PASBO Annual Meeting March 16, 2011
Act 32 Earned Income TaxConsolidation Update:
The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly
Clarence C. Kegel, Jr., Esq.Jason T. Confair, Esq.
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP24 North Lime Street Lancaster, PA 17602 TEL 717-392-1100 FAX 717-392-4385 www.kkaglaw.com
Topics• Where Are We Now?• New EIT Tax Enactments• Act 32 Transition Plan
• Outreach Plan• DCED Issues/Regulations• TCC Tax Regulations• TCC Information
Exchange Agreement• Looking Forward:
Oversight/Bureaus/ Management
• Issues You Are Experiencing/Questions
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
2
PASBO Work• Act 32 Task Force (Chair Rick Vensel)• Many programs• TCC Infrastructure
Bylaws Tax Collection Agreement Employer outreach video/forms
• Input to DCED• Assistance to TCCs on DCED issues• Regionalization of Earned Income Tax Collection
Under Act 32 of 2008: A Detailed Legal Analysis (technical assistance document prepared by Kegel Kelin Almy & Grimm LLP for the PASBO Act 32 Task Force) (April 2009)
• Much more
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
3
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
4
Act 32 Overarching Purposes
County-wide EIT collection – reduce number of collectors
State-wide uniformity (except Philadelphia)Avoid delay and loss of tax fundsBuild expertise in EIT and other tax collection
oversight – maximize revenue/minimize cost
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
5
560 69Every county (except Phila. and
Allegheny) will select a single collector
67 Counties (w/Phila.)
Allegheny County split – 4 TCCs
Actual collector number will be 18!
5
New Act 32 Rules• Universal non-resident withholding – every employer must
withhold tax from every employee subject to EIT and remit to the Tax Collector for the employment place – eliminates most current withholding loopholes – precludes direct payment to place of residence. Non-resident vs. resident withholding (employer remits one
place vs. multiple places) Substantial new employer duties Philadelphia exception – not part of consolidation and
uniformity DCED will need address Philadelphia issues in regulations
• Multi-site employer option – multi-site employers may elect to file combined return for all counties and remit in only one Pennsylvania county (Wal-Mart Amendment).
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
6
One Tax Collection Agreement
• Major change – one master Tax Collection Agreement between Tax Collector and TCC – TCC enters contract for all taxing authorities
• Instead of prior individual Tax Collection Agreements between Tax Collector and each taxing authority
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
7
Major Statewide Issues• Tax collector capacity• Employer compliance
Everywhere – including employers located in areas where no EIT and where employers have not previously withheld EIT
• Perfect storm – substantial new employer duties + technology issues + estimated distribution prohibition = funds flow disruption?
• PA Department of Revenue – will not collect EIT … but state tax form instructions and website should provide information on and warn taxpayers of duty to pay local EIT (as done by other state revenue departments)
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
8
Miscellaneous Issues• Most TCCs moving from TC appointment to Act 32
collection transition• 2011 early implementation experiences• Northumberland County weighted vote litigation• Pike County – no EIT/no TCC/employer “workaround”• Hanna single SD in TCD legislation
Would affect Allegheny Central (Pittsburgh), Cameron, Clinton, Forest, Juniata, Mifflin, Sullivan, and Warren
SD may assume complete responsibility for tax collection; municipal advisory committee
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
9
All TCCsShould Now Have Basics
• Officers• Solicitor• Bylaws• Committees• Management
structure
• “Tax facts” compiled
• Bank, PLGIT, or other account
• Budget + auditor• Insurance
10KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
All TCCsShould Now Have Basics
• Ethics Act filings• Tax Appeal Board
appointments• Act 32 Tax Collection
Agreement• Deposit and
Investment Policy (funds held by Tax Collector or TCC)
• Tax Records Policy
• Right-to-Know Records Policy
• Detailed Timeline/Action Plan
• D-Day = 01/01/12
11KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
Annual Organization Steps• May 1 each year – Ethics Act filings• July 1 each year – TCC reweight delegate votes
(if TCC uses weighted votes)• December each year – SDs/munis make annual
delegate appointment• December each year – TCC advertise next year
meeting schedule• TCC annual organization meeting/notify DCED of
new officers (see Bylaws)
12KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
Before Long• New EIT tax enactments (if not done in 2010) – see
below• Act 32 Tax Collection Startup Steps – see below• TCC Tax Regulations, Policies, and Procedures
(12/31/11 deadline) (Act 32 § 508(d)(2) directed DCED to provide sample regulations by 12/31/09; § 505(a.1)(7) authorizes TCC to implement)
• Tax Appeal Board organization structure/policies/procedures/ appeal forms (12/31/11 deadline) (§ 505(j) mandates)
• TCC General Records Policy (records other than tax records) (12/31/11 deadline)
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
13
Before Long• TCC Unidentified Funds Policy (12/31/11 deadline)
(§ 513(a)(4) mandates)• TCC Interest Payment/Claim Policy (12/31/11
deadline) (§ 513(b)(2), § 510 necessitates) • Delinquent Taxpayer Interest and Penalty Abatement
Policy (12/31/11 deadline) (Act 32 § 509(i)(2) directs DCED to provide guidelines for use in developing policy; requires TCC to adopt)
• TCC Information Exchange Agreement between TCC and Department of Revenue (Act 32 § 509(g) – 12/31/11 deadline)
14KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
TCC Auditor• TC auditor audits TC business funds• Tax Collection Agreement determines
whether TC auditor or TCC auditor audits TC tax fund collections
• TCC needs auditor in any event:Audit TCC fundsReview and comment on TC financial
statements/internal controls
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
15
We Already Have Tax Bureau !?Cannot opt out of Act 32 – TCC requirements still apply:• Option 1 – 2 organizations (same or separate
governance of bureau vs. TCC)• Option 2 – 1 organization (TCC takes over existing
bureau)• Option 3 – dissolve tax bureau; retain third party
vendor• Issues
PSERS? Compensate “prior owners”? Many others
• Fact sensitive – no “one size fits all”
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
16
New EIT Tax Resolutions/Tax Ordinances
• Very important – most important 2011 action! (if not done in 2010)
• Get started now! Time of essence!• Is a new tax resolution/ordinance required?
Act 32 does not expressly mandateBut existing resolutions and ordinances generally
inconsistent with Act 32Uniform TCC tax enactment form benefits!Statewide uniformity?
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
17
New EIT Tax Resolutions/Tax Ordinances
• Adoption issues Nonresident tax for municipalities “Special” tax terms – like a municipal open space tax Exemptions – age, low income, or other? Exemption or credit for out-of-state residents –
complex issues• Advertisement requirements/form
3 weeks – newspaper general circulationLegal journal advertising – 45 Pa.C.S.A. § 301 et seq.?
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
18
New EIT Tax Resolutions/Tax Ordinances
• Timing for adoption?December 1 deadline to notify DCED (plus certified
copy)But note substantial advance planning/advertising
required – get started now!• Consult solicitor!• Cost sharing?
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
19
20
Tax Collection AgreementTax Collection Agreement Purposes• Act 32 and other law compliance• Change balance: from TC-oriented document to TA-
protection document• New transparency to TC activities/performance• Ensure you collect maximum revenue / least cost• Protect taxing authorities against loss• Improve/enhance tax collection process – raise the
bar on effective / cost efficient tax collection
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
Tax Collection Agreement Startup Steps
• 3 initial TCC TCA startup steps Familiarize – TCC officers familiar with key
TCA terms Transition plan – TCC/tax collector develop
plan/ timetable for transition to Act 32 collection – see below
Calendar – calendar listing deadlines for TCC/tax collector action under TCA
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
21
Transition Plan – One Part of Startup• July 1 deadline – but get started now!• Tax facts compiled• New EIT tax enactments• New collector deliver financial statements/initial year CPA
approval• TCC approve tax collector bank/financial institution• New collector deliver bond/certificate of insurance –
acceptable terms? TCC review/approval!• TCC adopt policies listed on slides 14,15• Outreach plan / outreach plan / outreach plan!• Plan for collection of pre-Act 32 out-of-jurisdiction
amounts/delinquent tax
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
22
Transition Plan – One Part of Startup• TCC notify new collector of TCC budget shares owed by
SDs and munis and to be deducted from tax revenue• PA Department of Revenue Information Exchange
Agreement• LST/other tax collection steps – see below• Old collector closeout steps
Final reports/payments Transfer unidentified/future funds Monitor open legal proceedings Final year financial statements See old tax collection agreement
• See ACT 32 TAX COLLECTION AGREEMENT STARTUP STEPS: KKAG Checklist of TCC/Tax Collector Steps Under Act 32 Tax Collection Agreement
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
23
LST/Other Tax Collection Decisions
• Related steps:Taxing Authority Contract for Collection of Tax Other
than EIT?New tax levy resolutions or ordinances?
• Consult solicitor!
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
24
Outreach Plan• Critical importance – 2011 early implementation
experience• Audiences
EmployersPayroll servicesCPAs/tax preparers Individual taxpayersOther collectors
• No “one size fits all” – adapt to your area• Primary responsibility – new collector
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
25
Outreach Plan• Advertisements• Mailings• Direct personal contact/presentations to major employers• Chamber of Commerce• Service group luncheons• Resources
New tax collector PICPA website PASBO website
o Employer Training Videoso Employer Instructionso Centre County TCC Transition Steps
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
26
Department of Revenue Information Exchange Agreement
• Act 32 directs TCCs to obtain countywide information from PA Department of Revenue
• Replaces prior fragmented system requiring each SD and muni to have agreement with Dept. of Revenue
• Dept. of Revenue is currently revising forms to accommodate
• Not yet completed
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
27
DCED Issues• Where to start?• Many issues
Tax collection agreement No legal counsel needed Legislative testimony 2011 early implementation resistance Frequent position changes
• Forms/employer and tax collector electronic reporting formats Certificate of Residence Other forms not yet completed
• DCED Tax Register – for some addresses, accurately shows resident tax and nonresident tax; for others, Tax Register does not work
• Regulations – see belowKEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
28
DCED Regulations• What is DCED mandate?
Quarterly estimated tax return rules Multi-site employers – rules on where may file Info TC must transmit with funds sent other TCs DCED mediation rules TC bond and financial security guidelines Tax penalty and interest abatement rules Lancaster County opt out rules Philadelphia issues?
• Substantive tax regulations § 508(d)(2) directs DCED to provide “sample” regulations
by 12/31/09 § 505(a.1) directs TCCs to adopt tax regulations
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
29
DCED RegulationsDCED Regulation Status• Initial draft
Long, detailed substantive tax regulations Many rules contrary to law 2% of revenue TC bond rule
• Latest draft Still many issues + unnecessary provisions that simply repeat
Act 32 provisions TCC may waive quarterly estimates if income less than $400
($4 tax)o PA PIT rule = $8,000 income ($246 tax)
Multi-site employerso May file where payroll operations locatedo May file elsewhere only if payroll operations outside PA; then
file only per DCED specific advance approval
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
30
DCED RegulationsDCED Regulation Status
TCC borrowing rules – does Local Government Unit Debt Act apply?
Tax appeal board rules – too detailed and restrictive DCED mediation rules TC bond rules – “max amount on hand” unless TCC
agrees to lower amount based on assessment of TC financial strength, fiscal controls, and insurance
TC fiscal control rules – much too detailed – need refocus on TCC auditor review and a few key issues
Procurement rules – competitive bidding goods and services – 7 pages
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
31
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
32
Who’s on First?
Chaos and bedlam ?
What ShouldTCC Tax Regulations Address?
• Cross-reference Pennsylvania PIT law and regulations – also Pennsylvania Personal Income Tax Guide
• Address income level that will trigger requirement for individuals to file quarterly estimated tax returns (subject to DCED established parameters)
• Address delinquent tax collection costs TC is permitted to assess against taxpayer
• Address differences from PA PIT, including: What is a “workplace”? This concept is inapplicable to PIT,
but controls whether an employer is obligated to withhold. For example, consider:o Employee with no fixed work locationo Employee who works from home
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
33
What ShouldTCC Tax Regulations Address?
Individual residence determination Subchapter S corporation income – generally reported to PA
as “net income from operation of business or profession,” but not subject to EIT unless shareholder provides services and has artificially low salary
Individual who manages multiple rental properties and reports income to PA as “rents” rather than “net income from operation of business or profession”
Individual who reports income from “writing” to PA as “royalties” instead of “net income from operation of business or profession”
Credit for tax paid to Philadelphia or place of residence Other-state resident exemptions or credits against PA
municipality nonresident EIT
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
34
Looking Forward:Tax Collector Oversight
• Tax fund safety items
• Tax revenue oversight items
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
35
Tax Fund Safety Items• Initial tax collector bond form – proper amount and
terms!• Tax collector annual audited financial statements –
proper terms!• TCC approve tax collector auditor• TCC monitor tax revenue vs. bond amount• TCC monitor tax collector insurance• TCC monitor tax collector bank selection, investment
permissibility, and collateralization• TCC monitor tax collector financial strength• TCC monitor tax collector compliance with Act 32 + Tax
Collection Agreement
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
36
Tax Revenue Oversight Items• Tax revenue trends/prior year comparisons• Investment earnings (where applicable)• Tax return processing times• Enforcement steps
Nonfiler identification steps and numbersClaims against other tax collectorsTaxpayer auditsDelinquent tax collection amountsCivil legal proceedingsCriminal prosecutionsWage attachments
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
37
How Does TCC Perform Oversight?
• Review monthly reports; bond form; financial statements; and annual reports
• TCC auditor review and comment on financial information
• School district and municipality input/evaluation• Periodic TCC dialogue/meetings with tax
collector• Formal annual tax collector evaluation
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
38
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
39
Looking Forward: Tax Bureaus• Advantages of tax bureau include:
Through local control, reduce risk of loss of funds Eliminate extra cost of private party profit Decouple collection decisions from profit motive Avoid India outsourcing risk Responsiveness to taxing authorities Local government control over tax collection process – in
order to maximize revenue – EIT not like real estate tax clearly defined tax duplicateo $100 new revenue outweighs $10 extra costo Identify and prosecute nonfilerso Audit questionable returnso Delinquent tax collection stepso Employer complianceo Other steps to maximize revenue
Avoid third party vendor capacity concern
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
40
Looking Forward: Tax Bureaus• Potential disadvantages include:
Start-up cost and complexity to create (and achieve high performance level)
Public official or employee time involved in bureau governance
Unless cover large geographic area, difficult to achieve economies of scale
Some third party vendors might achieve “state-of-the-art” sooner
Third party vendors generally bid lower % collection cost – but is this a savings?
• Tax bureau = big topic (for another day)
Looking Forward: TCC Management• Big job for volunteer!• Leader duties include:
Make recommendations on key TCC decisionsEnsure mandated Act 32 steps occurLiaison with legal counsel, auditor, and tax collectorFinancial steps and oversight, including establishing
and monitoring of bank accounts, preparation and implementation of annual budget, TCC expense allocation and collection, and interface with TCC auditor
Obtain and monitor TCC insuranceRight-to-Know Law compliance/serve as Open
Records Officer
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
41
Looking Forward: TCC ManagementEthics Act compliance, including obtaining and review
of statements of financial interestSunshine Law compliance, including required public
noticesDevelop tax collector transition planOversee tax appeal board operationCoordinate TCC involvement in DCED mediation
process (to the extent appropriate)Calculate new weight for delegate votes each yearMaintain required TCC recordsTax collector oversightOversee all other aspects of TCC operations
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
42
Looking Forward: TCC Management• No “one size fits all”• Alternatives to perform duties include:
Full time Executive DirectorPart time Executive Director (retired SD or muni
business administrator?)Executive Director shared with another TCCExecutive assistant or clerical employee perform
some or all operations dutiesSchool district, municipality, IU, county, or other
employee serve as Executive Director, or by contract perform specified duties and report to TCC Chairperson
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
43
Looking Forward: TCC ManagementNo employees – TCC officers perform some or all
operations duties (with or without delegation or purchase of services from SD, muni, IU, or county)
Third party consultant If the TCC has an executive Director or other
employee, this raises additional complications and requirements in terms of personnel policies, payroll, and many other issues. If an employee is needed, the TCC should explore some type of joint employment relationship with an SD, muni, IU, county, or other employer in order to allow human resource functions to be performed by an entity with a pre-existing employee base and human resources capability
See § 505(a.2)(4)
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
44
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
45
Looking Forward: TCC Compensation• May the TCC compensate tax appeal board members
or a TCC officer who performs employee operating duties?
• Act 32 § 505(a.2)(4) authorizes compensation for employees, but 505(j) is silent as to tax appeal board members and officers, and Act 32 is silent as to whether officers may serve as employees
• Pennsylvania Ethics Act issue – Is compensation prohibited if not expressly authorized? Is officer precluded from serving as employee?
• See also – 53 Pa.C.S.A. § 8430 (Local Taxpayer Bill of Rights) on compensation of members of a joint tax appeals board
• Open legal issues – exercise caution!
Questions & Answers
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP
46
Kegel Kelin Almy & Grimm LLP
Kegel Kelin Almy & Grimm LLP is a regional law firm with offices in Lancaster, Pennsylvania. KKAG is solicitor and general counsel to 17 school districts and joint school systems – and bond counsel, finance counsel, or special counsel to many others in Central and Eastern Pennsylvania. KKAG is also solicitor and general counsel to 7 Tax Collection Committees. KKAG is recognized for expertise on school district and municipal taxes. In addition, KKAG frequently serves Pennsylvania school districts for unusual and challenging problems, projects, or litigation.
KEGEL KELIN ALMY & GRIMM LLP24 North Lime Street Lancaster, PA 17602 TEL 717-392-1100 FAX 717-392-4385
www.kkaglaw.com