Date post: | 12-May-2015 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | arc-advisory-group |
View: | 1,926 times |
Download: | 8 times |
Opportunities and Challenges for the
Opportunities and Challenges for thefor the
Food, Beverage, and CPG Industriesfor the
Food, Beverage, and CPG Industries
John BlanchardResearch Director
Food , Beverage , and CPG IndustriesARC Advisory GroupARC Advisory Group
Challenging TimesChallenging Times
Food, beverage, and CPG manufacturers find themselves caught between slow growth, risingthemselves caught between slow growth, rising
costs, waning pricing power, accelerated regulatory and customer requirements, and a growing
percentage of sales from a limited number of p gpowerful and demanding retailer, and increasingly
limited capital, human, and even material resources
2
© ARC Advisory Group
Challenging TimesChallenging Times
How do we improve margins and increase profitable
growth to sustaingrowth to sustain shareholder value?
3
© ARC Advisory Group
Business EnvironmentBusiness Environment
♦ F d d d t f t d dili i i♦ Food and product safety due diligence increasing• Concerned consumer • Yearly food borne illness statistics
• Global terrorism• Global sourcing & rapid high volume distributionGlobal sourcing & rapid high volume distribution
• These facts plus product counterfeiting are producing• New industry and company food safety initiatives• Increased regulatory and customer requirements
4
© ARC Advisory Group
Business EnvironmentBusiness Environment
♦ I i t l ti♦ Increasing government regulations• US Bioterrorism Act
• FDA and USDA regulations• CBP/CT PAT• CBP/CT-PAT• DHS
Customs- Trade Partnership Against Terrorism
• Truth in labeling laws
• FDA & USDA mandated HACCP programs
E. coli
Listeria
St h
Foreign Matl
Recall Reason
for fish, meat, poultry, and juices
• Environmental regulations: land, water, air
StaphSalmonel
Allergen
5
© ARC Advisory Group
Business EnvironmentBusiness Environment
♦ Increasing share of market controlled by a limited number powerful retailers, manufacturers, and suppliers
♦ Increasing global competition for everyone
♦ Mature US and European markets with limited growth opportunities
♦ Seeking opportunities in high growth emerging markets
2 8 .0 %
2 1%2 2 .5% 2 3 .0 %
$6 .8 b25.0%
30.0%
$6.0
$7.0
$8.0
10 .5%12 .0 % 12 .0 %
12 .2 %13 .0 %
17.2 % 16 .3 % 17.0 %
$1.8 b$1.0 b $1.0 b
$3 .6 b
$1.4 b$1.8 b
$0 3 b$0 .9 b
$0 3 b$0 .9 b $0 .4 b5.0%
10.0%
15.0%
20.0%
$1.0
$2.0
$3.0
$4.0
$5.0
$0 .3 b $0 .3 b0.0%
Sara Le
e
Gillette
Kellog
g
Kraft
Mills (E
x. Sam
's)
Mills (In
cl. S
am's)
Energi
zer
P&GHers
hey
Revlon
CloroxDial C
orp.
$0.0
6
© ARC Advisory Group
Genera
l MGen
eral M
i
Share of Business at Wal*Mart Dollar Sales
+Data sources did not indicate whether Sam’s Club data was included or not in the reports.
Rapid Change, More Complexity, Limited ResourcesRapid Change, More Complexity, Limited Resources
♦ Global sourcing of more limited, higher cost, more exotic ingredients
♦ Value health and environmentally conscious and demanding new♦ Value, health, and environmentally conscious and demanding new consumer
♦ Lots of consumer short (fads) changing purchasing patterns
♦ Rapidly changing demographics and new geographies (small♦ Rapidly changing demographics and new geographies (small bodegas)
♦ Increasing number of SKUs and new product introductions
♦ Increasing percentage of sales from promotions♦ Increasing percentage of sales from promotions
♦ Increasing importance of packaging
♦ Limited resources
♦ Available capital
♦ L b l d kill t
7
© ARC Advisory Group
♦ Labor pool and skill sets
♦ Water, energy, ingredients, packaging materials
More Sustainable ManufacturingMore Sustainable Manufacturing
♦ Driven by retailer initiatives• “The challenge of creating a low-carbon society will
require a revolution in thought and action – arequire a revolution in thought and action – a revolution in green consumption.” - Terry Leahy –CEO Tesco
♦ Driven by business and regulatory y g yrequirements
• As a part of their effort to eliminate waste and improve efficiency, Pepsico has been applying eco-friendly technology in packaging, deploying solarfriendly technology in packaging, deploying solar energy and methane gas recovery technology, and testing hybrid vehicle programs in their delivery fleets
♦ Driven by limited resources for manufacturing in most♦ Driven by limited resources for manufacturing in most parts of the world
♦ Driven by the “green” consumer/shareholderA 50% f id “ ” i h i h i
8
© ARC Advisory Group
• A recent survey over 50% of consumers consider “green” in their purchasing decisions and 20% are ardent “green” even concerned over how a company treats its employees
Sustainable ManufacturingSustainable Manufacturing
♦ To the consumer♦ To the consumer• Product availability• Environmental
responsibility
Environment& Resource
Friendlyresponsibility
♦ To the employee and his/her family
FriendlyProducts
/ y
♦ To the local community
♦ To many segments of
Environment & Resource
Friendly Plants
Environment & Resource
Friendly Supply Chain♦ To many segments of
manufacturing
♦ To Wall Street
PlantsSupply Chain
9
© ARC Advisory Group
Response to Changing Business EnvironmentResponse to Changing Business Environment
i i l “Margins rise while returns are flat”♦ Initial Strategy• Mergers, acquisitions, divestitures, outsourcing• Product portfolio rationalization/optimization
“Margins rise while returns are flat”
Product portfolio rationalization/optimization• Productivity initiatives
• OEE, TPM, continuous improvement
• Supply chain optimization programs• Supply chain optimization programs
10
© ARC Advisory Group
Now Food, Beverage, and CPG Manufacturers Are AskingNow Food, Beverage, and CPG Manufacturers Are Asking
♦ How do I address the fluctuating price and availability of commodities?
♦ How do I reduce my energy and other utilities costs and ensure the long term availability of these resources?
♦ How do I find and evaluate new technology that will support innovation and speed time-to-market?
♦ How do I reduce my manufacturing cycle time?♦ How do I reduce my manufacturing cycle time?
♦ How do I come up with new ideas or equipment that is multi-tasking and that can reduce change over time?
♦ Wh t th b t t i t t f t f t i♦ What are the best metrics to support future manufacturing requirements?
♦ How do I support my ever expanding manufacturing and business automation systems and networks?
11
© ARC Advisory Group
business automation systems and networks?
Response to Changing Business EnvironmentResponse to Changing Business Environment
♦ Strategy Going Forward –
“An agile, innovative enterprise to sustain growth and improve
margins”
• Global “super branding”• Expansion of distribution channels• Process automation and integration of• Process automation and integration of
manufacturing & business processes enterprise-wide
• More sustainable & flexible manufacturing & supply h ichains
• Develop a more innovative and extended organization and culture (people)
12
© ARC Advisory Group
Operational excellence is no longer enough.
Its power to differentiate has eroded.
Rory A. M. DelaneySenior Vice President
13
© ARC Advisory Group
Strategic TechnologyGeneral Mills
A Discipline of Innovation Emerging A Discipline of Innovation Emerging
Innovation is generally recognized as the principle driver of growth and shareholder value
• An increased rate of change has made an ability to change more valuable
g
• Methods and tools are emerging to vastly improve innovation success rates
• Companies need new insights to achieve p ggrowth
• Companies are “globalizing” their innovation processes. A “follow the sun” process is p pemerging
• Companies are also utilizing more external resources to drive innovation
14
© ARC Advisory Group
A Discipline of Innovation Emerging A Discipline of Innovation Emerging
Innovation is generally recognized as the principle driver of growth and shareholder value
• Companies involving suppliers earlier in design phase of new products and processes
g
• Some OEMs are driving innovation faster than their clients – even in non-traditional areas of their business• Patented product packaging a e ed p oduc pac ag g• More functions on a single unit or machine• More continuous on-line quality verification• New environmentally friendly technology• Packaging end line provider• Packaging end line provider
• Sustainable manufacturing and limited resources in emerging markets will
15
© ARC Advisory Group
resources in emerging markets will drive innovation even faster
Where Are We Today?Where Are We Today?
♦ Few food, beverage, CPG manufacturing sites have their processing, packaging, warehousing, logistics, and business systems networked together with bi-and business systems networked together with bidirectional electronic exchange of information
♦ Over 67% of packaging lines do not measure performanceperformance
♦ All respondents felt there was room for improvement in on-line quality verification, with almost two thirds saying there was significant room for improvement
ARC Insights & Manufacturing Performance Surveys 2007
16
© ARC Advisory Group
Increased Need for On-line Quality VerificationIncreased Need for On-line Quality Verification
17
© ARC Advisory Group
Where Are We Today?Where Are We Today?
♦ One of the primary reasons for purchasing production management software is compliance
♦ Leading edge companies depend upon production management software to optimize margin and qualitymanagement software to optimize margin and quality
ARC Insights & Manufacturing Performance Surveys 2007
♦ Some factors inhibiting adoption of technology• Lack of ease of use for operatorsLack of ease of use for operators• Cost and complexity of maintaining technology• Lack of resources to evaluate new technologies• Long standing purchasing & amortization policies
18
© ARC Advisory Group
• Long standing purchasing & amortization policies
What Do We Need To Do?What Do We Need To Do?
♦ A More Comprehensive Plan to Meet Business and Regulatory Requirements includes:Regulatory Requirements includes:
• Increased emphasis on performance monitoring , continuous improvement, and flexibility
• Improved electronic tracking and tracing from the source to the consumer
• Improved manufacturing plant security• Increased on-line quality verification and Quality by
Design (QBD)• An “in depth” sustainable manufacturing strategy• An automation strategy that recognizes the commonality
in both business and regulatory requirementsA f l l bl
19
© ARC Advisory Group
• A focus on people – your most valuable resource
It’s Not Just About TechnologyIt’s Not Just About Technology
“To sustain the productivity surge, today's managers must develop incentives that encourage their workers-as well as
themselves-to be more creative, self-starting, educated, and willing to experiment. Jobs that call for simply following recipeswilling to experiment. Jobs that call for simply following recipes
will become scarcer, and demand for an innovation-driven workforce will continue to grow.”
“……..It took 40 years for businesses to figure out how to redesign their factories and processes so that electricity could deliver a productivity payoff. Managers cannot afford to wait
decades to harness the greater productivity offered by today's
“Productivity's Technology Iceberg” March, 2004 by Erik Brynjolfsson,Professor of Management
decades to harness the greater productivity offered by today s IT advances. …….
20
© ARC Advisory Group
Professor of Management MIT Sloan School of Management
21
© ARC Advisory Group