Topic - Management of the CMA
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
S7/007 Stephen and Elly Simpson 5.7.6 Seawalls Amend Provide for appropriate coastal hazard mitigation activities (including protection) as permitted or controlled activities.
Reject
/S7/008 Stephen and Elly Simpson 5.7.6 Seawalls Amend Provide for coastal hazard mitigation activities (including
protection) to be no greater than discretionary activities and ensure that no coastal hazard mitigation activity is non-complying or prohibited.
Reject
/S16/007 Donald Robert Frampton 5.7.6 Seawalls Amend Provide for appropriate coastal hazard mitigation activities
(including protection) as permitted or controlled activities.Reject
/S16/008 Donald Robert Frampton 5.7.6 Seawalls Amend Provide for coastal hazard mitigation activities (including
protection) to be no greater than discretionary activities and ensure that no coastal hazard mitigation activity is non-complying or prohibited.
Reject
/S29/012 Powerco Objective O53:
Functional need in the coastal marine area
Support Retain Objective O53 without further modification Accept
FS73/009 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support in Allow in part
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 1 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
partS29/013 Powerco Objective O54:
Use and development in the coastal marine area
Support Retain Objective O54 without further modification Accept
/S29/035 Powerco Policy P132:
Functional need and efficient use
Support Retain Policy 132 without further modification. Accept
FS73/011 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowS29/036 Powerco Policy P138:
Structures in sites with significant values
Support Retain Policy P138 without further modification. Accept
FS73/012 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowS29/037 Powerco Policy P139:
SeawallsSupport Retain Policy 139 without further modification. Accept
FS73/013 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowS29/054 Powerco Rule R149:
Maintenance or repair of structures - permitted activity
Oppose in part
Retain Rule R149 with the following modifications:The maintenance or repair of a structure and the maintenance repair and replacement of any services attached to a structure in the coastal marine area, including any associated:...is a permitted activity, provided the following conditions are met:(f) the maintenance and repair of the structureor service is contained within the form of the existing structure and there is no increase in length, width, or height of the existing structure (except for increases for the purposes of
Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 2 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
replacement, removal and alterations of existing services attached to structures) aerial telecommunications cables where these activities will not result in increases in design voltage and the new or altered cables will not be lower in height above the foreshore or seabed), and(g) for structures identified in Schedule E1 (heritage structures) the materials used for maintenance and repair of the structure and/ or service shall match the existing structures...
FS57/052 The Oil Companies Support in part
Allow in part
FS56/094 Powerco Support in part
Allow in part
FS73/017 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowS29/055 Powerco Rule R168:
Alteration of structures identified in Schedule E2 or Schedule E3 - permitted activity
Oppose in part
Modify Rule R168 as followsThe alteration of a structure or service attached to a structure identified in Schedule E2 (wharves and boatsheds) or Schedule E3 (navigation aids) in the coastal marine area, including any associated...
Reject
FS49/162 CentrePort Properties Limited Support AllowFS56/108 Powerco Support in
partAllow in part
FS57/054 The Oil Companies Support in part
Allow in part
S29/058 Powerco Rule R182: Occupation of
Support Retain Rule R182 without further modification. Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 3 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
space by a structure owned by a network utility operator - permitted activity
/S31/007 Hamish Trolove Policy P132:
Functional need and efficient use
Amend Recognition that some structures will be providing valuable habitat and it may be worth leaving them in place in special circumstances.
Reject
FS49/121 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose DisallowS31/008 Hamish Trolove Policy P138:
Structures in sites with significant values
Amend Include a comment about marine energy devices (at least those that are below the water surface)
Reject
/S32/027 Wellington Recreational Marine
Fishers AssociationMap 30: Hutt Valley aquifer zone in Wellington Harbour (Port Nicholson)
Amend Record that the Wellington Harbour has a number of submarinefreshwater springs from off Petone Beach to alongside Somes Island, into EvansBay and around the Falcon Shoals.[See submission point S32/18].
Reject
/S33/027 Porirua Harbour and Catchment
Community TrustPolicy P133: Recreational values
Support [Retain Policy P133]. Accept
FS61/038 Minister of Conservation Support AllowS33/028 Porirua Harbour and Catchment
Community TrustPolicy P134: Public open space values and visual amenity
Support [Retain Policy P134]. Accept
/S37/007 Quentin Poole 5.7.6 Seawalls Amend Provide for appropriate coastal hazard mitigation activities
(including protection) as permitted or controlled activities.Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 4 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
/S37/008 Quentin Poole 5.7.6 Seawalls Amend Provide for coastal hazard mitigation activities (including
protection) to be no greater than discretionary activities and ensure that no coastal hazard mitigation activity is non-complying or prohibited.
Reject
/S39/004 Timothy Bruce Caughley 5.7.6 Seawalls Amend Provide for appropriate coastal hazard mitigation (including
protection) activities to be permitted or controlled activities.Provide for coastal hazard mitigation (including protection) activities to be, at worst, discretionary activities and ensure that none of them is (or could become due to other rules) a non-complying or prohibited activity.
Reject
/S53/007 Christine Ann Edwards 5.7.6 Seawalls Amend Provide for appropriate coastal hazard mitigation activities
(including protection) as permitted or controlled activities.Reject
/S53/008 Christine Ann Edwards 5.7.6 Seawalls Amend Provide for coastal hazard mitigation activities (including
protection) to be no greater than discretionary activities and ensure that no coastal hazard mitigation activity is non-complying or prohibited.
Reject
/S55/010 The Oil Companies Objective O53:
Functional need in the coastal marine area
Support Retain Objective O53 without further modification. Accept
/S55/011 The Oil Companies Objective O54:
Use and Support Retain Objective O54 without further modification. Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 5 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
development in the coastal marine area
/S55/038 The Oil Companies Policy P132:
Functional need and efficient use
Support Retain Policy 132 without further modification Accept
/S55/039 The Oil Companies Policy P138:
Structures in sites with significant values
Support Retain Policy 138 without further modification. Accept
/S55/040 The Oil Companies Policy P139:
SeawallsSupport Retain Policy 139 without further modification. Accept
/S55/063 The Oil Companies Rule R149:
Maintenance or repair of structures - permitted activity
Oppose in part
Retain Rule 149 [with modifications as per p40 of original submission].
Reject
FS57/053 The Oil Companies Support in part
Allow in part
FS56/095 Powerco Support in part
Allow in part
S55/064 The Oil Companies Rule R168: Alteration of structures identified in Schedule E2 or Schedule E3 - permitted activity
Oppose in part
Modify Rule 168 as follows:The alteration of a structure or service attached to a structure identified in ...
Reject
FS57/055 The Oil Companies Support in part
Allow in part
FS56/109 Powerco Support in part
Allow in part
FS49/163 CentrePort Properties Limited Support AllowS55/067 The Oil Companies Rule R182: Support Retain Rule 182 without further modification. Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 6 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
Occupation of space by a structure owned by a network utility operator - permitted activity
/S62/001 Wellington Civic Trust Lambton Harbour
AreaSupport [Retain] the extension as provided for in the definition and map in
general terms subject to the careful management of development in the area.
Accept
FS49/001 CentrePort Properties Limited Support AllowS62/007 Wellington Civic Trust Objective O53:
Functional need in the coastal marine area
Support Retain the specified objectives with their current wording. Accept
/S62/008 Wellington Civic Trust Objective O56:
New development in the coastal marine area
Support Retain the specified objectives with their current wording. Accept
/S62/009 Wellington Civic Trust Objective O57:
Use and development in Lambton Harbour Area
Amend Reword Objective O57 by adding at the end of the objective "..... and has particular regard to Objective O55 and O56".
Reject
FS83/008 Mt Victoria Residents Association Inc Support AllowFS49/052 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose Disallow
S62/023 Wellington Civic Trust Policy P142: Lambton Harbour Area
Amend Include specific mention of the Wellington Waterfront Framework 2001 in Policy P142(j).
Reject
FS49/137 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose DisallowS63/007 Warwick Stanley Wyatt 5.7.6 Seawalls Amend Provide for appropriate coastal hazard mitigation activities
(including protection) as permitted or controlled activities.Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 7 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
/S63/008 Warwick Stanley Wyatt 5.7.6 Seawalls Amend Provide for coastal hazard mitigation activities (including
protection) to be no greater than discretionary activities and ensure that no coastal hazard mitigation activity is non-complying or prohibited.
Reject
/S65/007 Mike Weir 5.7.6 Seawalls Amend Provide for appropriate coastal hazard mitigation activities
(including protection) as permitted or controlled activities.Reject
/S65/008 Mike Weir 5.7.6 Seawalls Amend Provide for coastal hazard mitigation activities (including
protection) to be no greater than discretionary activities and ensure that no coastal hazard mitigation activity is non-complying or prohibited.
Reject
/S66/029 GBC Winstone 5.7 Coastal
management rules
Amend Clarify the extent of application of the rules in 5.7, Coastal Management.
Reject
/S69/007 Friends of Taputeranga Marine
Reserve TrustRule R153: Removal or demolition of a structures or part of a structure - restricted discretionary activity
Not stated [Decision unclear; refer to original submission for details.] Reject
/S75/009 Minister of Conservation Functional need Support Retain as notified Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 8 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
/S75/011 Minister of Conservation Operational
requirementSupport Retain as notified Accept
/S75/045 Minister of Conservation Objective O53:
Functional need in the coastal marine area
Support Retain as notified Accept
FS41/005 Coastal Ratepayers United Incorporated
Oppose Disallow
S75/046 Minister of Conservation Objective O54: Use and development in the coastal marine area
Support Retain as notified Accept
/S75/047 Minister of Conservation Objective O55:
Public open space
Support Retain as notified Accept
/S75/048 Minister of Conservation Objective O56:
New development in the coastal marine area
Support Retain as notified Accept
FS41/006 Coastal Ratepayers United Incorporated
Oppose Disallow
S75/107 Minister of Conservation Policy P132: Functional need and efficient use
Support Retain as notified Accept
FS41/020 Coastal Ratepayers United Incorporated
Oppose Disallow
S75/108 Minister of Conservation Policy P138: Structures in sites with significant values
Support in part
Retain policy but ensure that Policy 11 NZCPS is given effect to in policies.
Reject
FS41/021 Coastal Ratepayers United Incorporated
Oppose Disallow
S75/109 Minister of Conservation Policy P139: Seawalls
Amend Amend as follows, or similar:(d) suitably located and designed to minimise adverse
Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 9 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
effects on the coastal environment, and certified by a qualified, professional engineer
FS41/022 Coastal Ratepayers United Incorporated
Oppose Disallow
S75/161 Minister of Conservation 5.7.3 Maintenance, repair, additions and alterations to existing structures
Amend Remove 'additions and alterations' of existing coastal structures from Rules R161 and R162, to ensure that these activities are solely managed by Rules in Section 5.7.3.Add two new rules to Section 5.7.3 to provide for situations where the conditions in Rule R151 cannot be met. Restricted discretionary activities when outside a Scheduled site, and a discretionary activity when inside.
Accept in part
FS49/155 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose DisallowFS49/149 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose Disallow
S75/162 Minister of Conservation 5.7.5 New and replacement structures (including temporary structures)
Amend Remove 'additions and alterations' of existing coastal structures from Rules R161 and R162, to ensure that these activities are solely managed by Rules in Section 5.7.3.Add two new rules to Section 5.7.3 to provide for situations where the conditions in Rule R151 cannot be met. Restricted discretionary activities when outside a Scheduled site, and a discretionary activity when inside.
Accept in part
/S75/163 Minister of Conservation Rule R149:
Maintenance or repair of structures - permitted activity
Support Retain as notified Accept
/S75/164 Minister of Conservation Rule R150: Minor
additions or Support Retain as notified Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 10 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
alterations to structures - permitted activity
/S75/165 Minister of Conservation Rule R151:
Additions or alterations to structures - controlled activity
Support Retain as notified Accept
/S75/166 Minister of Conservation Rule R154: New
temporary structures outside sites of significance - permitted activity
Amend Add reference to Schedule E within condition (f). Reject
FS49/151 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose DisallowS75/167 Minister of Conservation Rule R155: New
temporary structures - restricted discretionary activity
Amend Add reference to Schedule E within matter of discretion 7. Reject
FS49/152 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose DisallowS75/168 Minister of Conservation 5.7.5 New and
replacement structures (including temporary structures)
Support Retain Accept
/S75/169 Minister of Conservation Rule R163:
Replacement of structure or parts of structures - permitted activity
Amend Add Replacement of Parts of Structures to Rule R164. Accept
FS49/156 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose DisallowFS56/106 Powerco Support Allow
S75/170 Minister of Conservation Rule R164: Amend Add Replacement of Parts of Structures to Rule R164. Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 11 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
Replacement of structures - restricted discretionary activity
FS49/157 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose DisallowFS56/107 Powerco Support Allow
S75/173 Minister of Conservation Rule R165: Additions or alterations to existing seawalls - controlled activity
Support Retain as notified Accept
/S75/174 Minister of Conservation Rule R166:
Seawalls outside sites of significance - discretionary activity
Support Retain as notified Accept
/S75/175 Minister of Conservation Rule R167:
Seawalls inside sites of significance - non-complying activity
Support Retain as notified Accept
/S82/002 Meridian Energy Limited Functional need Support Retain the definition of 'functional need'. Accept
/S82/003 Meridian Energy Limited Operational
requirementSupport Retain the definition of 'operational requirement'. Accept
/S82/024 Meridian Energy Limited Policy P134:
Public open space values and visual amenity
Amend The adverse effects of new use and development (excluding upgrading of existing authorised activities) on public open space and ...
Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 12 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
/S82/025 Meridian Energy Limited Policy P138:
Structures in sites with significant values
Support Retain Policy P138. Accept
FS73/028 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowS84/005 Hutt City Council Policy P139:
SeawallsAmend Amend Plan to provide for other existing types of infrastructure
(not just regionally significant infrastructure), such as local roads and cycleways. Policy P139 should extend the ability to provide protective structures such as seawalls for regionally significant infrastructure to other types of infrastructure, such as the recently announced Eastern Bays Shared Path or local roads adjacent to the coast.
Accept
FS49/129 CentrePort Properties Limited Support in part
Allow in part
S84/006 Hutt City Council Rule R167: Seawalls inside sites of significance - non-complying activity
Amend Amend R167 to make seawalls a discretionary activity rather than a non-complying activity, regardless of location within a site of significance or not. An exception could be provided to specified sites of significance of high natural character in rural environments.
Reject
/S84/007 Hutt City Council 2. Interpretation Amend Include a definition of infrastructure or specify that the PNRP
adopts the RMA definition.
Add a definition of 'seawall' to the plan.
Accept
/S84/020 Hutt City Council Policy P138:
Structures in sites Oppose Reconsider the use of the term 'avoid' and ensure that it does not
unnecessarily and inappropriately constrain activities that result in Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 13 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
with significant values
effects that are significant and/or provide essential services for the health and safety of the community and protection of the environment.Provide a policy framework that provides a pathway for new infrastructure reasonably needed to support existing or planned future development to gain resource consent. This would allow for resource consent for these activities to be granted in appropriate circumstances.
FS25/037 Wellington Water Limited Support AllowS84/021 Hutt City Council Policy P139:
SeawallsOppose Reconsider the use of the term 'inappropriate' and ensure that it
does not unnecessarily and inappropriately constrain activities that result in effects that are significant and/or provide essential services for the health and safety of the community and protection of the environment.Provide a policy framework that provides a pathway for new infrastructure reasonably needed to support existing or planned future development to gain resource consent. This would allow for resource consent for these activities to be granted in appropriate circumstances.
Accept
FS49/130 CentrePort Properties Limited Support in part
Allow in part
S84/025 Hutt City Council Rule R162: New structures, additions or alterations to structures inside sites of significance - non-complying activity
Oppose Amend Rule R162 and change the activity status from a non-complying activity to a discretionary activity.
Reject
/S84/026 Hutt City Council Rule R167:
Seawalls inside sites of significance - non-complying activity
Oppose Amend Rule R167 and change the activity status from a non-complying activity to a discretionary activity.
Reject
/S85/053 Roading, Parks and Gardens and Policy P139: Amend Amend Policy P139 to Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 14 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
Solid Waste departments of Hutt City Council and Upper Hutt City Council
Seawalls recognise that seawalls can be the only reasonably practicable option toprotect important assets from damage. Insert a policy providing for the alteration, addition, replacement, and occupation of existing seawalls.
FS61/040 Minister of Conservation Support in part
Allow
S85/056 Roading, Parks and Gardens and Solid Waste departments of Hutt City Council and Upper Hutt City Council
Rule R165: Additions or alterations to existing seawalls - controlled activity
Amend Delete condition (g) relating to seawalls extending further seaward,given horizontal projection is covered in condition (f).
Reject
/S85/057 Roading, Parks and Gardens and
Solid Waste departments of Hutt City Council and Upper Hutt City Council
Rule R166: Seawalls outside sites of significance - discretionary activity
Amend Delete condition (g) relating to seawalls extending further seaward,given horizontal projection is covered in condition (f).
Reject
/S85/058 Roading, Parks and Gardens and
Solid Waste departments of Hutt City Council and Upper Hutt City Council
2.1.6 Definitions, schedules and maps
Amend Insert a definition for "seawall". Accept
FS40/001 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Support in part
Allow in part
FS49/012 CentrePort Properties Limited Support Allow in partS85/059 Roading, Parks and Gardens and
Solid Waste departments of Hutt City Council and Upper Hutt City Council
Rule R154: New temporary structures outside sites of significance - permitted activity
Amend Amend Rule R154 to provide for temporary dammingof coastal water as a permitted activity (subject to reasonable conditions).Remove the requirement for all work to be contained in the CMA from generalcondition 5.7.2(i).
Reject
FS25/053 Wellington Water Limited Support AllowS85/083 Roading, Parks and Gardens and
Solid Waste departments of Hutt Policy P138: Structures in sites
Amend Amend the wording in the policies [P45, P138, P143, P148] and rules [R67, R114, R152, R162, R167, R195, R205, R198, R209,
Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 15 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
City Council and Upper Hutt City Council
with significant values
R215] to ensure necessaryworks [within scheduled sites], such as structures in rivers or in the CMA, can be carried out by HCCand UHCC.
/S88/021 Trelissick Park Group Objective O55:
Public open space
Amend The northern beach of the reclamation needs improved public access.
Reject
FS40/004 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Oppose DisallowS88/024 Trelissick Park Group 2. Interpretation Amend Amend the Plan to include a definition of 'structure'. Reject
/S91/001 Philip and Dorothy Tortell 3.13 Coastal
managementAmend [Add an objective to protect and safeguard the existing rights of
those who live on the coast.]Reject
/S91/002 Philip and Dorothy Tortell Rule R165:
Additions or alterations to existing seawalls - controlled activity
Amend Amend Rule 165 to permitted activity status. Reject
/S91/004 Philip and Dorothy Tortell 3.13 Coastal
managementAmend Give effect to the NZCPS by protecting, to the extent possible, the
built environment along the coast and outlining proposed actions by GWRC to assist and support ratepayers with managing the natural risks associated with the coastal environment.
Reject
/S93/005 Coastal Ratepayers United
Incorporated3. Objectives Amend Develop and include an overarching objective and corresponding
policy in respect of use and development in the coastal environment to prevent the Plan from inadvertently preventing activities that might otherwise be contemplated by the NZCPS.
Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 16 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
[See p3, p15 of original submission for further details].
FS49/019 CentrePort Properties Limited Support Allow in partS93/022 Coastal Ratepayers United
IncorporatedFunctional need Amend Reconsider use of the terms "functional need" and "operational
requirement" in the rules and either change the rules or the definitions to enable appropriate hazard mitigation measures that might be able to be located elsewhere but are more efficiently, effectively or cost-effectively located in the particular location.
Reject
/S93/038 Coastal Ratepayers United
IncorporatedObjective O53: Functional need in the coastal marine area
Amend Revise the objective to address the concerns expressed [with use of "functional need" and "operational requirement"; See p17-18 of original submission for further detail].
Reject
FS49/044 CentrePort Properties Limited Support in part
Allow in part
S93/039 Coastal Ratepayers United Incorporated
Objective O56: New development in the coastal marine area
Amend Revise the objective to also recognise the purpose of the new development. An option is to add "and its purpose" at the end of the objective.
Reject
FS49/050 CentrePort Properties Limited Support AllowS93/042 Coastal Ratepayers United
Incorporated4. Policies Amend Include a policy that enables appropriate use and development in
the coastal environment to ensure the Plan does not inadvertently prevent activities that might otherwise be contemplated by the NZCPS.
Accept
FS49/055 CentrePort Properties Limited Support Allow in partS93/044 Coastal Ratepayers United
Incorporated4. Policies Amend Include a policy that provides for a risk management framework to
be used in the management of use and development in the coastal environment.
Accept
/S93/061 Coastal Ratepayers United
IncorporatedPolicy P132: Functional need and efficient use
Oppose in part
Revise the policy so that language that is currently problematically inconsistent across the PNRP is made consistent. Revise the policy to enable the situation where appropriate hazard mitigation measures might be able to be located elsewhere but are more efficiently, effectively or cost-effectively located in the coastal
Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 17 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
marine area. Reconsider (f), the use of the word "redundant" and, if it remains, provide a definition of "Redundant" so that for example, structures that might be built, become covered in sand but might, in fullness of time, be useful again are not caught.
/S93/062 Coastal Ratepayers United
IncorporatedPolicy P134: Public open space values and visual amenity
Oppose in part
Revise the policy to address the concerns expressed. An option is to, in (b), add "built and/or" before "natural character" or refer to degree of naturalness or similar to reflect the fact that the coastal environment includes significant built areas.
Reject
FS49/124 CentrePort Properties Limited Support in part
Allow in part
S93/063 Coastal Ratepayers United Incorporated
Policy P138: Structures in sites with significant values
Oppose in part
Delete the policy or make it less extreme to deal with the concerns expressed. A possible solution is to simply refer to avoiding, remedying or mitigating the effects of structures in the areas and remove "and in respect of (a) to (d): (e) there are no practicable alternative methods of providing for the activity".
Reject
/S93/064 Coastal Ratepayers United
IncorporatedPolicy P139: Seawalls
Oppose in part
Delete Policy P139 and replace it with a policy that gives effect to Policy 27 of the NZCPS, including that seawalls may be appropriate to protect areas of significant existing development from natural hazards.
Accept
FS49/133 CentrePort Properties Limited Support in part
Allow in part
S93/076 Coastal Ratepayers United Incorporated
5.7 Coastal management rules
Amend Reconsider all references to "open coastal water" throughout the PNRP and replace them with "water" or if there is a valid reason why "water" is not acceptable, then with "coastal water".
Reject
/S93/078 Coastal Ratepayers United
Incorporated5.7.6 Seawalls Amend Make it clear that the rules about structures apply to seawalls
except for those explicitly different in section 5.7.6 or create new rules in the seawalls section that deals with matters that are missing in relation to the seawall rules e.g., maintenance and
Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 18 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
repair. Include a note in the relevant general structure rule referring the reader to the different seawall provision.
/S93/079 Coastal Ratepayers United
IncorporatedRule R162: New structures, additions or alterations to structures inside sites of significance - non-complying activity
Oppose in part
Revise the rule and related rules (or create new rules) to address the concerns expressed throughout this submission. Make coastal hazard mitigation (including protection) structures outside sites of significance a permitted, controlled or restricted discretionary activity with structures inside sites of significance being a discretionary activity.
Reject
/S93/080 Coastal Ratepayers United
IncorporatedRule R163: Replacement of structure or parts of structures - permitted activity
Amend Remove condition (f). Reject
/S93/081 Coastal Ratepayers United
Incorporated5.7.6 Seawalls Oppose in
partAmend the rules about seawalls to address the concerns expressed throughout this submission, especially in relation to areas of significant existing development. Amend the rules or create new rules to address the material that may be associated with a seawall e.g., rip rap but that is not attached to the land so is not a structure and that includes occupation of space in the coastal marine area. Make coastal hazard mitigation (including protection) structures outside sites of significance a permitted, controlled or restricted discretionary activity with structures inside sites of significance a discretionary activity.
Reject
/S93/101 Coastal Ratepayers United
Incorporated12 Schedules Oppose in
partRevise the schedules to appropriately address the concerns expressed throughout the submission.
Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 19 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
/S93/102 Coastal Ratepayers United
Incorporated13 Maps Oppose in
partRevise the maps to appropriately address the concerns expressed throughout the submission.
Reject
/S93/105 Coastal Ratepayers United
IncorporatedOperational requirement
Amend [See submission point S93/022]. Reject
/S94/009 Heritage New Zealand Rule R149:
Maintenance or repair of structures - permitted activity
Support Retention of R149, but with appropriate cross referencing and the use of clearer rule headings and web navigation options.
Accept
/S95/001 Phillip Walker Rule R180: New
swing moorings inside Mooring Areas - permitted activity
Oppose Rule R180: Swing moorings inside Mooring Areas - permitted activity A new swing mooring inside a Mooring Area ...
Accept
/S95/002 Phillip Walker Rule R183:
Renewal of existing resource consents for occupation of space by structures - controlled activity
Oppose Amend to ensure existing moorings are permitted activities orrelief that meets the same outcome.
Reject
/S96/007 Christopher Butler 5.7.6 Seawalls Amend Provide for appropriate coastal hazard mitigation activities
(including protection) as permitted or controlled activities.Reject
/S96/008 Christopher Butler 5.7.6 Seawalls Amend Provide for coastal hazard mitigation activities (including Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 20 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
protection) to be no greater than discretionary activities and ensure that no coastal hazard mitigation activity is non-complying or prohibited.
/S98/002 Spark New Zealand Trading Limited Functional need Support in
partAmend definition to provide greater clarity what 'dependant' entails. Definition of both function and operational need to be reviewed or delete both definitions.
Reject
FS56/003 Powerco Support AllowS98/003 Spark New Zealand Trading Limited Operational
requirementSupport in part
Amend definition to provide greater clarity what 'needs to be carried out' entails. Definitions of both function and operational need to be reviewed or delete both definitions.
Reject
FS56/007 Powerco Support AllowS98/019 Spark New Zealand Trading Limited Policy P132:
Functional need and efficient use
Support in part
Amend P132:Use and development in the coastal marine area shall..(h) recognise the location, operation and function of existing regionally significant infrastructure.
Reject
FS22/024 Transpower NZ Ltd Support AllowS98/027 Spark New Zealand Trading Limited 5.7.2 Coastal
management general conditions
Oppose in part
Amend 5.7.2(c):(c) there is no disturbance of the foreshore or seabed to a depth greater than 0.5m 2.0m below the seabed or foreshore with the Hutt Valley Aquifer zone shown on Map 30, and
Accept
FS57/064 The Oil Companies Support AllowFS56/093 Powerco Support Allow
S98/028 Spark New Zealand Trading Limited Rule R150: Minor additions or
Oppose in part
Amend R150: to clearly define thresholds for minor additions or alterations to structures.
Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 21 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
alterations to structures - permitted activity
FS57/066 The Oil Companies Support AllowFS49/148 CentrePort Properties Limited Support Allow
S98/029 Spark New Zealand Trading Limited Rule R161: New structures, additions or alterations to structures outside sites of significance - discretionary activity
Oppose in part
Amend R161: to clearly define thresholds for minor additions or alterations to structures.
Reject
FS49/154 CentrePort Properties Limited Support AllowFS56/102 Powerco Support Allow
S98/030 Spark New Zealand Trading Limited Rule R162: New structures, additions or alterations to structures inside sites of significance - non-complying activity
Oppose Amend R162:A new structure, addition or alteration to a structure and the associated use of the structure outside a site or habitat...
Reject
FS73/033 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Support AllowFS56/104 Powerco Support Allow
S99/015 Kapiti Coast Airport Holdings Limited
Policy P135: Safe passage
Support Retain Policy P135 in Section 4.10.1 of the Proposed Plan as notified without modification.
Accept
/S99/016 Kapiti Coast Airport Holdings
LimitedPolicy P137: Airport height restriction areas
Support Retain Policy P137 in Section 4.10.1 of the Proposed Plan as notified without modification.
Accept
/S99/017 Kapiti Coast Airport Holdings
LimitedRule R159: Structures in airport height
Support Retain Rule P159 in Section 5.7.5 of the Proposed Plan as notified without modification
Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 22 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
restriction areas or navigation protection areas - prohibited activity
/S99/033 Kapiti Coast Airport Holdings
Limited13 Maps Support in
partAmend the Maps contained in the Proposed Plan that relate to the Kapiti Coast Airport showing lines, labels and height restrictions to ensure they correctly identify current and future Airport operations.
And such other additional or consequential relief as is necessary to achieve consistency with the above and to satisfy the concerns of the KCAHL.
Accept in part
/S102/001 Petroleum Exploration and
Production Association of New Zealand
Objective O53: Functional need in the coastal marine area
Support Support Objective O53 Accept
/S106/007 Jenny Clark 5.7.6 Seawalls Amend Provide for appropriate coastal hazard mitigation activities
(including protection) as permitted or controlled activities.Reject
/S106/008 Jenny Clark 5.7.6 Seawalls Amend Provide for coastal hazard mitigation activities (including
protection) to be no greater than discretionary activities and ensure that no coastal hazard mitigation activity is non-complying or prohibited.
Reject
/S117/022 Kāpiti Coast District Council Objective O53:
Functional need in the coastal marine area
Support Retain the objective Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 23 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
/S117/048 Kāpiti Coast District Council Policy P132:
Functional need and efficient use
Support Retain the provision Accept
/S117/049 Kāpiti Coast District Council Policy P134:
Public open space values and visual amenity
Support Retain the provision Accept
FS61/039 Minister of Conservation Support AllowS117/050 Kāpiti Coast District Council Policy P138:
Structures in sites with significant values
Support Retain the provision Accept
/S117/051 Kāpiti Coast District Council Policy P139:
SeawallsSupport Retain the provision Accept
/S118/001 Selwyn Feary Rule R166:
Seawalls outside sites of significance - discretionary activity
Amend [set] Mean High Water Springs as at 2015 Reject
/S121/003 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Commercial Port
AreaSupport in part
Amend to provideclarification as to what other Maps define or link to the Commercial Port Area.
Accept in part
/S121/004 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Common marine
and coastal areaSupport in part
Provide clarification as to the extent of application of the CoastalPlan provisions, specifically in relation to whether the wider environment isincluded, to enable certainty.
Reject
/S121/006 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Functional need Support Retain this definition in
its current form.Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 24 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
/S121/011 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Operational
requirementSupport Retain this definition in its current form. Accept
/S121/018 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Temporary
structureSupport in part
Amend the definition of 'temporary structure' asfollows:
A structure in the coastalmarine area outside of the Commercial Port Area which is not in place for a period exceeding a total of 31days or part days during a 12 month period, inclusive of the placement andremoval.
Reject
/S121/035 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Objective O53:
Functional need in the coastal marine area
Support Retain Objective O53 in its current form. Reject
/S121/036 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Objective O55:
Public open space
Support in part
Amend Objective O55 as follows. The need for appropriately located public open space in the coastal marine area is recognised
Reject
FS69/034 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowS121/037 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Objective O56:
New development in the coastal marine area
Support in part
Amend Objective O56 as follows:New development in the coastal marine area is of a scale, density and design that is compatible with its function and its location in the coastal environment.
Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 25 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
FS69/035 Wellington International Airport Limited Support in part
Allow
FS49/048 CentrePort Properties Limited Support AllowS121/039 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Objective O59:
Passage of vessels and aircraft
Support Retain Objective O58 in its current form. Accept
/S121/074 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Policy P132:
Functional need and efficient use
Support Retain Policy P132 in its current form. Accept
/S121/075 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Policy P133:
Recreational values
Support in part
Amend Policy P133 as follows: The adverse effects of use and development in the coastal marine area on recreational values shall be managed, where practicable, by providing for a diverse range of recreational opportunities while avoiding conflicts and safety issues.
Reject
/S121/076 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Policy P135: Safe
passageSupport Retain Policy P135 in its current form. Accept
/S121/077 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Policy P136: Hutt
Valley aquifer zone in Wellington Harbour (Port Nicholson)
Support in part
Retain Policy P136 but amend Map 30 to exclude the Commercial Port Area. [see also submission points on Map 30]
Reject
FS25/036 Wellington Water Limited Oppose DisallowS121/078 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Policy P136: Hutt
Valley aquifer zone in Wellington Harbour (Port Nicholson)
Support in part
Clarify, following scientific investigation, the areas of Wellington Harbour where the confined Hutt Valley aquifer currently exists.
Reject
/
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 26 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
S121/079 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Policy P137: Airport height restriction areas
Support in part
Clarify height restrictions in P137 or Map 50 and the related online GIS information.
Accept
FS69/064 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowS121/080 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Policy P138:
Structures in sites with significant values
Support in part
Amend Policy P138 as follows:New structures, replacement of a structure or any addition or alteration to a structure ... shall be avoided, except where:...and in respect of (a) to (d):(e) there are no practicable alternative locations or methods of providing for the activity.
Accept
/S121/081 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Policy P139:
SeawallsSupport in part
Amend Policy P139 as follows:The construction of a new seawall is inappropriate except where the seawall is required to protect:...and in respect of (a) and (b):(c) there is are no reasonable or practicable alternative means methods and locations, and (d) suitably located, designed and certified by a qualified, professional engineer, and(e)designed to incorporate the use of soft engineering options where appropriate and practicable.
Reject
/S121/105 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) 5.7 Coastal
management rules
Amend Consider restructuring the Coastal Management Rules to make it clear what rules apply to the commercial Port Area and those that do not.
Reject
/S121/108 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Rule R149:
Maintenance or repair of structures - permitted activity
Support Retain Rule R149 in its current form. Accept
/S121/109 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Rule R152: Oppose Amend Rule R152 as follows: The removal or demolition of a Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 27 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
Removal or demolition of structures or part of a structure - permitted activity
structure or part of a structure, including any associated:...is a permitted activity, provided the following conditions are met:...(f) the structure is not inside a site or habitat identified in Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule F4 (coastal sites) except for structures within the Commercial Port Area or Schedule F5 (coastal habitats), and(g) the removal or demolition shall not disturb more than 10m3 of the foreshore or seabed except for structures within the Commercial Port Area, and(h) the structure or part of the structure is completely removed from the coastal marine area except for structures within the Commercial Port Area, and...
/S121/110 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Rule R154: New
temporary structures outside sites of significance - permitted activity
Support in part
Amend Rule R154(f) as follows:...(f) the structure is outside a site or habitat identified in Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule F4 (coastal sites) unless located in the Commercial Port Area, Schedule F5 (coastal habitats) or Schedule J (geological features), and ...
Reject
/S121/111 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Rule R155: New
temporary structures - restricted discretionary activity
Support in part
Amend Rule R155 Matters for discretion (10) as follows:10. Navigational safety including the notification of the Wellington Regional Council Harbourmaster, the Chief Pilot of CentrePort Ltd and Maritime New Zealand.
Accept
/
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 28 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
S121/112 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Rule R156: New or replacement navigation aids - permitted activity
Support in part
Amend Rule R156 (g) as follows:(g) written notice ... to:(i) the Wellington Regional Council Harbourmaster, and(ii) Maritime New Zealand, and(iii) Land Information New Zealand, and(iv) The Chief Pilot of CentrePort Ltd, and ...
Reject
/S121/113 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Rule R158:
Structures in airport height restriction areas or navigation protection areas for airport/navigation purposes or navigation protection areas - discretionary activity
Support in part
Amend Rule R158 (i) as follows:(i) in respect of condition (b), written approval is given by the Wellington Regional Council Harbourmaster and the Chief Pilot of CentrePort Ltd.
Reject
/S121/114 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Rule R161: New
structures, additions or alterations to structures outside sites of significance - discretionary activity
Oppose Amend Rule R161 as follows:A new structure, addition or alteration to a structure and the associated use of the structure outside a site or habitat identified in Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule F4 (coastal sites) unless located in the Commercial Port Area, Schedule F5 (coastal habitats) or Schedule J (geological features) in the coastal marine area, including any associated ...
Reject
/S121/115 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Rule R162: New
structures, additions or alterations to
Oppose Amend Rule R161 [R162] as follows:A new structure, addition or alteration to a structure and the associated use of the structure inside a site or habitat
Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 29 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
structures inside sites of significance - non-complying activity
identified in Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule F4 (coastal sites) unless located in the Commercial Port Area, Schedule F5 (coastal habitats) or Schedule J (geological features) in the coastal marine area, including any associated ...
/S121/116 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Rule R165:
Additions or alterations to existing seawalls - controlled activity
Support in part
Amend Rule R165(f) as follows:(f) any addition shall add no more than 10m 5m in horizontal projection and 1m in vertical projection to the structure as it existed on the date of public notification of the Proposed Natural Resources Plan (31.07.2015), and ...
Reject
/S121/117 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Rule R166:
Seawalls outside sites of significance - discretionary activity
Support in part
Amend Rule R166 as follows:A new seawall, or the addition to or alteration or replacement of an existing seawall, and the associated use of the structure outside a site or habitat identified in Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule F4 (coastal sites) unless located in the Commercial Port Area, Schedule F5 (coastal habitats) or Schedule J (geological features) in the coastal marine area including any associated: ...
Reject
/S121/118 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Rule R167:
Seawalls inside sites of significance - non-complying activity
Oppose Amend Rule R167 as follows:A new seawall, or the addition to or alteration or replacement of an existing seawall, and the associated use of the structure inside a site or habitat identified in Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule F4 (coastal sites) unless located in the Commercial Port Area, Schedule F5 (coastal habitats) or Schedule J (geological
Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 30 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
features) in the coastal marine area including any associated: ...
/S121/124 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Rule R173:
Additions or alterations to structures inside the Commercial Port Area - permitted activity
Support in part
Amend Rule R173 to remove reference to Kaiwharawhara Stream Estuary through its inclusion in Schedule F4 and subject to the change proposed to general condition (c). [see S121/106]
Reject
/S121/125 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Rule R174:
Additions or alterations to structures inside the Commercial Port Area - controlled activity
Support Retain Rule R174 in its current form and subject to the change proposed to general condition (c). [see S121/106]
Reject
/S121/126 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Rule R175: New
structures associated with passenger and cargo handling inside the Commercial Port Area - permitted activity
Support Retain Rule R175 in its current form and subject to the change proposed to general condition (c). [See S121/106]
Reject
/S121/127 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Rule R182:
Occupation of space by a structure owned by a network utility operator - permitted activity
Support Retain Rule R182 in its current form. Accept
/
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 31 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
S121/128 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Rule R183: Renewal of existing resource consents for occupation of space by structures - controlled activity
Support Retain Rule R183 in its current form. Accept
FS61/060 Minister of Conservation Support AllowS121/129 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Rule R184:
Occupation of space - discretionary activity
Support Retain Rule R184 in its current form. Accept
/S121/146 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Map 30: Hutt
Valley aquifer zone in Wellington Harbour (Port Nicholson)
Oppose Amend Map 30 to more accurately reflect the extent of the Aquifer, or- Delete condition (c) of the coastal management general conditions, or- Exclude the Commercial Port Area in the rule [from having to meet condition (c)] [see S121/106]
Accept
FS25/060 Wellington Water Limited Oppose DisallowS121/147 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Map 32:
Commercial port, Lambton Harbour Area & noise control lines - Lambton Harbour
Amend Amend Map 32 so that the Lambton Harbour Area (Northern Zone) shown onMap 32 is also overlain with the Commercial Port Area notation.
Reject
/S121/149 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Map 50:
Wellington International Airport height restrictions
Amend Clarify height restrictions in Map 50 and the related onlineGIS information.
Accept
FS69/084 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowS121/150 CentrePort Limited (CentrePort) Rule R149: Amend Provision for activities in or on an existing structure or use of that Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 32 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
Maintenance or repair of structures - permitted activity
structure, similar to that provided under Rules 10 and 25 of the Operative Regional Coastal Plan.
/S126/007 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Temporary
structureAmend Amend the definition of Temporary Structures to allow network
utilities to erect and operate temporary structures for a period no more than 6 continuous months.
Reject
FS56/011 Powerco Support AllowS126/009 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Functional need Support Support the term 'Functional need' being defined in the Proposed
NRP and seek it is retained, unaltered.Accept
/S126/011 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited 2.2 Definitions Amend Add a new definition for 'Maintenance' as follows:
"Maintenance means the replacement, repair or renewal of existing infrastructure and where the effects of that utility remain the same or similar in character, intensity and scale."
Reject
FS60/001 NZ Transport Agency Support Allow in partFS56/015 Powerco Support AllowFS35/001 First Gas Ltd Support AllowFS57/007 The Oil Companies Support Allow
S126/018 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Policy P132: Functional need and efficient use
Support WELL support Policy P132 as currently worded. Accept
/S126/019 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Policy P138:
Structures in sites with significant values
Support in part
Policy P138 is supported.WELL's support is contingent on the definition for Regionally Significant Infrastructure being amended in accordance with submission point #S126/006. If submission point S126/006 is not accepted, support for P138 is retracted, and an alternative definition and policy framework should added to provide for WELL's critical electricity facilities across the Wellington Region.
Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 33 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
/S126/020 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Policy P139:
SeawallsAmend Amend P139 to include a new provision to ensure the seawall
design is undertaken in consideration/agreement with other existing infrastructure owners.
Reject
/S126/032 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Rule R149:
Maintenance or repair of structures - permitted activity
Support Support Rule R149 and seek it is retained, unaltered. Accept
/S126/033 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Rule R150: Minor
additions or alterations to structures - permitted activity
Amend Amend Rule R150 to enable structures to be relocated within a 5m radius of its existing position as a permitted activity in the coastal marine environment, as follows:"...(j) the minor addition or alteration shall be within a 5m radius of the original structure, shall add no more than 5m in horizontal projection and 1m in vertical projection to the structure as it existed on the date of public notification of the Proposed Natural Resources Plan (31.07.2015) in the coastal marine area, and ..."
Reject
/S126/034 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Rule R182:
Occupation of space by a structure owned by a network utility operator - permitted activity
Amend Amend Rule R182 to include the word 'facility', as follows:"Occupation of space by a structure or facility owned by a network utility operator - permitted activity" [this change is to rule title, may also require amendment of rule text]
Reject
/S129/001 Alana Bowman Policy P136: Hutt
Valley aquifer Support Approval of this provision. Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 34 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
zone in Wellington Harbour (Port Nicholson)
/S129/002 Alana Bowman Policy P137:
Airport height restriction areas
Support Approval of this provision. Accept
/S135/128 Wellington Water Limited Policy P136: Hutt
Valley aquifer zone in Wellington Harbour (Port Nicholson)
Support Support Accept
/S135/129 Wellington Water Limited Policy P138:
Structures in sites with significant values
Support Support (d) Accept
/S135/183 Wellington Water Limited Rule R150: Minor
additions or alterations to structures - permitted activity
Amend Amend condition (k) to allow for minimum excavation required for suitable bedding of the stormwater pipe, or to like effect.
Accept
/S135/184 Wellington Water Limited Rule R182:
Occupation of space by a structure owned by a network utility operator - permitted activity
Support Support Accept
/S140/001 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Commercial Port
AreaSupport in part
Amend to provide clarification as to what other Maps define or link to The Commercial Port Area
Accept in part
/
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 35 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
S140/002 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Common marine and coastal area
Not stated Provide clarification as to the extent of application of the Coastal Plan provisions, specifically in relation to whether the wider environment is included, to enable certainty.
Reject
/S140/005 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Functional need Support Retain Accept
/S140/009 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Operational
requirementSupport Retain Accept
FS47/004 Maypole Environmental Limited Support AllowS140/025 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Objective O53:
Functional need in the coastal marine area
Support Retain Accept
/S140/026 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Objective O55:
Public open space
Support in part
Amend Objective 55The need for public open space in appropriate areas of the coastal marine area is recognised.
Reject
/S140/027 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Objective O56:
New development in the coastal marine area
Support in part
Amend Objective O56New development in the coastal marine area is of a scale, density and design that is compatible with its function and its location in the coastal environment.
Reject
FS35/003 First Gas Ltd Support AllowFS60/008 NZ Transport Agency Support AllowFS49/049 CentrePort Properties Limited Support Allow
S140/045 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Policy P132: Functional need and efficient use
Support Retain Accept
/S140/046 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Policy P135: Safe
passageSupport Retain Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 36 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
/S140/047 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Policy P138:
Structures in sites with significant values
Support Retain Accept
/S140/065 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Rule R165:
Additions or alterations to existing seawalls - controlled activity
Support in part
Amend (f): any addition shall add no more than 10m 5m in horizontal projection and 1m in...
Reject
/S140/066 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Rule R166:
Seawalls outside sites of significance - discretionary activity
Support in part
Amend Rule R166 as follows:A new seawall, or the addition to or alteration or replacement of an existing seawall, and the associated use of the structure outside a site or habitat identified in Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule F4 (coastal sites) unless located in the Commercial Port Area, Schedule F5 (coastal habitats) or Schedule J (geological features) in the coastal marine area including any associated...
Reject
/S140/067 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Rule R167:
Seawalls inside sites of significance - non-complying activity
Oppose A new seawall, or the addition to or alteration or replacement of an existing seawall, and the associated use of the structure inside a site or habitat identified in Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule F4 (coastal sites) unless located in the Commercial Port Area, Schedule F5 (coastal habitats) or Schedule J (geological features) in the coastal marine area including any associated:...
Reject
/
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 37 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
S140/068 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Rule R173: Additions or alterations to structures inside the Commercial Port Area - permitted activity
Support Retain Accept
/S140/069 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Rule R174:
Additions or alterations to structures inside the Commercial Port Area - controlled activity
Support Retain Accept
/S140/070 Kiwi Rail Holdings Limited Rule R175: New
structures associated with passenger and cargo handling inside the Commercial Port Area - permitted activity
Support Retain Accept
/S141/001 CentrePort Properties Limited 3. Objectives Amend Amend the objectives, policies and rules relevant to the Waterloo
Quay Wharf and InterIsland Wharf to provide for the mixed use redevelopment, either as a complete change of use or in combination with Port related activities; and retain underlying provisions relating to port operations in the Commercial Port Area, until such time as mixed use redevelopment occurs; and apply appropriate controls over redevelopment.
Reject
/S141/003 CentrePort Properties Limited 5.7.3
Maintenance, repair, additions and alterations to
Amend Amend the objectives, policies and rules relevant to the Waterloo Quay Wharf and InterIsland Wharf to provide for the mixed use redevelopment, either as a complete change of use or in combination with Port related activities; and retain underlying
Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 38 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
existing structures
provisions relating to port operations in the Commercial Port Area, until such time as mixed use redevelopment occurs; and apply appropriate controls over redevelopment.
/S141/015 CentrePort Properties Limited Objective O53:
Functional need in the coastal marine area
Amend Use and development in the coastal marine area has a functional need or operational requirement to be located there, unless the use and development is in the Lambton Harbour Area.
Accept in part
/S141/016 CentrePort Properties Limited Objective O54:
Use and development in the coastal marine area
Support Retainin its current form. Accept
/S141/017 CentrePort Properties Limited Objective O56:
New development in the coastal marine area
Amend Retain in its current form. Accept
/S141/018 CentrePort Properties Limited Objective O57:
Use and development in Lambton Harbour Area
Support Retain in its current form. Accept
/S141/019 CentrePort Properties Limited Objective O59:
Passage of vessels and aircraft
Support Retain in its current form. Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 39 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
/S141/027 CentrePort Properties Limited Policy P132:
Functional need and efficient use
Amend (b) have an operational requirement to locate within the coastal marine area, and no reasonable or practicable alternative to locating in the coastal marine area, or be located in the Lambton Harbour Area, or...
Accept
/S141/028 CentrePort Properties Limited Policy P133:
Recreational values
Amend The adverse effects of use and development in the coastal marine area on recreational values shall be managed where practicable by providing for a diverse range of recreational opportunities while avoiding conflicts and safety issues.
Reject
/S141/029 CentrePort Properties Limited Policy P134:
Public open space values and visual amenity
Amend Amend Policy P134 to delete the reference to "havingparticular regard to any relevant provisions contained in any borderingterritorial authorities' proposed and/or operative district plan." and seeks the development of appropriate (including site specific)controls or guidelines.
Reject
FS63/001 Wellington City Council Oppose DisallowS141/030 CentrePort Properties Limited Policy P135: Safe
passageSupport Retain in its current form. Accept
/S141/031 CentrePort Properties Limited Policy P136: Hutt
Valley aquifer zone in Wellington Harbour (Port Nicholson)
Amend RetainPolicy P136 in its current form. Removethe Lambton Harbour Area (Northern Zone) from the Hutt Valley aquifer zone.
Reject
FS25/035 Wellington Water Limited Oppose Disallow
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 40 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
S141/032 CentrePort Properties Limited Policy P139: Seawalls
Amend The construction of a new seawall is generally inappropriate except where the seawall is required to protect:(a) existing, or upgrades to, infrastructure, reclaimed land or structures or...
Reject
/S141/033 CentrePort Properties Limited Policy P142:
Lambton Harbour Area
Amend Amendpolicy P142(j) to state: hasparticular regard to provisions, including design guides, contained in theWellington City District Plan and any relevant proposed plan changes orvariations, including the following matters: amenity values; noise andvibration; views; traffic; wind; lighting and glare; sunlight and shading;height, bulk and form; and urban design, except in the case of use anddevelopment in the Lambton Harbour Area (NorthernZone):
Also seeks an appropriate height limit(s,) building envelopes site coverage.
Reject
FS63/002 Wellington City Council Oppose DisallowS141/042 CentrePort Properties Limited Rule R149:
Maintenance or repair of structures - permitted activity
Support Retainin its current form. Accept
/S141/043 CentrePort Properties Limited Rule R150: Minor
additions or alterations to structures - permitted activity
Support Retainin its current form. Accept
/S141/044 CentrePort Properties Limited Rule R151: Amend Retain in its current form. Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 41 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
Additions or alterations to structures - controlled activity
/S141/045 CentrePort Properties Limited Rule R152:
Removal or demolition of structures or part of a structure - permitted activity
Support Retain in its current form. Accept
/S141/046 CentrePort Properties Limited Rule R153:
Removal or demolition of a structures or part of a structure - restricted discretionary activity
Support Seeks the following additional matters of discretion [to Rule R153]:Removal or demolition is for the purpose of appropriate development in the Lambton Harbour Area (Northern Zone); and Positive effects on the Lambton Harbour Area.
Reject
/S141/047 CentrePort Properties Limited Rule R154: New
temporary structures outside sites of significance - permitted activity
Support RetainRule R154 in its current form. CentrePortseeks such further, consequential or alternative relief as may be necessary,desirable, or appropriate to give effect to the decision sought.
Reject
/S141/048 CentrePort Properties Limited Rule R155: New
temporary structures - restricted discretionary activity
Amend Additional matters of discretion: New temporary structure is for the purpose of appropriate development in the Lambton Harbour Area (Northern Zone); and Positive effects on the Lambton Harbour Area.
Reject
/S141/049 CentrePort Properties Limited Rule R161: New
structures, additions or alterations to
Support Retain in its current form. Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 42 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
structures outside sites of significance - discretionary activity
/S141/050 CentrePort Properties Limited Rule R163:
Replacement of structure or parts of structures - permitted activity
Amend Amend Rule R164 so that it applies to redevelopment of the wharves inthe Lambton Harbour Area (Northern Zone).
Reject
/S141/051 CentrePort Properties Limited Rule R164:
Replacement of structures - restricted discretionary activity
Amend Deletethe reference in condition (f) to Schedule E2 (wharves and boatsheds).
Accept
/S141/052 CentrePort Properties Limited Rule R166:
Seawalls outside sites of significance - discretionary activity
Support Retainin its current form. Accept
/S141/054 CentrePort Properties Limited Rule R169:
Additions or alterations to structures identified in Schedule E1 and or Schedule E2 - restricted discretionary activity
Amend Additional matters of discretion: Whether or not the additions or alterations are for the purpose of appropriate development in the Lambton Harbour Area (Northern Zone); and Positive effects on the Lambton Harbour Area.
Reject
/S141/057 CentrePort Properties Limited Rule R173:
Additions or alterations to
Amend RetainRule R173 in its current form, or amend to be consistent with Rules 6, 10, and12 in Section 6.3 of the Operative Regional Coastal Plan.
Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 43 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
structures inside the Commercial Port Area - permitted activity
/S141/058 CentrePort Properties Limited Rule R174:
Additions or alterations to structures inside the Commercial Port Area - controlled activity
Amend RetainRule R174 in its current form, or amend to be consistent with Rule 13 inSection 6.3 of the Operative Regional Coastal Plan.
Accept
/S141/059 CentrePort Properties Limited Rule R183:
Renewal of existing resource consents for occupation of space by structures - controlled activity
Support Retain in its current form. Accept
/S141/060 CentrePort Properties Limited Rule R184:
Occupation of space - discretionary activity
Support Retain in its current form. Accept
/S141/077 CentrePort Properties Limited Map 32:
Commercial port, Lambton Harbour Area & noise control lines - Lambton Harbour
Amend Retain the incorporation of the Waterloo Quay Wharf and the Inter-Island Wharf (also known as the Railway Wharf) in the Lambton Harbour Area (Northern Zone).Add the Commercial Port Area as an overlay on the Waterloo Quay Wharf and the Inter-Island Wharf (also known as the Railway Wharf) and adjoining areas.
Reject
/S141/079 CentrePort Properties Limited Rule R149: Amend Provision for activities in or on an existing structure or use of that Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 44 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
Maintenance or repair of structures - permitted activity
structure, similar to that provided under Rules 10 and 25 of the Operative Regional Coastal Plan.
/S144/002 Chorus New Zealand Limited Functional need Amend Amend the definition to provide greater clarity around what the
word 'dependent' entails.Reject
FS56/002 Powerco Support AllowS144/003 Chorus New Zealand Limited Operational
requirementAmend Amend the definition to provide greater clarity around what 'needs
to be carried out' entails.Reject
FS56/006 Powerco Support AllowS144/019 Chorus New Zealand Limited Policy P132:
Functional need and efficient use
Amend Amend Policy 132 as follows: Use and development in the coastal marine area shall...(h) recognise the location, operation and function of existing regionally significant infrastructure.
Reject
FS69/063 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowS144/028 Chorus New Zealand Limited 5.7.2 Coastal
management general conditions
Amend Amend Coastal Management General Condition 5.7.2 (c) as follows: (c) there is no disturbance of the foreshore or seabed to a depth greater than 0.5m 2.0m below the seabed or foreshore within the Hutt Valley Aquifer Zone shown on Map 30, and ...
Reject
FS57/065 The Oil Companies Support AllowFS56/092 Powerco Support Allow
S144/029 Chorus New Zealand Limited Rule R150: Minor Amend Amend Rule R150 to clearly define thresholds for minor additions Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 45 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
additions or alterations to structures - permitted activity
or alterations to structures.
FS49/147 CentrePort Properties Limited Support AllowFS56/096 Powerco Support AllowFS57/067 The Oil Companies Support Allow
S144/030 Chorus New Zealand Limited Rule R161: New structures, additions or alterations to structures outside sites of significance - discretionary activity
Amend Amend Rule R161 to clearly define thresholds for minor additions or alterations to structures.
Reject
FS69/075 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowFS56/101 Powerco Support AllowFS49/153 CentrePort Properties Limited Support Allow
S144/031 Chorus New Zealand Limited Rule R162: New structures, additions or alterations to structures inside sites of significance - non-complying activity
Amend Amend Rule R162 as follows:A new structure, addition or alteration to a structure and the associated use of the structure ...
Reject
FS56/103 Powerco Support AllowS145/008 First Gas Ltd Functional need Amend When an activity is dependent on having its location, including
in the coastal marine area or in the beds of lakes and rivers.
Reject
FS56/001 Powerco Support AllowS145/011 First Gas Ltd Operational
requirementAmend When an activity needs to be carried out in a particular location or
way in order to be able to function safely, effectively and efficiently.
Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 46 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
FS32/003 Meridian Energy Limited Support AllowS146/011 NZ Transport Agency Common marine
and coastal areaSupport Retain Accept
/S146/017 NZ Transport Agency Functional need Support in
partAmend the definition: When an activity is dependent on having its location in the coastal marine area or in the beds of lakes and rivers or where that location represents the best practicable option for that activity.
Reject
/S146/027 NZ Transport Agency Operational
requirementSupport in part
Amend the definition of operational requirement: When an activity needs to be carried out in a particular location or way in order to be able to function safely, effectively and efficiently.
Reject
FS25/005 Wellington Water Limited Support AllowFS69/001 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowFS22/003 Transpower NZ Ltd Support AllowFS32/004 Meridian Energy Limited Support Allow
S146/032 NZ Transport Agency 2.2 Definitions Not stated Add a new definition for 'seawall' as follows: Seawall means a man-made structure in the coastal environment primarily constructed for protective purposes but which may also accommodate other beneficial uses such as walkways or cycleways
Accept in part
FS61/076 Minister of Conservation Oppose in part
Allow in part
FS69/003 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowS146/068 NZ Transport Agency Objective O53:
Functional need Support Retain Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 47 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
in the coastal marine area
/S146/069 NZ Transport Agency Objective O54:
Use and development in the coastal marine area
Support Retain Accept
/S146/070 NZ Transport Agency Objective O56:
New development in the coastal marine area
Support Retain Accept
/S146/071 NZ Transport Agency Objective O57:
Use and development in Lambton Harbour Area
Support Retain Accept
/S146/072 NZ Transport Agency Objective O59:
Passage of vessels and aircraft
Support in part
Amend Objective O59: The efficient and safe passage of pedestrians, cyclists, motorised vehicles, vessels and aircraft that support the movement of people, goods and services is provided for in the coastal marine area.
Reject
/S146/128 NZ Transport Agency Policy P132:
Functional need and efficient use
Support Retain Accept
/S146/129 NZ Transport Agency Policy P134:
Public open space values and visual amenity
Support in part
Amend Policy 134: The adverse effects of new use and development on public open space and visual amenity viewed within, to and from the coastal marine area shall be avoided, remedied or mitigated by: . .
Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 48 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
FS49/127 CentrePort Properties Limited Support in part
Allow in part
S146/130 NZ Transport Agency Policy P138: Structures in sites with significant values
Support in part
Amend Policy 138: New structures, replacement of a structure or any addition or alteration to a structure in a site identified in Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule F4 (coastal sites), Schedule F5 (coastal habitats) and Schedule J (geological features) shall be avoided, except where: . . . . (d) it is necessary to enable the development, operation, maintenance and upgrade and development of regionally significant infrastructure and in respect of (a) to (d): (e) the activity represents the best practicable option there are no practicable alternative methods of providing for the activity.
Reject
/S146/131 NZ Transport Agency Policy P139:
SeawallsSupport in part
Amend Policy 139 The construction of a new seawall is inappropriate except where the seawall is required to protect: (a) existing, or upgrades to, or replacement of infrastructure, or (b) new regionally significant infrastructure, and in respect of (a) and (b): (c) the activity represents the best practicable option there is no reasonable or practicable alternative means, and (d) suitably located, designed and certified by a qualified, professional engineer, and (e) designed to incorporate the use of soft engineering options where appropriate.
Reject
FS69/065 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowFS49/128 CentrePort Properties Limited Support in
partAllow in part
S146/132 NZ Transport Agency Policy P142: Support in Amend Policy 141: Use and development of the Lambton Harbour Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 49 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
Lambton Harbour Area
part Area may be appropriate if the use and development: . . . . (g) enables social and economic benefits to Wellington City and the wider region, and (h) provides for open space, pedestrian and cycle through routes and access to and from the water, and. . . . (k) is regionally significant infrastructure which has a functional need or operational requirement to be located in the Lambton Harbour Area.
/S146/192 NZ Transport Agency 5.7.2 Coastal
management general conditions
Support in part
Amend conditions under 5.7.2 [see original submission p69-70 for detailed changes sought].
Accept in part
FS69/073 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowS146/193 NZ Transport Agency 5.7.2 Coastal
management general conditions
Not stated Add a new rule for existing structures in all wetlands Existing permitted or otherwise lawfully established structures in the coastal marine area and common marine and coastal area existing at the date of notification of the Proposed Natural Resources Plan, and the use of those structures, is a permitted activity.
Reject
/S146/194 NZ Transport Agency Rule R149:
Maintenance or repair of structures - permitted activity
Amend (f) the maintenance and repair of the structure is contained within the form of the existing structure and there is no increase in length, width, or height of the existing structure (except for increases for the purposes of replacement, removal and alterations of existing aerial telecommunications cables where these activities will not result in increases in
Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 50 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
design voltage and the new or altered cables will not be lower in height above the foreshore or seabed), and . . . . . . . . (h) the activity shall comply with the coastal management general conditions specified above in Section 5.7.2 apart from condition b) or e).
FS49/146 CentrePort Properties Limited Support AllowS146/195 NZ Transport Agency Rule R150: Minor
additions or alterations to structures - permitted activity
Support in part
Amend Rule 150: (l) the activity shall comply with the coastal management general conditions specified above in Section 5.7.2 apart from condition b) or e).
Reject
/S146/196 NZ Transport Agency Rule R151:
Additions or alterations to structures - controlled activity
Support in part
Amend Rule 151: (l) the activity shall comply with the coastal management general conditions specified above in Section 5.7.2 apart from condition b) or e).
Reject
/S146/197 NZ Transport Agency Rule R152:
Removal or demolition of structures or part of a structure - permitted activity
Support in part
Amend Rule 152: The removal or demolition of a structure or part of a structure, in the coastal marine area including any associated: . . . . (h) the structure or part of the structure is completely removed from the coastal marine area, and (k) the activity shall comply with the coastal management general conditions specified above in Section 5.7.2.
Accept in part
FS56/098 Powerco Support AllowS146/198 NZ Transport Agency Rule R154: New
temporary structures outside sites of significance - permitted activity
Support in part
Amend Rule 154 (p) the activity shall comply with the coastal management general conditions specified above in Section 5.7.2 apart from conditions b) and e). Provide clarity on conditions (i) and (m)
Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 51 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
/S146/199 NZ Transport Agency Rule R155: New
temporary structures - restricted discretionary activity
Support in part
Amend Rule 155 to include a new matter for discretion: 11. whether the structure is associated with the use, operation, maintenance, upgrading or development of regionally significant infrastructure
Reject
FS69/074 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowFS56/100 Powerco Support AllowFS22/044 Transpower NZ Ltd Support Allow
S146/200 NZ Transport Agency Rule R161: New structures, additions or alterations to structures outside sites of significance - discretionary activity
Support Retain Accept
/S146/201 NZ Transport Agency 5.7.5 New and
replacement structures (including temporary structures)
Not stated Add a new rule: to provide for new structures, additions or alterations to a structure and the associated use of the structure inside a site of significance as a discretionary activity where there is a functional and operational need.
Reject
FS56/099 Powerco Support AllowFS61/057 Minister of Conservation Oppose in
partDisallow
FS49/150 CentrePort Properties Limited Support in part
Allow in part
S146/202 NZ Transport Agency Rule R162: New structures, additions or alterations to structures inside sites of
Oppose Retain Rule 162, subject to providing for a new rule managing new structures, additions or alterations to a structure and the associated use of the structure inside a site or habitat identified in Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule F4 (coastal sites), Schedule F5 (coastal habitats) or Schedule J (geological features) in the coastal marine area where associated with regionally
Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 52 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
significance - non-complying activity
significant infrastructure.
FS69/076 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowFS22/045 Transpower NZ Ltd Support AllowFS56/105 Powerco Support AllowFS61/058 Minister of Conservation Support in
partAllow
S146/203 NZ Transport Agency Rule R163: Replacement of structure or parts of structures - permitted activity
Support in part
Delete conditions (f) and (l) and amend (m): the activity shall comply with the coastal management general conditions specified above in Section 5.7.2, apart from conditions b) and e).
Reject
/S146/204 NZ Transport Agency Rule R164:
Replacement of structures - restricted discretionary activity
Support in part
Matters for discretion 8. whether the structure is associated with the use, operation, maintenance, upgrading or development of regionally significant infrastructure
Reject
FS69/077 Wellington International Airport Limited Support AllowFS22/046 Transpower NZ Ltd Support Allow
S146/205 NZ Transport Agency Rule R165: Additions or alterations to existing seawalls - controlled activity
Support (h) the activity shall comply with the coastal management general conditions specified above in Section 5.7.2, apart from conditions b) and e).
Reject
/S146/206 NZ Transport Agency Rule R166:
Seawalls outside sites of significance - discretionary activity
Support Retain Accept
/
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 53 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
S146/207 NZ Transport Agency Rule R167: Seawalls inside sites of significance - non-complying activity
Oppose Add new rule or amend Rule 166 to provide for new seawalls, additions, alterations or replacement and the associated use and other activities to enable construction (such as deposition disturbance etc) inside a site of significance as a discretionary activity where the seawall and use is associated with regionally significant infrastructure.
Reject
/S146/208 NZ Transport Agency Rule R182:
Occupation of space by a structure owned by a network utility operator - permitted activity
Support in part
Rule R182: Occupation of space by regionally significant infrastructure and a structure owned by a network utility operator - permitted activity The occupation of space in the common marine and coastal area by a structure existing before the date of public notification of the Proposed Natural Resources Plan (31.07.2015) which is regionally significant infrastructure or owned by a network utility operator is a permitted activity.
Reject
FS22/047 Transpower NZ Ltd Support AllowFS57/063 The Oil Companies Support Allow
S146/209 NZ Transport Agency Rule R183: Renewal of existing resource consents for occupation of space by structures - controlled activity
Support in part
Amend Rule 183: The first renewal of an existing resource consent for the occupation of space by a structure in the common marine and coastal area, after the date of public notification of the Proposed Natural Resources Plan (31.07.2015) is a controlled activity. Matters of control 1. If enabled by the existing structure, public access is not restricted other than temporarily for health and safety reasons 1. Effects on public access 2. Effects on public open space and visual amenity
Reject
FS49/164 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose DisallowS146/210 NZ Transport Agency Rule R184:
Occupation of space -
Support Retain Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 54 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
discretionary activity
/S150/007 Fiona Jean Heron 5.7.6 Seawalls Amend Provide for appropriate coastal hazard mitigation activities
(including protection) as permitted or controlled activities.Reject
/S150/008 Fiona Jean Heron 5.7.6 Seawalls Amend Provide for coastal hazard mitigation activities (including
protection) to be no greater than discretionary activities and ensure that no coastal hazard mitigation activity is non-complying or prohibited.
Reject
/S153/001 Andrew James Alan McIntyre Entire Plan Oppose in
partEnsure that the Proposed Natural Resources Plan implements the provisions of the New Zealand Coastal Policy Statement, 2010.
Reject
/S153/003 Andrew James Alan McIntyre 3.4 Natural
character, form and function
Oppose in part
Develop and include an over-arching objective to prevent the plan inadvertantly preventing activities which might otherwise be contemplated by the New Zealand Coastal Policy Statement.
Reject
/S158/007 Peter Stevens and Michelle Glogau 5.7.6 Seawalls Amend Provide for appropriate coastal hazard mitigation activities
(including protection) as permitted or controlled activities.Reject
/S158/008 Peter Stevens and Michelle Glogau 5.7.6 Seawalls Amend Provide for coastal hazard mitigation activities (including
protection) to be no greater than discretionary activities and ensure that no coastal hazard mitigation activity is non-complying or prohibited.
Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 55 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
/S160/001 Site 10 Redevelopment Limited
Partnership (S10RLP)Policy P142: Lambton Harbour Area
Support Submitter is not opposed to the concept of development of Waterloo and the Inter-Island Wharves for a use other than operational port activities provided developments are appropriate and the same landward Wellington waterfront provisions apply.
Accept in part
FS49/135 CentrePort Properties Limited Support in part
Allow in part
S160/002 Site 10 Redevelopment Limited Partnership (S10RLP)
Objective O57: Use and development in Lambton Harbour Area
Amend Express recognition in this objective that new development in the CMA be compatible with the surroundings in particular the Wellington waterfront.
Reject
FS49/053 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose DisallowS160/003 Site 10 Redevelopment Limited
Partnership (S10RLP)Policy P138: Structures in sites with significant values
Amend Express incorporation of the Wellington City Council (WCC) district plan provisions as regards the Lambton Harbour Area (LHA) and adoption of the Wellington Waterfront framework as the guiding document for the LHA. Recognition of the WCC central area design guide as regards to LHA in particular the stepping down of the high city in the CBD to the low city at the city edges (including the waterfront).
Reject
FS49/136 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose DisallowS162/012 Mt Victoria Residents Association
IncRule R168: Alteration of structures identified in Schedule E2 or Schedule E3 - permitted activity
Not stated We recommend the description of its significant values in Schedule E1 more specifically mention the seawalls, breakwaters, moorings and boatsheds in the area so it is clear the Rules apply to all parts of this significant heritage site.
Reject
FS49/161 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose DisallowS163/045 Porirua City Council Objective O55:
Public open space
Support [Retain] Accept
/S163/076 Porirua City Council Policy P138: Amend Add the following to the list: "the structure is required to protect or Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 56 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
Structures in sites with significant values
enhance recreational values or public access".
/S163/077 Porirua City Council Policy P139:
SeawallsAmend Amend to read as follows: "The construction of a new seawall is
inappropriate except where the seawall is required: (a) to protect existing, or upgrades to, infrastructure, or (b) to protect new regionally significant infrastructure, or (c) to protect public access to and within the coastal marine area and existing recreational assets, or (d) in accordance with a hazard management strategy, and in respect of (a), (b), (c) and (d): (e) there is no reasonable or practicable alternative means, and (f)..."
Reject
/S163/129 Porirua City Council Rule R149:
Maintenance or repair of structures - permitted activity
Not stated Supported in principle but some allowance should be made for very minor disturbance associated with essential works. Refer to comments on general conditions [submission point S163/128].
Reject
/S163/130 Porirua City Council Rule R150: Minor
additions or alterations to structures - permitted activity
Not stated Refer to comments on general conditions [submission point S163/128].
Reject
/S163/131 Porirua City Council Rule R151:
Additions or alterations to structures - controlled activity
Support [Retain] Accept
FS57/068 The Oil Companies Support AllowFS56/097 Powerco Support Allow
S163/132 Porirua City Council Rule R152: Removal or demolition of structures or part of a structure - permitted activity
Amend Consider adding permitted activity conditions to address any potential adverse effects of removing structures within Schedule C, F4 and F5 sites, rather than automatically classing these as restricted discretionary.
Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 57 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
FS61/059 Minister of Conservation Oppose DisallowS163/133 Porirua City Council Rule R153:
Removal or demolition of a structures or part of a structure - restricted discretionary activity
Amend See comments on R152 [submission point S163/132]. Reject
/S163/134 Porirua City Council Rule R157: New
or replacement structures for scientific or education purposes - controlled activity
Amend Either delete Schedule 1 from condition (g) or introduce a discretionary activity status for Schedule J sites. Amend condition (f) to read: "the structure is not identified in..."
Accept in part
/S163/135 Porirua City Council Rule R160:
Structures and disturbance associated with motor vehicles inside the Cook Strait Cable Protection Zone - discretionary activity
Amend Remove "and mana whenua sites of significance" from thetitle of this rule.
Reject
/S163/136 Porirua City Council Rule R161: New
structures, additions or alterations to structures outside sites of significance - discretionary activity
Amend Add a permitted activity status for small structures occupying less than 10m2, as in rules R104 and R117. Add "or controlled by Rule R151".
Reject
/S163/137 Porirua City Council Rule R162: New Amend Review this and related rules to improve interpretation and Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 58 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
structures, additions or alterations to structures inside sites of significance - non-complying activity
practical application regarding multiple rules for the same activity. Either amend this rule to make the activity discretionary, or be more specific about the nature of the structures to be covered by the rule, to allow that some structures of low impact or that promote sustainability overall, should be excluded from the rules. Create a separate restricted discretionary rule.
/S163/138 Porirua City Council Rule R165:
Additions or alterations to existing seawalls - controlled activity
Amend Consider changing the activity status of this rule to permitted, or introduce a higher size threshold for minor alterations to become classed as controlled.
Reject
/S163/139 Porirua City Council Rule R167:
Seawalls inside sites of significance - non-complying activity
Amend Amend the rule so that it is consistent with Policy P139. New seawalls that are required to protect existing or upgrades to infrastructure should be amended to discretionary activity status. The definition of "upgrade" also needs to be amended [see S163/34]
Reject
/S163/140 Porirua City Council Rule R176: Use
of boatsheds - permitted activity
Support [Retain permitted status] Accept
/S163/141 Porirua City Council Rule R179: New
boatsheds outside Boatshed Management Areas - non-complying activity
Support [Retain] Accept
/S163/162 Porirua City Council Map 31:
Boatshed areasAmend Amend map title to read: "Boatshed Management Areas". Accept
/S165/013 Transpower NZ Ltd Policy P132: Support in Amend Policy P132, as follows: RejectSummary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMA
Page 59 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
Functional need and efficient use
part Use and development in the coastal marine area shall:(a) have a functional need, or(b) have an technical or operational requirement to locate within the coastal marine area, and no reasonable or practicable alternative to locating in the coastal marine area, or...Except in relation to the National Grid, shall:(f) result in the removal of structures ...
/S165/014 Transpower NZ Ltd Policy P138:
Structures in sites with significant values
Support Retain Accept
/S165/015 Transpower NZ Ltd Policy P139:
SeawallsSupport Retain Accept
/S165/075 Transpower NZ Ltd 5.7 Coastal
management rules
Amend Retain the coastal management general conditions specified in Section 5.7.2except as follows:Amend or remove standard (b) to clarify what is the intent of the standard, as follows;Standard (b) any disturbance of the foreshore or seabed is removed in 48 hours.
Accept
/S165/076 Transpower NZ Ltd 5.7 Coastal
management rules
Not stated Add an additional Rule R156A: Activities associated with the National Grid on the foreshore and in the Cook Strait Cable Protection Zone, including those within Schedule C (mana whenua sites of significance) - permitted activity [see original submission for suggested wording]
Reject
/
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 60 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
S165/077 Transpower NZ Ltd Rule R160: Structures and disturbance associated with motor vehicles inside the Cook Strait Cable Protection Zone - discretionary activity
Amend Amend as follows (or similar):New structures and or disturbance associated with motor vehicles inside of the foreshore or seabed in the Cook Strait Cable Protection Zone and mana whenua sites of significance,- discretionary activityA new structure and the associated use of the structure and or disturbance associated with motor vehicles of the foreshore or seabed in the coastal marine area related to the Cook Strait Cable within the Cook Strait Cable Protection Zone shown on Map 52, including any associated:(a)...that is not permitted under Rule 156A, controlled by Rule R157, or a non-complying activity, is a discretionary activity.
Reject
/S165/078 Transpower NZ Ltd Rule R160:
Structures and disturbance associated with motor vehicles inside the Cook Strait Cable Protection Zone - discretionary activity
Amend Add an additional rule as follows (or similar):Rule R160A:Activities associated with the National Grid on the foreshore or in Cook Strait Cable Protection Zone, including those within Schedule C (mana whenua sites of significance) - discretionary activityActivities associated with the use, operation, maintenance, upgrade or development of the Cook Strait cable on the foreshore or in the Cook Strait Cable Protection Zone, including within sites of significance listed in Schedule C (mana
Accept in part
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 61 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
whenua), including any associated:(a) occupation of the common marine and coastal area, and(b) disturbance of the foreshore or seabed, and(c) deposition in, on or under the foreshore or seabed, and(d) discharge of contaminants, and(e) diversion of open coastal waterthat is not permitted by Rule R156A is a discretionary activity.
/S165/079 Transpower NZ Ltd Rule R160:
Structures and disturbance associated with motor vehicles inside the Cook Strait Cable Protection Zone - discretionary activity
Amend Amend Rules R151, R152, R155, R157, R161, R162, R164, R182, R183, R186, R187, R188, R195, R196, R197, R198, R204, R204, R205, R209, and R214 to ensure that activities covered by new Rules R165A and R160A are exempt fromthese rules, as follows (or similar):...That is not permitted by Rule R156A, or a discretionary activity under Rule R160A, is a permitted activity, provided the following conditions are met
Reject
/S165/080 Transpower NZ Ltd Rule R183:
Renewal of existing resource consents for occupation of space by structures - controlled activity
Amend Rule R183: Renewal of existing resource consents for occupation of space by structures - controlled activityExcept as provided for in Rule R156A or R160A...
Reject
/S165/081 Transpower NZ Ltd 5.7.2 Coastal
management Amend Add an advice note to Section 5.7.2 and/or to 5.7.11, as follows
(or similar):Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 62 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
general conditions
Advice Note: Any activities which disturb the foreshore or seabed within the Cook Strait Cable Protection Zone (shown in Map 52), including anchoring and fishing, has the potential to damage the Cook Strait Cables, and is required to comply with the Submarine Cables and Pipeline Protection Order 2009.
/S166/007 Bob Stewart Family Trust 5.7.6 Seawalls Amend Provide for appropriate coastal hazard mitigation activities
(including protection) as permitted or controlled activities.Reject
/S166/008 Bob Stewart Family Trust 5.7.6 Seawalls Amend Provide for coastal hazard mitigation activities (including
protection) to be no greater than discretionary activities and ensure that no coastal hazard mitigation activity is non-complying or prohibited.
Reject
/S167/004 Sustainable Wairarapa Inc 3.13 Coastal
managementNot stated A point has been made with regard to coastal areas and how the
NZCPS refers specifically to the coastal environment which has broad implications for the wider coastal environment.
Reject
/S168/001 Strait Shipping Limited Map 32:
Commercial port, Lambton Harbour Area & noise control lines - Lambton Harbour
Amend Amend Map 32 to rezone the Lambton Harbour Area (northern Zone) comprising of the Inter-Island and Waterloo Wharves as Commercial Port Area; orAny alternative relief to ensure Strait Shipping Limited's operations are not significantly affected or constrained by the proposed change of zoning.
Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 63 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
FS49/179 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose DisallowS172/001 Royal Port Nicholson Yacht Club Rule R181: New
swing moorings outside Mooring Areas - non complying activity
Amend Ask that the Public Notification requirement is removed from section 181. The decision as to whether it should be publically notified or not should be assessed on a case by case basis.
Accept
/S175/009 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier Functional need Amend Reconsider use of the terms "functional need" and "operational
requirement" in the rules and either change the rules or the definitions to enable appropriate hazard mitigation measures that might be able to be located elsewhere but are more efficiently, effectively or cost-effectively located in the particular location.
Reject
/S175/010 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier Operational
requirementAmend Reconsider use of the terms "functional need" and "operational
requirement" in the rules and either change the rules or the definitions to enable appropriate hazard mitigation measures that might be able to be located elsewhere but are more efficiently, effectively or cost-effectively located in the particular location.
Reject
/S175/026 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier Objective O53:
Functional need in the coastal marine area
Oppose in part
Revise the objective to address the concerns expressed. Options could include inserting "generally" after "area" and adding "or is more efficiently, effectively or cost-effectively located there" at the end of the objective.
Reject
FS49/046 CentrePort Properties Limited Support in part
Allow in part
S175/027 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier Objective O56: New development in the coastal marine area
Amend Revise the objective to also recognise the purpose of the new development. An option is to add "and its purpose" at the end of the objective.
Reject
FS49/051 CentrePort Properties Limited Support AllowS175/047 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier Policy P132:
Functional need Oppose in part
Make inconsistent language consistent across the PNRP. Revise Policy P132 to enable the situation where appropriate natural
Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 64 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
and efficient use hazard mitigation measures might be able to be located elsewhere but are more efficiently, effectively or cost-effectively located in the coastal marine area.
/S175/048 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier Policy P134:
Public open space values and visual amenity
Amend Revise the policy to address the concerns expressed. An option is, in (b), to add "built character," before "natural character".
Reject
FS49/125 CentrePort Properties Limited Support in part
Allow in part
S175/049 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier Policy P138: Structures in sites with significant values
Amend Delete policy P138 or make it less extreme to deal with the expressed concerns, possibly by adding a reference to avoiding, remedying or mitigating the effects of structures in the areas and removing "and in respect of (a) to (d): (e) there are no practicable alternative methods of providing for the activity".
Reject
/S175/050 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier Policy P139:
SeawallsOppose in part
Delete Policy P139 and replace it with a policy that gives effect to Policy 27 of the NZCPS, including that seawalls may be appropriate to protect areas of significant existing development from natural hazards.
Accept
FS49/134 CentrePort Properties Limited Support in part
Allow in part
S175/061 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier 5.7 Coastal management rules
Amend Reconsider all references to "open coastal water" throughout the PNRP and replace them with "water".
Reject
/S175/062 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier 5.7 Coastal
management rules
Amend In the rules that permit discharge of contaminants, remove the confusing interaction between the coastal management general conditions and the rules that refer to them, preferably by indicating that general condition (e) does not apply. Revise the rules and general conditions to deal with the concerns expressed throughout the submission.
Reject
/
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 65 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
S175/063 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier 5.7.6 Seawalls Amend Make it clear that the rules about structures apply to seawalls except for those explicitly different in section 5.7.6 or create new rules in the seawalls section that deal with matters that are missing in relation to the seawall rules. Include a note in the relevant general structure rules referring the reader to the different seawall provision.Expand the rules to address associated activities that are not structures e.g. materials to protect the structures.Revise all rules relating to structures and all rules relating to seawalls to deal with concerns expressed throughout the submission.
Reject
FS49/159 CentrePort Properties Limited Support in part
Allow in part
S175/064 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier Rule R162: New structures, additions or alterations to structures inside sites of significance - non-complying activity
Oppose in part
Make coastal hazard mitigation (including protection) structures outside sites of significance a permitted, controlled or restricted discretionary activity with structures inside sites of significance being a discretionary activity.Revise the rule and related rules (or create new rules) to address the concerns expressed throughout this submission.
Reject
/S175/065 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier Rule R163:
Replacement of structure or parts of structures - permitted activity
Amend Remove condition (f). Reject
/S175/066 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier 5.7.6 Seawalls Oppose in
partAmend the rules about seawalls to address the concerns expressed throughout this submission, especially in relation to areas of significant existing development. Amend the rules or create new rules to address e.g. the deposition of materials that may be associated with a seawall and any other aspects that need to be addressed. Make coastal hazard mitigation (including protection) structures outside sites of significance a permitted, controlled or restricted discretionary activity with structures inside sites of significance a discretionary activity.
Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 66 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
FS49/158 CentrePort Properties Limited Support in part
Allow in part
S175/082 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier 12 Schedules Oppose in part
Revise the schedules to appropriately address the concerns expressed throughout. See also submission point S175/070 regarding identifying areas where motor vehicles are not a permitted activity (subject to appropriate exceptions).
Reject
/S175/083 Joan Allin and Rob Crozier 13 Maps Oppose in
partRevise the maps to appropriately address the concerns expressed throughout. See also submission point S175/070 regarding a new map for areas where motor vehicles are not a permitted activity (subject to appropriate exceptions).
Reject
/S177/001 Mana Cruising Club Rule R181: New
swing moorings outside Mooring Areas - non complying activity
Amend Public notification requirement is removed, and the decision to notify or not should be assessed on a case by case basis.
Accept
/S178/001 Wellington Volunteer Coastguard Rule R181: New
swing moorings outside Mooring Areas - non complying activity
Amend The Public Notification requirement is removed from the rule. Accept
/S179/001 Lowry Bay Yacht Club Rule R181: New
swing moorings outside Mooring Areas - non complying activity
Amend We ask that the Public Notification requirement is removed from Rule R181. The decision as to whether it should be publicly notified or not should be assessed on a case by case basis.
Accept
/S277/009 Wellington Chamber of Commerce Policy P138:
Structures in sites with significant
Support in part
[Not stated] Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 67 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
values/
S277/010 Wellington Chamber of Commerce Policy P139: Seawalls
Support in part
[Not stated] Reject
/S277/011 Wellington Chamber of Commerce Policy P142:
Lambton Harbour Area
Support Retain Accept
/S277/019 Wellington Chamber of Commerce Policy P139:
SeawallsNot stated Submitter would request clarity of terms: "no practicable
alternative" [Policy 139 (c)]Reject
/S277/020 Wellington Chamber of Commerce Policy P138:
Structures in sites with significant values
Not stated Submitter questions the definition of "no practicable alternative" [see Policy 138 (e) ]
Reject
/S279/064 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Objective O53:
Functional need in the coastal marine area
Amend Amend the objective to state: Activities shall not be located in the coastal marine area except where (sic) they have a functional need to be located there.
Accept in part
FS49/045 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose DisallowS279/065 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Objective O54:
Use and development in the coastal marine area
Support Retain as notified Accept
/S279/066 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Objective O55:
Public open space
Support Retain as notified Accept
/S279/067 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Objective O56:
New development in the coastal marine area
Support Retain as notified Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 68 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
/S279/069 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Objective O59:
Passage of vessels and aircraft
Support Retain as notified Accept
/S279/157 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Policy P132:
Functional need and efficient use
Amend Amend the policy and associated rules so that the sites listed in Schedules A-F are protected from inappropriate use and development .
Reject
FS73/058 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Oppose DisallowFS49/122 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose Disallow
S279/159 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Policy P133: Recreational values
Support Retain as notified Accept
/S279/160 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Policy P138:
Structures in sites with significant values
Amend Amend the policy and associated rules to add an additional qualifier for (d) that adverse effects on the sites listed in the first sentence of the policy must be avoided.
Reject
FS32/052 Meridian Energy Limited Oppose DisallowFS73/059 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Oppose Disallow
S279/161 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Policy P142: Lambton Harbour Area
Amend Amend the policy and associated rules to direct that any of the exceptions in (b) to (d) must be managed to avoid adverse effects on the sites and their associated values.
Reject
FS83/016 Mt Victoria Residents Association Inc Support in part
Allow in part
FS49/139 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose DisallowS279/213 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc 5.7 Coastal
management rules
Amend The rules in this section that require discretionary or non-complying consent for activities within sites identified in Schedules A to F are supported. Where rules do not require discretionary or non-complying consent for activities within sites in those schedules, rules should be amended or added to do so. Rules should be amended and added to manage the actual and potential effects of oil and gas exploration and extraction, and mining of minerals and other materials from the coastal marine
Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 69 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
area, through resource consents of a status no lower than restricted discretionary activity status.
FS69/072 Wellington International Airport Limited Oppose in part
Disallow
FS22/042 Transpower NZ Ltd Oppose DisallowFS49/143 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose Disallow
S279/257 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Policy P134: Public open space values and visual amenity
Support Retain Accept
/S279/258 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Policy P135: Safe
passageSupport Retain Accept
/S282/003 Wellington International Airport
LimitedOperational requirement
Support Retain Accept
/S282/022 Wellington International Airport
LimitedObjective O53: Functional need in the coastal marine area
Support Retain Accept
/S282/023 Wellington International Airport
LimitedObjective O54: Use and development in the coastal marine area
Support Retain Accept
/S282/024 Wellington International Airport
LimitedObjective O55: Public open space
Support Retain Accept
/S282/025 Wellington International Airport
LimitedObjective O56: New development
Amend Amend Objective O56 as follows:New development in the coastal marine area is of a scale, density and design that is compatible
Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 70 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
in the coastal marine area
with its location in the coastal environment whilst recognising functional needs or operational requirements of such development.
/S282/027 Wellington International Airport
LimitedObjective O59: Passage of vessels and aircraft
Support Retain Accept
/S282/046 Wellington International Airport
LimitedPolicy P132: Functional need and efficient use
Amend Amend Policy P132 as follows:... and in respect of (a), (b) and (c):d) ensure that the only extent of the use provides for the efficient operation of infrastructure the minimum area necessary, ande) be made available for public or multiple use unless a restriction on public accessis where appropriate, and
Reject
/S282/047 Wellington International Airport
LimitedPolicy P133: Recreational values
Oppose Delete policy Reject
/S282/048 Wellington International Airport
LimitedPolicy P134: Public open space values and visual amenity
Amend Amend Policy P134 as follows:
The adverse effects of new use and development on public open space and visual amenity viewed within, to and from the coastal marine area shall be minimised avoided, remedied or mitigated by:(a) having particular regard to any relevant provisions contained in any bordering territorial
Accept in part
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 71 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
authorities' proposed and/or operative district plan, and(b) managing use and development to be of a scale, location, density and design which is compatible with the natural character, natural features and landscapes, and amenity values of the coastal environment and the functional needs, operational requirements and locational constraints of regionally significant infrastructure, and(c) taking account of the future need for public open space in the coastal marine area.
FS49/126 CentrePort Properties Limited Support in part
Allow in part
S282/049 Wellington International Airport Limited
Policy P135: Safe passage
Support Retain Accept
/S282/050 Wellington International Airport
LimitedPolicy P137: Airport height restriction areas
Support Retain Accept
/S282/051 Wellington International Airport
LimitedPolicy P139: Seawalls
Amend Amend Policy P139 as follows:
The construction of a new seawall is inappropriate except where the seawall is required to protect:...b) new or additional development of, regionally significant infrastructure...
Reject
FS59/041 Roading, Parks and Gardens and Solid Waste departments of Hutt City Council and Upper Hutt City Council
Support Allow
S282/058 Wellington International Airport Rule R149: Support Retain Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 72 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
Limited Maintenance or repair of structures - permitted activity
FS22/043 Transpower NZ Ltd Support AllowS282/059 Wellington International Airport
LimitedRule R151: Additions or alterations to structures - controlled activity
Amend Amend Rule R151 as follows:
Matters of control...5. Effects on a site or habitat identified in Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule F2c (birds-coastal), Schedule F4 (coastal sites), Schedule F5 (coastal habitats), Schedule J (geological features) or Schedule K (surf breaks).
Reject
/S282/060 Wellington International Airport
LimitedRule R157: New or replacement structures for scientific or education purposes - controlled activity
Amend Amend Rule R157 as follows:Matters of control...5. Effects on a site or habitat identified in Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule F2c (birds-coastal), Schedule F4 (coastal sites), or Schedule F5 (coastal habitats) or Schedule K (surf breaks)....
Reject
/S282/061 Wellington International Airport
LimitedRule R158: Structures in airport height restriction areas or navigation protection areas for airport/navigation purposes or navigation protection areas - discretionary activity
Amend Amend Rule R158 as follows:...b) within an airport height restriction area shown on Map 50 or Map 51...
Accept
/
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 73 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
S282/062 Wellington International Airport Limited
Rule R159: Structures in airport height restriction areas or navigation protection areas - prohibited activity
Support Retain Accept
/S282/063 Wellington International Airport
Limited5.7.6 Seawalls Support Insert a new rule within section 5.7.6 of the Proposed Plan for
replacement or maintenance of seawalls as a permitted activity [See original submission p36-37 for suggested wording].
Reject
/S282/064 Wellington International Airport
LimitedRule R165: Additions or alterations to existing seawalls - controlled activity
Amend Amend Rule R165 as follows:
Rule R165: The A additions to, or replacement or alterations to of existing seawalls - controlled activityThe replacement of, or addition or alteration to, an existing seawall......That is not permitted by Rule R(insert corresponding new rule number), is a controlled activity...Matters of control...4. Effects on a site or habitat identified in Schedule C (mana whenua), Schedule F4 (coastal sites), Schedule F5 (coastal habitats), Schedule J (geological features)or Schedule K (surf breaks)...
Reject
/S282/065 Wellington International Airport
LimitedRule R166: Seawalls outside sites of
Amend Rule R166: Seawalls outside sites of significance - discretionary activity A new seawall...that is not a permitted activity under
Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 74 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
significance - discretionary activity
Rule R(Insert new rule number), or a controlled activity under Rule R165 is a discretionary activity.
/S282/066 Wellington International Airport
LimitedRule R167: Seawalls inside sites of significance - non-complying activity
Amend Rule R167: Seawalls inside sites of significance - non-complying activity A new seawall...that is not a permitted activity under Rule R(Insert new rule number), a controlled activity under Rule R165 or a discretionary activity under Rule R166, is a non-complying activity.
Reject
/S282/067 Wellington International Airport
LimitedRule R184: Occupation of space - discretionary activity
Oppose Delete R184 Reject
FS49/165 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose DisallowS283/001 Mana Coastguard Rule R181: New
swing moorings outside Mooring Areas - non complying activity
Amend Public notification requirement is removed from Rule 181. Accept
/S286/003 Wellington City Council 3.13 Coastal
managementAmend Amend the Plan to include provisions that manage and control the
use of buildings and structures and changes of use in the CMA.Reject
FS49/041 CentrePort Properties Limited Support in part
Allow in part
S286/019 Wellington City Council Policy P139: Seawalls
Amend Amend Policy 139 to:- recognise that seawalls might be the only practical option to protect important community assets; and
Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 75 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
- explicitly reference roads.
Amend the definition of 'soft engineering' to include a broader range of engineering and non-engineered options that have lesser environmental impacts.
Include a policy that recognises the benefits of existing seawalls and provides for their alteration, addition, replacement (and any associated occupation of the seabed).
Amend the coastal management general conditions that relate to the depth of disturbance and discharge of sediment.
Insert a definition of seawall.
FS59/040 Roading, Parks and Gardens and Solid Waste departments of Hutt City Council and Upper Hutt City Council
Support Allow
FS59/012 Roading, Parks and Gardens and Solid Waste departments of Hutt City Council and Upper Hutt City Council
Support Allow
FS49/131 CentrePort Properties Limited Support in part
Allow in part
S286/032 Wellington City Council Rule R161: New structures, additions or alterations to structures outside sites of significance - discretionary activity
Amend Change the activity status of new structures, additions or alterations to structures in the Te Aro Pa (Site of Significance to Mana Whenua identified in Schedule C) and any other site of significance to Mana Whenua within the urban area, from non-complying activities to discretionary unrestricted activities (Rules 161 and 162).
Reject
/S286/035 Wellington City Council Policy P142:
Lambton Harbour Area
Amend Amend Policy P142 to remove the 'and' between each of matters (a) to (j) and replace with semi-colons.
Accept in part
FS49/138 CentrePort Properties Limited Support AllowS304/005 Anders and Emily Crofoot Policy P139:
SeawallsOppose Delete policy Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 76 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
FS49/132 CentrePort Properties Limited Support in part
Allow in part
S316/092 DairyNZ and Fonterra Co-operative Group Limited
Policy P138: Structures in sites with significant values
Amend Add subclause (e) to Policy P138: "(e) where there is a functional need or operational requirement and in respect of (a) to (e): (f) there are no practicable alternative methods of providing for the activity."
Reject
FS74/224 Rangitāne o Wairarapa Inc Oppose DisallowS326/007 Te Runanga o Toa Rangatira Inc Coastal
ManagementAmend Add clause to ensure that primary coastal policies do not
contradict historical treaty settlement redress conditionsReject
/S353/045 Royal Forest and Bird Protection
SocietyObjective O53: Functional need in the coastal marine area
Oppose Replace reference to coastal marine area with coastal environment. Add the following at the end of the objective: and avoids adverse effects on significant indigenous vegetation and significant habitat of indigenous fauna and outstanding landscapes and features in the coastal environment.
Reject
FS49/047 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose DisallowFS59/022 Roading, Parks and Gardens and Solid
Waste departments of Hutt City Council and Upper Hutt City Council
Oppose Disallow in part
FS26/063 South Wairarapa District Council Oppose DisallowFS26/044 South Wairarapa District Council Oppose DisallowFS69/033 Wellington International Airport Limited Oppose DisallowFS30/042 Masterton District Council Oppose Disallow
S353/046 Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society
Objective O54: Use and development in the coastal marine area
Support Retain Accept
/S353/047 Royal Forest and Bird Protection
SocietyObjective O55: Public open
Support Retain Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 77 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
space/
S353/048 Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society
Objective O56: New development in the coastal marine area
Support Retain Accept
/S353/049 Royal Forest and Bird Protection
SocietyObjective O57: Use and development in Lambton Harbour Area
Support Retain Accept
/S353/126 Royal Forest and Bird Protection
SocietyPolicy P132: Functional need and efficient use
Support in part
Add new provision (h)(h) adverse effects are managed in accordance with [new] Policy 41A
Reject
FS73/068 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Oppose DisallowFS35/009 First Gas Ltd Oppose DisallowFS60/016 NZ Transport Agency Oppose DisallowFS49/123 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose Disallow
S353/127 Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society
Policy P138: Structures in sites with significant values
Support in part
Add new provision (e)(e) adverse effects are managed in accordance with [new] Policy 41A
Reject
FS73/069 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Oppose DisallowS353/128 Royal Forest and Bird Protection
SocietyPolicy P139: Seawalls
Support in part
In (e) replace "appropriate" with "possible" Reject
FS69/066 Wellington International Airport Limited Oppose DisallowFS73/070 Wellington Electricity Lines Limited Oppose Disallow
S353/160 Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society
5.7.3 Maintenance, repair, additions and alterations to existing structures
Support Retain subject to any consequential amendments necessary to give effect to submissions on the objectives and policies.
Accept in part
FS49/145 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose DisallowS366/063 South Wairarapa District Council Objective O53: Support in Amend Objective O53 to read:. Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 78 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
Functional need in the coastal marine area
part Use and development in the coastal marine area has a functional or historical need or operational requirement to be located there.
FS49/043 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose DisallowS366/064 South Wairarapa District Council Objective O59:
Passage of vessels and aircraft
Support in part
Amend Objective O59 to read:The efficient and safe passage of vessels and aircraft that support the movement of people, goods and services is provided for .
Reject
/S366/097 South Wairarapa District Council Policy P132:
Functional need and efficient use
Amend Retain Policy P132, with the following amendments:Policy P132: Functional , historical need and efficient useUse and development in the coastal marine area shall:(a) have a functional need or historical need, or
Reject
/S366/098 South Wairarapa District Council Policy P139:
SeawallsSupport Retain Policy P139 Accept
/S367/063 Masterton District Council Objective O53:
Functional need in the coastal marine area
Support in part
Amend Objective O53 to read:.Use and development in the coastal marine area has a functional or historical need or operational requirement to be located there.
Reject
FS49/042 CentrePort Properties Limited Oppose DisallowS367/064 Masterton District Council Objective O59:
Passage of vessels and aircraft
Support in part
Amend Objective O59 to read:The efficient and safe passage of vessels and aircraft that support the movement of people, goods and services is provided for .
Reject
/S367/097 Masterton District Council Policy P132:
Functional need Amend Retain Policy P132, with the following amendments: Reject
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 79 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
and efficient use Policy P132: Functional , historical need and efficient useUse and development in the coastal marine area shall:(a) have a functional need or historical need, or
/S367/098 Masterton District Council Policy P139:
SeawallsSupport Retain Policy P139 Accept
/S398/041 Atiawa ki Whakarongotai Rule R153:
Removal or demolition of a structures or part of a structure - restricted discretionary activity
Support Retain reference to Schedules B and C, mahinga kai and Maori customary use in Rules R51, R125, R153, R155, R165
Accept
/S398/042 Atiawa ki Whakarongotai Rule R155: New
temporary structures - restricted discretionary activity
Support Retain reference to Schedules B and C, mahinga kai and Maori customary use in Rules R51, R125, R153, R155, R165
Accept
/S398/043 Atiawa ki Whakarongotai Rule R165:
Additions or alterations to existing seawalls - controlled activity
Support Retain reference to Schedules B and C, mahinga kai and Maori customary use in Rules R51, R125, R153, R155, R165
Accept
/S436/001 Wellington Police Maritime Unit Rule R181: New
swing moorings outside Mooring Areas - non
Amend We ask that the Public Notification requirement is removed from R181. The decision as to whether it should be publicly notified or not should be assessed on a case by case basis.
Accept
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 80 of 81
Submission point
Further submission point
Submitter Provision Support Oppose
Decision requested Panel decision
complying activity
/S437/001 Gwenyth Stewart Rule R181: New
swing moorings outside Mooring Areas - non complying activity
Amend Currently the rule states the following - "In respect of Rule R181, applications must be publicly notified". I submit that this be either removed or changed to - In respect of Rule R181, applications may be publicly notified
Accept
/
Summary Table of Decisions on the Proposed Natural Resources Plan: Topic – Management of the CMAPage 81 of 81