+ All Categories
Home > Documents > OBSERVATIONAL&TRIAL&OFQIGONG&AS&ACOMPLEMENTARY&PRACTICE&IN...

OBSERVATIONAL&TRIAL&OFQIGONG&AS&ACOMPLEMENTARY&PRACTICE&IN...

Date post: 11-Mar-2018
Category:
Upload: hadan
View: 216 times
Download: 4 times
Share this document with a friend
1
Most par)cipants in this study are experienced CFQ prac))oners (n=24) and may have already seen improvements in pain levels. Some par)cipants in this study had lower levels of pain (<4) at baseline (n=12). Higher baseline pain levels may be required to see significant changes in pain scores. Although there were no significant changes in pain scores, pa)ents con)nue to prac)ce CFQ because they feel the prac)ce has benefit and gives them a greater sense of control over their pain (this is reflected in qualita)ve comments). ALer 24 weeks of prac)ce, par)cipants have a greater internal locus of control. Internal locus of control is essen)al to a successful pain self management program. Qualita)ve data also indicates the benefit of CFQ for other health areas (e.g. sleep, diges)ve health). Further research in this area is warranted. Introduc6on OBSERVATIONAL TRIAL OF QIGONG AS A COMPLEMENTARY PRACTICE IN A CHRONIC PAIN PROGRAM M.Pike, J. Sawynok, PhD, M. Lynch, MD, FRCPC, A J. Clark, MD, FRCPC, D. Marcon Conclusions References Acknowledgements Contact Results Summary Methods Qualita6ve Comments aLer 6 WEEKS OF PRACTICE PAIN I AM NOT NEW TO CFQ QIGONG SO I USE THE CLASSES TO MAINTAIN CONTROL OF MY PAIN AND ENJOYMENT OF LIFE. (78.5% reported decrease in pain) SLEEP I NO LONGER NEED MY CPAP AT ALL. (53.5% reported improvement in sleep) QOL ALTHOUGH I STILL SUFFER WITH PAIN I CAN LIVE WITH IT NOW AND HAVE REGAINED MY JOY OF LIFE. I CAN NOW GO OUT WITH FRIENDS OR FAMILY AND ENJOY MYSELF AND AM NO LONGER HOUSEBOUND. WHEN I HAVE A BUSY DAY I REST THE FOLLOWING DAY. LIFE IS MUCH MORE PEACEFUL AND I AM GRATEFUL. (78.5% reported improvement in quality of life) OTHER HEALTH MY DIGESTIVE HEALTH SEEMS TO HAVE IMPROVED. I’VE BEEN EATING SOME OF THE FOODS I STRICTLY HAD TO AVOID BEFORE, AND I’VE BEEN OK! THIS FEELS LIKE A MIRACLE, AND IT’S MAKING ME FEEL SO MUCH HAPPIER AND LESS TENSE/ANXIOUS ABOUT EATING. (71% reported improvement in other health areas) PAIN I NO LONGER HAVE PAIN. (50% reported decrease in pain) SLEEP SLEEPING THROUGH THE NIGHT NEARLY EVERY NIGHT MAINTAINING SLEEP, FASTER TO FALL ASLEEP, FEEL MORE RESTED AFTER I'VE GOTTEN UP. (50% reported improvement in sleep) QOL IMPROVED OVERALL OUTLOOK, PATIENCE, RESILIENCY TO HANDLE LIFE CHALLENGES. (50% reported improvement in quality of life) OTHER HEALTH MY SENSITIVITIES TO FOOD ARE GONE, I CAN EAT WHATEVER I WANT. (50% reported improvement in other health areas) Qualita6ve Comments aLer 24 WEEKS OF PRACTICE Table A. Data Collec)on Periods CFQ is a form of “Medita6ve Movement” that uses movement in coordina)on with aeen)on to breath and body propriocep)on. Exis)ng evidence of benefits of CFQ as a complementary prac)ce for fibromyalgia, anxiety and depression. Literature indicates further research in this area is warranted. Pain selfmanagement is an integral part of chronic pain treatment (Nicholas, 2015) The current study consists of a mixedmethods, prospec)ve observa)onal study examining the effects of Chaoyi Fanhuan Qigong (CFQ) prac)ce on chronic pain CFQ classes are offered through QEll Health Sciences Center’s Pain Management Unit. Each session lasts 6 weeks with weekly, 2hour classes. Group membership is open with no limit to how many classes one can aeend. New par)cipants can enter the study at the beginning of any 6week session. Current data is presented for n=28, including both new and experienced prac66oners Outcomes measured by a series of surveys collected at baseline and aLer each 6week session Primary outcome measure: Pain (Brief Pain Inventory). Secondary outcome measures: Quality of Life (Short Form 12), Mood (Profile of Mood States), Health Locus of Control, Prac)ce Time ANOVA (Analysis of Variance) used to compare outcomes to baseline. Thema)c analysis used to evaluate qualita)ve informa)on No significant changes in pain scores between baseline (wk=0) and aLer 6, 12, 18 and 24 weeks of prac)ce. No significant changes in Health Locus of Control (HLOC) Scores between baseline (wk=0) and aLer 6, 12 and 18 weeks of prac)ce; however, by 24 weeks of prac)ce there was a significant decrease in Health Locus of Control (HLOC) Scores from baseline (wk=0). Lower HLOC scores correlate to a greater internal locus of control. Qualita)ve data reveals the benefits of CFQ for pa6ents living with chronic pain. Quan)ta)ve data indicates that CFQ prac)ce fosters an internal locus of control, which is an essen)al component of any pain selfmanagement program. This research is ongoing – two more cohorts of data are currently being collected and analyzed (an)cipate n=10 addi)onal subjects). This communitybased study reveals the benefits of CFQ and should encourage clinicians and other health care professionals to consider recommending CFQ to pa)ents living with chronic pain. 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Score Weeks of Prac6ce BPI Scores aLer 6 weeks (n=28) Worst Pain Least Pain Average Pain Current Pain Pain Interference 0 6 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Score Weeks of Prac6ce BPI Scores aLer 24 weeks (n=8) Worst Pain Least Pain Average Pain Current Pain Pain Interference 0 6 12 18 24 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 Score Weeks of Prac6ce HLOC Scores aLer 6 weeks (n=28) 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 Score Weeks of Prac6ce HLOC Scores aLer 24 weeks (n=8) 0 6 0 6 12 18 0 6 12 18 24 Department of Anaesthesia, Pain Management and Periopera)ve Medicine and QEII Health Sciences Centre Pain Management Unit for suppor)ng this research Dana Marcon, Level 1 CFQ instructor Dalhousie University School of Medicine Research in Medicine (RIM) Program RIM Studentship Award Sylva de la Ronde and Colleen O’Connell for sta)s)cal support Dworkin RH, Turk DC, Farrar JT, Haythornthwaite JA, Jensen MP, Katz NP, Kerns RD, (2005). Core outcome measures for chronic pain clinical trials: IMMPACT recommenda)ons. Pain 113:919. Lynch M, Sawynok J, Hiew C, Marcon D (2012). A randomized controlled trial of qigong for fibromyalgia. Arthri)s Research & Therapy 14:111. Nicholas M (2015). Expanding Pa)ents’ Access to Help in Managing Their Chronic Pain. Interna)onal Associa)on for the Study of Pain. 23(1):18. Sawynok J, Lynch M, Marcon D (2013). Extension Trial of Qigong for Fibromyalgia: A Quan)ta)ve and Qualita)ve Study. Evidence Based Complementary and Alterna)ve Medicine 2013:111. Meghan Pike, Principal Inves)gator [email protected] *
Transcript
Page 1: OBSERVATIONAL&TRIAL&OFQIGONG&AS&ACOMPLEMENTARY&PRACTICE&IN ...my!joy!of!life.!ican!now!go!out!withfriends!orfamily ... foods!istrictly!had!to!avoid!before,!and!i’ve!been!ok!!this!feels

   §  Most  par)cipants  in  this  study  are  experienced  

CFQ  prac))oners  (n=24)  and  may  have  already  seen  improvements  in  pain  levels.  

§  Some  par)cipants  in  this  study  had  lower  levels  of  pain  (<4)  at  baseline  (n=12).  Higher  baseline  pain  levels  may  be  required  to  see  significant  changes  in  pain  scores.  

§  Although  there  were  no  significant  changes  in  pain  scores,  pa)ents  con)nue  to  prac)ce  CFQ  because  they  feel  the  prac)ce  has  benefit  and  gives  them  a  greater  sense  of  control  over  their  pain  (this  is  reflected  in  qualita)ve  comments).  

§  ALer  24  weeks  of  prac)ce,  par)cipants  have  a  greater  internal  locus  of  control.  Internal  locus  of  control  is  essen)al  to  a  successful  pain  self-­‐management  program.  Qualita)ve  data  also  indicates  the  benefit  of  CFQ  for  other  health  areas  (e.g.  sleep,  diges)ve  health).  Further  research  in  this  area  is  warranted.  

Introduc6on  

   

OBSERVATIONAL  TRIAL  OF  QIGONG  AS  A  COMPLEMENTARY  PRACTICE  IN  A  CHRONIC  PAIN  PROGRAM  M.Pike,  J.  Sawynok,  PhD,  M.  Lynch,  MD,  FRCPC,  A  J.  Clark,  MD,  FRCPC,  D.  Marcon    

Conclusions  

References  

Acknowledgements  

Contact  

Results  

Summary  

Methods  

Qualita6ve  Comments  aLer  6  WEEKS  OF  PRACTICE  PAIN   I  AM  NOT  NEW  TO  CFQ  QIGONG  SO  I  USE  THE  CLASSES  TO  MAINTAIN  CONTROL  OF  

MY  PAIN  AND  ENJOYMENT  OF  LIFE.  (78.5%  reported  decrease  in  pain)  SLEEP   I  NO  LONGER  NEED  MY  C-­‐PAP  AT  ALL.  (53.5%  reported  improvement  in  sleep)  QOL   ALTHOUGH  I  STILL  SUFFER  WITH  PAIN  I  CAN  LIVE  WITH  IT  NOW  AND  HAVE  

REGAINED  MY  JOY  OF  LIFE.  I  CAN  NOW  GO  OUT  WITH  FRIENDS  OR  FAMILY  AND  ENJOY  MYSELF  AND  AM  NO  LONGER  HOUSEBOUND.  WHEN  I  HAVE  A  BUSY  DAY  I  REST  THE  FOLLOWING  DAY.  LIFE  IS  MUCH  MORE  PEACEFUL  AND  I  AM  GRATEFUL.  (78.5%  reported  improvement  in  quality  of  life)  

OTHER  HEALTH  

MY  DIGESTIVE  HEALTH  SEEMS  TO  HAVE  IMPROVED.  I’VE  BEEN  EATING  SOME  OF  THE  FOODS  I  STRICTLY  HAD  TO  AVOID  BEFORE,  AND  I’VE  BEEN  OK!  THIS  FEELS  LIKE  A  MIRACLE,  AND  IT’S  MAKING  ME  FEEL  SO  MUCH  HAPPIER  AND  LESS  TENSE/ANXIOUS  ABOUT  EATING.  (71%  reported  improvement  in  other  health  areas)  

PAIN   I  NO  LONGER  HAVE  PAIN.  (50%  reported  decrease  in  pain)    SLEEP   SLEEPING  THROUGH  THE  NIGHT  NEARLY  EVERY  NIGHT  -­‐  MAINTAINING  SLEEP,  

FASTER  TO  FALL  ASLEEP,  FEEL  MORE  RESTED  AFTER  I'VE  GOTTEN  UP.  (50%  reported  improvement  in  sleep)  

QOL   IMPROVED  OVERALL  OUTLOOK,  PATIENCE,  RESILIENCY  TO  HANDLE  LIFE  CHALLENGES.  (50%  reported  improvement  in  quality  of  life)    

OTHER  HEALTH  

MY  SENSITIVITIES  TO  FOOD  ARE  GONE,  I  CAN  EAT  WHATEVER  I  WANT.    (50%  reported  improvement  in  other  health  areas)    

Qualita6ve  Comments  aLer  24  WEEKS  OF  PRACTICE  

Table  A.  Data  Collec)on  Periods  

 §  CFQ  is  a  form  of  “Medita6ve  Movement”  that  

uses  movement  in  coordina)on  with  aeen)on  to  breath  and  body  propriocep)on.  

§  Exis)ng  evidence  of  benefits  of  CFQ  as  a  complementary  prac)ce  for  fibromyalgia,  anxiety  and  depression.  Literature  indicates  further  research  in  this  area  is  warranted.  

§  Pain  self-­‐management  is  an  integral  part  of  chronic  pain  treatment  (Nicholas,  2015)  

§  The  current  study  consists  of  a  mixed-­‐methods,  prospec)ve  observa)onal  study  examining  the  effects  of  Chaoyi  Fanhuan  Qigong  (CFQ)  prac)ce  on  chronic  pain    

§  CFQ  classes  are  offered  through  QEll  Health  Sciences  Center’s  Pain  Management  Unit.  Each  session  lasts  6  weeks  with  weekly,  2-­‐hour  classes.  Group  membership  is  open  with  no  limit  to  how  many  classes  one  can  aeend.    

§  New  par)cipants  can  enter  the  study  at  the  beginning  of  any  6-­‐week  session.  Current  data  is  presented  for  n=28,  including  both  new  and  experienced  prac66oners  

§  Outcomes  measured  by  a  series  of  surveys  collected  at  baseline  and  aLer  each  6-­‐week  session    

§  Primary  outcome  measure:  Pain  (Brief  Pain  Inventory).  Secondary  outcome  measures:  Quality  of  Life  (Short  Form  12),  Mood  (Profile  of  Mood  States),  Health  Locus  of  Control,  Prac)ce  Time    

§  ANOVA  (Analysis  of  Variance)  used  to  compare  outcomes  to  baseline.  Thema)c  analysis  used  to  evaluate  qualita)ve  informa)on  

No  significant  changes  in  pain  scores  between  baseline  (wk=0)  and  aLer  6,  12,  18  and  24  weeks  of  prac)ce.  

No  significant  changes  in  Health  Locus  of  Control  (HLOC)  Scores  between  baseline  (wk=0)  and  aLer  6,  12  and  18  weeks  of  prac)ce;  however,  by  24  weeks  of  prac)ce  there  was  a  significant  decrease  in  Health  Locus  of  Control  (HLOC)  Scores  from  baseline  (wk=0).  Lower  HLOC  scores  correlate  to  a  greater  internal  locus  of  control.    

§  Qualita)ve  data  reveals  the  benefits  of  CFQ  for  pa6ents  living  with  chronic  pain.  

§  Quan)ta)ve  data  indicates  that  CFQ  prac)ce  fosters  an  internal  locus  of  control,  which  is  an  essen)al  component  of  any  pain  self-­‐management  program.    

§  This  research  is  ongoing  –  two  more  cohorts  of  data  are  currently  being  collected  and  analyzed  (an)cipate  n=10  addi)onal  subjects).  

§  This  community-­‐based  study  reveals  the  benefits  of  CFQ  and  should  encourage  clinicians  and  other  health  care  professionals  to  consider  recommending  CFQ  to  pa)ents  living  with  chronic  pain.    

0  

1  

2  

3  

4  

5  

6  

7  

8  

9  

10  

Score  

Weeks  of  Prac6ce  

BPI  Scores  aLer  6  weeks  (n=28)  

Worst  Pain  

Least  Pain  

Average  Pain  

Current  Pain  

Pain  Interference  

0                                                                                                                                                                                                                        6  0  

1  

2  

3  

4  

5  

6  

7  

8  

9  

10  

Score  

Weeks  of  Prac6ce  

BPI  Scores  aLer  24  weeks  (n=8)  

Worst  Pain  

Least  Pain  

Average  Pain  

Current  Pain  

Pain  Interference  

0                                                                                    6                                                                                12                                                                              18                                                                              24                                  

0  

5  

10  

15  

20  

25  

30  

35  

40  

Score  

Weeks  of  Prac6ce  

HLOC  Scores  aLer  6  weeks  (n=28)  

0  

5  

10  

15  

20  

25  

30  

35  

40  

Score  

Weeks  of  Prac6ce  

HLOC  Scores  aLer  24  weeks  (n=8)  

0                                                                                                                                                    6   0                                                            6                                                                12                                                      18                   0                                              6                                                    12                                        18                                                  24                                                            

§  Department  of  Anaesthesia,  Pain  Management  and  Periopera)ve  Medicine  and  QEII  Health  Sciences  Centre  Pain  Management  Unit  for  suppor)ng  this  research  

§  Dana  Marcon,  Level  1  CFQ  instructor    §  Dalhousie  University  School  of  Medicine  Research  in  Medicine  

(RIM)  Program    §  RIM  Studentship  Award    §  Sylva  de  la  Ronde  and  Colleen  O’Connell  for  sta)s)cal  support  

Dworkin  RH,  Turk  DC,  Farrar  JT,  Haythornthwaite  JA,  Jensen  MP,  Katz  NP,  Kerns  RD,  (2005).  Core  outcome  measures  for  chronic  pain  clinical  trials:  IMMPACT  recommenda)ons.  Pain  113:9-­‐19.      Lynch  M,  Sawynok  J,  Hiew  C,  Marcon  D  (2012).  A  randomized  controlled  trial  of  qigong  for  fibromyalgia.  Arthri)s  Research  &  Therapy  14:1-­‐11.      Nicholas  M  (2015).  Expanding  Pa)ents’  Access  to  Help  in  Managing  Their  Chronic  Pain.  Interna)onal  Associa)on  for  the  Study  of  Pain.  23(1):1-­‐8.    Sawynok  J,  Lynch  M,  Marcon  D  (2013).  Extension  Trial  of  Qigong  for  Fibromyalgia:  A  Quan)ta)ve  and  Qualita)ve  Study.  Evidence-­‐Based  Complementary  and  Alterna)ve  Medicine  2013:1-­‐11.        

Meghan  Pike,  Principal  Inves)gator    [email protected]    

*  

Recommended