+ All Categories
Home > Documents > NUCLEAR REGULATORY CCMMISSICN4 Irving Place /,s' New York City 10003 ' ' New York City 10003 'c ', "...

NUCLEAR REGULATORY CCMMISSICN4 Irving Place /,s' New York City 10003 ' ' New York City 10003 'c ', "...

Date post: 01-Mar-2021
Category:
Upload: others
View: 1 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
7
. .. UNITED STATE 3 0F AXERICA ' ' NUCLEAR REGULATORY CCMMISSICN BEFCRE THE ATOMIC 3AFETY AND LICENSING 30nRD --- Administrative Judges: Louis J. Carter, Chairman Oscar H. Paris ;'; m jg p7gg Frederick J. Shon - _g In the Matter of . CONSOLIDATED EDISON COMPANY OF MEW YORK : (Indian Point, Unit #2) Dockct Kos. . POWER A TEORITY CF THE STATE OF NEW YORK 50-247-SP . (Indian Point, Unit #3) 50-286-SP * : AMENDED FETITION FCR LEAVE TO INTERVENE 1. Petitioner, Parents Concerned About Indian Point, - recuests leave to intervene in the adjudicatory hearing initiated by the Euclear Regulatory Commission in-its Memo- randun and Order of January 8, 1981, as amended on September 18, 1981. Petitioner requests leave pursuant to the rules of practice of the Nuclear Regulatory Conmission at 10 CFR 2.714. 2. Petitioner is a voluntary unincorporated association, all of whose nembers live within the 50 mile ingestion exposure pathway Emergency Planning Zone. More than half of its members live within the 10 mile plume exposure pathway Emergency Plan- ning Zone. 3. Members of Parents Concerned About Indian Point | and their children stand to lose life, .!;ood health, and property if defective safety conditions result in a serious nuclear accident at Indian Point. 4. If adequate emergency plans are not implemented, the injury to members will be exacerbated. Conversely, a W ~ well designed and properly implemented energency plan co ,' minimi::e the disastrous effects of a radiation release. ' a RECEWup , 3 DEC1719816 5 *~ c - "NE75$8? ' 0,0t, 8 \ = ? o o$)2)g%an !JJgjo: o g Ph O - ,, , , - _ . _ __
Transcript
Page 1: NUCLEAR REGULATORY CCMMISSICN4 Irving Place /,s' New York City 10003 ' ' New York City 10003 'c ', " Geoffrey Cobb Syan-Charles M Pratte al Counsel '[7 12C Audubon Society,, 71 W.

. ..

UNITED STATE 3 0F AXERICA'

'

NUCLEAR REGULATORY CCMMISSICN

BEFCRE THE ATOMIC 3AFETY AND LICENSING 30nRD ---

Administrative Judges:Louis J. Carter, ChairmanOscar H. Paris ;'; m jg p7ggFrederick J. Shon

-

_g

In the Matter of .

CONSOLIDATED EDISON COMPANY OF MEW YORK :(Indian Point, Unit #2) Dockct Kos..

POWER A TEORITY CF THE STATE OF NEW YORK 50-247-SP.

(Indian Point, Unit #3) 50-286-SP*

:

AMENDED FETITION FCR LEAVE TO INTERVENE

1. Petitioner, Parents Concerned About Indian Point,-

recuests leave to intervene in the adjudicatory hearing

initiated by the Euclear Regulatory Commission in-its Memo-randun and Order of January 8, 1981, as amended on September18, 1981. Petitioner requests leave pursuant to the rules of

practice of the Nuclear Regulatory Conmission at 10 CFR 2.714.2. Petitioner is a voluntary unincorporated association,

all of whose nembers live within the 50 mile ingestion exposure

pathway Emergency Planning Zone. More than half of its memberslive within the 10 mile plume exposure pathway Emergency Plan-

ning Zone.

3. Members of Parents Concerned About Indian Point| and their children stand to lose life, .!;ood health, and property

if defective safety conditions result in a serious nuclear

accident at Indian Point.

4. If adequate emergency plans are not implemented,the injury to members will be exacerbated. Conversely, a

W ~

well designed and properly implemented energency plan co ,'minimi::e the disastrous effects of a radiation release. '

a RECEWup,

3 DEC1719816 5*~

c - "NE75$8?'

0,0t, 8 \ =? oo$)2)g%an !JJgjo:o g

Ph O- ,, ,

, - _ . _ __

Page 2: NUCLEAR REGULATORY CCMMISSICN4 Irving Place /,s' New York City 10003 ' ' New York City 10003 'c ', " Geoffrey Cobb Syan-Charles M Pratte al Counsel '[7 12C Audubon Society,, 71 W.

. .,

.

-2-

5. Most of the members of Parents Concerned AboutIndian Point and their children, living within 10 miles ofIndian Point, will be required to implement any evacuationplan in case of an accident at Indian Point. All the nenbers,

living within 50 miles, will be required to implement otheremergency response plans. As these emergency plans will

directly control their behavior in the event of a nuclearaccident at Indian Point, they have a stake in any determin-ation of the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board re6arding the" current status and degree of conformity with NRC/PEMA

~

guidblines of state and local emergency plannin6" and" improvements in the level of planning" which"can be ex-pected in the near future."

6. The risks of a nuclear accident at Indian Pointare directly related to the safety factors which are thesubject of the current investigation by the Atomic Safetyand licensing Board. Therefore the probability that membersof Parents' Concerned About Indian Point and their childrenwill be called upon to react in a nuclear emer6ency will beaffected by the outcome of the proceedings.

7. Petitioner requests leave to intervene in the

j adjudicatory hearing to represent the interests of members -

! of the group and their children, including the followingI named persons whoexercise direct electoral control over theI business of the organization, and who have authorized Parents

Concerned About Indian Point to represent them:|

j Ms. ?at Posner Ms. Ervine Eimerling

| 22 Park Trail 34 Piney Point .. venue

Croton-on-Hudson Croton-on-HudsonNew York, 10520 New York, 10520

Pred & Debby Bobson Mc. Phyllis Rodrigue:36 Heatherdell Road 64 Elmore Avenue,

Ardsley, New York 10512 Croton-on-Eudson!

Hew York, 10520

|

;

i

I

Page 3: NUCLEAR REGULATORY CCMMISSICN4 Irving Place /,s' New York City 10003 ' ' New York City 10003 'c ', " Geoffrey Cobb Syan-Charles M Pratte al Counsel '[7 12C Audubon Society,, 71 W.

. .,

.

_3-,

8. Parrnts Concerned About Indian Point can reasonably

be expected to make valuable contributions in developing therecord regarding "the current status...of state and local emer-

gency planning" and "other offsite e=ergency procedures thatare feasible and should be taken to protect the public."

Members, all living in the affected area immediately surrounding

Indian Point, are able to elicit information from local

officials, administrators, emergency personnel, doctors,

teachers, and parents regarding their knowledge.of e=ergency

plans, their responsibilities under the plan, and their abilityto implement the plan.,

9. Petitioner is uniquely qualified by residence within

the Emergency Planning Zone, to uncover and point out specialproblems or situations in the EPZ which might adversely affectimplementation of the emergency response plans.10. Petitioner specifically seeks leave to intervene in

respect to the.following issues, which have been further devel-

oped in formal contentions filed at the Pre-Hearin6 Conferenceon December 2:

(i) Whether the psychol 6gical, emotional, andphysical health and safety of children areadequat-ely protected against the dangers ofthe Indian Point nuclear Power Station.

(11) Whether the emergency response plans forIndian Point, within the 10 and the 50 mileEmergency Planning Zone, conform with NRC/ FEMAguidelines, are capable of being implemented,and are adequate to protect the health and safetyof children.

(iii) Whether the permane.nt closnng of the IndianPoint nuclear Power Station will have a bene-ficial effect on the environ =ent of the childrenof members of petitinner.

10. For=the foregoing reasons, Petitioner requests

leave to intervene in the above-captioned hearing.

December 10, 1981P.O. Box 125 Respectfully submitted

Croton-onHudson, UY 10520

M le M A-Service List Attached' / J

. . . .

Page 4: NUCLEAR REGULATORY CCMMISSICN4 Irving Place /,s' New York City 10003 ' ' New York City 10003 'c ', " Geoffrey Cobb Syan-Charles M Pratte al Counsel '[7 12C Audubon Society,, 71 W.

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _

. . .,

.

CERTI?IC d E OF' SEhVIC E.

I here'oy certify the.t on the 10th day of Decemoer, 1981,I caused a copy of the foregoing Amended Petition for Leaveto Intervene to be served by first-class = ail, postage prepaid,

on the following:

Louis J. Carter, Ch;.irman WESPAC.Atomic Saftey and Licensing P.C. Box 488

Board White Plains, ICf 10602

US h3CWashington, D.C . 20555 Greater NY Council_--

e ;- on nnergy3 rent L. Frandenberg ,.j ,. C N ,s c/o CorrenConsolidated Edison ,y V .\ h"f U , 26 S tuyve r e r.t F t .-

New York City 100034 Irving Place /,s'' '

New York City 10003 'c "', Geoffrey Cobb Syan-

Charles M Pratt '[7 12C Audubon Societye al Counsel 71 W. 23rd St. fle23, ,

ew n City 1001010 Columous Circle - gg.

..

New York C ty 10019 Stanley 3. Klintergi

liew York state Energy CfcJeffrey h. slum, maq. ~-2 R c h',eller5tae3 cla::;aKiU Law School any, M 12223423 Vanderbilt Mc.ll40 Washington Square S.New York City 10012 Hon. Ruth W. essenger

Coundll MemcerMr. John Gilroy 4th Listrict, HannattanMs. Hoah Holt City HallFf?IRG New York C ty, 10007i5 Beekman StreetNew York City 10038 Friends of the Ea thr

208 W. 13th St.New Yo k City 10011Environmental Protection r

3ureauNYS Attorney General's Office Mr. Alfred LelBello2 World Trade Center County Executive,

'ie tchecter C ountyNew York City 10047 s148 hartine .we

General Counsel White Plains, 'Fi 10601Port ofthority of :2 & KJCne World Trade Center Office of Executive LegalNew York City 10048 Direcoor

US . IGicMayor George Legany Washington, D.C. 20555Vill?Ce of muchanan236 Tate Avenue Docketing x. . service

.,

Suchanan, iri 10511 F.a uRCaashington, D.C. 20 _p:

Prederick Shon MemberOscar Paris, Memcer

/] / q4

AS & L2, R~GRC u - -/- -e ' v /, +n..w..?'l,

'

./ i -- -',Washington 3,C. 20555 /. ''

Page 5: NUCLEAR REGULATORY CCMMISSICN4 Irving Place /,s' New York City 10003 ' ' New York City 10003 'c ', " Geoffrey Cobb Syan-Charles M Pratte al Counsel '[7 12C Audubon Society,, 71 W.

. ;.

.

C:4I:ED STATES OF nMERICAhECLEaR REGLL: CRi CCIGISSICh .

ACMIC S..F E : A:iD LICEboIhG FLARD

.efore sdministrhtive JaA,ec, . ..

,

,3 i., U- 3 2 b., ,o, . , ,

'

ou t s a . t, art er , enairman #, s4Dr. Uscar H. PariaFrederick J. Shon ,

In the matter of :Docket hes: 50-247-SF

Consolidated Ediaon Company of : 50-286-oPLew fork (Indian Point, Unit 2)

Power uthority of the State :of hew York (Indian Point, Unit 3)

.

Affidavit of ?.embership

PnRENrS CONCER ;ED A CM IhDI.,E ECIET

dtate of New YorkCounty of Westchester ss.:

irvine Kimerling ,being duls sworn, states:

I as a resident of Piney Point Avenue, Croton-on-Hudson,..ew York. My nome is approximately 1x mile; from tne IndianPoint ';uclear Power 6tation.

I am a memcer of Parents Concerned Acout Indian 'roint,a voluntary unicorporated association which has the purposeof assuring the safety of children, includin6 my children,in the fifty mile ingestion exposure pathway EmergencyPlanning Zone.

As part of my effort to secure the safety of myenildren in the face of a possit:le nuclear emergency atIPi?S, I authorize Parents Concernec Acout Indian foint tointervene on my cehalf and on cen.slf of my cnildren athearines before the atomic Cafety and Licensing oardconvened pursuant to Nuclear Regul . tory '.oramission Memo-randums and Crders dated Janunry 3, 1981 and deptember 18, 1961.

, -

W ~/ /

G r+ /m>$~..a'

/ f

'Jworn to befope me this .

~

day of, 434k - lWl

. MG/ W'n

JOHN A. BENSoNNOTARY PUBUC. Ctate of New York

No. 60 0247983Quebfied m Westcheeter C )

Commission Empires March 30.1

Page 6: NUCLEAR REGULATORY CCMMISSICN4 Irving Place /,s' New York City 10003 ' ' New York City 10003 'c ', " Geoffrey Cobb Syan-Charles M Pratte al Counsel '[7 12C Audubon Society,, 71 W.

- _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

. x,

.

,

C';II1ED STATES d c,MERIC.ib.

KUCLE..R REGULAiCRY CCMMISSICL~'

ATCMIC Sc_FETY AND LICEh6IIiG BCARDT 3M 2 37'iefore Administrative Judgea

MLouis J. Carter, ChairmanDr. Oscar H. ParisFrederick J. Shon -

In the matter of :D cket hos: 50-247-JF

Consolidated Edison Company of : %-28c-aPLew York (Indian Point, Unit 2)

Power suthority of the State :of hew York (Indian Point, Unit 3)

.

Affidavit of Membership

PAREfff S CONCERNED A3CCr INDI.d POINT

State of New York~

"ounty of Westchester ss.:

Ervine Kimerling ,beins duly sworn, sta.tes:

I am a resident of Piney Point Avenue, Croton-on-Hudson,1ew York. My home is approximately six miles from the IndianPoint Nuclear Power Station.

I an a member of Parents Concerned Aoout Indian koint,a voluntary unicorporated association which has the purposeof assuring the safety of children, including my children,in the fifty mile ingestion exposure pathway EmergencyPlanning Zone.

As part of my effort to secure the safety of myenildren in the face of a possible nuclear emergency atIPi.P S , I authorize Parents Conc nec About Indian Point tointervene on my behalf and on 'oehalf of my cnildren athearines before the Atomic Safety =nd Licensing conrdconvened pursuant to Nuclear Regulc, tory Commission >iemo-rancums and Crders dated January 8, 1981 and Septemter le, 19ei.

Ai' W /

(J n w a r Y , - .- i u '-

!dworn to befo e me thisday of, lW

,YLGJOHN A. BENSON

NOTARY PUSUC State of New YorkNo. 60-02A7983

Quehtied m WestchesterCommission Expree Merch 30,1

1

''

- . _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ - - _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _________J

Page 7: NUCLEAR REGULATORY CCMMISSICN4 Irving Place /,s' New York City 10003 ' ' New York City 10003 'c ', " Geoffrey Cobb Syan-Charles M Pratte al Counsel '[7 12C Audubon Society,, 71 W.

- - _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ .

m'

.. .

UfiI1ED S1 ATES LP AMERIC ATJCLEAR REGULA1LRT ULL ISSIUN

MCMIC S AFE!? ALD LICE;iSI::3 %ARD31 D :d 32:3.,1

Before .idministrative Judges: gLouis J. Carter, Chiirmanescar E. Paria . ..

.

Frederick J. Shen

In the Metter of :

Consolidated Edison L;ompeny of New York [ Docket*

Noc:(Indian Point, Unit c) : 5L-247-3P

: 50-286-SPPower Authority of the State of New York :

(Indian Point, Unit 3) :*.

:

Affidavit of Jiuthorization

PAREN2S CGECEREED AiUUi INDI.1N PCILT

State of New YorkCounty of Westcheeter ss.:

Pat Posner, cein6 duly sworn, states:,

The memcership of P& rents Concerned Acout IndicnPoint has established a Special Co.uittee to supervise theorganizational erfort to participt.te in the adjudicatory. hearing captioned aoove.

Committee memoers are Pat Posner, Phyllia Rodriguea,Kathy Toscani, Sherry Horowitz, Kancy Johnson, and damanthaSczerba.

Each of these individuals resides within th'e50 mile ingestion exposure pathway Emergency Planning Zone.

Each memoer of the committee is authcrized toact individually in filin6 documenta prepared on behalf of '

Parents Concernea About Indian Point, and in representingParents Concerned Acout Indian Point in any meeting, conference,correspondence, and/or affidavit related to the adjudicatoryhearing.

Parents Concerned Acout Indian Point receivedmail at P.O. :ox 125, Croton-on-Hudson, 2.ew York,10$20.

')|.^. ,

,'V- : ' ' , ,x ;,sn.. . t/! -

'O ? Pat PosnerSworntobefore!methisday of/7,k r. 1081. Picum P. f.*CTT

i.fi ,..; / :. . / , . tioter rutke. Sn?.'.Li<" wkQ~(;/x:,f!>

i no. mvw Ai

vuahfied m CutUc?S C0tr.!fd'emm $$:0A f eb*dt3 I*7403 D+ SN

.


Recommended