+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Optimization of Pomace and Banana Peel Fermentation for Production of Single Cell Oil

Optimization of Pomace and Banana Peel Fermentation for Production of Single Cell Oil

Date post: 01-Apr-2016
Category:
Upload: shirley-wang
View: 224 times
Download: 1 times
Share this document with a friend
Description:
http://www.fmfi-journal.org/paperInfo.aspx?ID=5354 Present study was carried out to obtain single cell oil using fermented apple pomace and banana peel. The variables selected for the final experiments were levels of pH (3.0, 4.0 and 5.0), fermentation time (24, 48 and 72 hrs) and inoculum level (0.8, 1.0 and 1.2 ml). Designed experiments were conducted randomly to reveal the effect of these variables on pH, sugar utilization and single cell oil yield. Fermentation of apple pomace (50%) with banana peel (50%) resulted in maximum single cell oil production (5.87%) by using R. minuta. Statistical analysis resulted in the optimum conditions (pH 3.0, fermentation time 56.4 hrs and inoculum level 1.12 ml) for maximum single cell oil production. The model F- value was found to be highly significant at 1% level of significance in case of pH, utilized sugar and single cell oil yield. Hence, second order model could be fitted to predict all the dependent parameters.
Popular Tags:
9
www.fmfi-journal.org Focusing on Modern Food Industry (FMFI) Volume 2 Issue 4, November 2013 170 Optimization of Pomace and Banana Peel Fermentation for Production of Single Cell Oil A. Kulkarni* 1 , A. Singh 2 , B.K Kumbhar 3 , M. Sahgal 4 Department of Post Harvest Process & Food Engineering, College of Technology, GB Pant University of Agri & Technology, Pantnagar 263 145 U.S Nagar, Uttarakhand, INDIA 2 corresponding author e-mail: [email protected] Abstract Present study was carried out to obtain single cell oil using fermented apple pomace and banana peel. The variables selected for the final experiments were levels of pH (3.0, 4.0 and 5.0), fermentation time (24, 48 and 72 hrs) and inoculum level (0.8, 1.0 and 1.2 ml). Designed experiments were conducted randomly to reveal the effect of these variables on pH, sugar utilization and single cell oil yield. Fermentation of apple pomace (50%) with banana peel (50%) resulted in maximum single cell oil production (5.87%) by using R. minuta. Statistical analysis resulted in the optimum conditions (pH 3.0, fermentation time 56.4 hrs and inoculum level 1.12 ml) for maximum single cell oil production. The model F- value was found to be highly significant at 1% level of significance in case of pH, utilized sugar and single cell oil yield. Hence, second order model could be fitted to predict all the dependent parameters. Key words Single Cell Oil; Fermentation; Pomace; Agro Waste Utilization Introduction The concept of single cell oil produced by lipid- producing microorganisms as the supplementary sources of conventional oils and fats has attracted attention since early 1980s. Hence, it is very important to develop new oil resources by using microbes, which offers many advantages compared with traditional methods using animal fat and plant oils. Single cell protein production technologies have arisen as a promising way to solve the problem of worldwide protein shortage. They evolved as bioconversion processes which turned low-value by-products, often wastes, into products with added nutritional and market value and since single cell protein belongs to one of the cheapest protein products in the market, its production is profitable. The ability of the organism to metabolize a wide variety of sugars indicates that other agricultural and food-processing wastes may be able to support its growth and oil production. Various juice industries produce huge quantity of apple pomace, which is notutilized for human consumption. The utilization of such wastes needs to be emphasized to save the resources, and protect the environment from pollution. Various microbiological transformations of apple pomace have been proposed to obtain valuable products i.e. single cell protein, enzymes, aroma compounds, ethanol etc. Apple pomace in combination with other substrates like molasses, orange peel, banana peel etc. can be the potential source to obtain single cell oil. Recycling of agricultural residue can be achieved naturally and artificially by microorganisms. Oleaginous yeasts are often considered for the production of single cell oil. Lipid yields from 0.08 to 0.11 g/g have been observed during batch and continuous cultures of oleaginous yeasts and molds on glycerol (Sajbidor et al., 1988; Chen and Chang, 1996; Papanikolaou and Aggelis, 2002) or on soluble starch (Chen and Chang, 1996; Chen and Liu, 1997) utilized as carbon substrate. Johnson et al. (2002) reported that maximum lipid production (66% w/w dry wt.) in Rhodotorula glutinis utilizing glucose in fed-batch fermentation under N- limiting conditions at 30°C, was at pH 4. The economics of these bioprocesses has become more favourable when zero or negative value waste substrates are utilized as carbon or nitrogen sources (Pan et al., 2009). Food processing wastes might have potential for recycling raw materials or for conversion into useful product of higher value (Rashad and Nooman, 2009). Solid state fermentation for the production of single cell oil using oil free rice bran waste and local isolate of Aspergillus niger as substrate was used. Sodium nitrate at C/N ratio of 1.387 was found to be an effective nitrogen-supplementing source, as it gave the higher biomass yield (Anupama et al. , 2001).
Transcript
Page 1: Optimization of Pomace and Banana Peel Fermentation for Production of Single Cell Oil

www.fmfi-journal.org Focusing on Modern Food Industry (FMFI) Volume 2 Issue 4, November 2013

170

Optimization of Pomace and Banana Peel Fermentation for Production of Single Cell Oil A. Kulkarni*1, A. Singh2, B.K Kumbhar3, M. Sahgal4 Department of Post Harvest Process & Food Engineering, College of Technology, GB Pant University of Agri & Technology, Pantnagar 263 145 U.S Nagar, Uttarakhand, INDIA 2 corresponding author e-mail: [email protected] Abstract

Present study was carried out to obtain single cell oil using fermented apple pomace and banana peel. The variables selected for the final experiments were levels of pH (3.0, 4.0 and 5.0), fermentation time (24, 48 and 72 hrs) and inoculum level (0.8, 1.0 and 1.2 ml). Designed experiments were conducted randomly to reveal the effect of these variables on pH, sugar utilization and single cell oil yield. Fermentation of apple pomace (50%) with banana peel (50%) resulted in maximum single cell oil production (5.87%) by using R. minuta. Statistical analysis resulted in the optimum conditions (pH 3.0, fermentation time 56.4 hrs and inoculum level 1.12 ml) for maximum single cell oil production. The model F- value was found to be highly significant at 1% level of significance in case of pH, utilized sugar and single cell oil yield. Hence, second order model could be fitted to predict all the dependent parameters.

Key words

Single Cell Oil; Fermentation; Pomace; Agro Waste Utilization

Introduction

The concept of single cell oil produced by lipid-producing microorganisms as the supplementary sources of conventional oils and fats has attracted attention since early 1980s. Hence, it is very important to develop new oil resources by using microbes, which offers many advantages compared with traditional methods using animal fat and plant oils. Single cell protein production technologies have arisen as a promising way to solve the problem of worldwide protein shortage. They evolved as bioconversion processes which turned low-value by-products, often wastes, into products with added nutritional and market value and since single cell protein belongs to one of the cheapest protein products in the market, its production is profitable. The ability of the organism to metabolize a wide variety of sugars indicates that other agricultural and food-processing wastes may be able to support its growth and oil production.

Various juice industries produce huge quantity of apple pomace, which is notutilized for human consumption. The utilization of such wastes needs to be emphasized to save the resources, and protect the environment from pollution. Various microbiological transformations of apple pomace have been proposed to obtain valuable products i.e. single cell protein, enzymes, aroma compounds, ethanol etc. Apple pomace in combination with other substrates like molasses, orange peel, banana peel etc. can be the potential source to obtain single cell oil. Recycling of agricultural residue can be achieved naturally and artificially by microorganisms. Oleaginous yeasts are often considered for the production of single cell oil. Lipid yields from 0.08 to 0.11 g/g have been observed during batch and continuous cultures of oleaginous yeasts and molds on glycerol (Sajbidor et al., 1988; Chen and Chang, 1996; Papanikolaou and Aggelis, 2002) or on soluble starch (Chen and Chang, 1996; Chen and Liu, 1997) utilized as carbon substrate. Johnson et al. (2002) reported that maximum lipid production (66% w/w dry wt.) in Rhodotorula glutinis utilizing glucose in fed-batch fermentation under N-limiting conditions at 30°C, was at pH 4.

The economics of these bioprocesses has become more favourable when zero or negative value waste substrates are utilized as carbon or nitrogen sources (Pan et al., 2009). Food processing wastes might have potential for recycling raw materials or for conversion into useful product of higher value (Rashad and Nooman, 2009).

Solid state fermentation for the production of single cell oil using oil free rice bran waste and local isolate of Aspergillus niger as substrate was used. Sodium nitrate at C/N ratio of 1.387 was found to be an effective nitrogen-supplementing source, as it gave the higher biomass yield (Anupama et al. , 2001).

Page 2: Optimization of Pomace and Banana Peel Fermentation for Production of Single Cell Oil

Focusing on Modern Food Industry (FMFI) Volume 2 Issue 4, November 2013 www.fmfi-journal.org

171

Keeping in mind the importance of food processing wastes and agro wastes, a study has been planned to work on production of single cell oil with the help of fermented apple pomace and banana peel with the specific objective i.e to study the effect of processing and operational parameters for enhanced recovery of single cell oil.

Materials and Methods

Apples (variety: red delicious) were purchased from the local market of Pantnagar, Uttarakhnad, India as per requirement and pomace was made using carver press (Model M-25). Banana peel in combination with apple pomace was also used for single cell oil production as banana peel contains lipid (2.2-10.9%) and rich in polyunsaturated fatty acids, particularly linoleic acid and γ-linolenic acid (Mohapatra, et al., 2010), addition of banana peel may help increase the oil recovery. Preliminary experiments were conducted to select dilution level (1:9, 1:10 and 1:15) of the different combinations of apple pomace and banana peel (25% banana peel and 75% apple pomace, 50% banana peel and 50% apple pomace).

Fermentation experiments were carried out at different fermenting conditions i.e. pH (3.0, 4.0, and 5.0), fermentation time (24, 48, and 72 h) and inoculum level (0.8, 1.0 and 1.2 ml). Fermenting liquor was inoculated with different concentrations of R. minuta, as this species is considered to be oleaginous and accumulates triacyl-glycerol from 20 to 70% of biomass under appropriate cultivation conditions. The samples were withdrawn at regular time intervals (0, 24, 48, 72 h) and analyzed for change in pH, amount of sugar utilized and single cell oil produced. Fermenting liquor was centrifuged at 5000 rpm for 10 min and biomass was dried in oven for 2 h at 70°C. The dried biomass was milled and then solvent extraction was done by using soxtec apparatus to extract single cell oil.

The final experiments were designed by considering the following constant, independent and dependent parameters as reported in Table 1 A and B.

TABLE 1 A CONSTANT PARAMETERS

S. No Parameter Value 1 Temperature of fermentation 30 0 C 2 Agitation 40 rpm 3 Pressing time 60 min 4 Crushing time 1 min. 5 Pressure applied 1-1.2 tonnes 6 Sample size 250 ml

7 Dilution Range 1:10

For apple pomace (50%) in combination with banana peel (50%)

TABLE 1 B INDEPENDENT AND DEPENDENT VARIABLES

Independent variables S. No Parameter Range Levels

1 pH 3.0, 4.0, 5.0 3 2 Incubation period 24, 48, 72 3

3 Concentration

levels 0.8, 1, 1.2 3

Dependent variables 1 pH of each sample 2 Utilized sugar 3 Single cell oil

To find out all possible combinations of parameters, experiments were designed using Response Surface Methodology.

TABLE 2 PROCESS VARIABLES AND THEIR LEVELS

Independent variables Coded Levels

Name Code -1 0 1

Actual Levels

pH X1 3.0 4.0 5.0

Fermentation time (h)

X2 24 48 72

Inoculum level (ml)

X3 0.8 1.0 1.2

The Box Behenken design was used on three independent variables (pH, fermentation time (h) and inoculum level (ml)) at three levels. The experimental design is given in Table 3.

TABLE 3 EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN

Expt. No.

Serial No.

Coded Levels Real Levels

X1 X2 X3 pH Fermentation

time Inoculum

level 1 10 0 1 -1 4.0 72 0.8 2 11 0 -1 1 4.0 24 1.2 3 1 -1 -1 0 3.0 24 1.0 4 9 0 -1 -1 4.0 24 0.8 5 4 1 1 0 5.0 72 1.0 6 17 0 0 0 4.0 48 1.0 7 2 1 -1 0 5.0 24 1.0 8 13 0 0 0 4.0 48 1.0 9 15 0 0 0 4.0 48 1.0 10 6 1 0 -1 5.0 48 0.8 11 8 1 0 1 5.0 48 1.2 12 7 -1 0 1 3.0 48 1.2 13 3 -1 1 0 3.0 72 1.0 14 16 0 0 0 4.0 48 1.0 15 5 -1 0 -1 3.0 48 0.8 16 14 0 0 0 4.0 48 1.0 17 12 0 1 1 4.0 72 1.2

Optimization of Independent Variable

Full second order model was fitted in various responses and independent variables using least square regression analysis. Data analysis was done by using Design-Expert 7.0.0 software. The optimization was also carried out using Design-Expert 7.0.0. Effect of independent variables on the responses was

Page 3: Optimization of Pomace and Banana Peel Fermentation for Production of Single Cell Oil

www.fmfi-journal.org Focusing on Modern Food Industry (FMFI) Volume 2 Issue 4, November 2013

172

interpreted using the models. Contour plots were drawn with the help of SURFER 9.0 to get the range of independent variables for product development.

Results and Discussions

The responses (pH, utilized sugar and single cell oil yield) were observed for different combinations of the experiments as mentioned in Table 3 and results of experiments with apple pomace in combination with banana peel have been reported in Table 4 along with the experiment number. A full second order mathematical model was fitted into each response.

Effect of pH, Fermentation Time and Inoculum Level on the Process

1) pH

During the fermentation of apple pomace in combination with banana peel, the range was found to be 2.86 (Expt. no.14) to 5.02 (Expt. no. 1). During initial stage of fermentation, there could be accumulation of acidic intermediates which were formed during the growth phase of yeast cells. But during the later stage, increase in pH was observed because these intermediates formed during the fermentation were soon utilized and hence pH increased.

2) Sugar Utilization

Observations presented in Table 4 were recorded for the utilized sugar for several combinations of the experiments performed (Expt. 1-17), as mentioned in Table 3. In case of fermentation of apple pomace in combination with banana peel, the utilized sugar ranged from 1.27 to 7.52%. The maximum sugar (7.52%) was utilized in the case of experiment with initial pH 4.0, fermentation time 72 h and inoculum level of 1.2 ml. Minimum sugar (1.27%) was utilized when the sample was kept for 24 h of fermentation at the initial pH of 4.0 and inoculums level 0.8 ml. The reason for this might be the fact that within 24 h, yeast isolates entered lag phase and hence the cell multiplication was observed to be slow as they took some time (24 h) to acclimatize themselves. But after 48 h of fermentation period, the yeast isolates entered the log phase (exponential phase) cell, started multiplying faster and therefore rate of sugar utilization was observed to be faster (up to 72 h of fermentation).

3) Single Cell Oil Yield

The results of yield of single cell oil during fermentation of apple pomace in combination with banana peel are reported in Table 4. Yield of single cell oil varied from 4.14% (Expt. no. 6) to 5.87% (Expt. no. 2). Experiment no. 6 indicated the conditions where sample was treated with 0.8 ml of inoculum, pH level was kept as 4.0 and fermentation time was 24 h, whereas experiment no. 2 implied the fermenting conditions having 1.0 ml of

inoculum, pH level of 5.0 and fermentation time of 72 h. This clearly indicated that an increase in the initial pH and the fermentation time leads to enhanced single cell oil production.

The effect of three independent parameters viz. pH, fermentation time and inoculum level can be observed from the Table 4. The maximum single cell oil yield in the case of fermentation of apple pomace in combination of banana peel was 5.87% when sample was treated with 1.0 ml of inoculum at pH level of 5.0 and after 72 h of fermentation. Similarly, in the case of fermentation time i.e. 72 h, maximum conversion of sugar (7.52%) was observed for the time interval of 48-72 h of fermentation during experiments with apple pomace in combination with banana peel. Sugar utilization during the later stages of fermentation (i.e. 72 h) was found to be maximum because the yeast cells in the log phase of their growth cycle convert the maximum amount of substrate into product.

Development of Second Order Model

A second order response function for three independent variables has the following general form:

Where, β0, βii, βij and Xi, Xj are constants and variables (coded). The experimental data were then analyzed employing multiple regression techniques to develop response functions and variable parameters optimized for best outputs. The regression coefficients of complete second order model and their significance are reported Table 5.

Effect of pH, Fermentation Time and Inoculum Level on pH During Fermentation of Apple Pomace and Banana Peel

In the experiments of fermentation of apple pomace and banana peel, the maximum change (0.16) was obtained in the experiment where the initial pH was 3.0 and the sample was kept for 48 h fermentation with inoculation of 1.2 ml while the corresponding minimum value (0.02) was obtained when the sample was inoculated with 1.0 ml strain of R. minuta at pH 5.0 and the sample was kept for 24 h for fermentation.

Full second order model, Eqn. 1 was fitted to the responses observed for levels of pH and various experimental conditions using multiple regression analysis. Results obtained are given in Table 5. The coefficient of determination (R2) for the regression

∑ ∑ ∑ ∑ = + = = =

+ + + = 3

1 i

2 i ii

3

1 i j j i ij

3

1 i

2

1 i i i 0 X β X X β X β β Y

Page 4: Optimization of Pomace and Banana Peel Fermentation for Production of Single Cell Oil

Focusing on Modern Food Industry (FMFI) Volume 2 Issue 4, November 2013 www.fmfi-journal.org

173

model for this parameter was 99.28%, implying that the model could account for 99.28% data. Model was highly significant (p <0.01) with F-value of 106.79. Therefore, second order model was found to be adequate in describing change in pH content.

TABLE 4 EXPERIMENTAL DATA ON SINGLE CELL OIL RECOVERY FROM APPLE POMACE IN COMBINATION WITH BANANA PEEL

Variables Responses

Exp.

No. pH

Fermentation time (h)

Inoculum level

(ml) pH

Utilized Sugar

(percent)

Single cell oil (percen

t) 1 5.0 24 1.0 5.02* 4.32 5.32 2 5.0 72 1.0 4.88 7.31 5.87**

3 4.0 48 1.0 4.15 3.56 4.82

4 4.0 48 1.0 3.87 4.62 4.98

5 5.0 48 0.8 4.88 3.66 4.93

6 4.0 24 0.8 4.04 1.27* 4.14*

7 3.0 24 1.0 2.98 3.21 5.19

8 4.0 48 1.0 3.90 3.52 5.04

9 3.0 48 0.8 2.91 3.46 4.93

10 5.0 48 1.2 4.85 3.61 5.07

11 4.0 48 1.0 3.93 3.54 5.04

12 3.0 72 1.0 2.87 7.23 5.66

13 4.0 48 1.0 3.86 3.55 5.28

14 3.0 48 1.2 2.86**

3.49 4.97

15 4.0 72 1.2 3.85 7.52** 5.86

16 4.0 24 1.2 3.96 1.32 4.38

17 4.0 72 0.8 3.84 7.29 5.49

* Minimum value, ** Maximum value

TABLE 5 RESULT OF REGRESSION ANALYSIS FOR DEPENDENT PARAMETERS DURING FERMENTATION OF APPLE POMACE AND BANANA PEEL

Source

pH Utilized sugar Single cell oil

Coeff. P value

(%) Coeff.

P value (%)

Coeff. P value

(%)

Cons 3.94 0.01 3.76 0.32 5.03 4.14

X1 1.00 0.01 0.19 52.36 0.055 59.75

X2 -0.069 7.18 2.40 0.01 0.48 0.18

X3 -0.019 58.15 0.032 91.12 0.098 35.71

X1X2 -0.010 83.37 -0.26 53.80 0.021 88.51

X1X3 5E-3 91.63 -0.020 96.13 0.027 85.41

X2X3 0.023 63.89 0.045 91.31 0.033 81.92

X12 -0.027 56.16 0.48 25.35 0.24 11.60

X22 0.020 66.44 1.28 1.32 0.23 13.11

X32 -0.040 40.36 -0.69 12.04 -0.30 6.20 R2% 99.28 92.72 83.61

F value

106.79 9.91 3.97

LOF NS NS NS

NS = non significant

Where, X1 is pH, X2 is fermentation time, h and X3 is inoculum level, ml.

Effect of independent variables on pH at linear, quadratic and interactive level was revealed using ANOVA. The results showed that the effect was highly significant (p < 0.01) at linear level. The model F-value was also found to be highly significant at 1% level of significance.

Effect of pH, Fermentation Time and Inoculum Level on the Utilized Sugar During Fermentation of Apple Pomace and Banana Peel

The utilized sugar after fermentation ranged from 1.27 to 7.52%. The maximum sugar (7.52%) utilized indicated the conditions where samples of apple pomace and banana peel was treated with the combination of 1.2 ml of inoculum, pH level was kept at 4.0 and the fermentation period of 72 h while the corresponding process conditions for the minimum utilization (1.27%) were at 0.8 ml inoculated sample kept for 24 h at the initial pH of 4.0.

Full second order model, Eqn. 2 was fitted to the responses for utilized sugar and experimental conditions using multiple regression analysis. The results obtained are reported in Table 6.

The coefficient of determination (R2) for the regression model for utilized sugar was 92.72%, which implied that the model could account for 92.72% data. Model was highly significant (p < 0.01) with F-value as 9.90. Lack of fit was insignificant; therefore, second order model was adequate in describing utilized sugar content.

Where, X1 is pH, X2 is fermentation time, h and X3 is inoculum level, ml.

Effect of independent variables on sugar utilized at linear, quadratic and interactive level was determined. Results showed that the effect was highly significant (p < 0.01) at linear level and (p < 0.05) at quadratic level. The model F-value was also found to be highly significant at 1% level of significance.

Total effect of individual parameter on sugar utilized was calculated using the sequential sum of squares and it was observed that only fermentation time affected the utilization of sugar at 1% level of

Sugar utilized= 3.76+0.19X1+2.40X2+0.032X3-0.26X1X2-0.020X1X3+0.045X2X3+0.48X12+1.28X22-0.69X32 (2)

pH = 3.94+ 1.00X1- 0.069X2- 0.019X3- 0.010X1X2+ 5.00E-003X1X3+0.023X2X3-0.027X12+0.020X22-0.040X32 (1)

Page 5: Optimization of Pomace and Banana Peel Fermentation for Production of Single Cell Oil

www.fmfi-journal.org Focusing on Modern Food Industry (FMFI) Volume 2 Issue 4, November 2013

174

significance.

Effect of pH, Fermentation Time and Inoculum Level on Single Cell Oil Production During Fermentation of Apple Pomace and Banana Peel

Full second order model, Eqn. 3 was fitted to the responses for single cell oil yield and experimental conditions using multiple regression analysis. The results obtained are reported in Table 5. The coefficient of determination (R2) for the regression model for ethanol yield was 83.61%, which implied that the model could account for 83.61% data. Lack of fit was insignificant; therefore, second order model was adequate in describing utilized sugar content.

Where, X1 is pH, X2 is fermentation time, h and X3 is inoculum level, ml.

The single cell oil yield varied from 4.14% to 5.87%. The maximum single cell oil yield of 5.87% indicated the conditions when the sample was inoculated with 1.0 ml of inoculum, pH level was kept at 5.0 and the period of fermentation was 72 h. While the minimum yield (4.14%) implied the conditions of inoculation with 0.8 ml of inoculum, pH level of 4.0 and the fermentation period was 24 h.

Total effect of individual parameter on single cell oil yield was calculated using the sequential sum of squares. There was no significant effect of pH, fermentation time and inoculum level on the parameter.

Optimization of Process Parameters for Fermentation of Apple Pomace and Banana Peel

Optimization of processing conditions was carried out to minimize the pH change from the fermentation using software design expert 7.0.0. The minimum change in pH at the optimum conditions was found to be 0.02. Optimum values of different parameters thus obtained are given in Table 6.

TABLE 6 OPTIMUM VALUE OF PARAMETERS DURING FERMENTATION OF APPLE POMACE AND BANANA PEEL

Value pH, (X1)

Fermentation time, h

(X2)

Inoculum level, ml (X3)

Coded -1 0.35 -0.6 Actual 3 56.4 1.12

In order to show the effect of variables and to determine the operating range for best result, contour

plots were drawn. The contour equations were developed by keeping other two variables either at centre point or optimum value and reported in Table 7 and 8, respectively.

TABLE 7 CONTOUR EQUATION FOR PH AT CENTRE POINT DURING FERMENTATION OF APPLE POMACE AND BANANA PEEL

XY Parameter

Change variable

Contour equations

X1X2 X3

0 z=(3.94+1.00*(x)-0.069*(y)-

0.01*(x*y)0.027*(pow(x,2))+0.02*(pow(y,2)))

X1X3 X2

0 z=(3.94+1.00*(x)- 0.019*(y)+(5.00*(pow(10,-

3)))*(x*y)-0.027*(pow(x,2))-0.040*(pow(y,2)))

X2X3 X1

0 z=(3.94-0.069*(x)-

0.019*(y)+0.023*(x*y)+0.02*(pow(x,2))-0.040*(pow(y,2)))

TABLE 8 CONTOUR EQUATION FOR PH AT OPTIMUM POINT DURING FERMENTATION OF APPLE POMACE AND BANANA PEEL

XY Parameter

Change variable

Contour equations

X1X2 X3 -0.6 z=(3.94+0.997*(x)-0.0828 *(y)-0.010*(x*y)-

0.027*(pow(x,2))+0.020*(pow(y,2)))

X1X3 X2 0.35 z=(3.9183+0.9965*(x)-

0.01095*(y)+(5.00*(pow(10,-3)))*(x*y)-0.027*(pow(x,2))-0.04*(pow(y,2)))

X2X3 X1 -1 z=(2.913-0.059*(x)-

0.024*(y)+0.023*(x*y)+0.02*(pow(x,2))-0.04*(pow(y,2)))

The contours are shown in Fig. 1 for various combinations of interactive terms either at optimum value or centre point. From the Fig. 1 A1 and 1B1, it was observed that pH value was independent of fermentation time. Fig. 1A2 and 1B2 showed that the pH was independent of inoculum level. From Fig. 1A3 and 1B3 it is clear that as the inoculum level and fermentation time increased, the change in pH was gradually insignificant.

A) At Centre Point A1)

Single cell oil = 5.03+0.055X1+0.48X2+0.098X3+0.021X1X2+0.027X1X3+0.033X2X3+0.24X12+0.23X22-0.30X32 (3)

Page 6: Optimization of Pomace and Banana Peel Fermentation for Production of Single Cell Oil

Focusing on Modern Food Industry (FMFI) Volume 2 Issue 4, November 2013 www.fmfi-journal.org

175

A2)

A3)

B) At Optimum Point

B1)

B2)

B3)

FIG. 1 CONTOUR PLOTS FOR PH DURING FERMENTATION OF APPLE POMACE AND BANANA PEEL

Optimization of Process Parameters for Utilized Sugar during Fermentation of Apple Pomace and Banana Peel

Optimization of processing conditions was carried out to maximize the sugar utilization from the fermentation process. The maximum utilized sugar at the optimum conditions was found to be 7.52%. Optimum values of different parameters thus obtained are given in Table 8.

In order to show the effect of variables and to determine the operating range for best result, contour plots were drawn. The contour equations were developed by keeping other two variables either at centre point or optimum value. The contours are shown in Fig. 2 for various combinations of interactive terms either at optimum value or centre point.

A) At Centre Point A1)

A2)

Page 7: Optimization of Pomace and Banana Peel Fermentation for Production of Single Cell Oil

www.fmfi-journal.org Focusing on Modern Food Industry (FMFI) Volume 2 Issue 4, November 2013

176

A3)

B) At Optimum Point

B1)

B2)

B3)

FIG. 2 CONTOUR PLOTS FOR UTILIZED SUGAR DURING

FERMENTATION OF APPLE POMACE AND BANANA PEEL

Optimization of Process Parameters for Single Cell Oil During Fermentation of Apple Pomace and Banana Peel

The maximum single cell oil yield at the optimum conditions was found to be 5.87%. Optimum values of different parameters thus obtained are given in Table 9.

In order to show the effect of variables and to determine the operating range for best result, contour plots were drawn (Fig 3).

A) At Centre Point A1)

A2)

A3)

Page 8: Optimization of Pomace and Banana Peel Fermentation for Production of Single Cell Oil

Focusing on Modern Food Industry (FMFI) Volume 2 Issue 4, November 2013 www.fmfi-journal.org

177

B) At Optimum Point B1)

B2)

B3)

FIG. 3 CONTOUR PLOTS FOR SINGLE CELL OIL DURING

FERMENTATION OF APPLE POMACE AND BANANA PEEL

The contours are shown in Fig. 3 for various combinations of interactive terms either at optimum value or centre point. From the Fig. 3 A1 and 3 B1 it is clear that as fermentation time increased, there was increase in single cell oil production. Fig. 3A2 and 3 B2 showed that there was maximum single cell oil production at Saddle point at the centre. From Fig. 3 A3 and 3 B3 it is clear that as the inoculum level and fermentation time was increased, single cell oil production was also increased.

The optimum levels of variables in coded and actual form for fermentation of apple pomace in combination with banana peel have been reported in Table 9 and 10 respectively.

TABLE 9 CONSTRAINTS FOR OPTIMIZATION FOR FERMENTATION PROCESS OF APPLE POMACE AND BANANA PEEL

Name Goal Lower limit

Upper limit

pH Is in range -1 +1 Fermentation time minimize -1 +1

Inoculum level minimize -1 +1

pH minimize 2.86 5.02

Utilized sugar maximum 1.27 7.52 Single cell oil maximum 4.14 5.87

TABLE 10 OPTIMUM LEVELS OF VARIABLES FOR FERMENTATION PROCESS OF APPLE POMACE AND BANANA PEEL

Independent variables Coded levels Actual levels

pH (X1) -1 3

Fermentation time (X2) 0.35 56.40 h Inoculum level (X3) -0.6 1.12 ml

From the above results, it is clear that single cell oil production increased in the case where apple pomace (50%) in combination with the banana peel (50%) was fermented when optimum value pH of sample was kept as 3.0, fermentation time 56.40 h and inoculum level as 1.12 ml.

Conclusions

Through the experimental studies conducted under already described conditions, it could be concluded that fermentation of apple pomace and banana peel resulted in enhanced single cell oil recovery with 5.87% yield when pH was 5.0 and fermentation period was 72 h. Optimum values of parameters from the optimization process for production of single cell oil using apple pomace and banana peel were found to be 3.0 pH, fermentation time 56.4 h and inoculum level 1.12 ml. Initial pH and inoculum level both affected the process of single cell oil production but effect of fermentation time was found to be more significant.

REFERENCES

Anupama and Ravindra, P., 2001. Studies on Production of

Single Cell Protein by Aspergillus niger in Solid State

Fermentation of Rice Bran. Brazilian Archives of Biology

and Technology, 44(1): 79 – 88.

Chen, H.C. and Chang, C.C., 1996. Production of γ-linolenic

acid by the fungus Cunninghamella echinulata CCRC 31840.

Biotechnol. Prog, 12: 338–341.

Page 9: Optimization of Pomace and Banana Peel Fermentation for Production of Single Cell Oil

www.fmfi-journal.org Focusing on Modern Food Industry (FMFI) Volume 2 Issue 4, November 2013

178

Chen, H. and Liu, T., 1997. Inoculum effects on the

production of γ -linolenic acid by the shake culture of

Cunninghamella echinulata CCRC 31840. Enzyme and

Microbial Technology, 21:137-142.

Johnson, V., Singh, M., Saini, V.S., Sista, V.R. and Yadav,

N.R., 2002. Effect of pH on lipid accumulation by an

oleaginous yeast:Rhodotorula glutinis IIP-30. World Journal

of Microbiology and Biotechnology, 8(4): 382-384.

Mohapatra, D., Mishra, S. and Sutar, N., 2010. Banana and

it’s by-product utilization: an overview. Journal of

Scientific and Industrial Research, 69: 323-329.

Pan, L.X., D.F. Yang, L. Shao, W. Li, G.G. Chen and Z.Q.

Liang, 2009. Isolation of the oleaginous yeasts from the

soil and studies of their lipid-producing capacities. Food

Technol. Biotechnol., 47: 215-220.

Papanikolaou, S. and Aggelis, G., 2002. Lipid production by

Yarrowia lipolytica growing on industrial glycerol in a

single-stage continuous culture. Bioresour. Technol., 82: 43-

49.

Rashad, M. M. and Nooman, M. U., 2009. Production,

Purification and Characterization of Extracellular

Invertase from Saccharomyses Cerevisiae NRRL Y-12632 by

Solid-State Fermentation of Red Carrot Residue.

Australian Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences, 3(3): 1910-

1919.

Sajbidor, J., Certik, M. and Dobronova, S., 1988. Influence of

different carbon sources on growth, lipid content and

fatty acid composition in four strains belonging to

Mucorales. Biotechnol. Lett. 10: 347–350.


Recommended