+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

Date post: 05-Apr-2018
Category:
Upload: charles-e-colman
View: 215 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend

of 170

Transcript
  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    1/170

    [OHTKD ]TCTK] DH]TZHMT MA[ZT' MKOTZCG DH]TZHMT AI

    MCGHIAZOHC &^k}tkzo Dhyh}hao , Ga} Conkgk}(

    MHYHG DAMEKT IAZ MC]K -0 :024,my,28464,CFL,]F

    Rkzikmt 32 Hom y/ Naangk Hom kt cgC}}hnokd ta0 @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp

    Zkikzzkd ta0 Lcnh}tzctk @{dnk ]tkrfko @/ FhgglcoLkljkz mc}k0 &Yhk~ Lkljkz Mc}k(

    Zkgctkd Mc}k0 :02:,my,2>9:4,CFL ,]F

    Mc}k ho atfkz ma{zt0 8tf MMC' 29,;;429

    8tf MMC' 29,;;4:;

    8tf MMC' 29,;;>;8

    8tf MMC' 29,;;6;4

    8tf MMC' 29,;;6>>

    8tf MMC' 32,;9=39

    Mc{}k0 3>0323 Marxzhnft Hoizhonklkot

    Dctk Ihgkd0 33!38!:224Dctk Tkzlhoctkd0 24!:9!:23:

    @{zx Dklcod0 JatfOct{zk ai ]{ht0 6:2 Marxzhnft@{zh}dhmthao0 Ikdkzcg S{k}thao

    Rgchothii

    Rkzikmt 32 Homc Mcghiazohc mazrazcthao

    zkrzk}kotkd jx Dcohkg @ MaarkzRkzikmt 32>: Jkykzgx Rcze DzhykJkykzgx Fhgg}' MC 82:32=32,:2;,863>TKZLHOCTKD0 23!29!:232GKCD CTTAZOKXCTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    @kiizkx O Lc{}okz

    Gc~ Aiihmk} ai @kiizkx O/ Lc{}okz

    :3622 Avoczd ]tzkkt ]{htk 832^aadgcod Fhgg}' MC 83=9>=32,93>,6322Klchg0 kiiBlc{}okzgc~/malTKZLHOCTKD0 2;!2:!:23:GKCD CTTAZOKX

    CTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    ]kco K Lcmhc}

    Lcmhc} Ma{o}kg Hom=2: k}t Magazcda Ja{gkyczdRc}cdkoc' MC 8332;9:9,644,>>2>

    Icv0 9:9,644,>>3>Klchg0 }kcoBlcmhc}ma{o}kg/mal

    TKZLHOCTKD0 32!:4!:226GKCD CTTAZOKXCTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    Dcyhd Octfco ]mf{gtp

    @@ Ghttgk ) C}}amhctk} RM33;22 ^k}t Agxlrhm Ja{gkyczd ]{htk

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    2/170

    =39Ga} Conkgk}' MC 82294=32,9::,8;:>Icv0 =32,4>>,8;:>Klchg0 }mf{3864Bxcfaa/malCTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    @kiizkx D Nagdlco

    @kiikz Lconkg} J{tgkz ) Lczlcza3822 Cyko{k ai tfk ]tcz}' >tf IgaazGa} Conkgk}' MC 8229>,43:2=32,:2=,6262Klchg0 nagdlcoB`ljl/malTKZLHOCTKD0 24!3;!:226

    Octcghk F Gamek

    Octcghk GamekCttazokx ct Gc~3362= Oazihkgd Ma{zt

    Ga} Conkgk}' MC 822>>=32,4>9,6:=3Icv0 =32,4>9,63=6Klchg0 octcghkfgamekBxcfaa/malCTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    Rktkz Z Dhao,Ehodkl

    Dhao,Ehodkl ) Mzamektt RM:3:>3 J{zjcoe Ja{gkyczd ]{htk 322^aadgcod Fhgg}' MC 83=9>636,66=,4422Icv0 636,9>9,2:49Klchg0 rktkzBdemgc~/malCTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    Z{}}kgg @ Izcmelco

    Lhtmfkgg ]hgjkzjkzn cod Eo{rr33=>> Agxlrhm JgydGa} Conkgk}' MC 82294,396==32,=3:,:222Icv0 =32,=3:,=322Klchg0 z`iBl}e/malTKZLHOCTKD0 28!3>!:226

    Y/

    Dkikodcot

    Naangk Homc mazrazcthao

    zkrzk}kotkd jx Mfczgk} E YkzfakykoS{hoo Klco{kg [zs{fczt ) ]{gghycoGGR;2 Mcghiazohc ]tzkkt ::od Igaaz

    ]co Izcomh}ma' MC 8433343;,6>;,9922Icv0 43;,6>;,9>22Klchg0

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    3/170

    mfczgk}ykzfakykoBs{hooklco{kg/malGKCD CTTAZOKXCTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    @koohikz C Naghoykc{v

    ^ho}tao cod ]tzc~o

    323 Mcghiazohc ]tzkkt']co Izcomh}ma' MC 8433343;,;83,3;29Klchg0 naghoykc{vB~ho}tao/malTKZLHOCTKD0 2:!:2!:226GKCD CTTAZOKXCTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    Lhmfckg ] Jzarfx

    Z{}} C{n{}t ) Ecjct3:4:4 hg}fhzk Ja{gkyczd m3:tf IgaazGa} Conkgk}' MC 822:;=32,6:9,>4>4

    Icv0 =32,6:9,9883Klchg0 ljzarfxBzcegc~/malTKZLHOCTKD0 2:!:2!:226GKCD CTTAZOKXCTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    Lhmfckg T Pkggkz

    S{hoo Klco{kg [zs{fczt ) ]{gghycoGGR69; ]a{tf Ihn{kzac ]tzkkt 32tf IgaazGa} Conkgk}' MC 8223>,:;4=:3=,44=,=222Icv0 :3=,44=,=322Klchg0

    lhmfckgpkggkzBs{hooklco{kg/malGKCD CTTAZOKX

    CTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    Codzk~ R Jzhdnk}

    Iko~hme ) ^k}t GGR;;; Mcghiazohc ]tzkkt3:tf Igaaz]co Izcomh}ma' MC 8432443;,6>;,:=22

    Icv0 43;,:63,3=;2Klchg0 cjzhdnk}Biko~hme/malTKZLHOCTKD0 2:!:2!:226

    CTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    Jzcdgkx Zajkzt Gayk

    Jczok} ) Tfazoj{zn GGR33 ]a{tf Lkzhdhco ]tzkktHodhcocragh}' HO 49:24,=;=;

    =3>,:=9,3=3=Icv0 =3>,:=3,>4==Klchg0 jzcdgkx/gaykBjtgc~/mal

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    4/170

    CTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    Jzhdnkt Cook Fc{gkz

    S{hoo Klco{kg [zs{fczt ) ]{gghyco'GGR69; ]a{tf Ihn{kzac ]tzkkt' 32tf Igaaz

    Ga} Conkgk}' MC 8223>:3=,44=,=42:Icv0 :3=,44=,=322Klchg0jzhdnktfc{gkzBs{hooklco{kg/malCTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    Lcznzkt L Mcz{}a

    S{hoo Klco{kg [zs{fczt ) ]{gghyco;;; T~ho Dagrfho Dzhyk ;tf IgaazZkd~aad ]fazk}' MC 8429;9;2,623,;222Icv0 9;2,623,;322

    Klchg0lcznzktmcz{}aBs{hooklco{kg/malTKZLHOCTKD0 32!:2!:233CTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    Lczn{kzhtk I Ktfhkz

    Gkompokz ]gcnft Zaxmk ]lhtf Nzhiiho

    GGR3=2 Cdkgchdk ]tzkkt ^k}t ]{htk :922Tazaota' Aotczha L;F =R;MCOCDC43;,69;,:8>8Icv0 439,69;,8232Klchg0 lktfhkzBghthnctk/malCTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    Lcttfk~ Cgkv ]mfkzj

    ^ho}tao ) ]tzc~o GGR323 Mcghiazohc ]tzkkt' ]{htk =822]co Izcomh}ma' MC 8433343;,;83,3222TKZLHOCTKD0 2:!:2!:226CTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    Zcmfkg F Ec}}cjhco

    S{hoo Klco{kg [zs{fczt ) ]{gghycoGGR

    ;;; T~ho Dagrfho Dzhyk ;tf IgaazZkd~aad ]fazk}' MC 8429;9;2,623,;222Icv0 9;2,623,;322Klchg0zcmfkgec}}cjhcoBs{hooklco{kg/malCTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    Dkikodcot

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    5/170

    Dak}3 tfza{nf 322' homg{}hyk

    Ma{otkz Mgchlcot

    Naangk Homc mazrazcthao

    zkrzk}kotkd jx Codzk~ R Jzhdnk}&]kk cjayk iaz cddzk}}(TKZLHOCTKD0 2:!:2!:226GKCD CTTAZOKX

    CTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    Mfczgk} E Ykzfakyko

    &]kk cjayk iaz cddzk}}(GKCD CTTAZOKXCTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    Lhmfckg T Pkggkz

    &]kk cjayk iaz cddzk}}(GKCD CTTAZOKXCTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    Jzcdgkx Zajkzt Gayk

    &]kk cjayk iaz cddzk}}(CTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    @koohikz C Naghoykc{v

    ^ho}tao cod ]tzc~o323 Mcghiazohc ]tzkkt' =8tf Igaaz]co Izcomh}ma' MC 8433343;,;83,3;29Klchg0 naghoykc{vB~ho}tao/malTKZLHOCTKD0 2:!:2!:226CTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    Lcznzkt L Mcz{}a

    &]kk cjayk iaz cddzk}}(TKZLHOCTKD0 32!:2!:233CTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    Lcttfk~ Cgkv ]mfkzj

    &]kk cjayk iaz cddzk}}(TKZLHOCTKD0 2:!:2!:226CTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    Zcmfkg F Ec}}cjhco

    &]kk cjayk iaz cddzk}}(

    CTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    Y/

    Ma{otkz Dkikodcot

    Rkzikmt 32 Homc Mcghiazohc mazrazcthao

    zkrzk}kotkd jx @kiizkx O Lc{}okz&]kk cjayk iaz cddzk}}(TKZLHOCTKD0 2;!2:!:23:

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    6/170

    GKCD CTTAZOKXCTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    Dcyhd Octfco ]mf{gtp

    &]kk cjayk iaz cddzk}}(CTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    @kiizkx D Nagdlco

    &]kk cjayk iaz cddzk}}(TKZLHOCTKD0 24!3;!:226

    Octcghk F Gamek

    &]kk cjayk iaz cddzk}}(CTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    Rktkz Z Dhao,Ehodkl

    &]kk cjayk iaz cddzk}}(CTTAZOKX TA JK OATHMKD

    Dctk Ihgkd - Damekt Tkvt

    33!38!:224 3 MALRGCHOT cncho}t dkikodcot Naangk Hom/&Ihghon ikk $ 3;2/( @{zxDklcodkd/ ' ihgkd jx rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/&zzkx' ( Ladhihkd ao6!:2!:226 &}la(/ &Kotkzkd0 33!:4!:224(

    33!38!:224 :2 Dcx ]{llao} H}}{kd zk Malrgchot , &Dh}maykzx( 3 c} ta Naangk Hom/&zzkx' ( &Kotkzkd0 33!:4!:224(

    33!38!:224 : MKZTHIHMCTHAO ai Hotkzk}tkd Rczthk} ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/&zzkx' ( &Kotkzkd0 33!:4!:224(

    33!38!:224 ZKRAZT AO TFK IHGHON AI CO CMTHAO ZKNCZDHONMARXZHNFT &mm0 iazl lchgkd ta c}fhontao' D/M/( &Arkohon( &zzkx' (&Kotkzkd0 33!:4!:224(

    33!38!:224 ZKRAZT AO TFK IHGHON AI CO CMTHAO ZKNCZDHONTZCDKLCZE] &mm0 iazl lchgkd ta c}fhontao' D/M/( &Arkohon( &zzkx'( &Kotkzkd0 33!:4!:224(

    33!38!:224 = OATHMK TA RCZTHK] AI CDZ RHGAT RZANZCL ihgkd/&zzkx' (&Kotkzkd0 33!:4!:224(

    33!:=!:224 4 LHO[TK] HO MFCLJKZ]0 Ma{o}kg czk oathihkd tfct tfk cmthao fc}jkkozkmkotgx c}}hnokd ta tfh} Ma{zt/ Tfk mazzkmt o{ljkz iaztfh} mc}k h}

    oa~ MY24,8464,OL&M^v(/ Cgg }{j}ks{kotdam{lkot} ihgkd ~htf tfkma{zt l{}t zkigkmt tfh} mc}ko{ljkz/ Cgg dam{lkot} l{}t jk ho Thlk}

    Zalco 34 iaot'r{z}{cot ta Gamcg Z{gk 33,=/3/3/ Ma{o}kg czk koma{zcnkdtazkyhk~ tfk Mkotzcg Dh}tzhmt.} ~kj}htk iaz cddhthaocghoiazlcthao/ Tfkcddzk}} h} *fttr0!!~~~/mcmd/{}ma{zt}/nay*/jx @{dnk Oazc L/LcokggcMa{zt Zkraztkz0 Oaok Crrkczhon/ &r`' ( &Kotkzkd0 33!:4!:224(

    33!:=!:224 ; ]TCODHON AZDKZ0 Tfh} maotzag} tfh} mc}k cod dhiikz} ho }alkzk}rkmt}izal tfk gamcg z{gk} jx @{dnk Oazc L/ Lcokggc'&r`' ( &Kotkzkd0

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    7/170

    33!:4!:224(

    3:!28!:224 9 RZAAI AI ]KZYHMK Kvkm{tkd jx rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom' {rao NaangkHom }kzykd ao 33!:4!:224' co}~kz d{k 3:!34!:224/ Tfk ]{llao} codMalrgchot ~kzk }kzykd jx ikdkzcg kvrzk}} }kzyhmk' oa ]tct{tk hodhmctkd'cddzk}}kd ta Codzk~ Jzhdnk} K}s ai ^ho}tao cod ]tzc~o/ D{k Dhgghnkomk

    dkmgczcthao oat cttcmfkd/ Azhnhocg ]{llao} oat zkt{zokd/ &r`' ( &Kotkzkd03:!32!:224(

    3:!28!:224 > RZAAI AI ]KZYHMK ihgkd jx rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ }tcodhon azdkz~c} }kzykd ao 3:!>!:224/ &r`' ( &Kotkzkd0 3:!34!:224(

    23!36!:22; 6 CLKODKD MALRGCHOT cncho}t dkikodcot Naangk Hom' Dak}clkodhon Malrgchot , &Dh}maykzx( 3 5 Dklcod iaz @{zx Tzhcg 'ihgkd jxrgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom &r`' ( &Kotkzkd0 23!:2!:22;(

    2:!2=!:22; 8 CO]^KZ ta Clkodkd Malrgchot 6 @[ZX DKLCOD/'MA[OTKZMGCHL] cncho}t Rkzikmt 32 Hom ihgkd jx dkikodcot NaangkHom/&r`' ( Ladhihkd ao 6!:2!:226 &}la(/ &Kotkzkd0 2:!24!:22;(

    2:!2=!:22; ICV o{ljkz iaz Cttazokx Codzk~ R Jzhdnk} h} 43;,;83,3422/ &r`' (

    &Kotkzkd0 2:!24!:22;(

    2:!2=!:22; 32 MKZTHIHMCTHAO COD OATHMK ai Hotkzk}tkd Rczthk} ihgkd jx Ma{otkzMgchlcot Naangk Hom' Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &r`' ( &Kotkzkd0 2:!24!:22;(

    2:!3>!:22; 33 LHO[TK] HO MFCLJKZ]0 Ma{o}kg czk oathihkd tfct c ]mfkd{ghonMaoikzkomk }kt iaz =!:6!:22; 28022 CL/ Ma{o}kg ahot ]tct{} Zkrazt ihgkdoa gctkz tfco =!>!:22; jx @{dnk Oazc L/ Lcokggc/Ma{zt Zkraztkz0 OaokCrrkczhon/ &r`' ( &Kotkzkd0 2:!36!:22;(

    2:!3>!:22; 3: CO]^KZ TA NAANGK] Ma{otkzmgchl 8 ihgkd jx Ma{otkz dkikodcot

    Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ Dklcod iaz @{zx Tzhcg &r`' ( &Kotkzkd0 2:!:=!:22;(

    2=!2>!:22; 3= CDZ RHGAT RZANZCL S[K]THAOOCHZK ihgkd jx cttazokx @kiizkx DNagdlco ao jkfcgi ai Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom cod cttazokx' }hnoct{zkhggknhjgk iaz Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/&d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 2=!28!:22;(

    2=!2>!:22; 34 @AHOT ZKRAZT Z{gk :9&i( Lkkthon5 k}thlctkd gkontf ai tzhcg ; ta :2

    dcx}/ ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzizkmt 32 Hom cod Dkikodcot Naadngk Hom&d~' (&Kotkzkd0 2=!34!:22;(

    2=!:6!:22; 3; LHO[TK] ]mfkd{ghon Maoikzkomk jx @{dnk Oazc L/ Lcokggc0 Ma{zt }kt}tfk iagga~hon }mfkd{gk0 Dkcdghok iaz ihghon ]kttgklkot ]kgkmthao0 4!4!2;5Dh}maykzx M{taii' Icmt0 :!:4!29' Kvrkzt0 ;!:9!295 Lathao} d{k jx9!:9!:229/ @{zx Tzhcg }kt iaz 3:!3:!:229 260=2 CL jkiazk Faoazcjgk

    Oazc L/ Lcokggc/ Rzktzhcg Maoikzkomk }kt iaz 32!=2!:229 32022 CLjkiazk Faoazcjgk Oazc L/ Lcokggc/ &]kk dam{lkot iaz i{ztfkzhoiazlcthao(Ma{zt Zkraztkz0 Oat Crrghmcjgk/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 2=!=3!:22;(

    2=!:8!:22; 39 AZDKZ!ZKIKZZCG TA CDZ RHGAT RZANZCL jx @{dnk Oazc L/

    Lcokggc0 azdkzkd ta c rzhyctk lkdhctaz jc}kd {rao c }thr{gcthao ai tfkrczthk} ta jk ihgkd oa gctkz tfco 4!4!2;/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 2=!=3!:22;(

    2=!:8!:22; 3> AZDKZ ZK MHYHG TZHCG jx @{dnk Oazc L/ Lcokggc0 Ma{zt fc} azdkzkd

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    8/170

    tfk dctk} c} hodhmctkd cjayk cod dk}mzhjkd c} iagga~}0 Dh}maykzx m{t,aii;!:9!:229/ Lathao} d{k jx 9!:9!:229/ @{zx Tzhcg }kt iaz 3:!3:!:229 260=2CL jkiazk Faoazcjgk Oazc L/ Lcokggc/ Rzktzhcg Maoikzkomk }kt iaz32!=2!:229 32022 CL jkiazk Faoazcjgk Oazc L/ Lcokggc/ &]kk

    dam{lkot iaz i{ztfkz hoiazlcthao&d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 2=!=3!:22;(

    24!2;!:22; 36 ]KTTGKLKOT RZAMKD[ZK ]KGKMTHAO OATHMK ZKS[K]T CODAZDKZ jx @{dnk Oazc L/ Lcokggc0 HT H] ]A AZDKZKD' tfk cjaykzks{k}t h} crrzaykd0 ]kttgklkot Rzamkd{zk Oa/ = , Tfk rczthk} }fcgg crrkczjkiazk c zkthzkd `{dhmhcg aiihmkz az atfkz rzhyctk az oao,rzaiht dh}r{tkzk}ag{thao jadx&d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 24!29!:22;(

    29!2=!:22; 38 @AHOT Zkrazt Zk0 ]kgkmthao ai lkdhctaz cod }mfkd{gk ai lkdhcthao ihgkdjx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom' Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &mc' ( &Kotkzkd029!39!:22;(

    26!36!:22; RZKRCZKD AZDKZ ZK TZCO]IKZ R{z}{cot ta Nkokzcg Azdkz ::4&Zkgctkd Mc}k( jx Mgkze5 zkgctkd ta MY 2:,>9:4 CFL &]Fv(/ &zo' (

    &Kotkzkd0 26!36!:22;(

    26!:4!:22; :2 AZDKZ ZK TZCO]IKZ R[Z][COT TA NKOKZCG AZDKZ ::4 ,Zkgctkd Mc}k, ihgkd/ Zkgctkd Mc}k Oa0 MY 2:,>9:4 CFL &]Fv(/ Mc}ktzco}ikzkd izal @{dnk Oazc L/ Lcokggc cod Mczgc ^akfzgk ta @{dnk C/Fa~czd Lctp cod ]tkrfko @/ Fhgglco iaz cgg i{ztfkz rzamkkdhon}/ Tfkmc}k o{ljkz ~hgg oa~ zkigkmt tfk hohthcg} ai tfk tzco}ikzkk @{dnk MY 24,8464 CFL &]Fv(/]hnokd jx @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp &zo' ( &Kotkzkd026!:4!:22;(

    26!:4!:22; :: OATHMK AI LATHAO COD LATHAO ai Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom iazRzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao5 Lklazcod{l ai Rahot} cod C{tfazhthk} ihgkd jx

    Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ Lathao }kt iaz fkczhon ao 8!38!:22; ct 32022 CLjkiazk Faoazcjgk C/ Fa~czd Lctp/ Gadnkd Rzara}kd Azdkz/ &d~' (

    &Kotkzkd0 26!=2!:22;(

    26!:4!:22; := DKMGCZCTHAO ai @kiizkx O/ Lc{}okz Ho ]{rrazt ai Lathao ai RgchothiiRkzikmt 32 Hom Iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao zk LATHAO iaz RzkghlhoczxHo`{omthao :: ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd026!=2!:22;(

    26!:4!:22; :4 DKMGCZCTHAO ai Oazlco Pcdc Ho ]{rrazt ai Lathao ai RgchothiiRkzikmt 32 Hom Iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao zk LATHAO iaz RzkghlhoczxHo`{omthao :: ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0

    26!=2!:22;(

    26!:4!:22; :; DKMGCZCTHAO ai Rctzhme ]~czt Ho ]{rrazt ai Lathao ai RgchothiiRkzikmt 32 Hom/ Iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao zk LATHAO iaz RzkghlhoczxHo`{omthao :: ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd026!=2!:22;(

    26!:4!:22; :9 DKMGCZCTHAO ai Dcyk Lazkc{ Ho ]{rrazt ai Lathao ai RgchothiiRkzikmt 32 Hom Iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao zk LATHAO iaz RzkghlhoczxHo`{omthao :: ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd026!=2!:22;(

    26!:4!:22; :> ZKS[K]T IAZ @[DHMHCG OATHMK Ho ]{rrazt ai LATHAO iaz

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    9/170

    Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao :: 5 Dkmgczcthao ai Z{}}kgg @/ Izcmelco ihgkd jxRgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 26!=2!:22;(

    26!:4!:22; :6 KVFHJHT] Ta Dkmgczcthao ai Oazlco Pcdc Ho ]{rrazt ai LATHAO iazRzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao :: Yag{lk H' Kvfhjht} 3,=9 ihgkd jx RgchothiiRkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 26!=2!:22;(

    26!:4!:22; :8 KVFHJHT] Ta Dkmgczcthao ai Oazlco Pcdc Ho ]{rrazt ai LATHAO iazRzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao :: Yag{lk HH Kvfhjht} =>,>9 ihgkd jx RgchothiiRkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 26!=2!:22;(

    26!:4!:22; =2 KVFHJHT] Ta Dkmgczcthao ai Oazlco Pcdc Ho ]{rrazt ai LATHAO iazRzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao :: Yag{lk HHH Kvfhjht} >>,33> ihgkd jx RgchothiiRkzikmt 32 Hom/&d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 26!=2!:22;(

    26!:9!:22; :3 HOHTHCG AZDKZ Iagga~hon Ihghon ai Malrgchot C}}hnokd ta @{dnk Lctpjx @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp0 Tfh} mc}k fc} jkko c}}hnokd ta tfk mcgkodcz ai@{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp/ Ma{o}kg iaz Rgchothii }fcgg }kzyk tfh} azdkz ao cggdkikodcot} cod!az tfkhz ma{o}kg cgaon ~htf tfk }{llao} cod malrgchot az

    hi tfct h} oat rzcmthmcjgk c} }aao c} ra}}hjgk tfkzkcitkz/ &]kk dam{lkot iazi{ztfkz hoiazlcthao(&d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 26!:8!:22;(

    26!=2!:22; =3 LHO[TK] AI HO MFCLJKZ] AZDKZ jx @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp 0Tfk Ma{zt fkzkjx azdkz} Dkikodcot Naangk' Hom/ &Naangk( ta ajtcho cmarx ai Clcpao/mal.} Lathao Ta ]tcx Cmthao [othg Maomg{}hao Ai Ihz}tIhgkd Zkgctkd Cmthao Az Cgtkzocthykgx Iaz Mao}aghdcthao' ihgkd jxClcpao/mal ao 6!:;!2;' ho Rkzikmt 32' Hom/ y/ Clcpao/mal' Hom/' kt cg/'MY 2;,4>;=/ Tfk Ma{zt i{ztfkz azdkz} Naangk ta ihgk' jx oat gctkz tfco8!>!2;' c }tctklkot oat ta kvmkkd ihyk rcnk} zknczdhon Naangk.} ra}hthaoao mao}aghdcthao ~htf tfct mc}k/ Naangk }fcgg }kzyk marhk} ao jatf

    Clcpao/mal cod Rkzikmt 32/Ma{zt Zkraztkz0 Oat Zkraztkd/ &}la' (&Kotkzkd0 26!=2!:22;(

    28!2:!:22; =: ]THR[GCTHAO COD AZDKZ IAZ MAOTHO[COMK AI FKCZHONCOD IAZ JZHKIHON ]MFKD[GK AO RGCHOTHII.] LATHAO IAZRZKGHLHOCZX HO@[OMTHAO jx @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp 0 Dkikodcot}fcgg ihgk cod rkz}aocggx }kzyk ht} jzhki ho arra}hthao ta tfk lathao ao8!:9!2;/ Rgchothii }fcgg ihgk cod }kzyk jx aykzohnft ma{zhkz ht} zkrgx jzhki ho}{rrazt ai tfk lathao ao 32!3>!2;/ Fkczhon ao LATHAO iaz RzkghlhoczxHo`{omthao :: h} maotho{kd ta 32!=3!:22; ct 32022 c/l/&}la' ( &Kotkzkd028!2:!:22;(

    28!3:!:22; == ZK]RAO]K ta 6!=2!2; Lho{tk Azdkz Zk Mao}aghdcthao ihgkd jxDkikodcot Naangk Hom/ Zk0 Mhyhg Lho{tk} =3 &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 28!3=!:22;(

    28!38!:22; =4 LHO[TK] AI Lathao Fkczhon fkgd jkiazk @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp0 Ma{ztNZCOT] HO RCZT COD DKOHK] HO RCZT tfk cjayk Lathao &Lathaota ]tcx Cmthao az Cgtkzocthykgx iaz Mao}aghdcthao ihgkd 6!:;!2;( ihgkd hoMY2;,4>;= CFL/ Ma{zt }rkmhihmcggx dkohk} tfk zks{k}t ta }tcx cmthao codnzcot} tfk zks{k}t ta mao}aghdctk MY2;,4>;= CFL &]Fv( ~htf MY24,8464 CFL/ Ma{zt maotho{k} rgchothii.} lathao iaz rzkghlhoczx ho`{omthaoho MY24,28464 CFL &]Fv( ta 33!>!2; ct 32022cl ta jk fkczd ~htf

    rgchothii.} 33!>!2; lathao iaz rzkghlhoczx ho`{omthao ho MY2;,4>;= CFL&]Fv(/ Ma{zt cg}a }kt} c i{ztfkz mao}aghdctkd }mfkd{ghon maoikzkomk iaz33!:3!2; ct 30=2rl/ ZK0 LATHAO iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao :: '

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    10/170

    Zk}ktthon Fkczhon c} ta LATHAO iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao :: Ma{ztZkraztkz0 Gk}ghk C/ Ehon/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 28!:3!:22;(

    28!:2!:22; =; AZDKZ ]ktthon I{ztfkz Mao}aghdctkd Z{gk :9&i( ]mfkd{ghon Maoikzkomkjx @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp0 Tfh} mc}k fc} jkko c}}hnokd ta @{dnk C/Fa~czd Lctp/ ]mfkd{ghon Maoikzkomk }kt iaz 33!:3!:22; 230=2 RL

    jkiazk Faoazcjgk C/ Fa~czd Lctp/ &]kk dam{lkot iaz i{ztfkzhoiazlcthao(&d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 28!:3!:22;(

    28!:3!:22; =9 OATHMK AI LATHAO COD LATHAO iaz Rzatkmthyk Azdkz IazMaoikzkomk} htf Ma{o}kg Oat c Oao,Gc~xkz Zkrzk}kotcthyk ai TfkhzMghkot ao Dh}maykzx Dh}r{tk} [odkz Gamcg Z{gk =>,3 ihgkd jx DkikodcotNaangk Hom/ Lathao }kt iaz fkczhon ao 32!3>!:22; ct 2:022 RL jkiazkFaoazcjgk C/ Fa~czd Lctp/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 28!:>!:22;(

    28!:3!:22; => @AHOT ]THR[GCTHAO Zk Naangk.} Lathao iaz Rzatkmthyk Azdkz iazMaoikzkomk} ~htf Ma{o}kg Oat C Oao,Gcx~kz Zkrzk}kotcthyk ai TfkhzMghkot Ao Dh}maykzx Dh}r{tk} [odkz Gamcg Z{gk =>,3/ ihgkd jx Rgchothii

    Rkzikmt 32 Hom' Naangk Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 28!:>!:22;(

    28!:9!:22; =8 LATHAO ta ]tzhek Dkmgczcthao ai Oazlco Pcdc :4 ihgkd jx DkikodcotNaangk Hom/ Lathao }kt iaz fkczhon ao 33!>!:22; ct 32022 CL jkiazkFaoazcjgk C/ Fa~czd Lctp/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 28!:8!:22;(

    28!:9!:22; 4: DKMGCZCTHAO ai Cgkvcodkz LcmNhgghyzcx Ho ]{rrazt ai Nanngk.}Arra}hthao ta Rgchothii.} LATHAO iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao :: ihgkd jxDkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 28!=2!:22;(

    28!:9!:22; 4= ARRA]HTHAO ta Rkzizkmt 32.} LATHAO iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao ::ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 28!=2!:22;(

    28!:9!:22; 44 DKMGCZCTHAO ai @afo Z Gkyhok Ho ]{rrazt ai Arra}hthao ta Rkzikmt

    32.} LATHAO iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao :: ihgkd jx Dkikodcot NaangkHom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 28!=2!:22;(

    28!:9!:22; 4; DKMGCZCTHAO ai ]{}co K Gkk Ho Arra}hthao ta Rkzikmt 32.} LATHAOiaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao :: ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &d~' (&Kotkzkd0 28!=2!:22;(

    28!:9!:22; 49 DKMGCZCTHAO ai Codzk~ R Jzhdnk} Ho Arrah}htao ta Rkzikmt 32.}LATHAO iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao :: ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/&d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 28!=2!:22;(

    28!:9!:22; 4> RZAAI AI ]KZYHMK ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ zk Dkmgczcthao 4: 'Arra}hthao ta Lathao 4= ' Dkmgczcthao 44 ' Dkmgczcthao ( 4; ' Dkmgczcthao49 ' ~c} }kzykd ao 8!:9!2;/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 28!=2!:22;(

    28!:6!:22; =6 OATHMK AI DAM[LKOT DH]MZKRCOMHK] COD AZDKZ jx @{dnkC/ Fa~czd Lctp AZDKZHON Oathmk ai Lahtao ta ]tzhek Dkmgczcthao aiOazlco Pcdc }{jlhttkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom zkmkhykd ao 8!:6!2; tajk ihgkd cod rzamk}}kd5 ihgkd dctk ta jk tfk dctk tfk dam{lkot ~c}}tclrkd Zkmkhykd j{t oat Ihgkd ~htf tfk Mgkze/&d~' ( &Kotkzkd028!:8!:22;(

    28!:6!:22; 42 OATHMK AI LATHAO ta ]tzhek Dkmgczcthao ai Oazlco Pcdc zk

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    11/170

    LATHAO ta ]tzhek Dkmgczcthao =8 ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ Lathao}kt iaz fkczhon ao 33!>!:22; ct 32022 CL jkiazk Faoazcjgk C/ Fa~czdLctp/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 28!:8!:22;(

    28!:6!:22; 43 OATHMK AI DAM[LKOT DH]MZKRCOMHK] COD AZDKZ jx @{dnkC/ Fa~czd Lctp AZDKZHON Dkikodcot}. Lathao ta ]tzhek Dkmgczcthao'

    Dkmgczcthao ai Oazlco Pcdc }{jlhttkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom zkmkhykdao 8!:9!2; ta jk ihgkd cod rzamk}}kd5 ihgkd dctk ta jk tfk dctk tfkdam{lkot ~c} }tclrkd Zkmkhykd j{t oat Ihgkd ~htf tfk Mgkze/&d~' (&Kotkzkd0 28!:8!:22;(

    32!33!:22; ;4 RZAAI AI ]KZYHMK zk LATHAO iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao :: ihgkd jxDkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &]kk dam{lkot iaz cddhthaocg dam{lkot} }kzykd(&d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 32!3>!:22;(

    32!3=!:22; 46 OATHMK AI DAM[LKOT DH]MZKRCOMHK] COD AZDKZ jx @{dnkC/ Fa~czd Lctp0 Azdkzhon Lathao ai Clhm{} M{zhck Iaz Gkcyk ta IhgkClhm{} M{zhck Jzhk5 Dkmgczcthao ai @c}ao Mf{gtx Ho ]{rrazt ai ]kzyhmk5

    Jzhi Clhm{} M{zhck ihgkd jx &Ihgkz oat }rkmhihkd( ta jk zk`kmtkd cod oat

    ihgkd cod h} AZDKZKD zkt{zokd ta Ma{o}kg/ Zkc}ao iaz zk`kmthao0 GamcgZ{gk 9/3 ^zhttko oathmk ai lathao gcmehon az thlkghok}} ai oathmkhomazzkmt5 Atfkz0 Ma{zt zks{hzk} 34 Rahot Iaot ]hpk&d~' ( &Kotkzkd032!34!:22;(

    32!3=!:22; ;2 LATHAO iaz Gkcyk ta Ihgk Jzhki Clhm{} M{zhck ihgkd jx KgkmtzaohmIzaothkz Ia{odcthao &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 32!3>!:22;(

    32!3=!:22; ;3 OATHMK AI LATHAO ai Kgkmtzaohm Izaothkz Ia{odcthao iaz Gkcyk taIhgk Jzhki Clhm{} M{zhck zk LATHAO iaz Gkcyk ;2 &d~' ( &Kotkzkd032!3>!:22;(

    32!3=!:22; ;: DKMGCZCTHAO ai @c}ao L ]mf{gtp Ho ]{rrazt ai LATHAO ai

    Kgkmtzaohm Izaothkz Ia{odcthao Iaz Gkcyk ta Ihgk Clhm{} M{zhck ;2 ihgkdjx Clhm{} M{zhck' Kgkmtzaohm Izaothkz Ia{odcthao &d~' ( &Kotkzkd032!3>!:22;(

    32!3=!:22; ;= RZAAI AI ]KZYHMK ai Oathmk ai Lathao ai Kgkmtzaohm IazothkzIa{odcthao iaz Gkcyk ta Ihgk Jzhki Clhm{} M{zhck &]kk dam{lkot iazcddhthaocg dam{lkot} }kzykd( ihgkd jx Clhm{} M{zhck ~c} }kzykd ao32!3=!2;/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 32!3>!:22;(

    32!34!:22; 48 OATHMK AI DAM[LKOT DH]MZKRCOMHK] COD AZDKZ jx @{dnkC/ Fa~czd Lctp0 Azdkzhon tfk Oathmk ai Lahtao ai Kgkmtzaohm IzaothkzIa{odcthao Iaz Gkcyk ta Ihgk Clhm{} M{zhck5 Lathao iaz Gkcyk ta Ihgk

    Jzhki Clhm{} M{zhck5 Dkmgczcthao ai @c}ao L ]mf{gtp ho ]{rrazt5Rzara}kd Azdkz Jzhki Clhm{} M{zhck5 Rzaai ai zkmkhykd 32!3=!2; h} ta jkihgkd cod rzamk}}kd/ Ihghon dctk h} AZDKZKD ta jk tfk dctk tfk da{mlkot~c} }tclrkd zkmkhykd j{t oat ihgkd ~htf tfk Mgkze/ rzamk}}kd/ &d~' (&Kotkzkd0 32!3>!:22;(

    32!34!:22; ;9 MKZTHIHMCTHAO C] TA HOTKZK]TKD RCZTHK] ihgkd jx Clhm{}M{zhck Kgkmtzaohm Izaothkz Ia{odcthao &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 32!36!:22;(

    32!3>!:22; ;; LHO[TK] AI Lathao Fkczhon fkgd jkiazk @{dnk ]tkrfko @/ Fhgglco 0Tkgkrfaohm czn{lkot fkgd/ Lathao iaz Rzatkmthyk Azdkz h} DKOHKD/

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    12/170

    Fa~kykz rgchothii.} ma{o}kg h} kvrkmtkd ta jk c} rzkrczkd c} ra}}hjgk iazdh}maykzx lkkt cod maoikz }k}}hao}' }a tfct Dz/ Pcdc.} rczthmhrcthao h}ekrt ta c lhohl{l/Tcrk -0 2;,=6/ &}j{' ( &Kotkzkd0 32!36!:22;(

    32!3>!:22; ;> KYHDKOTHCZX AJ@KMTHAO] ai Rkzikmt 32 Hom ta tfk Dkmgczcthao aiCgkvcodkz LcmNhgghyzcx zk LATHAO iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao :: ihgkd

    jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 32!38!:22;(

    32!3>!:22; ;6 ZKRGX DKMGCZCTHAO ai Oazlco Pcdc Ho ]{rrazt ai LATHAO AiRgchothii Rkzikmt :2 Hom iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao :: ihgkd jx RgchothiiRkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 32!38!:22;(

    32!3>!:22; ;8 DKMGCZCTHAO ai @kiizkx D Nagdlco Ho ]{rrazt ai LATHAO aiRgchothii Rkzikmt :2 Hom iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao :: ihgkd jx RgchothiiRkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 32!38!:22;(

    32!3>!:22; 92 KYHDKOTHCZX AJ@KMTHAO] Ai Rkzikmt 32 ta tfk Dkmgczcthao aiCodzk~ Jzhdnk} ta LATHAO iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao :: ihgkd jxRgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 32!38!:22;(

    32!3>!:22; 93 KYHDKOTHCZX AJ@KMTHAO] ai Rkzikmt 32 Hom ta tfk Dkmgczcthao ai

    ]{}co K Gkk Zk0 LATHAO iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao :: ihgkd jx RgchothiiRkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 32!38!:22;(

    32!3>!:22; 9: KYHDKOTHCZX AJ@KMTHAO] ai Rkzikmt 32 Hom ta tfk Dkmgczcthao ai@afo Z/ Gkyhok ta LATHAO iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao :: ihgkd jxRgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 32!38!:22;(

    32!3>!:22; 9= ZKRGX LKLAZCOD[L ho ]{rrazt ai Lathao ai Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32Hom iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao :: ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' (&Kotkzkd0 32!38!:22;(

    32!3>!:22; 94 DKMGCZCTHAO ai Cggko ^con Ho ]{rrazt ai Rkzikmt 32.} Zkrgx Zk0Lathao ai Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao :: ihgkd jxRgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 32!38!:22;(

    32!3>!:22; 9; RZAAI AI ]KZYHMK Zk Zkrgx Dam{lkot} ho ]{rrazt ai Lathao ai

    Rkzikmt 32 Hom iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom'zk Zk}rao}k ho Arra}hthao ta Lathao ;> ' Zk}rao}k ho Arra}hthao taLathao 93 ' Zk}rao}k ho Arra}hthao ta Lathao 9: ' Lklazcod{l ho]{rrazt ai Lathao 9= ' Dkmgczcthao &Lathao zkgctkd( 94 ' Dkmgczcthao&Lathao zkgctkd( ;6 ' Dkmgczcthao &Lathao zkgctkd( ;8 ' Zk}rao}k hoArra}hthao ta Lathao 92 ' ~c} }kzykd ao 32!3>!2;/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd032!38!:22;(

    32!:2!:22; 99 OATHMK ai Crrkczcomk ai @clk} N? Nhgghgcod @z/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0

    32!:3!:22;(

    32!:3!:22; 9> ARRA]HTHAO ta LATHAO ta ]tzhek Razthao} ai tfk Dkmgczcthao ai Dz/Oazlco Pcdc &Lathao zkgctkd( :4 =8 ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &xg'( &Kotkzkd0 32!:9!:22;(

    32!:4!:22; 96 LKLAZCOD[L Ai Rahot} cod C{tfazhthk} ai Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 hoArra}hthao ta Lathao ai Kgkmtzaohm Izaothkz Ia{odcthao iaz Gkcyk ta IhgkJzhki Clhm{} M{zhck zk LATHAO ;2 ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    13/170

    &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 32!:9!:22;(

    32!:4!:22; 98 DKMGCZCTHAO ai Kgkoc ]kncg Ho Arra}hthao ta Lathao ai KgkmtzaohmIzaothkz Ia{odcthao Iaz Gkcyk ta Ihgk Jzhki Clhm{} M{zhck zk LATHAOiaz Gkcyk ;2 ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd032!:9!:22;(

    32!:6!:22; >2 OATHMK AI ZKS[K]T TA MZA]],KVCLK DKMGCZCOT OATLCOPCDC ihgkd jx Dkikodcot cod Ma{otkzmgchlcot Naangk Hom' Naangk Hom/&}fj' ( &Kotkzkd0 33!2:!:22;(

    32!=3!:22; >3 ZKRGX ta zk}rao}k ta LATHAO ta ]tzhek Dkmgczcthao ai Oazlco Pcdc:4 =8 ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &}fj' ( &Kotkzkd0 33!2:!:22;(

    33!23!:22; >: OATHMK ai Ihghon Azhnhocg Rzaai} ai ]kzyhmk ihgkd jx Dkikodcot NaangkHom' zk Oathmk &Atfkz( >2 ' ~c} }kzykd ao 32!=3!2;/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd033!2=!:22;(

    33!24!:22; >= ZK]RAO]K ta Rkzikmt 32.} Aj`kmthao} ta Dkmgczcthao ai ]{}co K Gkk ho

    }{rrazt ai Arra}hthao ta LATHAO iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao :: ihgkd jxDkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &}fj' ( &Kotkzkd0 33!26!:22;(

    33!24!:22; >; ZK]RAO]K ta Kyhdkothczx Aj`kmthao} ai Rkzikmt 32' Hom ta tfk

    Dkmgczcthao ai Codzk~ Jzhdnk} ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom &}fj' (&Kotkzkd0 33!26!:22;(

    33!24!:22; >9 DKMGCZCTHAO ai ]{}co K Gkk ho }{rrazt ai Naangk.} Zk}rao}k taAj`kmthao} ta Gkk Dkmgczcthao ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &}fj' (&Kotkzkd0 33!26!:22;(

    33!24!:22; >> ZK]RAO]K ta Kyhdkothczx Aj`kmthao} ai Rkzmkmt 32' Homy ta tfkDkmgczcthao ai @afo Z Gkyhok ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom &}fj' (

    &Kotkzkd0 33!26!:22;(

    33!24!:22; >6 ZK]RAO]K ta kyhdkothczx Aj`kmthao} ai Rkzmkmt 32' Hom ta tfkDkmgczcthao ai Cgkvcodkz LcmNhgghyzcx ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom&}fj' ( &Kotkzkd0 33!26!:22;(

    33!24!:22; >8 KV RCZTK CRRGHMCTHAO iaz Gkcyk ta ihgk ]{z,Zkrgx ho ]{rrazt ai

    Naangk.} Arra}hthao ta Lathao iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao ihgkd jxDkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &}fj' ( &Kotkzkd0 33!26!:22;(

    33!24!:22; 62 RZAAI AI ]KZYHMK ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom' zk Zk}rao}k &oao,lathao( >; ' Dkmgczcthao &oao,lathao( >9 ' Zk}rao}k &oao,lathao( >> 'Zk}rao}k &oao,lathao( >6 ' KV RCZTK CRRGHMCTHAO iaz Gkcyk ta ihgk]{z,Zkrgx ho ]{rrazt ai Naangk.} Arra}hthao ta Lathao iaz Rzkghlhoczx

    Ho`{omthao >8 ' ~c} }kzykd ao 33!4!2;/ &}fj' ( &Kotkzkd0 33!26!:22;(

    33!2>!:22; >4 LHO[TK] AI Lathao Fkczhon fkgd jkiazk @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp 0Ma{zt h}}{k} dzcit a{tghok cod s{k}thao} ma{o}kg/ Iaz zkc}ao} }tctkd ao tfkzkmazd' tfk Ma{zt NZCOT] Kgkmtzaohm Izaothkz Ia{odcthao.} Lathao iaz

    Gkcyk ta Ihgk Clhm{} M{zhck cod DKOHK] Dkikodcot.} Lathao ta ]tzhektfk Dkmgczcthao ai Oazlco Pcdc/ Ma{zt cg}a NZCOT] tfk zks{k}t iaz`{dhmhcg oathmk cod DKOHK] tfk Kv Rcztk Crrghmcthao ta Ihgk c ]{z,Zkrgx/Tfk rzara}kd ]{z,Zkrgx ~hgg jk }tclrkd *RGCMKD HO IHGK OAT

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    14/170

    []KD/* Ma{zt tcek} [ODKZ ][JLH]]HAO jatf ai Rgchothii.} Lathao}iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao/Ma{zt Zkraztkz0 Gk}ghk C/ Ehon/ &}la' (&Kotkzkd0 33!26!:22;(

    33!2>!:22; RGCMKD HO IHGK , OAT []KD zk URzara}kd\ ]{z,Zkrgx Dkmgczcthao aiCgkvcodkz LcmNhgghyzcx Ho ]{rrazt ai Naangk.} Arra}hthao ta Rgchothii.}

    Lathao iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao }{jlhttkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/&d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 33!28!:22;(

    33!2>!:22; RGCMKD HO IHGK , OAT []KD zk Rzaai ai ]kzyhmk }{jlhttkd jxDkikodcot Naangk Hom/ ]kzyhmk ao 33!>!2; &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 33!28!:22;(

    33!2>!:22; 64 ARRA]HTHAO ta Naangk.} KV RCZTK CRRGHMCTHAO iaz Gkcyk ta ihgk]{z,Zkrgx Cod ]{rrazthon Dkmgczcthao} Ho Arra}hthao ta Rkzikmt 32.}Lathao iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao >8 5 Dkmgczcthao ai Oazlco Pcdc ihgkdjx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 33!28!:22;(

    33!2>!:22; RGCMKD HO IHGK , OAT []KD zk URzara}kd\ Azdkz Nzcothon KgkmtzaohmIzaothkz Ia{odcthao Gkcyk ta Ihgk Jzhki Clhm{} M{zhck }{jlhttkd jx

    Clhm{} M{zhck &xg' ( &Kotkzkd0 33!39!:22;(

    33!2>!:22; RGCMKD HO IHGK , OAT []KD zk Urzara}kd\ Azdkz Nzcothon Naangk.}Kv Rcztk Crrghmcthao iaz Gkcyk ta Ihgk ]{z Zkrgx Rcrkz} }{jlhttkd jxDkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &xg' ( &Kotkzkd0 33!39!:22;(

    33!2>!:22; RGCMKD HO IHGK , OAT []KD zk Urzara}kd\ }{zzkrgx lklazcod{l hoarra}hthao ta rgchothii.} lathao iaz rzkghlhoczx ho`{omthao }{jlhttkd jxDkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &xg' ( &Kotkzkd0 33!39!:22;(

    33!2>!:22; RGCMKD HO IHGK , OAT []KD zk Urzara}kd\ }{zzkrgx dkmgczcthao ai@koohikz C Naghoykc{v ho }{rrazt ai arra}htao ta lathao iaz rzkghlhoczxho`{omthao }{jlhttkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &xg' ( &Kotkzkd0

    33!39!:22;(

    33!26!:22; 63 ]THR[GCTHAO IAZ RZATKMTHYK AZDKZ jx @{dnk Zajkzt @/

    Ekggkfkz0 Fcyhon zkyhk~kd tfk tkzl} ai tfk iazknahon ]thr{gcthao codihodhon tfct naad mc{}k kvh}t} iaz }chd Rzatkmthyk Azdkz zks{k}tkd HT H]]A AZDKZKD/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 33!28!:22;(

    33!26!:22; 6= OATHMK AI DAM[LKOT DH]MZKRCOMHK] COD AZDKZ jx @{dnkC/ Fa~czd Lctp AZDKZHON 3( Rzara}kd ]{z,Zkrgx Dkmgczcthao aiCgkvcodkz LcmNhgghyzcx 5 :( Rzaai ai ]kzyhmk jx K Lchg =( Rzaai ai]kzyhmk jx Fcod dkghykzx }{jlhttkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom zkmkhykd ao33!>!2; ta jk ihgkd cod rzamk}}kd5 ihgkd dctk ta jk tfk dctk tfk dam{lkot~c} }tclrkd Zkmkhykd j{t oat Ihgkd ~htf tfk Mgkze/&d~' ( &Kotkzkd0

    33!28!:22;(

    33!26!:22; RGCMKD HO IHGK , OAT []KD zk Rzaai ai ]kzyhmk }{jlhttkd jxDkikodcot Naangk Hom/ ]kzyhmk ao 33!9!2; &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 33!28!:22;(

    33!26!:22; 68 JZHKI CLHM[] M[ZHCK AI Kgkmtzaohm Izaothkz Ia{odcthao &xg' (&Kotkzkd0 33!:3!:22;(

    33!28!:22; 6: OATHMK AI MGKZHMCG KZZAZ0 D{k ta mgkzhmcg kzzaz Dam{lkot Oa/63' ]thr{gcthao iaz Rzatkmthyk Azdkz ~c} kzzaoka{}gx damektkd ta MY24,

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    15/170

    28464 CFL &]Fv( Zk0 ]thr{gcthao cod Azdkz' Rzatkmthyk Azdkz 63 &d~' (&Kotkzkd0 33!28!:22;(

    33!28!:22; 6; KYHDKOTHCZX MHTCTHAO] ][JLHTTKD JX Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32' Hom/Ho Zk}rao}k ta Ma{zt.} S{k}thao} ct Fkczhon Ao Lathao iaz RzkghlhoczxHo`{omthao ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom >4 &xg' ( &Kotkzkd0 33!3>!:22;(

    33!3>!:22; 69 LHO[TK] AI HO MFCLJKZ] AZDKZ jx @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp 0 Aotfk Ma{zt.} a~o lathao' tfk Ma{zt fkzkjx maotho{k} tfk I{ztfkzMao}aghdctkd ]mfkd{ghon Maoikzkomk =; izal 33!:3!2; ta 3:!3:!2; ct30=2 r/l/ Z{gk :9 Lkkthon Zkrazt d{k jx 3:!;!:22;/ Ma{zt Zkraztkz0 OatZkraztkd/ &}la' ( &Kotkzkd0 33!3>!:22;(

    33!36!:22; 6> ZKMKHRT AI ZKRAZTKZ] TZCO]MZHRT ai rzamkkdhon} iaz tfkiagga~hon dctk}0 33!>!2; Ma{zt Zkraztkz0 Gk}ghk C/ Ehon &la' ( &Kotkzkd033!36!:22;(

    33!36!:22; 66 TZCO]MZHRT ihgkd iaz rzamkkdhon} fkgd ao 33!>!2;/ Ma{zt Zkraztkz0Gk}ghk C/ Ehon/ &la' ( &Kotkzkd0 33!36!:22;(

    33!::!:22; 82 OATHMK AI LATHAO COD LATHAO iaz Rzatkmthyk Azdkz ihgkd jx

    dkikodcot cod ma{otkzmgchlcot Naangk Hom' Naangk Hom/ Lathao }kt iazfkczhon ao 3:!38!:22; ct :022 RL jkiazk Faoazcjgk C/ Fa~czd Lctp/&mc' ( &Kotkzkd0 33!:8!:22;(

    33!::!:22; 83 @AHOT ]THR[GCTHAO ZK0 zk LATHAO iaz ht} Rzatkmthyk Azdkz 82 ihgkdjx dkikodcot cod ma{otkzmgchlcot Naangk Hom' Naangk Hom/ &mc' ( &Kotkzkd033!:8!:22;(

    33!:8!:22; 8: LHO[TK] AI &Ho Mfcljkz}( jx @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp0 Ao tfk Ma{zt.}a~o lathao tfk Ma{zt fkzkjx maotho{k} tfk I{ztfkz Mao}aghdctkd]mfkd{ghon Maoikzkomk ta 3!32!:229 230=2 RL/Ma{zt Zkraztkz0 Oat

    Zkraztkd/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 33!=2!:22;(

    3:!:>!:22; 8= LHO[TK] AI Lathao Fkczhon fkgd jkiazk @{dnk ]tkrfko @/ Fhgglco 0

    Iagga~hon azcg czn{lkot ao 3:,:3,2;' tfk ma{zt oa~ z{gk} ao Naangk.}Lathao iaz kotzx ai Rzatkmthyk Azdkz/ Dkikodcot Clpao ffc} `ahodkd hodkikodcot Naangk.} Lathao rcrkz}' cod azcg czn{lkot' tfa{nf Clcpaofc} oat ihgkd athao rcrkz} ao ht} a~o/ Cmmazdhongx' tfk ma{zt kotkz}rgchothii.} Rzara}kd Rzatkmthyk Azdkz/Tcrk -0 2;,;3/ &}j{' ( &Kotkzkd03:!:6!:22;(

    3:!:>!:22; 84 RZATKMTHYK AZDKZ jx @{dnk ]tkrfko @/ Fhgglco0 HT H] ]AAZDKZKD/ &]kk Dam{lkot iaz i{ztfkz hoiazlcthao(&d~' ( &Kotkzkd03:!:8!:22;(

    3:!:6!:22; 89 DH]MAYKZX LATHAO0 OATHMK AI LATHAO ta Malrkg Naadngk Homta Rzad{mk Dam{lkot}5 @ahot ]thr{gcthao5 Dkmgczcthao} ai Oazlco Pcdc5@koohikz Naghoykc{v ihgkd jx rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ Lathao }kt iazfkczhon ao 3!:=!:229 ct 2:022 RL jkiazk Lcnh}tzctk @{dnk ]tkrfko @/Fhgglco/ &`r' ( &Kotkzkd0 23!29!:229(

    3:!:6!:22; 8> @AHOT ]THR[GCTHAO Zknczdhon Rgchothii LATHAO ta MalrkgDkikodcot Naadngk Hom ta Rzad{mk Dam{lkot} 89 ihgkd jx rgchothiiRkzikmt 32 Hom/ &`r' ( &Kotkzkd0 23!29!:229(

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    16/170

    3:!:6!:22; 86 DKMGCZCTHAO ai @KOOHIKZ C/ NAGHOYKC[V ho }{rrazt aiArra}hthao ta LATHAO ta Malrkg Naadngk Hom ta Rzad{mk Dam{lkot}89 ihgkd jx rgchothii Naangk Hom/ &`r' ( Ladhihkd ao 3!9!:229 &`r' (/&Kotkzkd0 23!29!:229(

    3:!:6!:22; 88 DKMGCZCTHAO ai OAZLCO PCDC ho }{rrazt ai LATHAO ta

    Malrkg Naadngk Hom ta Rzad{mk Dam{lkot} 89 ihgkd jx rgchothii Rkzikmt32 Hom/ &`r' ( &Kotkzkd0 23!29!:229(

    23!2=!:229 322 OATHMK AI LATHAO ta Malrkg Dkikodcot Naangk Hom ta Co}~kzHotkzzanctazhk} ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ Lathao }kt iaz fkczhon ao3!=2!:229 ct 2:022 RL jkiazk Lcnh}tzctk @{dnk ]tkrfko @/ Fhgglco/ &d~'( &Kotkzkd0 23!32!:229(

    23!2=!:229 323 DKMGCZCTHAO ai Oazlco Pcdc cod @kiizkx O Lc{}okz ho ]{rrazt aiRkzikmt 32.} LATHAO ta Malrkg Dkikodcot Naangk Hom ta Co}~kzHotkzzanctazhk} 322 ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd023!32!:229(

    23!2=!:229 32: DKMGCZCTHAO ai @koohikz C Naghoykc{v Ho ]{rrazt ai Naangk Hom.}Arra}hthao ta Rkzikmt 32.} LATHAO ta Malrkg Dkikodcot Naangk Hom taCo}~kz Hotkzzanctazhk} 322 ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &d~' (&Kotkzkd0 23!32!:229(

    23!2=!:229 32= @AHOT ]THR[GCTHAO Zk Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom.} Lathao ta MalrkgDkikodcot Naangk Hom ta Co}~kz} Hotkzzanctazhk} ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt32 Hom' cod Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 23!32!:229(

    23!2;!:229 8; LHO[TK] AI HO MFCLJKZ] AZDKZ jx @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp 0 Aotfk Ma{zt.} a~o lathao' tfk Ma{zt fkzkjx ycmctk} tfk 3!32!29 I{ztfkzMao}aghdctkd ]mfkd{ghon Maoikzkomk/ Tfk Ma{zt ~hgg zk}kt tfk }mfkd{ghonmaoikzkomk citkz ht z{gk} ao tfk rkodhon rzkghlhoczx ho`{omthao

    lathao}/Ma{zt Zkraztkz0 Oat Zkraztkd/ &}la' ( &Kotkzkd0 23!2;!:229(

    23!:>!:229 324 LHO[TK] AI HO MFCLJKZ] AZDKZ jx @{dnk ]tkrfko @/ Fhgglco 0'Zk}ktthon Fkczhon c} ta LATHAO ta Malrkg 89 ' LATHAO iaz Azdkz iazMalrkg Dkikodcot Naangk Hom ta Co}~kz Hotkzzanctazhk} 322 Lathao }ktiaz fkczhon ao :!:3!:229 cod :!::!:229 ct 280=2 CL jkiazk Lcnh}tzctk@{dnk ]tkrfko @/ Fhgglco/Ma{zt Zkraztkz0 oaok rzk}kot/ &}j{' ( &Kotkzkd023!=2!:229(

    2:!23!:229 32; OATHMK ai Crrkczcomk ai Lcze T @co}ko cod Cotfaox @ Lcg{ttc ihgkdjx Dkikodcot} Clcpao/Mal Hom cod C8/Mal Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd02:!2=!:229(

    2:!28!:229 329 ZKYH]KD @AHOT ]THR[GCTHAO Zk Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom.} Lathao taMalrkg Dkikodcot Naangk Hom ta Co}~kz Hotkzzanctazhk} ihgkd r{z}{cot taAzdkz ai @{dnk Fhgglco ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd02:!34!:229(

    2:!28!:229 32> DKMGCZCTHAO ai Oazlco Pcdc cod @kiizkx O/ Lc{}okz ho ]{rrazt aiRkzikmt 32.} LATHAO Malrkg Dkikodcot Naangk Hom ta Co}~kzHotkzzanctazhk} 322 Ihgkd htf Zkyh}kd @ahot ]thr{gcthao R{z}{cot taAzdkz ai @{dnk Fhgglco ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd02:!34!:229(

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    17/170

    2:!28!:229 326 DKMGCZCTHAO ai @koohikz C Naghoykc{v' Zcdfhec Lcgrcoh' cod DhcokTcon Ho ]{rrazt ai Naangk Hom.} ta Co}~kz Hotkzzanctazhk} Ihgkd R{z}{cotta Azdkz ai @{dnk Fhgglco zk LATHAO iaz Azdkz iaz Malrkg DkikodcotNaangk Hom ta Co}~kz Hotkzzanctazhk} 322 ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/

    &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 2:!34!:229(

    2:!3=!:229 328 OATHMK AI LATHAO COD LATHAO ta Malrkg Rzad{mthao aiDam{lkot} cod Zk}rao}k} ta Hotkzzanctazhk} ai Rgchothii' ihgkd jxDkikodcot Naangk Hom/ Lathao }kt iaz fkczhon ao =!3=!:229 ct 2:022 RLjkiazk Lcnh}tzctk @{dnk ]tkrfko @/ Fhgglco/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 2:!3>!:229(

    2:!3=!:229 332 DKMGCZCTHAO ai ]{}co K Gkk Ho ]{rrazt ai Naangk.} LATHAO taMalrkg Rzad{mhta ai Dam{lkot} cod Zk}raok} ta Hotkzzanctazhk} 328ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 2:!3>!:229(

    2:!3=!:229 333 DKMGCZCTHAO ai Oazlco Pcdc cod @kiizkx O Lc{}okz Ho ]{rrazt aiRkzikmt 32.} Lathao ta Malrkg Naangk ta Rzad{mk Dam{lkot} Ihgkd ^htfZkyh}kd @ahot ]thr{gcthao R{z}{cot ta Azdkz ai @{dnk Fhgglco zk

    LATHAO ta Malrkg 89 ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0

    2:!3>!:229(

    2:!3=!:229 33: OATHMK tfct Zkyh}kd @ahot ]thr{gcthao Zk Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom.}Lathao ta Malrkg Dkikodcot Naangk Hom ta Rzad{mk Dam{lkot} Citkz]kmaod ]kt ai Maoikzkomk} ai Ma{o}kg Ihgkd R{z}{cot ta Azdkz ai @{dnkFhgglco h} Jkhon Ihgkd [odkz ]kcg R{z}{cot ta tfk Zks{k}t ai DkikodcotNaangk Hom ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 2:!:3!:229(

    2:!3=!:229 33= @AHOT ]THR[GCTHAO Zk Naangk.} LATHAO ta Malrkg Rzad{mthao aiDam{lkot} cod Zk}rao}k} ta Hotkzzanctazhk} 328 ihgkd jx DkikodcotRkzikmt 32 Hom' Naangk Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 2:!:3!:229(

    2:!3=!:229 334 DKMGCZCTHAO ai Codzk~ R Jzhdnk} Ho ]{rrazt ai Naangk.} LATHAO

    ta Malrkg Rzad{mthao ai Dam{lkot} cod Zk}rao}k} ta Hotkzzanctazhk} zk0LATHAO ta Malrkg 328 ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd02:!:3!:229(

    2:!3=!:229 33; RZAAI AI ]KZYHMK ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom' zk LATHAO taMalrkg Co}~kz} ta Hotkzzanctazhk} ai Rgchothii LATHAO ta Malrkg 328 'Dkmgczcthao &Lathao zkgctkd( 332 ' Lathao Zkgctkd Dam{lkot 33= 'Dkmgczcthao &Lathao zkgctkd( 334 ' ~c} }kzykd ao :!3=!29/ &d~' (&Kotkzkd0 2:!:3!:229(

    2:!3=!:229 339 ]KCGKD DAM[LKOT ZK0 ]rzkcd}fkkt} &Kvfhjht} 3,;( iaz Lathao taMalrkg Rzad{mthao ai Dam{lkot} cod Zk}rao}k} ta Hotkzzanctazhk} zk

    LATHAO ta Malrkg Co}~kz} ta Hotkzzanctazhk} 328 &d~' ( Ladhihkd ao:!:3!:229 &d~' (/ &Kotkzkd0 2:!:3!:229(

    2:!3=!:229 33> ]KCGKD DAM[LKOT zk0 ][RRGKLKOTCG DKMGCZCTHAO] aiZcdfhec Lcgrcoh' Gc~zkomk Xa{' cod @koohikz C Naghoykc{v Ho ]{rraztai Arra}hthao ta Zkyh}kd Lathao} ta Malrkg ta Rzad{mk Dam{lkot} codta Co}~kz Hotkzzanctazhk} Ihgkd R{z}{cot ta Azdkz ai @{dnk Fhgglco &d~' (Ladhihkd ao :!:3!:229 &d~' (/ Ladhihkd ao :!:3!:229 &d~' (/ &Kotkzkd02:!:3!:229(

    2:!3=!:229 336 ]KCGKD DAM[LKOT ZK ZKYH]KD @AHOT ]THR[GCTHAO Zk

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    18/170

    Lathao ta Malrkg Dkikodcot ta Rzad{mk Dam{lkot} Citkz ]kmaod ]kt aiMaoikzkomk} ai Ma{o}kg Ihgkd R{z}{cot ta Azdkz ai @{dnk Fhgglco &d~' (Ladhihkd ao :!:3!:229 &d~' (/ &Kotkzkd0 2:!:3!:229(

    2:!3>!:229 338 AZDKZ Nzcothon ho Rczt cod Dkoxhon Ho Rczt Rkzikmt 32.} Lathao iazRzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao Cncho}t Naangk jx @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp0 Ma{zt

    NZCOT] HO RCZT cod DKOHK] HO RCZT Rkzikmt 32.} lathao iaz crzkghlhoczx ho`{omthao cnho}t Naangk/ zk LATHAO iaz RzkghlhoczxHo`{omthao :: &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 2:!:3!:229(

    2:!:3!:229 3:2 LHO[TK] AI HO MFCLJKZ] AZDKZ jx @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp0Ma{zt DKOHK] Rkzikmt 32.} lathao iaz rzkghlhoczx ho`{omthao cncho}tClcpao/ ZK0 LATHAO iaz Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao :: Ma{zt Zkraztkz0O!C/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 2:!::!:229(

    2:!:4!:229 3:3 AZDKZ ]KTTHON I[ZTFKZ Z[GK :9&i( ]MFKD[GHONMAOIKZKOMK jx @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp0 Tfk maoikzkomk ~hgg jk fkgdr{z}{cot ta Ikd/Z/Mhy/R/ 39&j(/ Tfk rczthk} czk zklhodkd ai tfkhz

    ajghncthao} {odkz Ikd/Z/Mhy/R/ :9&c(&3( ta dh}mga}k hoiazlcthao &~htfa{t

    c~chthon c dh}maykzx zks{k}t( cod {odkz Z/ :9&i( ta maoikz ao c dh}maykzxrgco oat gctkz tfco t~kotx,aok &:3( dcx} rzhaz ta tfk }mfkd{ghonmaoikzkomk cod ta ihgk c zkrazt ~htf tfk Ma{zt kothtgkd *I{ztfkz @ahot Z{gk:9&i( Zkrazt* oat gctkz tfco ia{ztkko &34( dcx} citkz tfkx maoikz/ I{ztfkz@ahot Z{gk :9 Zkrazt d{k jx =!:>!29/ I{ztfkz ]mfkd{ghon Maoikzkomk }ktiaz 4!=!29 ct 30=2 r/l/ jkiazk @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp/&}la' ( &Kotkzkd02:!:4!:229(

    2:!:4!:229 Tkzlhoctkd cgg agd }mfkd{ghon dkcdghok} cod fkczhon}/ &}la' (

    &Kotkzkd0 2:!:4!:229(

    2=!26!:229 3:: @AHOT ]TCTKLKOT Zknczdhon Rzara}kd Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao/ &`r' (&Kotkzkd0 2=!3>!:229(

    2=!:2!:229 3:= RZKGHLHOCZX HO@[OMTHAO OATHMK AI CRRKCG CODZKRZK]KOTCTHAO ]TCTKLKOT ta 8tf MMC ihgkd jx rgchothii Rkzikmt32 Hom/ Crrkcg ai Azdkz' 338 Ihgkd Ao0 :!3>!295 Kotkzkd Ao0 :!:3!295Ihghon ikk $:;;' Rchd zkmkhrt o{ljkz 6==83/ mm0 @kiizkx O/ Lc{}okz5Lhtmfkgg' ]hgjkzjkzn cod Eo{rr5 Dcohkg @/ Maarkz5 ho}tao cod ]tzc~o']co Izco}h}ma' Mcghiazohc5 ho}tao cod ]tzc~o' Ga} Conkgk}' Mcghizaohc5Ta~o}kod cod Ta~o}kod cod Mzk~/ &nfcr' ( Ladhihkd ao =!:3!:229&nfcr' (/ &Kotkzkd0 2=!:3!:229(

    2=!:2!:229 Mhyhg Crrkcg} Damekthon ]tctklkot zkmkhykd izal rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Homiaz~czdkd ta 8tf MMC/ ZK0 Crrkcg ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt' 3:= / &nfcr' (&Kotkzkd0 2=!:3!:229(

    2=!:2!:229 3:4 CRRGHMCTHAO ta Ihgk Kvfhjht} ta tfk Dkmgczcthao ai Fkzcgda Jatkgfa ho]{rrazt ai Lklazcod{l ho ]{rrazt ai Naangk.} Rzara}kd Iazl aiRzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao R{z}{cot ta :!:3!29 Azdkz [odkz ]kcg ihgkd jxDkikodcot Naangk Hom/ Gadnkd Rzara}kd Azdkz/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd02=!:=!:229(

    2=!:2!:229 3:; LKLAZCOD[L ho ]{rrazt ai Naangk Hom.} Rzara}kd Iazl aiRzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao R{z}{cot ta :!:3!29 Azdkz CRRGHMCTHAO ta ]kcg

    3:4 ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 2=!:=!:229(

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    19/170

    2=!:2!:229 3:9 DKMGCZCTHAO ai Fkzcgda Jatkgfa Ho ]{rrazt ai Naadgk.}Lklazcod{l Ho ]{rrazt ai Naangk.} Rzara}kd Iazl ai RzkghlhoczxHo`{omthao R{z}{cot ta :!:3!29 Azdkz/ zk CRRGHMCTHAO ta ]kcg 3:4Kvfhjht} C tfza{nf M Ihgkd [odkz ]kcg R{z}{cot ta Rzatkmthyk Azdkz

    Kotkzkd 3:!:>!2; ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd02=!:=!:229(

    2=!:2!:229 3:> DKMGCZCTHAO ai Codzk~ R Jzhdnk} Ho ]{rrazt ai Naangk.}Lklazcod{l ho ]{rrazt ai Naangk.} Rzara}kd Iazl ai RzkghlhoczxHo`{omthao R{z}{cot ta :!:3!29 Azdkz zk CRRGHMCTHAO ta ]kcg 3:4 ihgkdjx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 2=!:=!:229(

    2=!:2!:229 3:6 RZAAI AI ]KZYHMK ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom' zk Lklazcod{lho ]{rrazt ai Lathao 3:; ' Dkmgczcthao &Lathao zkgctkd(' Dkmgczcthao&Lathao zkgctkd( 3:9 ' Dkmgczcthao &Lathao zkgctkd( 3:> ' ~c} }kzykd ao=!:2!29/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 2=!:=!:229(

    2=!:2!:229 3;= RGCHOTHII.] JZHKI Zk Iazl ai Rzkghlhohczx Ho`{omthao ihgkd jx

    Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 24!3=!:229(

    2=!:2!:229 3;4 DKMGCZCTHAO ai Oazlco Pcdc ho ]{rrazt ai Rkzikmt 32.} Jzhki zkIazl ai Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao 3;= ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~'( &Kotkzkd0 24!3=!:229(

    2=!::!:229 Tzco}lh}}hao ai Oathmk ai Crrkcg cod Damekt ]fkkt ta [] Ma{zt aiCrrkcg} zk0 Crrkcg ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt' 3:= / &nfcr' ( &Kotkzkd0 2=!::!:229(

    2=!::!:229 3:8 AZDKZ Nzcothon Crrghmcthao ta Ihgk Kvfhjht} ta tfk Dkmgczcthao aiFkzcgda Jatkgfa Ho ]{rrazt ai Lklazcod{l ho ]{rrazt ai Naangk.}Rzara}kd Iazl ai Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao R{z}{cot ta :!:3!29 Azdkz[odkz ]kcg jx @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp0 NZCOTKD/ zk CRRGHMCTHAO ta]kcg 3:4 &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 2=!:=!:229(

    2=!::!:229 3=2 ]KCGKD DAM[LKOT ZK0 KVFHJHT] C TFZA[NF M ta tfkDkmgczcthao ai Fkzcgda Jatkgfa Ho ]{rrazt ai Lklazcod{l ho ]{rrazt aiRzara}kd Iazl ai Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao R{z}{cot ta :!:3!29 Azdkz &d~'( &Kotkzkd0 2=!:=!:229(

    2=!::!:229 3=3 RZKGHLHOCZX HO@[OMTHAO OATHMK AI MZA]],CRRKCG!Zkrzk}kotcthao ]tctklkot ta 8tf MMC ihgkd jx dkikodcotNaangk Hom/ Crrkcg ai Azdkz 338 Ihgkd Ao0 2:!3>!295 Kotkzkd Ao02:!:3!29/ Ihghon ikk $:;;' Rchd' zkmkhrt o{ljkz 6=4;3/ mm0 Codzk~ R/Jzhdnk}5 Z{}}kgg @/ Izcmelco5 @kiizkx O/ Lc{}okz5 Dcohkg @/ Maarkz5Cotfaox @/ Lcg{ttc/ &mjz' ( Ladhihkd ao =!:4!:229 &mjz' (/ &Kotkzkd0

    2=!:4!:229(

    2=!::!:229 Mhyhg Crrkcg} Damekthon ]tctklkot zkmkhykd izal dkikodcot Naangk Homiaz~czdkd ta 8tf MMC/ ZK0 Crrkcg ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt 3=3 / &mjz' ( &Kotkzkd02=!:4!:229(

    2=!::!:229 3=: TZCO]MZHRT DK]HNOCTHAO COD AZDKZHON IAZL Iaz Dctk}033!>!2;5 Ma{zt Zkraztkz0 Gk}ghk C/ Ehon5 Zk0 Crrkcg ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt' 3:=/ &nfcr' ( &Kotkzkd0 2=!:4!:229(

    2=!:4!:229 Tzco}lh}}hao ai Oathmk ai Crrkcg cod Damekt ]fkkt ta [] Ma{zt ai

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    20/170

    Crrkcg} zk0 Crrkcg ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt 3=3 / &mjz' ( &Kotkzkd0 2=!:4!:229(

    2=!:>!:229 3== AZDKZ Nzcothon Crrghmcthao ta Ihgk Dkmgczcthao} ai Zcdfhec Lcgrcohcod @k}}hk @hcon cod Razthao} ai Naadgk Hom.} Zk}rao}k ta Rgchothii.} JzhkiZk Iazl ai Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao [odkz ]kcg jx @{dnk C Fa~czd Lctp0NZCOTKD/ &d~' ( Ladhihkd ao =!:6!:229 &d~' (/ &Kotkzkd0 2=!:6!:229(

    2=!:>!:229 3=4 ]KCGKD DAM[LKOT ZK]RAO]K ta Rgchothii .} Jzhki Zk Iazl aiRzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao &[ozkdcmtkd Ykz}hao( &d~' ( Ladhihkd ao=!:8!:229 &d~' (/ &Kotkzkd0 2=!:6!:229(

    2=!:>!:229 3=; ]KCGKD DAM[LKOT DKMGCZCTHAO ai Zcfhec Lcgrcoh ho ]{rraztai Naangk.} Zk}rao}k ta Rgchothii.} Jzhki Zk Iazl ai RzkghlhoczxHo`{omthao &d~' ( Ladhihkd ao =!:8!:229 &d~' (/ &Kotkzkd0 2=!:6!:229(

    2=!:>!:229 3=9 ]KCGKD DAM[LKOT DKMGCZCTHAO ai @k}}hk @hcon Ho ]{rrazt aiNaangk.} Zk}rao}k ta Rgchothii.} Jzhki Zk Iazl ai Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao&d~' ( Ladhihkd ao =!:8!:229 &d~' (/ &Kotkzkd0 2=!:6!:229(

    2=!:>!:229 3=> ZK]RAO]K ta Rgchothii.} Jzhki Zknczdhon Iazl ai Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao&Zkdcmtkd Ykz}hao( ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &`r' ( &Kotkzkd0

    2=!:8!:229(

    2=!:>!:229 3=6 DKMGCZCTHAO ai CODZK^ R/ JZHDNK] ho }{rrazt ai NaangkZk}rao}k ta Rgchothii.} Jzhki Zknczdhon Iazl ai Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao3=> ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &`r' ( &Kotkzkd0 2=!:8!:229(

    2=!:>!:229 3=8 CRRGHMCTHAO ta Ihgk Razthao} ai Naadgk Hom Zk}rao}k ta Rgchothii Jzhkizknczdhon iazl ai rzkghlhoczx ho`{omthao cod Dkmgczcthao} ai ZcdfhecLcgrcoh cod @k}}hk @hcon [odkz ]kcg ihgkd jx dkikodcot Naangk Hom/Gadnkd Rzara}kd Azdkz cod [odkz ]kcg Dam{lkot}/ &`r' ( &Kotkzkd02=!:8!:229(

    2=!:>!:229 342 RZAAI AI ]KZYHMK Zk}rao}k ta Rgchothii .} Jzhki Zknczdhon Iazl aiRzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao &Zkdcmtkd Ykz}hao( 3=> ' Dkmgczcthao ai

    CODZK^ R/ JZHDNK] ho }{rrazt ai Naangk Zk}rao}k ta Rgchothii.}Jzhki Zknczdhon Iazl ai Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao 3=6 ' CRRGHMCTHAO taIhgk Razthao} ai Naadgk Hom Zk}rao}k ta Rgchothii Jzhki zknczdhon iazl airzkghlhoczx ho`{omthao cod Dkmgczcthao} ai Zcdfhec Lcgrcoh cod @k}}hk@hcon [odkz ]kcg 3=8 ' ~c} }kzykd ao =!:>!:229 ihgkd jx dkikodcotNaangk Hom/ &`r' ( &Kotkzkd0 2=!:8!:229(

    2=!:>!:229 343 ZKRGX JZHKI ai Rgchothii zknczdhon iazl ai rzkghlhoczx ho`{omthao ihgkdjx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &`r' ( &Kotkzkd0 2=!:8!:229(

    2=!:>!:229 34: DKMGCZCTHAO ai OAZLCO PCDC ho }{rrazt ai Rkzikmt 32 JZHKI

    zknczdhon iazl ai rzkghlhoczx ho`{omthao 343 ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32Hom/ &`r' ( &Kotkzkd0 2=!:8!:229(

    2=!:>!:229 34= DKMGCZCTHAO ai AIIHZ N[TKGPAO ho }{rrazt ai Rkzikmt 32 ZkrgxJzhki zknczdhon iazl ai rzkghlhoczx ho`{omthao 343 ihgkd jx RgchothiiRkzikmt 32 Hom/ &`r' ( &Kotkzkd0 2=!:8!:229(

    2=!:>!:229 344 ]KCGKD DAM[LKOT , DKMGCZCTHAO ai JAJ ]G[LCO ho}{rrazt ai Rkzikmt 32 Zkrgx Jzhki zknczdhon iazl ai rzkghlhoczx

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    21/170

    ho`{omthao/ &`r' ( &Kotkzkd0 2=!:8!:229(

    2=!:>!:229 34; TZCO]MZHRT DK]HNOCTHAO COD AZDKZHON IAZL Iaz Dctk}033!>!2;5 Rzkghlhoczx Fkczhon5 Ma{zt Zkraztkz0 Gk}ghk Ehon5 Zk0 Crrkcg taMhzm{ht Ma{zt' 3=3 / &nfcr' ( &Kotkzkd0 2=!:8!:229(

    2=!=2!:229 349 LHO[TK] AI HO MFCLJKZ] AZDKZ jx @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp 0 Aotfk Ma{zt.} a~o lathao' tfk Ma{zt fkzkjx maotho{k} tfk I{ztfkzMao}aghdctkd ]mfkd{ghon Maoikzkomk 3:3 izal 4!=!29 ta 4!3>!29 ct 30=2r/l/ Ma{zt Zkraztkz0 Oat Zkraztkd/ &}la' ( &Kotkzkd0 2=!=2!:229(

    2=!=2!:229 34> OATHIHMCTHAO jx Mhzm{ht Ma{zt ai Crrkggctk Damekt O{ljkz 29,;;429' 8tf MMC zknczdhon Crrkcg ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt' 3:= ihgkd jx Rkzikmt32 Hom/ &nfcr' ( &Kotkzkd0 2=!=2!:229(

    24!2=!:229 3;2 I[ZTFKZ @AHOT ZKRAZT ai Z{gk :9&i(Lkkthon ihgkd5 k}thlctkd gkontfai tzhcg 3: ta :2 dcx}/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 24!32!:229(

    24!24!:229 3;3 AZDKZ izal 8tf MMC ihgkd c} ta Crrkcg ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt' 3:= ihgkd jx

    Rkzikmt 32 Hom' Crrkcg ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt' 3=3 ihgkd jx Naangk Hom' MMC -29,;;429' 29,;;4:;/ Azdkz zkmkhykd ho tfh} dh}tzhmt ao 4!9!29/ Crrkcg}

    O{ljkz 29,;;42;' 29,;;429' 29,;;4:; czk rzkghlhoczx ho`{omthaocrrkcg}/ Cmmazdhongx' Ohotf Mhzm{ht Z{gk =,= }fcgg crrgx/ Tfk ma{zt }{c}raotk mao}aghdctk} crrkcg o{ljkz 29,;;42; cod 29,;;429/ Cddhthaocggx'tfk ma{zt oatk} tfct o{ljkz 29,;;4:; h} c mza}},crrkcg ai tfk }clk azdkzct h}}{k ho o{ljkz 29,;;429/ Hi tfkx fcyk oat cgzkcdx daok }a' ~htfho >mcgkodcz dcx} ai tfk ihghon dctk ai tfh} azdkz' tfk rczthk} }fcgg lcekczzconklkot} ta ajtcho izal tfk ma{zt zkraztkz co aiihmhmcg tzco}mzhrt airzamkkdhon} ho tfk dh}tzhmt ma{zt tfct ~hgg jk homg{dkd ho tfk zkmazd aocrrkcg/ Tfk jzhki }mfkd{gk h} }kt/ &nfcr' ( &Kotkzkd0 24!33!:229(

    24!29!:229 346 MKZTHIHMCTK AI ZKMAZD Tzco}lhttkd ta []MC zk Crrkcg ta Mhzm{ht

    Ma{zt' 3:= ihgkd jx Rkzikmt 32 Hom' 5 Ma{zt ai Crrkcg} Mc}k O{ljkz0 29,;;429/ &nfcr' ( &Kotkzkd0 24!29!:229(

    24!29!:229 3;; ZKIHGHON AI RGCHOTHII.] JZHKI zk Iazl ai Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao5Jzhki ~c} Rzkyha{}gx Ihgkd ao =!:2!29 J{t Dak} oat Crrkcz ao tfkDamekt ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 24!3=!:229(

    24!29!:229 3;9 ZKIHGHON ai tfk DKMGCZCTHAO ai Oazlco Pcdc Ho ]{rrazt aiRkzikmt 32.} Jzhki Zk Iazl ai Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao5 Dkmgczcthao ~c}Rzkyha{}gx Ihgkd ao =!:2!29 j{t dak} oat crrkcz ao tfk damekt zk Jzhki&oao,lathao oao,crrkcg( 3;; ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' (&Kotkzkd0 24!3=!:229(

    24!2>!:229 348 OATHIHMCTHAO jx Mhzm{ht Ma{zt ai Crrkggctk Damekt O{ljkz 29,;;4:;' 8tf MMC zknczdhon Crrkcg ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt' 3=3 ihgkd jx NaangkHom/ &mjz' ( &Kotkzkd0 24!2>!:229(

    24!33!:229 3;: @AHOT ]THR[GCTHAO Iaz ]tcx ai Rzamkkdhon} Zknczdhon Clcpao/Malcod C8/Mal Aogx Rkodhon Z{ghon Jx Ma{zt ai Crrkcg} cod AZDKZ jx@{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp0 R{z}{cot ta tfk ]thr{gcthao ai tfk rczthk} codihodhon naad mc{}k tfkzkiazk tfk Ma{zt fkzkjx AZDKZ]0 Dh}maykzx'lathao}' cod cgg atfkz rzamkkdhon} ho tfk cjayk,kothtgkd mao}aghdctkdcmthao cncho}t Clcpao/mal cod C8/mal aogx &Mc}k 2;,4>;=( }fcgg jk

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    22/170

    }tcxkd {othg khtfkz h( tfk 8tf Mhzm{ht h}}{k} c dkmh}hao ao Rgchothii.} rkodhoncrrkcg izal tfk Ma{zt.} :!::!29 azdkz dkoxhon Rgchothii.} rzkghlhoczxho`{omthao lathao cncho}t dkikodcot} Clcpao/mal az hh( c rkzhad ai 32laotf} izal tfk dctk tfct Rgchothii ihgk} ht arkohon jzhki ao crrkcg

    ~fhmfkykz malk} ihz}t/ &]kk dam{lkot iaz i{ztfkz hoiazlcthao(&d~' (&Kotkzkd0 24!3:!:229(

    24!33!:229 3;8 Naangk Hom.} AJ@KMTHAO] ta Dkmgczcthao ai Pcdc N{tkggggpao cod]g{lco ho }{rrazt ai Rgchothii} Zkrgx Jzhki zk Iazl ai RzkghlhoczxHo`{omthao ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &}fj' ( &Kotkzkd0 24!36!:229(

    24!3=!:229 392 ZKRAZT ta Ma{zt Zk ]tct{} ai &Rzara}kd( Azdkz Zk Dh}maykzx Lathao zkLATHAO ta Malrkg 89 ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd024!38!:229(

    24!3>!:229 3;6 LHO[TK] AI ]mfkd{ghon Maoikzkomk fkgd jkiazk @{dnk C/ Fa~czdLctp0 Ma{zt h}}{k} tkotcthyk Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao Azdkz cod s{k}thao}ma{o}kg/ Tfk rczthk} czk ta }{jlht yhc klchg c zkd,ghokd ykz}hao ai tfk

    rzara}kd rzkghlhoczx ho`{omthao azdkz/ Tfk rczthk} czk cg}a cdyh}kd ai tfk

    ra}}hjgk zktkothao ai c ma{zt,crrahotkd }rkmhcg cdyh}az/ Ma{zt azdkz} tfkrczthk} ta lkkt cod maoikz zknczdhon c ra}}hjgk }tcx ai dh}maykzx cod taoathix tfk Ma{zt ai tfk a{tmalk ai tfkhz dh}m{}}hao}/ C} c zk}{gt ai tfkrkodhon crrkggctk jzhkihon }mfkd{gk' tfk Ma{zt dkmghok} ta }kt cox rzktzhcgcod tzhcg dctk} ct tfh} thlk/Ma{zt Zkraztkz0 Gk}ghk C/ Ehon/ &}la' (&Kotkzkd0 24!36!:229(

    24!36!:229 3;> MKZTHIHMCTK AI ZKMAZD Tzco}lhttkd ta []MC zk Crrkcg ta Mhzm{htMa{zt' 3=3 ihgkd jx Naangk Hom' 5 Ma{zt ai Crrkcg} Mc}k O{ljkz0 29,

    ;;4:;/ &nfcr' ( &Kotkzkd0 24!36!:229(

    2;!2:!:229 39: AZDKZ izal 8tf MMC ihgkd c} ta Crrkcg ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt' 3:= ihgkd jxRkzikmt 32 Hom' Crrkcg ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt 3=3 ihgkd jx Naangk Hom' MMC -

    29,;;429' 29,;;4:;/ Azdkz zkmkhykd ho tfh} dh}tzhmt ao 2;!24!29/ Tfk}kmao}aghdctkd mc}k} czk rzkghlhoczx ho`{omthao crrkcg}/ Tfk rczthk}.}thr{gctkd lathao} ta clkod tfk jzhkihon }mfkd{gk} czk nzcotkd/ Jzhki}mfkd{gk }kt/ &mjz' ( &Kotkzkd0 2;!28!:229(

    2;!26!:229 393 RZKGHLHOCZX HO@[OMTHAO AZDKZ jx @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp0TFK MA[ZT TFKZKIAZK AZDKZ] COD DKMZKK] C] IAGGA^]03( Naangk h} rzkghlhoczhgx ko`ahokd izal koncnhon ho tfk hoizhonhonmaod{mt dk}mzhjkd ho tfk Hohthcg Azdkz/ &]kk dam{lkot iaz i{ztfkzhoiazlcthao(&d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 2;!28!:229(

    2;!39!:229 39> TZCO]MZHRT ihgkd iaz rzamkkdhon} fkgd ao 4!3>!29/ Ma{zt Zkraztkz0Gk}ghk Ehon/ &nfcr' ( &Kotkzkd0 2;!:4!:229(

    2;!38!:229 394 AZDKZ jx @{dnk ]tkrfko @/ Fhgglco' zk LATHAO ta Malrkg Co}~kz}ta Hotkzzanctazhk} ai Rgchothii LATHAO ta Malrkg 328 &}j{' ( &Kotkzkd02;!::!:229(

    2;!:3!:229 399 ZKMKHRT AI ZKRAZTKZ] TZCO]MZHRT ai rzamkkdhon} iaz tfkiagga~hon dctk}0 4!3>!29 Ma{zt Zkraztkz0 Gk}ghk Ehon &nfcr' ( &Kotkzkd02;!:4!:229(

    2;!::!:229 39= AZDKZ jx @{dnk ]tkrfko @/ Fhgglco' zk LATHAO iaz Azdkz iaz Malrkg

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    23/170

    Dkikodcot Naangk Hom ta Co}~kz Hotkzzanctazhk} 322 &}j{' ( &Kotkzkd02;!::!:229(

    2;!::!:229 396 OATHMK AI CRRKCG ta 8tf MMC ihgkd jx rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/Crrkcg ai Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao' 393 Ihgkd Ao0 ;!6!295 Kotkzkd Ao0;!8!295 Ihghon ikk $ 4;; rchd/ mm0 @kiizkx O/ Lc{}okz5 Codzk~ R/ Jzhdnk}5

    Lcze T/ @co}ko &dlcr' ( &Kotkzkd0 2;!:9!:229(

    2;!::!:229 CRRKCG IKK RCHD0 zk Crrkcg ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt 396 c} ta RgchothiiRkzikmt 32 Hom5 Zkmkhrt O{ljkz0 6;6;2 ho tfk cla{ot ai $4;;/ &gz' (&Kotkzkd0 29!28!:229(

    2;!:=!:229 39; LHO[TK] AI HO MFCLJKZ] AZDKZ fkgd jkiazk @{dnk ]tkrfko @/Fhgglco 0 Rgchothii fc} rzkyha{}gx hodhmctkd tfct ht ~hgg oat jk ihghon cLathao ta ]tcx Dh}maykzx/ Hi Naangk hotkod} ta da }a ho tfk okcz i{t{zk'ht}fcgg cdyh}k tfk ma{zt oa gctkz tfco @{ok 3' :229/ Hi Naangk dak} oat ihgk cLathao ta }tcx dh}maykzx ho tfk okcz i{t{zk' tfk ma{zt ~hgg rzamkkd ~htftfk dh}maykzx lcttkz ~fhmf fcyk rzkyha{}gx jkko tceko {odkz

    }{jlh}}hao/Ma{zt Zkraztkz0 oaok rzk}kot/ &}j{' ( &Kotkzkd0 2;!:=!:229(

    2;!:=!:229 3>; TZCO]MZHRT DK]HNOCTHAO COD AZDKZHON IAZL Iaz Dctk}04!3>!295 Ma{zt Zkraztkz0 Gk}ghk C/ Ehon5 Ma{zt ai Crrkcg} Mc}k O{ljkz029,;;4295 Zk0 Crrkcg ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt' 3:= &nfcr' ( &Kotkzkd029!3;!:229(

    29!2:!:229 3>3 ]KCGKD DAM[LKOT KV RCZTK CRRGHMCTHAO iaz Azdkz iazLadhixhon tfk Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao Azdkz Kotkzkd ;!8!295Lklazcod{l ai Rahot} cod C{tfazhthk} ho ]{rrazt Tfkzkai &[ozkcdcmtkdykz}hao( &d~' ( Ladhihkd ao 9!3:!:229 &d~' (/ &Kotkzkd0 29!3:!:229(

    29!2:!:229 3>: ]KCGKD DAM[LKOT DKMGCZCTHAO ai Zcdfhec Lcgrcoh ho]{rrazt ai Naangk.} Kv Rcztk Crrghmcthao iaz co Azdkz Ladhixhon tfk

    Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao Azdkz Kotkzkd ;!8!29 &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 29!3:!:229(

    29!2:!:229 3>9 KV RCZTK CRRGHMCTHAO ta ladhix Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao 393 5lklazcod{l ihgkd jx dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &gm' ( &Kotkzkd0 29!3;!:229(

    29!2:!:229 3>> CRRGHMCTHAO iaz Gkcyk ta Ihgk razthao ai kv rcztk ta ladhixrzkghlhoczx ho`{omthao azdkz cod dkmgczcthao ai Zcdfhec Lcgrcoh {odkz}kcg ihgkd jx dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &gm' ( &Kotkzkd0 29!3;!:229(

    29!2:!:229 3>6 RZAAI AI ]KZYHMK zk KV RCZTK CRRGHMCTHAO ta ladhix zkRzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao' 393 3>9 ' CRRGHMCTHAO iaz Gkcyk ta Ihgkrazthao ai kv rcztk ta ladhix rzkghlhoczx ho`{omthao azdkz cod dkmgczcthaoai Zcdfhec Lcgrcoh {odkz }kcg 3>> cod }{rrazthon dam{lkot} ~kzk

    }kzykd ao 9!:!29 jx icv cod lchg ihgkd jx dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &gm' (&Kotkzkd0 29!3;!:229(

    29!2;!:229 3>4 ARRA]HTHAO ta KV RCZTK CRRGHMCTHAO iaz Azdkz iaz Ladhixhontfk Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao Azdkz 3>3 ihgkd jx rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/&rmg' ( &Kotkzkd0 29!34!:229(

    29!2;!:229 3>8 AZDKZ jx @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp nzcothon dkikodcot Naangk}CRRGHMCTHAO iaz Gkcyk ta Ihgk razthao ai kv rcztk ta ladhixrzkghlhoczx ho`{omthao azdkz cod dkmgczcthao ai Zcdfhec Lcgrcoh {odkz

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    24/170

    }kcg 3>> &gm' ( &Kotkzkd0 29!3;!:229(

    29!29!:229 398 OATHIHMCTHAO jx Mhzm{ht Ma{zt ai Crrkggctk Damekt O{ljkz 29,;;>;8' 8tf MMC zknczdhon Crrkcg ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt 396 ihgkd jx Rkzikmt 32Hom'/ &dlcr' ( &Kotkzkd0 29!29!:229(

    29!2>!:229 36= RZKGHLHOCZX HO@[OMTHAO OATHMK AI CRRKCG CODZKRZK]KOTCTHAO ]TCTKLKOT ta 8tf MMC ihgkd jx dkikodcotNaangk Hom/ Crrkcg ai Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao' 393 Ihgkd Ao0 ;!26!295Kotkzkd Ao0 ;!28!295 Ihghon ikk $4;;5 Rchd5 zkmkhrt o{ljkz 6;6;2/ mm0Codzk~ R/ Jzhdnk}5 Z{}}kgg @/ Izcmelco' @kiizkx O/ Lc{}okz' Dcokhg @/Maarkz' Cotfaox @/ Lcg{ttc &gz' ( &Kotkzkd0 29!38!:229(

    29!2>!:229 Mhyhg Crrkcg} Damekthon ]tctklkot zkmkhykd izal dkikodcot Naangk Homiaz~czdkd ta 8tf MMC/ jx Ikdkv5 ZK0 Crrkcg ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt' 36= Ihgkdao0 9!2>!295 Kotkzkd ao0 9!38!29 &gz' ( &Kotkzkd0 29!38!:229(

    29!26!:229 3>2 AZDKZ jx @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp0 Naangk.} Kv Rcztk Crrghmcthao iaz coAzdkz Ladhixhon tfk Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao Azdkz Kotkzkd ;!8!29 h}

    DKOHKD/ &}la' ( &Kotkzkd0 29!26!:229(

    29!28!:229 3>= OATHMK ai Dkra}ht ai Mc}fhkz.} Mfkme &$322'222( R{z}{cot taRzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao Azdkz ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' (&Kotkzkd0 29!3=!:229(

    29!28!:229 362 OATHMK AI LATHAO COD LATHAO ta ]tcx Dh}maykzx ihgkd jxDkikodcot Naangk Hom/ Lathao }kt iaz fkczhon ao >!:4!:229 ct 32022 CLjkiazk @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp/ &egn' ( &Kotkzkd0 29!39!:229(

    29!28!:229 363 DKMGCZCTHAO ai ]{}co K Gkk ho }{rrazt ai LATHAO ta ]tcxDh}maykzx 362 ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &egn' ( &Kotkzkd029!39!:229(

    29!28!:229 36: RZAAI AI ]KZYHMK ihgkd jx Dkikodcot cod Ma{otkzmgchlcot NaangkHom' zk LATHAO ta ]tcx Dh}maykzx 362 ' Dkmgczcthao ai ]{}co K Gkk 363

    ' Kvfhjht K' N' H' @' E &cgg Kvfhjht} maoihdkothcg,,IHGKD [ODKZ ]KCG(~c} }kzykd ao 9!8!29/ &egn' ( &Kotkzkd0 29!39!:229(

    29!28!:229 366 CRRGHMCTHAO ta Ihgk [odkz ]kcg tfk @ahot ]thr{gcthao Zk0 Rkzikmt 32.}Lathao ta Malrkg Naangk ta Rzad{mk Dam{lkot} &Kvfhjht K( cod tfkDkmgczcthao} ai Zcdfhec Lcgrcoh &Kvfhjht} N cod H( Dhcok Tcon &Kvfhjht@( cod Gc~zkomk Xa{ &Kvfhjht E( ho ]{rrazt ai Naangk.} Arra}hthao taRkzikmt 32.} Lathao ta Malrkg R{z}{cot ta Rzatkmthyk Azdkz KotkzkdDkmkljkz :>' :22; ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ Gadnkd Rzara}kdAzdkz Kvfhjht} K ) N' H , E/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 29!:2!:229(

    29!3:!:229 383 AZDKZ Zk Crrghmcthao ta Ihgk Kvfhjht} K'N'H'@ cod E ai tfk Dkmgczcthaoai ]{}co K Gkk ho ]{rrazt ai Naangk Hom.} Lathao ta ]tcx [odkz ]kcg jx@{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp0 NZCOTKD/ zk CRRGHMCTHAO ta ]kcg 366 &d~'( &Kotkzkd0 29!:3!:229(

    29!3:!:229 384 ]KCGKD DAM[LKOT KVFHJHT K ta tfk Dkmgczcthao ai ]{}co K Gkk ho]{rrazt ai Naangk Hom.} Lathao ta ]tcx Dh}maykzx &d~' ( &Kotkzkd029!:3!:229(

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    25/170

    29!3:!:229 38; ]KCGKD DAM[LKOT KVFHJHT N Ta tfk Dkmgczcthao ai ]{}co K Gkkho ]{rrazt ai Naangk Hom.} Lathao ta ]tcx Dh}maykzx &d~' ( &Kotkzkd029!:3!:229(

    29!3:!:229 389 ]KCGKD DAM[LKOT KVFHJHT H ta tfk Dkmgczctaho ai ]{}co K Gkk ho]{rrazt ai Naangk Hom.} Lathao ta ]tcx Dh}maykzx &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0

    29!:3!:229(

    29!3:!:229 38> ]KCGKD DAM[LKOT KVFHJHT @ ta tfk Dkmgczcthao ai ]{}co K Gkk ho]{rrazt ai Naangk Hom.} Lathao ta ]tcx Dh}maykzx &d~' ( &Kotkzkd029!:3!:229(

    29!3:!:229 386 ]KCGKD DAM[LKOT KVFHJHT E ta tfk Dkmgczcthao ai ]{}co K Gkk ho]{rrazt ai Naangk Hom.} Lathao ta ]tcx Dh}maykzx &d~' ( &Kotkzkd029!:3!:229(

    29!3=!:229 IHOCOMHCG KOTZX0 Zkmkhykd $322'222/22 hota tfk zknh}tzx ai tfkMa{zt izal Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &ke' ( &Kotkzkd0 29!3=!:229(

    29!3=!:229 364 CRRGHMCTHAO ta Ihgk Razthao} ai Naangk.} Kv Rcztk Crrghmcthao Iaz]tcx ai tfk ;!8!29 Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao cod Kvfhjht C ta tfk Dkmgczcthao

    ai @koohikz C Naghoykc{v [odkz ]kcg ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/Gadnkd Rzara}kd Azdkz cod Kv Rcztk [odkz ]kcg/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd029!38!:229(

    29!3=!:229 36; KV RCZTK CRRGHMCTHAO Iaz ]tcx ai tfk ;!8!29 RzkghlhoczxHo`{omthao5 Lklazcod{l ai Rahot} cod C{tfazhthk} ho ]{rrazt Tfkzkai5]{rrazthon Dkmgczcthao ai @koohikz C Naghoykc{v &Zkdcmtkd Ykz}hao(ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ Gadnkd Rzara}kd Azdkz/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd029!38!:229(

    29!3=!:229 369 RZAAI AI ]KZYHMK ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom' zk CRRGHMCTHAO

    ta ]kcg 364 ' KV RCZTK CRRGHMCTHAO ta ]tcx rkodhon RzkghlhoczxHo`{omthao 36; ' ~c} }kzykd ao 9!3=!29/ &]kk dam{lkot iaz cddhthaocgdam{lkot} }kzykd( &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 29!38!:229(

    29!34!:229 368 ARRA]HTHAO ta Naangk.} KV RCZTK CRRGHMCTHAO Iaz ]tcx Ai tfkRzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao Azdkz 36; ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' (&Kotkzkd0 29!:3!:229(

    29!34!:229 382 AZDKZ Nzcothon Crrghmcthao ta Ihgk Razthao} ai Naangk.} Kv RcztkCrrghmcthao Iaz ]tcx ai tfk ;!8!29 Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao cod Kvfhjht Cta tfk Dkmgczcthao ai @koohikz C Naghoykc{v [odkz ]kcg jx @{dnk C/Fa~czd Lctp0 NZCOTKD/ zk CRRGHMCTHAO ta ]kcg 364 &d~' (&Kotkzkd0 29!:3!:229(

    29!34!:229 38= ]KCGKD DAM[LKOT KV RCZTK CRRGHMCTHAO Iaz ]tcx ai tfk;!8!29 Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao5 Lklazcod{l ai Raot} cod C{tfazhthk}5]{rrazthon Dkmgczcthao ai @koohikz Naghoykc{v &d~' ( &Kotkzkd029!:3!:229(

    29!3;!:229 36> LHO[TK] AI HO MFCLJKZ] AZDKZ fkgd jkiazk @{dnk C/ Fa~czdLctp0 Tfk Ma{zt NZCOT] c tklrazczx }tcx ta rkzlht Naadgk ta crrgx tatfk Ohotf Mhzm{ht iaz c }tcx ai tfk rzkghlhoczx ho`{omthao/ ]tcx }fcggzklcho ho kiikmt {othg 9!:=!29/ &]kk dam{lkot iaz i{ztfkz hoiazlcthao( ZK0

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    26/170

    KV RCZTK CRRGHMCTHAO ta ]tcx rkodhon Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao 36;Ma{zt Zkraztkz0 O!C/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 29!38!:229(

    29!3;!:229 38: RZKGHLHOCZX HO@[OMTHAO OATHMK AI CRRKCG CODZKRZK]KOTCTHAO ]TCTKLKOT ta 8tf MMC ihgkd jx dkikodcotNaangk Hom/ Crrkcg ai Azdkz 3>2 Ihgkd Ao0 9!26!295 Kotkzkd Ao0

    29!26!295 Ihghon ikk $4;;5 Rchd5 zkmkhrt o{ljkz 69339/ mm0 Codzk~ R/Jzhdnk}5 Z{}}kgg @/ Izcmelco' @kiizkx O/ Lc{}okz' Dcohkg @/ Maarkz &gz' (&Kotkzkd0 29!:3!:229(

    29!3;!:229 Mhyhg Crrkcg} Damekthon ]tctklkot zkmkhykd izal dkikodcot Naangk Homiaz~czdkd ta 8tf MMC/ ZK0 Crrkcg ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt' 38: &gz' ( &Kotkzkd029!:3!:229(

    29!3;!:229 388 NANNGK HOM.] ZKRGX Ho ]{rrazt ai Ht} KV RCZTK CRRGHMCTHAOIaz ]tcx ai tfk ;!8!29 Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao 38= ihgkd jx DkikodcotNaangk Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 29!::!:229(

    29!3;!:229 :22 AZDKZ izal 8tf MMC ihgkd c} ta Crrkcg ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt' 3:= ihgkd jx

    Rkzikmt 32 Hom' Crrkcg ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt' 36= ihgkd jx Naangk Hom' Crrkcgta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt' 38: ihgkd jx Naangk Hom' Crrkcg ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt 396ihgkd jx Rkzikmt 32 Hom' MMC - 29,;;42;' 29,;;429' 29,;;4:;' 29,;;>;8/Azdkz zkmkhykd ho tfh} dh}tzhmt ao 29!38!29/ O{ljkz} 29,;;42; cod 29,;;429 czk mao}aghdtkd rzkghlhoczx ho`{omthao crrkcg}/ O{ljkz} 29,;;4:;cod 29,;;>;8 cod rzkghlhoczx ho`{mthao mza}},crrkcg} zkgcthon ta o{ljkz29,;;429/ Ohotf Mhzm{ht Z{gk =,= crrghk} ta tfk}k crrkcg}/ &mjz' (&Kotkzkd0 29!:=!:229(

    29!3;!:229 RGCMKD HO IHGK , OAT []KD zk URzara}kd\ Azdkz Nzcothon NaangkHom.} Kv Rcztk Crrghmcthao iaz ]tcx ai tfk Lcx 8' :229 Rzkglhoczx

    Ho`{omthao }{jlhttkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd029!:9!:229(

    29!38!:229 Tzco}lh}}hao ai Oathmk ai Crrkcg cod Damekt ]fkkt ta [] Ma{zt aiCrrkcg} zk0 Crrkcg ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt' lchg jx Ikdkv5 36= Ihgkd ao09!2>!295 Kotkzkd ao0 9!38!29/ &gz' ( &Kotkzkd0 29!38!:229(

    29!:3!:229 Tzco}lh}}hao ai Oathmk ai Crrkcg cod Damekt ]fkkt ta [] Ma{zt aiCrrkcg}5 zk0 Crrkcg ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt' 38: &gz' ( &Kotkzkd0 29!:3!:229(

    29!:8!:229 :23 ARRA]HTHAO ta Naangk.} LATHAO ta ]tcx Dh}maykzx 362 ihgkd jxRgchothii &Zkdcmtkd Ykz}hao( Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 2>!32!:229(

    29!:8!:229 :2: OATHMK ai Ihghon tfk Iagga~hon Dam{lkot} [odkz ]kcg0 3( Rkzikmt 32.}Arra}hthao ta Naangk.} Lathao ta ]tcx Dh}maykzx5 :( Dkmgczcthao ai

    @kiizkx Lc{}okz ho Arra}hthao ta Naangk.} Lathao ta ]tcx Dh}maykzx5 =(Dkmgczcthao ai Oazlco Pcdc Ho Arra}hthao ta Naangk.} Lathao ta ]tcxDh}maykzx zk LATHAO ta ]tcx rkodhon Dh}maykzx 362 ihgkd jx RgchothiiRkzikmt 32 Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 2>!32!:229(

    29!:8!:229 :2= ]KCGKD DAM[LKOT ARRA]HTHAO TA NAANGK.] LATHAO TA]TCX DH]MAYKZX &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 2>!32!:229(

    29!:8!:229 :24 ]KCGKD DAM[LKOT DKMGCZCTHAO ai @kiizkx Lc{}okz hoArra}hthao ta Naangk.} Lathao ta ]tcx Dh}maykzx&d~' ( &Kotkzkd0

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    27/170

    2>!32!:229(

    29!:8!:229 :2; ]KCGKD DAM[LKOT DKMGCZCTHAO ai Oazlco Pcdc ho Arra}hthaota Naangk.} Lathao ta ]tcx Dh}maykzx &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 2>!32!:229(

    2>!32!:229 :29 OATHIHMCTHAO jx Mhzm{ht Ma{zt ai Crrkggctk Damekt O{ljkz0 29,

    ;;6>>' 8tf MMC zknczdhon Crrkcg ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt' 38: ihgkd jx NaangkHom/ &gz' ( &Kotkzkd0 2>!32!:229(

    2>!3=!:229 :2> OATHIHMCTHAO jx Mhzm{ht Ma{zt ai Crrkggctk Damekt O{ljkz0 29,;;6;4' 8tf MMC zknczdhon Crrkcg ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt' 36= ihgkd jx NaangkHom'/ &gz' ( &Kotkzkd0 2>!3=!:229(

    2>!3>!:229 :28 ZKRGX ho ]{rrazt ai Lathao ta ]tcx Dh}maykzx zk0 Kv Rcztk Crrghmcthao38= ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 2>!:;!:229(

    2>!3>!:229 :32 DKMGCZCTHAO ai @koohikz C Naghoykc{v ho ]{rrazt ai Naangk.} ZkrgxZk Lathao ta ]tcx Dh}maykzx zk KV RCZTK CRRGHMCTHAO ta ]tcxrkodhon ai tfk ;!8!29 Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao 38= ihgkd jx Dkikodcot

    Naangk Hom/ &d~' ( &Kotkzkd0 2>!:;!:229(

    2>!38!:229 :33 ]TCTKLKOT ai Oao,Arra}hthao ta Dkikodcot Naangk Hom. Lathao ta]tcx Dh}maykzx Rkodhon Crrkcg zk LATHAO ta ]tcx rkodhon Dh}maykzx

    362 ihgkd jx Dkikodcot} Clcpao/Mal Hom.} cod C8/Mal Hom/ &d~' (&Kotkzkd0 2>!:6!:229(

    2>!:4!:229 :26 LHO[TK] AI Lathao Fkczhon fkgd jkiazk @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp 0Ma{zt s{k}thao} ma{o}kg' h}}{k} tkotcthyk z{ghon dkoxhon tfk cjayk lathao'cod fkcz} azcg czn{lkot/ Iaz zkc}ao} cod ihodhon} }tctkd ao tfk zkmazd'tfk Ma{zt DKOHK] tfk LATHAO ta ]tcx rkodhon Dh}maykzx 362 / Ma{ztho}tz{mt} ma{o}kg ta ihgk c rzara}kd jzhkihon }mfkd{gk iaz {rmalhondh}maykzx lathao} ta jk oathmkd jkiazk Lcnh}tzctk @{dnk ]tkrfko @/

    Fhgglco/ Ma{zt Zkraztkz0 Gk}ghk C' Ehon/ &}la' ( &Kotkzkd0 2>!:4!:229(

    26!3;!:229 :3: ZKMKHRT AI ZKRAZTKZ] TZCO]MZHRT ai rzamkkdhon} iaz tfk

    iagga~hon dctk0 >!:4!:229 Ma{zt Zkraztkz0 Gk}ghk C Ehon/ &ee} ( &Kotkzkd026!3>!:229(

    26!3;!:229 :3= TZCO]MZHRT ihgkd iaz rzamkkdhon} fkgd ao >!:4!:229/ Ma{zt Zkraztkz0Gk}ghk C Ehon/ &ee} ( &Kotkzkd0 26!3>!:229(

    26!39!:229 :34 LHO[TK] AI HO MFCLJKZ] AZDKZ fkgd jkiazk @{dnk ]tkrfko @/Fhgglco 0' ]kt Fkczhon}0 Tkgkrfaohm ]tct{} Maoikzkomk }kt iaz 6!:8!:22932022 CL jkiazk Lcnh}tzctk @{dnk ]tkrfko @/ Fhgglco/Ma{zt Zkraztkz0oaok rzk}kot/ &}j{' ( &Kotkzkd0 26!:4!:229(

    28!:2!:229 :3; ZKMKHRT AI ZKRAZTKZ] TZCO]MZHRT ai rzamkkdhon} iaz tfkiagga~hon dctk}0 6!:8!295 Ma{zt Zkraztkz0 D Jcjxeho &gz' ( &Kotkzkd028!:>!:229(

    28!:2!:229 :39 TZCO]MZHRT ihgkd iaz rzamkkdhon} fkgd ao 6!:8!29/ Tkgkrfaohm

    Fkczhon5 Ma{zt Zkraztkz0 D/ Jcjxeho/ &gz' ( &Kotkzkd0 28!:>!:229(

    32!:=!:229 :38 ZKMKHRT AI ZKRAZTKZ] TZCO]MZHRT ai rzamkkdhon} iaz tfkiagga~hon dctk}0 32!3:!29 Ma{zt Zkraztkz0 D/ Jcjxeho &kt( &Kotkzkd0

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    28/170

    33!2=!:229(

    32!:=!:229 ::2 TZCO]MZHRT ihgkd iaz rzamkkdhon} fkgd ao 32!3:!29/ Ma{zt Zkraztkz0Dazatfx Jcjxeho/ &kt( &Kotkzkd0 33!2=!:229(

    33!2:!:229 :3> ZKMAZD AO CRRKCG }kot ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt zk0 Crrkcg o{ljkz' 29,

    ;;429 Zkmazd mao}h}t} ai 33 yag{lk}5 32 j{gex dam{lkot} &}kk dam{lkotiaz dktchg}(5 4 tzco}mzhrt} zk Crrkcg ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt' 3:= &dlcr' (&Kotkzkd0 33!2:!:229(

    33!2:!:229 :36 CRRKCG ZKMAZD }kcgkd dam{lkot} }kot ta Mhzm{ht Ma{zt zk0 Crrkcgo{ljkz' 29,;;429/ 38 &}kk dam{lkot iaz dktchg}( dam{lkot} ~kzk }kot~htf tfh} tzco}lhttcg/ &dlcr' ( &Kotkzkd0 33!2:!:229(

    29!:8!:22> ::3 OATHMK AI LATHAO COD LATHAO iaz @{dnlkot ao tfk Rgkcdhon} c}ta tfk Ia{ztf Mc{}k ai Cmthao &Mhzm{lkykothao ai Marxzhnft Rzatkmthao]x}tkl}(5 Lklazcod{l ai rahot} cod c{tfazhthk} ho }{rrazt tfkzkai5 ihgkdjx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/Lathao }kt iaz fkczhon ao >!:=!:22> ct 32022CL jkiazk @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp/ &ln( &Kotkzkd0 2>!3:!:22>(

    2>!29!:22> ::: ZK]RAO]K ta Naangk.} LATHAO iaz @{dnlkot ao tfk Rgkcdhon} c} ta

    tfk Ia{ztf Mc{}k ai Cmthao &Mhzm{lykothao ai Marxzhnft Rzatkmthao]x}tkl}( ::3 ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &ln( &Kotkzkd0 2>!3:!:22>(

    2>!33!:22> ::= OATHMK AI DAM[LKOT DH]MZKRCOMHK] COD AZDKZ jx @{dnkC/ Fa~czd Lctp0 Dkikodcot Clcpao/mal.} Oathmk ai Lathao iaz@{dnlkot ao tfk Rgkcdhon} c} ta tfk Ia{ztf zkmkhykd ao tfk Ia{ztf Mgchl'zkmkhykd ao >!33!2>' h} ta jk ihgkd cod rzamk}}kd/ Tfk ihghon dctk h}Azdkzkd ta jk tfk dctk tfk dam{lkot ~c} }tclrkd zkmkhykd j{t oat ihgkd~htf tfk Mgkze/ &ln( &Kotkzkd0 2>!3=!:22>(

    2>!39!:22> ::6 ZKRGX ho }{rrazt ai LATHAO iaz @{dnlkot ao tfk Rgkcdhon} ::3 ihgkd

    jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &ln( &Kotkzkd0 2>!=3!:22>(

    2>!:=!:22> ::4 OATHMK ai Mfconk ai Cttazokx Hoiazlcthao0 mfconhon cddzk}} ta :3622

    Avoczd ]tzkkt' ]{htk 832' aadgcod Fhgg}' MC 83=9>5 tkgkrfaok 636,88:,>;22 cod =32,93>,63225 icv o{ljkz 636,>39,:>>=5 iaz cttazokx @kiizkxO Lc{}okz/ Ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom &ln( &Kotkzkd0 2>!:4!:22>(

    2>!:=!:22> ICV o{ljkz iaz Cttazokx @kiizkx O Lc{}okz h} 636,>39,:>>=/ &ln(&Kotkzkd0 2>!:4!:22>(

    2>!:=!:22> ::9 LHO[TK] ai Lathao Fkczhon fkgd jkiazk @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp0Rzamkkdhon}0 3( Dkikodcot} Naangk Hom.} LATHAO iaz @{dnlkot ao tfkRgkcdhon} ::3 5 :( Clcpao/mal Hom.} cod C8/mal Hom.} Lathao iaz@{dnlkot ao tfk Rgkcdhon}/ Ma{zt h}}{k} tkotcthyk azdkz ~htfa{t azcg

    czn{lkot/ Iaz zkc}ao} cod ihodhon} }tctkd ao tfk zkmazd' tfk Ma{ztNZCOT] tfk cjayk lathao} ~htf rzk`{dhmk/ Azdkz ta h}}{k/ Ma{ztZkraztkz0 Mhodx Ohzkojkzn/&ln( &Kotkzkd0 2>!=3!:22>(

    2>!:=!:22> ::> LHO[TK] &HO MFCLJKZ] AZDKZ( fkgd jkiazk @{dnk C/ Fa~czdLctp0 C} ho jatf HL] cod Knhglco' okhtfkz ai tfk rgkcdhon} ct h}}{k fkzkmaotcho} cox cggkncthao tfct tfk dkikodcot} cmmk}}kd az rzayhdkd cmmk}} taRkzikmt 32.} ~kj}htk jx cyahdhon az jxrc}}hon tkmfoaganhmcg lkc}{zk}dk}hnokd ta rzatkmt marxzhnftkd ~aze/ C} }tctkd ho HL]' *c mc{}k ai cmthao

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    29/170

    {odkz tfk DLMC dak} oat cmmz{k {rao {oc{tfazhpkd cod ho`{zha{} cmmk}}cgaok5 zctfkz' tfk DLMC btcznkt} tfk mhzm{lykothao ai dhnhtcg ~cgg}n{czdhon marxzhnftkd lctkzhcg/.** HL]' =2> I/]{rr/:d ct ;=: &klrfc}h} hoazhnhocg(/ Tf{}' tfk maod{mt cggknkd ho jatf rgkcdhon} ichg} ta }tctk c mgchl

    mao}tht{thon *mhzm{lykothao* {odkz tfk DLMC/ C} c zk}{gt' tfk Ma{ztNZCOT] jatf Naangk.} ::3 cod Clcpao.} lathao/ Ho}tkcd ai kotkzhon

    `{dnlkot ao tfk rgkcdhon}' ~fhmf hoyhtk} rzamkd{zcg maoi{}hao' tfk Ma{ztdh}lh}}k} tfk ia{ztf mc{}k} ai cmthao ~htf rzk`{dhmk/ &ln( &Kotkzkd02>!=3!:22>(

    2>!=2!:22> ::; TZCO]MZHRT ihgkd iaz rzamkkdhon} fkgd ao 2>!:=!2>/ Ma{zt Zkraztkz0Mhodx G/ Ohzkojkzn/ &jkl' ( &Kotkzkd0 2>!=3!:22>(

    32!2;!:22> :== CRRGHMCTHAO TA IHGK [ODKZ ]KCG TFK DKMGCZCTHAO AIZCDFHEC LCGRCOH ][JLHTTKD HO ][RRAZT AI NAANGK.]ARRA]HTHAO TA RKZIKMT 32.] LATHAO TA MALRKG'R[Z][COT TA RZATKMTHYK AZDKZ KOTKZKD DKM/ :>' :22; zkLATHAO ta Malrkg ::8 ihgkd jx dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ Gadnkd {odkz}kcg cod Azdkz/ &yf( &Kotkzkd0 32!32!:22>(

    32!28!:22> ::8 OATHMK AI LATHAO COD LATHAO ta Malrkg Dkikodcot Naangk taRzad{mk dam{lkot} ihgkd jx rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/Lathao }kt iaz fkczhonao 33!38!:22> ct 2:022 RL jkiazk Lcnh}tzctk @{dnk ]tkrfko @/ Fhgglco/&}j{( &Kotkzkd0 32!32!:22>(

    32!28!:22> :=2 @AHOT ]THR[GCTHAO ta LATHAO ta Malrkg ::8 ihgkd jx RgchothiiRkzikmt 32 Hom/ &}j{( &Kotkzkd0 32!32!:22>(

    32!28!:22> :=3 DKMGCZCTHAO ai @koohikz Naghoykc{v ho arra}hthao LATHAO taMalrkg ::8 ihgkd jx Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ &}j{( &Kotkzkd0 32!32!:22>(

    32!28!:22> :=: DKMGCZCTHAO ai @kiizkx O/ Lc{}okz ho }{rrazt LATHAO ta Malrkg

    ::8 ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &}j{( &Kotkzkd0 32!32!:22>(

    32!3>!:22> :=4 AZDKZ jx @{dnk ]tkrfko @/ Fhgglco' NZCOTHON CRRGHMCTHAO taihgk {odkz }kcg tfk dkmgczcthao ai Zcdfhec Lcgrcoh }{jlhttkd ho }{rrazt aiNaangk.} arra}hthao ta rkzikmt 32.} lathao ta malrkg r{z}{cot tarzatkmthyk azdkz kotkzkd Dkm/ :>' :22; ::8 ' :== / &mc( &Kotkzkd032!3>!:22>(

    33!2;!:22> :=; OATHMK AI LATHAO COD LATHAO ta Rzad{mk Dam{lkot} ,RKZIKMT 32.] ][RRGKLKOTCG LKLAZCOD[L HO ][RRAZT AI

    HT] LATHAO TA MALRKG DKIKODCOT NAANGK' HOM/ TA

    RZAD[MK DAM[LKOT] , ihgkd jx rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/Lathao }kt

    iaz fkczhon ao 33!38!:22> ct 32022 CL jkiazk Lcnh}tzctk @{dnk ]tkrfko@/ Fhgglco/ &Cttcmflkot}0 - 3 Kvfhjht Kczghkz Azdkz zk Rkzikmt 32.} Lathaota Malrkg Dkikodcot Naangk' Hom/ ta Rzad{mk Dam{lkot} cod ta Co}~kzHotkzzanctazhk}(&Lc{}okz' @kiizkx( &Kotkzkd0 33!2;!:22>(

    33!2;!:22> :=9 OATHMK AI LATHAO COD LATHAO ta Rzad{mk Dam{lkot} ,DKMGCZCTHAO AI DZ/ OAZL PCDC HO ][RRAZT AI RKZIKMT

    32.] ][RRGKLKOTCG LKLAZCOD[L HO ][RRAZT AI HT]

    LATHAO TA MALRKG DKIKODCOT NAANGK' HOM/ TA RZAD[MK

    DAM[LKOT] , ihgkd jx rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/Lathao }kt iaz fkczhon ao

    33!38!:22> ct 32022 CL jkiazk Lcnh}tzctk @{dnk ]tkrfko @/ Fhgglco/

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    30/170

    &Cttcmflkot}0 - 3 Kvfhjht Kvfhjht 32 , Naangk Tzkod} Nzcrf- : KvfhjhtKvfhjht 33 , Aykzt{zk }kczmf zk}{gt}- = Kvfhjht Kvfhjht 3: , rcnk 3 ,Naangk Cocgxthm}- 4 Kvfhjht Kvfhjht 3: , rcnk : , Naangk Cocgxthm}- ;Kvfhjht Kvfhjht 3: , rcnk = , Naangk Cocgxthm} Tkzl}- 9 Kvfhjht Kvfhjht

    3= , IAAJZ , Naangk Cocgxthm}- > Kvfhjht Kvfhjht 34 , K,lchg}- 6Kvfhjht Kvfhjht 3; , rcnk 3 , Cd} jx Naangk , Conkghoc @aghk- 8 Kvfhjht

    Kvfhjht 3; , rcnk : , Cd} jx Naangk , @koohikz Garkp- 32 Kvfhjht Kvfhjht39 , Kvmkzrt izal Dkikodcot Naangk' Hom/.} Zk}rao}k ta Rgchothii.} Tfhzd]kt ai Zks{k}t} iaz Cdlh}}hao}- 33 Kvfhjht Kvfhjht 3> , Gkttkz ta tfkOhotf Mhzm{ht Ma{zt ai Crrkcg}- 3: Kvfhjht Kvfhjht 3>,3 , Ok~} Czthmgk ,cttcmflkot ta gkttkz ta Ohotf Mhzm{ht- 3= Kvfhjht Kvfhjht 3>,: ,Dkmgczcthao ai Aiihz N{tkgpao ho ]{rrazt ai Rkzikmt 32.} Zkrgx Jzhki ZkIazl ai Rzkghlhoczx Ho`{omthao , cttcmflkot ta gkttkz ta Ohotf Mhzm{ht- 34

    Kvfhjht Kvfhjht 3>,= , Rzhota{t ai razthao ai ~kj}htk rhm}ma{t/mal zkhlcnk zkmanohthao , cttcmflkot ta gkttkz ta Ohotf Mhzm{ht(&Lc{}okz'@kiizkx( &Kotkzkd0 33!2;!:22>(

    33!2;!:22> :=> ][RRGKLKOT ta LATHAO ta Malrkg ::8 }{rrgklkothon Dkikodcotcod Ma{otkz,Mgchlcot Naangk Hom/.} Arra}hthao ta tfk Lathao ta Malrkg

    ihgkd jx Ma{otkz Mgchlcot Naangk Hom' Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/&Cttcmflkot}0 - 3 ]{rrgklkotcg Dkmgczcthao ai @koohikz C/Naghoykc{v(&]mfkzj' Lcttfk~( &Kotkzkd0 33!2;!:22>(

    33!29!:22> :=6 OATHMK TA IHGKZ AI DKIHMHKOMHK] ho Kgkmtzaohmcggx IhgkdDam{lkot}/ Tfk iagga~hon dkihmhkomx ~c} ia{od homazzkmt dam{lkot txrk

    }kgkmtkd0 ZK LATHAO ta Rzad{mk Dam{lkot} , RKZIKMT 32.]][RRGKLKOTCG LKLAZCOD[L HO ][RRAZT AI HT] LATHAO TA

    MALRKG DKIKODCOT NAANGK' HOM/ TA RZAD[MK DAM[LKOT]

    ,:=; / &mc( &Kotkzkd0 33!29!:22>(

    33!29!:22> :=8 OATHMK TA IHGKZ AI DKIHMHKOMHK] ho Kgkmtzaohmcggx IhgkdDam{lkot}/ Tfk iagga~hon dkihmhkomx ~c} ia{od homazzkmt dam{lkot txrk

    }kgkmtkd0 ZK LATHAO ta Rzad{mk Dam{lkot} , DKMGCZCTHAO AI DZ/OAZL PCDC HO ][RRAZT AI RKZIKMT 32.] ][RRGKLKOTCGLKLAZCOD[L HO ][RRAZT AI HT] LATHAO TA MALRKG

    DKIKODCOT NAANGK' HOM/ TA RZAD[MK DAM[LKOT] ,:=9 /&mc( &Kotkzkd0 33!29!:22>(

    33!39!:22> :42 LHO[TK] AI HO MFCLJKZ] AZDKZ fkgd jkiazk @{dnk ]tkrfko @/Fhgglco 0 zk0 LATHAO ta Malrkg ::8 / Lathao maotho{kd ta 33!:>!:22>ct 80=2c/l/ &}j{( &Kotkzkd0 33!:3!:22>(

    33!:>!:22> :4; LHO[TK] AI HO MFCLJKZ] AZDKZ fkgd jkiazk @{dnk ]tkrfko @/Fhgglco 0 zk0 LATHAO ta Rzad{mk Dam{lkot} :=9 ' LATHAO ta Rzad{mkDam{lkot} :=; / &}j{( &Kotkzkd0 2:!2;!:226(

    3:!32!:22> :43 TZCO]MZHRT ihgkd iaz rzamkkdhon} fkgd ao 33!:>!2> Ma{zt Zkraztkz0F{othontao Ma{zt Zkraztkz}/ &jkl' ( &Kotkzkd0 3:!34!:22>(

    3:!:3!:22> :4: OATHMK ai C}}amhcthao ai Ma{o}kg Ihgkd jx Ma{otkz Mgchlcot NaangkHom' Dkikodcot Naangk Hom &Pkggkz' Lhmfckg( &Kotkzkd0 3:!:3!:22>(

    3:!:9!:22> :4= LCODCTK ai 8tf MMC ihgkd zk0 Crrkcg ta 8tf Mhzm{ht Ma{zt ai Crrkcg}'3:= ' Crrkcg ta 8tf Mhzm{ht Ma{zt ai Crrkcg} 396 ' Crrkcg ta 8tf Mhzm{htMa{zt ai Crrkcg}' 3=3 ' Crrkcg ta 8tf Mhzm{ht Ma{zt ai Crrkcg}' 38: '

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    31/170

    MMC - 29,;;42;' 29,;;429' 29,;;4:;' 29,;;>;8' 29,;;6;4 cod 29,;;6>>/ Tfk @{dnlkot h} ciihzlkd ho rczt' zkykz}kd ho rczt' zklcodkd/Lcodctk zkmkhykd ho tfh} dh}tzhmt ao 3:!:6!:22>/ &dlcr( &Kotkzkd023!32!:226(

    23!32!:226 :44 OATHMK Oathmk ai htfdzc~cg c} Ma{o}kg iaz Rgchothii ihgkd jx rgchothii

    Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &Izcmelco' Z{}}kgg( &Kotkzkd0 23!32!:226(

    2:!33!:226 :49 CRRKCG ZKMAZD ZKT[ZOKD izal 8tf MMC Zkmkhykd0 Yag{lk&}(0 3tfza{nf 335 ]kcgkd Dam{lkot}&}(0 385 Tzco}mzhrt}&}(0 45 ZK0 CrrkcgZkmazd ]kot ta []MC &C,:9( :3> &mcz( &Kotkzkd0 2:!3:!:226(

    2:!34!:226 :4> OATHMK ai Lco{cg Ihghon ihgkd jx Ma{otkz Mgchlcot Naangk Hom'Dkikodcot Naangk Hom ai Dkmg ai Zcmfkg L/ Fkzzhme zk &Rzara}kd( Azdkz5]thr{gcthao ta Ihgk [odkz ]kcg5 &Rzara}kd( Azdkz ta Ihgk [odkz ]kcg5 Rzaaiai ]kzyhmk/ &Pkggkz' Lhmfckg( &Kotkzkd0 2:!34!:226(

    2:!34!:226 :46 DKMGCZCTHAO ai Zcmfkg L/ Fkzzhme zk &Rzara}kd( Azdkz zk Rkzikmt32.} Lathao ta Malrkg ihgkd jx Ma{otkz Mgchlcot Naangk Hom' Dkikodcot

    Naangk Hom/ &Cttcmflkot}0 - 3 Kvfhjht C,H ta Dkmgczcthao ai Zcmfkg L/Fkzzhme(&Pkggkz' Lhmfckg( &Kotkzkd0 2:!34!:226(

    2:!38!:226 :48 CRRGHMCTHAO ai Codzk~ R/ Jzhdnk}' Lhmfckg ]/ Jzarfx' @koohikz C/Naghoykc{v' cod Lcttfk~ C/ ]mfkzj ai ^ho}tao ) ]tzc~o GGR ta^htfdzc~ c} Cttazokxiaz Naangk Hom/ ihgkd jx Dkikodcot codMa{otkzmgchlcot Naangk Hom/ &]mfkzj' Lcttfk~( &Kotkzkd0 2:!38!:226(

    2:!:2!:226 :;2 OATHMK TA IHGKZ AI DKIHMHKOMHK] ho Kgkmtzaohmcggx IhgkdDam{lkot}/ Tfk iagga~hon dkihmhkomx ~c} ia{od0 Rzara}kd Azdkz oat}{jlhttkd c} }krczctk cttcmflkot c} ta CRRGHMCTHAO ai Codzk~ R/Jzhdnk}' Lhmfckg ]/ Jzarfx' @koohikz C/ Naghoykc{v' cod Lcttfk~ C/]mfkzj ai ^ho}tao ) ]tzc~o GGR ta ^htfdzc~ c} Cttazokx iaz Naangk

    Hom/ :48 &}k( &Kotkzkd0 2:!:2!:226(

    2:!:2!:226 :;3 AZDKZ jx @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp0 zk CRRGHMCTHAO ai Codzk~ R/Jzhdnk}' Lhmfckg ]/ Jzarfx' @koohikz C/ Naghoykc{v' cod Lcttfk~ C/]mfkzj ai ^ho}tao ) ]tzc~o GGR ta ^htfdzc~ c} Cttazokxiaz NaangkHom/:48 ' Cttazokx @koohikz C Naghoykc{v5 Lcttfk~ Cgkv ]mfkzj5Codzk~ R Jzhdnk} cod Lhmfckg ] Jzarfx tkzlhoctkd/ HT H] FKZKJXAZDKZKD tfct ^ho}tao ) ]tzc~o GGR cod ht} cttazokx} Codzk~ R/Jzhdnk}' Lhmfckg ]/ Jzarfx' @koohikz C/ Naghoykc{v' cod Lcttfk~ C/]mfkzj czk c{tfazhpkd ta ~htfdzc~ c} ma{o}kg iaz Dkikodcot cod

    Ma{otkzmgchlcot Naangk Hom/ ho tfh} cmthao cod }fcgg fkzkjx jk mao}hdkzkd~htfdzc~o/ &}la( &Kotkzkd0 2:!:2!:226(

    2:!:3!:226 :;: LHO[TK] AI HO MFCLJKZ] AZDKZ ZK KGKMTZAOHM IHGHONfkgd jkiazk @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp &}k( &Kotkzkd0 2:!:3!:226(

    2:!:3!:226 :;= OATHMK ai Crrkczcomk ihgkd jx cttazokx Zcmfkg L Fkzzhme ao jkfcgi aiMa{otkz Mgchlcot Naangk Hom' Dkikodcot Naangk Hom &Fkzzhme' Zcmfkg(&Kotkzkd0 2:!:3!:226(

    2:!::!:226 :;4 AZDKZ jx @{dnk ]tkrfko @/ Fhgglco' zk LATHAO ta Malrkg ::8 &}j{(&Kotkzkd0 2:!::!:226(

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc. v. Google Inc. et al, CV 04-9484 (C.D. Cal., filed 2004) (DOCKET as of 4-28-12)

    32/170

    2=!2;!:226 :;; ]THR[GCTHAO iaz Kvtko}hao ai Thlk ta Ihgk Lathao iaz Zkyhk~ aiOaodh}ra}hthyk Z{ghon ai Lcnh}tzctk @{dnk Fhgglco ihgkd jx Dkikodcotcod Ma{otkzmgchlcot Naangk Hom/ &Cttcmflkot}0 - 3(&Fkzzhme' Zcmfkg(&Kotkzkd0 2=!2;!:226(

    2=!2>!:226 :;9 AZDKZ CRRZAYHON ]THR[GCTHAO AI KVTKO]HAO AI THLK TA

    IHGK LATHAO IAZ ZKYHK^ AI OAODH]RA]HTHYK Z[GHON AILCNH]TZCTK @[DNK FHGGLCO jx @{dnk C/ Fa~czd Lctp' zk]thr{gcthao iaz Kvtko}hao ai Thlk ta Ihgk :;; 0 MA[ZT FKZKJXAZDKZ] tfct' ta tfk kvtkot kcmf rcztx ihgk} c lathao iaz zkyhk~ aiLcnh}tzctk @{dnk Fhgglco.} z{ghon0 Kcmf rcztx.} Lathao iaz Zkyhk~ }fcggjk d{k ao Lczmf 34' :226/ Kcmf rcztx.} Arra}hthao ~hgg jk d{k ao Lczmf:9' :226/ Kcmf rcztx.} Zkrgx ~hgg jk d{k ao Crzhg 4' :226/ Tfk rczthk}.Lathao} ~hgg jk fkczd ao Crzhg 34' :226 ct 32022 c/l/ &}la( &Kotkzkd0

    2=!2>!:226(

    2=!34!:226 :;> OATHMK AI LATHAO COD LATHAO iaz Zkyhk~ ai Razthao} aiLcnh}tzctk @{dnk Fhgglco.} Azdkz ai Ikjz{czx ::' :226 Nzcothon ho RcztRkzikmt 32.} Lathao ta Malrkg Dkikodcot Naangk' Hom/ ta Rzad{mk

    Dam{lkot}' cod Aj`kmthao} Tfkzkta5 Lklazcod{l ai Rahot} codC{tfazhthk} ho ]{rrazt Tfkzkai zk Azdkz :;4 ihgkd jx rgchothii Rkzikmt 32Hom/Lathao }kt iaz fkczhon ao 4!34!:226 ct 32022 CL jkiazk @{dnk C/Fa~czd Lctp/ &Cttcmflkot}0 - 3 Kvfhjht 3- : Kvfhjht :- = Kvfhjht =- 4Kvfhjht 4- ; Rzara}kd Azdkz(&Lc{}okz' @kiizkx( &Kotkzkd0 2=!34!:226(

    2=!34!:226 :;6 OATHMK AI LATHAO COD Ihz}t LATHAO iaz Zkyhk~ ai Azdkz zk0

    Rkzikmt 32.} Lathao Ta Malrkg Dkikodcot Naangk Hom/ Ta Rzad{mkDam{lkot} R{z}{cot ta Rkzikmt 32.} Zks{k}t} iaz Rzad{mthao Oa}/ 3:6,3=3' 3>4' cod 384,389ihgkd jx Dkikodcot cod Ma{otkzmgchlcot NaangkHom/Lathao }kt iaz fkczhon ao 4!34!:226 ct 32022 CL jkiazk @{dnk C/Fa~czd Lctp/ &Cttcmflkot}0 - 3 Dkmgczcthao Dkmgczcthao ai Zcmfkg L/Fkzzhme Zknczdhon Naangk Hom/.} Aj`kmthao} ta tfk Lcnh}tzctk @{dnk.}

    Azdkz ai Ikjz{czx ::' :226- : Kvfhjht Kvfhjht C ta tfk Dkmgczcthao aiZcmfkg L/ Fkzzhme- = Kvfhjht Kvfhjht J ta tfk Dkmgczcthao ai Zcmfkg L/Fkzzhme- 4 Kvfhjht Kvfhjht M ta tfk Dkmgczcthao ai Zcmfkg L/ Fkzzhme- ;

    Rzara}kd Azdkz &Rzara}kd( Azdkz ]{}tchohon Naangk Hom/.} Aj`kmthao} tatfk Lcnh}tzctk @{dnk.} Azdkz ai Ikjz{czx ::' :226(&Pkggkz' Lhmfckg(&Kotkzkd0 2=!34!:226(

    2=!34!:226 :;8 Clkodlkot ta LATHAO iaz Zkyhk~ ai Razthao} ai Lcnh}tzctk @{dnkFhgglco.} Azdkz ai Ikjz{czx ::' :226 Nzcothon ho Rczt Rkzikmt 32.}Lathao ta Malrkg Dkikodcot Naangk' Hom/ ta Rzad{mk Dam{lkot}' codAj`kmthao} Tfkzkta5 Lklazcod{l ai Rahot} cod C{tfazhthk} h :;> ihgkd jxRgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom/ &Lc{}okz' @kiizkx( &Kotkzkd0 2=!34!:226(

    2=!:9!:226 :92 OATHMK ai Lco{cg Ihghon ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom ai Crrghmcthaota Ihgk [odkz ]kcg tfk Iagga~hon Dam{lkot} fhmf Maotcho HoiazlcthaoDk}hnoctkd jx Naangk c} Maoihdkothcg az Fhnfgx Maoihdkothcg0 Rkzikmt32.} Lklazcod{l ho Arra}hthao ta Naangk.} Aj`kmthao} ta @{dnkFhgglco.} Azdkz Nzcothon ho Rczt Rkzikmt 32.} Lathao ta Malrkg5 PcdcDkmgczcthao ho ]{rrazt Tfkzkai/ &Lc{}okz' @kiizkx( &Kotkzkd0 2=!:9!:226(

    2=!:9!:226 :93 OATHMK ai Lco{cg Ihghon ihgkd jx Rgchothii Rkzikmt 32 Hom ai URzara}kd\Azdkz tfct tfk Iagga~hon Dam{lkot} fhmf Maotcho HoiazlcthaoDk}hnoctkd jx Naangk c} Maoihdkothcg!Fhnfgx Maoihdkothcg jk Ihgkd

  • 8/2/2019 Perfect 10 Inc.


Recommended