Date post: | 21-Jan-2018 |
Category: |
Health & Medicine |
Upload: | onsanity-solutions-sl |
View: | 47 times |
Download: | 0 times |
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com
Josep Mª Monguet
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Crowdfunding
Co-creation
Social netsMOOC’s
e-Democracy
Do it yourself
Collaborative
design
CrowdsourcingCollaborative
economy
Shared
knowledge
Prediction market
Livinglabs
Collective
action
Collective data
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Management
Design
CommunicationEducation
Politics
Crowdfunding
Co-creation
Social netsMOOC’s
e-Democracy
TechnologyDo it yourself
Collaborative
design
CrowdsourcingCollaborative
economy
Shared
knowledge
Prediction market
Livinglabs
Collective
action
Collective data
New drivers of…
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Management
Design
Education
Crowdfunding
Co-creation
Social netsMOOC’s
e-Democracy
TechnologyDo it yourself
Participation Collaborative
design
CrowdsourcingCollaborative
economy
Shared
knowledge
Prediction market
Livinglabs
Collective
action
Collective data
Communication
Politics
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
New mental framework
+ Participation+ Efficiency
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
0
20,000
40,000
60,000
80,000
100,000
1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020
“Co-creation” GS
0
10,000
20,000
30,000
40,000
50,000
1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020
"Collective Intelligence" GS
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020
“Health participation” GS
Domains of Participation
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Participation
Marginality
Heath domain
Professional Patient
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Participation
Marginality
It’s becoming a citizens right
New scale for the involvement in everyday personal lifeComplex & multidimensional
Professional Patient
Heath domain
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Participation
Marginality
Professional Patient
Involvement in:- Decision making- Control of personal health
Innovation in - Professional practice - Service delivery
Heath domain
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Participation
Marginality
Professional Patient
Involvement in:- Decision making- Control of personal health
Innovation in - Professional practice - Service delivery
Coproduction of services
Collaboration
Heath domain
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Collaboration
Coproduction of services
Participation
Less dependencyMore results
Marginality
Involvement in:- Decision making- Control of personal health
Innovation in - Professional practice - Service delivery
Professional Patient
Heath domain
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Collaboration
Coproduction of services
Participation
Involvement in the health system designFeeling of belonging and sense
Marginality
Involvement in:- Decision making- Control of personal health
Innovation in - Professional practice - Service delivery
Professional Patient Less dependency
More results
Heath domain
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Consensus
Diversity
Co-creation
Decision making
Prediction
Co-learning
Participation
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
CulturesWhich areas &sensitivities
covers the group?
ActivitiesWhich tools has the group to
perform as a group?Relationships
Which is the learning capacity of the group?
Building a collective intelligence environment
Participation
Consensus
DiversityCo-learning
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
SharingWhat’s going to happen?
ReasoningWhich one is the priority?
Acting How can we
work together?
Applying “participation engineering”
Participation
Co-creation
Decision making
Prediction
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
ActivitiesWhich tools has the group to
perform as a group?
Building a collective intelligence environment
Participation
Consensus
DiversityCo-learning
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
If the arithmetic mean was one of the
participants, it would always win.
Consensus
Value of the group
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Condorcet’s jury theoremConsensus
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
The audience joker ¡Consensus
90 % of the times the
guess of the audience
is correct
Slumdog millionaire, 2006
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Delphi methodConsensus
RAND Corp. 1959Olaf Helmer, Norman Dalkey & Nicholas Rescher.
We will share an
scenario of how the
third world war would
be…
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Delphi methodConsensus
Capture experts opinion probability & intensity of enemy attacks.
Other experts anonymously giving feedback.
Process was repeated several times (Rounds) until a consensus emerged.
RAND Corp. 1959Olaf Helmer, Norman Dalkey & Nicholas Rescher.
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Case/ Spine Surgery Aggressiveness Score
European Spine Study Group
Consensus
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Consensus
Modifying factorsRevision surgeryImplant density Location (lumbar/thoracic)Surgeon experience
Surgical actionsSegment fusionDecompressionPosterior interbody fusionSPO (schwab type 2)PSO (schwab 3 and 4)VCR (schwab 5 and 6)Pelvic fixation Cement augmentation
Case/ Spine Surgery Aggressiveness Score
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Consensus
21.8
Actionsn of fused segments: 6n Decompressed segments: 0Pelvic fixation: no (0)…
FactorsImplant density: 1.54Surgical team: surgeon alone…
Case/ Spine Surgery Aggressiveness Score
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Consensus
60.4
Actionsn of fused segments: 10n Decompressed segments: 2Pelvic fixation: yes (1)…
FactorsImplant density: 1.9Surgical team: surgeon alone…
Case/ Spine Surgery Aggressiveness Score
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
1
Consensus
Modifying factorsRevision surgeryImplant density Location (lumbar/thoracic)Surgeon experience
Surgical actionsSegment fusionDecompressionPosterior interbody fusionSPO (schwab type 2)PSO (schwab 3 and 4)VCR (schwab 5 and 6)Pelvic fixation Cement augmentation
4 - 40
Case/ Spine Surgery Aggressiveness Score
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Consensus
Case/ Spine Surgery Aggressiveness Score
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Consensus
Case/ Spine Surgery Aggressiveness Score
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Consensus
Case/ Critical laboratory results
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Consensus
Case/ Critical laboratory results
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Consensus
Specialities
Case/ Critical laboratory results
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Consensus
Case/ Critical laboratory results
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
CulturesWhich characteristics
has the group?
Consensus
DiversityCo-learning
Participation
Building a collective intelligence environment
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
IQ Score Classification> 145 Genius130–144 Gifted120–129 Superior110–119 Above Average90–109. Average80–89 Below Average70–79 Borderline impaired55–69 Mildly Impaired< 54 Moderately Impaired
What does it really matter in group intelligence?Diversity
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
IQ Score Classification> 145 Genius130–144 Gifted120–129 Superior110–119 Above Average90–109. Average80–89 Below Average70–79 Borderline impaired55–69 Mildly Impaired< 54 Moderately Impaired
Diversity
What does it really matter in group intelligence?
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Diversity
Each 10% +in ethnical and racial
diversity in an executive
senior team
0,8% + Profits of the company
What does it really matter in group intelligence?
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Levels of diversity
Optimal diversity =+ Creativity
+ Management of
cognitive conflicts
SuperficialGenderRace Age
ProfoundValues and believesPersonality profileAbilities
Diversity
What does it really matter in group intelligence?
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Past
Control Centrality
Complexity Low
DiversityIt’s perceived as a problem
Participation Concession
Threat Change
DiversitySociodiversity increases knowledge, ideas & resilience.
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Past Present
Control Centrality Majorities
Complexity Low Relevant
DiversityIt’s perceived as a problem
Accepted
Participation Concession Empowerment
Threat Change Artificial limitations
Diversity
+ Sociodiversity g + Knowledge, ideas & resilience
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
+ Sociodiversity g + Knowledge, ideas & resilience
Past Present Future
Control Centrality Majorities Collective intelligence
Complexity Low Relevant Growing non stop
DiversityIt’s perceived as a problem
Accepted A lot will be needed
Participation Concession Empowerment Science of citizens
Threat Change Artificial limitations Lack of values
Diversity
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Case / How may be measured “team intelligence“?
Can you guess my
current emotion?
Diversity
Correlated with: • Average social sensitivity of group members• Equality in distribution of conversational turn-taking• Proportion of females in the group
Surprised ı Joking ı Happy ı Sure
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Diversitat
http://team.onsanity.com
Individual profiles can be mixed to
see the profile of the group
http://onsanity.com/project-view/team-
equilibrium-management/
About Team equilibrium
Team equilibrium
Case/ How may be measured “team intelligence“?
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
RelationshipsWhich are the learning
capacity as a group
Building a collective intelligence environment
Participation
Consensus
DiversityCo-learning
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Frequency of knowledge doubling?
co-Learning
1900 1950 2000
10025
1
Knowledge as a highly complex flux.
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Knowledge as a highly complex flux.
How this explosion
can be managed ?
co-Learning
Frequency of knowledge doubling?
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
co-Learning
Real time Big data: Unconscious consensus
Knowledge as a highly complex flux.
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
• 10.000 enrolled per course*
• Free, low cost or paid.
• Teaching: Top world experts.
• Students contribution through
assessment activities.
* 2016. Approximate values: 60.000.000 student in 6.000 MOOC courses.
co-Learning
Case/ Massive-Online-Open-Courses.
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
co-Learning
Case/ Massive-Online-Open-Courses.
Consensus as a pedagogical resource
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
CulturesWhich characteristics
has the group?
ActivitiesWhich tools has the group to
perform as a group?Relationships
Which are the learning capacity as a group ?
Building a collective intelligence environment
Participation
Consensus
DiversityCo-learning
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
SharingWhat’s going to happen?
ReasoningWhich one is the priority?
Acting How can we
work together?
Applying “participation engineering”
Participation
Co-creation
Decision making
Prediction
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Applying participation engineering
Participation
Co-creation
Decision making
Prediction
SharingWhat’s going to happen?
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Prediction
The past of the future
Joining visions, future can be partially seen.
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Aggregate the opinion of
carefully selected experts to
identify credible scenarios
The future can be one of the diverse options that we can imagine, assess and debate.
Prediction
Joining visions, future can be partially seen.
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Prediction market
Investing money (simulated) in the probability that an event occurs is an incentive to make more accurate predictions.
Prediction
Joining visions, future can be partially seen.
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
ReasoningWhich one is the priority?
Applying participation engineering
Participation
Co-creation
Decision making
Prediction
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Shared leadership:
Decisions
If so, we have the right to participate
Are we affected by the decision?
+ Values and transparency- Power and status quo
Deciding the most convenient option
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Ars electionis. Llull
Voting by coupelsBinary exhaustive comparisons
Couples = n*(n-1) / 2
Decisions
Deciding the most convenient option
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Selecting some ideas from thousands.
Decisions
Deciding the most convenient option
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Case/ Explosion of decisions in healthDecisions
Open
international
marketplace
for diagnosis
One error in
every two
decisions
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Last Mile Health
patientslikeme.com
Decisions
Sant Joan de Déu
NHS
Case/ Explosion of decisions in health
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Applying participation engineering
Participation
Co-creation
Decision making
Prediction Acting
How can we work together?
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
co-Creation
Consumers: from YES or NO to Co-creation
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
“Los catalanes hacen cosas”*
I feel creative
1980 2010
20%
60%
co-Creation
2020
*”Catalans do things”
Consumers: from YES or NO to Co-creation
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Purchase decisions based on
consensus among groups of
individuals with different roles.
Selling by consensus
co-Creation
Consumers: from YES or NO to Co-creation
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Case/ New stakeholders landing in healthco-Creation
London Health Commission
hackingmedicine.mit.edu
Startup + Health
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
Management
Design
Education
DomainsCrowdfunding
Co-creation
Social netsMOOC’s
e-Democracy
TechnologyDo it yourself
Collaborative
design
CrowdsourcingCollaborative
economy
Shared
knowledge
Prediction market
Livinglabs
Collective
action
Collective data
Communication
Politics
Health
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
BarriersParticipation
Consensus
Diversity
Co-creation
Decision making
Prediction
Co-learning
Collective Intelligence & Health
huntingmammoths.com [email protected]
BarriersParticipation
Consensus
Diversity
Co-creation
Decision making
Prediction
Co-learning
Are managers willing to share control?
Are users prepared and motivated?
Is society overcoming consumerism?
Are organizations
moving towards new
paradigms ?
Are we conscious
about other people's interests?
Does we actually
want to take control
of our future?