). Changing the velocity distribution to stationary coordinates by subtracting the rotational velocity of the rotor results in the distribution shown in figure 16(b). Replacing the stationary velocity distribution with streamlines results in figure 16(c).

At first glance figure 16(c) seems to indicate that particles travel. across the main stream and abruptly change direction as they flow across the wake. This, however, is not the case. Since figure 16(c) is an instantaneous picture, it can be seen that although particles , in the main stream travel along the streamlines, they never enter the wakes, and that particles in the wake remain in the wake. The magnitude of the instrument error that results from these fluctuations in velocity is at the present unknown. Its direction is such as to increase the measured turning angle.

Page 12: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

NACA RN L51H20 rON 11

Effect of Guide-Vane Wakes on Instrument Accuracy

The pattern of the data obtained from the instrument behind the rotor indicated that the flow was not uniform in the circumferential direction. The guide vanes seemed to be the most likely cause of this lack of uniformity. To determine the shape and magnitude of the defects produced by the guide-vane wakes behind the rotor, the flow was surveyed using a 16-tube total pressure rake (fig. 5(a)) mounted in place of the usual instrument at station III. Plots of the total pressure defect for several angles of attack at station III are shown for the outboard, mean, and inboard sections in figures 17(a ), 17(b ), and 17(c), respectively. Since the instrument was stationary, the shift of the defects shown was due to the increased turning of the air through the rotor with increased angles of attack. In order to obtain accurate data for the determination of 6, an additional instrument was mounted one and one-halfguide-vane spaces away in the tangential direction. Thus, one or the other of , the instruments was in the uniform stream. It was found that in general the total momentum defect of the flow was not appreciably reduced in passing through the rotor as shown in figure 18. In fact, except at the mean section for angles of attack near design, the measured total momentum defect behind the rotor was equal to or larger than the defect measured between the guide vanes and rotor. The greater defect was probably due to the increase in angle of attack of the rotor blades on entering the low-velocity air of the wake and to the static-pressure rise through the rotor. The larger wake ahead of the rotor shown in figure 18(c) is due to a support strut.

Normal-Force Coefficients

As a check on the accuracy of the pressure distributions, the normal-force coefficients were computed from the compressor data by three methods: (1) integration of measured pressure distributions CNp)

(2) from the measured changes in momentum and static pressure neglecting the drag force, CN, and (3) from the inlet angle and turning angle

assuming constant-axial velocity with no loss in total pressure, CN.

Plots of these coefficients are shown in figure 19. The values of CN cOmputed from the pressure distribution CN differ from those computed

from momentum change CN primarily because of experimental inaccuracies

and radial flow. The value of C will ordinarily be higher since it

represents an ideal condition. In general CN and C are in goodNM

agreement, indicating that radial flow and profile drag have a small effect. The values of CN and C are in progressively worse agreementNM

Page 13: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

12 SE N NACA RM L51H20

with CN 6 as e is increased, primarily because the ideal theoretical

static-pressure rise, was not realized. The measured static-pressure rise was used in computing CN and the ideal in computing CNè. The differ-ence between the measured and the ideal pressure rise was greatest at highest angles of attack where the large radial flow of the boundary layer produced high turning angles that were used in computing the values

Of C 0

CONCLUSIONS

The turning angles, pressure rise, and pressure distribution about the blades of a rotor having 65-series compressor blades were'measured and compared with similar data for the same blade profiles measured in a two-dimensional porous-wall cascade tunnel. Guide vanes, necessary to produce a free-vortex flow ahead of the rotor, produced secondary disturb- ances not present in the cascade. The secondary effects are considered small enough 'to permit a direct comparison of rotor and cascade data. From an examination of the data, it is found that:

1. The two-dimensional cascade tunnel data agreed closely with the rotor data at the design conditions of the rotor.

.2. At off-design angles of attack, differences were observed in performance; secondary flows have a large effect on the operating charac-teristics of the rotor. This result was found especially true near the inner and outer casings. The deviations in performance were attributed to radial flow of the blade-surface boundary layer due to centrifugal force being out of balance with the radial static-pressure gradient.

3. The total-pressure defects produced by the upstream row of stator blades were not significantly dispersed by the rotor, but rather the integrated total-pressure defect was greater after passing through the rotor.

4• The ratio be the local velocity and the entering velocity remains nearly constant at one paint on the convex surface of NACA 65-series compressor blades. If this phenomenon exists at high speeds, it may be used to determine impact and static pressures in a multistage axial-flow compressor by orifices located at the desired radial stations at the proper chordwise position of the stator blades and pitot tubes.

Langley Aeronautical Laboratory National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics

Langley Field, Va.

SNOW

Page 14: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

NASA BM L51H20 Sfl . ON 13

1. Weske, John R.: An Investigation of the Aerodynamic Characteristics of a Rotating Axial-Flow Blade Grid. NACA TN 1128, 1947.

2. Mihlemann, Ernst: Experiinentelle Unterpuchungen an ether axialen Geblasestufe., Mitt. Nr. 12, Inst. fur Aero. Tech. H. S. Zurich, Gebr. Leemann & Co. (Zirich), 1946.

3. Erwin, John R., and Emery, James C.: Effect of Tunnel Configuration and Testin Technique on Cascade Performance. NACA TN 2028, 1950.

4. Herrig, L. Joseph, Emery, James C., and Erwin, John R.: Systematic Two-Dimensional . Cascade Tests of NACA 65-Series Compressor Blades at Low Speeds. NACA RM L51G31, 1951 . -

5. Runckel, Jack F., and Davey, Richard S.: Pressure-Distribution Measurements on the Rotating Blades of a Single-Stage Axial-Flow Compressor. NACA TN 1189, 1947.

6. Katzoff, Samuel, and Hannah, Margery S.: Further Comparisons of Theoretical and Experimental Lift and Pressure Distributions on Airfoils in Cascade at Low-Subsonic Speeds. NACA TN 2391, 1951.

Page 15: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

37

Vane-type otUe

---

SFJ" N NACA RN L51H20

B1oier

(a) Schematic sketch of compressor test arrangement. (All linear dimensions are in feet.)'

Survey stations

Support struts 4/ Pressure tea to aneter 1 Ti

Pressure-transfer device

Support struts

i- Guide vanes

(b) Schematic sketch of test section. (All linear dimensions are in inches.)

Figure l. - General arrangement.

Page 16: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

Outboard

NACA RM L511120 SW' ON 15

Axis of rotation

5.5 48' . 1 0—'.

Outboard

Orifice

IL)

KA

locations

Mean

46.l0 Inboard

- I

I I L -----------

•1

Linear dimensions are in inches.Inboard

ç;77'

Figure 2.— Sketch of rotor blades.

Page 17: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

16

E wow P.

NACA RM L51H20

O)

is

<Zzz:^^

0 r4

4.)

0

•H

0) rd

4.) cc

bU

•-1 rd

4.) r1 C.) 0

r-1 0)

cy

0)

•r-I

Page 18: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

NACA RM L511120 iON 17

0 I I I I I I

Free vortex

® Measured.0

0

0

Inboard .

0 - Mean -

Outboard

00 - - 0

H H H . H

I II I I 1.1 I • • I I I 15.0 16.0 17.0 18.0 190 ta ra

Radial position, incles

Figure Il..- Comparison of measured guide-vane turning angle with angles required for free-vortex flow.

50

54

H

ct to S

142

36

314

30

Page 19: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

nN

18 C.. N NACA RM L71H20

4 —v--

— M Mfr9 -. 0;_

.1 __ *fr .j F(\

co

CO

j j ,-

rr *a

*0

— f

4

eff

AVAP

cd

•'-1-'

aja) H 0

:3t 4J

Cd

-S

'do)

co I +

HO aiH a)

4J 4-3 0 C E-14-

a) -p

Cd r_4

0 U)

•H

VI)

a)0)

0)

H aJ

4) 0

E-i

Page 20: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

I I I I

4

41 z

1-4

-

-HI I I

0 0

D A

0

0 0 (V.'

0

UN 43 CV

0

) 4)

Cd

-I ,0

QV o

cd.

0I N

Cd 0 r1

a) .I +

Cd 4.'a) I

.-1

D

-4

NACA RM L5 111 20 0001% 1

19

0 1A 0 0 CM CJ

(Jbs/q) (I 3_PJ.nSe9U1) uoiuoo ansed ot

Page 21: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

a U Mass flow (slugs/sec

5..124° .028

84° 147° .024 -- -- 10.8° 7.0° .020

124° 17.3° .018 ----13.4° 8.5° .016 -----17.8° 9.6° .012

0 — Upper surface E3 — Lower surface _Design condition

ao

1.8

1.6

.8

.6

.4

20 SI:'

NACA EM L51H20

II

1.2

q3

1.0

Cr

P/

N - // N •\\ N

I

\.\ \

\

16/

\\\ 'I

\ I / \ \\ •\

\ \ - 0\

0

'\ \ \ \

\ \

II I

' \\\ \ \ \\

\\ \\ -

.220 40 60

80 100

Percent chord

(a) Outboard section

Figure 7.- Pressure distributions at various angles of attack.

Page 22: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

NACA RM L711120 0#10"rON 21

.8

11.6

.4

.2

1.0

Th q3

.8

.6

.4

I ' a B Mass flow (slugs/sec) 8.9° 14.70 .028

107° 7.4° .024 132° 18.9° .020 14.3° 20.00 .018 15.6° 20.8° .016

\ -----19.0° 22.66 .012

o'

0 - Upper surface -

O-•0 Lower surface

- —Design condition P /

0/ ..' b

N

? \ \

" \ N \ \ \ \\

I I

'

\ \ \

\

\\

It'\

\\

Q \\ \.

\\ \ S -\ \ \ \

El,,, I ,, S

\

5 \• \\\ -

N'

/ -d

- -

-

.2 L 0 20 40 60

Percent chord

(b) Mean section.

Figure 7.- Continued.

80 100

Page 23: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

22 SE NACA RM L71H20 WI..

L8

.1.6

.4

12

1.0

Th q3

S

.6

.4

2 kI I I

0 20 40 60 80 iIOO Percent chord

(c) Inboard section.

Figure 7.- Concluded.

Page 24: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

fo"rON NACA RM L71H20

1.6 -

23

1.4

1.2

1.0

q3

B

.6

.4

.2

0

a 9 N3. R

12.2° 17.4° .253 820,000 12.4° 17.3° .284 930,000

- - 12.4° 17.2° .318 1,040,000 - - - - 12.2° I7.2 .365 1190,000

0 -Upper surface 0 Lower surface

WI 0 20 40 60 80 100

Percent chord

(a) Outboard section.

Figure 8.-. Pressure distributions at design angle of attack, with M3 V1'

Page 25: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

NACA RM L511120

1.6

1.4

a 8 M3 R 14.3° 20.0° .262 860,000

- - - - - - -

142° 14.3°

20.0° 19.9°

295 960,000 328 1,060,000

- 14.4° 192° 378 1,220,000

0 — Upper surface D -Lower surface

1.2

10

q3

.8

.6

- .4

2

20 40 60 Percent chord

(1) Mean section.

• Figure 8.- Continued.

POW

'VU

Page 26: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

NACA RM 1,51H20 27

1.6

'.4

a 8 M3 R

16.2° 20.4° .279 860,000 -----16.2° 21.2° .315 960,000

--16.4° ----15.8°

2150 351 1,060,000 21.5° 399 1,220,000

0 — Upper surface 0 — Lower surface

1.2

1.0

q3

.8

.6

.4

2

0.L 0

20 40 60 80 100 Percent chord

(c) Inboard section,

Figure 8. - Concluded. .

Page 27: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

1.8

16

1.4

12

q3

.8

.6

4

26 NACA RM L71H20

- I I I I I 0 20 40 60 80 100

Percent chord

(a) Outboard section.

Figure 9.- Pressure distriI5ütions at highest and l6west angles of attack.

Page 28: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

NPtCA EM L511120 400WON 27

2.0

18

1.6

.4

2

q3 H-

1.0

.8

.6

.4

.20 20 40 60 80 100

Percent chord

(b) Mean section.

Figure 9. - Continued.

-I

Page 29: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

28

SNACA RM L511120

L8

1.6

'.4

.2

q3

.0

.8

.6

.4

20 80 100 20 40 60

Percent chord

(c) Inboard section.

Figure 9.- Concluded.

Page 30: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

S _.. ._JON NACA RM L511120

1.6

/ - T1.14

1.2

1.0

H - q3

.8

S

r

Cascade - - - 1.0 600 16.90

a

Blower 1.05 12.20 600 17.70

21 I I

0 20 140 60 80 100 Percent chord

(a) 65-( 10 .96)10 (outboard section).

Figure 10. - Comparison of blower and cascade pressure distributions at design angle of attack.

-

.6

.14

Page 31: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

30 SEC NACA RM L511120

1.6

1.14

1.2

1.0

H - q3

.8

.6

.14

.2

1 I

--

I' I

I. I N.

\%. I \s \ ..% I \\ - \ \ \\

I. \\ L \\

\\ ji

\

L -

- - - - Cascade 1.183 114.10 60° 19.70 Blower 1.183 14.10 600 19.80

I I 20 140 60 80 100

Percent chord

(b) 67-.(12)10 (mean section).

Figure 10.- Continued.

Page 32: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

NACA RM L51H20 -" 31

1.6

1.14

1.2

'I II I "S

II 'I ' I IN

II \ N i/-

\ I

\ \

\\

\\ \\ \\ \\

--S. '-S

1.0

H) -

q3

.8

.6

.14

a a 5'.

-S

- - - - Cascade 1.3 1.30 600 21.30 Blower ,1.3 1.30 60° 21.50

.20 20 140 60

Percent chord

(c) 65-(13.04)io (inboard section).

Figure 10.- Concluded.

80 100

Page 33: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

32 si;-

NACA RM L51H20

214

22

bo

20

Cd

18

I16

114

12

10

0 — 800 RPM - 900 RPM

1000 RPM

— 1140 RPM0 -

Compressor

'-U -

- DCascade

- 0/

LI / /

/ /

/

/ /

/ /

/

CA

14 6 8 10 12 14 16

Angle of attack, a deg.

(a) At the outboard section.

Figure 11.- Turning angle against angle of attack.

Page 34: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

MACA RM L51H20 OOMWON .33

- 800 RPM - K— 900 RPM

1000' RPM LI —

1110 RPM

Compressor

to 0

Cascade - • - • .

(,LJ

/

/

/

- /

6 8 10. 12 14 16 18 •. 2C

I I I I I,

S

Angle of attack, a deg.

• • (b) At the mean section.'ection

Figure 1I. - Continued.

• 26

• 24

Cd

0

bC

20

16

• 12

Page 35: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

311. SE UN NACA BM L511120

• 32LAI

0 — 800 RPM 0- 900 RPM

b - 1000 RPM

1— 1140 RPM

CD

ho

Compressor bD

.26

I214 EO

' I

-

22 - - Cascade -

20

/ /• 4d

18- - A

/

I I I .0 12 ih 16 18 20 29 2b

Angle of attack, a deg,

(c) At the inboard section.

Figure 11.- Concluded.

16..

Page 36: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

14 - J.J - - -L4 .l.'J A.

cD

a a,

r1 ho

bO

NACA RM L511120 35

Angle of attack, a

(a) At the outboard section.

Figure 12.-.Turning angle against angle of attack, corrected to a mean axial velocity.

Page 37: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

CD

S -

36 SW T-ION NACA RM L71H20

Angle of attack, a

(b) At the mean section.

Figure 12.- Continued.

0.^^^

Page 38: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

100 ' 120 140 160 180 200 220 210

CD

'I

ho

NACA RML511120 ')N 37

Angle of attack, a

(c) At the inboard section.

Figure 12.- Concluded.

Page 39: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

38 Si NACA RM L51H20

IL)

V

V

$ U

U

4) C-, II)

r4

0 0

O) 4)

rj r1 00

E -

r1 )q5

cda)

0o

r1 Q) rd rl

bD

0C

Ij) H Cd

I-I

•H

Page 40: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

NAC! RM L51H20

39

I I .. II

- .. O--a11.3° - .

El 12.80 -

• .

- -

to • -0 17 . 00 -

g__a=19.10 .

LO

LO

Inboard Outboard

401.O 16.0 • • 17.0- 18.0 . 19.0 :20.0 21.

0

0

a)

a)

.r1 4-) 0

S..

Radial position, inches

Figure 114.— Flow direction behind the rotor for various angles of attack at mean section;

Page 41: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

0 —J Li.

cr

z 0

F—

F-0

H^t

C iDENTIATOV

S4rTY INPrl

NACA RM L51H20

n I.

\ U

\ re%_4

2N.bD cd

Cc

cli

rd Cd

Cc

Cd

Cd

pq

Cd

'a) 4)

cd

+

ci)

Page 42: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

a)

4)

R rc 0 N-

) N— 0 H

rdo

Cd

0

a) -1 H 4D cd d

Cc a) rj

ro rl H 0H C) Sc cUa) 0 Jrd C)

caj I

LC\ cd H

r0j a) a)

0 4) H Oa) çx1

Cd

0

co

+0

0

C) 4) ci)

Isd Ct

4

\ ' ' %

\

NACA RM L511120

41

Page 43: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

42 S NACA RM L511120

\ Blade row

\\ \

' \ \\\ -- \

\ \ \ \ \\ \ \ \ \ \\

\\ \ ' \ \ \ \ \\\

\• \ \

\ \ \ ç

-' \ \ \\\\ \ \ \ \ \ \

\\\\ \ \ - \ _\ \ Wake

\ #\\

\ \ \

\. \

•\

\\c\

\\\ \ ' Wake

-

\ \\

\ \. \\ \ \ c.

\\\ \ \ \ \\\\ \\\\

-'

\\

\ \ ' \ \ Wake\

_\. \

\ \ \ \\\\\\ \\ \ \

\ \ \\ \ \\\\

\\

(a) Flow behind the rotor in rotating coordinates.

Figure 16.- Wake patterns.

Page 44: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

Blade row

/ //Ifl\\, 1/ I

4,

Wake

f/I Wake

Wake

(b) Velocity distribution behind the rotor in stationary coordinates.

Figure 16.- Continued.

NACA RM L71H20

43 —w

Page 45: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

44. S NACA RM L511120

V I I.

I I I , I / /

Blade row

III II

jI

I / I \

I l I

I // I

I I I I I '-1

I / Wake Ii

/ 111 11 111 /. ,Il /

I/I I I I / / I / I /•

,'1Wake/ I /

I I,I

,•' ,': /

/ / I '• /

/ II I

/I

/ / I I I / i./

I

/ \Wake /

,'•

II ii II II I ,/ /

CA

(c) Flow behind the rotor in stationary coordinates.

Figure 16.- Concluded.

Page 46: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

NPLCA RM L711120 45

Ci IV

CD

.c. 0)

'I

0 Cd

Cd

0

tLD

Cl)

a) H

Cd

H Cd

0)

ci) 0)

0 cl—I

(Y

0

Cd

•-4

+ U)

+ Cd

U)

Cd

0)

cd

ci)

•1-4

H

ci)

•H

1i

0 "0 0

.4)

0

U)

Cd 0

0

Page 47: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

o • -1 •H + 4) o 11) 0

Cd

Cl) ()

1 I

Q) N—z

- a)

.-I

r.4

QMVT

46 S9 NACA RML51H2O

Page 48: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

o . o O 0 'd • .,-I :i

+' H 0 0 a) u) 0

Cd

0

-I I

0 N-H

NACA EM L51H20 S' J'IN

0ir

Page 49: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

2

2(

1

Ahead of rotor L1111111 -

NACA RM L51H20

Behind rotor ()

1

1

40

20

DO ^_

801. .1 3

Distance normal to streamlines

(a) Rotor blade angle of attack of 12.70 ) at the outboard section.

Figure 18.- Change in guide-vane wakes on passing through the rotor.

Page 50: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

NACA RM L511120 0N

119

220

Ahead of rotor II

200

18c

• 160

c-I

ci

ito

----Behind rotor

12C

1OC

8o1 2 3

Distance normal to streamlines

(b) Rotor blade angle of attack of 1 1 .90 , at the mean section.

Figure 18.- Continued.

Page 51: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

C) ti) U)

C) 0

H t3)

50 SF' NECA BM L51H20

1 2 3 IL 5

Distance normal to streamlines

(c) Rotor blade angle of attack of 17.40 , at the inboard section.

Figure 18.- Concluded.

Page 52: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

•5

4)

a)

C)

a) 0 C)

a) C.)

2 .1

r1 Lfund

NACA RM L511120 S N 51

(cn)e From corrected a e curve

a (c) From area of pressure distribution I 0 - (c) From IrEasured change in static

pressure and momentum.

10 12 14 lb 10 20 22

Turning angle, e (Corrected) deg.

(a) Outboard section.

Figure 19.- Normal-force coefficient against turning angle.

Page 53: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

4

3

•. 0

0

'4

C)

C)

0 '4

52 SF N

NACA RM L51H20

z

S

I-- (c)9 From corrected a e curve I

I o - ( Cfl)p From area of pressure distribution

Io - ( ca) From measured change in static

I M pressure and momentum.

1H

I I I I

16 18 20 • 22 21i

Turning angle, e (Corrected) deg.

(b) Mean section.

Figure 19.- Continued.

Vow

Page 54: NACA - NASA · PDF filecomparison of naca 65-series compressor-blade ... the inner case. introduction ... 2 ..j-.-1.ll naca rm l51h20

73 NACA BM L71H2b

JpN.1;1-r.

Si uqATION

.7

.6

C)

4.,

4)

C) r1

c-s

r .3

.2

.1

16

I I

0 13

( cn)e From corrected a 0 curve

o - (c) From area of pressure distribution

0-- ( cfl )M From measured change in static -

pressure and momentum. -

1 • I I I 20 24 28 32 36

Turning angle, e (Corrected) deg.

(c) • Inboard section.

- Figure 19.— Concluded.

NACA-Langley - 11-16-51 - 325


Recommended