Opportunities in Non-Container Trade and the Expanding
Cruise Industry
AAPA Commissioners Seminar
Steven Cernak, Port DirectorPort of Galveston
San Francisco, CAMay 18, 2005
The Port Industry• Is a highly competitive industry• Requires large amounts of Capital
Investment in its Facilities for both the Port and its Customers
• Is subject to Market and Industry Shifts• Is subject to Fluctuations in Trade and
Trade Policy• Ports themselves have limited control
over these business factors
How Does the Port of Galveston Operate?
• The Port operates as an Enterprise Utility:– The properties belonging to the City of Galveston are set
apart and designated as a separate utility of the City known as the "Galveston Wharves.“
• The Port is Financially Independent from the City:– The Galveston Wharves, and the income and revenue there
from, shall be fully managed, controlled, maintained and operated by a Board of Trustees to be known as "Board of Trustees of the Galveston Wharves.“
• The Board of Trustees have complete management and control of the Port of Galveston and the income and revenue thereof.
How Does the Galveston Wharves Operate?
• The Board of Trustees has the power to contract for all essential purposes.
• These provisions are set forth in the Galveston City Charter and also under Chapter 54 of The Texas Transportation Code.
Financial Considerations• As an Enterprise Utility, the Port had limited
ability to issue new debt to support project development.
• Existing Bonds had very restrictive covenants that pledged all future earnings towards the repayment of that debt.
• Debt Service coverage was mandated at 150%.
Financial Considerations• The Port had an opportunity to capture a
unique market opportunity, but had to find a way to capture the increased revenue while ensuring that existing bondholders were protected.
• The solution was found in the creation of the Galveston Port Facilities Corporation, a 501c3 Corporation created under the Texas Transportation Code.
Financial ConsiderationsThis Solution Provided the ability to:
– Capture Increased Market Share
– Develop a true “Public-Private Partnership”
– Develop a long-term Partnership with Carnival Corporation and Royal Caribbean International
– Secure Long-Term Operating Agreements
– Be Recognized by the National Council for Public Private Partnerships in using this approach in redevelopment by awarding the Port, Carnival Corporation and Royal Caribbean International their 2004 Industry Award
Cruise Homeport Opportunities
As a “homeport” the marketing approach is two fold:
1. To promote the port to the cruise line and how the port meets their needs.
2. To promote the port as a friendly and attractive cruise passenger departure point.
Cruise Planning: Strategic, Marketing and Operational Objectives
Regarding operations, Identify:
1. Demographics and population density the cruise lines can draw passengers from.
2. Port proximity to airlift and open sea.
3. Terminal facilities to accommodate check-in, luggage lay-down, proper federal agency clearance areas, adequate space for provision staging.
Cruise Itinerary Planning: Strategic, Marketing and Operational Objectives
Regarding passengers, Identify:
1. Available transportation to and from airlift2. Tourist amenities located near terminal3. Comfortable efficient facilities for passengers4. Adequate parking facilities5. Friendly community supportive of cruise business
Choosing Home Ports vs. Ports-of-Call vs. Destination Port
1. Determining how a port fits into a targeted cruise line’s operations is a key element for a home port marketing strategy to the lines.
2. Zeroing in on the line’s current business will help you understand how your port can fit into their goals.
3. Be prepared to prove your port will fill their beds or be a unique destination on the itinerary.
Responding to the Changing Expectations of the Cruise Passengers
Understanding that each cruise product in your port has a different identity and customer base, helps home ports react to passenger demands.
Challenges of Responding to the Changing Cruise Industry
1. Not unlike destinations, home ports need infrastructure to accommodate bigger vessels and handle larger numbers of passengers.
2. Financial burdens of facility expansion.3. Increased security measures4. Home ports need to provide adequate staging areas
for luggage and provisions trucks, garbage handling and other support activities.
Challenges of Responding to the Changing Cruise Industry (Cont’d)
5. Home ports need adequate water supply to service vessel.
6. As a pioneer in the popularity of drive market ports, parking and shuttle buses were a critical part of Galveston’s infrastructure.
7. Securing long term contracts to support financing.8. Working with state legislators on local issues that
impact cruise business.
Economic Impacts of Cruise Home Ports
Direct Economic Impact
1. Jobs –Meet & Greet services, taxis, longshoremen, line handlers, tug boats, pilots, police and security personnel, construction, etc.
2. Suppliers-Local produce suppliers, local florists, local liquor suppliers, IT services, copier/fax repairs services, garbage collection, fuel suppliers, etc.
3. Crew members- Act like temporary residents, eating, shopping, using city services, medical facilities and other community facilities.
Economic Impacts of Cruise Home Ports
Indirect Economic Impact
Includes:Pre and Post cruise hotel nights, parking, city transportation, local shopping, post office, new business creation, restaurants, etc.
Be Careful of What you Ask For
0
50
100
150
200
25019
7419
7519
7619
7719
7819
7919
8019
8119
8219
8319
8419
8519
8619
8719
8819
8919
9019
9119
9219
9319
9419
9519
9619
9719
9819
9920
0020
0120
0220
0320
0420
05
Year Ending
Tot
al S
hip
Cal
ls
050,000100,000150,000200,000250,000300,000350,000400,000450,000500,000550,000600,000650,000700,000750,000800,000850,000900,000950,0001,000,0001,050,000
Tot
al R
even
ue P
asse
nger
s
Total Ship Calls
Total RevenuePassengers
Year Tampa New Orleans Houston Galveston2000 459803 319000 187588 662792001 517235 362000 894 2984732002 632929 587000 13036 5272572003 821614 631382 30710 7463332004 780657 734643 167664 869976
Revenue Passengers Gulf Ports
0
200000
400000
600000
800000
1000000
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004
Year
Pass
enge
rs
Tampa New Orleans Houston Galveston
Working with the Community
1. Community Involvement - Established a cruise committee of interested citizens
2. Worked with CVB on promotion and helping with cruise line executives when in town.
3. Provide assistance, if possible, to the local community to communicate with the cruise lines to try to get home port information on board the ships for the passengers (brochures, TV)
4. Work with local newspapers, TV stations etc. to stimulate interest and educate community on benefits of having cruise line in town.
Other Opportunities• Expansion of an existing Bulk Terminal• BP LNG Project• Development of a new Ro-Ro Terminal• Expansion of Refrigerated
Warehousing• New Shipyard Lease• Tourist Area Expansion• Piers 36-41 Redevelopment
Pelican Island
Galveston
Houston Ship Channel
Texas City Channel
Texas City Refinery
Pelican Island
Galveston
Houston Ship Channel
Texas City Channel
• Remote Location• Surrounded by
USACE dredge materials site
• Easily accessible for marine traffic
• Accessible to consumer markets
• Allows Galveston to be part of the regional clean energy solution
BP LNG Facility
BP LNG Project
• As an Enterprise Utility of the City, this project puts a non-performing property under the Port’s control to productive financial use, while allowing the Port to diversify its revenue sources and increase operating revenues by at least $2.5 million dollars per year if FERC approval is granted.
BP LNG Project
Secondary Financial Benefits included, based on a projected $200 million assessed valuation of infrastructure improvements at the site, potential annual payments as follows:
GISD - $3 millionCity of Galveston - $1 millionGalveston County - $1.2 millionGalveston College - $400,000
BP LNG Project
Increased employment opportunities, including:
– Approximately 450 jobs during construction
– Approximately 80 direct and indirect jobs during operations.
BP LNG Project
In summary:
This project provided significant economic benefit to the Port as it continues to meet its challenge of being economically viable in a highly competitive environment, while providing economic benefit to the Galveston Community.
In Summary
• Recognize the Opportunity
• Understand the Market
• Know your Competition
• Properly Locate the Project
• Be Aware of Financial Considerations
• Protect the Investment
• Understand the Politics of a Given Project