2 Shri Shishir Lal, Head-Sustainability excellence Centre, Mis Emaar Mgf Land Ltd.,
Emaar Mgf Business Park, M.G. Road, Sikander Chowk, Sector 28, Gurgaon 122002for information & necessary action.
18
Monitoring the Implementation of Environmental Safeguards Ministry of Environment, Forest& Climate Change
Northern Regional Office, Chandigarh
MONITORING REPORT PART-I
DATA SHEET I. Project type: River- valley/ Mining! Industry / Others - (Group Housing)
Thermal! Nuclear/Other (specify) 2. Name of the project EC {or proposed group housing at Village
Shikhopur, Sector-77, Gurgaon, Haryana by M/s Emaar MGF Land Pvt. Ltd.
3. Clearance letter (s)/OM No. &date No. SEIAA/HR/20 I 0/907 dated 29.10.20 I 0 4. Location:
District (s) Gurgaon State (s) Haryana Location Latitude/Longitude 28°23' 18.28" N /76°5845.30"
5. Address for correspondence The CEO, Address of the Concerned Project Chief M/s Emaar MGF Land Limited, Engineer (with Pin Code & telephone/ telex/ ECE House, 1st Floor,28 Kasturba Gandhi Marg, fax numbers) New Delhi - 11000 J
b) Address of the Executive Project Engineer Shri Shishir Lal, / Manager (with Pin Code & telephone / telex Head-Sustainability excellence Centre, / fax numbers) Mis Emaar Mgf Land Ltd., Emaar Mgf Business
Park, M.G. Road, Sikander Chowk, Sector 28, Gurgaon 122 002
6. Salient feature!; Project envisages group housing comprising of Ofthe project Plot 65 towers (S+7 floors = 19 Towers; S+8=17
To ll'f:; S+9 = :W Towenj S-I-10;:::7 Tow ri; S+ II = 2 Towers - Total = 65 Towers) covering built-up area of 2,82,527 sq m, spread over total area of area - 1,00,244 sq m (i.e., 24 acres). It also includes dwelling units of 1139,296 EWS.
Of the EMP EMP report has been submitted which includes installation of STP (capa. 600 KLPD), dual plumbing for recycling of treated wastewater in flushing &horti., storm drainage &RWH, plantation of species, segre.& collection of SW, organic waste converter for biodegradable waste, use of energy efficient fixtures etc.
7. Breakup of the project area Submergence area: forest & non-Forest Total Area - 1,00,244 sq m ; Built-up area Others 2,82,527 sq m
8. Breakup of the project affected population with NA enumeration of those losing houses/dwelling units only agricultural land only both dwelling units & agricultural land & landless laborers/artisans: SC, ST/Adivasi Others (Please indicate whether these figures are based on any scientific and systematic survey carried out or only provisional fig., if survey carried out give details & year of survey)
Certification & MNR of Group Housing Project,Gurgaon, Haryana by Ms Emaar MGF 19.1.2017 - 1
- -
- -
- -
- -
Financial details: Project cost as originally planned &
9. Original Project cost - Rs300Crs
subsequent revised estimates & year of price Revised Project Cost - Rs. 544 Crs reference b) Allocation made for EMP with item wise Non recur. - Rs 6.40 Crs; Recur.-Rs 0.03 Crs for and year wise break-up APC, WPC, Noise, RWH, GB &monit. BC ratio/IRR and the year of assessment Will be provided after completion of project Whether (C)inclcost of EM Yes Actual expend. incurred on project so far Rs. 383 Crs Actual expcnJ. incurred 011 EMP so far Rs 6.40 ers
NA The status of approval for diversion of forest land for non-forestry use The status of clearing felling The status of CA, if any Comments on the viability & sustainability of CA program in the light of actual field experience so far
Forest land requirement10.
The status of clear felling in non-forest areas NA (Such as submergence area or reservoir, approach Roads.), if any with quantitative information required.
lI.
Status of construction: (actual &!or planned) a) Date of commencement
I:L. December 20 I I
b) Date of completion Planned completion by- December, 2017 Project development delayed due to recessionReasons for delay, if the project is yet to start13.
Olltr.q of qitC'. vi"lit14. 19.07.2013
Date of present site visit Date of previous sltc visit
19.1.2017 As bt-II.lw
Authorities for obtaining act on plans/information on status of compliance to safeguards other than the routine letters for logistic support for site visits). (The first monitoring report may contain the details of all the letters issued so far, but the later reports may cover only the letter issued subsequently)
Date Letter from RO
Details of corre~portdertl'e ",.,Illh prl~l:'l·.l15.
Date Reply from PA
4.1.11 Requisite information sub. sheet & reports req. 11.11.10 Comp!., work status, fund details, consents, data
13.10.11Inform.reg app!. for NOC & compo will be sub. 3.10.11 Request for six monthly compliance report 15.12.11 Compo with analytical reports, permi. of AA, CTE & NOC from Forest dept.sub. 19.3.12 Construction status & expenditure sub. 27.2.12 Construction status req. 14.6.12 Compo without analytical data sub.
11.3 .13 Req for six monthly comp report as per schedule 18.12.12 Compo and analytical data sub. 8.7.13 Compo and analytical data sub.
25.5 .14 Req for six monthly comp report as per schedule 31.12.13 Compo and analytical data sub. 7.7.14 Informed that compo rep was sub. 11.6.14 Compo and analytical data sub. --17.3.15 Compo and analytical data sub. --
26.5.16 higher pollutants were noticed in analytical data 19.2.16 Compo and analytical data sub. 18.11.16 Information sought for certifications 15.11.16 Req for compliance certification
2.6.16 Compo and analytical data sub. -
--15.12.16 Inf. for certification sub. -
Certification & MNR of Group Housing Project,Gurgaon, Haryana by Ms Emaar MGF 19.1.2017 - 2
PART-II (CHECK LIST OF COMPLIANCE)
& PART-III
DETAILED MONITORING REPORT I. Construction Phase: Specific Condition Status
1 A First Aid Room as proposed in project Being Complied. First Aid facility was report will be provided both during provided and will be maintained during construction and operation of the project. operation phase of the project as submitted.
2 Adequate drinking water & sanitary Being Complied. Potable water and sanitary HlCilities should be provided for facilities including toilets have been provided construction workers at site. Provision at labor colony (Photo 1). Wastewater & solid should be made for mobile toilets. Open wastes generated during construction is being defecation by laborers is strictly prohibited. disposed off safely as submitted. Safe disposal of wastewater & solid wastes generated during construction should be ensured.
3 All the top soil excavated during Being Complied. Top soil excavated during oonotruction aotivitieo ohould be otorod for UriC) in hnrtin1l1tnrnilnnr!'1nnpn nm.'plnpmC1llf'1
com;truction phaGe haG been used for lnnrl'1nnpilll3 fwd lm:nline nt nitn nt nlnimnrl nn
within the project site. also observed during the visit (Photos 2-3). About 50,000 m3 top soil was stored at site for reuse 111 2013. PA was uireL:leu lu sul.illlil quantitative details of generation & utilization of nod nlone with nflxt oompiiancil fflport. Thus, condition is considered as complied for lhl: 'pn;~l:lll vl~ll.
4 Dispusal uf lIlUL:k uuriug L:uuslrut:liuu phase Nut CUIIIVIi~d. Necessary precauliulls have should not create any adverse effect on been adopted so as not to create any adverse neighboring communities & be disposed-off effect on neighboring communities as claimed taking necessary precautions for general by PA. However, PA did not submit safety & health aspects of people, only in quantitative details of generation & disposal of approved sites with approval of competent muck.. authority.
5 Construction spoils including bituminous Being Complied. PA has submitted that waste material & other HM must not be allowed to oil from DG sets was being stored 111
contaminate water course & dump sites for earmarked area and will be sold to authorized such material must be secured so that they recycler. Water analysis reports do not show should not leach into GW & HW generated any anomaly. during construction phase should be disposed off as per applicable rules & norms with necessary approval of HSPCB.
6 Diesel generator sets to be used during Being Complied. Low sulphur diesel was construction should be low sulphur diesel being used in DG sets with proper acoustic type & should conform to Environment enclosure as observed. The report for DG (Protection) Rules prescribed for air & noise stacks emission & noise, as submitted, show emission standards. parameters within the limits.
7 Diesel required for operating DG sets shall Being Complied. At present very small be stored in underground tanks & if amount of diesel is required & was being required, clearance from CCE shall be purchased on daily basis which was stored in
Certification & MNR of Group Housing Project,Gurgaon, Haryana by Ms Emaar MGF 19.1.2017 - 3
taken. 200 lit barrels at designated area. It was submitted that clearance from CCE will be taken as and when required.
8 Ambient noise levels should conform residential standards both during day
to &
Being Complied. Ambient air and noise level monitoring was carried out at project site on
night. Incremental pollution loads and noise quality should be
on AA closely
six monthly basis. Copy of reports show parameters within limits. It was submitted that
monitored during construction. Adequate measure should be made to reduce AA &
measures like water sprinkling, usage of PPE by labors & training etc., have been
noise level during construction, so as to implemented. conform to stipulated residential standards.
9 Fly ash should be used as building material in construction as per the provisions of Fly
Not Complied. PA has claimed that fly ash based ready mix concrete was being utilized
Ash Notification of September 1999 & for construction but quantitative details of amended as on 27.08.2003. utilization were not submitted. Thus, condition
is considered as not complied for present visit. 10 Ready mixed concrete
building construction. must be used m Being Complied. Ready mix concrete
being utilized for building construction. was
11 Storm water control and its reuse as per Agreed to Comply. Since construction work is CGWB and BIS standards applications should be ensured.
for various still under progress, PA has assured that storm water will be chaIUldiL.~d llu0ugh Sl01'111
drainage Systtiii & will Lt rtuseu and controlled as per CGWB norms.
12 Water demand during construction should Being Complied. PA had submitted that prebe reduced by us of pre-mixed cuncrde, mixed l;UIIl;lde allu litaltu waslt waJtl was curmg agents & other best practices being used to reduce water demand. lC[cl1tU.
13 Permission from competent authority for Agreed to Comply. PA has assured to abide supply of water shall be obtained prior to by the oondition prior to operation phane. operation of the project.
14 Roof should meet prescriptive requirement Agreed to Comply. PA has assured to abide as per Energy Conservation Building Code by the condition by means of implementation by using appropriate thermal material to fulfill requirement.
insulation of energy conservation operation phase.
measures prior to
15 Opaque wall requirement as
should meet prescriptive per Energy Conservation
Agreed to Comply. Optimum window sizes and openings were provided on external face of
Building Code mandatory for
which all air
is proposed conditioned
to be spaces
the building. Window to wall ratio WWR 0.3 0.4. Glass surfaces have been protected by
while it is aspirational for non-air overhangs and work is yet to be completed. conditioned spaces by use of appropriate thermal insulation to fulfill requirement.
Further, PA condition.
has assured to abide by the
16 The approval of competent authority shall be obtained for structural safety of the building due to earthquake, adequacy of fire fighting equipments etc. as per NBC including protection measures from lightening etc. If any forest land is involved
Being Complied. Necessary approvals will be obtained from T&CP. Approval for firefighting scheme of the project & Aravali NOC from Forest Department have been obtained and submitted. Permission was not required for approach road under FC Act.
in proposed site, clearance under FC Act shall be taken from competent authority.
17 The PP will use water for construction phase through tankers. However, prior permission from CGWA will be taken
Being Complied. Treated wastewater available from nearest HUDA sewage treatment plant facilities was being purchased for construction
Certification & MNR ofGroup Housing Project,Gurgaon, Haryana by Ms Emaar MGF 19.1.2017 - 4
18
before using bore well water for construction purposes. PP will construct 25 (Twenty Five) no. of rainwater harvesting pits for recharging groundwater within project premises.
PP will start construction only after getting permission of Airport Authority (AA). II. Operation Phase: Since 80% buildings
9). Part B: General Conditions: The environmental safeguards contained in EIA/EMP Report should be implemented in letter & spirit. Six monthly compliance reports should be submitted to HSPCB and RO, MOEF, 001, Chandigarh and copy to SEIAA Haryana.
19
20
21
22 SEIAA Haryana reserves the right to add additional safeguard measures subsequently, if found necessary. EC granted will be revoked if it is found that false information has been given for getting approval of this project. PP will start construction only after getting NOC from Forest department that area under consideration does not fall under section 4 and 5 PLPA 1900. All other statutory clearances such as approvals for storage of diesel from CCE, Fire Department, Civil Aviation Department, FC Act, 1980 and WLP Act, 1972, PLPA, 1900, Forest Act, 1927 etc. shall be obtained as applicable by PP from the respective authorities pnor to construction of the project. PP will not violate any judicial orders Ipronouncements issued by the Hon'ble Supreme Court I High Courts.
23
24
25
purpose as per the records.
Agreed to Comply. PA has assured to abide by the condition by construction of rainwater harvesting pits. Two pits, one each near STP unit & underground water storage have been seen during the visit which was constructed along storm water drainage system (Photo 4). PA was directed to assess the design and location for further developnlenL of such pits. Being Complied. Permission from AA was obtained, and copy has been submitted.
and 45% infrastructure works have been completed, conditions pertaining to operational phase will be reviewed later (Photos 5-8). It was observed that STP of capacity of 100 KLPD was installed but yet to be operated (Photo
Will be adhered as submitted by PA.
Being Complied. Six monthly reports were being submitted to RO, MOEFCC as evident from point 15 of DATA SHEET. Noted as submitted by PA.
Being Complied. Aravali NOC from Forest Department has been obtained, and copy was submitted to MOEFCC.
Being Complied. Permissions from Airport Authority, NOC from Forest Department, and Consent to Establish from HSPCB have been obtained, and copies were submitted to MPEFCC.
Will be adhered as submitted by PA.
ENDNOTE:
It was noted during visit that Mis. Emaar MOF Land Ltd involves in development of group housing comprising of Plot 65 towers (S+7 floors = 19 Towers; S+8=17 Towers; S+9 = 20 Towers; S+10=7 Towers; S+11 = 2 Towers - Total = 65 Towers) covering built-up area of 2,82,527 sq m, spread over total area of area - 1,00,244 sq m (Le., 24 acres). It also includes dwelling units of 1139,296 EWS. Project involves total area of 24 acres & has proposed an expansion in another 5 acres.
Certification &MNR of Group Housing Project,Gurgaon, Haryana by Ms Emaar MGF 19.1.2017 - 5
Total water requirement is about 426 KLPD and about 508 KLPD domestic sewerage will be generated as per EC. PA had installed STP of 100 KLPD at present. It was observed and learnt during the visit that about 80% building and 45% infrastructural works have been completed so far. Green belt (GB) was found under development at few places (Photos 10-11). No works in proposed area was started.
1. Chronology of events: PA has requested Regional OlIice of the Ministry for issuance of certi'fication vide letter dated 15.11.2016. The Regional Office had requested vide letter dated 18.11.2016 for additional information W.r.t. issuance of certification. Requisite information was submitted by PA vide letter dated 15.12.2016.
2. Implementation of Conditions: It is evident from the above review that Consent to Establish has been obtained which was expired. Latest copy is yet to be submitted. It is evident from above mentioned review of compliance that majority of conditions of construction phase was complied whereas a few needs attention. The six monthly monitoring of noise, air & water quality and its submission along with six monthly compliance reports after 2012 was found regular.
3. Review w.r.f. to MOEFs letter dated 30.5.2012: The report was prepared after site visit on 19.1.17. 4. With regards to issuance of show cause/closure notices: HSPCB had issued show-cause notice vide
letter of 20 13 for non submission ofland papers, affidavit for construction of STP &extension of CTE. PA had replied vide letter dated 16.5.14 and submitted papers. Another show-cause notice was issued vide letter dated 1.8.16 under Water and Air Acts for non submission of valid copy of licen~e from DTep. The reply was submitted by PA vide letter dated 4.8.16 informing that application was made on 9.6.16 and will submit the same as soon as received. Renewal of CTE is yet to be issued by HSPCB as per record.
Certification & MNR ofGroup Housing Project,Gurgaon, Haryana by Ms Emaar MGF 19.1.2017 -6
Photo 1: Showing labor colony at site \' " -:-; ,
,.' ~, ( .. .
\ ! . I
Photos 5 - 6: Showing construction stage of project ~ ~II·
i.
Certification & MNR of Group Housing Project,Gurgaon, Haryana by Ms Emaar MGF 19.1.2017 -7
Certification & MNR of Group Housing Project,Gurgaon, Haryana by Ms Emaar MGF 19.1.2017 - 8
