Page 1
[ORIGINAL J STATE OF INDIANA
INDIANA UTILITY REGULATORY COMMISSION
IN THE MATTER OF AN ORDER ) APPROVING ADVISORY COMMITTEE ) RECOMMENDATIONS PURSUANT TO ) INDIANA CODE CHAPTER 8-1-26. )
APPROVED:
ORDER OF THE COMMISSION
MAY 0 3 2017
Indiana Code chapter 8-1-26 provides the procedure for the Indiana Utility Regulatory Commission's Pipeline Safety Division ("Division") to find violations of said chapter. Upon review of those findings, the Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee ("Advisory Committee") reviews those recommendations and recommends civil penalties in the Case.
Tfie Cases receive pursuant to naiana Co e c apter 8-=-1-26 ana npe fmCommission action are attached hereto and collectively referred to as the Advisory Committee Recommendations.
Pursuant to statute, the Advisory Committee has submitted their recommendations to the Commission. The Commission hereby UPHOLDS the findings of violations by the Pipeline Safety Division and APPROVES the recommendations of the Advisory Committee as listed on the attached pages. The Assistant General Counsel to the Division is hereby directed to prepare and send notice to the parties advising them of the determination.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
ATTERHOLT, HUSTON, AND ZIEGNER CONCUR; FREEMAN AND WEBER ABSENT
APPROVED: MAY 0 3 2017
I hereby certify that the above is a true and correct copy of the Order as approved.
Page 2
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Vectren Energy Delivery Blankenberger Brothers, Inc. 2933 2/28/2017 5/08/2012
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(1)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone D Failure to Plan D Self-Repair
D Damaging Lines D Potholing D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 Dig Tickets 0 Probing 0 White Lining
-------1Ll1Jemolitions
--t5V "~ Training or $2',000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
Additional Information: _:[;....._· ...:;..:rcu="--'-' ()..:....;_1_,_'tj~---'Co'°-r 0f__.___.ft ...... · <-"-kd=-=--""""S_._/-L.7_._/..L..J--'3=-·---
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 3
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party:
Concreteplus Foundations LLC Vectren Energy Delivery
Case Number: 11008 Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 7/21/2015
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D W aming letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining --------F1~ emob-t1-on-s-------------------------------
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1 ,000
D Civil penalty of $1 ,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
Civil penalty of $t:~~an mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------
Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 4
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Re"spondent: Other Party: Case Number:
Infrasource Underground Construction Northern Indiana Public Service Company 12298
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 4/11/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(l)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining ~~D~D_e_m_o_lit-io-ns -------------~~-~---~-------~---~-"---
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
ti, Civil penalty of$ _L/~1 _5..._C ..... :0"""""'-----------------
0 Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 5
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
L & S Underground, Inc. Vectren Energy Delivery 12854 2/28/2017 4/8/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(3)(b)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone D Failure to Plan
D Damaging Lines D Potholing
D Dig Tickets D Probing ····-···-oneillolitions--·--·~~····--·······----··
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
~ Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 6
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Blankenberger Brothers, Inc. Vectren Energy Delivery 13292 2/28/2017 5/5/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(3)(b)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Demolrt10ns
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing - ---------------
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
~ Civil penalty of$ _5-=-+l-=onJ-"'<-'"""-------------------0 Other -----------------------------------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 7
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party:
Lawrenceburg Conservancy District Sycamore Gas Company
Case Number: 13371 Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 6/29/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s ): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing -----~------- ---+0_,_,,....D=em~o~h~tio=n~s ------------
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
~ Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 8
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Pahl's Lawn Care, Inc. Other Party: Case Number:
Indiana Natural Gas Corporation 13491
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/2/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
0 Warning letter (Special instructions:)
0 Clearance Zone
0 Damaging Lines
0 Dig Tickets
Dem-olittons
0 Failure to Plan
0 Potholing
0 Probing
0 Self-Repair
0 Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining
i8 Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
0 Civil penalty of $1,000
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 9
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Citizens Gas Citizens Energy Group 13494 2/28/2017 7/28/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(1)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
0 Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining - Demoliti-on-s-------------------------------
D Training or $5 ,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
l'1._ Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1 ,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions: Warren
APPROVED: Dan Meiners Vice Chairman
Page 10
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company Kline Excavating, Inc.
Case Number: 13549 Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 6/23/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
Demolifions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
~ Civil penalty of $1 ,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ~~--------------------------
Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 11
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Town of New Whiteland Vectren Energy Delivery 13590 2/28/2017 6/7 /2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s ): IC 8-1-26-16(h)(prior)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining --------+-+-Bemolition<--------------------------------
~ Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 12
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Lewen Line Construction Vectren Energy Delivery 13601 2/28/2017 6/9/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets --------LJDemolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
~ Training or $5 ,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civilpenaltyof$1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: -f Af_/ ---Ben Warren Chairman
Page 13
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Blankenberger Brothers, Inc. Vectren Energy Delivery 13605 2/28/2017 6/10/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-l-26-20(a)(l)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
ernolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1 ,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
~ Civil penalty of$ -~'-t-· t:>Q1_l)O,.__ ________________ _
D Other ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-
Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 14
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Vectren Energy Delivery C C & T Construction, Inc. 13613 2/28/2017 6/14/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(1)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
Demofitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self~Repair D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
~ Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 15
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
City of Greenfield Vectren Energy Delivery 13619 2/28/2017 6/16/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)(expire)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning 1 etter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
0 Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1 ,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
~ Civil penalty of$ -=3...:...+-1 _,.,51'0"---~----------------D Other
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-
Abstentions:
APPROVED: .zµ---· Ben Warren Chairman
Page 16
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
City of Loogootee Vectren Energy Delivery 13620 2/28/2017 6/16/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s) : IC 8-l-26-20(a)(2)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
~ Warning letter (Special instructions:)
~ Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining -------...-.-.Demohti-on-s-------------------------------...
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chainnan
Page 17
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Good Shepherd Fence Co. Vectren Energy Delivery 13627 2/28/2017 6/20/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)(prior)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining D Demoliti-on_s ______________________________ __._
~ Training or $5 ,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ -------------------- - - -
0 Other ----- - ------------------- ---Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 18
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number:
Vectren Energy Delivery Robinson Trenching & Boring 13629
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 6/20/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining ~-------.=.~ emolili-on-s-------------------------------
D Training or $5 ,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
~ Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 19
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Doug Wilcox Vectren Energy Delivery 13633 2/28/2017 6/20/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
~ Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone D Failure to Plan
D Damaging Lines
fj._Dig Tickets
emoI1t10ns
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 20
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Vectren Energy Delivery Town of Sellersburg 13637 2/28/2017 6/2112016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-lS(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D W aming letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
@ Civil penalty of $1 ,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 21
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Vectren Energy Delivery Hummel Electric, Inc. 13638 2/28/2017 6/22/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-IS(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
0 Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining
C Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
~ Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ---------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 22
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Vectren Energy Delivery City of Terre Haute 13647 2/28/2017 6/24/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
emoht10ns
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
~ Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1 ,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 23
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party:
William Byrley (Trust of Mary Wayne Eble) Vectren Energy Delivery
Case Number: 13648 Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 6/25/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee rec01mnends the following penalty:
~ Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
&8'.. Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining D Dernoli~ti-on_s ______________________________ _._
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ -----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 24
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Jonathan Araujo Vectren Energy Delivery 13650 2/28/2017 6/26/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(l)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
~ Warning letter (Special instructions:)
~Clearance Zone
0 Damaging Lines
0 Dig Tickets
Demolitions
~ Failure to Plan
0 Potholing
0 Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
0 Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
0 Civil penalty of $1,000
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 25
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Karman Arbuckle Vectren Energy Delivery 13652 2/28/2017 6/26/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
6.. Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
ikoig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
0 Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining Demolit1.~on-s-------------------------------
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of$1 ,000
D Civil penalty of $1 ,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 26
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party:
Mt. Carmel Stabilization Group, Inc. Vectren Energy Delivery
Case Number: 13655 Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 6/27/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Conunittee reco1runends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
Demoff 10ns
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
& Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 27
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Vectren Energy Delivery Duke Energy Indiana 13657 2/28/2017 6/28/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(1)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
0 Probing
0 Self-Repair
0 Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 'White Lining emolili-on-s-------------------------------
D Training or $5 ,000 civil penalty if fai l to complete training
D(l Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1 ,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 28
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Schneider Plumbing Vectren EnergJ' Delivery 13660 2/28/2017 6/28/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s) : IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
0 Warning letter (Special instructions:)
0 Clearance Zone
0 Damaging Lines
0 Dig Tickets
Demolitions
0 Failure to Plan
0 Potholing
0 Probing
0 Self-Repair
0 Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 ·white Lining
~ Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
0 Civil penalty of $1,000
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------
Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 29
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Da1e Jefferies Vectren Energy Delivery 13661 2/28/2017 6/28/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
~ Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
~Dig Tickets --------,D Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ~---------------------------
Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chaim1an
Page 30
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number:
North Lawrence Water Corp. Vectren Energy Delivery 13667
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 6/29/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16{h){expire)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
~ Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
~Dig Tickets
emolit10ns
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
0 Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chaim1an
Page 31
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Vectren Energy Delivery Gehring Underground, Inc. 13669 2/28/2017 6/29/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
0 Clearance Zone
0 Damaging Lines
0 Dig Tickets
emolit10ns
0 Failure to Plan
D Potholing
0 Probing
D Self-Repair
0 Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
~ Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 32
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Pour Boys Concrete Vectren Energy Delivery 13672 2/28/2017 6/30/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D \Vaming letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
emolffions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
0 Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
~ Training or $5 ,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ~---------------------------
Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
=--
Page 33
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
BeBout Excavating Vectren Energy Delivery 13673 2/28/2017 6/29/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): JC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Sp ecial instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
Demofffions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
~ Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1 ,000
D Civil penalty of $1 ,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1 ,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ~---------------------------
Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 34
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number:
Wright Excavating & Trucking, Inc. Indiana Natural Gas Corporation 13691
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/23/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-l-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining --------+-+-.Bernotirions-------------------------------
Q( Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-------------- ------ ---
0 Other -------------- --------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 35
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: 0th er Party:
Exceptional Excavating, LLC Citizens Gas
Case Number: 13693 Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/24/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(2)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
~ Warning letter (Special instructions:)
Kl. Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining --------+-+-Bemolitions-------------------------------
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1 ,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions: Warren
APPROVED: Dan Meiners Vice Chairman
Page 36
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
AC Electric Citizens Gas 13694 2/28/2017 8/22/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(2)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining 0 Demofiti'-on- s--------------------------------'-
R. Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1 ,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------
Abstentions: Warren
APPROVED: Dan Meiners Vice Chairman
Page 37
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
The Hoosier Workshop Citizens Gas 13695 2/28/2017 8/21/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
0 Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone 0 Failure to Plan
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
emolit10ns
0 Potholing
0 Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining
(1\ Training or $5 ,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1 ,000
O Civil penalty of $1 ,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1 ,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions: Warren
APPROVED: Dan Meiners Vice Chairman
Page 38
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Howard Jay Kern Citizens Gas 13696 2/28/2017 8/20/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)(prior)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
~ Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
t® Dig Tickets
Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-------- - - ------------ -
0 Other --- ------------------ -------
Abstentions: Warren
Additional Infonnation: ~()'4\CooJ..ec1 dO..>N\ll~ ..
APPROVED: Dan Meiners Vice Chai1man
Page 39
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Midwest Underground, Inc. Citizens Gas 13699 2/28/2017 8/18/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(3)(b)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets --------o· Dem_olitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions: Warren
APPROVED: Dan Meiners Vice Chairman
Page 40
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Jennings Design, LLC Citizens Gas 13704 2/28/2017 8/1/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
0 Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
emolit1ons
0 Failure to Plan
0 Potholing
0 Probing
0 Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
'it Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
0 Civil penalty of $1,000
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------
Abstentions: Warren
APPROVED: Dan Meiners Vice Chairman
Page 41
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Uesseler Construction Indiana Utilities Corporation 13707 2/28/2017 8/24/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining --------+-+-Bemohtions·------------------------------~
~ Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chainnan
Page 42
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company Midwest Trenchless Services
Case Number: 13721 Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 7/13/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
emoiitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
0 Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
~ Civil penalty of $1 ,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$------ ------ -----------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 43
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: 0th er Party:
Northern Indiana Public Senrice Company Midwest Trenchless Services
Case Number: 13722 Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 7/13/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-lS(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
0 Warning letter (Special instructions:)
0 Clearance Zone
0 Damaging Lines
0 Dig Tickets
0 Demolitions
0 Failure to Plan
0 Potholing
0 Probing
0 Self-Repair
0 Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining
0 Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
~ Civil penalty of $1,000
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 44
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: S & S Directional Boring, LTD Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company 13723
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 7/13/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(2)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1 ,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
IQ(_ Civil penalty of$ _S ..... -......1 .... \A9D _______________________ _ D Other
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-
Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 45
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Meade Electric Company, Inc. Northern Indiana Public Service Company 13736 2/28/2017 7/11/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(2)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 46
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company R T Boring, Inc.
Case Number: 13737 Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 7/11/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(1)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
0 Demolitions -
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
~ Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 47
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number:
Rieth-Riley Construction Co., Inc. Northern Indiana Public Service Company 13738
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 7/11/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(2)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets ~-------,0 Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
IG. Civil penalty of$ _.5_......·- 1'"""'1_.jf;O....._._~------------------D Other ----------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chaim1an
Page 48
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IU RC
Respondent: Terry Keefer Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company 13744
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 7/10/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s ): IC 8-1-26-16(h)(expire)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
~ Warning letter (Special instruciions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
IM Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
0 Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------
Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 49
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company City of Elkhart
Case Number: 13748 Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 7/8/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(1)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
ll Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1 ,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1 ,500, can mitigate $1 ,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ~---------------------------
Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 50
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Amanda Coffield Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company 13759
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 7/6/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
{lf. W aming letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
~ Dig Tickets
D Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
0 Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 51
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number:
Heads Up Irrigation & Lighting, LLC Northern Indiana Public Service Company 13984
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 7/31/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
~ Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 52
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Adam Grapengeter Other Party: Northern Indiana Public Service Company
13986 Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 7/30/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
tO\ Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
~Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining -----------+O--t--'T"D=em=o=""h""n=on=s-------------
D
D
D
D
D
D
Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
Civil penalty of $1,000
Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
Civil penalty of$----------------------
Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: !J.= Ben Warren Chairman
Page 53
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company Ross Kline
Case Number: 13987 Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 7/30/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(1)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
emoli wns
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
~ Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1 ,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions : Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 54
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Pro Electric Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company 13989
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 7/30/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-l-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
LJ Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
~ Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 55
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Crosby Excavating, Inc. Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company 13990
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 7/29/2016
The TIJRC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(2)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
~ Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
Ben Warren Chairman
Page 56
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company Glover Cable Construction LLC
Case Number: 13991 Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 7/29/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining ~~~~~~~_,_._.Demofiti~on-s-------------------------------+-
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
~ Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1 ,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: l Ben Warren Chairman
Page 57
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Michael Hutchison Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company 13992
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 7/29/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
~ Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D' Clearance Zone
0 Damaging Lines
e Dig Tickets
Demolitions
0 Failure to Plan
0 Potholing
0 Probing
0 Self-Repair
0 Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining
0 Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
0 Civil penalty of $1,000
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of$ -----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 58
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company New Horizon Drilling Solution, Inc.
Case Number: 13995 Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 7/29/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
0 Warning letter (Special instructions:)
0 Clearance Zone
0 Damaging Lines
0 Dig Tickets
0 Failure to Plan
0 Potholing
0 Probing
0 Self-Repair
0 Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining -Demofi~t10_n_s-------------------------------
0 Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
~ Civil penalty of $1,000
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 59
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Area Plumbing & Sewer Co., Inc. Northern Indiana Public Service Company 13997
Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 7/28/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)(expire)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D
D
D
n u
D
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Demohbons
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
Civil penalty of $1,000
Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,5 00 by completing training and corrective action plan
Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
Other ----------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 60
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
GeoForce Utility Technologies Northern Indiana Public Service Company 13999 2/28/2017 7/28/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)(expire)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Demoht1ons
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
S-. Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
Additional Information: ~\vied {rcU n I.,., ;;( /d_ \ //7.
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 61
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: GeoForce Utility Technologies Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Senrice Company 14000
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 7/28/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)(expire)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
0 Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining
~ Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
Additional Information: ~ ltAul d I ex\ l 11
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 62
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party:
Northern India_na Public Service Company Key Concrete, Inc.
Case Number: 14002 Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 7/28/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
emoht1ons
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
~ Civil penalty of $1 ,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1 ,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 63
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number:
Saint Joseph County Highway Department Northern Indiana Public Service Company 14003
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 7/28/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(2)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
0 Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
®. Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 64
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Concrete Guys, Inc. Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company 14004
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 7/28/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
Civil penalty of $(~~an mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
I& Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
Additional Information: f(ij\d -\-<> fu.L ~aJa/':j i 11
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 65
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Beall Construction, Inc. Vectren Energy Delivery 14040 2/28/2017 7/8/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(2)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
¥l. Warning letter (Special instructions:)
r,;. Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ---------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 66
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Vectren Energy Delivery 3D Co., Inc. 14041 2/28/2017 7/9/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D
~
D
D
D
D
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
Civil penalty of $1,000
Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
Other ---------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 67
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
3D Co., Inc. Vectren Energy Delivery 14043 2/28/2017 7/28/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(b)(expire)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
0 Warning letter (Special instructions:)
0 Clearance Zone
0 Damaging Lines
0 Dig Tickets
0 Failure to Plan
0 Potholing
0 Probing
0 Self-Repair
0 Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining
0 Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
0 Civil penalty of $1,000
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
~ Civil penalty of$ ~3"""-J-1 ....,s;v0'-=------------------0 Other ---------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 68
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Geswein Construction Vectren Energy Delivery 14053 2/28/2017 7/8/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D W aming letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
emo 1tions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
jj!,.. Training or $5 ,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ---------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 69
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Brady S. Posey Vectren Energy Delivery 14054 2/28/2017 7/7/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
COO Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
~ Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ---------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 70
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party:
Calumet Civil Contractors, Inc. Vectren Energy Delivery
Case Number: 14057 Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 7/6/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(2)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone D Failure to Plan
D Damaging Lines
0 Dig Tickets
D Demoht10ns
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,5 00 by completing training and corrective action plan
~ Civil penalty of$ .... 3....,,_LJ()t....__.) __________________ _
D Other ~---------------------------------------------------
Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 71
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number:
Vectren Energy Delivery Calumet Civil Contractors, Inc. 14058
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 7/28/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-lS(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
0 Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining ~-------+-+-Bemolitiorrs·~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-
D Training or $5 ,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
S Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-
Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 72
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Extreme Builders Vectren Energy Delivery 14064 2/28/2017 7/11/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
0 Probing ------···· ··-ot-+-Tu~e-m~o1~1t1-on_s __________ _
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
~ Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ~--------------------------
Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 73
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
George Adams Vectren Energy Delivery 14066 2/28/2017 7/31/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)(expire)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
~ Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
~ Dig Tickets
D Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
~ Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ~--------------------------
Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 74
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Vectren Energy Delivery International, Inc. 14070 2/28/2017 7/29/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-lS(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
6(1' Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ---------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 75
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Lykins Contracting Co. Vectren Energy Delivery 14079 2/28/2017 7/27/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(l)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
0 Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
~ Civil penalty of$ _5~, ....... fJ'--eiJ ________________ _ D Other -----------------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: L tL----Ben Warren Chairman
Page 76
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Milestone Contractors, LP Vectren Energy Delivery 14086 2/28/2017 7/13/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(2)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D
D
D
D
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Demoht1ons
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
Civil penalty of $1,000
Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
~ Civil penalty of$ _3~1_..SLJL ................. l""""'~ ---------------
Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 77
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Milestone Contractors, LP Vectren Energy Delivery 14087 2/28/2017 7/28/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(l)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Self-Repair
D Dig Tickets D Demofiti~on-s------------------------------~
0 Probing
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1 ,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
Civil penalty of$ _ y......,_.,d .... QOD....._,co_ _________________ _
D Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
Additional Infonnation:
APPROVED:
------------------------
Ben Warren Chairman
Page 78
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Vectren Energy Delivery Miller Pipeline, LLC 14089 2/28/2017 7/11/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining D Demoriti.-on_s ______________________________ _,_
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
~ Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions: ~llring & Miller
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 79
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
P P M I Construction Co. Vectren Energy Delivery 14094 2/28/2017 7/27/2016
The IlJRC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)(expire)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
~ Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
~ Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ---------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 80
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Schmitt Back.hoe Service Vectren Energy Delivery 14100 2/28/2017 7/7/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(l)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
Q Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ---------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 81
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Stabilization Services, Inc. Vectren Energy Delivery 14102 2/28/2017 7/112016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(l)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
~ Warning letter (Special instructions:)
0 Clearance Zone
0 Damaging Lines
0 Dig Tickets
D Demolit10ns
~Failure to Plan
0 Potholing
0 Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 82
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Terry Newcom Vectren Energy Delivery 14106 2/28/2017 7/112016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
®.. Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
~Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ---------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 83
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Hagerman Construction Vectren Energy Delivery 14107 2/28/2017 7/8/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(b)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
0 Warning letter (Special instructions:)
0 Clearance Zone
0 Damaging Lines
0 Dig Tickets
0 Failure to Plan
0 Potholing
0 Probing ~ -~---- ------+-D,__,D""<ce=m~or...,1t~10~ns~------
0 Self-Repair
0 Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining
~ Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
0 Civil penalty of $1,000
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
0 Other ---------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 84
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number:
Vectren Energy Delivery Whalen Construction Co., Inc. 14113
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 7/11/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
[J Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
[J Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D VVhite Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
~ Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,5 00 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ~--------------------------
Abstentions:
APPROVED: -L W---Ben Warren Chairman
Page 85
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Vectren Energy Delivery Other Party: Case Number:
A-1 Septic Service & Excavating, Inc. 14116
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/1/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-lS(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone D Failure to Plan
D Damaging Lines D Potholing
D Dig Tickets
------o Demolitions
0 Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 \Vhite Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
8' Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ~---------------------------
Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 86
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
E & B Paving, Inc. Vectren Energy Delivery 14118 2/28/2017 8/1/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(l)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ---------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 87
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Vectren Energy Delivery Indiana Foundation Service 14119 2/28/2017 8/1/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
~ Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ---------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 88
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Vectren Energy Delivery J P Excavating, Inc. 14120 2/28/2017 8/1/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
0 Warning letter (Special instructions:)
0 Clearance Zone
0 Damaging Lines
0 Dig Tickets
Demolitions
0 Failure to Plan
0 Potholing
0 Probing
0 Self-Repair
0 Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining
0 Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
~ Civil penalty of $1,000
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
0 Other ---------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 89
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Michael S. Evans Vectren Energy Delivery 14121 2/28/2017 8/1/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone D Failure to Plan
D Damaging Lines
f15. Dig Tickets
E>-errrntitions
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 90
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Pyramid Technologies, Inc. Vectren Energy Delivery 14122 2/28/2017 8/1/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)(expire)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
0 W aming letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
~ Dig Tickets
Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
0 Probing
D Self-Repair
0 Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------
Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chainnan
Page 91
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Beldon Fence Co., Inc. Vectren Energy Delivery 14123 2/28/2017 8/2/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(2)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
~ Warning letter (Special instructions:)
/& Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
Demolit ions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5 ,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1 ,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 92
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
City of Evansville Vectren Energy Delivery 14124 2/28/2017 8/2/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s) : IC 8-1-26-16(h)(out)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Spe cial instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1 ,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
R Civil penalty of$ _5"-i· 1,......,eoQ~------------------0 Other
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-
Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 93
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number:
Crider & Crider Construction Vectren Energy Delivery 14165
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/20/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(2)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
Demo it1ons
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
0 Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining
!ti(. Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ---------------------------Abstentions:
Additional Information: -~~fi'"""'"ZU""""" .. _._O _; ~"'+-_C, __ Dlli-f......_____...~-..........J...._··_q""'"""'/,__q...._./...__.__.J le..__ __ _
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 94
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Vectren Energy Delivery Joink LLC 14168 2/28/2017 8/22/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
0 Warning letter (Special instructions:)
0 Clearance Zone
0 Damaging Lines
0 Dig Tickets
Demolitions
0 Failure to Plan
0 Potholing
0 Probing
0 Self-Repair
0 Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining
0 Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
~ Civil penalty of $1,000
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ~---------------------------
Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 95
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Vectren Energy Delivery Minnesota Limited, LLC 14169 2/28/2017 8/22/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
0 Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
~ Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 96
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Vectren Energy Delivery Scotty Jennings 14170 2/28/2017 8/22/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(1)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
0 Demoht10ns ·
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
B. Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ _____________________ _
D Other --------------------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 97
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Superior Construction Vectren Energy Delivery 14171 2/28/2017 8/22/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining --------------------------+-D+-'lD"'-e=m""ol""'it'"'ion=s~------
D
D
D
D
D
Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
Civil penalty of $1,000
Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
Civil penalty of$ LJ. DOO ($3t COO + \11, CW no ±J'chJ escaJa}-/cn J Other
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-
Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 98
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Y ardberry Landscape Co. Vectren Energy Delivery 14173 2/28/2017 8/22/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)(out)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining -- -~ '-----"----~D~D_e_m-ol~iti~on_s ______ _
rii:
D
D
D
D
D
Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
Civil penalty of $1,000
Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
Civil penalty of$----------------------
Other ---------------------------Abstentions:
Additional Information: _x-...._\ ..._Ci ...... O""'A._....0'""""i-~-"'+-----"L""""'? ...... · fY\J()----=--l ..... e_..k.._._..d...___..c;.?~/--d__,,,..._/..__J 7 __
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 99
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party:
A B C Cutting Contractors, Inc. Vectren Energy Delivery
Case Number: 14174 Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/23/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D W aming letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone D Failure to Plan
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
Demolitions
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
~ Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1 ,500, can mitigate $1 ,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ -----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 100
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to lURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
International, Inc. Vectren Energy Delivery 14175 2/28/2017 8/23/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)(expire)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
0 Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
LJTiemo ht10ns
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
0 Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining
g Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ----------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 101
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Wooten Concrete, LLC Vectren Energy Delivery 14176 2/28/2017 8/23/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(2)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
~ Warning letter (Special instructions:)
~ Clearance Zone
0 Damaging Lines
0 Dig Tickets
D Demolitions
0 Failure to Plan
0 Potholing
0 Probing
D Self-Repair
0 Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ---------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 102
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Terrell Contracting, Inc. Vectren Energy Delivery 14178 2/28/2017 8/24/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
{)l$, Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
[] Other ---------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 103
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: Date of Damage:
Vectren Energy Delivery Black Excavating 14180 2/28/2017 8/25/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-l-26-18(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Demoht10ns
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
t&... Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ---------------------------Abstentions:
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 104
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: James Lindsey (Contractor) Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company 14592
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/2/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
emolt ions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
0 Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
~ Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ -----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 105
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company All Seasons Underground Construction, Inc. 14593
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/2/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(1)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
& Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 106
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: City of Portage Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company 14594
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/2/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(l)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
I: Civil penalty of$ -3....-..+1~~-------------------D Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 107
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Elmer's Service, LLC Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company 14595
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/2/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
K Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 108
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company Meade Electric Company, Inc.
Case Number: 14597 Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/2/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(1)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special insn·uctions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
ernoh 10ns
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
(X Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
0 Civil penalty of$----------------------
0 Other ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-
Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 109
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company Niblock Excavating, Inc.
Case Number: 14601 Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/2/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
Jl Civil penalty of $1, 000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 110
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: City of Portage Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company 14604
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/1/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 111
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Herd Agri-Enterprises, Inc. Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company 14605
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/1/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Demoht1ons
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
~ Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 112
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Ironclad Excavating, Inc. Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company 14606
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/1/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(l)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D
n LJ
D
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Demol!t10ns
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
Civil penalty of $1, 000
Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: l Ben Warren Chairman
Page 113
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Kline Trucking & Excavating, Inc. Northern Indiana Public Service Company 14607
Other Party: Case Number: Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/1/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(l)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
~ Warning letter (Special instructions:)
~ Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
JI§,. Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining ~~·---- --~~-----" D Demoli6ons
D
D
D
D
D
D
Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
Civil penalty of $1, 000
Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 114
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Pulver Asphalt Paving, Inc. Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company 14608
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/1/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
Berrro-liti:urrs
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
~ Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ~~~~---------~----~~--------
Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 115
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Rosa Medina Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company 14772
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/26/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
I( Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
Kl Dig Tickets
D Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 116
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Earl Miller Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company 14774
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/26/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
k Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
~ Dig Tickets --- -- ----------- ----------o Demolit10ns
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 117
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: V & H Excavating Co Inc Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company 14777
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/25/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-l-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D W aming letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
rp..._ Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1, 000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: L {;]_ Ben Warren Chairman
Page 118
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company SIT Bancroft Electric, Inc.
Case Number: 14778 Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/25/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
~ Civil penalty of $1, 000
D Civil penalty of $1 ,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1 ,500, can mitigate $1 ,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-
Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 119
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Adrian Kaser Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company 14779
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/25/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
l&. Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
~ Dig Tickets
D Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
0 Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 120
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: City of Goshen Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company 14782
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/24/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-l-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
0 Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining
a Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 121
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Shane Bagley Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company 14783
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/23/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
~ Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
'ADig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 122
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: David Roti Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company 14784
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/23/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
'If; Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1, 000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 123
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Northern Indiana Public Service Company Other Party: Case Number:
Indiana American Water Co. DBA Indiana American 14785
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/23/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Demolitions
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
J& Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: ~Al---Ben Warren Chairman
Page 124
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company A & R Wastewater Management
Case Number: 14787 Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/23/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone D Failure to Plan
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
emofffions
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
~ Civil penalty of $1 ,000
D Civil penalty of $1 ,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 125
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company De Boer Egolf Corp.
Case Number: 14788 Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/23/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(1)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
0 Demolitions ~---------------- ~----------------~----"-"-----------------
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
l® Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other __________________________ _
Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 126
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Dyer Construction Co., Inc. Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company 14792
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/22/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-20(a)(2)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
0 Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining
~ Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 127
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Greg Ritchie Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company 14793
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/21/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
6(. Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
~Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $7 50 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 128
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Walter Monterroso Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company 14796
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/20/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
~ Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
~Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining D Demoliti.-on_s ______________________________ __,_
D Training or $5 ,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and con-ective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,5 00, can mitigate $1,5 00 by completing training and con-ective action plan
D Civil penalty of$-----------------------
0 Other ----------------------------
Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Wan-en Chairman
Page 129
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Other Party:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company City of Hammond
Case Number: 14798 Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/19/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-18(f)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
D Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
D Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
D White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
~ Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ---------------------------Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
Page 130
Indiana Underground Plant Protection Advisory Committee Recommendation to IURC
Respondent: Rogers Electric Other Party: Case Number:
Northern Indiana Public Service Company 14802
Date of Advisory Meeting: 2/28/2017 Date of Damage: 8/18/2016
The IURC Pipeline Safety Division finds the following violation(s): IC 8-1-26-16(h)(expire)
The Advisory Committee recommends the following penalty:
~ Warning letter (Special instructions:)
D Clearance Zone
D Damaging Lines
~Dig Tickets
D Failure to Plan
D Potholing
D Probing
D Self-Repair
D Using Stakes or Post Hole Diggers
0 White Lining
D Training or $5,000 civil penalty if fail to complete training
D Civil penalty of $1,000
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $750 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of $1,500, can mitigate $1,500 by completing training and corrective action plan
D Civil penalty of$ ______________________ _
D Other ~---------------------------
Abstentions: Selking
APPROVED: Ben Warren Chairman
