Copyright © NoIR 2020 All rights reserved
Laser Safety Eyewear for Law
Enforcement
David W. Bothner, VP Business and Product Development
NoIR Laser, 4975 Technical Drive, Milford, Michigan 48381
Copyright © NoIR 2020 All rights reserved
Objectives
• Understand the state of the times
• Overview lasers and laser safety
• Illustrate the visual effects and injury risk of laser exposure and illuminations
• Detail NoIR GlareShield solutions
• Considerations
Helicopter under laser illumination/attack
Copyright © NoIR 2020 All rights reserved
State of the Times
• Hand-held lasers are being used against aircraft (on average over 6,000 reported
incidents per year) and law enforcement (no reporting mechanism).
• Might be intended as a non-violent act, but it is an act of violence.
• Different concerns for each instance:
• Fixed and rotary wing aircraft: temporary and dazzling flash/glare blindness
balanced against the need to view colored displays, and long exposure
distances.
• For ground personnel: temporary and dazzling flash/glare blindness plus real
risk of retinal injury due to short exposure distances.
532nm green laser hitting a face shield visor
Copyright © NoIR 2020 All rights reserved
State of the Times (additional)
• Fear of injury and being rendered unable to face the threat means the attack is
successful.
• It’s a Federal crime to illuminate aircraft, and in some states a crime to illuminate
police officers.
Helicopter under laser illumination/attack, Hong Kong
protests. Image may be subject to copyright.
Copyright © NoIR 2020 All rights reserved
LightAmplificationbyStimulatedEmissionofRadiation
• Laser energy is coherent, monochromatic and collimated, posing both skin and
eye hazards with energy delivered over time over area.
• Laser energy poses eye hazard, depending upon wavelength, power and
distance from the laser.
• Nominal Hazard Zone (NHZ): Zone of laser operation in which direct or reflected
laser energy exceeds the Maximum Permissible Exposure (MPE) and requires the
use of protective eyewear.
• Readily available, handheld, battery powered diode lasers are powerful enough
to have NHZs of hundreds of meters.
Electromagnetic spectrum absorbed by the human body
Copyright © NoIR 2020 All rights reserved
Eye Hazard Regions• For visible lasers between 400-800nm, the eye is 100,000 times more vulnerable to injury
than the skin. Due to the focusing properties of the eye, irradiance in this region of
1mW/cm2 entering the eye irradiates the retina at 100W/cm2. The bio-effect mechanism is
burning of the retina.
• UV (190-400nm) and Mid/Far IR energy 1400-11,000nm) poses a corneal/lens hazard. The
bio-effect mechanism is burning of the cornea.
Images courtesy of LIA
The human eye
Absorption of energy by the eye
Copyright © NoIR 2020 All rights reserved
Laser ClassificationClass Definition Control Measure
1 Non-hazardous Eyewear not required.
1M
Eye safe visible laser (400-700nm) if
used without magnifying optics.
Eyewear not required unless used with
magnifying optics.
2
Eye safe visible laser (400-700nm) up to
1mW (safe within the blink reflex of
0.25s). Eyewear not required.
2M
Eye safe visible laser (400-700nm) (safe
within the blink reflex of 0.25s) if used
without magnifying optics. Eyewear recommended.
3R
Visible laser with output of 1–5 mW,
Likely unsafe for intrabeam viewing. Eye hazard; eyewear is recommended.
3B
Visible or invisible laser operating
between 5-500mW. Eye hazard for
intrabeam viewing. Eye hazard; eyewear is generally required.
4
Visible or invisible laser operating
above 500mW. Eye and skin hazard for
direct and diffuse exposure. Fire and
burn hazard.
Eye protection and other personal safety
equipment is required.
Presentation type laser pointers are Class 2 (<1mW) or Class 3R (<5 mW).
Handheld lasers are class 3B and operate between >5–<500 mW and Class 4
lasers operate above 500 mW.
Copyright © NoIR 2020 All rights reserved
NOHDNOHD: Nominal Ocular Hazard Distance is the distance beyond which a specific laser
presents no eye or skin hazard (energy delivered is lower than the MPE - Maximum Permissible
Exposure). The NOHD is the area outside the Nominal Hazard Zone.
Examples of NOHD distances for a 532nm
Green Laser.
• 532nm 10mW: NOHD ... 21.4 m / 70ft
• 532nm 70mW: NOHD ... 58.2 m / 191ft
• 532nm 125mw: NOHD ... 78.2 m / 257ft
• 532nm 500mW: NOHD ... 156.3 m / 513ft
http://www.pangolin.com/faa/laser-aircraft-animation-and-explanation.htm
Copyright © NoIR 2020 All rights reserved
Laser Pointers vs Handheld Lasers• 5mW “Office laser pointers” are generally eye-safe.
• The risk of injury is very real from readily available, powerful 250mW – 5W handheld lasers.
• There’s no telling which is which when under attacked and being illuminated.
• While a given laser exposure may not cause eye injury/damage, the Visual Interference
Effects of even a 5mW laser pointer at 10s to 100s of meters will impair performance
(distraction, glare, irritation, veiling glare, after image, intimidation and fear).
• In a tense, nighttime environment, all laser attacks and illuminations induce fear of injury
and deliver dazzle and disabling glare because the target’s eyes are low-light adapted
and the visual effect is more pronounced.
Image may be subject to copyright.
Copyright © NoIR 2020 All rights reserved
Optical DensityProtection Values
• Optical Density (OD) is a measure of the attenuation of energy passing through a filter.
The higher the OD, the higher the attenuation and the greater the protection.
• Select eyewear with ODs that reduce the energy below the MPE.
• Beam spots and laser energy of visible lasers (400-700nm) are still partially visible when
viewed through eyewear with OD 0-3 .
OD (Optical Density) Transmission in % Attenuation Factor
0 100% 1
1 10% 10
2 1% 100
3 0.1% 1,000
4 0.01% 10,000
5 0.001% 100,000
6 0.0001% 1,000,000
7 0.00001% 10,000,000
Example of the reduction of visible beam
Copyright © NoIR 2020 All rights reserved
Flight Deck Test Illuminations
Images from LAPD Air Support Division flight deck tests: 11 August 2011
Laser: 70mW 532nm green laser at 152m / 500ft
Glareshield™ filter PBG 445nm OD 1.5+ / 532nm OD2.5+
Direct hit, no filter Direct hit, filter deployed
Copyright © NoIR 2020 All rights reserved
Flight Deck Test Illuminations
Images from LAPD Air Support Division flight deck tests: 11 August 2011
Laser: 70mW 445nm blue laser at 152m / 500ft
Glareshield™ filter PBG 445nm OD 1.5+ / 532nm OD2.5+
Direct hit, no filter Direct hit, filter deployed
Copyright © NoIR 2020 All rights reserved
Riot and Crowd Control Filter ARG
ARG - Orange
• 99.99999% Blue Beam
reduction (OD 7+)
• 99.99999% Green Beam
reduction (OD 7+)
• 49% Photopic (daylight)
Transmittance
• 9% Scotopic (nighttime)
Transmittance
ARG - Orange
• Full protection against
Blue/Green lasers to 5 Watts
or more
• Wearer will not see the
beam or experience any
disabling glare or flash
blindness
• ANSI Z87 impact and Z136 +
CE laser standards
Copyright © NoIR 2020 All rights reserved
Riot and Crowd Control Filter CC1
CC1
• 99.9% Blue Beam reduction
(OD3+)
• 99.9% Green Beam
reduction (OD 3+)
• 49% Photopic (daylight)
Transmittance
• 19% Scotopic (nighttime)
Transmittance
CC1
• Protection against ~5W Blue
and Green lasers.
• Wearer will see some beam
energy for point source
location, without significant
disabling glare or flash
blindness.
• ANSI Z81 Impact + Z136 and
CE laser standards
Copyright © NoIR 2020 All rights reserved
Riot and Crowd Control Filter CC2
CC2
• Protection against ~5W Blue
and Green lasers and ~50mW
Red lasers.
• Wearer will see some beam
energy for point source
location, without significant
disabling glare or flash
blindness.
• ANSI Z87.1 Impact + Z136 and
CE laser standards
CC2
• 99.9% Blue Beam reduction
(OD 3+)
• 99.9% Green Beam reduction
(OD 3+)
• 90% Red Beam reduction
(OD1+)
• 23% Photopic (daylight)
Transmittance
• 15% Scotopic (nighttime)
Transmittance
Copyright © NoIR 2020 All rights reserved
Pilot Filter PBG
PBG
• Protection against Blue and
lasers up to approx. 100mW
and Green lasers to approx.
1W at close proximity (much
higher at aircraft distance)
• Wearer will see some beam
energy for point source
location, without significant
disabling glare or flash
blindness
• ANSI Z87.1 Impact + Z136 and
CE laser standards
PBG
• 97% Blue Beam reduction (OD
1.5+)
• 99.5% Green Beam reduction
(OD 2.5+)
• 49% Photopic (daylight)
Transmittance
• 18% Scotopic (nighttime)
Transmittance
• Good instrument panel
visibility
Copyright © NoIR 2020 All rights reserved
Frame Options
• Universal Fit-over frames fit well for those who do and those who do not wear prescription
glasses.
• Wrap-around frames fit closer to the face for those not wearing Rx glasses.
• Most NoIR frames fit under helmets and face shields/visors.
• Laser protection is not available as a visor or a film to be applied to a visor.
• All filters are available in all NoIR frames.
Images of NoIR frames
ARG in #35 Adjustable Wraparound
CC2 #53 Universal Fitover
CC1 #52 Wraparound
Copyright © NoIR 2020 All rights reserved
Laser Safety for Avon Respirators
• NoIR GlareShield Laser Protection is available for Avon Protection Respirator 50 Series Masks.
• By utilizing the Vision Correction Assembly, NoIR puts laser safety inside the mask so users can safely breath and see.
• Mask compatibility:• C50 PC50
• FM50 HM50
• FM53 FM54
CC1_Avon
Copyright © NoIR 2020 All rights reserved
Considerations• Short distance, close-proximity laser attacks present possible eye-injury risk and certain disabling
visual effects, along with fear and intimidation.
• Not being able to determine the threat, it’s critical to prepare for the worst, most likely scenario.
Based on collected data from 2019 on aircraft illuminations, 87.2% involved green lasers, 8.2%
were blue and 1.2% were red (the rest were undetermined).
• SOPs for use should be well defined prior to deploying the eyewear.
• Are the glasses to be worn full-time or to be deployed at the time of illumination or during a
response to a laser incident?
• Will all ground personnel require the eyewear?
• Is a lower OD protection value useful to identify and apprehend the perpetrator?
• Or is high OD, full protection (to the point of not even recognizing there’s a laser attack) the
better choice?
Helicopter under laser illumination/attack,
Hong Kong protests.
Copyright © NoIR 2020 All rights reserved
Considerations(additional)
• Selecting the right filter involves a risk assessment that balances selecting the highest percentage
Visible Light Transmittance possible with affording enough beam protection against the assumed
laser threat.
• NEVER view a laser illumination with binoculars, even when wearing eye protection. Binoculars
magnify/focus the beam, thereby increasing the energy hitting the back of the eye. Serious eye
injury may result from viewing laser illuminations with binoculars or other magnifying optics.
Ground personnel under laser illumination/attack, Hong Kong protests. Image may be subject to copyright.
Copyright © NoIR 2020 All rights reserved
Contact Information
Additional information is available at
https://noirlaser.com/laser-pointer-hazard
Contact:
David W. Bothner, VP Business and Product Development
1.800.521.9746 - 248.387.4148