+ All Categories
Home > Documents > PM0010-SLM-Unit-09

PM0010-SLM-Unit-09

Date post: 04-Jun-2018
Category:
Upload: idealparrot
View: 212 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend

of 22

Transcript
  • 8/13/2019 PM0010-SLM-Unit-09

    1/22

    Introduction to Project Management Unit 9

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No.: 179

    Unit 9 Project Procurement and Contracting

    Structure

    9.1 Introduction

    Objectives

    9.2 Importance of Project Procurement

    9.3 Project Procurement ManagementOverview

    Operations Procurement and Project Procurement

    Project Procurement Management Process

    9.4 Types of Contracts

    Traditional Lump Sum Fixed Cost/Time

    Design (D), Construct (C) Novation and Turnkey (T)

    CM, PM and PM/CM

    On-Call Contracting

    Guaranteed Maximum Price

    Full Cost Reimbursable Procurement

    9.5 Contract Negotiation Techniques

    9.6 Summary

    9.7 Terminal Questions

    9.8 Answers

    9.9 Glossary

    9.1 Introduction

    Procurement and contracting are vastly interrelated domains. These

    domains constitute the single most important strategic planning exercise in

    successfully implementing large and complex projects. For example in

    executing a power plant, the EPC contractor who is implementing the power

    plant, usually outsources the total implementation of the Water Treatment

    (WT) plant which is needed to provide de-mineralised water to be fed into

    the boiler. This is because the agency to whom this work is outsourced has

    the technological expertise to design, assemble, erect, commission (and

    even operate and maintain for a pre-agreed period, if desired by its

    customer) the WT system. The WT system vendor, in turn, treats the

    implementation of the total WT system as a project that has been secured

    from the power plant EPC contractor. The WT system therefore involves the

    works of design, procurement (involving purchase) and site works for

    implementation.

  • 8/13/2019 PM0010-SLM-Unit-09

    2/22

  • 8/13/2019 PM0010-SLM-Unit-09

    3/22

    Introduction to Project Management Unit 9

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No.: 181

    When a project sponsor awards the work of a project to a project manager

    the sponsor himself is procuring the project from the project manager. Inreal terms, the project is a commitment, i.e. a contract between the project

    manager and the project sponsorthe commitment is to deliver a product or

    service to the sponsor within a specified time, budget and quality

    specifications.

    Project procurement management can have cost and schedule effects on

    the internal targets of an organisation i.e. a cost increase over the budget for

    the procured item or a delay in the delivery schedule of the procured item

    may have an adverse impact on the profitability of the project for the

    performing company.

    This makes project procurement a major challenge faced by the project

    manager when the project is one of infrastructure, or an industrial plant or a

    manufacturing facility.

    9.3 Project Procurement Management Overview

    Project procurement management is a part of the project management

    process. In this process, products or services are acquired or purchased

    from outside of the organisation in order to complete the task or project.

    9.3.1 Operations Procurement and Project Procurement

    The differences between the procurement carried out for the overalloperation of an organisation, and the procurement carried out for a specific

    project, are shown in Table 9.1.

    Table 9.1: Differences between Operations Procurement and Project

    Procurement

  • 8/13/2019 PM0010-SLM-Unit-09

    4/22

    Introduction to Project Management Unit 9

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No.: 182

    9.3.2 Project Procurement Management Process

    The project procurement method varies depending on the category of thecontracted product or service. The broad categories are:

    Materials or products

    Equipment or tools

    Labours

    Professional services

    Totally engineered systems

    Total project

    Project Procurement Management generally involves the following:

    Deciding to Make or Buy Outsourcing the work for a Buy decision.

    Managing risk (although risk management is often addressed

    separately, it is noteworthy that contracts are, at their core, risk

    management tools.)

    All procurement requires some level of planning. The intensity and the effort

    required in planning depend on the complexity of the scope of work in the

    procurement package.

    For a manufacturing company deciding to starts a project, the make or buy

    decision forms the first step in the procurement planning. This decision isbased on a cost comparison between make and buy, and the timely

    availability of the manufacturing equipment or shop personnel for meeting

    deliveries without adversely affecting their other job orders. Several

    companies in India exist, wherein; the company or a division of the company

    already manufactures a product, and the company is also executing projects

    for its clients which require the same product as part of another project

    scope. For example, Larsen & Turbo manufactures switchgear, pressure

    vessels, heat exchangers etc. These products are also required in several

    electrical projects or petrochemical projects that they execute for clients.

    Another example, Kamani Engineering manufactures transmission towers,and also executes large power transmission projects for Power Grid

    Corporation of India, where the bulk of the transmission towers are their in-

    house supply. The Table 9.2 shows the comparison of costs for in-house

    development and outsourcing.

  • 8/13/2019 PM0010-SLM-Unit-09

    5/22

    Introduction to Project Management Unit 9

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No.: 183

    Table 9.2: Comparison of Costs for In-house Development and Outsourcing

    The additional investment of Rs 30000 for In-house option will break even if

    the software usage is for more than 20 months i.e. (Rs. 3500/month

    Rs. 2500/month) x 20 months.

    Therefore if you plan to use the software for less than 20 months then go foroutsourcing but if plan to use the software for more than 20 months then go

    for In-house development. The market scenario for the product or service to

    be procured gives rise to any of the following three conditions:

    Sole Source:In this case there is only one qualified seller in the market.

    For example, Dow Chemicals under their patent was the only

    manufacturer Reverse Osmosis (RO) membranes which was utilised for

    desalinating saline water and all water treatment package vendors had

    to buy RO membranes only from them or their licensee in a country.

    Single Source:This is a case when your organisation prefers to work

    with an identified seller, even though other sellers may offer a lower

    price. Sometimes companies show a preference for a supplier with a

    view to create a long term relationship for a niche product which the

    company may require to procure often.

    Oligopoly: This is a condition where the providers of the product or

    service are so few in number that the actions and pricing of one seller

    affect the actions and pricing of the other sellers. Examples of airline

    fares, oil prices, and hardware prices can fall in this category.

    The Table 9.3 summarises the actual procurement processes involved in

    each of the process groups.

  • 8/13/2019 PM0010-SLM-Unit-09

    6/22

    Introduction to Project Management Unit 9

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No.: 184

    Table 9.3: Procurement Management Processes (As per PMBoK)

    The function performed by each process is explained below.

    Plan Purchases and Acquisition

    Plan Purchases and Acquisitions is the process for deciding what to buy or

    acquire and when and how to buy that. It is a process of identifying the risks

    involved in each make or buy decision. It also reviews the type of contractwith regard to mitigating the risk by determining what risks can be

    transferred to seller.

    The outputs of this process are:

    Project management plan describing how procurement process will be

    managed starting with development of procurement documentation and

    culminating in contract closure.

    Contract Statement of Work (SOW)2(describes the portion of the project

    scope which is included in the particular contract).

    2Refer "Information Technology, Project Management, Fifth Edition" Kathy Schwalbe,

  • 8/13/2019 PM0010-SLM-Unit-09

    7/22

    Introduction to Project Management Unit 9

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No.: 185

    Plan Contracting

    This process includes preparation of a procurement document for eachcontract planned. This document is issued to prospective sellers who are

    invited to bid. The invitation is termed Invitation To Bid (ITB), Request For

    Quotation (RFQ), tender notice, Request For Proposal (RFP), invitation for

    negotiation or contractor initial response.

    ITB and RFQ (both imply the same type of invitation) are focused on getting

    the sellers price, and not his ideas. For example if RFP asks for a price that

    means in addition, it necessarily asks for the sellers and ideas on how the

    project work should be done, which implies that there is a bit of consultancy

    service demanded from the sellers in their response.

    Evaluation criteria: The first category of evaluation relates to

    prequalification of a firm for receiving the ITB. Here, a prior assessment of

    the capability of a firm to perform the intended scope of work is made. For

    large value contracts, the ITB is preceded by an invitation to submit a

    prequalification offer, in which the seller is asked to submit his experience

    list for similar works carried out by enumerating the following:

    List of projects completed with contract value, completion period, and

    scope of work.

    Audited financial statements like balance sheet, Profit and Loss (P & L)

    account for the last 3 to 5 years.

    Contract completion certificates from his clients.

    Firms organisational structure

    List of key personnel of the firm

    List of construction equipment/production machinery owned.

    Any other technical/financial/organisational data considered relevant by

    the owner.

    This data submitted by all prospective bidders is analysed to arrive at a list

    of pre-qualified bidders, eligible to receive the ITB/RFP.

    The second category of evaluation criteria relates to evaluating the bidsreceived in response to the ITB/RFP. These may involve price loading

    criteria for technical and commercial deviations stipulated by the bidders in

    their bids, as well as specific criteria for price loading on utilities

  • 8/13/2019 PM0010-SLM-Unit-09

    8/22

    Introduction to Project Management Unit 9

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No.: 186

    consumption (electricity, water etc.) where system performance is evaluated

    based on system life-cycle costs.Request Seller Responses

    While the prospective sellers are expected to submit their bids in response

    to the ITB/RFP as issued to them, it is a common practice in large value

    contracts to host a bidders conference, where all bidders are present and

    are permitted to ask questions concerning the SOW. This method is

    followed to ensure that all bidders possess the same information on which to

    base their prices and proposals. After satisfactory completion of this step, a

    due date for submission of the bid/proposal is communicated to all bidders.

    This process is called solicitation.

    The output of this process is a bunch of bids proposals from the bidders.

    The proposals are the sellers prepared document that describes the sellers

    ability to provide the requested products/services at his quoted price.

    Select Sellers

    This process involves complete evaluation (techno-commercial evaluation

    and price evaluation) of the bids received, followed by negotiations with the

    bidders. Here the bidders have been pre-qualified following a fairly

    extensive evaluation; the final selection of the seller is usually based on the

    lowest evaluated price.

    The outputs of this process are:

    The Contract: This can be a simple purchase order or a complex

    document. A contract is a legal document backed by the countrys legal

    system (as long as it does not include illegal activities).

    Contract Management Plan: This covers contract administration

    activities through the life of the contract.

    Contract Administration

    Contract administration is a process of managing the contract between

    buyer and seller. It is also provides:

    Regular review of sellers performance in executing the SOW, as well asdocumentation of this performance.

    Continuously manage contract related changes.

    Provide a basis for future relationship with the seller.

  • 8/13/2019 PM0010-SLM-Unit-09

    9/22

    Introduction to Project Management Unit 9

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No.: 187

    Contract Closure

    Contract closure is a process of completing the contract by resolving allopen items. Sometimes, a contract may be foreclosed or terminated by

    mutual agreement between buyer and seller.

    Activity 1:

    List down the components of procurement contract between a

    consultancy (Resources unlimited) and its client (United Technology)

    9.4 Types of Contracts

    All procurements are carried out based on a contract between buyer and

    seller. A contract is a binding agreement between two or more parties for

    performing some specified acts in exchange for lawful consideration. A

    contract is entered into after a decision is made by the buyer on which seller

    to use. The nature of the goods and works that are purchased dictate the

    appropriate contract type.

    Purchase of standard products for a project like cement, steel, pipes, cables

    etc. are usually carried with a simple purchase order (contract). Such a

    purchase order usually stipulates a fixed unit price for each item.

    Alternatively, if the deliveries are required over a long period of time, the

    contract may contain a price variation clause to take care of price variations

    in the costs of raw materials used in their manufacture. For example, in caseof copper cables, the government published copper price index can be used

    as a basis for arriving at a price variation formula in the contract.

    The following major key clauses are incorporated in construction contracts:

    Scope of Work

    Contractors obligations

    Owners obligations

    Technical and Commercial specifications

    Payment terms

    Warranties Performance security

    Termination rights

    Dispute resolution mechanism

    Indemnities

  • 8/13/2019 PM0010-SLM-Unit-09

    10/22

    Introduction to Project Management Unit 9

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No.: 188

    Project procurement requires a high level of understanding of contracts by

    the project manager, although a centralised contract department is presentin many project companies to undertake implementation of large projects.

    Contracts in India are governed by the Indian Contract Law 1872.

    PMBoK categorises contracts into three broad categories:

    Fixed price or lump sum contracts:Here, the product to be supplied

    or SOW to be carried out is very well defined and the seller is paid a

    fixed price.

    Cost-reimbursable contracts: Here the seller is paid for his actual

    costs plus a fee to cover his profit. The actual cost includes direct cost

    (salaries of full-time project staff) and indirect cost (salaries of

    management and support staff indirectly involved in the project plus costof office facilities like rent, electricity etc.). The variations in this category

    are:

    o Cost-Plus-Fee (CPF) or Cost-Plus-Percentage of Cost (CPPC): The

    payment is made for the actual cost plus an agreed percentage of

    the actual cost as fee.

    o Cost-Plus-Fixed-Fee (CPFF): This is same as CPPC except that the

    fee is fixed and does not increase or decrease with the actual cost

    unless project scope changes.

    o Cost-Plus-Incentive-Fee (CPIF); Here, in addition to the payment as

    per the CPPC or CPFF mode, an incentive is paid upon achieving

    certain specified performance levels of the project.

    Time and Material (T&M) contracts: Here the contract contains the

    feature of both cost reimbursable and fixed price contracts. Unit rate

    contracts are an example, where the unit rates for specific items of work

    are fixed, but the contractor is paid for the actual quantities executed,

    since quantities are not known at the time of signing the contract with

    the contractor.

    To illustrate project procurement contract examples, we look at large

    construction projects, where sharing of the risk between the majorstakeholders, like the buyer (owner) and the seller (contractor) is a very

    important consideration. For a more comprehensive understanding of

    contracting in large projects, we examine seven types of contracts with

    varying degrees of risks assumed by these stakeholders as per a review

  • 8/13/2019 PM0010-SLM-Unit-09

    11/22

    Introduction to Project Management Unit 9

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No.: 189

    conducted and presented in an international publication Procurement

    strategies A Relationship based approach by Derek Walker and KeithHampson. Figure 9.1 shows a construction cost continuum for project

    delivery.

    Figure 9.1: A Construction Cost Continuum for Project Delivery3

    The contract types shown in the figure 9.1 range from the traditional fixed

    cost/time type (lowest cost risk to owner and designated as 1) at one end to

    the fully cost reimbursable type (highest cost risk to owner and designated

    as 7) at the other end. The descriptions of the seven types are as follows:

    1. Traditional lump sum fixed cost/time

    2. Design + Construct or Turnkey

    3. Design + Novate + Construct

    4. Construction Management (CM), Project Management (PM)

    3Adapted from Procurement strategies A Relationship-based Approach by Derek Walker and Keith

    Hampson

  • 8/13/2019 PM0010-SLM-Unit-09

    12/22

  • 8/13/2019 PM0010-SLM-Unit-09

    13/22

    Introduction to Project Management Unit 9

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No.: 191

    Many owners perceive that they may be at the mercy of construction

    contractors looking for opportunities to create additional revenue andprofit from such gaps in the tender. This may lead to a confrontational

    approach over disputes which may ultimately need to be settled by

    arbitration or a court of law.

    Notwithstanding these disadvantages, fixed contracts are in vogue

    where designs can be more or less frozen prior to tendering for

    construction, with some contractual provisions for price variations

    incorporated in the contract.

    BOO, BOT, BOOT (total package options):

    The letters here imply:

    BBuild

    First OOperate

    Second OOwn

    TTransfer

    Here, an entity exists or an entity is formed which meets the clients project

    need. The entity enters into one of these three types of contract with the

    client to design, build, operate and own for some period of time (called the

    concession period) and transfers the facility to the owner at the end of this

    period. The conventional wisdom that is accepted here is that, the

    contracting parties i.e. client and the entity individually assume the risk

    within whose control the risk most lies. The major function of the contract

    assignment is to provide for and agree to the mechanism for the assignment

    and management of these risks. Usually the entity is an alliance or joint

    venture of firms who provide the facility for the client. The client makes a

    concession agreement to fund the facility until the facilitys ownership is

    transferred to the client. This mode of contracting is common for

    infrastructure projects where the concession permits tolls and other

    payments to be made by end users.

    The concept of constructability is therefore present to a high degree, as it

    covers the life-cycle cost effectiveness. The incentive for minimising the long

    term costs and developing a highly cost-effective solution over the life cycle

    thus gets in-built into the entity which is responsible for design, construction

    and operation/maintenance of the facility. The client therefore has no direct

  • 8/13/2019 PM0010-SLM-Unit-09

    14/22

    Introduction to Project Management Unit 9

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No.: 192

    cost risk but faces the possible risk that the facility does not meet its needs

    or that the concession agreement is not satisfactory. While there have beenexamples of successful BOT projects, there have also been cases of

    failures, which mainly arise out of a lack of trust or communication between

    contracting parties. As the client is usually a government department,

    political bottlenecks regarding land acquisition and politically motivated

    decisions like toll rates being decreased in the operation phase have

    resulted in failure or inordinate delays in such projects.

    9.4.2 Design (D), Construct (C) Novation and Turnkey (T)

    Here, a Project Management (PM) or Construction Management (CM) entity

    enters into a contract with the client to represent the client in leading the

    design team and in the management of the construction process, with asingle point of contact in the PM/CM company. There are two variations in

    this mode of contracting, they are:

    The PM/CM entity is an Advisor to the client and becomes an internal

    design and construction group of the client. The managerial instructions

    given to the actual contractors by the entity are therefore persuasive

    rather than directive.

    The PM/CM can have a contractual arrangement with the client in which

    the design and construct type of contracting takes a financial risk. The

    Design and Construct type of contracting is usually considered as

    falling in this category, especially when the PM/CM entity is a builder by

    experience.

    In the D + C mode of contracting, the client initially engages a design

    consultant to develop concept project solution, which is used as the basis

    for obtaining bids from D + C bidders. Thus, each D + C bidder gets the

    opportunity to involve his design team in the bid for suggesting innovative

    solutions over and above this concept. This increases the chances of the

    client finding a most cost effective solution for the project from among the

    D + C bids received.

    The mode of Novated D + C mode of contracting is developed from theD + C model and is gaining popularity among large commercial and

    residential projects in Australia. Novation, as a legal term, implies the

    replacement of an existing contract between X and Y by a new contract on

    the same terms between X and Z and this requires the agreement of all

  • 8/13/2019 PM0010-SLM-Unit-09

    15/22

    Introduction to Project Management Unit 9

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No.: 193

    three parties X, Y and Z.. For a novated D + C contract. The novation

    parties as per the above referred definition are:X is the Client

    Y is the Design consultant

    Z is the D + C contractor

    The clients cost risk is reduced since the D + C contractor engages the

    design consultant and becomes directly accountable to the client with

    respect to all the design development, and thus the client cannot make a

    claim for extra costs on account of errors or omissions in design.

    Here, it is also relevant to briefly discuss the concept of a Turnkey project.

    In a turnkey project, the D + C contractor also finances the project. Theclient may opt to make milestone payments or payment after handing over

    to the D + C contractor.

    9.4.3 CM, PM and PM/CM

    In this type of contract, the Construction Management contractor acts as a

    consultant bidder and provides advice on the practicality of the design with

    respect to the construction methods that can be deployed. He also provides

    services of construction planning, coordination and supervision of the

    construction work carried out by contractors appointed by the client, and

    cost control. The advantages of this type of contract are:

    Availability of construction expertise in the design phase.

    Less confrontation between the design team and the team responsible

    for supervising the construction.

    Fewer contract variations.

    An extended form of the CM contract is the PM/CM contract where the

    PM/CM contractor also takes responsibility for design coordination.

    9.4.4 On-Call Contracting

    This mode is adopted by the owner in the beginning of the project when the

    owner is more familiar with the nature of work than the consultant, but this

    balance shifts in the execution stage of the project. Hence, conventional

    wisdom in this mode of contracting is that the consultant should assume

    most cost risk at the execution stage. This scheme is implemented by the

    owner signing a master contract with one consultant at the beginning of the

    project, and then dividing the project into Task Orders (TOs) that are

  • 8/13/2019 PM0010-SLM-Unit-09

    16/22

    Introduction to Project Management Unit 9

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No.: 194

    released to the consultant in stages. Table 9.4 shows the typical

    characteristics of on call contracting.Table 9.4: Typical Characteristics of On Call Contracting

    9.4.5 Guaranteed Maximum Price

    In this contracting mode, the contract calls for a reimbursable fee, i.e.

    reimbursement of actual cost plus a fee, but there is a cap to the total

    amount paid, which is termed the Guaranteed Maximum Price (GMP). This

    mode of contracting is adopted when the design is partially developed at the

    time of contracting. The contractor makes his judgment of the cushion he

    must provide in fixing his GMP which becomes part of the contract. The

    design is however fixed. If the actual cost exceeds the GMP, the contractor

    absorbs the excess. If the actual cost is less than the GMP, a portion of the

    difference amount is shared with the contractor as an incentive.

    This mode is similar to novated D + C as the design development is partial

    at the time of contracting. But in the GMP mode, the contractor may or may

    not agree to take over the design team and its initial design concept.

    9.4.6 Full Cost Reimbursable Procurement

    This contracting mode is applicable when the client prefers to retain control

    over the design, detailed planning, procurement and the construction

    phases of the project, but does not find it feasible to deploy the personnel ofhis own organisation to implement the project. Some large projects where

    aspects of safety and secrecy are very important and where client cannot

    afford to employ a large contingent of project design and project

    management personnel fall in this category. For example in India, Nuclear

  • 8/13/2019 PM0010-SLM-Unit-09

    17/22

    Introduction to Project Management Unit 9

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No.: 195

    Power Corporation of India Limited (NPCIL) deploys engineering consulting

    firms like TCE Consulting Engineers for generating all the civil/structuralpiping drawings for the nuclear power plants being implemented by them.

    M.N.Dastur Consulting Engineers were also deployed by Steel Authority of

    India Ltd. in the 1950s and 1960s to carry out detailed design and drawings

    for steel plants. This full cost reimbursable type of procurement is based on

    the clients high degree of trust and confidence in the agency deployed by

    him. This type of contract can also apply to projects where design details

    are unknown at the time of tendering and/or external influences on project

    scope and design are significant, resulting in the clients requirements

    undergoing changes frequently during project implementation.

    Overview of Types of Contract for Large ProjectsThree teams are primarily involved in the implementation of a large project

    like, Client, Design team and Contractor. For large projects or the type of

    projects mentioned above, the extent of clients influence over the des ign

    and other implementation areas of the project assume importance. The type

    of contract which the client selects for such projects thus depends on

    whether the client prefers to exert a high influence on the design and

    procurement of the project or whether the client permits the contractor to

    exercise influence over these processes. At one end of the scale is a project

    where the client has a very high level of confidence in his expertise to

    control the design, procurement and construction processes; at the otherend is the project (example, BOO or BOOT type), where these processes

    are under the contractors control. In the former, the client depends on his

    appointed design consulting firms expertise in shaping the project details;

    and in the latter, the client depends on the market to provide a total solution

    to the project and project delivery. In the middle lie the CM/PM type and the

    GMP/Novation types of contract.

    Self Assessment Questions

    Fill in the blanks:

    1. CPF stand for _______ and CPFF stands for _______.

    2. The first step in the procurement process is to decide whether to

    ________ or ______.

    3. The document detailing the scope of work in a procurement contract is

    called ________.

  • 8/13/2019 PM0010-SLM-Unit-09

    18/22

    Introduction to Project Management Unit 9

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No.: 196

    4. In a GMP contract, there is a _______ to the total amount paid.

    5. In PMBoK, the process of receiving quotations from prospective vendorsis called __________.

    State whether the following statements are true or false:

    6. The financial risk in a fully reimbursable contract is borne by the

    contractor.

    7. In on-call contracting, the Master contract keeps the risk with the

    contractor.

    9.5 Contract Negotiation Techniques

    In a large project, for subcontracting a major portion of the project scope theproject manager relies on the personnel in the purchase and/or contract

    department of the project organisation. However, the project manager faces

    the need to understand and track the negotiating process to ensure that

    both the project needs and his organisations needs are met in the outcome

    of the contract negotiations with the seller.

    Therefore, the needs to become familiar with negotiation techniques as well

    as negotiation skills, required in conducting the negotiations. Project

    contract negotiation is invariably a two-way street wherein the buyer seeks

    to exercise a good degree of control over the sellers performance, as well

    as wants to maintain a harmonious relationship.

    Negotiating skills comprise a combination of hard skills and soft skills. Hard

    skills include product/service/technical knowledge, analytical/financial,

    computer literacy and legal aspects of contracting.

    The negotiation process itself comprises three phases, each of which

    requires careful planning and execution effort like planning the negotiation,

    conducting the negotiation and documenting the negotiation/forming the

    contract when the negotiation is successful.

    Table 9.5 shows the checklists for the buyer and a checklist of contract best

    negotiation practices for an overall understanding of the negotiationtechniques.

  • 8/13/2019 PM0010-SLM-Unit-09

    19/22

    Introduction to Project Management Unit 9

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No.: 197

    Table 9.5: Checklist of Contract Negotiation Best Practices

    Buyer Activity

    Know what you want lowest price or bestvalue.

    State your requirements in performanceterms and evaluate accordingly.

    Conduct market resource about potentialforces before selection.

    Evaluate potential sources promptly anddispassionately.

    Follow the evaluation criteria stated in thesolicitation.

    Develop organisational policies to guide and

    facilitate the source selection process. Use a weighting system to determine which

    evaluation criteria are most important.

    Use a screening system to pre-qualifysources.

  • 8/13/2019 PM0010-SLM-Unit-09

    20/22

    Introduction to Project Management Unit 9

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No.: 198

    Self Assessment Questions

    8. The three phases in contract negotiations are ______, _______, and________ the negotiations.

    9. Contract negotiation requires ______ skills and ______ skills.

    10. The project manager does not require being familiar with the contract

    negotiation skills and techniques since contracts are handled by other

    departments in the organisation. (True/False)

    Activity 2:

    List the contract negotiation techniques you will use when dealing with a

    construction contractor.

    9.6 Summary

    Procurement and contracting are vastly interrelated functions and constitute

    the single most important strategic planning exercise in successfully

    implementing large and complex projects.

    Project procurement management is the process of acquiring goods,

    services or results needed from outside the project team to perform the work

    as well as contract management processes. Procurement is formalised by a

    contract between buyer and seller. In large projects, an entire system can

    get outsourced to a firm specialising in that identified system.

    The procurement method adopted depends on the category of

    product/service being contracted. The categories are materials/products,

    equipment/tools, labour, professional services, totally engineered systems,

    total projects. For a manufacturing/production taking up a project,

    procurement starts with the make or buy decision.

    For subcontracting a major portion of the project scope in a large project,

    the project manager relies on the personnel in the purchase and/or contract

    department of the project. Although the personnel of this department usually

    carry out contract negotiations in large projects, the project manager should

    understand and track the negotiating process to ensure that both the projectneeds and his organisations needs are met in the outcome of the contract

    negotiations with the seller.

  • 8/13/2019 PM0010-SLM-Unit-09

    21/22

    Introduction to Project Management Unit 9

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No.: 199

    Contract negotiating skills comprise a combination of hard skills and soft

    skills. The negotiation process itself comprises three phases like planningthe negotiation, conducting the negotiation and documenting the

    negotiation/forming the contract when the negotiation is successful.

    9.7 Terminal Questions

    1. Bring out the meanings of the terms purchase, procurement and

    contract.

    2. Explain the overall project procurement process using the processes

    outlined in the PMBoK of PMI, USA.

    3. Explain the types of contracts that are entered into in project

    procurement.

    4. What are the guidelines which the buyer should keep in mind while

    negotiating a contract?

    5. What are the factors that both the buyer and seller should understand as

    forming a checklist for contract negotiations?

    9.8 Answers

    Answers to Self Assessment Questions

    1. Cost Plus Fee and Cost Plus Fixed Fee

    2. Make, buy

    3. Statement of Work (SOW)

    4. Cap5. Solicitation

    6. False

    7. False

    8. Planning, conducting, documenting

    9. Hard, soft

    10. False

    Answers to Terminal Questions

    1. Refer sections 9.1 and 9.2

    2. Refer section 9.3.2

    3. Refer section 9.44. Refer section 9.5

    5. Refer section 9.5

  • 8/13/2019 PM0010-SLM-Unit-09

    22/22


Recommended