+ All Categories
Home > News & Politics > Nc for senate dec2

Nc for senate dec2

Date post: 08-Jul-2015
Category:
Upload: duwangcamarines
View: 270 times
Download: 1 times
Share this document with a friend
Popular Tags:
53
HOUSE BILL NO. 4820 AN ACT CREATING THE PROVINCE OF NUEVA CAMARINES A PRESENTATION TO THE SENATE November 15, 2011
Transcript
Page 1: Nc for senate dec2

HOUSE BILL NO. 4820

AN ACT CREATING THE PROVINCE OF NUEVA

CAMARINES

A PRESENTATION TO THE SENATENovember 15, 2011

Page 2: Nc for senate dec2

INTRODUCTION

2

HB NO. 4820 WAS

APPROVED IN THE HOUSE

OF CONGRESS WITH A VOTE OF 229 AGAINST 1

Page 3: Nc for senate dec2

FOUR (4) CAMARINES SUR

CONGRESSMEN JOINTLY

SPONSORED HB NO. 4820

1. Rep. Arnulfo P. Fuentebella (4th District)

2. Rep. Luis R. Villafuerte (3rd District)

3. Rep. Diosdado Arroyo (2nd District)

4. Rep. Rolando R. Andaya, Jr. (1st District)

Page 4: Nc for senate dec2

OTHER CONGRESSMEN SPONSORS

Page 5: Nc for senate dec2

MAJORITY OF THE LOCAL

LEADERS OF CAMARINES SUR

SUPPORT HB 4820

24 MAYORS

24 VICE MAYORS

MAJORITY OF COUNCILORS

MAJORITY OF BARANGAY CAPTAINS

NGOS AND CIVIC ORGNIZATIONS

BUSINESS SECTOR, AND

MANY NON-POLITICAL ORGS./GROUPS

Page 6: Nc for senate dec2

6

4TH DISTRICT

1 GOA HON. ANTERO S. LIM

2 CARAMOAN HON. CONSTANTINO H. CORDIAL, JR.

3 PRESENTACION HON. JOEY DELEÑA

4 SAGÑAY HON. EVELYN B. FUENTEBELLA

5 SIRUMA HON. KAREN POLINGA

6 TIGAON HON. ARNULF BRIAN B. FUENTEBELLA

7 TINAMBAC HON. RUEL T. VELARDE

5TH DISTRICT

8 IRIGA CITY HON. MADELAINE Y. ALFELOR-GAZMEN

9 BAAO HON. MELQUIADES I. GAITE

3RD DISTRICT

10 CALABANGA HON. EVELYN S. YU

11 BOMBON HON. MA. LUISA DC. ANGELES

12 CAMALIGAN HON.EMMANUEL T. PRADO

13 CANAMAN HON. EMMANUEL S. REQUEJO

2ND DISTRICT

14 GAINZA HON. WILLIAM ABILAY

15 LIBMANAN HON. MARILYN A. JIMENEZ

16 SAN FERNANDO HON. EUGENIO LAGASCA JR.

17 PAMPLONA HON. GEMINO IMPERIAL

18 MINALABAC HON. LEOVEGILDO BASMAYOR JR.

19 PASACAO HON. ASUNCION ARCEO

20 MILAOR HON. ROGELIO A. FLORES

MAYORS OF CAMARINES SUR

SUPPORTING HB 4820

Page 7: Nc for senate dec2

*CamarinesSur is the largest province in the Bicol

Region in terms of Land Area (30.23%) and

Population (33.17%)

BICOL REGION

COMPARATIVE STATISTICAL DATA

PROVINCE LAND AREA

(Km2)

POPULATION

2007

ALBAY 2,565.80 1,187,185

CAMARINES NORTE 2,320.10 513,785

* CAMARINES SUR 5,502.00 1,693,821

CATANDUANES 1,492.20 232,757

MASBATE 4,151.80 768,939

SORSOGON 2,119.00 709,673

Sources: LMB, NSCB &NSO 7

Page 8: Nc for senate dec2

1

2 3

4

5

PROFILE OF

CAMARINES

SUR

PARTICULARS CY 2010

NO. OF TOWNS 35

NO. OF CITIES (Iriga-component, Naga- chartered) 2

NO. OF CONGRESSIONAL DISTRICTS 5

NO. OF BARANGAYS 1,036

POPULATION 1,693,8218

Page 9: Nc for senate dec2

LEGAL BASIS OF HB NO. 4820

1. Article X, Section 10 of the 1987

Philippine Constitution.

2. Section 461 of R.A. 7160 - 1991

Local Government Code

Page 10: Nc for senate dec2

Article X, Section 10 of the

1987 Philippine Constitution

No province xxx may be

xxxDIVIDEDxxx or its boundary

substantially altered, EXCEPT in

accordance with the CRITERIA

established in the LOCAL

GOVERNMENT CODE and subject to

approval by a majority of the votes cast

in a PLEBISCITE in the political units

DIRECTLY AFFECTED.

Page 11: Nc for senate dec2

SECTION 461 OF R.A. 7160

1991 LOCAL GOVERNMENT CODE

1. Average income for the last two years of not less than

P20M, based on 1991 CPI (present value = P65M);

-and either-

2. Population of not less than 250,000;

-or-

3. Land area of not less tha 2,000 sq. km.

PROVIDED:

1. The division does not reduce the income population, or land

area of the LGU to less than the minimum requirements of

this Code; and

2. The income classification of the original LGU shall not fall

below its current classification prior to such division.

Page 12: Nc for senate dec2

LEGAL COMPLIANCE

OF HB NO. 4820 TO

SECTION 461 OF RA 7160(1991 LOCAL GOVERNMENT CODE)

Page 13: Nc for senate dec2

COMPLIANCE OF H.B.

4820 TO

SECTION 461

OF R.A. 7160

PARTICULARS REQUIREMENTS COMPLIANCE

CAMARINES SUR (MOTHER PROVINCE)

DISTS. 1,2&3

COMPLIANCE NUEVA

CAMARINES

(NEW PROVINCE)

DISTS 4 & 5

AVE. INCOME (1991 CPI)

AND EITHER

P20.0 M

(2010=P65M)

P283.48 M P223.4 M

POPULATION OR 250,000 892,203 801,618

LAND AREA (sq. km.) 2,000 2,531.60 2,970.40

BLGF CERTIFICATION – MARCH 10, 2011

NSO CERTIFICATION - MARCH 07, 2011

LMB CERTIFICATION - APRIL 07, 2011

13

Page 14: Nc for senate dec2

BLGF COMPUTATION OF THE

AVERAGE ANNUAL INCOME

TO COMPUTE FOR THE AVE. ANNUAL INCOME FOR

2009 & 2010, THE 2009 & 2010 INCOME SHOULD BE

DEFLATED BASED ON 1991 CPI

THE DEFLATORS WERE ARRIVED AS FOLLOWS:

1991 CPI(2000 as base year) = 53.60

2009 CPI(2000 as base year) = 160.00

2010 CPI(2000 as base year) = 166.10

2009 DEFLATOR = 160.00/53.60 = 2.985

2010 DEFLATOR = 166.10/53.60 = 3.099

14

Page 15: Nc for senate dec2

INCOME CLASSIFICATION BRACKET OF PROVINCES

1ST CLASS – P450.0 M OR MORE2ND CLASS – P360.0 M TO P 450.0 M3RD CLASS – P270.0 M TO P360.0 M4TH CLASS – P180.0 M TO P270.0 M5TH CLASS – P90.0 M TO P180.0 M6TH CLASS – BELOW P90.0

To compute income classification:

Get actual income last 4 years (2007-2010)

Get the average then compare with income brackets

15

INCOME CLASSIFICATION

Page 16: Nc for senate dec2

MOTHER PROVINCE REMAINS

AS A FIRST CLASS PROVINCE

YEAR INCOME

2007 P 567,475,416.64

2008 P 671,207,205.49

2009 P 848,188,234.55

2010 P 848,088,883.09

TOTALS P 2,934,959,739.09

DIVIDED BY 4 YEARS

AVE. INCOME P 733,739,934.94

SECTION 461 OF R.A. 7160 MANDATES THAT THE INCOME

CLASSIFICATION OF MOTHER PROVINCE IS NOT REDUCED

1ST CLASSPER DOF DO

NO. 23-08

DTD 7/29/09

BLGF Certification dated March 10, 2011

P450M Average

Income for 4 yrs

16

Page 17: Nc for senate dec2

NUEVA CAMARINES

AS A SEPARATE PROVINCE

MAY ALSO BECOME A

FIRST CLASS PROVINCE

YEAR COMPUTED INCOME

2007 P 478,288,701.38

2008 P 548,315,572.68

2009 P 648,611,023.38

2010 P 689,675,196.63

TOTALS P 2,364,890,494.07

DIVIDED BY 4 YEARS

AVE. INCOME P 591,222,623.52

1ST CLASSPER DOF DO

NO. 23-08

DTD 7/29/09

BLGF Certification dated March 10, 2011P450M Average

Income for 4 yrs17

Page 18: Nc for senate dec2

COMPARATIVE DATA ON NEW &

ORIGINAL (MOTHER) PROVINCE

1

2 3 4

5

MOTHER

PROVINCE

Dists. 1,2, & 3

NUEVA

CAMARINES

Dists. 4 & 5

BLGF CERTIFICATION – MARCH 10, 2011

NSO CERTIFICATION - MARCH 07, 2011

LMB CERTIFICATION - APRIL 07, 2011

18

PARTICULARS MOTHER PROVINCE

DISTS 1,2&3

NUEVA CAMARINES

DISTS. 4 & 5

NO. TOWNS 19 + NAGA CITY 16 + IRIGA CITY

POPULATION 892,203 801,618

LAND AREA (sq. km.) 2,531.60 2,970.40

AVE. INCOME (1991 CPI) P283.5 M P223.4 M

INCOME CLASSIFICATION(AVERAGE FOUR YEARS INCOME)

P733.7 M-1ST CLASS P591.2 M-1ST CLASS COMPUTED RESULTING INCOME

CLASSIFICATION

2010 REGULAR INCOME P 848.1 M P 689.7 M

Page 19: Nc for senate dec2

RATIONALE FOR PROPOSING TO

CREATE A NEW PROVINCE

1

2 3 4

5

MOTHER

PROVINCE

Dists. 1,2, & 3

NUEVA

CAMARINES

Dists. 4 & 5

19

1. GOOD GOVERNANCE

2. POVERTY INCIDENCE

Page 20: Nc for senate dec2

INDICATORS IN DETERMINING

GOOD GOVERNANCE

20

• ECONOMIC GOVERNANCE INDEX

• POLITICAL GOVERNANCE INDEX

• ADMINISTRATIVE GOVERNANCE INDEX

A. EDUCATION INDEX

B. HEALTH INDEX

C. POWER AND ICT INDEX

Page 21: Nc for senate dec2

PER NATIONAL STATISTICAL COORDINATION

BOARD (NSCB) ANALYSIS, THE FOLLOWING

ARE INDICATORS OF GOOD GOVERNANCE

• ECONOMIC GOVERNANCE INDEX• Total Financial Resources Generated Per

Capita

• Per Capita Tax and Non-Tax

• Per Capita Total Deposits

• Per Capita Expenditure on Social Services

• Unemployment Rate

• Underemployment Rate

• Inflation Rate

• Poverty Gap

• Poverty Incidence

Page 22: Nc for senate dec2

• POLITICAL GOVERNANCE INDEX•Crime Solution Efficiency Rate

•Voter’s Turnout Rate

• ADMINISTRATIVE GOVERNANCE INDEXA. EDUCATION INDEX• Elementary Teacher to Pupil Ratio

• High School Teacher to student Ratio

• No. of Public Elem. Sch. per 1000 School Age

population

• No. of Public High Sch. per 1000 School Age pop’n

INDICATORS OF GOOD GOVERNANCE

(C0NTINUED)

Page 23: Nc for senate dec2

A. EDUCATION INDEX (continued)• Enrolment in Gov’t. Elem Sch per 1000 Sch. Age Pop’n

• Enrolment in Gov’t. HS Sch per 1000 Sch. Age Pop’n

• Elementary Pupil-Classroom Ratio

• High School Pupil-Classroom Ratio

B. HEALTH INDEX – Total Health Personnel per 1000 Population

– % Birth less than 2500 grams

– % Of Household with access to safe water

– Barangay Health Station per 100,000 Population

C. POWER AND ICT INDEX– Power Index/Electrification

– ICT Index (Telephone Density per 1000 Population)

INDICATORS OF GOOD GOVERNANCE

(C0NTINUED)

Page 24: Nc for senate dec2

IN DETERMINING

POVERTY LEVEL

24

1. AN ANNUAL FAMILY

INCOME OF PhP16,000 and

below is classified as “poor”

Page 25: Nc for senate dec2

25

PRESENT OUTLOOK OF CAMARINES SUR

CAMARINES SUR IS AMONG THE BIGGEST

PROVINCES IN THE COUNTRY. IT’S LAND AREA

IS 5,502 SQUARE KM WHICH IS ALMOST AS BIG

AS THE PROVINCES OF ILOCOS NORTE AND

ILOCOS SUR COMBINED (6,100 SQUARE KM)

RANKS SECOND TO THE LOWEST IN GOOD

GOVERNANCE (78TH OUT OF 79 PROVINCES)

MAGUINDANAO BEING THE 79TH.

2ND TO THE HIGHEST POVERTY INCIDENCE IN

BICOL REGION AND THIRD OVER ALL IN THE

MAGNITUDE OF POOR FAMILIES IN THE

PHILIPPINES

Page 26: Nc for senate dec2

26

MAGNITUDE OF THE AREA

OF THE PROVINCE

• Camarines Sur has 1,036

Barangays

• There is only 365 DAYS in a year

• It will take more than 3 years to

visit all barangays

Page 27: Nc for senate dec2

SMALL AND BIG PROVINCES COMPARED

Provinces

which have

decided to

divide in the

past have done

much better in

terms of good

governance,

poverty

alleviation, and

in governing

their economic,

political and

administrative

affairs.

27

SMALLER

PROVINCES FROM

Area

(km2)

Pop’n,

2007

NSCB, 2011

POVERTY

CLUSTER/

INCIDENCE

GGI

(79 -

worst)

IlocosNorte Ilocos 3,504 547,284 5/12.4% 24

Ilocos Sur Ilocos 2,596 632,255 4/ 17.0% 12

QUIRINO N.Viscaya 2,323 397,837 4/ 12.3% 14

SIQUIJOR Negros Or. 337 87,695 2/ 38.0% 2

AURORA Quezon 3,147 187,802 3/ 24.2% 17

BILIRAN Leyte 536 150,031 2/ 34.9% 15

GUIMARAS Iloilo 604 151,238 4/ 20.5% 38

KALINGA Kalinga A. 3,231 103,633 3/ 25.9% 3

CAMIGUIN Misamis Or. 237 81,293 2/ 44.6% 1

BIG PROV.

MASBATE Sorsogon 4,151 768,939 1/54.2% 76

CAM SUR

Ambos

Cam 5,502 1,693,821 1/ 47.0% 78

QUEZON 9,069 1,646,510 3/ 32.5% 74

LEYTE 6,515 1,722,036 3/ 34.3% 77

The state of poverty in divided provinces was much

better than in Cam Sur.

Page 28: Nc for senate dec2

Difficulty of establishing accountability.

Too many people involved

Residents are at a loss on who is doing what

and how redress can be sought when public

service is badly delivered.

The absence of accountability induces under-

performance, abuse of powers, and

inefficiencies, and corruption.28

Negative consequences

of “BIGNESS”- Public Finance Institute of the Philippines, Headed byAIM President and former

Sec. of Finance Hon. Roberto De Ocampo

Page 29: Nc for senate dec2

BIGGER LGUsDON’T NECESSARILY

MEAN BETTER

The Province of Rizal which was broken into smaller

local government units and was not merely fragmented

into 2 or 3 separate and independent LGUs, but 15

LGUs, namely:

1. Las Pińas 6. Malabon 11. Makati

2. Parańaque 7. Navotas 12. Pasay

3. Muntinglupa 8. Pasig 13. Mandaluyong

4. Taguig 9. Marikina 14. Quezon City

5. Pateros 10.Caloocan 15. San Juan

The Province of Rizal did not lose its financial viability

and its socio-economic growth stunted.29

Page 30: Nc for senate dec2

LOGODEF STUDY• The primordial concern of the Local Government Code in

establishing the minimum standards for creating a new

province is to establish a local government system that is

capable of local governance and local development. Said

minimum standards should not be ignored because that

would be anathema to the long-term foundation of robust

central-local government relations for development.

• The provisions of the Local Government Code establishing

criteria or requisites for creation of a new province “CANNOT

BE INTERPRETED TO MEAN THAT BIGGER LOCAL

GOVERNMENTS ARE BETTER AND MORE VIABLE

MECHANISM FOR EFFECTIVE GOVERNANCE”.

30

Page 31: Nc for senate dec2

Camarines Sur is poorly governed --

compared to its regional peers and

the entire country

• Compared to the 79 provinces in the Philippines, CamarinesSur is ranked 78 in good governance in 2008, down by two ranks compared to 2006 (NSCB, 2011)

• “Compared to its regional peers,Cam Sur is the worst-run province in the entire Bicol region.”(Prof. Ben Diokno, UP School of Economics, former DBM Secretary)

31

Page 32: Nc for senate dec2

Poverty incidence and the number of poor people increase in CamarinesSur at

rates higher than the national averageIn 2009, poverty

incidence in

Cam Sur was

47.0, higher than

the national

average of 26.5

and regional

average of 45.1.

Except for

Masbate, its

other provincial

peers in the

Bicol region had

addressed

poverty much

better.32

Poverty

Incidence

Magnitude of Poor

People

Change

2006 2009 2006 2009 % No.

Philippines 26.4 26.5 22,173,190 23,142,481 4.4 969,291

Region V 45.2 45.1 2,335,684 2,422,267 3.7 86,583

Albay 42.8 43.6 512,762 512,079 -0.1 -683

Cam Norte 41.5 42.3 215,911 232,685 7.8 16,774

Cam Sur 44.9 47.0 760,730 794,832 4.5 34,102

Catanduanes 44.3 28.5 99,457 66,801 -32.8 -32,656

Masbate 52 54.2 425,966 441,688 3.7 15,722

Sorsogon 44.9 41.3 320,858 374,183 16.6 53,325

From 2006 to 2009, the number of poor people

in Cam Sur increased by 2% or by 34,102.

Page 33: Nc for senate dec2

33

Cebu, Negros Occidental and Camarines Sur continue to have the biggest share in the total number of poor families

Page 34: Nc for senate dec2

Economic Argumentsby: Prof. Benjamin Diokno, UP School of Economics, former DBM Secretary

The body of evidence is that Camarines Sur is not governed well and it has not addressed the welfare of its constituents. The dissatisfaction with the present state of affairs explains the clamor for an alternative province (Nueva Camarines). This bill will give those who are against the present state of affairs the right to ‘vote with their feet’ [a phrase coined by Charles M. Tiebout in his seminal article “A Pure Theory of Local Expenditures,” Journal of Political Economy 64(October 1956), pp. 416-4240]

34

Page 35: Nc for senate dec2

35

Page 36: Nc for senate dec2

36

Page 37: Nc for senate dec2

37

Page 38: Nc for senate dec2

38

Page 39: Nc for senate dec2

HOW DID CAMSUR PROVINCIAL

GOV’T SPEND TAXPAYERS MONEY

IN 2010?

39

PARTICULARS TOTALS

Casuals P 33,571,232.93

Consultancy 22,304,821.10

General Services 120,385,877.69

Other Professional Services 10,460,241.46

Gas, Oil & Lubricants 35,625,319.03

Donations 90,815,330.71

Confidential Expense 40,000,000.00

Food Supplies 97,775,981.28

Security 22,304,821.10

Other Supplies 30,068,549.91

Advertising 4,390,957.64

Drugs and Medicine Expense 133,547.13

Medical, Dental & Laboratory Supplies 97,664.15

Page 40: Nc for senate dec2

DISCRETIONARY FUNDS OF THE

GOVERNOR

40

PARTICULARS

GOVERNOR’S

OFFICE

OTHER

PROVINCIAL

OFFICES

TOTALS

Casuals P 6,000,000.00 P

27,476,000.00

P 33,476,000.00

Consultancy 5,000,000.00

16,570,000.00

21,570,000.00

General Services 10,676,201.30 41,190,308.00 51,866,509.30

Other Prof. Services 2,000,000.00 6,619,500.00 8,619,500.00

Other MOOE 6,049,500.00 174,003,913.96 180,053,413.96

Donations 6,967,032.32 65,897,515.52 72,864,547.84

Confidential Expense 30,000,000.00 2,368,932.00 32,368,932.00

Intelligence Expenses 25,685,697.00 2,000,000.00 27,685,697.00

TOTAL DICRETIONARY

FUNDS OF THE GOV

P92,378,430.62 P336,126,169.48 P428,504,600.10

Page 41: Nc for senate dec2

Particulars Amount %

R&M-Office Buildings, School Buildings, Hospitals &

Health Centers, Other Structures, Office Equipment,

Motor Vehicles, Highways and Bridges

205,000.00 0.10%

R&M-Other Public Infrastructure 18,000,000.00 8.43%

Construction-School Buildings 10,000,000.00 4.68%

Construction-Other Infrastructure 130,900,000.00 61.31%

Construction-Other Public Infra 30,000,000.00 14.05%

Gasoline, Oil and Lubricants 10,000,000.00 4.68%

Land Improvements 1,000,000.00 0.47%

Procurement-Motor Vehicle,IT Equipment & Software,

Technical & Scientific Machinery &Eqpt, & Other PPE

3,100,000.00 1.45%

Others 10,302,515.57 4.83%

Total Special Purpose Appropriation (PEO) 213,507,515.57

BREAKDOWN OF SPECIAL PURPOSE APPROPRIATION

(PROVINCIAL ENGINEER’S OFFICE)

OUT OF 213 M SPECIAL PURPOSE APPROPRIATION, 188 M OR

88% WAS USED ON OTHER PURPOSES WHICH PRACTICALLY

AMOUNTS TO AN ADDITIONAL DISCRETIONARY FUND

Page 42: Nc for senate dec2

NEGLECT OF BASIC

INFRASTRUCTURE

THE CY 2011 SPECIAL PURPOSE APPROPRIATION

OF P213.5 MILLION UNDER THE OFFICE OF THE

PROVINCIAL ENGINEER ALLOTED A MEASLY P205

THOUSAND FOR REPAIRS AND MAINTENANCE OF:

OFFICE BUILDING P 1,000.00

SCHOOL BUILDINGS P 1,000.00

HOSPITALS & HEALTH CTR P 1,000.00

OTHER STRUCTURES P 1,000.00

OFFICE EQUIPMENT P 500.00

MOTOR VEHICLES P 500.00

HIGHWAYS & BRIDGES P 200,000.00

Page 43: Nc for senate dec2

NEGLECT OF AGRICULTURE

THE CY 2011 BUDGET OF P41.4 MILLION OF THE

OFFICE OF THE PROVINCIAL AGRICULTURIST

ALLOTED A MEASLY P1.24 MILLION FOR THE

FOLLOWING:

AGRICULTURAL MACHINERIES P 30,000.00

AGRI, FISHERY & FORESTRY EQPT P 50,000.00

OTHER MACHINERIES & EQPT P 10,000.00

OTHER PROPERTY, PLANT & EQPT P 50,000.00

ANIMAL/ZOOLOGICAL SUPPLIES P 1,000,000.00

AGRICULTURE & MARINE SUPPLIES P 100,000.00

Page 44: Nc for senate dec2

NEGLECT OF

HEALTH SERVICES

Budget Allocation Per Person for CY 2011

Population

Total

Budget

/Pax

MDL

Eqpt

Food

Supplies

Drugs

&Meds

MDL

Supplies

Cooking

Gas

Camarines Sur 1,435,322 2.45 0.06 0.56 0.90 0.88 0.07

HOSPITALS

Provincial Health Office 62,024 5.16 0.32 - 1.61 3.22 -

LibmananDistrict 92,839 4.10 0.05 1.35 1.45 1.08 0.17

PartidoDistrict 35,768 12.76 0.14 4.75 4.19 3.40 0.28

Ragay District 47,743 10.03 0.21 3.35 3.14 3.14 0.19

SipocotDistrict 57,861 5.76 0.09 1.73 2.07 1.73 0.14

CaramoanMunicipal 39,642 8.00 0.13 2.52 2.65 2.52 0.18

OcampoDistrict 36,316 8.31 0.06 1.10 3.30 3.44 0.41

San Ramon Community 97,983 0.97 0.02 0.05 0.51 0.36 0.03

SirumaCommunity 17,035 11.45 0.29 0.88 4.70 4.70 0.88

Garchitorena Medicare 24,825 10.84 0.20 2.42 4.03 4.03 0.16

TinambacMunicipal 59,125 3.97 0.17 0.34 1.69 1.69 0.08

BuhiCommunity 70,765 1.98 0.07 0.07 1.13 0.64 0.07

PresentacionMunicipal 20,266 - - - - - -

Page 45: Nc for senate dec2

1. THE LEGAL REQUIREMENTS HAVE

BEEN COMPLIED WITH;

2. THE PROCESS OF

CONSULTATION WAS FULLY OBSERVED;

CONCLUSION

45

Page 46: Nc for senate dec2

3. THE OLD CAMARINES SUR HAS BEEN

TRYING UNSUCCESSFULLY TO

COPE WITH THE PROBLEMS AND

NEEDS OF A LARGE AREA (5,502 SQ.

KM), AND A BIG NUMBER OF

POPULATION (1,693,821), TOWNS (35),

CITY (1) AND BARANGAYS (1,036)

(EXCLUDING NAGA CITY);

CONCLUSION

46

Page 47: Nc for senate dec2

4. THE TWO EMERGING PROVINCES

WILL DEVELOP AN AREA ROUGHLY

50% OF THE OLD PROVINCE AND

SEE TO THE NEEDS OF ALSO

ROUGHLY 50% OF ITS

POPULATION;

CONCLUSION

47

Page 48: Nc for senate dec2

5. THE FUNDS TO BE MADE

AVAILABLE TO BOTH EMERGING

PROVINCES WILL BE MORE THAN

THAT OF THE OLD (WHOLE)

PROVINCE IN TERMS OF PER

CAPITA AND PER SQUARE KM.

CONCLUSION

48

Page 49: Nc for senate dec2

6. IT IS NOT TRUE THAT DIVIDING A

PROVINCE WEAKENS BOTH NEW

PROVINCES AS CAN BE SEEN IN

THE FIGURES BELOW:

CONCLUSION

REGULAR INCOME INCOME CLASS

MOTHER PROVINCE

– CAMARINES SUR

(DIST 1,2&3)

P848.1 M FIRST CLASS

NUEVA CAMARINES

(DIST 4&5)P689.7 M BLGF:RESULTING

COMPUTED INCOME

MAY BECOME

FIRST CLASS

49

Page 50: Nc for senate dec2

7. DEVELOPMENT EFFORTS WILL

BE FOCUSED ON SMALLER AREA

AND FEWER LOCAL

GOVERNMENT UNITS; SERVICES

WILL BE DELIVERED TO FEWER

POPULATION.

50

CONCLUSION

Page 51: Nc for senate dec2

8. THE CREATION OF THE PROVINCE OF NUEVA CAMARINES WILL ACCELERATE THE POLITICAL, SOCIAL AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT THAT WILL GREATLY BENEFIT NOT ONLY THE PEOPLE IN THE PROPOSED PROVINCE, BUT ALSO THOSE IN THE MOTHER PROVINCE OF CAMARINES SUR, NOT TO MENTION THE ENTIRE COUNTRY.

51

CONCLUSION

Page 52: Nc for senate dec2

IN SUMMARY

THE CREATION OF NUEVA CAMARINES SHALL BRING ABOUT BETTER

GOVERNANCE AND IMPROVED ECONOMIC PROSPECTS WHICH COULD LEAD TO REDUCTION IN POVERTY INCIDENCE.

ERGO

ACCELERATED ECONOMIC, SOCIAL AND POLITICAL DEVELOPMENT FOR THE TWO

CAMARINES PROVINCES (CAMARINES SUR AND NUEVA CAMARINES)

52

Page 53: Nc for senate dec2

THANK YOU

53


Recommended