The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
A New Approach to High Performance Polyolefin CoatingsA New Approach to High Performance Polyolefin Coatings
by Catherine Lam, Dennis T. Wong, Robert E.
Steele and Stephen J. Edmondson
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Steel
Coating
Diffusion
Migration
O2 H2O
• Low Permeability• Excellent Adhesion to Steel
Steel Corrosion Steel Corrosion
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Fusion Bonded Epoxy (FBE)• Low permeability to oxygen
• Excellent Adhesion to Steel
• Excellent Resistance to Cathodic Disbondment
• Low Impact Resistance
• Permeable to moisture
• Tendency to disbond when exposed to HOT & WET conditions for long periods of time
Coating Systems for PipelinesCoating Systems for Pipelines
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Polyolefins Topcoat• Low Permeability to Moisture
• High resistant to Impact Damage
• Flexible
• Tough
• Relatively Low Cost (e.g. PE, PP)
Coating Systems for PipelinesCoating Systems for Pipelines
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Steel
Polyolefin
FBECopolymer Adhesive
Adhesion to Steel
3LPO Coating
Coating Systems for PipelinesCoating Systems for Pipelines
Mechanical Properties
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Pipes with OD > 24” (610 mm)
Pipe Welded Area
Cross Section of a Typical Weld on a Pipe
Weld GeometryWeld Geometry
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Terminology used to describe Weld Geometry
Crown
Toe
HeightUndercut
Weld GeometryWeld Geometry
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Ideal weld shape
Square edges
Square edges with slight undercut
Square edge with severe undercut
Severe undercuts both sides and recess on top
Weld GeometryWeld Geometry
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Pressing Roller
Pipe
Extrudate
Weld
Ideal Weld Shape
Conventional 3LPO Side Extruded ProcessConventional 3LPO Side Extruded Process
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Pipe
Weld
Ideal Weld Shape
Conventional 3LPO Side Extruded ProcessConventional 3LPO Side Extruded Process
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Pipe
Weld
Ideal Weld Shape
Conventional 3LPO Side Extruded ProcessConventional 3LPO Side Extruded Process
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Pipe
Weld
Ideal Weld Shape
Conventional 3LPO Side Extruded ProcessConventional 3LPO Side Extruded Process
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Pressing Roller
Pipe
Weld
Extrudate
High Raised or Square Weld
Conventional 3LPO Side Extruded ProcessConventional 3LPO Side Extruded Process
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Pipe
Weld
High Raised or Square Weld
Conventional 3LPO Side Extruded ProcessConventional 3LPO Side Extruded Process
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Pipe
Weld
High Raised or Square Weld
Conventional 3LPO Side Extruded ProcessConventional 3LPO Side Extruded Process
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Pipe
Weld
High Raised or Square Weld
Conventional 3LPO Side Extruded ProcessConventional 3LPO Side Extruded Process
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Pressing roller is NOT Effective!
With high raised or square weld …
Void
Conventional 3LPO Side Extruded ProcessConventional 3LPO Side Extruded Process
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Water quenching
Conventional 3LPO Side Extruded ProcessConventional 3LPO Side Extruded Process
• Hoop Stress
• Volume Shrinkage
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Common Problems:
Voids• Weld Tenting
• Thinning across the top of the weld
Conventional 3LPO Side Extruded ProcessConventional 3LPO Side Extruded Process
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
• No distinct interface
• Smooth transition from rigid FBE to much tougher and compliant PE
Powder Applied PE adhesive and Topcoat
“Graded Structure” PE Coating“Graded Structure” PE Coating
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
• Eliminate interlayer adhesion failure
• Provide excellent uniform coverage of the raised weld
• Allow production of lower thickness coatings than is possible with conventional 3LPO coating process
Advantages:
“Graded Structure” PE Coating“Graded Structure” PE Coating
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
• More expensive for additional step of polyolefin grinding
• More difficult to apply a thick coating by powder application due to loss of heat transfer
Disadvantages:
“Graded Structure” PE Coating“Graded Structure” PE Coating
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Graded Structure
PE Coatings
Side-Wrap Extruded PE
Coatings
Prevent delaminationand loss of adhesionProvide uniform coverage over raised welds
• Attain thick coatings• Lower cost• Higher throughout
New Approach to Multi - Layer Polyolefin CoatingsNew Approach to Multi - Layer Polyolefin Coatings
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Advantages:
• Allow production of Multi-layer Polyolefin of any thickness with Uniform Thickness at all points
• No Tenting along the edges of welds
New Approach to Multi - Layer Polyolefin CoatingsNew Approach to Multi - Layer Polyolefin Coatings
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Conventional 3LPE Coating
New Approach Multi-layer PE
CoatingVS
Application
Coating Effectiveness
Physical Properties
New Approach to Multi - Layer Polyolefin CoatingsNew Approach to Multi - Layer Polyolefin Coatings
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Induction Coil
SheetExtruder
External Cooling
Coated Pipe
Internal Cooling
FBEAdhesive
FBEAdhesive
PE New Approach Multi-layer PE Coating
Conventional 3LPE Coating
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Coating EffectivenessCoating Effectiveness
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Conventional 3LPE Coating
New Approach to Multi-layer PE Coating
Weld Tentingtweld
tbody tweldtbody
~ 60-70%
Coating EffectivenessCoating Effectiveness
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
New Approach to Multi-layer PE Coating
Adhesive InterlayerFused Polyethylene Powder
FBE
Coating EffectivenessCoating Effectiveness
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Side-Wrapped GSPE on Spiral Weld Pipe (30”)
Coating EffectivenessCoating Effectiveness
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Close-Up Showing Excellent Conformance to the Long Seam Weld
Note how well-defined
the weld seam is.
Coating EffectivenessCoating Effectiveness
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Intersection of the Long Seam and the Girth Weld on Double-Jointed Pipe
Coating EffectivenessCoating Effectiveness
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Physical PropertiesPhysical Properties
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Flexibility Test at -30°C with 4.2°/pd
New Approach Multi-layer PE Coating
Conventional 3LPE Coating
Physical PropertiesPhysical Properties
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Rock Impact Test at - 40°C with 22 lb RockFell from 2 meters to the tested Coating
Round Rock Sharp Rock
Physical PropertiesPhysical Properties
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
Rock Impact Test at - 40°C with 22 lb Rock
Conventional 3LPE Coating
New Approach Multi-layer PE Coating
Physical PropertiesPhysical Properties
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
• A new coating system consists of HDPE Side-Wrapped over a “graded structure”PE is introduced.
• This new coating system overcomes the drawbacks of the conventional 3LPE coating.
ConclusionsConclusions
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
The new coating system ……
Provides exceptionally uniform coverage of external welds on both long and spiral welded pipes
Eliminated “weld tenting”
Leads to a coating with reduced residual stress
ConclusionsConclusions
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
The authors would like to acknowledge the contributions of:
• Hank Yih (Lab Manager)
• Scott Leonard (Product Development Technologist)
from Bredero Shaw R&D, Calgary
For providing the plant trial photos and test results.
AcknowledgementsAcknowledgements
The GLOBAL LEADER in Pipe Coating Solutions
You!
ThankThank