Perspectives on Polish involvement in development of
nuclear cogeneration
Anna Przybyszewska
National Centre for Nuclear Research in PolandNuclear Energy Division
Technical Meeting on Advances in Non‐Electric Applicationsof Nuclear Energy and on Efficiency Improvement at Nuclear Power Plants
25‐28 August 2015, IAEA Vienna
National Centre for Nuclear ResearchNuclear Energy Division
Primary Energy Consumption
25‐28 August 2015 Technical Meeting on Advances in Non‐Electric Applicationsof Nuclear Energy and on Efficiency Improvement at Nuclear Power Plants 2
solid fossil fuels17.6%
crude oil & petroleum products34.1%
gas23.5%
nuclear heat13.7%
renewable energies11.1%
non‐renewable wastes0.0%
European Union
solid fossil fuels51.8%
crude oil & petroleum products25.4%
gas13.9%
renewable energies8.8%
Poland
Source: Eurostat
National Centre for Nuclear ResearchNuclear Energy Division
Primary energy production in 2014
25‐28 August 2015 Technical Meeting on Advances in Non‐Electric Applicationsof Nuclear Energy and on Efficiency Improvement at Nuclear Power Plants 3
Source: www.stat.gov.pl
National Centre for Nuclear ResearchNuclear Energy Division
Energy transformations in 2013
25‐28 August 2015 Technical Meeting on Advances in Non‐Electric Applicationsof Nuclear Energy and on Efficiency Improvement at Nuclear Power Plants 4
Source: www.stat.gov.pl
National Centre for Nuclear ResearchNuclear Energy Division
District Heating Market
• In Poland exists about 500 thermal stations to provide hot water, district heating (and electricity)
• About 9000 heat sources have power (52% all generation) 5‐50 MWt
25‐28 August 2015 Technical Meeting on Advances in Non‐Electric Applicationsof Nuclear Energy and on Efficiency Improvement at Nuclear Power Plants 5
National Centre for Nuclear ResearchNuclear Energy Division
Advantages of cogeneration
• Cogeneration can reduce the consumption of fossil fuels• Cogeneration can help minimaize CO2 emmissions
25‐28 August 2015 Technical Meeting on Advances in Non‐Electric Applicationsof Nuclear Energy and on Efficiency Improvement at Nuclear Power Plants 6
VS.
National Centre for Nuclear ResearchNuclear Energy Division
Potential of Differend Reactor Types
25‐28 August 2015 Technical Meeting on Advances in Non‐Electric Applicationsof Nuclear Energy and on Efficiency Improvement at Nuclear Power Plants 7
Site types:• 6 chemical plants• 6 refineries• 2 power production/distribution companies
• 1 paper factory
Potential sites in PolandTypes & locations
825‐28 August 2015 Technical Meeting on Advances in Non‐Electric Applicationsof Nuclear Energy and on Efficiency Improvement at Nuclear Power Plants 8
M.Gadecka, Researchesfor HTR‐PL & NC2IR
National Centre for Nuclear ResearchNuclear Energy Division
Potential applications in Poland
25‐28 August 2015 Technical Meeting on Advances in Non‐Electric Applicationsof Nuclear Energy and on Efficiency Improvement at Nuclear Power Plants 9
Near‐term coupling scheme with Steam Generator (SG)
Source: C. Angulo etal. EUROPAIRS: The European project on coupling of High Temperature Reactors with industrial processes,Nuclear Engineering and Design, Vol.251, 2012, p.30‐37, ISSN 0029‐5493
National Centre for Nuclear ResearchNuclear Energy Division
Potential applications in Poland
25‐28 August 2015 Technical Meeting on Advances in Non‐Electric Applicationsof Nuclear Energy and on Efficiency Improvement at Nuclear Power Plants 10
Schematic of steam gasification of hard coal with nuclear processes heat
plant
Concept of steam gasification of coal usingnuclear heat
Source: Xing L. Yan, Ryutaro Hino, Nuclear Hydrogen Production Handbook,CRC Press, 2011, ISBN 1439810842
National Centre for Nuclear ResearchNuclear Energy Division
Potential applications in Poland
25‐28 August 2015 Technical Meeting on Advances in Non‐Electric Applicationsof Nuclear Energy and on Efficiency Improvement at Nuclear Power Plants 11
Diagram of HTGR steam reforming system
Helium Gas
Source: Xing L. Yan, Ryutaro Hino, Nuclear Hydrogen Production Handbook,CRC Press, 2011, ISBN 1439810842
National Centre for Nuclear ResearchNuclear Energy Division
HTR‐PL programme• 12 partners, Led by AGH, Kraków• Funded by Polish Government, budgetca. 1.2 M€
• Duration: 2.5 years from sept. 2012• Aim #1: Feasibility study of constructingindustrial HTR in Poland.
• Aim #2: Improving our knowledge on HTGRs– Thermal – hydraulic calculations– Neutronic calculations– Pebble bed movement simulations– Licensing process review
25‐28 August 2015 Technical Meeting on Advances in Non‐Electric Applicationsof Nuclear Energy and on Efficiency Improvement at Nuclear Power Plants 12
National Centre for Nuclear ResearchNuclear Energy Division
Pebble bed reactor
HTR core reactor model gradually filled with an fuel pebbles.
25‐28 August 2015 Technical Meeting on Advances in Non‐Electric Applicationsof Nuclear Energy and on Efficiency Improvement at Nuclear Power Plants 13
National Centre for Nuclear ResearchNuclear Energy Division
Tempretarue distrubution in the HTR cavity
Performing a CFD analysis
Mesh for CFD analysis of the pebble bed
25‐28 August 2015 Technical Meeting on Advances in Non‐Electric Applicationsof Nuclear Energy and on Efficiency Improvement at Nuclear Power Plants 14
Mean velocity through the domain
National Centre for Nuclear ResearchNuclear Energy Division
Atomic Law in Poland
Review of national legislation in terms of the obstacles for the construction of high‐temperature reactor cogeneration applications.
Provides a unified system to ensure nuclear safety and radiological protection of workers and the general population in Poland.Important provisions concern:
• issuing permits for activities involving exposure to ionizing radiation,• managers responsibilities of organizations operating with the use of
radiation,• President of the NAEA powers to control and supervision over those
activities.
25‐28 August 2015 Technical Meeting on Advances in Non‐Electric Applicationsof Nuclear Energy and on Efficiency Improvement at Nuclear Power Plants 15
National Centre for Nuclear ResearchNuclear Energy Division
Three pillars of the SNETP vision
25‐28 August 2015 Technical Meeting on Advances in Non‐Electric Applicationsof Nuclear Energy and on Efficiency Improvement at Nuclear Power Plants 16
National Centre for Nuclear ResearchNuclear Energy Division
NC2I‐R programme
• Abbreviation for: Nuclear CogenerationIndustrial Initiative ‐ Research
• An answer for Euratom call asking for creationof pan‐european initiative on nuclearco‐generation.
• 21 participants• 2,7 M€, 2013‐15• NCBJ is the leader
25‐28 August 2015 Technical Meeting on Advances in Non‐Electric Applicationsof Nuclear Energy and on Efficiency Improvement at Nuclear Power Plants 17
National Centre for Nuclear ResearchNuclear Energy Division
Strategic objective of NC2I‐R• Identify clearly the status of Europe’s public and private R&D infrastructures and
competences.• Define the safety requirements to prepare for the future licensing process for a
cogeneration demonstrator and limit the associated risk.• Define clear and consensual specifications for the demonstrator, ensuring its
economic viability, its market fit, its future replicability and its safety, in particularfor the coupling scheme, and limiting all construction project risks.
• Managing the knowledge from past projects on HTR and nuclear cogeneration witha comprehensive experience feedback in order to identify potential points ofattention and success factors.
• Prepare a joint roadmap paving the way for today’s European R&D capacitiestowards the commissioning of the specified demonstrator and identify potentialgaps.
• Prepare for and organise the cooperation with non‐European similar programmes topossibly share the demonstrator risk in line with the European interest and tosecure EU’s leadership position in the global competition for HTR.
• Prepare a smooth and inclusive governance for the future of NC2I, engaging allstakeholders including civil society.
25‐28 August 2015 Technical Meeting on Advances in Non‐Electric Applicationsof Nuclear Energy and on Efficiency Improvement at Nuclear Power Plants 18
National Centre for Nuclear ResearchNuclear Energy Division
25‐28 August 2015 Technical Meeting on Advances in Non‐Electric Applicationsof Nuclear Energy and on Efficiency Improvement at Nuclear Power Plants 19
National Centre for Nuclear ResearchNuclear Energy Division
Cooperation with U.S.A.• In the United States, a large R&D programme on HTGR technology called the Next
Generation Nuclear Plant (NGNP).• Collaboration between NC2I and the NGNP Industry Alliance was initiated in 2011
with a first bilateral preparatory workshop, and has recently gained momentum,with two workshops in 2014 which led to the signature of a Memorandum ofUnderstanding (MoU, June 2014) establishing the cooperation framework andintroducing a joint initiative called GEMINI.
• The GEMINI Initiative calls for a simple, transparent, accountable and strongagreement between the U.S. and EU partners to work with their governmentsunder an international agreement framework to carry out the design andregulatory work for the HTGR demonstrator.
25‐28 August 2015 Technical Meeting on Advances in Non‐Electric Applicationsof Nuclear Energy and on Efficiency Improvement at Nuclear Power Plants 20
National Centre for Nuclear ResearchNuclear Energy Division
Wake up for industry
• Poland’s power grid cut electricity suppliesfor industrial users for the first time in almostthree decades because of heatwave.
• There is “no reason to panic” but about 1600companies faced cuts in electricity supplies.
25‐28 August 2015 Technical Meeting on Advances in Non‐Electric Applicationsof Nuclear Energy and on Efficiency Improvement at Nuclear Power Plants 21
For the next years is predicted more restricted emission CO2, SOx and NOxfrom industry as well as some cut electricity supply for industrial users about2020.
National Centre for Nuclear ResearchNuclear Energy Division
Conclusion
25‐28 August 2015 Technical Meeting on Advances in Non‐Electric Applicationsof Nuclear Energy and on Efficiency Improvement at Nuclear Power Plants 22
In Poland is a huge market to deployment nuclearcogeneration also for „plug‐in” application.Most of potential "public end‐users" need SMR‐sizedsource to provide heat for district heating and hotwater.Now Poland is not prepared to construction any SMRfor industrial use, but after 2035 could be excellentplace to deployment this technology.Recently situation could accelerate adaptation SMR inindustry.