+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved...

Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved...

Date post: 24-Jun-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 0 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
38
Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond Roads and Maritime Services | November 2019
Transcript
Page 1: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond

Roads and Maritime Services | November 2019

Page 2: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

Document control File name RP2J Out of Hours Work Protocol Rev 4

Report name Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL

Approval and authorisation Reviewed by: Reviewed by: Review by:

Stuart Pigott Steve Dalley Simon Williams

30/10/2019 30/10//2019 01/11/2019

Roads and Maritime Senior Environment Officer

Roads and Maritime Project Manager

Independent Environmental Representative

Revision history Revision Date Description

0 01/07/2019 Draft for Roads and Maritime review

1 22/07/19 Draft for PM review

2 08/08/19 Draft for ER review

3 12/08/19 For submission to Department of Planning, Industry and Environment for approval

4 01/11/19 Updated following comments from Department of Planning, Industry and Environment

Re-submitted for approval

i | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 3: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

Table of Contents

1 Introduction .................................................................................................................... 1

1.1 Out of Hours Work Protocol scope ........................................................................... 1

1.2 Conditions of Approval ............................................................................................. 1

1.3 Standard construction hours ..................................................................................... 5

1.4 Highly noise intensive work ...................................................................................... 5

1.5 Environment Protection Licence ............................................................................... 6

1.6 Roles and responsibilities ......................................................................................... 6

1.7 Induction / training .................................................................................................... 6

2 Justification for OOHW .................................................................................................. 7

2.1 Emergency works ..................................................................................................... 7

2.2 OOHW which requires justification and approval ...................................................... 7

2.3 Process for obtaining approval for OOHW ................................................................ 8

3 OOHW noise and vibration assessment ..................................................................... 10

3.1 Risk based approach.............................................................................................. 10

3.2 Noise assessment .................................................................................................. 10

3.3 Vibration assessment ............................................................................................. 13

4 Mitigation measures ..................................................................................................... 16

4.1 Criteria for implementation of mitigation measures ................................................. 16

4.2 Ground-borne noise ............................................................................................... 16

4.3 Noise and vibration mitigation measures ................................................................ 16

4.4 Standard mitigation measures ................................................................................ 16

4.5 Additional mitigation measures .............................................................................. 17

5 Approval of OOHW ....................................................................................................... 21

5.1 Coordination with other OOHW approved by an EPL ............................................. 21

6 Consultation and notification ...................................................................................... 22

7 Monitoring and auditing ............................................................................................... 24

7.1 Monitoring for OOHW ............................................................................................. 24

7.2 Complaints management ....................................................................................... 24

7.3 Exceedances / non-conformances ......................................................................... 24

7.4 Records.................................................................................................................. 24

ii | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 4: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

Attachments

Attachment 1 OOHW approval request form

Attachment 2 Application of OOHW mitigation measures

iii | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 5: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

Glossary/ Abbreviations

0B0BTerm 1B1BExpanded text

Ambient noise The all-encompassing noise associated within a given environment at a given time, usually composed of sound from all sources near and far

CCLP (Contractor’s) Construction Community Liaison Plan

CCS Community Communication Strategy

CNVG Construction Noise and Vibration Guideline (Roads and Maritime, 2016)

CoA Conditions of Approval (issued for the project by the Department of Planning, Industry and Environment)

CRM Community Relations Manager

dBA Decibels using the A-weighted scale measured according to the frequency of the human ear

DPIE Department of Planning, Industry and Environment

EMM Environmental Management Measures (for the project)

ER Environmental Representative (for the project)

Feasible and reasonable Consideration of best practice taking into account the benefit of proposed measures and their technological and associated operational application in the NSW and Australian context. Feasible relates to engineering considerations and what is practical to build. Reasonable relates to the application of judgement in arriving at a decision, taking into account mitigation benefits and cost of mitigation versus benefits provided, community views and nature and extent of potential improvements.

Highly noise affected As defined in the Interim Construction Noise Guideline (DECC, 2009)

Highly noise intensive works

Works which are defined as annoying under the Interim Construction Noise Guideline (DECC, 2009) including: (a) use of power saws, such as used for cutting timber, rail lines, masonry,

road pavement or steel work (b) grinding metal, concrete or masonry (c) rock drilling (d) line drilling (e) vibratory rolling (f) bitumen milling or profiling (g) jackhammering, rock hammering or rock breaking (h) impact piling

ICNG Interim Construction Noise Guideline (DECC, 2009)

LAeqR(15min) The A-weighted equivalent continuous (energy average) A-weighted sound pressure level of the Construction works under consideration over a 15-minute period and excludes other noise sources such as from industry, road, rail and the community

LAR(max) The A-weighted maximum noise level only from the Construction works under consideration, measured using the fast time weighting on a sound level meter

NCA Noise Catchment Area

iv | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 6: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

0B0BTerm 1B1BExpanded text

NML Noise Management Level as defined in the Interim Construction Noise Guideline (DECC, 2009)

NVMP Noise and Vibration Management Plan

OOHW Out of hours works

RBL The Rating Background Level for each period is the medium value of the RBL values for the period over all of the days measured. There is therefore an RBL value for each period (day, evening and night)

RNP NSW Road Noise Policy

RP2J Rankin Park to Jesmond project (the project)

Sensitive receiver

Includes residences, educational institutions (including preschools, schools, universities, TAFE colleges), health care facilities (including nursing homes, hospitals), religious facilities (including churches), child care centres, passive recreation areas (including outdoor grounds used for teaching), commercial premises (including film and television studios, research facilities, entertainment spaces, temporary accommodation such as caravan parks and camping grounds, restaurants, office premises, and retail spaces), and others as identified by the Planning Secretary

SPB Shared Path Bridge

SPL Sound Pressure Level

SWP Sound Power Level

v | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 7: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

1 Introduction

1.1 Out of Hours Work Protocol scope This Out of Hours Work (OOHW) Protocol has been prepared by Roads and Maritime Services (Roads and Maritime) to comply with the Conditions of Approval (CoA) and project environmental management measures (EMM) for OOHW for the Rankin Park to Jesmond (RP2J) project (the project).

This protocol only applies to works not subject to an Environment Protection Licence (EPL). Project works not subject to an EPL include Stages 1 to 3 as outlined in the project Staging Report, namely: • Stage 1 – Early works • Stage 2 – Shared path bridge (SPB) over Newcastle Road • Stage 3 – Southern interchange utilities works

Stage 4 of the project is the Main works. Only Stage 4 of the project will constitute ‘scheduled’ activities under the POEO Act and will therefore be subject to an EPL. The process for approving OOHW for works that are subject to an EPL will be governed by the conditions of the EPL and are not discussed further in this OOHW protocol.

Stage 1 and 3 works will be carried out in accordance with this protocol and relevant Environmental Work Method Statements (EWMS). Stage 2 works will be carried out in accordance with this protocol, the relevant EWMS and the SPB Noise and Vibration Management Plan (NVMP).

1.2 Conditions of Approval CoA relevant to OOHW and where they are addressed in this OOHW protocol are identified in Table 1-1.

Table 1-1: Conditions of approval relevant to OOHW

CoA Condition requirements Reference in this OOHW Protocol

E26

Construction Hours Work must only be undertaken during the following construction hours: (a) 7:00 am to 6:00 pm Mondays to Fridays, inclusive; (b) 8:00 am to 5:00 pm Saturdays; and (c) at no time on Sundays or public holidays.

Section 1.3

E27

Variation to Works Hours Notwithstanding Conditions E26 and E30, work may be undertaken outside the hours specified, in the following circumstances: (a) for the delivery of materials where required by the NSW Police

Force or other authority for safety reasons; or (b) where it is required in an emergency to avoid injury or the loss of

life, to avoid damage or loss of property or to prevent

Section 2.1

1 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 8: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

CoA Condition requirements Reference in this OOHW Protocol

environmental harm; or (c) where different construction hours are permitted or required under

an EPL in force in respect of the SSI; or (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out

of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent (for work not subject to an EPL) under Condition E31; or

(e) work that causes: (i) no more than 5 db(A) above the rating background level at

any residence in accordance with the Interim Construction Noise Guideline (DECC, 2009), and

(ii) no more than the ‘Noise affected’ noise management levels specified in Table 3 of the Interim Construction Noise Guideline (DECC, 2009) at other sensitive land uses, and

(iii) continuous or impulsive vibration values, measured at the most affected residence are no more than the maximum values for human exposure to vibration, specified in Table 2.2 of Assessing Vibration: a technical guideline (DEC, 2006), and

(iv) intermittent vibration values measured at the most affected residence are no more than the maximum values for human exposure to vibration, specified in Table 2.4 of Assessing Vibration: a technical guideline (DEC, 2006).

Note: Section 5.24(1)(e) of the EP&A Act requires that an EPL be substantially consistent with this approval.

E28 On becoming aware of the need for emergency work in accordance with Condition E27(b), the Proponent must notify the ER and the EPA of the reasons for such work. The Proponent must use best endeavours to notify all noise and/or vibration affected sensitive receivers of the likely impact and duration of those works.

Section 2.1

E29 In order to undertake out-of-hours work, the Proponent must identify appropriate respite periods for the out-of-hours works in consultation with the community at each affected location on a monthly basis. This consultation must include (but not be limited to) providing the community with: (a) a schedule of likely out-of-hours work for a period of no less than

three (3) months in advance; (b) potential work, location and duration; (c) proposed respite periods; (d) noise characteristics and likely noise and vibration levels; and (e) likely mitigation and management measures. The outcomes of the community consultation, the identified respite periods and the scheduling of likely out-of-hour work must be provided to the ER, EPA and the Planning Secretary.

Section 4.3.5

E30

Highly Noise Intensive Work Except as permitted by an EPL, highly noise intensive works exceeding 75 dB(A) LAeq(15 minute) noise descriptor at a sensitive receiver must only be undertaken: (a) between 8:00 am to 6:00 pm Monday to Friday;

Section 1.4

2 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 9: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

CoA Condition requirements Reference in this OOHW Protocol

(b) between 8:00 am to 1:00 pm Saturday; and (c) if continuously, then not exceeding three (3) hours, with a

minimum respite from those activities and works of not less than one (1) hour.

For the purposes of this condition, 'continuous' includes any period during which there is less than one (1) hour between ceasing and recommencing any of the work.

E31 An Out-of-Hours Work Protocol must be prepared to identify a process for the consideration, management and approval of work which are outside the hours defined in Condition E26, and that are not subject to an EPL. The Protocol must be approved by the Planning Secretary before the commencement of the work. The Protocol must be prepared in consultation with the EPA and the ER. The Protocol must: (a) provide a process for the consideration of out-of-hours work

against the relevant noise and vibration criteria, including the determination of low and high-risk activities;

(b) provide a process for the identification of mitigation measures for residual impacts, including respite periods in consultation with the community at each affected location, consistent with the requirements of Condition E29;

(c) identify procedures to facilitate the coordination of out-of-hours work permitted by an EPL to ensure appropriate respite is provided;

(d) undertake a risk analysis that considers the risk of activities, proposed mitigation, management, and coordination, including where:

° low risk activities can be approved by the ER, and

° any other activity approved by the Planning Secretary; and (e) identify Department, EPA and community notification

arrangements for approved out of hours work, which may be detailed in the Communication Strategy.

The Out-of-Hours Work Protocol is not required if the Proponent has an existing Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent that addresses Condition E31 (a) to (e) and has been approved by the Planning Secretary prior to the commencement of work.

This OOHW Protocol Section 2.3 Section 4 Section 5.1 Section 3 CCS, Section 6 N/A

E32

Utility Coordination and Respite All work undertaken for the delivery of the SSI, including that undertaken by third parties (such as utility relocation), must be coordinated to ensure respite periods are provided. The Proponent must: (a) schedule any work to provide respite to impacted noise sensitive

receivers so that the respite is achieved in accordance with Condition E29; or

(b) consider the provision of alternative respite or mitigation to impacted noise sensitive receivers; and

(c) provide documentary evidence to the ER in support of any decision made by the Proponent in relation to respite or mitigation.

Section 4.3.7

3 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 10: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

CoA Condition requirements Reference in this OOHW Protocol

E33

Noise and Vibration Mitigation Noise generating work in the vicinity of sensitive receivers and landuses (including community, religious, educational institutions and noise and vibration-sensitive businesses, medical facilities, and the John Hunter Hospital) resulting in noise levels above the NMLs at critical working areas (such as operating theatres and precision laboratories) must not be timetabled within sensitive periods, unless other reasonable arrangements with the affected receivers are made at no cost to the affected receivers.

Section 4.2

E34 Mitigation measures must be implemented with the aim of achieving the following construction noise management levels and vibration criteria: (a) construction ‘Noise affected’ noise management levels

established using the Interim Construction Noise Guideline (DECC, 2009);

(b) vibration criteria established using the Assessing vibration: a technical guideline (DEC, 2006) (for human exposure);

(c) Australian Standard AS 2187.2 - 2006 “Explosives - Storage and Use - Use of Explosives”;

(d) BS 7385 Part 2-1993 “Evaluation and measurement for vibration in buildings Part 2” as they are “applicable to Australian conditions”; and

(e) The vibration limits set out in the German Standard DIN 4150-3: Structural Vibration- effects of vibration on structures (for structural damage).

Any work identified as exceeding the noise management levels and/or vibration criteria must be managed in accordance with the Noise and Vibration CEMP Sub-plan, including in any Out- of-Hours Work Protocol or Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent, required by Condition E31, and in relation to Bridge 7 the documents required by Condition A9. Note: The Interim Construction Noise Guideline identifies ‘particularly annoying’ activities that require the addition of 5 dB(A) to the predicted level before comparing to the construction Noise Management Level.

Section 4.1

E35 Mitigation measures must be applied when the following residential ground-borne noise levels are exceeded: • evening (6:00 pm to 10:00 pm) — internal LAeq(15 minute): 40 db(A);

and • night (10:00 pm to 7:00 am) — internal LAeq(15 minute): 35 dB(A). The mitigation measures must be outlined in the Noise and Vibration CEMP Sub-plan, including in any Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent, required by Condition E31, and i relation to Bridge 7 the documents required by Condition A9.

Section 4.2

E36 Landowner(s) and occupier(s) of properties at risk of exceeding the screening criteria for cosmetic damage must be notified before works that generate vibration commences near those properties. If the potential exceedance is to occur more than once or extend over a period of 24 hours, landowner(s) and occupier(s) must be provided a schedule of potential exceedances on a monthly basis for the duration

Section 4.2

4 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 11: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

CoA Condition requirements Reference in this OOHW Protocol

of the potential exceedances, unless otherwise agreed by the landowner and occupier. These properties must be identified and considered in the Noise and Vibration CEMP Sub-plan, including in any Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent, required by Condition E31, and in relation to Bridge 7 the documents required by Condition A9. Note: Condition E54 requires Pre-construction Building and Structure Condition Surveys of buildings and structures of risk of damage to be undertaken prior to the commencement of work in the vicinity of the buildings or structures.

Project EMM NV07*

An out of hours work procedure (for work outside the proposed extended construction hours) will be developed and would include the following: • Contact the local community potentially affected by the proposed

work and inform them by letter of the proposed work, location, type of work, days and dates of work and hours involved. The contact will be made before the start of work

• A suitable advertisement will be placed in local papers including a reference to night-time noise impacts

• A 24-hour community liaison phone number and permanent site contact will be provided so that complaints can be received and addressed in a timely manner

• Measures to investigate and respond to any valid noise complaints.

Section 6.1.2 Section 6.1.2 Section 6.1.2 Section 7.2

* Project EMM NV07 is not a CoA but is an Environmental Management Measure relevant to the OOHW protocol included in the project Submissions and Preferred Infrastructure Report, and has therefore been listed here for completeness.

1.3 Standard construction hours The standard construction hours for the project as defined in CoA E26 are as follows:

• 7:00 am to 6:00 pm Mondays to Fridays, inclusive

• 8:00 am to 5:00 pm Saturdays

• at no time on Sundays or public holidays.

1.4 Highly noise intensive work As required by CoA E30, except as permitted by an EPL, highly noise intensive works for the project exceeding 75 dB(A) LAeq(15 minute) noise descriptor at a sensitive receiver must only be undertaken: • between 8:00 am to 6:00 pm Monday to Friday • between 8:00 am to 1:00 pm Saturday • if continuously, then not exceeding three (3) hours, with a minimum respite from those

activities and works of not less than one (1) hour.

'Continuous' includes any period during which there is less than one (1) hour between ceasing and recommencing any of the work.

5 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 12: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

1.5 Environment Protection Licence As discussed in Section 1.1, this OOHW protocol only applies to works not subject to an EPL.

1.6 Roles and responsibilities This OOHW protocol has been prepared by Roads and Maritime. The project works will be carried out by Roads and Maritime Contractor/s.

The Contractor’s Environmental Site Representative will seek approval from Roads and Maritime for any OOHW (refer Section 2.3 and Section 5).

The Contractor’s requests for OOHW will be reviewed by the Roads and Maritime Environmental Manager (or delegate) and endorsed by the Roads and Maritime Project Manager (refer Section 5 of this Protocol). Where appropriate and compliant, an OOHW application will be considered and /or approved by the RP2J project Environmental ER (for low risk activities) or by the Planning Secretary (all other activities, referred to in this plan as high risk activities). The process of obtaining ER or Planning Secretary approval will be managed by Roads and Maritime.

The Contractor’s Community Relations Manager (CRM) will be responsible for ensuring that notification and consultation on the likely impacts of OOHW activities has occurred with community stakeholders and residents, in accordance with the RP2J project Community Communication Strategy (CCS) and any other relevant activity specific community consultation plans

The Contractor’s Environmental Site Representative will implement and oversee the noise monitoring program for OOHW to assess compliance with the CoA and the OOHW Protocol.

The Contractor’s Project Manager is responsible for notifying the ER, the Roads and Maritime Project Manager and Roads and Maritime Environmental Manager (or delegate) of any noise exceedances or complaints that occur during OOHW. If there is need for emergency work as per CoA E27(b), the Roads and Maritime Environmental Manager (or delegate) will notify the ER and the EPA of the reasons for such work in accordance with CoA E28. Roads and Maritime and the Contractor will use best endeavours to notify all noise and/or vibration affected sensitive receivers of the likely impact and duration of those works.

1.7 Induction / training RMS and Contractors will be required to comply with this OOHW protocol.

All site personnel (including RMS personnel, Contractors and Sub-Contractors) will be inducted on this OOHW Protocol, including the relevant control measures to be implemented to minimise impacts of OOHW on the community and environment. Training will include inductions, toolbox talks, pre-starts and targeted training for OOHW as required.

6 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 13: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

2 Justification for OOHW Construction activities will generally be carried out within the approved standard construction hours included in Section 1.3.

Construction of the project may require some work to be carried out outside of standard construction hours. Certain emergency works are permissible and considered justified under CoA 27 and do not require approval (refer Section 2.1). All other OOHW will require justification and approval before they can proceed (refer Section 2.2).

2.1 Emergency works CoA E27 allows for variation to standard work hours for OOHW that can be carried out without justification in the following circumstances: a) for the delivery of materials where required by the NSW Police Force or other authority

for safety reasons b) where it is required in an emergency to avoid injury or the loss of life, to avoid damage or

loss of property or to prevent environmental harm. As required by CoA E28, on becoming aware of the need for emergency work in accordance with CoA E27(b) above, the Roads and Maritime Environmental Manager (or delegate) will notify the project Environmental Representative (ER) and the EPA of the reasons for such work. Roads and Maritime and the Contractor will use best endeavours to notify all noise and/or vibration affected sensitive receivers of the likely impact and duration of those works.

2.2 OOHW which requires justification and approval For all other OOHW, aside for the emergency works specified in Section 2.1, the Contractor is required to provide Roads and Maritime with justification for the need for the works and obtain approval prior to undertaking the works.

Construction work associated with the project will be carried out in accordance with the assessment and management approach outlined in the Interim Construction Noise Guideline (ICNG) and Construction Noise and Vibration Guideline (Roads and Maritime, 2016) (CNVG). The ICNG outlines recommended standard construction hours and requires that work outside of these hours must be appropriately justified. In general, OOHW undertaken on appropriately assessed and approved public infrastructure projects such as road construction are considered justified in the ICNG.

Examples of OOHW that may be considered for approval under this OOHW protocol (or an EPL) include, but are not limited to:

• works required to maintain the structural and functional integrity of existing and new road infrastructure proposed as part of the project

• works required to maintain the safety of road users, construction personnel and the general public

• works where a road occupancy license will not be provided during standard times • where works have been agreed with affected sensitive receivers

7 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 14: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

• where a utility service operator has advised that the works undertaken during standard hours will result in a high risk to the operation or integrity of the network.

Construction activities that may require scheduled OOHW may include, but are not limited to: • bridgeworks • paving works • asphalting • concrete pours • ancillary facility operation • traffic management, traffic switches or road tie-in work • utility/service relocations • geotechnical investigations.

The following circumstances will also require approval under this OOHW protocol:

• OOHW that causes no more than 5 db(A) above the rating background level at any

residence in accordance with the Interim Construction Noise Guideline (DECC, 2009), and

• OOHW that causes no more than the ‘Noise affected’ noise management levels specified in Table 3 of the Interim Construction Noise Guideline (DECC, 2009) at other sensitive land uses, and

• OOHW that causes continuous or impulsive vibration values, measured at the most affected residence are no more than the maximum values for human exposure to vibration, specified in Table 2.2 of Assessing Vibration: a technical guideline (DEC, 2006), and

• OOHW that causes intermittent vibration values measured at the most affected residence are no more than the maximum values for human exposure to vibration, specified in Table 2.4 of Assessing Vibration: a technical guideline (DEC, 2006).

2.3 Process for obtaining approval for OOHW OOHW that require justification and approval will be assessed in accordance with the process outlined below:

1) a schedule of proposed OOHW will be submitted to Roads and Maritime by the Contractor each month and at least three months in advance of the proposed OOHW

2) an OOHW approval request form (refer Attachment 1) for each specific OOHW event will be submitted to Roads and Maritime by the Contractor. The form will be provided to the Roads and Maritime Environmental Manager (or delegate) at least 25 working days prior to the works commencing

3) the Roads and Maritime Environmental Manager (or delegate) will consider the request and determine if the works are justified. Predicted noise impacts will be confirmed as Low or High risk and appropriate mitigation measures (including community consultation) will be agreed

8 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 15: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

4) Roads and Maritime determination for approval of the request for OOHW will follow the process outlined in Section 5, including:

• Roads and Maritime endorsement • Roads and Maritime seeking approval from the ER (for low risk activities) or • Roads and Maritime seeking approval from the Planning Secretary (for any other

activity)

5) community consultation and notification will be undertaken as outlined in Section 6

9 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 16: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

3 OOHW noise and vibration assessment As part of the approval process for OOHW the Contractor will complete a noise and (if applicable) vibration assessment to assess the noise and vibration impacts for any OOHW activities. The assessment will include details of the work to be undertaken, plant and equipment required, scheduling and duration of the work, predicted impacts on potentially affected sensitive receivers, location of potentially affected receivers and proposed mitigation measures.

3.1 Risk based approach A risk based approach will be adopted to determine whether OOHW are considered to be low risk or high risk works. The risk factors in determining low and high risk works are outlined in Table 3-1 and are generally in accordance with the CNVG (Roads and Maritime, 2016).

Table 3-1: OOHW risk factors

Low risk factors: High risk factors:

• no sleep disturbance • less than 5dBALeq(15minutes) above

the Rating Background Level (RBL)

• one or two occurrences • no impulsive or tonal noise

vibration

• Prolonged work (i.e. >1 week) • Sleep disturbance possible • Impulsive noise and vibration likely

(e.g. vibratory rolling or rock breaking) • More than 5dBALeq(15minutes) above the

RBL

The approval process for proposed OOHW will be determined on a risk-based approach on a case-by-case basis to ensure that OOHW are approved by the appropriate delegate (ER or Planning Secretary) in accordance with CoA E31(d).

Low risk activities include work that is less than 5dBALeq(15minutes) above the RBL during any period, with no sleep disturbance potential and occurring for no longer than six weeks in the same Noise Catchment Area (NCA). OOHW with low risk factors may be approved by the ER.

High risk activities include OOHW that is more than 5dBALeq(15minutes) above the RBL with high impact noise, or for longer durations, where sensitive receivers will be affected by construction noise. OOHW with high risk factors will be approved by the Planning Secretary. Where the proposed OOHW includes high risk factors, the OOHW approval request form must be supported by a quantitative construction noise and vibration impact statement.

3.2 Noise assessment The Contractor will carry out a noise assessment using appropriately detailed noise prediction tools to predict the noise impacts of the proposed OOHW. The assessment will predict the extent of noise impact the construction activities will have on potentially affected sensitive receivers based on inputs of the location and types of construction machinery operating inside a NCA.

10 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 17: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

Project specific construction noise criteria (noise management levels, NML) and sleep disturbance criteria have been calculated for each NCA within the RP2J project area and are summarised in Table 3-2. Construction noise management level criteria for non-residential, commercial and industrial receivers are contained in Table 3-3. NMLs have been established based on the ICNG.

Quantitative noise assessments conducted by the Contractor for all OOHW will predict the potential exceedances of the OOHW scenario against the relevant NMLs and sleep disturbance screening criteria identified for the potentially affected sensitive receivers. The assessment will include, but not be limited to:

• details of the nature and scope of each activity and work, including details of times, vehicles, plant and equipment to be used

• detailed analysis to justify the scheduling and duration of each activity and work outside the standard construction hours, including taking into account the predicted impact on noise sensitive receivers and the preference that high noise impact works be undertaken during the day

• detailed analysis to justify use of the selected construction and work methods, plant and equipment compared to alternatives taking into consideration noise and vibration impacts

• for each activity and work in each noise catchment:

- the addresses of the most affected noise sensitive receivers

- the background noise level for each of the noise sensitive receivers

- NMLs

- the predicted LAeq (15 min) noise level, incorporating any 5 dB correction for particularly annoying activities as listed in the ICNG

- assessment of sleep disturbance where works are planned to extend over more than two consecutive nights.

• noise mitigation measures to be adopted including respite periods proposed to be adopted to minimise noise and vibration impacts on surrounding noise sensitive receivers in each locality (refer Section 4).

11 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 18: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

Table 3-2: Construction noise management levels for the RP2J project for residential receivers

NCA Adopted background noise RBL LA90 NML (LRAeq(15min)R (dBA) Standard working hours Out of standard hours

Day Evening Night Noise affected level Highly affected noise level

Day1 Evening2 Night3

1 45 39 33 55 75 50 44 38

2 49 43 35 59 75 54 48 40

3 37 37 30 47 75 42 42 35

4 47 46 36 57 75 52 51 41

5 55 51 41 65 75 60 56 46

6 33 35 29 43 75 38 40 34

7 39 36 34 49 75 44 41 39

8 52 48 33 62 75 57 53 38

9 34 32 25 44 75 39 37 30

10 38 35 26 48 75 43 30 31

11 50 42 33 60 75 55 47 38

12 36 36 27 46 75 41 41 32

13 56 49 33 66 75 61 54 38

14 38 37 35 48 75 43 42 40

1 OOHW Day = 7 am to 8 am and 5 pm to 6 pm Saturday, 8 am to 6 pm Sunday and public holidays 2 OOHW Evening = 6 pm to 10 pm, Monday to Sunday and public holidays 3 OOHW Night = 10 pm to 7 am, Monday to Saturday; 10 pm to 8 am Sunday and public holidays Additional notes: The ICNG Sleep disturbance screening criteria is that LAmax (dBA) should not exceed the ambient LA90(15min) noise level by more than 15 dB(A) The source of Table 3-2 information is from Table 4-5 of the RP2J project Submissions and Preferred Infrastructure Report.

12 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 19: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

Table 3-3: Construction noise management levels for non-residential, commercial and industrial receivers for the RP2J project

Land use NML LRAeq(15 minute)R dB(A)*

Places of worship 45 (Internal)

Classrooms at schools and other educational institutions 45 (Internal)

Hospital wards and operating theatres 45 (Internal)

Active recreation areas 65 (External)

Passive recreation areas 60 (External)

Industrial premises 75 (External)

Commercial premises 70 (External)

* When in use

3.3 Vibration assessment An assessment of vibration intensive activities that may impact sensitive receivers or structures will be required for out of hours vibration intensive works. The proposed OOHW activities will be assessed for compliance with safe working distances for:

• cosmetic and/or structural impacts (including safe working distances)

• human comfort impacts due to vibration and ground borne noise

Assessment will be undertaken in accordance with the safe working distance guide in Table 3-4. The safe working distances presented in Table 3-4 are indicative and will vary depending on the item of plant (particularly its power rating) and local geotechnical conditions.

Table 3-4: Vibration estimated safe working buffer distances (m)

Activity Human comfort BS 5228-2 criteria 1

(1.0 mm/s)

Structural damage

Heritage structure DIN 4150-3 criteria

(3.0 mm/s)

Standard dwellings DIN 4150-3 criteria

(5.0 mm/s)

Roller 90 24 13

15 tonne vibratory roller 140 35 18

Loader breaking kerbs 120 30 16

7 tonne compactor 90 24 13

Pavement Breaker 90 24 13

Dozer 60 15 8

Backhoe 10 3 2

Jackhammer 4 2 1

Excavator 25 7 4

13 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 20: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

Activity Human comfort BS 5228-2

Structural damage

Piling (bored/CFA) 120 35 17

Notes: 1 Based on levels derived from BS5228-2. Bored piling through stones or other obstruction. 2 As stated in the RTA’s Environmental Noise Management Manual, it can be assumed that the vibration level

is inversely proportional to distance. Field variations show that the distance relationship generally varies between d-0.8 and d-1.6, rather than d-1. For prediction of approximate safe working distance for sensitive equipment the mid-value of d-1.2 has been used as a guide.

Where the works are located close to or within the safe working distances, the OOHW vibration assessment will include an assessment against:

• the human comfort (vibration dose values criteria) detailed in Table 3-5

• the structural damage criteria detailed in Table 3-6.

Prior to undertaking an assessment, all other feasible and reasonable options to use less vibration intensive equipment will be investigated and exhausted.

Table 3-5: Acceptable intermittent vibration dose values (m/sP

1.7PP

5P)

Location DaytimeP

1 Night-timeP

1

Preferred Value

Maximum Value

Preferred Value

Maximum Value

Critical areas P

2 0.10 0.20 0.10 0.02

Residences 0.20 0.40 0.13 0.26

Offices, schools, educational institutions and places of worship

0.40 0.80 0.40 0.80

Workshops 0.80 1.60 0.80 1.60

Notes: P

1P Daytime is 7.00am to 10.00pm and night-time is 10.00pm to 7.00am

P

2P Includes operating theatres, precision laboratories and other areas where vibration sensitive activities

may occur.

Table 3-6: BS 7385 structural damage criteria

Group Type of structure Damage level

Peak component particle velocityP

1P (mm/s)

4 – 15 Hz 15 – 40Hz ≥40Hz

1

Reinforced or framed structures Industrial and heavy commercial buildings

Cosmetic 50 50 50

Minor P

2 100 100 100

Major P

2 200 200 200

2

Un-reinforced or light framed structures Residential or light commercial type buildings

Cosmetic 15 - 20 20 - 50 50

Minor P

2 30 - 40 40 - 100 100

Major P

2 60 - 80 80 - 200 200

Notes:

14 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 21: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

P

1 PPeak Component Particle Velocity is the maximum Peak particle velocity in any one direction (x, y, z) as measured by a tri-axial vibration transducer.

P

2P Minor and major damage criteria established based on BS 7385 Part 2 (1993) Section 7.4.2

15 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 22: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

4 Mitigation measures

4.1 Criteria for implementation of mitigation measures As required by CoA E34, mitigation measures will be implemented with the aim of achieving the following construction NMLs and vibration criteria:

• the construction ‘Noise affected’ NMLs established using the ICNG and detailed i Table 3-2 and Table 3-3 of this Protocol

• for human exposure, the acceptable vibration values set out in Assessing Vibration: A Technical Guideline (DEC, 2006)

• for structural damage to heritage structures, the vibration limits set out in the German Standard DIN 4150-3: Structural Vibration - effects of vibration on structures

• for damage to other buildings and/or structures, the vibration limits set out in the British Standard BS 7385-1:1990 - Evaluation and measurement for vibration in buildings - Guide for measurement of vibration and evaluation of their effects on buildings) and BS 7385 Part 2-1993 “Evaluation and measurement for vibration in buildings Part 2” as they are “applicable to Australian conditions”.

4.2 Ground-borne noise Ground-borne noise is noise generated by vibration transmitted through the ground into a structure. In accordance with CoA E35, mitigation measures will be applied when the following residential ground-borne noise levels are exceeded:

• evening (6:00 pm to 10:00 pm) - internal LAeq(15 minute): 40 db(A)

• night (10:00 pm to 7:00 am) - internal LAeq(15 minute): 35 dB(A).

4.3 Noise and vibration mitigation measures Prior to undertaking any OOHW, the Contractor will identify appropriate standard mitigation measures. Additional mitigations measures will be implemented where reasonable and feasible and will relate directly to the risk factor of the proposed OOHW.

Attachment 2 to this OOHW Protocol outlines the approach for the determination of standard and additional mitigation measures to minimise impacts of OOHW.

Standard and additional mitigation measures for OOHW are detailed in Sections 4.4 and 4.5 below and are also outlined in the SPB NVMP and Stage 1 and Stage 3 EWMS.

4.4 Standard mitigation measures Standard mitigation measures (as per Attachment 2) that will be implemented include, but are not limited to:

• Modifying behavioural practices on site

16 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 23: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

• Equipment selection / maintaining and monitoring plant

• Use and siting of plant and hoardings

• Site inductions

• Use of non-tonal reversing alarms

• Stakeholder notification

• Planning noisier work to be carried out earlier in the period.

4.4.1 Standard notification for OOHW

A schedule of likely out-of-hours work for a period of no less than three months in advance will be issued to all potentially affected sensitive receivers.

Specific notifications of OOHW will be issued to potentially affected sensitive receivers at least five days, and not more than 14 working days, prior to the OOHW commencing. The notification will include:

• potential work, location and duration

• proposed respite periods

• noise characteristics and likely noise and vibration levels

• likely mitigation and management measures

• the name and contact telephone number of the Contractor’s representative to enable potentially affected sensitive receivers to lodge any concerns about extended working hours.

OOHW notifications will be prepared in accordance with the CNVG (Roads and Maritime, 2016). Section 6.1.2 provides further details on notification.

4.5 Additional mitigation measures Where construction noise and vibration levels are still predicted to exceed the noise or vibration objectives after the application of the standard mitigation measures, additional mitigation measures will be implemented by the Contractor. Attachment 2 outlines the approach for the application of additional mitigation measures to minimise impacts of OOHW.

Noise generating work in the vicinity of sensitive receivers and landuses (including community, religious, educational institutions and noise and vibration-sensitive businesses, medical facilities, and the John Hunter Hospital) resulting in noise levels above the NMLs at critical working areas (such as operating theatres and precision laboratories) will not be timetabled within sensitive periods, unless other reasonable arrangements with the affected receivers are made at no cost to the affected receivers.

Additional mitigation measures that may be implemented include, but are not limited to:

• Stakeholder notifications

• Phone calls

• Individual briefing

17 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 24: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

• Respite offers

• Respite periods

• Duration respite

• Alternative accommodation.

Further details of the range of possible additional mitigation measures are provided below.

4.5.1 Stakeholder notifications

Additional notifications will be carried out to provide further detail on the OOHW for sensitive receivers.

4.5.2 Phone calls

Phone calls to potentially affected sensitive receivers detailing relevant information will be made within five working days of the proposed OOHW. Phone calls provide potentially affected sensitive receivers with personalised contact and tailored advice, with the opportunity to provide comments on the proposed OOHW and specific needs. The responses of sensitive receivers will be addressed to ensure an optimum outcome is achieved regarding mitigation of OOHW impacts. Where the resident cannot be telephoned then an alternative form of engagement will be used.

4.5.3 Individual briefings

Where required, individual briefings will be used to consult potentially affected sensitive receivers about the impacts of OOHW and mitigation measures that will be implemented. Where requied, the Contractor’s Community Liaison Representative will visit potentially affected sensitive receivers at least 48 hours ahead of the proposed OOHW. Individual briefings provide potentially affected sensitive receivers with personalised contact and tailored advice. Contact with sensitive receivers will be documented and concerns addressed where feasible and practicable.

Where there are many sensitive receivers predicted to be above the NML and it is not practical to discuss the proposed OOHW with every resident, or the resident cannot be met with individually, then an alternative form of engagement will be used.

4.5.4 Respite Offers

Respite Offers will be considered where there are high noise and vibration generating activities near affected sensitive receivers to provide residents with respite from an ongoing impact. As suggested in the CNVG (Roads and Maritime, 2016), work will be carried out in continuous blocks that do not exceed 3 hours each, with a minimum respite period of one hour between each block. The actual duration of each block of work and respite will be flexible to accommodate the usage of and amenity at nearby receivers. The purpose is to provide residents with respite from an ongoing impact. This measure will be evaluated on a an event-by-event basis, and may not be applicable to all OOHW events.

4.5.5 Respite Periods

In accordance with CoA E29, in order to undertake OOHW the Contractor will identify appropriate respite periods for the OOHW in consultation with the community at each

18 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 25: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

affected location. Scheduled respite periods determined in consultation with potentially affected sensitive receivers will be implemented to mitigate the impacts of ongoing periods of noise criteria exceedances at nearby receivers. Where reasonable and feasible, proposed OOHW will be coordinated to avoid the same sensitive receiver being affected over consecutive nights and OOHW will be staggered in order to maximise the respite period between OOHW. The Contractor will modify the scheduled construction activities to accommodate respite periods where necessary.

Consultation with sensitive receivers affected by OOHW will occur on a monthly basis. Consultation will include (but not be limited to) providing the potentially affected sensitive receivers with:

• potential work, location and duration

• proposed respite periods

• noise characteristics and likely noise and vibration levels

• likely mitigation and management measures

• the process for how complaints may be made and additional information obtained

• the 24 hour phone number for complaints and the project website address.

The RP2J CCS details a suite of communication tools and activities to be used to consult with affected sensitive receivers. The Contractor will proactively engage with affected sensitive receivers via appropriate methods as outlined in the RP2J CCS and the Contractor’s Construction Community Liaison Plan (CCLP), including door knocking, one on one or small group meetings, letterbox drop, email and phone calls, to discuss preferences for the proposed respite periods. All responses will be documented and recorded. Respite periods will be determined based on the outcomes of the consultation, with consideration of the majority view of those consulted. The outcomes of the community consultation, the identified respite periods and the scheduling of likely OOHW will be provided to the ER, EPA and the Planning Secretary.

Respite periods will be flexible and determined on a case-by-case basis, taking into account predicted maximum exceedance levels, duration and timing of exceedances, surrounding land uses and community feedback. Indicative respite periods for OOHW, to be discussed during consultation required under CoA E29, are provided in the CNVG and outlined in Table 4-1.

Table 4-1: Indicative out of hours respite periods

OOHW Period 1 Monday–Friday: 6 pm – 10 pm Saturday: 7 am - 8 am & 5 pm – 10 pm Sunday and Public Hol: 8 am – 6 pm

• Construction noise will be limited to no more than three consecutive evenings per week except where there is a Duration Respite. For night work these periods of work should be separated by not less than one week and no more than six evenings per month.

19 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 26: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

OOHW Period 2 Monday– Friday 10 pm – 7 am Saturday: 10 pm - 8 am Sunday and Public Hol. 6 pm – 7 am

• Night time construction noise will be limited to two consecutive nights except for where there is a Duration Respite. For night work these periods of work will be separated by not less than one week and six nights per month. Where possible, high noise generating works will be completed before 11 pm.

4.5.6 Duration Respite

Respite Offers and Respite Periods 1 and 2 may be counterproductive in reducing the impact on the community for longer duration activities. In this instance and where it can be strongly justified it may be beneficial to increase the work duration, number of evenings or nights worked through Duration Respite so that construction can be completed more quickly.

The Contractor’s Community Liaison Representative will engage with the community where noise levels are expected to exceed the NML to demonstrate support for Duration Respite. Consultation will be undertaken in accordance with the RP2J CCS.

Where there are few receivers above the NML each of these receivers will be visited to gain support for Duration Respite.

4.5.7 Utility coordination and respite

As required by CoA E32, all OOH utility works carried out for the project, (including those undertaken by third parties), will be coordinated to ensure respite periods are provided at noise affected locations, in accordance with the additional mitigation measures outlined in Attachment 2 and the CNVG. The Contractor will:

• schedule any works to provide respite to impacted noise sensitive receivers so that respite is achieved

• consider the provision of alternative respite or mitigation to impacted noise sensitive receivers

• provide documentary evidence to the ER in support of any decision made by Roads and Maritime or its Contractors in relation to respite or mitigation.

4.5.8 Alternative accommodation

Alternative accommodation options may be offered to residents living in close proximity to construction works who that are likely to experience highly intrusive noise levels. Aspects for consideration include whether the highly intrusive activities occur throughout the night or before midnight.

20 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 27: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

5 Approval of OOHW As discussed in Section 2.3, when OOHW have been identified as being required, the Contractor will seek approval from Roads and Maritime for the proposed OOHW by submitting an OOHW approval request form provided at Attachment 1 of this OOHW Protocol.

The Contractor will provide Roads and Maritime with sufficient information to assess the likely impacts on potentially affected sensitive receivers of the proposed OOHW (Section 3 of this Protocol) and specify the proposed mitigation measures (Section 4) as well as provide evidence of the consultation undertaken (Section 6).

Unless otherwise agreed, the OOHW approval request form will be completed by the Contractor and submitted to Roads and Maritime at least 25 working days prior to every OOHW event for review by the Environmental Manager (or delegate) and endorsement by the Roads and Maritime Project Manager. The Roads and Maritime Environmental Manager (or delegate) will review the level of risk associated with the activity, the predicted impacts and management measures to be implemented. The review will also consider if the community's interests have been addressed as much as is reasonable (including appropriate consideration and implementation of additional mitigation measures, such as respite). The Roads and Maritime Environmental Manager (or delegate) may add comments and/or conditions that need to be complied with for the proposed OOHW.

Following endorsement by Roads and Maritime, the ER shall consider a low risk approval request and provide comment or where suitable, approve the request for low risk activities. Where the proposed OOHW are considered to be high risk, the OOHW approval request form and supporting information will be issued to the Planning Secretary at least 28 prior days for review and where suitable, approval. Roads and Maritime will coordinate the process for seeking approval from the Planning Secretary.

The Contractor will not commence any OOHW until the written agreement of Roads and Maritime has been received subsequent to the ER or Planning Secretary (as applicable) approval of the OOHW request application.

Following approval for the OOHW, any standard and additional mitigation measures required for the OOHW will be:

• implemented prior to works (such as specific conditions that relate to the community)

• toolboxed to relevant site personnel before each shift to ensure awareness of work restrictions, management measures and expected behaviour

• implemented and monitored during the OOHW to ensure the mitigation measures are appropriate and to confirm or validate noise and vibration predictions.

5.1 Coordination with other OOHW approved by an EPL As part of the approval process, Roads and Maritime will consider any other OOHW that has been approved for the project. Roads and Maritime will also consider other OOHW permitted by the project EPL that may be occurring at the same time as the proposed OOHW. Roads and Maritime will ensure that cumulative noise impacts are minimised and appropriate respite is provided at potentially affected sensitive receivers.

21 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 28: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

6 Consultation and notification 6.1.1 Community consultation

Prior to undertaking OOHW, the Contractor will consult with, as appropriate:

• potentially affected sensitive receivers

• Roads and Maritime Project Manager

• Roads and Maritime Environmental Manager (or delegate)

• Newcastle City Council (as applicable)

• the ER.

As required by the RP2J CCS and CoA E29, consultation with the community at each location affected by OOHW will occur on a monthly basis in accordance with CoA E29 and as outlined in Section 4.3.5. The consultation will include, but not be limited to:

• providing a schedule of likely OOHW for a period of no less than three months in advance

• explaining potential work, location and duration

• discussing noise characteristics and likely noise and vibration levels

• discussing likely mitigation and management measures

The Contractor will provide the Roads and Maritime Project Manager and Roads and Maritime Environmental Manager (or delegate) evidence of the consultation undertaken for the OOHW. The outcomes of the community consultation, the identified respite periods and the scheduling of likely OOHW will be included in the assessment and mitigations as part of the OOHW application and provided to the ER and the Planning Secretary by Roads and Maritime with the application.

6.1.2 Community notification

Community notifications will be used as a mitigation measure for receivers of noise and vibration impacts from OOHW.

Where OOHW have been scheduled, the Contractor’s Community Liaison Representative will notify the potentially affected noise sensitive receivers of upcoming OOHW.

Specific notifications of OOHW events will be issued to potentially affected sensitive receivers at least five days, and not more than 14 working days, prior to the OOHW commencing.

OOHW notifications will be prepared in accordance with the CNVG (Roads and Maritime, 2016). The notifications will:

• be undertaken by letterbox drop or email

• be detailed on the project website

• clearly outline the reason that the work is required to be undertaken outside standard construction hours specified

22 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 29: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

• include a diagram that clearly identifies the location of the proposed works in relation to nearby cross streets and local landmarks

• include details of relevant time restrictions that apply to the proposed works

• clearly outline in plain English, the location, nature, scope and duration of the proposed works

• detail the expected noise impact of the works on potentially affected noise sensitive receivers

• detail the likely mitigation and management measures and proposed respite periods

• clearly state how complaints may be made and additional information obtained and

• include the number of the 24 hour telephone complaints line and the RPJ2 project website address.

In accordance with CoA E36, the Contractor’s Community Liaison Representative will notify the landowners and occupiers of properties at risk of exceeding the screening criteria for cosmetic damage prior to OOHW that generate vibration commencing near those properties. If the potential exceedance is to occur more than once or extend over a period of 24 hours, the Contractor will provide the landowners and occupiers a schedule of potential exceedances on a monthly basis for the duration of the potential exceedances, unless otherwise agreed by the landowner and occupier.

23 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 30: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

7 Monitoring and auditing

7.1 Monitoring for OOHW The Contractor’s Environmental Site Representative will ensure the following noise and vibration monitoring is undertaken for all high risk OOHW or after OOHW noise complaints are received:

• attended noise monitoring at representative sensitive receivers

• attended vibration monitoring at representative sensitive receivers

• additional noise and vibration monitoring and review if complaints about the activity are received.

All OOHW monitoring will be carried out by an appropriately trained person in the measurement and assessment of construction noise and vibration.

7.2 Complaints management Complaints received as a result of the OOHW will be managed in accordance with the RP2J project Complaints Management System (CMS) and the Contractor’s CCLP. On receipt of any complaints, the Contractor will carry out an investigation and where feasible and reasonable, make changes to the works to address the issue of concern. Where relevant to the detail of the complaint, monitoring will be undertaken to confirm compliance with the noise levels identified in CoA E27 and predicted vibration levels.

7.3 Exceedances / non-conformances Where monitoring identifies any exceedances of the levels predicted in the OOHW assessments, a review of OOHW activities will be carried out to determine whether noise or vibration levels can be further reduced via additional feasible and reasonable measures.

7.4 Records The Contractor will maintain accurate records of all OOHW applications and noise and vibration monitoring undertaken during OOHW for the duration of the works.

24 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 31: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

Attachment 1 - OOHW approval request form

Out of hours work approval request form

No: Notification date:

Approval date: Project:

A. Contact details Name Mobile number Email

Contractor Environmental Site Representative

Contractor Construction Manager

Contractor Foreman

Contractor Project Engineer

B. Details of work: Include a map showing location of work extent and nearest sensitive receivers

Location (Chainage):

NCA/s:

Description of works:

Machinery/ plant to be used

Traffic control measures required:

Lighting required:

Proposed dates:

Proposed timings:

25 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 32: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

Out of hours work approval request form

Justification - why does work need to occur outside of standard construction hours?: (attach support information as required)

C. Risk assessment NML (refer Table 3-2 of OOHW protocol)

Is the work highly noise intensive? (above 75dB(A) LAeq

(15 minute))

Risk factor category (low or high):

Low High Comments

D. Details of noise or vibration assessment completed:

Comments:

E. Proposed Mitigation Measures

F. Community Consultation carried out including details of community feedback and how this has been addressed

G. Respite framework – dates of previous respite periods, OOHW period 1 or 2, community agreements etc

26 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 33: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

Out of hours work approval request form

H. Details of non-residential receivers (if any) and corresponding NMLs

I. Are there any properties at risk of exceeding the screening criteria for cosmetic damage?

E. Review/ Endorsements

Contractor Community Liaison Representative

Community notified Date:

Additional consultation requirements:

Have the works been reviewed and endorsed? Yes / No

Name: Signature: Date:

Comments:

Roads and Maritime Environmental Manager (or delegate)

Agreed mitigation measures:

Have the works been reviewed and endorsed? Yes / No

Name: Signature: Date:

Comments:

Roads and Maritime Project Manager

Have the works been reviewed and endorsed? Yes / No

Name: Signature: Date:

Comments:

ER approval (low risk activities)

Are the works approved? Yes / No

Name: Signature: Date:

Comments:

27 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 34: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

Out of hours work approval request form

Planning Secretary approval (high risk activities)

Are the works approved? Yes / No

Name: Signature: Date:

Comments:

28 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 35: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

Attachment 2 – Application of OOHW mitigation measures

OOHW period dB(A) Mitigation measures

OOHW period 1

Monday–Friday: 6 pm – 10 pm Saturday: 7 am - 8 am and 5 pm – 10 pm Sunday and Public Hol.: 8 am – 6 pm

0-5 dB(A) above NML

Standard mitigation measures:

• Behavioural practices on site • Equipment selection / maintaining and

monitoring plant • Use and siting of plant and hoardings • Site inductions • Use of non-tonal reversing alarms • Notification • Planning noisier work to be carried out earlier

in the period

5-15 dB(A) above NML

Standard mitigation measures: • Standard measures as above.

Additional mitigation measures: • Notification • Respite offer period 1 • Duration respite

15-25 dB(A) above NML

Standard mitigation measures:

• Standard measures as above

Additional mitigation measures: • Notification • Verification • Respite offer period 1 • Duration respite

>25 d(B)A above NML

Standard mitigation measures:

• Standard measures as above.

Additional mitigation measures: • Notification • Verification • Individual briefing • Respite offer period 1 • Duration respite • Phone calls • Specific notifications

29 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 36: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

OOHW period dB(A) Mitigation measures

OOHW period 2

Monday– Friday: 10 pm – 7 am Saturday: 10 pm - 8 am Sunday and Public Hol. 6 pm – 7 am

0-5 dB(A) above NML

Standard mitigation measures: • Behavioural practices on site • Equipment selection / maintaining and

monitoring plant • Use and siting of plant and hoardings • Site inductions • Use of non-tonal reversing alarms • Notification • Planning noisier work to be carried out earlier

in the period

5-15 dB(A) above NML

Standard mitigation measures: • Standard measures as above.

Additional mitigation measures: • Notification • Verification • Respite offer period 2 • Duration respite

15-25 dB(A) above NML

Standard mitigation measures: • Standard measures as above

Additional mitigation measures: • Notification • Verification • Individual briefing • Respite offer period 2 • Duration respite • Phone calls • Specific notifications

>25 d(B)A above NML

Standard mitigation measures: • Standard measures as above.

Additional mitigation measures: • Notification • Verification • Individual briefing • Respite offer period 2 • Duration respite • Phone calls • Specific notifications • Alternative accommodation

30 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 37: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

Table of hours (standard, OOH, Highly affected noise hours, respite periods) Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sunday

1 AM 1 AM 1 AM 1 AM 1 AM 1 AM 1 AM

2 AM 2 AM 2 AM 2 AM 2 AM 2 AM 2 AM

3 AM 3 AM 3 AM 3 AM 3 AM 3 AM 3 AM

4 AM 4 AM 4 AM 4 AM 4 AM 4 AM 4 AM

5 AM 5 AM 5 AM 5 AM 5 AM 5 AM 5 AM

6 AM 6 AM 6 AM 6 AM 6 AM 6 AM 6 AM

7 AM 7 AM 7 AM 7 AM 7 AM 7 AM 7 AM

8 AM 8 AM 8 AM 8 AM 8 AM 8 AM 8 AM

9 AM 9 AM 9 AM 9 AM 9 AM 9 AM 9 AM

10 AM 10 AM 10 AM 10 AM 10 AM 10 AM 10 AM

11 AM 11 AM 11 AM 11 AM 11 AM 11 AM 11 AM

12 PM 12 PM 12 PM 12 PM 12 PM 12 PM 12 PM

1 PM 1 PM 1 PM 1 PM 1 PM 1 PM 1 PM

2 PM 2 PM 2 PM 2 PM 2 PM 2 PM 2 PM

3 PM 3 PM 3 PM 3 PM 3 PM 3 PM 3 PM

4 PM 4 PM 4 PM 4 PM 4 PM 4 PM 4 PM

5 PM 5 PM 5 PM 5 PM 5 PM 5 PM 5 PM

6 PM 6 PM 6 PM 6 PM 6 PM 6 PM 6 PM

7 PM 7 PM 7 PM 7 PM 7 PM 7 PM 7 PM

8 PM 8 PM 8 PM 8 PM 8 PM 8 PM 8 PM

9 PM 9 PM 9 PM 9 PM 9 PM 9 PM 9 PM

10 PM 10 PM 10 PM 10 PM 10 PM 10 PM 10 PM

11 PM 11 PM 11 PM 11 PM 11 PM 11 PM 11 PM

12 AM 12 AM 12 AM 12 AM 12 AM 12 AM 12 AM

Legend Standard hours (CoA E26) Monday to Friday 7 am to 6 pm

Saturday 8 am to 5 pm Highly affected noise hours (CoA E30) Monday to Friday 8 am to 6 pm

Saturday 8 am to 1 pm OOHW Day Saturday 7 am to 8 am and 5 pm to 6 pm

Sundays and public holidays 8 am to 6 pm OOHW Evening Monday to Sunday and public holidays 6 pm to 10 pm OOHW Night

Monday to Saturday 10 pm to 7 am

Sundays and public holidays 10 pm to 8 am Respite Periods OOHW period 1 Monday to Friday 6 pm – 10 pm Saturday 7 am - 8 am and 5 pm – 10 pm

31 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED

Page 38: Out of Hours Work Protocol – Works not subject to an EPL · 2020-02-13 · (d) work approved under an Out-of-Hours Work Protocol or an Out of Hours Work Management Process or equivalent

Sunday and public holidays 8 am – 6 pm OOHW period 2 Monday to Friday 10 pm – 7 am Saturday 10 pm (Sat) - 8 am (Sun)

Sunday and public holidays 6 pm (Sun) – 7 am (Mon)

32 | Newcastle Inner City Bypass – Rankin Park to Jesmond OOHW Protocol November 2019 Rev 4 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED


Recommended