Project No. 170228

PID 85377

CUY-SR 2-14.41

Federal

Type: BRIDGE REPAIR

Completion Date: 10/31/2018

Award Amount: $21,420,769.00

Contract Awarded To: VIMAS PAINTING COMPANY INC

Letting Date: 5/4/2017

Engineer's Estimate: $22,400,000.00

Ohio Department of Transportation

Official Bid Tabulation

Jerry Wray, Director

VIMAS PAINTING COMPANY INC

4328 MC CARTNEY RD

LOWELVILLE, OH 44436

Mahoning

Bidder 1

Bid $21,420,769.00

APBN INC

670 ROBINSON RD

CAMPBELL, OH 44405

Mahoning

Bidder 2

Bid $23,070,829.77

360 CONSTRUCTION COMPANY INC

1252 INDUSTRIAL PARKWAY NORTH SUITE 1

BRUNSWICK, OH 44212

Medina

Bidder 3

Bid $25,387,681.40

LIBERTY MAINTENANCE INC

777 N MERIDIAN RD

YOUNGSTOWN, OH 44509

Mahoning

Bidder 4

Bid $31,399,814.74

170228 - Page 1

Ref #1 646E10010 EDGE LINE, 6", (5.65 MILE)

Awd $25,990.00$4,600.00

2 $28,122.88$4,977.50

3 $28,250.00$5,000.00

4 $30,679.50$5,430.00

Ref #2 646E10110 LANE LINE, 6", (4.63 MILE)

Awd $14,353.00$3,100.00

2 $15,610.05$3,371.50

3 $16,205.00$3,500.00

4 $17,029.14$3,678.00

Ref #3 646E10310 CHANNELIZING LINE, 12", (2093 FT)

Awd $6,279.00$3.00

2 $5,546.45$2.65

3 $6,279.00$3.00

4 $6,069.70$2.90

Ref #4 646E10600 TRANSVERSE/DIAGONAL LINE, (309 FT)

Awd $4,635.00$15.00

2 $5,098.50$16.50

3 $4,712.25$15.25

4 $5,562.00$18.00

Section 1 - TRAFFIC CONTROL - Totals

Awd $51,257.00

2 $54,377.88

3 $55,446.25

4 $59,340.34

Ref #5 614E11110 LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER WITH PATROL CAR FOR ASSIST, (50 HOUR)

Awd $3,500.00$70.00

2 $3,300.00$66.00

3 $3,250.00$65.00

4 $5,000.00$100.00

Ref #6 614E12338 WORK ZONE IMPACT ATTENUATOR (BIDIRECTIONAL), (11 EACH)

Awd $24,200.00$2,200.00

2 $26,620.00$2,420.00

3 $25,300.00$2,300.00

4 $29,040.00$2,640.00

Ref #7 614E12410 SPEED ZONE AHEAD SYMBOL SIGN, (2 EACH)

Awd $200.00$100.00

2 $121.00$60.50

3 $250.00$125.00

4 $180.00$90.00

Ref #8 614E12420 DETOUR SIGNING, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $4,000.00$4,000.00

2 $1,870.00$1,870.00

3 $1,500.00$1,500.00

4 $3,240.00$3,240.00

Ref #9 614E12470 WORK ZONE SPEED LIMIT SIGN, (6 EACH)

Awd $600.00$100.00

2 $363.00$60.50

3 $750.00$125.00

4 $612.00$102.00

170228 - Page 2

Ref #10 614E12484 WORK ZONE INCREASED PENALTIES SIGN, (2 EACH)

Awd $200.00$100.00

2 $165.00$82.50

3 $420.00$210.00

4 $240.00$120.00

Ref #11 614E12500 REPLACEMENT SIGN, (10 EACH)

Awd $1,500.00$150.00

2 $1,650.00$165.00

3 $800.00$80.00

4 $1,800.00$180.00

Ref #12 614E13100 BARRIER REFLECTOR, (3599 EACH)

Awd $25,193.00$7.00

2 $31,671.20$8.80

3 $19,794.50$5.50

4 $30,231.60$8.40

Ref #13 614E18601 PORTABLE CHANGEABLE MESSAGE SIGN, AS PER PLAN, (8 SNMT)

Awd $16,000.00$2,000.00

2 $9,240.00$1,155.00

3 $7,600.00$950.00

4 $12,000.00$1,500.00

Ref #14 614E20000 WORK ZONE LANE LINE, CLASS I, (3.06 MILE)

Awd $1,836.00$600.00

2 $1,683.00$550.00

3 $979.20$320.00

4 $1,836.00$600.00

Ref #15 614E22000 WORK ZONE EDGE LINE, CLASS I, (18.67 MILE)

Awd $13,069.00$700.00

2 $12,630.26$676.50

3 $23,337.50$1,250.00

4 $13,778.46$738.00

Ref #16 614E23000 WORK ZONE CHANNELIZING LINE, CLASS I, (4964 FT)

Awd $4,964.00$1.00

2 $3,028.04$0.61

3 $2,978.40$0.60

4 $3,276.24$0.66

Ref #17 614E25000 WORK ZONE TRANSVERSE/DIAGONAL LINE, CLASS I, (233 FT)

Awd $699.00$3.00

2 $577.84$2.48

3 $547.55$2.35

4 $629.10$2.70

Ref #18 616E10000 WATER, (1 MGAL)

Awd $3,000.00$3,000.00

2 $110.00$110.00

3 $2,000.00$2,000.00

4 $2,000.00$2,000.00

Ref #19 622E41000 PORTABLE BARRIER, 32", (35990 FT)

Awd $287,920.00$8.00

2 $336,506.50$9.35

3 $251,930.00$7.00

4 $323,910.00$9.00

170228 - Page 3

Section 2 - MAINTENANCE OF TRAFFIC - Totals

Awd $386,881.00

2 $429,535.84

3 $341,437.15

4 $427,773.40

Ref #20 202E11203 PORTIONS OF STRUCTURE REMOVED, OVER 20 FOOT SPAN, , (LUMP SUM)

Awd $300,000.00$300,000.00

2 $327,800.00$327,800.00

3 $300,000.00$300,000.00

4 $357,600.00$357,600.00

Ref #21 202E11401 PORTIONS OF STRUCTURE REMOVED, AS PER PLAN, (2249 LB)

Awd $33,735.00$15.00

2 $37,108.50$16.50

3 $33,735.00$15.00

4 $40,482.00$18.00

Ref #22 509E10000 EPOXY COATED REINFORCING STEEL, (14316 LB)

Awd $42,948.00$3.00

2 $47,242.80$3.30

3 $42,948.00$3.00

4 $51,537.60$3.60

Ref #23 509E20001 REINFORCING STEEL, REPLACEMENT OF EXISTING REINFOR, (1000 LB)

Awd $3,000.00$3.00

2 $3,300.00$3.30

3 $5,000.00$5.00

4 $16,200.00$16.20

Ref #24 511E34444 CLASS QC2 CONCRETE, BRIDGE DECK, (98 CY)

Awd $509,600.00$5,200.00

2 $560,560.00$5,720.00

3 $539,000.00$5,500.00

4 $611,520.00$6,240.00

Ref #25 512E10050 SEALING OF CONCRETE SURFACES (NON-EPOXY), (55140 SY)

Awd $496,260.00$9.00

2 $394,251.00$7.15

3 $523,830.00$9.50

4 $551,400.00$10.00

Ref #26 512E10101 SEALING OF CONCRETE SURFACES (EPOXY-URETHANE), AS , (1010 SY)

Awd $33,835.00$33.50

2 $32,219.00$31.90

3 $35,350.00$35.00

4 $40,400.00$40.00

Ref #28 513E10200 STRUCTURAL STEEL MEMBERS, LEVEL UF, (32954 LB)

Awd $296,586.00$9.00

2 $326,244.60$9.90

3 $304,824.50$9.25

4 $355,903.20$10.80

Ref #29 513E95030 STRUCTURAL STEEL, MISC.: FORWARD SECTION COLUMN RE, (7 EACH)

Awd $11,200.00$1,600.00

2 $12,320.00$1,760.00

3 $11,200.00$1,600.00

4 $13,440.00$1,920.00

170228 - Page 4

Ref #30 513E95030 STRUCTURAL STEEL, MISC.: LAKEFRONT RAMP FLOORBEAM , (1 EACH)

Awd $7,500.00$7,500.00

2 $8,250.00$8,250.00

3 $7,500.00$7,500.00

4 $9,000.00$9,000.00

Ref #31 513E95030 STRUCTURAL STEEL, MISC.: LAKEFRONT RAMP GIRDER WEB, (1 EACH)

Awd $6,700.00$6,700.00

2 $7,370.00$7,370.00

3 $6,700.00$6,700.00

4 $8,040.00$8,040.00

Ref #32 513E95030 STRUCTURAL STEEL, MISC.: LAKEFRONT RAMP LATERAL BR, (1 EACH)

Awd $5,500.00$5,500.00

2 $6,050.00$6,050.00

3 $5,500.00$5,500.00

4 $6,600.00$6,600.00

Ref #33 513E95030 STRUCTURAL STEEL, MISC.: LAKEFRONT RAMP STRUT BRAC, (1 EACH)

Awd $5,500.00$5,500.00

2 $6,050.00$6,050.00

3 $5,500.00$5,500.00

4 $6,600.00$6,600.00

Ref #34 513E95030 STRUCTURAL STEEL, MISC.: LAKEFRONT TRESTLE KEEPER , (56 EACH)

Awd $16,800.00$300.00

2 $18,480.00$330.00

3 $16,800.00$300.00

4 $20,160.00$360.00

Ref #35 513E95030 STRUCTURAL STEEL, MISC.: MAIN TRUSS GUSSET PLATE E, (10 EACH)

Awd $20,000.00$2,000.00

2 $22,000.00$2,200.00

3 $20,000.00$2,000.00

4 $24,000.00$2,400.00

Ref #36 513E95030 STRUCTURAL STEEL, MISC.: WEST APPROACH FASCIA STRI, (3 EACH)

Awd $15,900.00$5,300.00

2 $17,490.00$5,830.00

3 $15,900.00$5,300.00

4 $19,080.00$6,360.00

Ref #37 513E95030 STRUCTURAL STEEL, MISC.: WEST APPROACH FASCIA STRI, (21 EACH)

Awd $44,100.00$2,100.00

2 $48,510.00$2,310.00

3 $44,100.00$2,100.00

4 $52,920.00$2,520.00

Ref #38 514E00101 SURFACE PREPARATION OF EXISTING STRUCTURAL STEEL, , (LUMP SUM)

Awd $9,000,000.00$9,000,000.00

2 $8,633,500.00$8,633,500.00

3 $10,000,000.00$10,000,000.00

4 $13,000,000.00$13,000,000.00

Ref #39 514E00201 FIELD PAINTING OF EXISTING STRUCTURAL STEEL, PRIME, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $2,000,000.00$2,000,000.00

2 $2,437,500.00$2,437,500.00

3 $4,000,000.00$4,000,000.00

4 $3,600,000.00$3,600,000.00

170228 - Page 5

Ref #40 514E00301 FIELD PAINTING STRUCTURAL STEEL, INTERMEDIATE COAT, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $2,000,000.00$2,000,000.00

2 $2,625,000.00$2,625,000.00

3 $2,500,000.00$2,500,000.00

4 $3,600,000.00$3,600,000.00

Ref #41 514E00401 FIELD PAINTING STRUCTURAL STEEL, FINISH COAT, AS P, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $1,900,000.00$1,900,000.00

2 $2,437,500.00$2,437,500.00

3 $2,000,000.00$2,000,000.00

4 $3,600,000.00$3,600,000.00

Ref #42 514E00504 GRINDING FINS, TEARS, SLIVERS ON EXISTING STRUCTUR, (2713 MNHR)

Awd $271,300.00$100.00

2 $135,650.00$50.00

3 $406,950.00$150.00

4 $406,950.00$150.00

Ref #43 514E10000 FINAL INSPECTION REPAIR, (622 EACH)

Awd $62,200.00$100.00

2 $62,200.00$100.00

3 $93,300.00$150.00

4 $124,400.00$200.00

Ref #44 516E14600 STRUCTURAL JOINT OR JOINT SEALER, MISC.: MODULAR E, (1224 FT)

Awd $153,000.00$125.00

2 $168,300.00$137.50

3 $153,000.00$125.00

4 $183,600.00$150.00

Ref #45 516E14600 STRUCTURAL JOINT OR JOINT SEALER, MISC.: STEEL COM, (898 FT)

Awd $143,680.00$160.00

2 $158,048.00$176.00

3 $143,680.00$160.00

4 $172,416.00$192.00

Ref #46 516E14600 STRUCTURAL JOINT OR JOINT SEALER, MISC.: STEEL EXP, (1162 FT)

Awd $168,490.00$145.00

2 $185,339.00$159.50

3 $168,490.00$145.00

4 $202,188.00$174.00

Ref #47 516E15000 STRUCTURAL JOINT OR JOINT SEALER, MISC.: MODULAR E, (2 EACH)

Awd $128,000.00$64,000.00

2 $140,800.00$70,400.00

3 $128,000.00$64,000.00

4 $153,600.00$76,800.00

Ref #48 516E15000 STRUCTURAL JOINT OR JOINT SEALER, MISC.: STEEL EXP, (17 EACH)

Awd $238,000.00$14,000.00

2 $261,800.00$15,400.00

3 $238,000.00$14,000.00

4 $285,600.00$16,800.00

Ref #49 516E15000 STRUCTURAL JOINT OR JOINT SEALER, MISC.: STRESS RE, (4 EACH)

Awd $164,000.00$41,000.00

2 $180,400.00$45,100.00

3 $164,000.00$41,000.00

4 $196,800.00$49,200.00

170228 - Page 6

Ref #50 518E62200 STRUCTURE DRAINAGE, MISC.: CLEANING AND REPAIR OF , (6 EACH)

Awd $48,000.00$8,000.00

2 $9,900.00$1,650.00

3 $12,000.00$2,000.00

4 $10,800.00$1,800.00

Ref #51 518E62200 STRUCTURE DRAINAGE, MISC.: MISCELLANEOUS DRAINAGE , (2 EACH)

Awd $6,000.00$3,000.00

2 $6,600.00$3,300.00

3 $6,200.00$3,100.00

4 $7,200.00$3,600.00

Ref #52 518E63300 STRUCTURE DRAINAGE, MISC.: SPAN 11 DRAINAGE INSTAL, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $23,000.00$23,000.00

2 $25,300.00$25,300.00

3 $23,000.00$23,000.00

4 $27,600.00$27,600.00

Ref #53 519E10000 PATCHING CONCRETE BRIDGE DECK OVERLAY WITH MICRO-S, (5 SY)

Awd $11,000.00$2,200.00

2 $3,795.00$759.00

3 $15,000.00$3,000.00

4 $13,200.00$2,640.00

Ref #54 519E11101 PATCHING CONCRETE STRUCTURE, AS PER PLAN, (6411 SF)

Awd $576,990.00$90.00

2 $613,532.70$95.70

3 $609,045.00$95.00

4 $565,450.20$88.20

Ref #55 519E11600 SPECIAL - PATCHING CONCRETE STRUCTURE, MISC.: TOP, (3500 SF)

Awd $234,500.00$67.00

2 $215,600.00$61.60

3 $227,500.00$65.00

4 $270,900.00$77.40

Ref #56 530E00200 SPECIAL - STRUCTURESFLAGGERS FOR GCRTA RAIL PROTEC, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $30,000.00$30,000.00

2 $18,700.00$18,700.00

3 $35,000.00$35,000.00

4 $40,000.00$40,000.00

Ref #57 530E00200 SPECIAL - STRUCTURESTEMPORARY FALSEWORK AND PROTEC, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $200,000.00$200,000.00

2 $165,000.00$165,000.00

3 $160,000.00$160,000.00

4 $186,000.00$186,000.00

Ref #58 530E00400 SPECIAL - STRUCTURESFORWARD SECTION CATWALK FENCE , (1 EACH)

Awd $3,000.00$3,000.00

2 $2,750.00$2,750.00

3 $4,000.00$4,000.00

4 $16,000.00$16,000.00

Ref #59 530E00600 SPECIAL - STRUCTURESCOMPOSITE FIBER WRAP SYSTEM, (1600 SF)

Awd $48,000.00$30.00

2 $77,440.00$48.40

3 $44,800.00$28.00

4 $107,200.00$67.00

170228 - Page 7

Ref #60 530E00600 SPECIAL - STRUCTURESFIBERGLASS OPEN GRID DECK, (915 SF)

Awd $36,600.00$40.00

2 $40,260.00$44.00

3 $36,600.00$40.00

4 $43,920.00$48.00

Ref #61 606E61000 IMPACT ATTENUATOR, MISC.: TYPE 3 REPAIR, (1 EACH)

Awd $8,460.00$8,460.00

2 $9,306.00$9,306.00

3 $9,000.00$9,000.00

4 $10,000.00$10,000.00

Ref #62 606E61000 IMPACT ATTENUATOR, MISC.:TYPE 2 REPAIR, (3 EACH)

Awd $33,960.00$11,320.00

2 $37,356.00$12,452.00

3 $36,000.00$12,000.00

4 $36,000.00$12,000.00

Ref #63 625E40010 SPECIAL - REPLACEMENT OF EXISTING LIGHTING UNIT, (1 EACH)

Awd $1,500.00$1,500.00

2 $5,500.00$5,500.00

3 $2,500.00$2,500.00

4 $5,000.00$5,000.00

Ref #64 690E91000 SPECIAL - AS-BUILT CONSTRUCTION PLANS, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $10,000.00$10,000.00

2 $11,000.00$11,000.00

3 $5,000.00$5,000.00

4 $15,000.00$15,000.00

Ref #65 690E98000 SPECIAL - MISC.: ACCESS DOOR REPLACEMENT, (5 EACH)

Awd $10,000.00$2,000.00

2 $8,250.00$1,650.00

3 $20,000.00$4,000.00

4 $15,000.00$3,000.00

Ref #66 690E98000 SPECIAL - MISC.: GARAGE DOOR REPLACEMENT, (1 EACH)

Awd $12,000.00$12,000.00

2 $15,061.20$15,061.20

3 $11,000.00$11,000.00

4 $18,000.00$18,000.00

Ref #100 844E10000 CONCRETE PATCHING WITH GALVANIC ANODE PROTECTION, (128 SF)

Awd $17,920.00$140.00

2 $13,939.20$108.90

3 $17,920.00$140.00

4 $25,344.00$198.00

Ref #101 625E40000 SPECIAL - MAINTAIN EXISTING LIGHTING, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $10,000.00$10,000.00

2 $55,000.00$55,000.00

3 $40,000.00$40,000.00

4 $100,000.00$100,000.00

Ref #102 607E23000 FENCE, TYPE CLT, (153 FT)

Awd $5,967.00$39.00

2 $6,479.55$42.35

3 $5,890.50$38.50

4 $7,650.00$50.00

170228 - Page 8

Ref #103 607E61200 GATE, TYPE CLT, (1 EACH)

Awd $4,000.00$4,000.00

2 $4,334.00$4,334.00

3 $3,940.00$3,940.00

4 $5,000.00$5,000.00

Ref #104 607E61201 GATE, TYPE CLT, AS PER PLAN, (1 EACH)

Awd $4,400.00$4,400.00

2 $4,812.50$4,812.50

3 $4,375.00$4,375.00

4 $6,000.00$6,000.00

Ref #105 690E98400 SPECIAL -MISC.: LAKEFRONT RAMP SECURITY FENCE AND , (LUMP SUM)

Awd $50,000.00$50,000.00

2 $53,592.00$53,592.00

3 $48,720.00$48,720.00

4 $50,000.00$50,000.00

Section 3 - STRUCTURE OVER 20 FOOT SPAN (CUY-2-1441) - Totals

Awd $19,463,131.00

2 $20,704,791.05

3 $23,290,798.00

4 $29,291,701.00

Ref #67 100E00300 PREMIUM ON RAILROADS' PROTECTIVE PUBLIC LIABILITY , (LUMP SUM)

Awd $10,000.00$10,000.00

2 $22,000.00$22,000.00

3 $6,000.00$6,000.00

4 $5,000.00$5,000.00

Ref #68 100E00300 PREMIUM ON RAILROADS' PROTECTIVE PUBLIC LIABILITY , (LUMP SUM)

Awd $10,000.00$10,000.00

2 $22,000.00$22,000.00

3 $6,000.00$6,000.00

4 $5,000.00$5,000.00

Ref #69 100E00300 PREMIUM ON RAILROADS' PROTECTIVE PUBLIC LIABILITY , (LUMP SUM)

Awd $10,000.00$10,000.00

2 $22,000.00$22,000.00

3 $6,000.00$6,000.00

4 $5,000.00$5,000.00

Ref #70 103E05000 PREMIUM FOR CONTRACT PERFORMANCE BOND AND FOR PAYM, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $200,000.00$200,000.00

2 $202,070.00$202,070.00

3 $200,000.00$200,000.00

4 $160,000.00$160,000.00

Ref #71 108E10000 CPM PROGRESS SCHEDULE, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $22,000.00$22,000.00

2 $22,000.00$22,000.00

3 $39,000.00$39,000.00

4 $32,000.00$32,000.00

Ref #72 614E11000 MAINTAINING TRAFFIC, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $350,000.00$350,000.00

2 $729,905.00$729,905.00

3 $450,000.00$450,000.00

4 $500,000.00$500,000.00

170228 - Page 9

Ref #73 619E16020 FIELD OFFICE, TYPE C, (21 MNTH)

Awd $52,500.00$2,500.00

2 $34,650.00$1,650.00

3 $168,000.00$8,000.00

4 $84,000.00$4,000.00

Ref #74 623E10000 CONSTRUCTION LAYOUT STAKES AND SURVEYING, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $25,000.00$25,000.00

2 $27,500.00$27,500.00

3 $25,000.00$25,000.00

4 $30,000.00$30,000.00

Ref #75 624E10000 MOBILIZATION, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $840,000.00$840,000.00

2 $800,000.00$800,000.00

3 $800,000.00$800,000.00

4 $800,000.00$800,000.00

Section 4 - INCIDENTALS - Totals

Awd $1,519,500.00

2 $1,882,125.00

3 $1,700,000.00

4 $1,621,000.00

170228 - Page 10

Project No. 177013

PID 105486

FAI-US 33-11.58

Non-Federal

Type: BRIDGE REPAIR

Completion Date: 8/15/2017

Award Amount: $293,707.50

Contract Awarded To: ARMSTRONG STEEL ERECTORS INC

Letting Date: 5/4/2017

Engineer's Estimate: $290,000.00

Ohio Department of Transportation

Official Bid Tabulation

Jerry Wray, Director

ARMSTRONG STEEL ERECTORS INC

50 SOUTH FOURTH ST P O BOX 577

NEWARK, OH 43058

Licking

Bidder 1

Bid $293,707.50

EVERS STEEL CONSTRUCTION LLC

7542 NEW HAVEN ROAD

HARRISON, OH 45030

Hamilton

Bidder 2

Bid $575,952.00

177013 - Page 11

Ref #1 614E11110 LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER WITH PATROL CAR FOR ASSIST, (21 HOUR)

Awd $1,890.00$90.00

2 $1,575.00$75.00

Ref #2 614E12336 WORK ZONE IMPACT ATTENUATOR (UNIDIRECTIONAL), (2 EACH)

Awd $4,000.00$2,000.00

2 $6,000.00$3,000.00

Ref #3 614E13100 BARRIER REFLECTOR, (22 EACH)

Awd $165.00$7.50

2 $1,100.00$50.00

Ref #4 614E18401 PORTABLE CHANGEABLE MESSAGE SIGN, AS PER PLAN, (21 DAY)

Awd $1,050.00$50.00

2 $6,300.00$300.00

Ref #5 615E10000 ROADS FOR MAINTAINING TRAFFIC, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $7,000.00$7,000.00

2 $60,000.00$60,000.00

Ref #6 615E25000 PAVEMENT FOR MAINTAINING TRAFFIC, CLASS B, (1698 SY)

Awd $61,128.00$36.00

2 $66,222.00$39.00

Ref #7 622E41000 PORTABLE BARRIER, 32", (1050 FT)

Awd $15,750.00$15.00

2 $21,000.00$20.00

Section 1 - MAINTENANCE OF TRAFFIC - Totals

Awd $90,983.00

2 $162,197.00

Ref #8 202E11401 PORTIONS OF STRUCTURE REMOVED, AS PER PLAN (MAIN M, (3000 LB)

Awd $9,000.00$3.00

2 $24,000.00$8.00

Ref #9 202E11401 PORTIONS OF STRUCTURE REMOVED, AS PER PLAN (SECOND, (353 LB)

Awd $529.50$1.50

2 $7,060.00$20.00

Ref #10 512E10600 CONCRETE REPAIR BY EPOXY INJECTION, (56 FT)

Awd $8,400.00$150.00

2 $14,000.00$250.00

Ref #11 513E10201 STRUCTURAL STEEL MEMBERS, LEVEL UF, AS PER PLAN, (353 LB)

Awd $5,295.00$15.00

2 $5,295.00$15.00

Ref #12 513E90000 STRUCTURAL STEEL, MISC.: LEVEL UF, (3000 LB)

Awd $6,000.00$2.00

2 $45,000.00$15.00

Ref #13 513E95000 STRUCTURAL STEEL, MISC.: REPAIR OF DAMAGED SECONDA, (100 FT)

Awd $1,000.00$10.00

2 $6,000.00$60.00

Ref #14 513E95000 STRUCTURAL STEEL, MISC.: REPAIR OF DAMAGEED MAIN M, (40 FT)

Awd $25,000.00$625.00

2 $2,400.00$60.00

177013 - Page 12

Ref #15 513E95030 STRUCTURAL STEEL, MISC.: REPAIR OF DAMAGED MEMBERS, (8 EACH)

Awd $1,000.00$125.00

2 $4,000.00$500.00

Ref #16 514E27700 FIELD PAINTING, MISC.: MAIN AND SECONDARY MEMBERS, (440 SF)

Awd $33,000.00$75.00

2 $52,800.00$120.00

Ref #17 516E47001 JACKING AND TEMPORARY SUPPORT OF SUPERSTRUCTURE, A, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $20,000.00$20,000.00

2 $60,000.00$60,000.00

Ref #18 849E10000 DAMAGE ASSESSMENT, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $1,500.00$1,500.00

2 $1,500.00$1,500.00

Ref #19 849E10500 SURFACE PREPARATION, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $3,000.00$3,000.00

2 $2,500.00$2,500.00

Ref #20 849E10600 REPAIRING DAMAGED MEMBERS BY GRINDING, (8 HOUR)

Awd $1,000.00$125.00

2 $1,200.00$150.00

Ref #21 849E10700 STRAIGHTENING DAMAGED MEMBERS, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $35,000.00$35,000.00

2 $48,000.00$48,000.00

Section 2 - STRUCTURE REPAIR (FAI-33-1158) - Totals

Awd $149,724.50

2 $273,755.00

Ref #22 103E05000 PREMIUM FOR CONTRACT PERFORMANCE BOND AND FOR PAYM, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $3,000.00$3,000.00

2 $20,000.00$20,000.00

Ref #23 614E11000 MAINTAINING TRAFFIC, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $40,000.00$40,000.00

2 $75,000.00$75,000.00

Ref #24 624E10000 MOBILIZATION, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $10,000.00$10,000.00

2 $45,000.00$45,000.00

Section 3 - INCIDENTALS - Totals

Awd $53,000.00

2 $140,000.00

177013 - Page 13

Project No. 177014

PID 101549

WAS-SR-SR 145-00.84

Federal

Type: SLIDE REPAIR

Completion Date: 11/30/2017

Award Amount: $408,514.04

Contract Awarded To: ALAN STONE CO INC

Letting Date: 5/4/2017

Engineer's Estimate: $386,000.00

Ohio Department of Transportation

Official Bid Tabulation

Jerry Wray, Director

ALAN STONE CO INC

1324 ELLIS RUN RD

CUTLER, OH 45724

Washington

Bidder 1

Bid $408,514.04

SHELLY & SANDS INC

1515 HARMON AVE

COLUMBUS, OH 43223

Franklin

Bidder 2

Bid $410,261.45

OHIO-WEST VIRGINIA EXCAVATING CO

56461 FERRY LANDING ROAD

SHADYSIDE, OH 43947

Belmont

Bidder 3

Bid $416,278.40

CROSS ROADS CONSTRUCTION INC

3155 HARDING LANE

CAMBRIDGE, OH 43725

Guernsey

Bidder 4

Bid $503,933.25

R C CONSTRUCTION COMPANY AND SON INC

8096 FEDERAL ROAD

CUTLER, OH 45724

Washington

Bidder 5

Bid $547,595.00

177014 - Page 14

Ref #1 201E11000 CLEARING AND GRUBBING, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $4,017.00$4,017.00

2 $3,990.00$3,990.00

3 $4,500.00$4,500.00

4 $25,000.00$25,000.00

5 $7,500.00$7,500.00

Ref #2 202E38000 GUARDRAIL REMOVED, (650 FT)

Awd $1,625.00$2.50

2 $1,300.00$2.00

3 $1,300.00$2.00

4 $1,300.00$2.00

5 $1,950.00$3.00

Ref #3 202E70000 SPECIAL - FILL AND PLUG EXISTING CONDUIT, (80 FT)

Awd $3,680.00$46.00

2 $2,400.00$30.00

3 $4,000.00$50.00

4 $6,000.00$75.00

5 $14,400.00$180.00

Ref #4 202E98100 REMOVAL MISC.:PILE EXTRACTION, (10 EACH)

Awd $4,017.50$401.75

2 $6,500.00$650.00

3 $3,600.00$360.00

4 $5,000.00$500.00

5 $15,000.00$1,500.00

Ref #5 203E10000 EXCAVATION, (142 CY)

Awd $3,266.00$23.00

2 $2,130.00$15.00

3 $4,544.00$32.00

4 $4,970.00$35.00

5 $2,840.00$20.00

Ref #6 203E20000 EMBANKMENT, (245 CY)

Awd $4,900.00$20.00

2 $3,552.50$14.50

3 $2,940.00$12.00

4 $8,575.00$35.00

5 $4,900.00$20.00

Ref #7 204E10000 SUBGRADE COMPACTION, (353 SY)

Awd $723.65$2.05

2 $1,765.00$5.00

3 $1,412.00$4.00

4 $1,059.00$3.00

5 $706.00$2.00

Ref #8 606E15050 GUARDRAIL, TYPE MGS, (587.5 FT)

Awd $10,575.00$18.00

2 $10,281.25$17.50

3 $9,987.50$17.00

4 $9,693.75$16.50

5 $11,750.00$20.00

177014 - Page 15

Ref #9 606E18500 GUARDRAIL POST, 9 FEET, (14 EACH)

Awd $294.00$21.00

2 $294.00$21.00

3 $364.00$26.00

4 $280.00$20.00

5 $490.00$35.00

Ref #10 606E26150 ANCHOR ASSEMBLY, MGS TYPE E, (1 EACH)

Awd $2,079.00$2,079.00

2 $2,100.00$2,100.00

3 $2,150.00$2,150.00

4 $1,980.00$1,980.00

5 $2,100.00$2,100.00

Section 1 - ROADWAY - Totals

Awd $35,177.15

2 $34,312.75

3 $34,797.50

4 $63,857.75

5 $61,636.00

Ref #11 601E32200 ROCK CHANNEL PROTECTION, TYPE C WITH FILTER, (15 CY)

Awd $1,695.00$113.00

2 $2,670.00$178.00

3 $1,575.00$105.00

4 $3,000.00$200.00

5 $1,275.00$85.00

Ref #12 659E10000 SEEDING AND MULCHING, (1569 SY)

Awd $5,020.80$3.20

2 $3,138.00$2.00

3 $3,138.00$2.00

4 $3,138.00$2.00

5 $3,138.00$2.00

Ref #13 659E20000 COMMERCIAL FERTILIZER, (0.14 TON)

Awd $95.52$682.29

2 $93.80$670.00

3 $91.00$650.00

4 $49.00$350.00

5 $168.00$1,200.00

Ref #14 659E31000 LIME, (0.32 ACRE)

Awd $20.16$63.00

2 $54.40$170.00

3 $38.40$120.00

4 $160.00$500.00

5 $256.00$800.00

Ref #15 659E35000 WATER, (4 MGAL)

Awd $4.20$1.05

2 $4.00$1.00

3 $4.00$1.00

4 $4.00$1.00

5 $2.00$0.50

177014 - Page 16

Ref #16 832E30000 EROSION CONTROL, (5000 EACH)

Awd $5,000.00$1.00

2 $5,000.00$1.00

3 $5,000.00$1.00

4 $5,000.00$1.00

5 $5,000.00$1.00

Section 2 - EROSION CONTROL - Totals

Awd $11,835.68

2 $10,960.20

3 $9,846.40

4 $11,351.00

5 $9,839.00

Ref #17 602E20000 CONCRETE MASONRY, (0.74 CY)

Awd $1,223.96$1,654.00

2 $1,776.00$2,400.00

3 $1,739.00$2,350.00

4 $2,590.00$3,500.00

5 $1,850.00$2,500.00

Ref #18 605E06000 4" BASE PIPE UNDERDRAINS, (642 FT)

Awd $14,766.00$23.00

2 $5,778.00$9.00

3 $642.00$1.00

4 $6,420.00$10.00

5 $22,470.00$35.00

Ref #19 611E07200 18" CONDUIT, TYPE A, 706.02, (37 FT)

Awd $7,131.75$192.75

2 $6,660.00$180.00

3 $7,659.00$207.00

4 $9,250.00$250.00

5 $3,515.00$95.00

Ref #20 611E10200 24" CONDUIT, TYPE A, 706.02, (39 FT)

Awd $8,112.00$208.00

2 $7,410.00$190.00

3 $7,995.00$205.00

4 $11,700.00$300.00

5 $4,095.00$105.00

Ref #21 611E99710 PRECAST REINFORCED CONCRETE OUTLET, (5 EACH)

Awd $1,493.75$298.75

2 $1,500.00$300.00

3 $750.00$150.00

4 $1,250.00$250.00

5 $750.00$150.00

Section 3 - DRAINAGE - Totals

Awd $32,727.46

2 $23,124.00

3 $18,785.00

4 $31,210.00

5 $32,680.00

177014 - Page 17

Ref #22 302E46000 ASPHALT CONCRETE BASE, PG64-22, (35 CY)

Awd $10,605.00$303.00

2 $7,805.00$223.00

3 $8,050.00$230.00

4 $7,875.00$225.00

5 $8,225.00$235.00

Ref #23 304E20000 AGGREGATE BASE, (59 CY)

Awd $5,900.00$100.00

2 $5,015.00$85.00

3 $5,015.00$85.00

4 $7,375.00$125.00

5 $4,425.00$75.00

Ref #24 407E20000 NON-TRACKING TACK COAT, (203 GAL)

Awd $852.60$4.20

2 $812.00$4.00

3 $913.50$4.50

4 $812.00$4.00

5 $1,015.00$5.00

Ref #25 441E50000 ASPHALT CONCRETE SURFACE COURSE, TYPE 1, (448), PG, (117 CY)

Awd $28,080.00$240.00

2 $26,325.00$225.00

3 $26,325.00$225.00

4 $26,325.00$225.00

5 $29,250.00$250.00

Ref #26 617E10100 COMPACTED AGGREGATE, (15 CY)

Awd $3,817.50$254.50

2 $2,025.00$135.00

3 $1,650.00$110.00

4 $1,500.00$100.00

5 $1,125.00$75.00

Section 4 - PAVEMENT - Totals

Awd $49,255.10

2 $41,982.00

3 $41,953.50

4 $43,887.00

5 $44,040.00

Ref #27 621E00100 RPM, (12 EACH)

Awd $5,259.00$438.25

2 $5,400.00$450.00

3 $2,580.00$215.00

4 $5,016.00$418.00

5 $5,040.00$420.00

Ref #28 621E54000 RAISED PAVEMENT MARKER REMOVED, (12 EACH)

Awd $144.00$12.00

2 $312.00$26.00

3 $456.00$38.00

4 $120.00$10.00

5 $600.00$50.00

177014 - Page 18

Ref #29 630E85100 REMOVAL OF GROUND MOUNTED SIGN AND REERECTION, (1 EACH)

Awd $157.50$157.50

2 $160.00$160.00

3 $168.00$168.00

4 $150.00$150.00

5 $75.00$75.00

Ref #30 642E00094 EDGE LINE, 6", (0.36 MILE)

Awd $944.64$2,624.00

2 $954.00$2,650.00

3 $1,044.00$2,900.00

4 $900.00$2,500.00

5 $1,260.00$3,500.00

Ref #31 642E00290 CENTER LINE, (0.18 MILE)

Awd $944.64$5,248.00

2 $954.00$5,300.00

3 $1,044.00$5,800.00

4 $900.00$5,000.00

5 $1,170.00$6,500.00

Section 5 - TRAFFIC CONTROL - Totals

Awd $7,449.78

2 $7,780.00

3 $5,292.00

4 $7,086.00

5 $8,145.00

Ref #32 410E13000 TRAFFIC COMPACTED SURFACE, TYPE C, (106 CY)

Awd $12,905.50$121.75

2 $7,950.00$75.00

3 $12,402.00$117.00

4 $10,600.00$100.00

5 $7,950.00$75.00

Ref #33 614E12338 WORK ZONE IMPACT ATTENUATOR (BIDIRECTIONAL), (2 EACH)

Awd $4,200.00$2,100.00

2 $4,300.00$2,150.00

3 $3,400.00$1,700.00

4 $5,000.00$2,500.00

5 $4,400.00$2,200.00

Ref #34 614E12740 WORK ZONE LIGHTING SYSTEM, (1 EACH)

Awd $4,199.00$4,199.00

2 $17,500.00$17,500.00

3 $870.00$870.00

4 $12,500.00$12,500.00

5 $5,500.00$5,500.00

Ref #35 614E13302 BARRIER REFLECTOR, TYPE B2, (16 EACH)

Awd $672.00$42.00

2 $192.00$12.00

3 $736.00$46.00

4 $160.00$10.00

5 $320.00$20.00

177014 - Page 19

Ref #36 614E13360 OBJECT MARKER, TWO WAY, (16 EACH)

Awd $928.00$58.00

2 $248.00$15.50

3 $736.00$46.00

4 $240.00$15.00

5 $320.00$20.00

Ref #37 614E22000 WORK ZONE EDGE LINE, CLASS I, (0.17 MILE)

Awd $936.87$5,511.00

2 $943.50$5,550.00

3 $935.00$5,500.00

4 $892.50$5,250.00

5 $2,125.00$12,500.00

Ref #38 614E26000 WORK ZONE STOP LINE, CLASS I, (24 FT)

Awd $408.00$17.00

2 $408.00$17.00

3 $384.00$16.00

4 $384.00$16.00

5 $1,200.00$50.00

Ref #39 622E41000 PORTABLE BARRIER, 32", (760 FT)

Awd $15,200.00$20.00

2 $13,680.00$18.00

3 $18,240.00$24.00

4 $16,720.00$22.00

5 $11,400.00$15.00

Section 6 - MAINTENANCE OF TRAFFIC - Totals

Awd $39,449.37

2 $45,221.50

3 $37,703.00

4 $46,496.50

5 $33,215.00

Ref #40 507E00400 STEEL PILES, MISC.: SOLDIER PILES, HP12x53, (1496 FT)

Awd $38,896.00$26.00

2 $46,376.00$31.00

3 $55,352.00$37.00

4 $74,800.00$50.00

5 $59,840.00$40.00

Ref #41 518E21200 POROUS BACKFILL WITH GEOTEXTILE FABRIC, (197 CY)

Awd $12,608.00$64.00

2 $18,912.00$96.00

3 $19,700.00$100.00

4 $16,745.00$85.00

5 $14,775.00$75.00

Ref #42 518E40000 6" PERFORATED CORRUGATED PLASTIC PIPE, (390 FT)

Awd $3,490.50$8.95

2 $585.00$1.50

3 $1,560.00$4.00

4 $3,900.00$10.00

5 $9,750.00$25.00

177014 - Page 20

Ref #43 518E40012 6" NON-PERFORATED CORRUGATED PLASTIC PIPE, (40 FT)

Awd $720.00$18.00

2 $340.00$8.50

3 $240.00$6.00

4 $400.00$10.00

5 $1,000.00$25.00

Ref #44 524E94603 DRILLED SHAFTS, 30" DIAMETER, ABOVE BEDROCK, AS PE, (538 FT)

Awd $40,350.00$75.00

2 $46,268.00$86.00

3 $26,631.00$49.50

4 $26,900.00$50.00

5 $67,250.00$125.00

Ref #45 524E94605 DRILLED SHAFTS, 30" DIAMETER INTO BEDROCK, AS PER , (530 FT)

Awd $45,050.00$85.00

2 $52,470.00$99.00

3 $53,000.00$100.00

4 $92,750.00$175.00

5 $82,150.00$155.00

Ref #46 530E00400 SPECIAL - STRUCTURES: PRECAST CONCRETE PANEL, NO. , (193 EACH)

Awd $33,775.00$175.00

2 $50,180.00$260.00

3 $64,848.00$336.00

4 $48,250.00$250.00

5 $33,775.00$175.00

Ref #47 530E00400 SPECIAL - STRUCTURES: PRECAST CONCRETE PANEL, NO. , (1 EACH)

Awd $510.00$510.00

2 $800.00$800.00

3 $1,400.00$1,400.00

4 $500.00$500.00

5 $1,500.00$1,500.00

Ref #48 530E00400 SPECIAL - STRUCTURES: PRECAST CONCRETE PANEL, NO. , (1 EACH)

Awd $510.00$510.00

2 $650.00$650.00

3 $1,400.00$1,400.00

4 $600.00$600.00

5 $1,500.00$1,500.00

Ref #49 530E00400 SPECIAL - STRUCTURES: PRECAST CONCRETE PANEL, NO. , (1 EACH)

Awd $510.00$510.00

2 $800.00$800.00

3 $370.00$370.00

4 $700.00$700.00

5 $1,500.00$1,500.00

Section 7 - RETAINING WALLS - Totals

Awd $176,419.50

2 $217,381.00

3 $224,501.00

4 $265,545.00

5 $273,040.00

177014 - Page 21

Ref #50 103E05000 PREMIUM FOR CONTRACT PERFORMANCE BOND AND FOR PAYM, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $2,700.00$2,700.00

2 $2,500.00$2,500.00

3 $8,500.00$8,500.00

4 $12,000.00$12,000.00

5 $20,000.00$20,000.00

Ref #51 614E11000 MAINTAINING TRAFFIC, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $38,000.00$38,000.00

2 $8,500.00$8,500.00

3 $25,000.00$25,000.00

4 $7,500.00$7,500.00

5 $35,000.00$35,000.00

Ref #52 623E10000 CONSTRUCTION LAYOUT STAKES AND SURVEYING, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $4,500.00$4,500.00

2 $8,500.00$8,500.00

3 $3,900.00$3,900.00

4 $5,000.00$5,000.00

5 $10,000.00$10,000.00

Ref #53 624E10000 MOBILIZATION, (LUMP SUM)

Awd $11,000.00$11,000.00

2 $10,000.00$10,000.00

3 $6,000.00$6,000.00

4 $10,000.00$10,000.00

5 $20,000.00$20,000.00

Section 8 - INCIDENTALS - Totals

Awd $56,200.00

2 $29,500.00

3 $43,400.00

4 $34,500.00

5 $85,000.00

177014 - Page 22