of 36
Project Management Session 7Project Management Control
Project Management Control
*Preamble
Project Management Control
*How do I manage the following:The overall health of the project;Scope;Acquisition of goods and services;Value.
Project Management Control
* Project planning: Milestones Schedule; Human resources; Budget; Responsibilities; Contingencies.Ownership: Stakeholder input; Conditions for satisfaction;Stakeholders feel their interest accommodated.
Project Health
Project Management Control
* Expertise: Have expertise; Members understand their responsibilities; Adequate training for team members; Top level support: Project sponsor share responsibility; TOR agreed; Sponsor and management support when required; Communication.Resources:Available HR; Technology available; Task management effective.
Project Health
Project Management Control
* Justifiable case: Project fully costed and budgeted; Also agreed with sponsor; ROI clear and acceptable;Metrics in place and methods to measure; Adequate funding;Specification:Objectives clear; Strategic and business alignment; Enthusiasm;Adequate documentation reports; budget; specs; deviations; delegations.
Project Health
Project Management Control
*How do I manage the following:The overall health of the project;Scope;Acquisition of goods and services;Value.
Project Management Control
*Scope Management
Project Management Control
*There are three basic causes for change in projects:Planners erred in their initial assessment about how to achieve a given end or erred in their choice of the proper goal for the project;The client/user or project team learns more about the nature of the project deliverable or about the setting in which it is to be used;Change in the environment in which the project is being conducted.Scope Management
Project Management Control
*Scope is defined at various levels:Project charter;Breakdown of deliverables, tasks etc (this is were the Work Breakdown Structure is important);The baseline plan and the budget also part of the scope.Underlying the issue of scope management is change control:Formal system of change control;Impact of changes should be motivated;Where it affects scope, client signoff should be sought and relevant documents updated.
Scope management
Project Management Control
*Scope related dilemmas:Scope creep:Changes that are changing the base plan. Inevitable but the project manager needs to keep these changes manageable ;Hope creep:Falling behind schedule, with the hope that one could catch up. The project manager needs to be very careful as this can have severe consequences for the project;Effort creep:Similar to hope creep. Activity that does not produce results;Feature creep:Adding features rather than sticking to the original agreement about deliverables.Scope management
Project Management Control
*How do I manage the following:The overall health of the project;Scope;Acquisition of goods and services;Value.
Project Management Control
*PMBOK the processes required to acquire goods and services; Procurement schedule (as such) should only be considered after the network diagram and schedule bar chart has been finalized but before the resource histograms and cash flow statements thus what, when before how much and how much when.Procurement
Project Management Control
*Procurement
Project Management Control
*How do I manage the following:The overall health of the project;Scope;Acquisition of goods and services;Value.
Project Management Control
*Context 70% of projects are:Over budgetBehind schedule
52% of all projects finish at 189% of their initial budget
And some, after huge investments of time and money, are simply never comple
Source: The Standish Group
Project Management Control
*What is Earned Value?Earned Value is an approach for understanding and assessing what a project is achieving with budgeted money.
Project Management Control
*What Do You Need for EVA?
Project Management Control
*Managing Without EVAExample you budget 100 hours to assemble bridgePillars and at the end of the period you have achieved the 100 hoursWow we are on budget !
BudgetActualVariance100 hours @ R 300R 100 hours @ R 300R 0
Project Management Control
*Managing Without EVADoes this mean we have achieved 100 hours worth of work ?Actual cost is not an indication of progress, - Only an indicator ofhours/money spent.
Project Management Control
*Important TermsBCWS - Budgeted Cost of Work Scheduled: Planned cost of the total amount of work scheduled to be performed by the milestone date;ACWP - Actual Cost of Work Performed: Cost incurred to accomplish the work that has been done to date;BCWP - Budgeted Cost of Work Performed: The planned (not actual) cost to complete the work that has been done.
Project Management Control
*Example
Chart2
50005000
1100012000
1750019000
2620029000
3500039000
4900055000
37803
37834
37865
37895
37926
37956
BCWP
BCWS
EVA Chart
500050005000
120001100012500
190001750019600
290002620029900
390003500039900
550004900056000
650003780337803
800003783437834
900003786537865
950003789537895
1000003792637926
1020003795637956
Project is:
13.8% Behind Schedule16.1% Over Cost
BCWS
BCWP
ACWP
Typical Chart
90008640
1800017280
2700025920
3600034560
4500043200
5400051840
6300060480
7200037834
8100037865
9000037895
9900037926
10800037956
Projected
Actual
Typical Data
1/1/032/1/033/1/034/1/035/1/036/1/037/1/038/1/039/1/0310/1/0311/1/0312/1/03
Projected900018000270003600045000540006300072000810009000099000108000
Actual8640172802592034560432005184060480
Factor0.96
ACWP
1/1/032/1/033/1/034/1/035/1/036/1/037/1/038/1/039/1/0310/1/0311/1/0312/1/03
BCWP50001100017500262003500049000
ACWP50001250019600299003990056000
ACWP
BCWP
ACWP
BCWP
1/1/032/1/033/1/034/1/035/1/036/1/037/1/038/1/039/1/0310/1/0311/1/0312/1/03
BCWP50001100017500262003500049000
BCWS50001200019000290003900055000
BCWP
BCWP
BCWS
BCWS
1/1/032/1/033/1/034/1/035/1/036/1/037/1/038/1/039/1/0310/1/0311/1/0312/1/03
BCWS5000120001900029000390005500065000800009000095000100000102000
BCWS
BCWS
EVA Data
1/1/032/1/033/1/034/1/035/1/036/1/037/1/038/1/039/1/0310/1/0311/1/0312/1/03
BCWS5000120001900029000390005500065000800009000095000100000102000
BCWP50001100017500262003500049000
ACWP50001250019600299003990056000
Schedule Variance0-1000-1500-2800-4000-6000
Sched. Var. %0.0%-8.3%-7.9%-9.7%-10.3%-10.9%
Schedule Perf. Index1.0000.9170.9210.9030.8970.891
Cost Variance0-1500-2100-3700-4900-7000
Cost Var. %0.0%-13.6%-12.0%-14.1%-14.0%-14.3%
Cost Perf. Index1.0000.8800.8930.8760.8770.875
EAC 1
VAC 1
VAC % 1
EAC 2
Project is:
10.9% Behind Schedule14.3% Over Cost
Project Management Control
*ExampleSV - Schedule Variance: (BCWP-BCWS):A comparison of amount of work performed during a given period of time to what was scheduled to be performed.A negative variance means the project is behind schedule
Project Management Control
*Example
Chart4
500050005000
120001100012500
190001750019600
290002620029900
390003500039900
550004900056000
650003780337803
800003783437834
900003786537865
950003789537895
1000003792637926
1020003795637956
BCWS
BCWP
ACWP
EVA Chart
500050005000
120001100012500
190001750019600
290002620029900
390003500039900
550004900056000
650003780337803
800003783437834
900003786537865
950003789537895
1000003792637926
1020003795637956
Project is:
13.8% Behind Schedule16.1% Over Cost
BCWS
BCWP
ACWP
Typical Chart
90008640
1800017280
2700025920
3600034560
4500043200
5400051840
6300060480
7200037834
8100037865
9000037895
9900037926
10800037956
Projected
Actual
Typical Data
1/1/032/1/033/1/034/1/035/1/036/1/037/1/038/1/039/1/0310/1/0311/1/0312/1/03
Projected900018000270003600045000540006300072000810009000099000108000
Actual8640172802592034560432005184060480
Factor0.96
Combined Chart
1/1/032/1/033/1/034/1/035/1/036/1/037/1/038/1/039/1/0310/1/0311/1/0312/1/03
BCWS5000120001900029000390005500065000800009000095000100000102000
BCWP50001100017500262003500049000
ACWP50001250019600299003990056000
Combined Chart
BCWS
BCWP
ACWP
ACWP
1/1/032/1/033/1/034/1/035/1/036/1/037/1/038/1/039/1/0310/1/0311/1/0312/1/03
BCWP50001100017500262003500049000
ACWP50001250019600299003990056000
ACWP
BCWP
ACWP
BCWP
1/1/032/1/033/1/034/1/035/1/036/1/037/1/038/1/039/1/0310/1/0311/1/0312/1/03
BCWP50001100017500262003500049000
BCWS50001200019000290003900055000
BCWP
BCWP
BCWS
BCWS
1/1/032/1/033/1/034/1/035/1/036/1/037/1/038/1/039/1/0310/1/0311/1/0312/1/03
BCWS5000120001900029000390005500065000800009000095000100000102000
BCWS
BCWS
EVA Data
1/1/032/1/033/1/034/1/035/1/036/1/037/1/038/1/039/1/0310/1/0311/1/0312/1/03
BCWS5000120001900029000390005500065000800009000095000100000102000
BCWP50001100017500262003500049000
ACWP50001250019600299003990056000
Schedule Variance0-1000-1500-2800-4000-6000
Sched. Var. %0.0%-8.3%-7.9%-9.7%-10.3%-10.9%
Schedule Perf. Index1.0000.9170.9210.9030.8970.891
Cost Variance0-1500-2100-3700-4900-7000
Cost Var. %0.0%-13.6%-12.0%-14.1%-14.0%-14.3%
Cost Perf. Index1.0000.8800.8930.8760.8770.875
EAC 1
VAC 1
VAC % 1
EAC 2
Project is:
10.9% Behind Schedule14.3% Over Cost
Project Management Control
*ExampleCV - Cost Variance: (BCWP-ACWP)A comparison of the budgeted cost of work performed with actual cost.A negative variance means the project is over budget.
Project Management Control
*ExampleSchedule Variance = BCWP-BCWS:
$49,000- 55,000SV = - $ 6,000
Cost Variance = BCWP-ACWP:
$49,000 56,000CV = - $7,000
Project Management Control
*Earned Value?BCWP - Budgeted Cost of Work Performed: The planned (not actual) cost to complete the work that has been done.
Project Management Control
*In Simple TermsActual Cost (26)Budget Plan (21)Earned Value (16)Time NowSchedule variance
Sheet:
J
F
M
A
M
J
J
A
S
O
N
D
Budget Plan
Actual Cost
Earned Value
Project Management Control
*In Simple TermsActual Cost (26)Budget Plan (21)Earned Value (16)Time NowCost Variance
Sheet:
J
F
M
A
M
J
J
A
S
O
N
D
Budget Plan
Actual Cost
Earned Value
Project Management Control
*In Simple TermsActual Cost (26)Budget Plan (21)Earned Value (16)Time NowTime variance
Sheet:
J
F
M
A
M
J
J
A
S
O
N
D
Budget Plan
Actual Cost
Earned Value
Project Management Control
*Important MetricsSPI: Schedule Performance Index:SPI=BCWP/BCWSSPI