+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to...

Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to...

Date post: 09-Jun-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 3 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
64
Report No. T&S Planning 2013-058 Page 1 Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations Planning 2013-058 October 11 th , 2013 Transmission and Stations Planning
Transcript
Page 1: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 1

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer

Capability of the Existing System

Report No. Transmission & Stations Planning 2013-058

October 11th

, 2013

Transmission and Stations Planning

Page 2: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 2

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

This page left blank intentionally

Page 3: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 3

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

The study and report were carried out by BC Hydro Transmission & Stations

Planning in conjunction with Powertech Labs Inc.

BC Hydro: Steven Pai

Powertech Labs Inc.: Dr. Khosro Kabiri

Page 4: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 4

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

CONTENTS

Executive Summary .................................................................................................... 6

1. Introduction .............................................................................................. 7

2. Study Data and conditions ....................................................................... 7

2.1 Heavy Summer............................................................................. 7

2.2 Heavy Winter ................................................................................ 9

3. Study Methodology ................................................................................ 10

3.1 Power Flow Analysis .................................................................. 10

3.2 Contingency Power Flow Analysis .............................................. 11

3.3 Transient Stability Analysis ......................................................... 11

4. Study Results ......................................................................................... 12

4.1 Heavy Summer........................................................................... 12

4.2 Heavy Winter .............................................................................. 13

5. Conclusion ............................................................................................. 16

Appendix A – Pre-outage Power Flows..................................................................... 17

Appendix B – Contingencies ..................................................................................... 28

Appendix C – Power Flow Contingency Results ....................................................... 30

Appendix D – Transient Stability Performance Plots ................................................. 36

Page 5: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 5

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

DISCLAIMER

This Report was prepared solely for internal purposes. All parties other than BC Hydro are third parties. BC Hydro does not represent, guarantee or warrant to any third party, either expressly or by implication:

(a) the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of,

(b) the intellectual or other property rights of any person or party in, or

(c) the merchantability, safety or fitness for purpose of,

any information, product or process disclosed, described or recommended in this Report.

BC Hydro does not accept any liability of any kind arising in any way out of the use by a third party of any information, product or process disclosed, described or recommended in this Report, nor does BC Hydro accept any liability arising out of reliance by a third party upon any information, statements or recommendations contained in this Report. Should third parties use or rely on any information, product or process disclosed, described or recommended in this Report, they do so entirely at their own risk.

COPYRIGHT NOTICE This Report is copyright by BC Hydro in 2013 and may not be reproduced in whole or in part without the prior written consent of BC Hydro.

Page 6: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 6

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

The planning assessment of BC to Alberta (Path1) transfer capability of the existing BC Hydro

transmission system was carried out at three different levels, 850 MW, 1100 MW and 1200 MW

based on N-0 (Category A) and N-1 (Category B) considerations. System limitations outside BC

that could affect the transfer limit were not included in the study. Impact of contingencies in

Alberta or US was not studied. The assessment was done both on the steady state and transient

stability performance. The study cases cover the heavy summer and heavy winter conditions with

Kootenay area generation varied as a sensitivity parameter. The impact of extremely low

probability simultaneous double contingencies (Category C) is not included in this assessment, but

will be addressed in a future study. The applicable remedial action schemes in response to the

various contingencies were simulated according to operation rules and requirements.

The findings based on Category A and B performance requirement of the selected BC Hydro

system conditions are listed below:

1. No unacceptable steady-state or dynamic performance was observed for 850 MW BC to

AB transfer under both summer and winter peak loading conditions.

2. Under summer loading conditions, 1200 MW BC to AB transfer does not cause Category

A or B performance violations.

3. Under winter loading conditions, 1200 MW BC to AB transfer does not cause Category A

or B violations, however the voltage performance was marginally acceptable. It would be

prudent to adopt 1100 MW as the BC to AB transfer limit until detailed operation planning

studies are completed.

Page 7: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 7

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

1. INTRODUCTION

The WECC Path rating catalogue shows the Alberta-British Columbia path (Path 1) ratings of

1000 MW East to West and 1200 MW West to East. The 2007 BC Transmission Corporation

(BCTC) studies1,2

identified BC to Alberta transfer limit of 850 MW. This study aims at updating

the 2007 studies using the latest system information and model based on BC Hydro (BCH) system

considerations. Systems outside BC are modeled but not included in the study scope. The focus of

the study is on the West to East transfer for which all the prepared study cases have power flows

from BC to Alberta (AB).

The study cases are developed from two WECC base cases; one for heavy summer and the other

for heavy winter conditions. These base cases and the study cases developed from them are

introduced in more detail in Section 2. Then in Section 3 the methodology employed in assessing

the system conditions is explained. The study findings are presented in Section 4 followed by the

conclusion in Section 5. The appendices contain the detailed study information and results of

simulations of selected cases.

2. STUDY DATA AND CONDITIONS

The data used in this study include the power flow and dynamic data models of the WECC system

and contingency files of BCH system.

2.1 Heavy Summer

The 2013 heavy summer base case3 together with dynamic files were obtained from the Montana

Alberta Tie Line (MATL) study group. The case is based on a 2013 WECC case in which the

MATL path is added and the case is tuned for study on MATL. The BC Hydro (area 50) load in

this base case is 7727 MW. Several power flow cases were derived from this base case by

adjusting the flow from BC to Alberta to different levels. The flow from BC to US was also

adjusted to the study conditions.

In order to assess the effect of area generation dispatch on the system, local generation in South

Interior near Selkirk (SEL) substation was varied which include Kootenay Canal (KCL) and Seven

Mile (SEV) generating stations. Figure 2-1 shows the Selkirk area connections. The total

generation capacity at KCL is 580 MW and at SEV is 800 MW. Reducing generation at these

locations means that the power transferred to Alberta would mainly come from Ashton Creek

(ACK) and Vaseux Lake (VAS) substations through 5L91 and 5L96 respectively.

64 1 “Point to Point US to BC, BC to Alberta and wheel through US to Alberta - System Impact Study”

2 “System Impact Study For Increasing Firm ATC From BC to Alberta and From BC Interior to the US”

3 13hs_3s_Case2b_2.raw

Page 8: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 8

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

50791CB

K 5

00 5

00.

50822

NLY 2PS2 230.

50784

NLY 230 230.

CB

K 5

00 5

00.

NLY 2PS2 230.

NLY 230 230.

50784

50822

5079150792

SEL 500 500.

5L

92

5L

92

SEL 500 500.

50792

51352

CBK 12T2 12.6CBK 12T2 12.6

51352

51353

CBK 12T3 12.6

50782

CB

K 2

30 2

30.

CBK 12T3 12.6

CB

K 2

30 2

30.

50782

51353

80641

SE

L 1

2T

1 12.6

80306

SE

L 1

2T

4 12.6

80305

SE

L 1

2T

3 12.6

SE

L 1

2T

1 12.6

SE

L 1

2T

4 12.6

SE

L 1

2T

3 12.6

803058030680641 80304

SE

L 1

2T

2 12.6

50783

SEL 230 230.

SE

L 1

2T

2 12.6

SEL 230 230.

50783

80304

2L2932L293

80640

AAL 2T3 230.

2L

294

2L

294

AAL 2T3 230.

80640

50702

AC

K 5

00 5

00.

AC

K 5

00 5

00.

50702

51134

VA

S 5

00 5

00.

50788

KC

L 2

30 2

30.

2L295

VA

S 5

00 5

00.

KC

L 2

30 2

30.

50788

51134

2L295

2L2992L299

CBK

SEL

ACK

VAS

KCL

AAL

NLY

50789

AAL 2T1 230.

2L

294

2L

294

AAL 2T1 230.

50789

50785

SEV 2T1 230.

2L

221

2L

221

SEV 2T1 230.

50785

51350

SEV 2T3 230.SEV 2T3 230.

51350

2L

222

2L

222

5L

91

5L

91

5L

96

5L

96

SEV40146

BOUNDRYW 230.

40146

BOUNDRYW 230.2L

112

2L

112

Figure 2-1: SEL area system connections

Table 2-1 shows the heavy summer cases that have been set up for the study, with BC exporting

power to both Alberta and the US. In all the cases, MATL path is in service and the MATL phase

shifter is adjusted to have negligible flow. The associated power flow plots are included in

Appendix A.

Table 2-1: Heavy summer study cases and power flows (MW)

Case BC to AB BC to US KCL Gen SEV Gen SEL

Interface MATL

(S to N)

13hs_case1 854 1020 570 580 480 -1

13hs_case1b 851 1200 0 0 -651 0

13hs_case2a 1098 1000 130 83 -697 1

13hs_case3 1201 1033 570 580 115 0

13hs_case3a 1200 999 150 170 -699 0

Note that the SEL interface in Table 2-1 is defined as follows4:

SEL Interface = 5L91 SEL + 5L96 SEL + 2L112 NLY + 48L KET

64 4 According to Attachment 1 of 7T-34, Effective Date: 03 January 2013, Page 7 of 69.

Page 9: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 9

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Where ‘5L91 SEL’ is the flow in the 500 kV line from SEL to ACK measured at SEL. ‘5L96

SEL’ is the flow in the 500 kV line from SEL to VAS measured at SEL. ‘2L112 NLY’ is the flow

in the 230 kV line from Nelway (NLY) to Boundary (BDY) measured at NLY, and ‘48L KET’ is

the flow in the 161 kV line from Kettle Valley (KET) to Bentley Terminal Station (BEN)

measured at KET.

A negative ‘SEL Interface’ flow means that the power flows from South Interior West to South

Interior East. The west to east flow is normally kept below 700 MW for the present system.

2.2 Heavy Winter

The heavy winter base case5 together with dynamic files were from Powertech Labs who prepared

the case from a 2013/14 WECC case for conducting the Path 3 (tie between the BC and US)

studies. The BC Hydro (area 50) load in this base case is 10752 MW. Several pre-outage power

flow study cases were derived from this base case by adjusting the flow from BC to Alberta to

different levels. The flow from BC to US was also modified to match the intended study

conditions.

Table 2-2 shows heavy winter cases set up for the study in which BC is exporting to Alberta and

importing from the US (negative numbers in BC to US Column indicate import into BC). The

MATL phase shifter is at the tap limit in Case 2a, Case 3, and Case 3b. The associated power flow

plots are included in Appendix A.

Table 2-2: Heavy winter study cases and power flows (MW)

Case BC to AB BC to US KCL Gen SEV Gen SEL

Interface MATL

(S to N)

13hw2ae_case1 868 -850 494 775 543 0

13hw2ae_case1a 850 -850 0 0 -692 0

13hw2ae_case2a 1099 -1095 69 195 -691 59

13hw2ae_case3 1204 -833 494 775 186 20

13hw2ae_case3b 1207 -1204 140 234 -698 101

64 5 13hw2ae_NI_500+400-MTL_300-PSE_785.pfb

Page 10: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 10

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

3. STUDY METHODOLOGY

The study looked into both the pre and post contingency steady-state conditions and the transient

stability performance of the BCH system. The pre-outage power flow cases for the study were

tuned to obtain acceptable voltage profile across the system for various transfer levels and

generation dispatches. The study is focused on the area close to the intertie, i.e. South Interior

West and South Interior East divisions of the BCH system.

3.1 Power Flow Analysis

Both the pre-outage and post-outage power flows are solved with the following control commands

turned on:

- Area Interchange Flow Control

- Continuous Shunt Adjustment

- Discrete Shunt Adjustment

- Transformer Tap Changer Adjustment

- Phase Shifter Adjustment

Distinctions are made between the manually controlled vs. automatically controlled devices. For

the pre-outage cases, all controlled devices were turn on. Whereas in the post contingency power

flow simulations, only automatically controlled actions were allowed.

When the Area Interchange control flag is on, the power flow solver adjusts the net exchange from

each area over its tie lines such that the net exchange power specified for the area is met. In this

solution method each area must have a swing bus to be used during the iterations. The difference

between generation on the one hand and the load and export on the other hand is absorbed by the

area swing bus.

Continuous Shunt Adjustment flag pertains to the static VAR compensators. The MVAr outputs of

these fast-acting shunts are adjusted continuously within their given ranges in order to regulate the

voltage of their specified controlled buses.

When the Discrete Shunt Adjustment flag is on, the shunts specified as ‘discrete’ in the model are

adjusted in a stepwise manner in order to regulate the voltage of their specified controlled buses. It

should be noted that shunts which are specified as ‘fixed’ or ‘frozen’ do not participate in this

control action. The manually switched shunts were frozen in solving the post-outage power flows.

With the Transformer Tap Changing flag on, adjustments are done to the tap ratios of adjustable

two-winding and three-winding transformers during iterations in order to regulate their controlled

bus voltages. The manually operated tap changers were disabled in solving the post-outage power

flows.

Phase shifters are transformers whose controlled variable is the real power. With the Transformer

Tap Changing flag on, adjustments are done to angle shift between the primary and secondary

Page 11: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 11

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

windings in order to regulate the real power flow through the phase shifter within the specified

range. Since the Nelway phase shifter is normally not on automatic MW flow control mode, its

controller was blocked for the post contingency power flow.

After the power flow was solved with the above parameters, a manual check was done on the

power flow levels and voltage magnitudes in BC to ensure they are in the acceptable ranges.

3.2 Contingency Power Flow Analysis

The list of BCH contingencies studied is provided in Appendix B. The contingency names

represent the element or elements that are directly affected by the contingency and are tripped out

as a result. Most of the N-1 contingencies analyzed in this study only affect a single element.

However, some N-1 contingencies involve more than one element as explained below.

For example, the ‘SEL T2 & T3’ contingency and ‘CBK T2 & T6’ contingency each involve the

loss of two transformers because they are in the same protection zone.

Some contingencies involve Remedial Action Schemes (RAS) that would subsequently trigger

actions on other elements in the system. The RAS actions are simulated in accordance with BCH

operating orders. Note that the 5L92 or 5L94 contingency would cause the MATL tie to trip due to

the high Path 1 flows which consequently would result in the Alberta system to become islanded.

3.3 Transient Stability Analysis

Time domain simulations were performed for the same set of N-1 contingencies as described in

Section 3.2. Equipment switching sequence and timings were applied in accordance with the

protection settings of various schemes, such as equipment within the same protection zones, auto

reclose, and RAS actions.

Page 12: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 12

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

4. STUDY RESULTS

In this section the study results are presented with separate sections for heavy summer and heavy

winter conditions.

4.1 Heavy Summer

Pre-outage Power Flows

With Path 1 flow at about 850 MW, the steady-state power flow voltages on the 500 kV and 230

kV levels in the BC Hydro system can be maintained at the preferred levels. However, as Path 1

flow is increased from 850 MW to 1200 MW the voltages around Cranbrook (CBK) and Natal

(NTL) area drop to lower values.

Table 4-1 lists the pre-outage study case voltages at CBK and NTL for three levels of BC to

Alberta transfer. At 1200 MW of transfer the voltage at NTL can be as low as 0.95 p.u. The

associated power flow plots of these cases are displayed in Appendix A.

Table 4-1: Pre-outage Voltage levels at CBK and NTL, heavy summer conditions

Case BC-AB Flow CBK 500 kV CBK 230 kV NTL 230 kV

[MW] [p.u.] [p.u.] [p.u.]

Heavy Summer 1 850 1.039 1.025 1.0154

Heavy Summer 1b 850 1.036 1.023 1.014

Heavy Summer 2a 1100 1.006 0.994 0.978

Heavy Summer 3 1200 0.987 0.974 0.942

Heavy Summer 3a 1200 0.988 0.974 0.946

Post Outage Power Flows

The two single contingencies that produced the worst post contingency power flow results are

5L91 and 2L294. Their respective results for the above cases are shown in Tables 4.2 and 4.3. Table 4-2: Post 5L91 Contingency Voltage levels at CBK and NTL, heavy summer conditions

Case BC-AB Flow CBK 500 kV CBK 230 kV NTL 230 kV

[MW] [p.u.] [p.u.] [p.u.]

Heavy Summer 1 850 1.032 1.018 1.010

Heavy Summer 1b 850 1.032 1.019 1.010

Heavy Summer 2a 1100 0.994 0.983 0.968

Heavy Summer 3 1200 0.973 0.962 0.932

Heavy Summer 3a 1200 0.968 0.956 0.931

Table 4-3: Post 2L294 Contingency Voltage levels at CBK and NTL, heavy summer conditions

Page 13: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 13

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Case BC-AB Flow CBK 500 kV CBK 230 kV NTL 230 kV

[MW] [p.u.] [p.u.] [p.u.]

Heavy Summer 1 850 1.033 1.020 1.012

Heavy Summer 1b 850 1.029 1.017 1.009

Heavy Summer 2a 1100 1.000 0.989 0.974

Heavy Summer 3 1200 0.968 0.956 0.922

Heavy Summer 3a 1200 0.968 0.956 0.932

Loss of 5L92 or 5L94 causes Alberta disconnected from BC which would result in MATL line

tripped and subsequent islanding of Alberta system. Generator shedding in BC was applied to

reduce the surplus power. No violation was observed in post contingency power flows.

Post contingency power flow voltages of cases 3 & 3a are displayed in Appendix C – Power Flow

Contingency Results.

Transient Stability Performance

No transient stability issues were observed for the studied system conditions after applying the

contingencies listed in Appendix B. Selected transient stability performance cases are listed in

Table 4-4 with their time domain simulation plots displayed in Appendix D.

Table 4-4: Transient Stability Plots, heavy summer conditions

Case BC-AB Flow [MW] Contingency Name Plots

Heavy Summer 3a 1200 5L91, 3ph flt@SEL500 HS1200_5L91

Heavy Summer 3a 1200 5L92, 3ph flt@CBK500 HS1200_5L92

Heavy Summer 3a 1200 2L294, 3ph flt@CBK230 HS1200_2L294

4.2 Heavy Winter

Pre-outage Power Flows

The BCH load is significantly higher in heavy winter than in heavy summer cases, resulting in

more stressed system conditions. With Path 1 flow at 850 MW, pre-outage steady state power flow

voltages on the 500 kV and 230 kV levels in the BC Hydro system can be maintained within the

acceptable range. However, compared to heavy summer conditions these voltages are generally

lower. Increasing the transfer to 1100 MW or 1200 MW would significantly reduce the area

voltages. Table 4-5 lists the pre-outage voltages at CBK and NTL for three different levels of BC

to Alberta flow.

Page 14: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 14

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Table 4-5: Pre-outage Voltage levels at CBK and NTL, heavy winter conditions

Case BC-AB Flow [MW]

CBK 500 kV [p.u.]

CBK 230 kV [p.u.]

NTL 230 kV [p.u.]

Heavy Winter 1 850 1.020 1.003 0.988

Heavy Winter 1a 850 1.025 1.009 0.993

Heavy Winter 2a 1100 0.985 0.971 0.952

Heavy Winter 3 1200 0.950 0.933 0.913

Heavy Winter 3b 1200 0.961 0.945 0.926

Post Outage Power Flows

Similar to the summer cases, the two single contingencies that produced the worst post

contingency power flow results were 5L91 and 2L294. Their respective results for the above cases

are shown in Tables 4.6 and 4.7 below. As expected the performance of winter cases are worse

than the summer cases. At 1200 MW transfer the voltage performance is only marginally

acceptable. Table 4-6: Post 5L91 Contingency Voltage levels at CBK and NTL, heavy winter conditions

Case BC-AB Flow [MW]

CBK 500 kV [p.u.]

CBK 230 kV [p.u.]

NTL 230 kV [p.u.]

Heavy Winter 1 850 1.006 0.989 0.973

Heavy Winter 1a 850 1.020 1.006 0.991

Heavy Winter 2a 1100 0.961 0.947 0.925

Heavy Winter 3 1200 0.932 0.917 0.896

Heavy Winter 3b 1200 0.942 0.928 0.909

Table 4-7: Post 2L294 Contingency Voltage levels at CBK and NTL, heavy winter conditions

Case BC-AB Flow [MW]

CBK 500 kV [p.u.]

CBK 230 kV [p.u.]

NTL 230 kV [p.u.]

Heavy Winter 1 850 1.009 0.996 0.981

Heavy Winter 1a 850 1.018 1.006 0.991

Heavy Winter 2a 1100 0.964 0.951 0.931

Heavy Winter 3 1200 0.928 0.915 0.895

Heavy Winter 3b 1200 0.941 0.928 0.910

Similar to the summer cases, loss of 5L92 or 5L94 causes Alberta disconnected from BC which

would result in MATL line tripped and subsequent islanding of Alberta system. Generator

shedding in BC was applied to reduce the surplus power in the simulations. No violation was

observed in post disturbance power flows of these contingencies.

Post contingency power flow voltages of cases 2a, 3 & 3b are displayed in Appendix C – Power

Flow Contingency Results.

Page 15: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 15

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Transient Stability Performance

No transient stability issues were observed for the studied system cases after applying the

contingencies in Appendix B except marginal performance at 1200 MW BC to AB transfer,

particularly when Kootenay area generations are high. Selected transient stability performance

cases are listed in Table 4-8 with their time domain simulation plots displayed in Appendix D.

Table 4-8: Transient Stability Plots, heavy winter conditions

Case BC-AB Flow [MW] Contingency Name Plots

Heavy Winter 2a 1100 5L91, 3ph flt@SEL500 HW1100_5L91

Heavy Winter 3 1200 5L91, 3ph flt@SEL500 HW1200_5L91

Heavy Winter 3b 1200 5L91, 3ph flt@SEL500 HW1200_5L91

Heavy Winter 3b 1200 5L92, 3ph flt@CBK500 HW1200_5L92

Heavy Winter 3b 1200 5L94, 3ph flt@CBK500 HW1200_5L94

Heavy Winter 3b 1200 2L294, 3ph flt@CBK230 HW1200_2L294

Given the poor performance of 1200 MW BC to AB transfer, It would be prudent to adopt 1100

MW transfer as an acceptable limit for winter conditions before detailed operation planning

studies are completed.

Page 16: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 16

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

5. CONCLUSION

The steady-state and transient stability of the BC Hydro system were assessed for three different

levels of BC to Alberta transfers: 850 MW, 1100 MW, and 1200 MW based on heavy summer and

heavy winter loading conditions of WECC base cases. Single contingencies (Category B) in the

South Interior West and South Interior East regions of BCH were applied for the assessment. No

contingency in Alberta or US was applied.

The findings based on Category A and B performance requirements are listed below:

1. No unacceptable steady-state or dynamic performance was observed for 850 MW BC to

AB transfer under both summer and winter peak load conditions.

2. Under summer loading conditions, 1200 MW BC to AB transfer does not cause Category

A or B performance violations.

3. Under winter loading conditions, 1200 MW BC to AB transfer does not cause Category A

or B violations, however the voltage performance was only marginally acceptable. It would

be prudent to adopt 1100 MW as the BC to AB transfer limit until detailed operation

planning studies are completed.

Page 17: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 17

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

APPENDIX A – PRE-OUTAGE POWER FLOWS

The pre-outage power flows of study cases listed in Tables 2-1, 2-2, 4-1, and 4-5 are displayed

below.

Page 18: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 18

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

50

79

1

1.0

394

CB

K 5

00

5

00.

50822

1.0399NLY 2PS2 230.

50784

1.0376NLY 230 230.

-53.5

753.6

0

9.2

7-8

.37

50

79

1

50822

50784

-53.5

753.6

0

1.0376

9.2

7-8

.37

NLY 230 230.

1.0399NLY 2PS2 230.

1.0

394

CB

K 5

00

5

00.

50792

1.0514SEL 500 500.

0.0

0

0.0

0

872.5

6

-860.70

5L

92

-48.5

3

105.65

51352

0.9751CBK 12T2 12.6

0.0

0

0.0

0

51353

0.9751CBK 12T3 12.6

50792

51352

51353

872.5

6

-860.70

1.0514

0.9751CBK 12T3 12.6

0.9751CBK 12T2 12.6

5L

92

-48.5

3

105.65

SEL 500 500.

50

78

2

1.0

246

CB

K 2

30

2

30.

-0.00

0.00

36.62

-28.99

-36.12

28.99

50

78

2

1.0

246

CB

K 2

30

2

30.

-0.00

0.00

36.62

-28.99

-36.12

28.99

-0.00

-0.00

36.65

-29.01

-36.15

29.018

06

41

0.9

867

SE

L 1

2T

1

12.6

80

30

6

0.9

866

SE

L 1

2T

4

12.6

80

30

5

0.9

868

SE

L 1

2T

3

12.6

80

64

1

80

30

6

80

30

5

0.9

868

SE

L 1

2T

3

12.6

0.9

866

SE

L 1

2T

4

12.6

0.9

867

SE

L 1

2T

1

12.6

-0.00

-0.00

36.65

-29.01

-36.15

29.01

80

30

4

0.9

870

SE

L 1

2T

2

12.6

50783

1.0400SEL 230 230.

0.00

-0.00

-82.13

366.35

102.48

-366.06

80

30

4

50783

1.0400SEL 230 230.

0.00

-0.00

-82.13

366.35

102.48

-366.06

0.9

870

SE

L 1

2T

2

12.6

0.08

0.00

-60.20

268.19

75.02

-267.98

0.00

-0.00

-59.53

265.54

74.28

-265.33

0.08

0.00

-60.20

0.00

-0.00

-59.53

265.54

74.28

-265.33

268.19

75.02

-267.98

-0.00

-0.00

-82.22

366.73

102.59

-366.43

-175.3

0

175.9

2

2L293

9.5

8

-8.4

1

80640

1.0276AAL 2T3 230.

-167.3

2169.9

02

L2

94

11.5

5-7

.25

-0.00

80640

-175.3

0

-167.3

2169.9

0

175.9

2

1.0276

2L

29

411.5

5-7

.25

AAL 2T3 230.

2L293

9.5

8

-8.4

1

-0.00

-82.22

366.73

102.59

-366.43

50

70

2

1.0

482

AC

K 5

00

5

00.

0.00

0.00

51

13

4

1.0

601

VA

S 5

00

5

00.

50

78

8

1.0

360

KC

L 2

30

2

30.

0.10

0.21

280.24

-275.6

8

2L295

-38.80

61.3

3

50

70

2

51

13

4

50

78

8

280.24

-275.6

8

1.0

360

2L295

-38.80

61.3

3

KC

L 2

30

2

30.

1.0

601

VA

S 5

00

5

00.

1.0

482

AC

K 5

00

5

00.

279.98

-275.4

3

2L299

-38.73

61.2

2

CBK

279.98

-275.4

3

0.10

0.21

SEL

2L299

-38.73

61.2

2

ACK

VAS

KCL

AAL

NLY

0.0

0

0.0

0

0.0

0

0.0

0

50789

1.0276AAL 2T1 230. 146.3

2

-143.63

2L

29

4

-17.9

6

18.60

167.3

2-1

67.3

2

-11.4

511.5

0

50785

1.0397SEV 2T1 230.

50789

146.3

2

50785

167.3

2-1

67.3

2

-143.63

1.0276

2L

29

4

1.0397SEV 2T1 230.

-11.4

511.5

0-1

7.9

6

18.60

AAL 2T1 230.

289.2

3-2

89.0

22

L2

21

-46.0

146.9

0

51350

1.0397SEV 2T3 230. 289.2

5-2

89.0

52

L2

22

-42.2

243.1

0

-30.7

5

30.77

5L

91

-139.4

8

-31.56

51350

289.2

3

289.2

5

-30.7

5

30.77

-289.0

5

-289.0

2

1.0397

0.00

0.00

2L

22

2

5L

91

-139.4

8

-31.56

-42.2

243.1

0

SEV 2T3 230.

2L

22

1

-46.0

146.9

0

-421.45

423.9

8

5L

96

-22.53

-166.3

5

SEV40146

1.0400BOUNDRYW 230.

53.5

7-5

3.5

62

L1

12

-9.2

78.6

0

50787

1.0155NTL 230 230.

-421.45

40146

423.9

8

50787

53.5

7-5

3.5

6

5L

96

1.0400

1.0155NTL 230 230.

2L

11

2

-9.2

78.6

0

BOUNDRYW 230.

-22.53

-166.3

5

-6.47

0.1

4

2L

11

3-1

04.2

0

105.37

-6.47

0.1

4

2L

11

3

LA

NG

DO

N2

500.

54

15

8

1.0

438

-104.2

0

105.37

LA

NG

DO

N2

500.

54

15

8

1.0

438

-33.36 92.28

5L94802.71 -785.34

-33.36 92.28

5L94802.71 -785.34

Interface: AB-BC: Path-1

Total From MW Flow: 854.49 MW

Interface: BC-US: Path-3

Total From MW Flow: 1020.29 MW

Interface: AB-MONTANA: Path-MATL

Total From MW Flow: 1.14 MW

54

23

2

CO

LE

MA

N7

138.

1.0

296

54

23

2

CO

LE

MA

N7

138.

1.0

296

50

77

6

NT

L 1

38

1

38.

1.0

400

50

77

6

NT

L 1

38

1

38.

1.0

400

48.66

-7.78

-47.88

7.43

1L27548.66

-7.78

-47.88

7.43

1L275

50

83

0

BC

K 2

74P

138.

1.0

103

50

83

0

BC

K 2

74P

138.

1.0

103

54

32

9

PO

CA

TE

R7

138.

1.0

435

54

32

9

PO

CA

TE

R7

138.

1.0

435

3.12

-1.81

-3.12

-1.16

1L2743.12

-1.81

-3.12

-1.16

1L274

13hs_case1_P1_08505

07

69

KC

L 1

3G

1

13.8

1.0

303

142.50

-2.171

50

76

9

KC

L 1

3G

1

13.8

1.0

303

142.501

-2.17

50

77

0

KC

L 1

3G

2

13.8

1.0

303

142.50

-2.172

50

77

0

KC

L 1

3G

2

13.8

1.0

303

142.502

-2.17

50

77

1

KC

L 1

3G

3

13.8

1.0

299

142.50

-2.173

50

77

1

KC

L 1

3G

3

13.8

1.0

299

142.503

-2.17

50

77

2

KC

L 1

3G

4

13.8

1.0

300

142.50

-2.174

50

77

2

KC

L 1

3G

4

13.8

1.0

300

142.504

-2.17

50766

SEV 13G1 13.8 1.0327

145.0

0

-9.7

11

50766

SEV 13G1 13.8 1.0327

145.0

01

-9.7

1

50767

SEV 13G2 13.8 1.0276

145.0

0

-7.5

52

50767

SEV 13G2 13.8 1.0276

145.0

02

-7.5

5

50768

SEV 13G3 13.8 1.0330

145.0

0

-9.2

43

50768

SEV 13G3 13.8 1.0330

145.0

03

-9.2

4

51036

SEV 13G4 13.8 1.0332

145.0

0

-11.7

24

51036

SEV 13G4 13.8 1.0332

145.0

04

-11.7

2

50786

INV 230 230. 1.0628

50786

INV 230 230. 1.0628

34.44

-49.43

-34.0

2

27.0

0

2L

25

8

34.44

-49.43

-34.0

2

27.0

0

2L

25

8

Page 19: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 19

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

50

79

1

1.0

356

CB

K 5

00

5

00.

50822

1.0401NLY 2PS2 230.

50784

1.0371NLY 230 230.

-150.8

5151.1

1

16.2

3-7

.31

50

79

1

50822

50784

-150.8

5151.1

1

1.0371

16.2

3-7

.31

NLY 230 230.

1.0401NLY 2PS2 230.

1.0

356

CB

K 5

00

5

00.

50792

1.0451SEL 500 500.

-133.7

9

0.0

0

900.7

6

-887.99

5L

92

-54.2

1

125.34

51352

0.9732CBK 12T2 12.6

0.0

0

0.0

0

51353

0.9732CBK 12T3 12.6

50792

51352

51353

900.7

6

-887.99

1.0451

0.9732CBK 12T3 12.6

0.9732CBK 12T2 12.6

5L

92

-54.2

1

125.34

SEL 500 500.

50

78

2

1.0

224

CB

K 2

30

2

30.

0.00

0.00

43.07

-44.70

-42.18

44.71

50

78

2

1.0

224

CB

K 2

30

2

30.

0.00

0.00

43.07

-44.70

-42.18

44.71

-0.00

-0.00

43.10

-44.74

-42.21

44.75

80

64

1

0.9

894

SE

L 1

2T

1

12.6

80

30

6

0.9

894

SE

L 1

2T

4

12.6

80

30

5

0.9

894

SE

L 1

2T

3

12.6

80

64

1

80

30

6

80

30

5

0.9

894

SE

L 1

2T

3

12.6

0.9

894

SE

L 1

2T

4

12.6

0.9

894

SE

L 1

2T

1

12.6

-0.00

-0.00

43.10

-44.74

-42.21

44.75

80

30

4

0.9

895

SE

L 1

2T

2

12.6

50783

1.0418SEL 230 230.

-0.00

-0.00

-32.75

28.52

33.02

-28.52

80

30

4

50783

1.0418SEL 230 230.

-0.00

-0.00

-32.75

28.52

33.02

-28.52

0.9

895

SE

L 1

2T

2

12.6

0.00

0.00

-23.97

20.88

24.17

-20.88

0.00

-0.00

-23.73

20.67

23.93

-20.67

0.00

0.00

-23.97

0.00

-0.00

-23.73

20.67

23.93

-20.67

20.88

24.17

-20.88

0.00

-0.00

-32.78

28.55

33.05

-28.55

-247.5

4

248.7

7

2L293

5.7

1

-0.3

1

80640

1.0286AAL 2T3 230.

-135.8

2137.5

12

L2

94

6.1

9-7

.69

0.00

80640

-247.5

4

-135.8

2137.5

1

248.7

7

1.0286

2L

29

4

6.1

9-7

.69

AAL 2T3 230.

2L293

5.7

1

-0.3

1

-0.00

-32.78

28.55

33.05

-28.55

50

70

2

1.0

439

AC

K 5

00

5

00.

0.00

0.00

51

13

4

1.0

564

VA

S 5

00

5

00.

50

78

8

1.0

360

KC

L 2

30

2

30.

0.10

0.21

94.06

-93.5

1

2L295

-30.38

25.2

3

50

70

2

51

13

4

50

78

8

94.06

-93.5

1

1.0

360

2L295

-30.38

25.2

3

KC

L 2

30

2

30.

1.0

564

VA

S 5

00

5

00.

1.0

439

AC

K 5

00

5

00.

93.97

-93.4

3

2L299

-30.34

25.1

9

CBK

93.97

-93.4

3

0.10

0.21

SEL

2L299

-30.34

25.1

9

ACK

VAS

KCL

AAL

NLY

0.0

0

-133.7

9

0.0

0

0.0

0

50789

1.0286AAL 2T1 230. 114.8

2

-113.17

2L

29

4

-13.1

5

6.89

135.8

2-1

35.8

2

-6.4

36.4

7

50785

1.0418SEV 2T1 230.

50789

114.8

2

50785

135.8

2-1

35.8

2

-113.17

1.0286

2L

29

4

1.0418SEV 2T1 230.

-6.4

36.4

7-1

3.1

5

6.89

AAL 2T1 230.

-0.2

00.2

02

L2

21

-0.1

1-0

.81

51350

1.0414SEV 2T3 230. -0.2

00.2

02

L2

22

-16.9

115.9

9

-659.8

7

668.27

5L

91

-40.9

5

-9.83

51350

-0.2

0

-0.2

0

-659.8

7

668.27

0.2

0

0.2

0

1.0414

0.00

0.00

2L

22

2

5L

91

-40.9

5

-9.83

-16.9

115.9

9

SEV 2T3 230.

2L

22

1

-0.1

1-0

.81

142.59

-142.2

8

5L

96

-65.23

-152.7

9

SEV40146

1.0400BOUNDRYW 230.

150.8

5-1

50.7

62

L1

12

-16.2

316.2

3

50787

1.0135NTL 230 230.

142.59

40146

-142.2

8

50787

150.8

5-1

50.7

6

5L

96

1.0400

1.0135NTL 230 230.

2L

11

2-1

6.2

316.2

3

BOUNDRYW 230.

-65.23

-152.7

9

-6.77

0.6

2

2L

11

3-1

04.8

4

106.04

-6.77

0.6

2

2L

11

3

LA

NG

DO

N2

500.

54

15

8

1.0

432

-104.8

4

106.04

LA

NG

DO

N2

500.

54

15

8

1.0

432

-40.92 99.51

5L94798.54 -781.25

-40.92 99.51

5L94798.54 -781.25

Interface: AB-BC: Path-1

Total From MW Flow: 850.94 MW

Interface: BC-US: Path-3

Total From MW Flow: 1200.56 MW

Interface: AB-MONTANA: Path-MATL

Total From MW Flow: -0.44 MW

54

23

2

CO

LE

MA

N7

138.

1.0

284

54

23

2

CO

LE

MA

N7

138.

1.0

284

50

77

6

NT

L 1

38

1

38.

1.0

386

50

77

6

NT

L 1

38

1

38.

1.0

386

49.35

-8.25

-48.55

7.98

49.35

-8.25

-48.55

7.98

50

83

0

BC

K 2

74P

138.

1.0

090

50

83

0

BC

K 2

74P

138.

1.0

090

54

32

9

PO

CA

TE

R7

138.

1.0

426

54

32

9

PO

CA

TE

R7

138.

1.0

426

3.05

-1.83

-3.05

-1.17

3.05

-1.83

-3.05

-1.17

13hs_case1b_P1_08505

07

69

KC

L 1

3G

1

13.8

0.9

987

0.001

-43.03

50

76

9

KC

L 1

3G

1

13.8

0.9

987

0.001

-43.03

50

77

0

KC

L 1

3G

2

13.8

1.0

355

2

50

77

0

KC

L 1

3G

2

13.8

1.0

355

2

50

77

1

KC

L 1

3G

3

13.8

1.0

355

3

50

77

1

KC

L 1

3G

3

13.8

1.0

355

3

50

77

2

KC

L 1

3G

4

13.8

1.0

355

4

50

77

2

KC

L 1

3G

4

13.8

1.0

355

4

50766

SEV 13G1 13.8 1.0413

1

50766

SEV 13G1 13.8 1.0413

1

50767

SEV 13G2 13.8 1.0413

2

50767

SEV 13G2 13.8 1.0413

2

50768

SEV 13G3 13.8 1.0409

3

50768

SEV 13G3 13.8 1.0409

3

51036

SEV 13G4 13.8 1.0332

0.0

04

-16.7

051036

SEV 13G4 13.8 1.0332

0.0

04

-16.7

0

50786

INV 230 230. 1.0613

50786

INV 230 230. 1.0613

34.55

-49.89

-34.1

3

27.6

1

2L

25

8

34.55

-49.89

-34.1

3

27.6

1

2L

25

8

Page 20: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 20

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

50

79

1

1.0

058

CB

K 5

00

5

00.

50822

1.0397NLY 2PS2 230.

50784

1.0343NLY 230 230.

-55.5

255.5

6

16.0

6-1

4.8

2

50

79

1

50822

50784

-55.5

255.5

6

1.0343

16.0

6-1

4.8

2

NLY 230 230.

1.0397NLY 2PS2 230.

1.0

058

CB

K 5

00

5

00.

50792

1.0426SEL 500 500.

-133.1

6

0.0

0

1114.1

6

-1093.87

5L

92

100.8

2

74.59

51352

0.9460CBK 12T2 12.6

0.0

0

0.0

0

51353

0.9461CBK 12T3 12.6

50792

51352

51353

1114.1

6

-1093.87

1.0426

0.9461CBK 12T3 12.6

0.9460CBK 12T2 12.6

5L

92

100.8

2

74.59

SEL 500 500.

50

78

2

0.9

937

CB

K 2

30

2

30.

0.00

0.00

43.45

-24.63

-42.84

24.64

50

78

2

0.9

937

CB

K 2

30

2

30.

0.00

0.00

43.45

-24.63

-42.84

24.64

-0.00

0.00

43.48

-24.65

-42.87

24.66

80

64

1

0.9

868

SE

L 1

2T

1

12.6

80

30

6

0.9

867

SE

L 1

2T

4

12.6

80

30

5

0.9

868

SE

L 1

2T

3

12.6

80

64

1

80

30

6

80

30

5

0.9

868

SE

L 1

2T

3

12.6

0.9

867

SE

L 1

2T

4

12.6

0.9

868

SE

L 1

2T

1

12.6

-0.00

0.00

43.48

-24.65

-42.87

24.66

80

30

4

0.9

869

SE

L 1

2T

2

12.6

50783

1.0390SEL 230 230.

-0.00

-0.00

-34.75

103.40

36.47

-103.38

80

30

4

50783

1.0390SEL 230 230.

-0.00

-0.00

-34.75

103.40

36.47

-103.38

0.9

869

SE

L 1

2T

2

12.6

-0.00

-0.00

-25.44

75.70

26.69

-75.68

0.00

-0.00

-25.19

74.95

26.44

-74.93

-0.00

-0.00

-25.44

0.00

-0.00

-25.19

74.95

26.44

-74.93

75.70

26.69

-75.68

0.00

0.00

-34.78

103.51

36.51

-103.49

-195.7

3

196.5

0

2L293

-3.0

6

5.3

1

80640

1.0114AAL 2T3 230.

-178.7

4181.7

42

L2

94

-5.9

613.2

8

0.00

80640

-195.7

3

-178.7

4181.7

4

196.5

0

1.0114

2L

29

4

-5.9

613.2

8

AAL 2T3 230.

2L293

-3.0

6

5.3

1

0.00

-34.78

103.51

36.51

-103.49

50

70

2

1.0

706

AC

K 5

00

5

00.

573.12

0.00

51

13

4

1.0

639

VA

S 5

00

5

00.

50

78

8

1.0

360

KC

L 2

30

2

30.

0.10

0.21

137.70

-136.5

8

2L295

-27.93

26.7

5

50

70

2

51

13

4

50

78

8

137.70

-136.5

8

1.0

360

2L295

-27.93

26.7

5

KC

L 2

30

2

30.

1.0

639

VA

S 5

00

5

00.

1.0

706

AC

K 5

00

5

00.

137.58

-136.4

6

2L299

-27.90

26.7

0

CBK

137.58

-136.4

6

0.10

0.21

SEL

2L299

-27.90

26.7

0

ACK

VAS

KCL

AAL

NLY

0.0

0

-133.1

6

0.0

0

0.0

0

50789

1.0114AAL 2T1 230. 157.7

3

-154.51

2L

29

4

-0.9

3

5.89

178.7

3-1

78.7

3

5.7

7-5

.70

50785

1.0389SEV 2T1 230.

50789

157.7

3

50785

178.7

3-1

78.7

3

-154.51

1.0114

2L

29

4

1.0389SEV 2T1 230.

5.7

7-5

.70

-0.9

3

5.89

AAL 2T1 230.

82.6

9-8

2.6

72

L2

21

-14.5

113.7

4

51350

1.0390SEV 2T3 230. -0.2

00.2

02

L2

22

-0.0

9-0

.83

-613.3

3

620.43

5L

91

-159.5

0

90.08

51350

82.6

9

-0.2

0

-613.3

3

620.43

0.2

0

-82.6

7

1.0390

573.12

0.00

2L

22

2

5L

91

-159.5

0

90.08

-0.0

9-0

.83

SEV 2T3 230.

2L

22

1

-14.5

113.7

4

143.75

-143.3

5

5L

96

-17.19

-200.5

4

SEV40146

1.0400BOUNDRYW 230.

55.5

2-5

5.5

12

L1

12

-16.0

515.4

0

50787

0.9784NTL 230 230.

143.75

40146

-143.3

5

50787

55.5

2-5

5.5

1

5L

96

1.0400

0.9784NTL 230 230.

2L

11

2-1

6.0

515.4

0

BOUNDRYW 230.

-17.19

-200.5

4

2.13

-6.7

7

2L

11

3-1

05.5

7

106.86

2.13

-6.7

7

2L

11

3

LA

NG

DO

N2

500.

54

15

8

1.0

271

-105.5

7

106.86

LA

NG

DO

N2

500.

54

15

8

1.0

271

11.25 252.81

5L941044.57 -1013.05

11.25 252.81

5L941044.57 -1013.05

Interface: AB-BC: Path-1

Total From MW Flow: 1097.98 MW

Interface: BC-US: Path-3

Total From MW Flow: 1000.48 MW

Interface: AB-MONTANA: Path-MATL

Total From MW Flow: -0.52 MW

54

23

2

CO

LE

MA

N7

138.

1.0

206

54

23

2

CO

LE

MA

N7

138.

1.0

206

50

77

6

NT

L 1

38

1

38.

1.0

280

50

77

6

NT

L 1

38

1

38.

1.0

280

48.76

-11.76

-47.94

11.56

48.76

-11.76

-47.94

11.56

50

83

0

BC

K 2

74P

138.

0.9

957

50

83

0

BC

K 2

74P

138.

0.9

957

54

32

9

PO

CA

TE

R7

138.

1.0

417

54

32

9

PO

CA

TE

R7

138.

1.0

417

4.65

-1.35

-4.64

-0.44

4.65

-1.35

-4.64

-0.44

13hs_case2a_P1_11005

07

69

KC

L 1

3G

1

13.8

1.0

111

130.001

-25.61

50

76

9

KC

L 1

3G

1

13.8

1.0

111

130.001

-25.61

50

77

0

KC

L 1

3G

2

13.8

1.0

355

2

50

77

0

KC

L 1

3G

2

13.8

1.0

355

2

50

77

1

KC

L 1

3G

3

13.8

1.0

355

3

50

77

1

KC

L 1

3G

3

13.8

1.0

355

3

50

77

2

KC

L 1

3G

4

13.8

1.0

355

4

50

77

2

KC

L 1

3G

4

13.8

1.0

355

4

50766

SEV 13G1 13.8 1.0327

83.0

01

-10.5

4

50766

SEV 13G1 13.8 1.0327

83.0

01

-10.5

4

50767

SEV 13G2 13.8 1.0384

2

50767

SEV 13G2 13.8 1.0384

2

50768

SEV 13G3 13.8 1.0386

3

50768

SEV 13G3 13.8 1.0386

3

51036

SEV 13G4 13.8 1.0386

4

51036

SEV 13G4 13.8 1.0386

4

50786

INV 230 230. 1.0344

50786

INV 230 230. 1.0344

34.23

-49.77

-33.7

7

29.0

1

2L

25

8

34.23

-49.77

-33.7

7

29.0

1

2L

25

8

Page 21: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 21

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

50

79

1

0.9

869

CB

K 5

00

5

00.

50822

1.0394NLY 2PS2 230.

50784

1.0282NLY 230 230.

-250.2

8251.0

1

47.2

9-2

1.8

7

50

79

1

50822

50784

-250.2

8251.0

1

1.0282

47.2

9-2

1.8

7

NLY 230 230.

1.0394NLY 2PS2 230.

0.9

869

CB

K 5

00

5

00.

50792

1.0422SEL 500 500.

0.0

0

0.0

0

1208.4

2

-1183.81

5L

92

201.7

0

33.37

51352

0.9271CBK 12T2 12.6

0.0

0

0.0

0

51353

0.9272CBK 12T3 12.6

50792

51352

51353

1208.4

2

-1183.81

1.0422

0.9272CBK 12T3 12.6

0.9271CBK 12T2 12.6

5L

92

201.7

0

33.37

SEL 500 500.

50

78

2

0.9

740

CB

K 2

30

2

30.

-0.00

-0.00

37.38

-18.09

-36.94

18.10

50

78

2

0.9

740

CB

K 2

30

2

30.

-0.00

-0.00

37.38

-18.09

-36.94

18.10

-0.00

-0.00

37.41

-18.11

-36.97

18.11

80

64

1

0.9

847

SE

L 1

2T

1

12.6

80

30

6

0.9

847

SE

L 1

2T

4

12.6

80

30

5

0.9

847

SE

L 1

2T

3

12.6

80

64

1

80

30

6

80

30

5

0.9

847

SE

L 1

2T

3

12.6

0.9

847

SE

L 1

2T

4

12.6

0.9

847

SE

L 1

2T

1

12.6

-0.00

-0.00

37.41

-18.11

-36.97

18.11

80

30

4

0.9

850

SE

L 1

2T

2

12.6

50783

1.0370SEL 230 230.

0.00

-0.00

-42.68

304.44

56.40

-304.24

80

30

4

50783

1.0370SEL 230 230.

0.00

-0.00

-42.68

304.44

56.40

-304.24

0.9

850

SE

L 1

2T

2

12.6

0.14

0.00

-31.39

222.86

41.29

-222.72

-0.00

-0.00

-30.94

220.67

40.88

-220.52

0.14

0.00

-31.39

-0.00

-0.00

-30.94

220.67

40.88

-220.52

222.86

41.29

-222.72

-0.00

0.00

-42.72

304.75

56.46

-304.55

-379.4

8

382.4

2

2L293

2.8

3

14.4

7

80640

0.9979AAL 2T3 230.

-193.1

8196.7

82

L2

94

-13.0

524.5

6

-0.00

80640

-379.4

8

-193.1

8196.7

8

382.4

2

0.9979

2L

29

4-1

3.0

524.5

6

AAL 2T3 230.

2L293

2.8

3

14.4

7

0.00

-42.72

304.75

56.46

-304.55

50

70

2

1.0

600

AC

K 5

00

5

00.

280.90

0.00

51

13

4

1.0

623

VA

S 5

00

5

00.

50

78

8

1.0

360

KC

L 2

30

2

30.

0.10

0.21

278.48

-274.0

0

2L295

-31.49

53.4

8

50

70

2

51

13

4

50

78

8

278.48

-274.0

0

1.0

360

2L295

-31.49

53.4

8

KC

L 2

30

2

30.

1.0

623

VA

S 5

00

5

00.

1.0

600

AC

K 5

00

5

00.

278.23

-273.7

6

2L299

-31.44

53.3

9

CBK

278.23

-273.7

6

0.10

0.21

SEL

2L299

-31.44

53.3

9

ACK

VAS

KCL

AAL

NLY

0.0

0

0.0

0

0.0

0

0.0

0

50789

0.9979AAL 2T1 230. 172.1

6

-168.21

2L

29

4

6.2

2

4.20

193.1

8-1

93.1

8

12.9

9-1

2.9

2

50785

1.0381SEV 2T1 230.

50789

172.1

6

50785

193.1

8-1

93.1

8

-168.21

0.9979

2L

29

4

1.0381SEV 2T1 230.

12.9

9-1

2.9

26.2

2

4.20

AAL 2T1 230.

289.2

4-2

89.0

42

L2

21

16.9

4-1

6.0

9

51350

1.0383SEV 2T3 230. 289.2

6-2

89.0

52

L2

22

29.8

4-2

8.9

8

-300.3

4

302.06

5L

91

-182.0

1

37.22

51350

289.2

4

289.2

6

-300.3

4

302.06

-289.0

5

-289.0

4

1.0383

280.90

0.00

2L

22

2

5L

91

-182.0

1

37.22

29.8

4-2

8.9

8

SEV 2T3 230.

2L

22

1

16.9

4-1

6.0

9

-143.51

143.9

6

5L

96

-2.00

-214.7

2

SEV40146

1.0400BOUNDRYW 230.

250.2

8-2

50.0

22

L1

12

-47.3

048.7

0

50787

0.9422NTL 230 230.

-143.51

40146

143.9

6

50787

250.2

8-2

50.0

2

5L

96

1.0400

0.9422NTL 230 230.

2L

11

2-4

7.3

048.7

0

BOUNDRYW 230.

-2.00

-214.7

2

23.95

-26.7

9

2L

11

3-1

05.8

7

107.32

23.95

-26.7

9

2L

11

3

LA

NG

DO

N2

500.

54

15

8

1.0

177

-105.8

7

107.32

LA

NG

DO

N2

500.

54

15

8

1.0

177

40.60 340.79

5L941147.61 -1107.98

40.60 340.79

5L941147.61 -1107.98

Interface: AB-BC: Path-1

Total From MW Flow: 1201.09 MW

Interface: BC-US: Path-3

Total From MW Flow: 1032.64 MW

Interface: AB-MONTANA: Path-MATL

Total From MW Flow: -0.35 MW

54

23

2

CO

LE

MA

N7

138.

1.0

262

54

23

2

CO

LE

MA

N7

138.

1.0

262

50

77

6

NT

L 1

38

1

38.

1.0

326

50

77

6

NT

L 1

38

1

38.

1.0

326

48.04

-12.72

-47.24

12.45

48.04

-12.72

-47.24

12.45

50

83

0

BC

K 2

74P

138.

0.9

995

50

83

0

BC

K 2

74P

138.

0.9

995

54

32

9

PO

CA

TE

R7

138.

1.0

417

54

32

9

PO

CA

TE

R7

138.

1.0

417

5.44

-0.95

-5.43

-0.11

5.44

-0.95

-5.43

-0.11

13hs_case3_P1_12005

07

69

KC

L 1

3G

1

13.8

1.0

343

142.501

2.56

50

76

9

KC

L 1

3G

1

13.8

1.0

343

142.501

2.56

50

77

0

KC

L 1

3G

2

13.8

1.0

343

142.502

2.56

50

77

0

KC

L 1

3G

2

13.8

1.0

343

142.502

2.56

50

77

1

KC

L 1

3G

3

13.8

1.0

341

142.503

2.56

50

77

1

KC

L 1

3G

3

13.8

1.0

341

142.503

2.56

50

77

2

KC

L 1

3G

4

13.8

1.0

341

142.504

2.56

50

77

2

KC

L 1

3G

4

13.8

1.0

341

142.504

2.56

50766

SEV 13G1 13.8 1.0500

145.0

01

23.7

1

50766

SEV 13G1 13.8 1.0500

145.0

01

23.7

1

50767

SEV 13G2 13.8 1.0500

145.0

02

21.4

3

50767

SEV 13G2 13.8 1.0500

145.0

02

21.4

3

50768

SEV 13G3 13.8 1.0500

145.0

03

23.1

1

50768

SEV 13G3 13.8 1.0500

145.0

03

23.1

1

51036

SEV 13G4 13.8 1.0500

145.0

04

27.8

451036

SEV 13G4 13.8 1.0500

145.0

04

27.8

4

50786

INV 230 230. 1.0233

50786

INV 230 230. 1.0233

34.95

-55.72

-34.3

8

36.5

3

2L

25

8

34.95

-55.72

-34.3

8

36.5

3

2L

25

8

Page 22: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 22

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

50

79

1

0.9

878

CB

K 5

00

5

00.

50822

1.0396NLY 2PS2 230.

50784

1.0339NLY 230 230.

-51.0

651.0

9

16.7

1-1

5.6

4

50

79

1

50822

50784

-51.0

651.0

9

1.0339

16.7

1-1

5.6

4

NLY 230 230.

1.0396NLY 2PS2 230.

0.9

878

CB

K 5

00

5

00.

50792

1.0440SEL 500 500.

0.0

0

0.0

0

1206.7

3

-1182.24

5L

92

204.8

2

28.26

51352

0.9274CBK 12T2 12.6

0.0

0

0.0

0

51353

0.9274CBK 12T3 12.6

50792

51352

51353

1206.7

3

-1182.24

1.0440

0.9274CBK 12T3 12.6

0.9274CBK 12T2 12.6

5L

92

204.8

2

28.26

SEL 500 500.

50

78

2

0.9

744

CB

K 2

30

2

30.

0.00

0.00

35.27

-17.55

-34.87

17.55

50

78

2

0.9

744

CB

K 2

30

2

30.

0.00

0.00

35.27

-17.55

-34.87

17.55

0.00

0.00

35.29

-17.56

-34.90

17.56

80

64

1

0.9

883

SE

L 1

2T

1

12.6

80

30

6

0.9

883

SE

L 1

2T

4

12.6

80

30

5

0.9

884

SE

L 1

2T

3

12.6

80

64

1

80

30

6

80

30

5

0.9

884

SE

L 1

2T

3

12.6

0.9

883

SE

L 1

2T

4

12.6

0.9

883

SE

L 1

2T

1

12.6

0.00

0.00

35.29

-17.56

-34.90

17.56

80

30

4

0.9

884

SE

L 1

2T

2

12.6

50783

1.0406SEL 230 230.

0.00

-0.00

-33.64

130.62

36.27

-130.59

80

30

4

50783

1.0406SEL 230 230.

0.00

-0.00

-33.64

130.62

36.27

-130.59

0.9

884

SE

L 1

2T

2

12.6

0.00

-0.00

-24.63

95.62

26.54

-95.60

0.00

-0.00

-24.38

94.68

26.29

-94.65

0.00

-0.00

-24.63

0.00

-0.00

-24.38

94.68

26.29

-94.65

95.62

26.54

-95.60

-0.00

-0.00

-33.68

130.76

36.30

-130.72

-205.9

6

206.8

2

2L293

-15.2

6

18.1

1

80640

1.0016AAL 2T3 230.

-193.8

0197.4

12

L2

94

-16.6

228.0

4

-0.00

80640

-205.9

6

-193.8

0197.4

1

206.8

2

1.0016

2L

29

4-1

6.6

228.0

4

AAL 2T3 230.

2L293

-15.2

6

18.1

1

-0.00

-33.68

130.76

36.30

-130.72

50

70

2

1.0

630

AC

K 5

00

5

00.

282.50

0.00

51

13

4

1.0

653

VA

S 5

00

5

00.

50

78

8

1.0

360

KC

L 2

30

2

30.

0.10

0.21

144.08

-142.8

5

2L295

-32.40

31.9

9

50

70

2

51

13

4

50

78

8

144.08

-142.8

5

1.0

360

2L295

-32.40

31.9

9

KC

L 2

30

2

30.

1.0

653

VA

S 5

00

5

00.

1.0

630

AC

K 5

00

5

00.

143.95

-142.7

2

2L299

-32.35

31.9

4

CBK

143.95

-142.7

2

0.10

0.21

SEL

2L299

-32.35

31.9

4

ACK

VAS

KCL

AAL

NLY

0.0

0

0.0

0

0.0

0

0.0

0

50789

1.0015AAL 2T1 230. 172.7

9

-168.82

2L

29

4

9.8

6

0.59

193.8

0-1

93.8

0

16.6

4-1

6.5

7

50785

1.0415SEV 2T1 230.

50789

172.7

9

50785

193.8

0-1

93.8

0

-168.82

1.0015

2L

29

4

1.0415SEV 2T1 230.

16.6

4-1

6.5

79.8

6

0.59

AAL 2T1 230.

169.6

1-1

69.5

42

L2

21

18.5

1-1

8.8

2

51350

1.0406SEV 2T3 230. -0.2

00.2

02

L2

22

-0.1

0-0

.83

-595.9

6

602.65

5L

91

-130.8

0

55.47

51350

169.6

1

-0.2

0

-595.9

6

602.65

0.2

0

-169.5

4

1.0406

282.50

0.00

2L

22

2

5L

91

-130.8

0

55.47

-0.1

0-0

.83

SEV 2T3 230.

2L

22

1

18.5

1-1

8.8

2

159.68

-159.2

1

5L

96

-18.01

-199.4

6

SEV40146

1.0400BOUNDRYW 230.

51.0

6-5

1.0

52

L1

12

-16.7

016.0

3

50787

0.9464NTL 230 230.

159.68

40146

-159.2

1

50787

51.0

6-5

1.0

5

5L

96

1.0400

0.9464NTL 230 230.

2L

11

2-1

6.7

016.0

3

BOUNDRYW 230.

-18.01

-199.4

6

18.95

-22.1

0

2L

11

3-1

05.7

5

107.16

18.95

-22.1

0

2L

11

3

LA

NG

DO

N2

500.

54

15

8

1.0

179

-105.7

5

107.16

LA

NG

DO

N2

500.

54

15

8

1.0

179

41.46 338.36

5L941147.13 -1107.60

41.46 338.36

5L941147.13 -1107.60

Interface: AB-BC: Path-1

Total From MW Flow: 1200.49 MW

Interface: BC-US: Path-3

Total From MW Flow: 998.95 MW

Interface: AB-MONTANA: Path-MATL

Total From MW Flow: 0.47 MW

54

23

2

CO

LE

MA

N7

138.

1.0

265

54

23

2

CO

LE

MA

N7

138.

1.0

265

50

77

6

NT

L 1

38

1

38.

1.0

355

50

77

6

NT

L 1

38

1

38.

1.0

355

47.89

-9.22

-47.13

8.87

47.89

-9.22

-47.13

8.87

50

83

0

BC

K 2

74P

138.

1.0

025

50

83

0

BC

K 2

74P

138.

1.0

025

54

32

9

PO

CA

TE

R7

138.

1.0

426

54

32

9

PO

CA

TE

R7

138.

1.0

426

5.47

-0.93

-5.46

-0.12

5.47

-0.93

-5.46

-0.12

13hs_case3a_P1_12005

07

69

KC

L 1

3G

1

13.8

1.0

356

1

50

76

9

KC

L 1

3G

1

13.8

1.0

356

1

50

77

0

KC

L 1

3G

2

13.8

1.0

356

2

50

77

0

KC

L 1

3G

2

13.8

1.0

356

2

50

77

1

KC

L 1

3G

3

13.8

1.0

171

75.003

-21.03

50

77

1

KC

L 1

3G

3

13.8

1.0

171

75.003

-21.03

50

77

2

KC

L 1

3G

4

13.8

1.0

172

75.004

-21.03

50

77

2

KC

L 1

3G

4

13.8

1.0

172

75.004

-21.03

50766

SEV 13G1 13.8 1.0500

85.0

01

15.6

2

50766

SEV 13G1 13.8 1.0500

85.0

01

15.6

2

50767

SEV 13G2 13.8 1.0500

85.0

02

12.6

8

50767

SEV 13G2 13.8 1.0500

85.0

02

12.6

8

50768

SEV 13G3 13.8 1.0402

3

50768

SEV 13G3 13.8 1.0402

3

51036

SEV 13G4 13.8 1.0402

4

51036

SEV 13G4 13.8 1.0402

4

50786

INV 230 230. 1.0212

50786

INV 230 230. 1.0212

34.55

-53.68

-34.0

1

34.2

7

2L

25

8

34.55

-53.68

-34.0

1

34.2

7

2L

25

8

Page 23: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 23

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

50

79

1

1.0

201

CB

K 5

00 5

00.

50822

1.0383NLY 2PS2230.

50784

1.0330NLY 230 230.

250.8

3-2

50.2

1

18.5

02.9

5

50

79

1

50822

50784

250.8

3-2

50.2

1

1.0330

18.5

02.9

5

NLY 230 230.

1.0383NLY 2PS2230.

1.0

201

CB

K 5

00 5

00.

50792

1.0373SEL 500 500.

0.0

0

0.0

0

933.7

5

-919.71

5L

92

-12.9

3

102.97

51352

0.9543CBK 12T212.6

0.0

0

0.0

0

51353

0.9543CBK 12T312.6

50792

51352

51353

933.7

5

-919.71

1.0373

0.9543CBK 12T312.6

0.9543CBK 12T212.6

5L

92

-12.9

3

102.97

SEL 500 500.

50

78

2

1.0

032

CB

K 2

30 2

30.

0.00

-0.00

25.62

-45.05

-24.97

45.05

50

78

2

1.0

032

CB

K 2

30 2

30.

0.00

-0.00

25.62

-45.05

-24.97

45.05

-0.00

-0.00

25.63

-45.08

-24.99

45.09

80

64

1

0.9

789

SE

L 1

2T

112.6

80

30

6

0.9

788

SE

L 1

2T

412.6

80

30

5

0.9

789

SE

L 1

2T

312.6

80

64

1

80

30

6

80

30

5

0.9

789

SE

L 1

2T

312.6

0.9

788

SE

L 1

2T

412.6

0.9

789

SE

L 1

2T

112.6

-0.00

-0.00

25.63

-45.08

-24.99

45.09

80

30

4

0.9

790

SE

L 1

2T

212.6

50783

1.0307SEL 230 230.

0.00

0.00

-43.07

485.55

77.99

-485.05

80

30

4

50783

1.0307SEL 230 230.

0.00

0.00

-43.07

485.55

77.99

-485.05

0.9

790

SE

L 1

2T

212.6

0.00

0.00

-31.51

355.45

57.07

-355.08

-0.00

0.00

-31.23

351.94

56.54

-351.58

0.00

0.00

-31.51

-0.00

0.00

-31.23

351.94

56.54

-351.58

355.45

57.07

-355.08

-0.00

-0.00

-43.12

486.05

78.08

-485.55

170.4

3

-169.8

4

2L293

-8.4

9

9.4

9

80640

1.0071AAL 2T3 230.

-231.3

4236.4

22

L2

94

4.3

416.6

6

-0.00

80640

170.4

3

-231.3

4236.4

2

-169.8

4

1.0071

2L

29

4

4.3

416.6

6

AAL 2T3 230.

2L293

-8.4

9

9.4

9

-0.00

-43.12

486.05

78.08

-485.55

50

70

2

1.0

547

AC

K 5

00 5

00.

51

13

4

1.0

480

VA

S 5

00 5

00.

50

78

8

1.0

360

KC

L 2

30 2

30.

0.10

0.21

240.29

-236.9

8

2L295

-14.85

28.8

4

50

70

2

51

13

4

50

78

8

240.29

-236.9

8

1.0

360

2L295

-14.85

28.8

4

KC

L 2

30 2

30.

1.0

480

VA

S 5

00 5

00.

1.0

547

AC

K 5

00 5

00.

240.07

-236.7

7

2L299

-14.81

28.7

7

CBK

240.07

-236.7

7

0.10

0.21

SEL

2L299

-14.81

28.7

7

ACK

VAS

KCL

AAL

NLY

50789

1.0071AAL 2T1 230. 197.9

6

-192.85

2L

29

4

-16.2

3

33.70

231.3

4-2

31.3

4

-4.3

44.3

4

50785

1.0311SEV 2T1 230.

50789

197.9

6

50785

231.3

4-2

31.3

4

-192.85

1.0071

2L

29

4

1.0311SEV 2T1 230.

-4.3

44.3

4-1

6.2

3

33.70

AAL 2T1 230.

388.7

7-3

88.4

02

L2

21

-25.5

127.8

4

51350

1.0314SEV 2T3 230. 383.8

4-3

83.4

82

L2

22

-11.7

514.0

0

188.5

5

-187.78

5L

91

-220.1

9

63.63

51350

388.7

7

383.8

4

188.5

5

-187.78

-383.4

8

-388.4

0

1.0314

2L

22

2

5L

91

-220.1

9

63.63

-11.7

514.0

0

SEV 2T3 230.

2L

22

1

-25.5

127.8

4

-550.53

554.9

6

5L

96

11.78

-36.5

6

SEV40146

1.0400BOUNDRYW230.

-250.8

3251.0

82

L1

12

-18.4

919.8

4

50787

0.9881NTL 230 230.

-550.53

40146

554.9

6

50787

-250.8

3251.0

8

5L

96

1.0400

0.9881NTL 230 230.

2L

11

2-1

8.4

919.8

4

BOUNDRYW230.

11.78

-36.5

6

1.10

-4.3

6

2L

11

3-1

16.4

8

118.02

1.10

-4.3

6

2L

11

3

LA

NG

DO

N2500.

54

15

8

1.0

378

-116.4

8

118.02

LA

NG

DO

N2500.

54

15

8

1.0

378

Interface: AB-BC: Path-1

Total From MW Flow: 868.50 MW

Interface: BC-US: Path-3

Total From MW Flow: -850.84 MW

Interface: AB-MONTANA: Path-MATL

Total From MW Flow: 0.11 MW

54

23

2

CO

LE

MA

N9138.

1.0

219

54

23

2

CO

LE

MA

N9138.

1.0

219

50

77

6

NT

L 1

38 1

38.

1.0

235

50

77

6

NT

L 1

38 1

38.

1.0

235

50

83

0

BC

K 2

74P

138.

0.9

821

50

83

0

BC

K 2

74P

138.

0.9

821

54

32

9

PO

CA

TE

R7138.

1.0

404

54

32

9

PO

CA

TE

R7138.

1.0

404

1L2741L274

13hw2ae_case1_P1_08695

07

69

KC

L 1

3G

113.8

1.0

395

123.491

7.26

50

76

9

KC

L 1

3G

113.8

1.0

395

123.491

7.26

50

77

0

KC

L 1

3G

213.8

1.0

395

123.492

7.26

50

77

0

KC

L 1

3G

213.8

1.0

395

123.492

7.26

50

77

1

KC

L 1

3G

313.8

1.0

394

123.493

7.26

50

77

1

KC

L 1

3G

313.8

1.0

394

123.493

7.26

50

77

2

KC

L 1

3G

413.8

1.0

394

123.494

7.26

50

77

2

KC

L 1

3G

413.8

1.0

394

123.494

7.26

50766

SEV 13G113.8 1.0351

195.0

01

12.7

3

50766

SEV 13G113.8 1.0351

195.0

01

12.7

3

50767

SEV 13G213.8 1.0314

195.0

02

13.4

7

50767

SEV 13G213.8 1.0314

195.0

02

13.4

7

50768

SEV 13G313.8 1.0353

195.0

03

12.6

2

50768

SEV 13G313.8 1.0353

195.0

03

12.6

2

51036

SEV 13G413.8 1.0352

190.0

04

12.9

751036

SEV 13G413.8 1.0352

190.0

04

12.9

7

50786

INV 230 230. 1.0282

50786

INV 230 230. 1.0282

84.38

-40.58

-83.0

3

25.9

3

2L

25

8

84.38

-40.58

-83.0

3

25.9

3

2L

25

8

-38.36

14.42

38.93

-15.19

1L275 -38.36

14.42

38.93

-15.19

1L275

0.0

0

0.0

0

-810.37

141.65

829.57

-53.00

5L94 -810.37

141.65

829.57

-53.00

5L94

0.0

0

0.0

0

Page 24: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 24

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

50

79

1

1.0

247

CB

K 5

00 5

00.

50822

1.0387NLY 2PS2230.

50784

1.0378NLY 230 230.

251.2

4-2

50.5

3

7.4

117.5

3

50

79

1

50822

50784

251.2

4-2

50.5

3

1.0378

7.4

117.5

3

NLY 230 230.

1.0387NLY 2PS2230.

1.0

247

CB

K 5

00 5

00.

50792

1.0403SEL 500 500.

0.0

0

-132.5

6

941.3

3

-927.17

5L

92

-20.0

7

111.27

51352

0.9598CBK 12T212.6

0.0

0

0.0

0

51353

0.9599CBK 12T312.6

50792

51352

51353

941.3

3

-927.17

1.0403

0.9599CBK 12T312.6

0.9598CBK 12T212.6

5L

92

-20.0

7

111.27

SEL 500 500.

50

78

2

1.0

089

CB

K 2

30 2

30.

-0.00

0.00

30.79

-57.62

-29.78

57.63

50

78

2

1.0

089

CB

K 2

30 2

30.

-0.00

0.00

30.79

-57.62

-29.78

57.63

0.00

0.00

30.82

-57.66

-29.80

57.67

80

64

1

0.9

860

SE

L 1

2T

112.6

80

30

6

0.9

860

SE

L 1

2T

412.6

80

30

5

0.9

860

SE

L 1

2T

312.6

80

64

1

80

30

6

80

30

5

0.9

860

SE

L 1

2T

312.6

0.9

860

SE

L 1

2T

412.6

0.9

860

SE

L 1

2T

112.6

0.00

0.00

30.82

-57.66

-29.80

57.67

80

30

4

0.9

861

SE

L 1

2T

212.6

50783

1.0380SEL 230 230.

0.00

-0.00

-25.77

139.34

28.68

-139.30

80

30

4

50783

1.0380SEL 230 230.

0.00

-0.00

-25.77

139.34

28.68

-139.30

0.9

861

SE

L 1

2T

212.6

-0.00

-0.00

-18.86

102.01

20.99

-101.98

-0.00

-0.00

-18.68

101.00

20.79

-100.97

-0.00

-0.00

-18.86

-0.00

-0.00

-18.68

101.00

20.79

-100.97

102.01

20.99

-101.98

-0.00

-0.00

-25.80

139.49

28.72

-139.44

188.0

2

-187.3

0

2L293

-27.7

6

29.6

5

80640

1.0156AAL 2T3 230.

-204.0

0207.8

82

L2

94

1.8

211.1

8

-0.00

80640

188.0

2

-204.0

0207.8

8

-187.3

0

1.0156

2L

29

4

1.8

211.1

8

AAL 2T3 230.

2L293

-27.7

6

29.6

5

-0.00

-25.80

139.49

28.72

-139.44

50

70

2

1.0

620

AC

K 5

00 5

00.

51

13

4

1.0

544

VA

S 5

00 5

00.

50

78

8

1.0

360

KC

L 2

30 2

30.

0.10

0.21

80.63

-80.2

4

2L295

-19.74

13.5

3

50

70

2

51

13

4

50

78

8

80.63

-80.2

4

1.0

360

2L295

-19.74

13.5

3

KC

L 2

30 2

30.

1.0

544

VA

S 5

00 5

00.

1.0

620

AC

K 5

00 5

00.

80.55

-80.1

7

2L299

-19.72

13.4

9

CBK

80.55

-80.1

7

0.10

0.21

SEL

2L299

-19.72

13.4

9

ACK

VAS

KCL

AAL

NLY

50789

1.0156AAL 2T1 230. 170.6

3

-166.90

2L

29

4

-13.6

5

21.70

204.0

0-2

04.0

0

-1.8

21.8

2

50785

1.0379SEV 2T1 230.

50789

170.6

3

50785

204.0

0-2

04.0

0

-166.90

1.0156

2L

29

4

1.0379SEV 2T1 230.

-1.8

21.8

2-1

3.6

5

21.70

AAL 2T1 230.

-0.2

00.2

02

L2

21

-4.2

83.3

8

51350

1.0380SEV 2T3 230. -0.2

00.2

02

L2

22

-0.1

0-0

.82

-467.3

5

471.50

5L

91

-166.5

9

56.47

51350

-0.2

0

-0.2

0

-467.3

5

471.50

0.2

0

0.2

0

1.0380

2L

22

2

5L

91

-166.5

9

56.47

-0.1

0-0

.82

SEV 2T3 230.

2L

22

1

-4.2

83.3

8

-7.67

7.7

4

5L

96

-42.33

-45.0

9

SEV40146

1.0400BOUNDRYW230.

-251.2

4251.4

92

L1

12

-7.4

18.7

6

50787

0.9929NTL 230 230.

-7.67

40146

7.7

4

50787

-251.2

4251.4

9

5L

96

1.0400

0.9929NTL 230 230.

2L

11

2

-7.4

18.7

6

BOUNDRYW230.

-42.33

-45.0

9

2.26

-5.8

6

2L

11

3-1

15.9

1

117.42

2.26

-5.8

6

2L

11

3

LA

NG

DO

N2500.

54

15

8

1.0

394

-115.9

1

117.42

LA

NG

DO

N2500.

54

15

8

1.0

394

Interface: AB-BC: Path-1

Total From MW Flow: 850.19 MW

Interface: BC-US: Path-3

Total From MW Flow: -848.88 MW

Interface: AB-MONTANA: Path-MATL

Total From MW Flow: -0.44 MW

54

23

2

CO

LE

MA

N9138.

1.0

244

54

23

2

CO

LE

MA

N9138.

1.0

244

50

77

6

NT

L 1

38 1

38.

1.0

268

50

77

6

NT

L 1

38 1

38.

1.0

268

50

83

0

BC

K 2

74P

138.

0.9

856

50

83

0

BC

K 2

74P

138.

0.9

856

54

32

9

PO

CA

TE

R7138.

1.0

432

54

32

9

PO

CA

TE

R7138.

1.0

432

1L2741L274

13hw2ae_case1a_P1_08505

07

69

KC

L 1

3G

113.8

1.0

148

0.001

-24.59

50

76

9

KC

L 1

3G

113.8

1.0

148

0.001

-24.59

50

77

0

KC

L 1

3G

213.8

1.0

355

2

50

77

0

KC

L 1

3G

213.8

1.0

355

2

50

77

1

KC

L 1

3G

313.8

1.0

355

3

50

77

1

KC

L 1

3G

313.8

1.0

355

3

50

77

2

KC

L 1

3G

413.8

1.0

355

4

50

77

2

KC

L 1

3G

413.8

1.0

355

4

50766

SEV 13G113.8 1.0351

0.0

01

-4.1

7

50766

SEV 13G113.8 1.0351

0.0

01

-4.1

7

50767

SEV 13G213.8 1.0374

2

50767

SEV 13G213.8 1.0374

2

50768

SEV 13G313.8 1.0376

3

50768

SEV 13G313.8 1.0376

3

51036

SEV 13G413.8 1.0376

4

51036

SEV 13G413.8 1.0376

4

50786

INV 230 230. 1.0342

50786

INV 230 230. 1.0342

84.36

-41.17

-83.0

3

26.1

6

2L

25

8

84.36

-41.17

-83.0

3

26.1

6

2L

25

8

-37.78

13.04

38.32

-13.88

1L275 -37.78

13.04

38.32

-13.88

1L275

0.0

0

0.0

0

-793.64

125.80

811.87

-51.68

5L94 -793.64

125.80

811.87

-51.68

5L94

0.0

0

-132.5

6

Page 25: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 25

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

50

79

1

0.9

848

CB

K 5

00 5

00.

50822

1.0382NLY 2PS2230.

50784

1.0311NLY 230 230.

251.5

5-2

50.8

1

22.3

73.6

7

50

79

1

50822

50784

251.5

5-2

50.8

1

1.0311

22.3

73.6

7

NLY 230 230.

1.0382NLY 2PS2230.

0.9

848

CB

K 5

00 5

00.

50792

1.0342SEL 500 500.

0.0

0

0.0

0

1166.8

3

-1143.74

5L

92

169.4

5

46.17

51352

0.9232CBK 12T212.6

0.0

0

0.0

0

51353

0.9232CBK 12T312.6

50792

51352

51353

1166.8

3

-1143.74

1.0342

0.9232CBK 12T312.6

0.9232CBK 12T212.6

5L

92

169.4

5

46.17

SEL 500 500.

50

78

2

0.9

702

CB

K 2

30 2

30.

-0.00

-0.00

30.71

-41.43

-30.03

41.44

50

78

2

0.9

702

CB

K 2

30 2

30.

-0.00

-0.00

30.71

-41.43

-30.03

41.44

0.00

0.00

30.73

-41.46

-30.05

41.47

80

64

1

0.9

810

SE

L 1

2T

112.6

80

30

6

0.9

810

SE

L 1

2T

412.6

80

30

5

0.9

810

SE

L 1

2T

312.6

80

64

1

80

30

6

80

30

5

0.9

810

SE

L 1

2T

312.6

0.9

810

SE

L 1

2T

412.6

0.9

810

SE

L 1

2T

112.6

0.00

0.00

30.73

-41.46

-30.05

41.47

80

30

4

0.9

811

SE

L 1

2T

212.6

50783

1.0326SEL 230 230.

0.00

0.00

-20.56

204.53

26.75

-204.44

80

30

4

50783

1.0326SEL 230 230.

0.00

0.00

-20.56

204.53

26.75

-204.44

0.9

811

SE

L 1

2T

212.6

0.00

0.00

-15.05

149.72

19.58

-149.66

0.00

0.00

-14.91

148.25

19.39

-148.18

0.00

0.00

-15.05

0.00

0.00

-14.91

148.25

19.39

-148.18

149.72

19.58

-149.66

-0.00

-0.00

-20.59

204.74

26.78

-204.65

156.2

9

-155.7

7

2L293

-32.4

4

32.9

4

80640

0.9908AAL 2T3 230.

-238.7

7244.3

52

L2

94

-15.4

339.9

7

-0.00

80640

156.2

9

-238.7

7244.3

5

-155.7

7

0.9908

2L

29

4-1

5.4

339.9

7

AAL 2T3 230.

2L293

-32.4

4

32.9

4

-0.00

-20.59

204.74

26.78

-204.65

50

70

2

1.0

642

AC

K 5

00 5

00.

51

13

4

1.0

523

VA

S 5

00 5

00.

50

78

8

1.0

360

KC

L 2

30 2

30.

0.10

0.21

103.09

-102.4

8

2L295

-8.89

4.2

6

50

70

2

51

13

4

50

78

8

103.09

-102.4

8

1.0

360

2L295

-8.89

4.2

6

KC

L 2

30 2

30.

1.0

523

VA

S 5

00 5

00.

1.0

642

AC

K 5

00 5

00.

103.00

-102.3

9

2L299

-8.87

4.2

4

CBK

103.00

-102.3

9

0.10

0.21

SEL

2L299

-8.87

4.2

4

ACK

VAS

KCL

AAL

NLY

50789

0.9908AAL 2T1 230. 205.3

6

-199.67

2L

29

4

3.4

1

18.72

238.7

7-2

38.7

7

15.4

3-1

5.4

3

50785

1.0328SEV 2T1 230.

50789

205.3

6

50785

238.7

7-2

38.7

7

-199.67

0.9908

2L

29

4

1.0328SEV 2T1 230.

15.4

3-1

5.4

33.4

1

18.72

AAL 2T1 230.

194.2

1-1

94.1

22

L2

21

-11.2

311.1

3

51350

1.0326SEV 2T3 230. -0.2

00.2

02

L2

22

-0.1

1-0

.80

-440.7

8

444.56

5L

91

-199.4

3

85.78

51350

194.2

1

-0.2

0

-440.7

8

444.56

0.2

0

-194.1

2

1.0326

2L

22

2

5L

91

-199.4

3

85.78

-0.1

1-0

.80

SEV 2T3 230.

2L

22

1

-11.2

311.1

3

19.23

-19.1

1

5L

96

-24.14

-62.5

2

SEV40146

1.0400BOUNDRYW230.

-251.5

5251.8

12

L1

12

-22.3

623.7

2

50787

0.9516NTL 230 230.

19.23

40146

-19.1

1

50787

-251.5

5251.8

1

5L

96

1.0400

0.9516NTL 230 230.

2L

11

2-2

2.3

623.7

2

BOUNDRYW230.

-24.14

-62.5

2

5.86

-7.5

8

2L

11

3-1

15.5

6

117.20

5.86

-7.5

8

2L

11

3

LA

NG

DO

N2500.

54

15

8

1.0

130

-115.5

6

117.20

LA

NG

DO

N2500.

54

15

8

1.0

130

Interface: AB-BC: Path-1

Total From MW Flow: 1098.80 MW

Interface: BC-US: Path-3

Total From MW Flow: -1095.51 MW

Interface: AB-MONTANA: Path-MATL

Total From MW Flow: -58.93 MW

54

23

2

CO

LE

MA

N9138.

1.0

277

54

23

2

CO

LE

MA

N9138.

1.0

277

50

77

6

NT

L 1

38 1

38.

1.0

317

50

77

6

NT

L 1

38 1

38.

1.0

317

50

83

0

BC

K 2

74P

138.

0.9

908

50

83

0

BC

K 2

74P

138.

0.9

908

54

32

9

PO

CA

TE

R7138.

1.0

417

54

32

9

PO

CA

TE

R7138.

1.0

417

1L2741L274

13hw2ae_case2a_P1_11005

07

69

KC

L 1

3G

113.8

1.0

407

69.001

6.11

50

76

9

KC

L 1

3G

113.8

1.0

407

69.001

6.11

50

77

0

KC

L 1

3G

213.8

1.0

355

2

50

77

0

KC

L 1

3G

213.8

1.0

355

2

50

77

1

KC

L 1

3G

313.8

1.0

355

3

50

77

1

KC

L 1

3G

313.8

1.0

355

3

50

77

2

KC

L 1

3G

413.8

1.0

355

4

50

77

2

KC

L 1

3G

413.8

1.0

355

4

50766

SEV 13G113.8 1.0351

195.0

01

9.7

6

50766

SEV 13G113.8 1.0351

195.0

01

9.7

6

50767

SEV 13G213.8 1.0323

2

50767

SEV 13G213.8 1.0323

2

50768

SEV 13G313.8 1.0321

3

50768

SEV 13G313.8 1.0321

3

51036

SEV 13G413.8 1.0321

4

51036

SEV 13G413.8 1.0321

4

50786

INV 230 230. 0.9949

50786

INV 230 230. 0.9949

84.35

-38.62

-82.9

3

26.0

5

2L

25

8

84.35

-38.62

-82.9

3

26.0

5

2L

25

8

-37.46

10.90

37.97

-11.83

1L275 -37.46

10.90

37.97

-11.83

1L275

0.0

0

0.0

0

-1026.94

289.08

1060.84

13.86

5L94 -1026.94

289.08

1060.84

13.86

5L94

0.0

0

0.0

0

Page 26: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 26

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

50

79

1

0.9

498

CB

K 5

00 5

00.

50822

1.0371NLY 2PS2230.

50784

1.0192NLY 230 230.

250.8

3-2

50.1

7

53.1

3-3

0.1

2

50

79

1

50822

50784

250.8

3-2

50.1

7

1.0192

53.1

3-3

0.1

2

NLY 230 230.

1.0371NLY 2PS2230.

0.9

498

CB

K 5

00 5

00.

50792

1.0153SEL 500 500.

0.0

0

0.0

0

1247.6

9

-1219.49

5L

92

264.9

1

25.07

51352

0.8874CBK 12T212.6

0.0

0

0.0

0

51353

0.8874CBK 12T312.6

50792

51352

51353

1247.6

9

-1219.49

1.0153

0.8874CBK 12T312.6

0.8874CBK 12T212.6

5L

92

264.9

1

25.07

SEL 500 500.

50

78

2

0.9

330

CB

K 2

30 2

30.

-0.00

0.00

17.80

-29.42

-17.47

29.42

50

78

2

0.9

330

CB

K 2

30 2

30.

-0.00

0.00

17.80

-29.42

-17.47

29.42

-0.00

0.00

17.81

-29.44

-17.48

29.44

80

64

1

0.9

672

SE

L 1

2T

112.6

80

30

6

0.9

672

SE

L 1

2T

412.6

80

30

5

0.9

671

SE

L 1

2T

312.6

80

64

1

80

30

6

80

30

5

0.9

671

SE

L 1

2T

312.6

0.9

672

SE

L 1

2T

412.6

0.9

672

SE

L 1

2T

112.6

-0.00

0.00

17.81

-29.44

-17.48

29.44

80

30

4

0.9

671

SE

L 1

2T

212.6

50783

1.0171SEL 230 230.

-0.00

-0.00

11.85

474.71

22.19

-474.22

80

30

4

50783

1.0171SEL 230 230.

-0.00

-0.00

11.85

474.71

22.19

-474.22

0.9

671

SE

L 1

2T

212.6

-0.00

0.00

8.69

347.51

16.23

-347.16

-0.00

-0.00

8.58

344.09

16.09

-343.73

-0.00

0.00

8.69

-0.00

-0.00

8.58

344.09

16.09

-343.73

347.51

16.23

-347.16

0.00

-0.00

11.85

475.20

22.22

-474.71

131.7

1

-131.3

5

2L293

-4.9

6

4.4

7

80640

0.9622AAL 2T3 230.

-271.4

5279.1

42

L2

94

-28.0

866.9

2

0.00

80640

131.7

1

-271.4

5279.1

4

-131.3

5

0.9622

2L

29

4-2

8.0

866.9

2

AAL 2T3 230.

2L293

-4.9

6

4.4

7

-0.00

11.85

475.20

22.22

-474.71

50

70

2

1.0

481

AC

K 5

00 5

00.

51

13

4

1.0

356

VA

S 5

00 5

00.

50

78

8

1.0

360

KC

L 2

30 2

30.

0.10

0.21

240.71

-237.3

6

2L295

18.23

-3.8

9

50

70

2

51

13

4

50

78

8

240.71

-237.3

6

1.0

360

2L295

18.23

-3.8

9

KC

L 2

30 2

30.

1.0

356

VA

S 5

00 5

00.

1.0

481

AC

K 5

00 5

00.

240.48

-237.1

4

2L299

18.24

-3.9

3

CBK

240.48

-237.1

4

0.10

0.21

SEL

2L299

18.24

-3.9

3

ACK

VAS

KCL

AAL

NLY

50789

0.9622AAL 2T1 230. 238.0

0

-229.85

2L

29

4

15.8

4

23.76

271.4

5-2

71.4

5

28.0

8-2

8.0

8

50785

1.0183SEV 2T1 230.

50789

238.0

0

50785

271.4

5-2

71.4

5

-229.85

0.9622

2L

29

4

1.0183SEV 2T1 230.

28.0

8-2

8.0

815.8

4

23.76

AAL 2T1 230.

388.7

5-3

88.3

72

L2

21

11.5

9-9

.16

51350

1.0189SEV 2T3 230. 383.8

1-3

83.4

32

L2

22

36.2

3-3

3.8

5

-9.1

9

9.46

5L

91

-257.4

3

100.13

51350

388.7

5

383.8

1

-9.1

9

9.46

-383.4

3

-388.3

7

1.0189

2L

22

2

5L

91

-257.4

3

100.13

36.2

3-3

3.8

5

SEV 2T3 230.

2L

22

1

11.5

9-9

.16

-398.78

401.3

4

5L

96

34.72

-84.2

1

SEV40146

1.0400BOUNDRYW230.

-250.8

3251.1

02

L1

12

-53.1

454.5

7

50787

0.9129NTL 230 230.

-398.78

40146

401.3

4

50787

-250.8

3251.1

0

5L

96

1.0400

0.9129NTL 230 230.

2L

11

2-5

3.1

454.5

7

BOUNDRYW230.

34.72

-84.2

1

7.50

-6.3

8

2L

11

3-1

20.1

5

122.07

7.50

-6.3

8

2L

11

3

LA

NG

DO

N2500.

54

15

8

1.0

072

-120.1

5

122.07

LA

NG

DO

N2500.

54

15

8

1.0

072

Interface: AB-BC: Path-1

Total From MW Flow: 1204.66 MW

Interface: BC-US: Path-3

Total From MW Flow: -833.44 MW

Interface: AB-MONTANA: Path-MATL

Total From MW Flow: -19.60 MW

54

23

2

CO

LE

MA

N9138.

1.0

222

54

23

2

CO

LE

MA

N9138.

1.0

222

50

77

6

NT

L 1

38 1

38.

1.0

244

50

77

6

NT

L 1

38 1

38.

1.0

244

50

83

0

BC

K 2

74P

138.

0.9

830

50

83

0

BC

K 2

74P

138.

0.9

830

54

32

9

PO

CA

TE

R7138.

1.0

428

54

32

9

PO

CA

TE

R7138.

1.0

428

1L2741L274

13hw2ae_case3_P1_12005

07

69

KC

L 1

3G

113.8

1.0

574

123.491

29.38

50

76

9

KC

L 1

3G

113.8

1.0

574

123.491

29.38

50

77

0

KC

L 1

3G

213.8

1.0

574

123.492

29.38

50

77

0

KC

L 1

3G

213.8

1.0

574

123.492

29.38

50

77

1

KC

L 1

3G

313.8

1.0

579

123.493

29.38

50

77

1

KC

L 1

3G

313.8

1.0

579

123.493

29.38

50

77

2

KC

L 1

3G

413.8

1.0

579

123.494

29.38

50

77

2

KC

L 1

3G

413.8

1.0

579

123.494

29.38

50766

SEV 13G113.8 1.0351

195.0

01

35.3

3

50766

SEV 13G113.8 1.0351

195.0

01

35.3

3

50767

SEV 13G213.8 1.0314

195.0

02

29.0

8

50767

SEV 13G213.8 1.0314

195.0

02

29.0

8

50768

SEV 13G313.8 1.0353

195.0

03

34.6

5

50768

SEV 13G313.8 1.0353

195.0

03

34.6

5

51036

SEV 13G413.8 1.0352

190.0

04

40.1

451036

SEV 13G413.8 1.0352

190.0

04

40.1

4

50786

INV 230 230. 0.9420

50786

INV 230 230. 0.9420

83.69

-24.32

-82.2

8

13.6

6

2L

25

8

83.69

-24.32

-82.2

8

13.6

6

2L

25

8

-43.30

16.05

44.03

-16.47

1L275 -43.30

16.05

44.03

-16.47

1L275

0.0

0

0.0

0

-1117.12

433.21

1160.64

9.82

5L94 -1117.12

433.21

1160.64

9.82

5L94

0.0

0

0.0

0

Page 27: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 27

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

50

79

1

0.9

612

CB

K 5

00 5

00.

50822

1.0377NLY 2PS2230.

50784

1.0256NLY 230 230.

251.8

5-2

51.0

8

34.3

1-7

.63

50

79

1

50822

50784

251.8

5-2

51.0

8

1.0256

34.3

1-7

.63

NLY 230 230.

1.0377NLY 2PS2230.

0.9

612

CB

K 5

00 5

00.

50792

1.0267SEL 500 500.

0.0

0

0.0

0

1265.7

1

-1237.37

5L

92

264.8

4

24.92

51352

0.9002CBK 12T212.6

0.0

0

0.0

0

51353

0.9002CBK 12T312.6

50792

51352

51353

1265.7

1

-1237.37

1.0267

0.9002CBK 12T312.6

0.9002CBK 12T212.6

5L

92

264.8

4

24.92

SEL 500 500.

50

78

2

0.9

462

CB

K 2

30 2

30.

0.00

-0.00

25.84

-35.01

-25.33

35.01

50

78

2

0.9

462

CB

K 2

30 2

30.

0.00

-0.00

25.84

-35.01

-25.33

35.01

0.00

-0.00

25.86

-35.04

-25.35

35.04

80

64

1

0.9

761

SE

L 1

2T

112.6

80

30

6

0.9

761

SE

L 1

2T

412.6

80

30

5

0.9

761

SE

L 1

2T

312.6

80

64

1

80

30

6

80

30

5

0.9

761

SE

L 1

2T

312.6

0.9

761

SE

L 1

2T

412.6

0.9

761

SE

L 1

2T

112.6

0.00

-0.00

25.86

-35.04

-25.35

35.04

80

30

4

0.9

761

SE

L 1

2T

212.6

50783

1.0271SEL 230 230.

0.00

0.00

-6.89

231.12

14.81

-231.01

80

30

4

50783

1.0271SEL 230 230.

0.00

0.00

-6.89

231.12

14.81

-231.01

0.9

761

SE

L 1

2T

212.6

-0.00

-0.00

-5.04

169.19

10.83

-169.11

0.00

0.00

-5.00

167.53

10.74

-167.44

-0.00

-0.00

-5.04

0.00

0.00

-5.00

167.53

10.74

-167.44

169.19

10.83

-169.11

0.00

-0.00

-6.90

231.36

14.83

-231.25

143.4

0

-142.9

6

2L293

-30.7

7

30.7

8

80640

0.9747AAL 2T3 230.

-254.1

2260.6

92

L2

94

-25.6

856.9

1

0.00

80640

143.4

0

-254.1

2260.6

9

-142.9

6

0.9747

2L

29

4-2

5.6

856.9

1

AAL 2T3 230.

2L293

-30.7

7

30.7

8

-0.00

-6.90

231.36

14.83

-231.25

50

70

2

1.0

652

AC

K 5

00 5

00.

51

13

4

1.0

505

VA

S 5

00 5

00.

50

78

8

1.0

360

KC

L 2

30 2

30.

0.10

0.21

126.50

-125.5

8

2L295

2.25

-4.7

0

50

70

2

51

13

4

50

78

8

126.50

-125.5

8

1.0

360

2L295

2.25

-4.7

0

KC

L 2

30 2

30.

1.0

505

VA

S 5

00 5

00.

1.0

652

AC

K 5

00 5

00.

126.38

-125.4

6

2L299

2.26

-4.7

2

CBK

126.38

-125.4

6

0.10

0.21

SEL

2L299

2.26

-4.7

2

ACK

VAS

KCL

AAL

NLY

50789

0.9747AAL 2T1 230. 220.7

0

-213.87

2L

29

4

13.5

4

16.83

254.1

2-2

54.1

2

25.6

8-2

5.6

8

50785

1.0273SEV 2T1 230.

50789

220.7

0

50785

254.1

2-2

54.1

2

-213.87

0.9747

2L

29

4

1.0273SEV 2T1 230.

25.6

8-2

5.6

813.5

4

16.83

AAL 2T1 230.

116.6

4-1

16.6

12

L2

21

-1.7

71.1

7

51350

1.0275SEV 2T3 230. 116.5

9-1

16.5

62

L2

22

7.2

0-7

.80

-434.2

9

438.09

5L

91

-227.7

5

116.55

51350

116.6

4

116.5

9

-434.2

9

438.09

-116.5

6

-116.6

1

1.0275

2L

22

2

5L

91

-227.7

5

116.55

7.2

0-7

.80

SEV 2T3 230.

2L

22

1

-1.7

71.1

7

32.80

-32.6

0

5L

96

2.88

-88.3

0

SEV40146

1.0400BOUNDRYW230.

-251.8

5252.1

12

L1

12

-34.3

235.7

1

50787

0.9259NTL 230 230.

32.80

40146

-32.6

0

50787

-251.8

5252.1

1

5L

96

1.0400

0.9259NTL 230 230.

2L

11

2-3

4.3

235.7

1

BOUNDRYW230.

2.88

-88.3

0

7.92

-8.2

8

2L

11

3-1

16.1

5

117.90

7.92

-8.2

8

2L

11

3

LA

NG

DO

N2500.

54

15

8

1.0

095

-116.1

5

117.90

LA

NG

DO

N2500.

54

15

8

1.0

095

Interface: AB-BC: Path-1

Total From MW Flow: 1206.90 MW

Interface: BC-US: Path-3

Total From MW Flow: -1203.97 MW

Interface: AB-MONTANA: Path-MATL

Total From MW Flow: -101.08 MW

54

23

2

CO

LE

MA

N9138.

1.0

298

54

23

2

CO

LE

MA

N9138.

1.0

298

50

77

6

NT

L 1

38 1

38.

1.0

334

50

77

6

NT

L 1

38 1

38.

1.0

334

50

83

0

BC

K 2

74P

138.

0.9

926

50

83

0

BC

K 2

74P

138.

0.9

926

54

32

9

PO

CA

TE

R7138.

1.0

380

54

32

9

PO

CA

TE

R7138.

1.0

380

1L2741L27413hw2ae_case3b_P1_1200

50

76

9

KC

L 1

3G

113.8

1.0

355

1

50

76

9

KC

L 1

3G

113.8

1.0

355

1

50

77

0

KC

L 1

3G

213.8

1.0

355

2

50

77

0

KC

L 1

3G

213.8

1.0

355

2

50

77

1

KC

L 1

3G

313.8

1.0

519

70.003

19.40

50

77

1

KC

L 1

3G

313.8

1.0

519

70.003

19.40

50

77

2

KC

L 1

3G

413.8

1.0

518

70.004

19.40

50

77

2

KC

L 1

3G

413.8

1.0

518

70.004

19.40

50766

SEV 13G113.8 1.0268

1

50766

SEV 13G113.8 1.0268

1

50767

SEV 13G213.8 1.0314

117.0

02

9.3

8

50767

SEV 13G213.8 1.0314

117.0

02

9.3

8

50768

SEV 13G313.8 1.0353

117.0

03

14.9

4

50768

SEV 13G313.8 1.0353

117.0

03

14.9

4

51036

SEV 13G413.8 1.0270

4

51036

SEV 13G413.8 1.0270

4

50786

INV 230 230. 0.9666

50786

INV 230 230. 0.9666

83.82

-33.97

-82.3

8

22.7

1

2L

25

8

83.82

-33.97

-82.3

8

22.7

1

2L

25

8

-39.03

12.05

39.58

-12.88

1L275 -39.03

12.05

39.58

-12.88

1L275

0.0

0

0.0

0

-1124.24

409.06

1167.32

25.71

5L94 -1124.24

409.06

1167.32

25.71

5L94

0.0

0

0.0

0

Page 28: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 28

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

APPENDIX B – CONTINGENCIES

The following table lists the contintencies applied in post contingency power flows and transient

stability analses. The contingencies used in the heavy summer and heavy winter cases are identical

while the RAS control actions could differ depending on the actual flows, etc. For transient

stability simulation, the switching sequence consisted of 3-phase fault applied at either side of the

device, followed by subsequent trip out by protection. Appropriate RAS actions were applied

where applicable, according to BCH operating order instructions. Multiple devices in the same

protection zone are regarded as a single contingency and are tripped with timings according to

protection settings. For post disturbance steady-state performance simulation, post contingency

power flows were performed with all applicable protection and RAS actions and automatically

controlled devices turned on.

Contingency Name Contingency Description Comment

SEL T1 SEL T1 contingency and trip out

SEL T2 & T3 Contingency on SEL T2 or T3, Trip out both T2 & T3

SEL T2 & T3 in the same protection zone

CBK T2 & T6 Contingency on CBK T2 or T6, Trip out both T2 & T6

CBK T2 & T6 in the same protection zone

5L71 MCA-NIC 5L71 contingency and trip out, Generation shedding applied at MCA

5L75 REV-ACK 5L71 contingency and trip out

5L76 ACK-NIC 5L76 contingency and trip out

5L81 NIC-ING 5L81 contingency and trip out Series-compensated line

5L82 NIC-MDN 5L82 contingency and trip out Series-compensated line

5L87 NIC-KLY 5L87 contingency and trip out Series-compensated line

5L91 ACK-SEL 5L91 contingency and trip out

5L92 CBK-SEL 5L92 contingency and trip out During high transfer, loss of 5L92 would result in tripping 5L94 and separation of 138kV ties with AB. Appropriate amount of generation shedding was applied in BCH.

5L94 trip out

Open 1L275 at Natal

Open 1L274 at Britt Creek if normally closed

Trip open MATL

Generation shedding applied in BCH

5L94 CBK-LGN 5L94 contingency and trip out During high transfer, loss of 5L94 would result in tripping open 138kV ties with AB. Appropriate amount of generation shedding was applied in BCH.

Open 1L275 at Natal

Open 1L274 at Britt Creek if normally closed

Page 29: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 29

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Trip open MATL Generation shedding applied in BCH

5L96 VAS-SEL 5L96 contingency and trip out

48L (BEN-KET 161) tripped by RAS

5L98 NIC-VAS 5L98 contingency and trip out

2L112 NLY-BDY 2L112 contingency and trip out

2L221 SEV-SEL 2L221 contingency and trip out

2L277 WAN-NLY 2L277 contingency and trip out , generation shedding at WAN

For the winter case, generation shedding applied to maintain transient stability

2L288 KCL-BTS 2L288 contingency and trip out

2L289 SEL-BTS 2L289 contingency and trip out

2L293 SEL-NLY 2L293 contingency and trip out

2L294 CBK-NLY 2L294 contingency and trip out

2L295 SEL-KCL 2L295 contingency and trip out

1L274 NTL-POCATER 1L274 contingency and trip out

1L275 NTL-COLEMAN 1L275 contingency and trip out

Page 30: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 30

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

APPENDIX C – POWER FLOW CONTINGENCY RESULTS

The tables in this appendix show more detailed contingecy analysis results for BC to AB transfers

of 1100 MW (heavy winter) and 1200 MW(heavy winter and heavy summer).

Page 31: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 31

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

HS Case 3 – 1200 MW BC to AB

Cont. Name NIC 500 ACK 500 SEL 500 SEL 230 VAS 500 CBK 500 CBK 230 NTL 230 NTL 138 NLY 230

LNGDN 500

[50703] [50702] [50792] [50783] [51134] [50791] [50782] [50787] [50776] [50784] [54158]

Pre Contingency 1.054 1.060 1.042 1.037 1.062 0.987 0.974 0.942 1.032 1.028 1.018

SEL T1 1.054 1.060 1.043 1.036 1.063 0.988 0.974 0.942 1.033 1.027 1.018

SEL T2&T3 1.054 1.060 1.044 1.035 1.063 0.988 0.974 0.942 1.032 1.026 1.018

CBK T2&T6 1.053 1.060 1.041 1.036 1.062 0.982 0.973 0.942 1.032 1.028 1.017

5L71 MCA-NIC 1.029 1.045 1.034 1.032 1.044 0.980 0.968 0.937 1.029 1.024 1.016

5L75 REV-ACK 1.047 1.048 1.038 1.034 1.056 0.984 0.971 0.940 1.030 1.026 1.017

5L76 ACK-NIC 1.043 1.051 1.036 1.033 1.052 0.982 0.970 0.938 1.029 1.024 1.016

5L81 NIC-ING 1.039 1.052 1.036 1.033 1.051 0.982 0.969 0.938 1.029 1.021 1.016

5L82 NIC-MDN 1.039 1.052 1.037 1.033 1.051 0.982 0.970 0.939 1.030 1.021 1.017

5L87 NIC-KLY 1.045 1.056 1.039 1.035 1.056 0.985 0.972 0.940 1.031 1.026 1.017

5L91 ACK-SEL 1.049 1.058 1.025 1.027 1.051 0.973 0.962 0.932 1.024 1.022 1.014

5L96 VAS-SEL 1.050 1.056 1.026 1.027 1.055 0.974 0.962 0.932 1.025 1.019 1.015

5L98 NIC-VAS 1.047 1.057 1.040 1.035 1.056 0.985 0.972 0.941 1.031 1.027 1.017

2L112 NLY-BDY 1.049 1.057 1.040 1.035 1.058 0.986 0.972 0.940 1.031 1.029 1.017

2L221 SEV-SEL 1.050 1.055 1.038 1.034 1.058 0.984 0.972 0.940 1.031 1.027 1.017

2L277 WAN-NLY 1.053 1.060 1.041 1.036 1.062 0.986 0.973 0.941 1.032 1.026 1.017

2L288 KCL-BTS 1.053 1.060 1.041 1.036 1.062 0.986 0.974 0.942 1.032 1.028 1.018

2L289 SEL-BTS 1.054 1.060 1.042 1.037 1.062 0.987 0.974 0.942 1.033 1.029 1.018

2L293 SEL-NLY 1.050 1.058 1.039 1.036 1.058 0.983 0.974 0.943 1.033 1.028 1.017

2L294 CBK-NLY 1.053 1.059 1.035 1.033 1.059 0.968 0.956 0.922 1.035 1.031 1.013

2L295 SEL-KCL 1.053 1.060 1.041 1.036 1.062 0.986 0.974 0.942 1.032 1.028 1.018

1L274 NTL-POCATER 1.055 1.061 1.045 1.039 1.064 0.995 0.984 0.973 1.033 1.030 1.019

1L275 NTL-COLEMAN 1.053 1.060 1.040 1.036 1.061 0.980 0.969 0.941 1.033 1.027 1.013

5L92 CBK-SEL 1.058 1.061 1.048 1.040 1.062 1.047 1.024 1.000 1.031 1.024 0.000

5L94 CBK-LGN 1.060 1.063 1.056 1.045 1.067 1.054 1.032 1.007 1.038 1.030 0.000

Page 32: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 32

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

HS Case 3a – 1200 MW BC to AB

Cont. Name NIC 500 ACK 500 SEL 500 SEL 230 VAS 500 CBK 500 CBK 230 NTL 230 NTL 138 NLY 230 LNGDN

500

[50703] [50702] [50792] [50783] [51134] [50791] [50782] [50787] [50776] [50784] [54158]

Pre Contingency 1.059 1.063 1.044 1.041 1.065 0.988 0.974 0.946 1.036 1.034 1.018

SEL T1 1.060 1.063 1.045 1.040 1.066 0.989 0.975 0.947 1.036 1.034 1.018

SEL T2&T3 1.060 1.064 1.046 1.040 1.066 0.989 0.975 0.947 1.036 1.033 1.018

CBK T2&T6 1.059 1.063 1.043 1.040 1.065 0.983 0.973 0.945 1.035 1.033 1.017

5L71 MCA-NIC 1.036 1.049 1.035 1.035 1.047 0.981 0.968 0.941 1.031 1.030 1.016

5L75 REV-ACK 1.054 1.053 1.040 1.038 1.059 0.985 0.972 0.944 1.034 1.032 1.017

5L76 ACK-NIC 1.051 1.055 1.039 1.037 1.058 0.984 0.971 0.943 1.033 1.031 1.017

5L81 NIC-ING 1.046 1.056 1.039 1.037 1.055 0.984 0.971 0.944 1.034 1.031 1.017

5L82 NIC-MDN 1.048 1.057 1.039 1.037 1.055 0.984 0.971 0.944 1.034 1.031 1.017

5L87 NIC-KLY 1.053 1.060 1.042 1.039 1.061 0.986 0.973 0.945 1.035 1.033 1.018

5L91 ACK-SEL 1.049 1.058 1.019 1.024 1.039 0.968 0.956 0.931 1.024 1.024 1.013

5L96 VAS-SEL 1.057 1.059 1.023 1.027 1.062 0.972 0.960 0.934 1.026 1.025 1.014

5L98 NIC-VAS 1.052 1.057 1.037 1.036 1.051 0.982 0.969 0.942 1.032 1.031 1.017

2L112 NLY-BDY 1.059 1.063 1.044 1.040 1.065 0.988 0.974 0.946 1.035 1.033 1.018

2L221 SEV-SEL 1.057 1.059 1.039 1.037 1.061 0.984 0.971 0.944 1.034 1.032 1.017

2L277 WAN-NLY 1.059 1.063 1.044 1.040 1.065 0.988 0.974 0.946 1.036 1.033 1.018

2L288 KCL-BTS 1.059 1.063 1.044 1.040 1.065 0.988 0.974 0.946 1.035 1.034 1.018

2L289 SEL-BTS 1.060 1.063 1.045 1.042 1.066 0.989 0.975 0.947 1.036 1.035 1.018

2L293 SEL-NLY 1.058 1.063 1.045 1.042 1.065 0.987 0.976 0.948 1.036 1.030 1.018

2L294 CBK-NLY 1.058 1.062 1.036 1.036 1.061 0.968 0.956 0.932 1.024 1.036 1.013

2L295 SEL-KCL 1.059 1.063 1.044 1.041 1.065 0.988 0.974 0.946 1.036 1.034 1.018

1L274 NTL-POCATER 1.060 1.064 1.048 1.043 1.068 0.997 0.986 0.982 1.030 1.036 1.020

1L275 NTL-COLEMAN 1.059 1.063 1.042 1.040 1.064 0.982 0.970 0.949 1.032 1.033 1.014

5L92 CBK-SEL 1.072 1.073 1.072 1.059 1.085 1.044 1.021 1.004 1.026 1.045 0.000

5L94 CBK-LGN 1.070 1.072 1.077 1.062 1.086 1.062 1.032 1.014 1.024 1.049 0.000

Page 33: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 33

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

HW Case 2a – 1100 MW BC to AB

Cont. Name NIC 500 ACK 500 SEL 500 SEL 230 VAS 500 CBK 500 CBK 230 NTL 230 NTL 138 NLY 230

LNGDN 500

[50703] [50702] [50792] [50783] [51134] [50791] [50782] [50787] [50776] [50784] [54158]

Pre Contingency 1.052 1.064 1.034 1.033 1.053 0.985 0.971 0.952 1.032 1.031 1.013

SEL T1 1.052 1.065 1.035 1.032 1.053 0.985 0.970 0.952 1.032 1.031 1.013

SEL T2&T3 1.052 1.065 1.035 1.032 1.053 0.986 0.971 0.952 1.032 1.030 1.014

CBK T2&T6 1.052 1.064 1.032 1.031 1.052 0.978 0.965 0.948 1.029 1.030 1.009

5L71 MCA-NIC 1.032 1.051 1.026 1.027 1.037 0.977 0.963 0.945 1.027 1.027 1.009

5L75 REV-ACK 1.052 1.060 1.033 1.032 1.051 0.984 0.969 0.951 1.031 1.031 1.012

5L76 ACK-NIC 1.045 1.060 1.030 1.030 1.047 0.980 0.965 0.947 1.028 1.029 1.010

5L81 NIC-ING 1.044 1.059 1.030 1.030 1.046 0.977 0.963 0.945 1.027 1.029 1.007

5L82 NIC-MDN 1.043 1.059 1.029 1.030 1.045 0.977 0.963 0.945 1.026 1.029 1.007

5L87 NIC-KLY 1.047 1.062 1.032 1.031 1.049 0.982 0.967 0.949 1.030 1.030 1.011

5L91 ACK-SEL 1.047 1.064 1.005 1.011 1.033 0.961 0.947 0.925 1.038 1.016 1.004

5L96 VAS-SEL 1.050 1.063 1.028 1.028 1.047 0.979 0.964 0.947 1.028 1.028 1.010

5L98 NIC-VAS 1.047 1.060 1.026 1.027 1.032 0.979 0.965 0.947 1.028 1.027 1.011

2L112 NLY-BDY 1.055 1.066 1.036 1.035 1.055 0.992 0.978 0.958 1.037 1.030 1.020

2L221 SEV-SEL 1.052 1.063 1.033 1.032 1.052 0.985 0.970 0.951 1.031 1.031 1.013

2L277 WAN-NLY 1.054 1.065 1.032 1.029 1.052 0.982 0.967 0.949 1.030 1.026 1.011

2L288 KCL-BTS 1.052 1.064 1.034 1.032 1.052 0.984 0.970 0.951 1.032 1.031 1.013

2L289 SEL-BTS 1.052 1.064 1.034 1.032 1.052 0.984 0.970 0.951 1.031 1.030 1.013

2L293 SEL-NLY 1.055 1.066 1.037 1.035 1.055 0.986 0.968 0.950 1.031 1.026 1.014

2L294 CBK-NLY 1.051 1.063 1.026 1.027 1.048 0.964 0.951 0.931 1.034 1.034 1.004

2L295 SEL-KCL 1.052 1.064 1.033 1.031 1.052 0.984 0.969 0.951 1.031 1.030 1.013

1L274 NTL-POCATER 1.054 1.066 1.039 1.036 1.055 0.997 0.985 0.993 1.030 1.034 1.019

1L275 NTL-COLEMAN 1.052 1.064 1.033 1.032 1.052 0.980 0.966 0.952 1.034 1.031 1.007

5L92 CBK-SEL 1.064 1.071 1.048 1.043 1.064 1.032 1.009 0.994 1.028 1.038 0.000

5L94 CBK-LGN 1.065 1.073 1.054 1.047 1.068 1.043 1.015 1.001 1.023 1.045 0.000

Page 34: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 34

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

HW Case 3 – 1200 MW BC to AB

Cont. Name NIC 500 ACK 500 SEL 500 SEL 230 VAS 500 CBK 500 CBK 230 NTL 230 NTL 138 NLY 230

LNGDN 500

[50703] [50702] [50792] [50783] [51134] [50791] [50782] [50787] [50776] [50784] [54158]

Pre Contingency 1.043 1.048 1.015 1.017 1.035 0.950 0.933 0.913 1.024 1.019 1.007

SEL T1 1.043 1.047 1.013 1.015 1.034 0.948 0.930 0.911 1.023 1.018 1.007

SEL T2&T3 1.043 1.047 1.011 1.014 1.033 0.947 0.930 0.909 1.030 1.017 1.007

CBK T2&T6 1.043 1.047 1.014 1.016 1.034 0.945 0.928 0.907 1.029 1.018 1.006

5L71 MCA-NIC 1.018 1.032 1.007 1.012 1.016 0.943 0.927 0.906 1.028 1.016 1.005

5L75 REV-ACK 1.038 1.036 1.011 1.015 1.030 0.946 0.930 0.910 1.022 1.018 1.006

5L76 ACK-NIC 1.032 1.038 1.009 1.014 1.025 0.944 0.928 0.907 1.028 1.017 1.005

5L81 NIC-ING 1.030 1.041 1.011 1.015 1.026 0.942 0.926 0.905 1.027 1.017 1.004

5L82 NIC-MDN 1.029 1.040 1.010 1.015 1.025 0.942 0.927 0.906 1.028 1.017 1.004

5L87 NIC-KLY 1.026 1.039 1.010 1.014 1.024 0.944 0.928 0.907 1.029 1.017 1.006

5L91 ACK-SEL 1.043 1.051 0.993 1.003 1.025 0.932 0.917 0.896 1.029 1.010 1.003

5L96 VAS-SEL 1.040 1.043 1.007 1.012 1.033 0.939 0.924 0.903 1.025 1.015 1.004

5L98 NIC-VAS 1.040 1.045 1.007 1.012 1.007 0.942 0.927 0.906 1.028 1.016 1.005

2L112 NLY-BDY 1.046 1.050 1.019 1.020 1.040 0.958 0.942 0.920 1.030 1.015 1.011

2L221 SEV-SEL 1.040 1.043 1.015 1.017 1.034 0.951 0.934 0.914 1.025 1.019 1.008

2L277 WAN-NLY 1.042 1.047 1.011 1.012 1.032 0.946 0.929 0.910 1.022 1.011 1.006

2L288 KCL-BTS 1.043 1.047 1.014 1.016 1.034 0.949 0.932 0.912 1.024 1.019 1.007

2L289 SEL-BTS 1.042 1.047 1.012 1.013 1.033 0.947 0.930 0.911 1.023 1.016 1.007

2L293 SEL-NLY 1.044 1.048 1.017 1.018 1.036 0.951 0.932 0.912 1.024 1.020 1.008

2L294 CBK-NLY 1.042 1.046 1.006 1.012 1.030 0.928 0.915 0.895 1.028 1.025 1.003

2L295 SEL-KCL 1.043 1.047 1.012 1.013 1.034 0.947 0.930 0.911 1.023 1.017 1.007

1L274 NTL-POCATER 1.044 1.049 1.019 1.020 1.037 0.962 0.949 0.958 1.024 1.022 1.010

1L275 NTL-COLEMAN 1.043 1.047 1.014 1.016 1.034 0.945 0.929 0.912 1.034 1.019 1.004

5L92 CBK-SEL 1.051 1.055 1.034 1.029 1.039 1.032 1.009 0.994 1.029 1.031 0.000

5L94 CBK-LGN 1.053 1.056 1.042 1.034 1.045 1.040 1.019 1.005 1.027 1.038 0.000

Page 35: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 35

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

HW Case 3b – 1200 MW BC to AB

Cont. Name NIC 500 ACK 500 SEL 500 SEL 230 VAS 500 CBK 500 CBK 230 NTL 230 NTL 138 NLY 230

LNGDN 500

[50703] [50702] [50792] [50783] [51134] [50791] [50782] [50787] [50776] [50784] [54158]

Pre Contingency 1.055 1.065 1.027 1.027 1.050 0.961 0.945 0.925 1.033 1.025 1.009

SEL T1 1.055 1.065 1.026 1.026 1.050 0.961 0.945 0.925 1.033 1.025 1.009

SEL T2&T3 1.055 1.065 1.026 1.026 1.050 0.960 0.945 0.925 1.033 1.025 1.009

CBK T2&T6 1.055 1.065 1.025 1.026 1.050 0.955 0.941 0.923 1.031 1.025 1.008

5L71 MCA-NIC 1.034 1.052 1.019 1.022 1.035 0.954 0.939 0.920 1.029 1.022 1.008

5L75 REV-ACK 1.053 1.060 1.025 1.026 1.048 0.959 0.944 0.924 1.032 1.025 1.009

5L76 ACK-NIC 1.046 1.059 1.022 1.024 1.044 0.957 0.942 0.922 1.030 1.024 1.008

5L81 NIC-ING 1.046 1.060 1.022 1.024 1.043 0.954 0.940 0.920 1.029 1.024 1.007

5L82 NIC-MDN 1.044 1.059 1.022 1.024 1.042 0.954 0.939 0.920 1.029 1.023 1.007

5L87 NIC-KLY 1.049 1.062 1.025 1.026 1.046 0.959 0.944 0.924 1.032 1.025 1.009

5L91 ACK-SEL 1.050 1.066 0.998 1.007 1.032 0.942 0.928 0.909 1.029 1.012 1.007

5L96 VAS-SEL 1.055 1.064 1.018 1.021 1.051 0.954 0.939 0.920 1.029 1.022 1.008

5L98 NIC-VAS 1.051 1.061 1.016 1.020 1.022 0.954 0.939 0.921 1.029 1.021 1.009

2L112 NLY-BDY 1.055 1.065 1.027 1.028 1.050 0.966 0.951 0.930 1.037 1.022 1.012

2L221 SEV-SEL 1.054 1.064 1.025 1.026 1.049 0.960 0.945 0.925 1.033 1.025 1.010

2L277 WAN-NLY 1.054 1.064 1.023 1.024 1.048 0.958 0.943 0.923 1.031 1.019 1.009

2L288 KCL-BTS 1.055 1.065 1.026 1.026 1.050 0.960 0.945 0.925 1.033 1.025 1.009

2L289 SEL-BTS 1.055 1.065 1.025 1.025 1.050 0.959 0.944 0.924 1.032 1.024 1.009

2L293 SEL-NLY 1.055 1.066 1.028 1.029 1.051 0.961 0.943 0.924 1.032 1.020 1.010

2L294 CBK-NLY 1.053 1.063 1.018 1.022 1.046 0.940 0.928 0.910 1.029 1.031 1.006

2L295 SEL-KCL 1.055 1.065 1.025 1.025 1.050 0.959 0.944 0.924 1.032 1.024 1.009

1L274 NTL-POCATER 1.056 1.067 1.031 1.030 1.053 0.974 0.962 0.973 1.025 1.029 1.012

1L275 NTL-COLEMAN 1.054 1.065 1.025 1.026 1.050 0.957 0.942 0.926 1.023 1.025 1.007

5L92 CBK-SEL 1.070 1.078 1.050 1.043 1.068 1.034 1.011 0.996 1.031 1.039 0.000

5L94 CBK-LGN 1.071 1.080 1.057 1.048 1.073 1.050 1.027 1.012 1.034 1.047 0.000

Page 36: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 36

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

APPENDIX D – TRANSIENT STABILITY PERFORMANCE PLOTS

Selected transient stability response to single contingencies listed in Appendix B and as listed in

Tables 4-4 and 4-8 are displayed below.

Page 37: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 37

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Generator MW Outputs 12 -- 5L91 ACK-SEL_2 3PH@SEL 500KV 13hs_case3a (BC-AB = 1200MW)

Bus Variables 12 -- 5L91 ACK-SEL_2 3PH@SEL 500KV 13hs_case3a (BC-AB = 1200MW)

Page 38: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 38

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Line Power Flows 12 -- 5L91 ACK-SEL_2 3PH@SEL 500KV 13hs_case3a (BC-AB = 1200MW)

Page 39: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 39

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Generator MW Outputs 13 -- 5L92 CBK-SEL 3PH@CBK 500KV 13hs_case3a (BC-AB = 1200MW)

Page 40: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 40

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Bus Variables 13 -- 5L92 CBK-SEL 3PH@CBK 500KV 13hs_case3a (BC-AB = 1200MW)

Page 41: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 41

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Line Power Flows 13 -- 5L92 CBK-SEL 3PH@CBK 500KV 13hs_case3a (BC-AB = 1200MW)

Page 42: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 42

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Generator MW Outputs 33 -- 2L294 CBK-NLY 3PH@CBK 230KV 13hs_case3a (BC-AB = 1200MW)

Page 43: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 43

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Bus Variables 33 -- 2L294 CBK-NLY 3PH@CBK 230KV 13hs_case3a (BC-AB = 1200MW)

Page 44: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 44

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Line Power Flows 33 -- 2L294 CBK-NLY 3PH@CBK 230KV 13hs_case3a (BC-AB = 1200MW)

Page 45: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 45

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Generator MW Outputs 12 -- 5L91 ACK-SEL_2 3PH@SEL 500KV 13hw2ae_case2a(BC-AB = 1100MW)

Page 46: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 46

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Bus Variables 12 -- 5L91 ACK-SEL_2 3PH@SEL 500KV 13hw2ae_case2a(BC-AB = 1100MW)

Page 47: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 47

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Line Power Flows 12 -- 5L91 ACK-SEL_2 3PH@SEL 500KV 13hw2ae_case2a(BC-AB = 1100MW)

Page 48: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 48

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Generator MW Outputs 12 -- 5L91 ACK-SEL_2 3PH@SEL 500KV 13hw2ae_case3(BC-AB = 1200MW)

Page 49: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 49

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Bus Variables 12 -- 5L91 ACK-SEL_2 3PH@SEL 500KV 13hw2ae_case3(BC-AB = 1200MW)

Page 50: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 50

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Line Power Flows 12 -- 5L91 ACK-SEL_2 3PH@SEL 500KV 13hw2ae_case3(BC-AB = 1200MW)

Page 51: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 51

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Generator MW Outputs 12 -- 5L91 ACK-SEL_2 3PH@SEL 500KV 13hw2ae_case3b(BC-AB = 1200MW)

Page 52: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 52

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Bus Variables 12 -- 5L91 ACK-SEL_2 3PH@SEL 500KV 13hw2ae_case3b(BC-AB = 1200MW)

Page 53: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 53

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Line Power Flows 12 -- 5L91 ACK-SEL_2 3PH@SEL 500KV 13hw2ae_case3b(BC-AB = 1200MW)

Page 54: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 54

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Generator MW Outputs 13 -- 5L92 CBK-SEL 3PH@CBK 500KV 13hw2ae_case3b(BC-AB = 1200MW)

Page 55: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 55

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Bus Variables 13 -- 5L92 CBK-SEL 3PH@CBK 500KV 13hw2ae_case3b(BC-AB = 1200MW)

Page 56: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 56

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Line Power Flows 13 -- 5L92 CBK-SEL 3PH@CBK 500KV 13hw2ae_case3b(BC-AB = 1200MW)

Page 57: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 57

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Generator MW Outputs 15 -- 5L94 CBK-LGN 3PH@CBK 500KV 13hw2ae_case3b(BC-AB = 1200MW)

Page 58: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 58

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Bus Variables 15 -- 5L94 CBK-LGN 3PH@CBK 500KV 13hw2ae_case3b(BC-AB = 1200MW)

Page 59: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 59

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Line Power Flows 15 -- 5L94 CBK-LGN 3PH@CBK 500KV 13hw2ae_case3b(BC-AB = 1200MW)

Page 60: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 60

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Generator MW Outputs 33 -- 2L294 CBK-NLY 3PH@CBK 230KV 13hw2ae_case3b(BC-AB = 1200MW)

Page 61: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 61

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Bus Variables 33 -- 2L294 CBK-NLY 3PH@CBK 230KV 13hw2ae_case3b(BC-AB = 1200MW)

Page 62: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 62

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Line Power Flows 33 -- 2L294 CBK-NLY 3PH@CBK 230KV 13hw2ae_case3b(BC-AB = 1200MW)

Page 63: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 63

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

Page 64: Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability ...€¦ · Planning Assessment of BC to Alberta Transfer Capability of the Existing System Report No. Transmission & Stations

Report No. T&S Planning – 2013-058 Page 64

Not to be reproduced without the permission of BC Hydro

END OF REPORT


Recommended