16
New Neutron Absorbers Absorbers Industry Meeting with NRC Neutron Absorber Material Degradation October 4 2012
New
Neu
tron
Abs
orbe
rsA
bsor
bers
Indu
stry
Mee
ting
with
NR
CN
eutro
n A
bsor
ber M
ater
ial D
egra
datio
n
Oct
ober
4 2
012
Neu
tron
Abs
orbe
rsin
US
Spen
tFue
lPoo
lsN
eutr
on A
bsor
bers
in U
S Sp
ent F
uel P
ools
Supp
lier
Prod
uctN
ame
Mat
rixA
bsor
ber
Supp
lier
Prod
uct N
ame
Mat
rixA
bsor
ber
BIS
CO
*B
oraf
lex
Pol
y D
imet
hyl
Silo
xane
Bor
on
Cer
adyn
e/A
AR
*B
oral
Al1
100
Allo
yB
oron
Cer
adyn
e/A
AR
Bor
alA
l 110
0 A
lloy
Bor
onH
olte
c/M
etam
icLL
C*
Met
amic
Al 6
061
Allo
yB
oron
BÖ
HLE
RB
lh
Nt
it30
4S
ti
lB
BÖ
HLE
R B
lech
e N
eutro
nit
304
Sta
inle
ss
Bor
onC
arpe
nter
Neu
troS
orb
AS
TM A
887
Bor
onC
arbo
rund
um C
o.*
Cab
orun
dum
Phe
nolic
Res
inB
oron
ES
K*
Tetra
bor
Phe
nolic
Res
inB
oron
Alc
anW
1100
N.X
XB
Al 6
351
Allo
yB
oron
*For
mer
Sup
plie
r/Out
of B
usin
ess
Cha
nge
inA
bsor
berM
arke
tC
hang
e in
Abs
orbe
r Mar
ket
Av
aila
ble
neut
ron
abso
rber
sfo
rspe
ntfu
elpo
olar
eal
mos
t
Avai
labl
e ne
utro
n ab
sorb
ers
for s
pent
fuel
poo
l are
alm
ost
excl
usiv
ely
Alu
min
um a
nd S
tain
less
Ste
el b
ased
m
ater
ials
N
o po
lym
er o
r res
in b
ased
neu
tron
abso
rber
mat
eria
l cu
rrent
ly b
eing
mar
kete
d fo
r spe
nt fu
el p
ool u
se
Sta
inle
ssS
teel
base
dm
ater
ials
use
boro
nan
d/or
S
tain
less
Ste
el b
ased
mat
eria
ls u
se b
oron
and
/or
gado
linia
as th
e ne
utro
n ab
sorb
er
Alu
min
um b
ased
mat
eria
ls u
se b
oron
as
the
neut
ron
abso
rber
Neu
tron
Abs
orbe
rsAv
aila
ble
forS
FPo
ols
Neu
tron
Abs
orbe
rs A
vaila
ble
for S
F Po
ols
Supp
lier
Prod
uctN
ame
Mat
rixA
bsor
ber
Stai
nles
s St
eel B
ased
Mat
eria
ls
Supp
lier
Prod
uct N
ame
Mat
rixA
bsor
ber
Car
pent
er??
????
?S
tain
less
Ste
elB
oron
, Gad
olin
iaB
ÖH
LER
Ble
che
Neu
troni
tS
tain
less
Ste
elB
oron
Car
pent
erN
eutro
Sor
bS
tain
less
Ste
elB
oron
AT
I Nuc
lear
Ene
rgy
NU
SH
IELD
Sta
inle
ss S
teel
Bor
on
Neu
tron
Abs
orbe
rs A
vaila
ble
for S
F Po
ols
Alu
min
umB
ased
Mat
eria
lsA
lum
inum
Bas
ed M
ater
ials
Supp
lier
Prod
uct N
ame
Mat
rixA
bsor
ber
Cer
adyn
eB
OR
AL
Al1
100
Allo
yB
oron
Cer
adyn
eB
OR
AL
Al 1
100
Allo
yB
oron
Cer
adyn
eB
OR
TEC
Al 1
100,
609
0 A
lloy
Bor
on
Hol
tec
Met
amic
Al6
061
Allo
yB
oron
Hol
tec
Met
amic
Al 6
061
Allo
yB
oron
Alu
min
um C
ore
Tech
nolo
gyM
AX
US
1070
Al c
ore
5052
Al A
lloy
clad
Bor
on
Talo
nC
ompo
site
sTa
lbor
Al6
061
Allo
yB
oron
Talo
n C
ompo
site
sTa
lbor
Al 6
061
Allo
yB
oron
Alc
anW
1100
N.X
XB
Al 6
351
Allo
yB
oron
Neu
tron
Abs
orbi
ngFe
-Bas
eA
lloy
Neu
tron
Abs
orbi
ng F
eB
ase
Allo
y
C
arpe
nter
Tech
nolo
gyC
orpo
ratio
n
Bor
on, G
adol
inia
Stai
nles
s St
eel
C
arpe
nter
Tec
hnol
ogy
Cor
pora
tion
W
yom
issi
ng, P
A
w
ww
.car
tech
.com
/ssa
lloys
prod
–N
o da
ta o
n th
is p
rodu
ct
A
uste
nitic
pow
der m
etal
lurg
y
A
tlea
st0
25w
t%bo
ron
A
t lea
st 0
.25
wt.%
bor
on
A
t lea
st 0
.05
wt.%
gad
olin
ia
Av
aila
ble
assh
eeto
rpla
teAv
aila
ble
as s
heet
or p
late
P
rodu
ct is
in d
evel
opm
ent
Neu
tron
it®N
eutr
onit
B
ÖH
LER
Ble
che
Gm
bH&
Co
KG
Bor
ated
Sta
inle
ss S
teel
B
ÖH
LER
Ble
che
Gm
bH &
Co
KG
M
ürzz
usch
lag,
AU
STR
IA
w
ww
.boh
ler-
blec
he.c
om/e
nglis
h/sp
ecia
l_al
loys
A
STM
-A88
7 A
lloy
B
oron
cont
entu
pto
19
wt%
B
oron
con
tent
up
to 1
.9 w
t.%
Av
aila
ble
as p
late
, she
et o
r stri
p
In
ser
vice
at G
inna
Neu
troni
tA 9
78 w
/1%
Bor
on
C
orro
sion
per
form
ance
test
ing
data
–
Ref
. 1
Neu
troS
orb
PLU
S®N
eutr
oSor
bPL
US
C
arpe
nter
Tech
nolo
gy
Bor
ated
Sta
inle
ss S
teel
C
arpe
nter
Tec
hnol
ogy
Cor
pora
tion
W
yom
issi
ng, P
A
w
ww
.car
tech
.com
/ssa
lloys
prod
A
STM
A88
7-89
Gra
de A
Allo
y
B
oron
cont
entu
pto
25
wt%
B
oron
con
tent
up
to 2
.5 w
t.%
Av
aila
ble
as s
heet
or p
late
In
use
at t
he U
S M
OX
faci
lity
Neu
troS
orb
Plu
s 1.
17 w
t.% b
oron
y
In
use
in U
S c
omm
erci
al re
acto
r sp
ent f
uel p
ools
C
orro
sion
perfo
rman
cete
stin
g
Cor
rosi
on p
erfo
rman
ce te
stin
g da
ta –
Ref
. 1
NU
SHIE
LD™
NU
SHIE
LD
A
llegh
eny
Tech
nolo
gies
Inco
rpor
ated
Bor
ated
Sta
inle
ss S
teel
A
llegh
eny
Tech
nolo
gies
Inco
rpor
ated
P
ittsb
urgh
, PA
w
ww
.ATI
met
als.
com
30
4 S
tain
less
Ste
el M
atrix
B
oron
con
tent
1.7
5-2.
25 w
/oFi
ldi
dh
bid
–Fi
nely
dis
pers
ed c
hrom
e-bo
rides
Av
aila
ble
as s
heet
or p
late
In
use
atth
eU
SM
OX
faci
lity
In u
se a
t the
US
MO
X fa
cilit
y
N
ot in
ser
vice
in U
S c
omm
erci
al re
acto
r sp
ent f
uel p
ools
Ci
ft
tid
t
Cor
rosi
on p
erfo
rman
ce te
stin
g da
ta –
Ref
. 2
BO
RA
L®B
OR
AL
C
erad
yne,
Inc.
Alu
min
um B
oron
Car
bide
Cer
met
y,
Q
uebe
c, C
anad
a
w
ww
.cer
adyn
ebor
on.c
om/p
rodu
cts
11
00 A
lum
inum
Allo
y C
lad
A
lum
inum
, Bor
on C
arbi
de C
ore
BC
tt
t67
l%i
th
B4C
con
tent
up
to 6
7 vo
l.% in
the
core
Av
aila
ble
as s
heet
N
otin
serv
ice
inU
Sco
mm
erci
alN
ot in
ser
vice
in U
S c
omm
erci
al
reac
tor s
pent
fuel
poo
ls
C
orro
sion
per
form
ance
test
ing
data
–R
ef3
Ref
. 3–
EP
RI L
ong
Term
Cor
rosi
on P
erfo
rman
ce
Test
BO
RTE
C®
BO
RTE
C
C
erad
yne
Inc
Alu
min
um M
etal
Mat
rix C
ompo
site
C
erad
yne,
Inc.
Q
uebe
c, C
anad
a
w
ww
.cer
adyn
ebor
on.c
om/p
rodu
cts
10
00, 5
000
& 6
000
Alu
min
um A
lloy
Mat
rix
B
Cco
nten
tup
to45
vol%
B
4C c
onte
nt u
p to
45
vol.%
Av
aila
ble
as b
illet o
r she
et
N
ot in
ser
vice
in U
S c
omm
erci
al
reac
tor s
pent
fuel
poo
ls
C
orro
sion
per
form
ance
test
ing
data
–R
ef. 3
Met
amic
®M
etam
ic
H
olte
cIn
tern
atio
nal
Alu
min
um M
etal
Mat
rix C
ompo
site
–M
arlto
n, N
J
M
etam
icLL
CL
kl
dFL
–La
kela
nd, F
L
w
ww
.met
amic
.com
60
61 A
lum
inum
Allo
y M
atrix
606
uu
oyat
B
oron
con
tent
up
to 3
3 w
t.%
Av
aila
ble
as e
xtru
sion
, she
et,
fi
dd
forg
ings
and
dra
wn
In
use
in U
S c
omm
erci
al re
acto
r sp
ent f
uel p
ools
6061
+21%
Bor
on C
arbi
de
C
orro
sion
per
form
ance
test
ing
data
–R
ef. 3
MA
XUS™
MA
XUS
A
lum
inum
Cor
e Te
chno
logy
C
lad
Met
al M
atrix
Com
posi
teH
ybrid
Alu
min
um M
etal
Mat
rix C
ompo
site
To
kyo,
Jap
an
w
ww
.nlm
etal
.com
/sol
utio
ns
–A
lum
inum
Cor
e –
5052
Alu
min
um A
lloy
Cla
d
N
ot in
ser
vice
in U
S c
omm
erci
al
B
4C in
cor
e 21
-40
wt.%
Av
aila
ble
as s
heet
reac
tor s
pent
fuel
poo
ls
80
00 h
our a
ccel
erat
ed
corr
osio
n te
st (p
ropr
ieta
ry)
(pp
y)
B4C
Aluminum
×100
×400
50μm
10μm
Talb
or®
Talb
or
Ta
lon
Com
posi
tes
LLC
Alu
min
um M
etal
Mat
rix C
ompo
site
Ta
lon
Com
posi
tes,
LLC
S
an J
uan
Cap
istra
no, C
A
w
ww
.talo
ncom
posi
tes.
com
Av
aila
ble
as 1
100
or 6
092
Alu
min
um
Allo
y M
atrix
for n
ucle
ar a
pplic
atio
ns
B
C1
40vo
l%
B4C
1-4
0 vo
l.%–
29.2
wt.%
B4C
@ 2
00x
Av
aila
ble
as s
heet
, ext
rude
d cr
oss
tilli
&f
ibl
kse
ctio
ns, r
ollin
g &
forg
ing
blan
ks
N
ot in
ser
vice
in U
S c
omm
erci
al
spen
t fue
l poo
ls
C
orro
sion
test
ing
to s
uppo
rt dr
y st
orag
e ap
plic
atio
n –
Ref
. 3
W11
0NXX
BW
110N
.XXB
R
io T
into
Alc
an
Alu
min
um M
etal
Mat
rix C
ompo
site
Q
uebe
c, C
anad
a
w
ww
.rtap
ublic
sale
s.rio
tinto
.com
A
lum
inum
110
0 A
lloy
Mat
rix
B
oron
con
tent
Fo
rUS
spen
tfue
lpoo
lapp
licat
ions
:–
For U
S s
pent
fuel
poo
l app
licat
ions
: 16
-40
vol.%
Av
aila
ble
as b
illet o
r she
et
ItL
Sll
Uit
2
In u
se a
t LaS
alle
Uni
t 2 a
s S
NA
P-IN
®sp
ent f
uel p
ool i
nser
ts
C
orro
sion
per
form
ance
test
ing
dt
Rf
4da
ta –
Ref
. 4–
Sub
mitt
ed a
s pa
rt of
LaS
alle
& P
each
B
otto
m L
AR
Cor
rosi
onPe
rfor
man
ceR
efer
ence
sC
orro
sion
Per
form
ance
Ref
eren
ces
1“E
lect
roch
emic
alC
orro
sion
Test
ing
ofN
eutro
nA
bsor
ber
Ope
n Li
tera
ture
1.E
lect
roch
emic
al C
orro
sion
Tes
ting
of N
eutro
n A
bsor
ber
Mat
eria
ls,”
List
er, T
., et
al,
May
200
7, Id
aho
Nat
iona
l La
bora
tory
, IN
L/E
XT-
06-1
1772
, Rev
. 12.
“ATI
304
B7
P/M
™ A
lloy
Tech
nica
l Dat
a S
heet
,” AT
I N
ucle
ar E
nerg
y, 1
2/2/
113
“Han
dboo
kof
Neu
tron
Abs
orbe
rMat
eria
lsfo
rSpe
nt3.
Han
dboo
k of
Neu
tron
Abs
orbe
r Mat
eria
ls fo
r Spe
nt
Nuc
lear
Fue
l Tra
nspo
rtatio
n an
d S
tora
ge A
pplic
atio
ns,
2009
Edi
tion,
” EP
RI,
TR 1
0191
10, N
ovem
ber 2
009
4.“M
ater
ial Q
ualif
icat
ion
of A
lcan
Com
posi
te fo
r Spe
nt
Fuel
Sto
rage
,” N
orth
east
Tec
hnol
ogy
Cor
p., N
ET-
259-
03, R
ev. 5
, Aug
ust 2
008
