21/11/2017
1
Population IssuesUnit 2 Social Studies 3211
October 2017
14.0 POPULATION ISSUESIn this outcome we will…
• 14.1 explain the relationship between population, carrying
capacity, and technology
• 14.2 explain the theory of demographic transition
• 14.3 explain the challenges and possible responses associated with high
population growth rates
• 14.4 explain the challenges and possible responses associated with high
population growth rates
21/11/2017
2
14.1 WORLD POPULATION TRENDS
Complete the activity
“World Population
Trends”
What are two major
trends that you identified
in the activity?
14.1 WORLD POPULATION TRENDS
First Trend
There was a population explosion beginning in the last half of
the 1600’s to the 1980s. From 1960 to 1999 the Earth’s
population doubled from 3 to 6 billion.
What are possible causes and challenges of this trend?
Causes of Population Increase Challenges of Population Increase
• Increase in food supply
• Better health care
• More demand for workers
• Less contraception
• Large families
• Overcrowding of cities
• Eventual trouble providing
enough food
• Overuse of resources
• Increased spending on children
and seniors
21/11/2017
3
14.1 WORLD POPULATION TRENDS
Second Trend
The world’s growth rate has declined since 1980. From 2.31 % in 1980 to
1.25 % in 2007. This represents the largest decline in history.
• Population growth rate refers to the rate at which a country’s
population is changing and is often shown as a percentage. A high rate is
anything over 2%, while a low rate would be 1% or less.
What are possible causes and challenges of this trend?
Causes of Population Decrease Challenges of Population Decrease
• Decrease in food supply
• Increase in disease
• Less demand for workers
• Access to contraception
• Smaller families
• Abandoned cities
• Decrease tax base
• Cost of providing services to smaller areas
• Attracting workers for new developments
14.1 WORLD POPULATION TRENDS
Which parts of the world
do you think have high
or low population
growth rates today?
• Core countries tend to
have lowest growth
• Periphery countries
tend to have the
highest growth
21/11/2017
4
14.1 POPULATION AND TECHNOLOGY
How can available technology be linked to population size?
• Remember carrying capacity – the number of people that can be sustained by the
Earth’s resources.
• You can apply the cornucopian thesis or the limits-to-growth thesis to answer this
question:
• New technology and scientific advancement can make us more efficient at
using resources, therefore supporting a larger population (Cornucopian).
• The Earth’s resources are finite and if we overuse them and they run out
we won’t be able to support larger populations (Limits-to-growth).
14.1 POPULATION AND TECHNOLOGY
Historically, there are three periods that represent major changes in the
influence of technology on population:
Stage 1: Hunting and Gathering (Paleolithic Era)
• Early human societies (2.5 million to 10,000 years ago) moved from
place to place collecting food and hunting animals.
• Stone (lithic) tools were effective, but limited amounts of food.
• Food supply was unreliable, preventing steady population growth.
• Carrying capacity was low due to large areas of land needed to
support small populations.
21/11/2017
5
14.1 POPULATION AND TECHNOLOGY
Stage 2: The Agricultural Revolution (Neolithic Era)
• Development of farming more than 10,000 years ago made
cultural and other technological advances possible.
• Humans went from finding food (when and where available) to
producing food, which gave them more control over the
environment. People could not only grow food, but could now
produce more food than needed, creating a surplus.
• More available food from each square kilometre of land meant
an increase in Earth’s carrying capacity.
14.1 POPULATION AND TECHNOLOGY
In low latitude regions (warmer
areas near the equator) across
the earth, people began to farm
and produce their own food at
around the same time in history
(approx. 10,000-12,000 years
ago).
The crops they grew depended
on the climate and local
environment.
21/11/2017
6
Agriculture leads
to civilization
(complex society)
• For the first
time in history,
food surpluses
meant people
could focus on
more than just
survival.
• Population
would grow and
life would
become more
diverse.
14.1 POPULATION AND TECHNOLOGY
Stage 3: The Industrial Revolution (c. 1750)
• The Industrial Revolution was the process by which
production of food and goods shifted from simple hand
tools to complex machinery.
• This improved upon previous sources of energy for
production (muscle power of people and animals). Coal
(late 1700s) and oil (1800s) would be developed later.
• In farming, tractors and machines were replacing farm
help, leading to increased urbanization (migration to
cities) as people sought to find work.
21/11/2017
7
14.1 POPULATION AND TECHNOLOGY
• The industrial revolution greatly increased the carrying capacity
of the land and resulted in the greatest population increase in
human history:
• New technology allowed people to plant and harvest food
faster (e.g., the seed drill, and combine harvesters)
• Steam engines increased the speed at which coal could be
mined, resulting in more powerful energy sources for
transportation and production of goods.
• Factories (buildings where mechanized production occurred)
could produce goods (e.g., clothing) faster to meet the needs
of a growing population.
14.1 POPULATION AND TECHNOLOGY
Questions (Read pp. 58-63)
1. How might your life change if the population of your community increased
dramatically? Include a variety of examples.
2. Summarize each of the stages of technological development in human history.
3. Which stage of technological change was the most important in affecting Earth’s
carrying capacity? Explain.
4. Which is the best course of action for human development: attempting to reduce
population growth or developing new technology to increase earth’s carrying capacity?
Complete a pro/con chart for each option to help you make your choice.
21/11/2017
8
POPULATION ISSUESIn this outcome we will…
• 14.1 explain the relationship between population, carrying capacity, and
technology
• 14.2 explain the theory of demographic transition
• 14.3 explain the challenges and possible responses associated with high
population growth rates
• 14.4 explain the challenges and possible responses associated with low
population growth rates
14.2 DEMOGRAPHIC TRANSITION
In the previous section we learned that the population growth rate can be greatly
influenced by new technologies that affect Earth’s carrying capacity.
Demographers – scientists who study population – believe that these changes in
growth rate are not random, but predictable. One way this is shown is through
analysis of birth rates, death rates, and factors that influence them.
The birth rate is the number of births in a country for every 1,000 people in the
population.
The death rate is the number of deaths in a country for every 1,000 people in the
population.
21/11/2017
9
14.2 DEMOGRAPHIC TRANSITION
When to find out how quickly a population is
changing due to natural factors, we take the birth
rate (BR) and subtract the death rate (DR). This
gives of the rate of natural increase (RNI)
RNI = BR - DR
For example, a country has a BR of 9.3 and
a DR of 7.4
RNI = BR – DR This means the population
RNI = 9.3 – 7.4 is increasing at a rate of
RNI = 1.9 1.9 for every 1,000.
A positive RNI means there is a natural
increase showing an increase in
population due to natural causes.
A negative RNI means there is a natural
decrease, showing a decrease in
population due to natural causes.
14.2 DEMOGRAPHIC TRANSITION
Countries with an RNI of over 2 are usually less globalized, while RNIs of less than 1
indicate a more globalized country.
This is the case because as a country becomes more globalized with greater access to a variety
of technologies, its birth rates and death rates both decline.
How can changes in technological development affect birth and death rates?
21/11/2017
10
14.2 DEMOGRAPHIC TRANSITION
The Demographic Transition Model (DTM) is the
theory that describes how countries experience a
decrease in birth and death rates as they gain access
to greater technology (i.e., become more globalized).
There are four stages in DTM.
• Stage 1: Pre-transition
• Stage 2: Early transition
• Stage 3: Late transition
• Stage 4: Post-transition
“Transition” here refers to the change from high
birth and death rates to low birth and death rates.
Complete “Demographic Transition”
activity and include it in your folder
as part of your portfolio mark.
14.2 DEMOGRAPHIC TRANSITION
Stage 1: Pre-transition stage – a high birth rate and
death rate result in a stable population.
This stage represents all countries before the Industrial
Revolution.
• Birth rate is high and stable
• Death rate is high and fluctuates due to war,
famine and disease outbreak
• Population sometimes increased / sometimes
decreased, but remained stable overall.
Before the industrial revolution the human population
of Earth was < 1 billion (it took thousands of years to
reach this).
21/11/2017
11
14.2 DEMOGRAPHIC TRANSITION
Stage 2: Early transition stage – a high birth rate and a
falling death rate result in a high population growth rate.
This stage represents Old Core countries during the
Industrial Revolution.
• Dramatic drop in death rate due to disease
control, personal sanitation and clean water
• Birth rate still high because large families were
needed to work on farms or as caregivers for
parents. Some religious forbade contraception
Population doubled from 1 billion to 2 billion between
1804 and 1927.
14.2 DEMOGRAPHIC TRANSITION
Germ Theory – some diseases are caused by organisms too small to be seen. This was a
new idea during the Industrial Revolution and was first developed by Dr. Ignaz
Semmelweis in the 1840s, but his theory was slow to catch on. He pioneered personal
sanitation procedures in medicine
• He worked in Vienna (Austria) in a maternity hospital.
• Video - https://youtu.be/U6-FjtpdePA
• Edward Jenner was an English country doctor in the late 1700s. In his practice,
smallpox was one of the most common and worst problems he encountered.
• In 1788, a smallpox epidemic occurred where Jenner practiced medicine and he
noticed that the cattle farmers were not the ones dying from smallpox.
• Jenner theorized that cowpox (a much milder but similar disease to smallpox) was
somehow protecting the farmers.
• His breakthrough led to the advent of modern vaccinations.
21/11/2017
12
14.2 DEMOGRAPHIC TRANSITION
Stage 3: Late transition stage – a declining birth rate and
a relatively low death rate lead to a slowing population
growth rate.
This stage represents Old Core countries during most of
the 20th century.
• Better medicine and healthcare mean low infant
mortality
• Fewer children needed to support family farms
(better production during Industrial Revolution).
• More people moved to cities for work in factories.
• More women begin working, double incomes mean
many families were better off.
Population growth slows, but reaches 4 billion by 1974.
14.2 DEMOGRAPHIC TRANSITION
Stage 4: Post-transition stage – a low birth rate and a low
death rate lead to a more or less stable population.
This stage represents Old Core countries at the end of the
20th century.
• Birth and death rates low and about equal
• Highly urbanized lifestyle (most people work in
service and industries, rather than agriculture)
• Small families due to lower infant mortality and
women delaying families in favour of careers
• Rate of Natural Increase nearly zero
Human population reached 7 billion by 2013, but
globally the growth rate has declined.
21/11/2017
13
14.2 DEMOGRAPHIC TRANSITION
Many Old Core countries have gone through demographic transition and are currently in Post-transition.
Less globalized countries are currently going through Early and Late transition.
1. Why is it important that less globalized countries reach post-transition as quickly as possible?
2. Do you think Old Core countries will remain in post-transition? Explain.
14.2 POPULATION PYRAMIDS
• Population Pyramid – a graph that shows the structure of a population by age and gender at one point in time.
• It breaks down the makeup of a population by male-female balance and the number of people at different age groups.
Male Female
Measure of the
population (by % or
total numbers)
21/11/2017
14
14.2 POPULATION PYRAMIDS
• These graphs can be used by demographers to identify problems that a country may face in the future and to determine which stage in the demographic transition model a country may be in.
14.2 POPULATION PYRAMIDS
Expanding population
• population is increasing because of a high birth rate
• high death rate is seen by the rapid decrease between age groups and few people that live beyond age 65
• usually indicates far periphery or near core
21/11/2017
15
14.2 POPULATION PYRAMIDS
Stationary population
• population is basically staying the same
• declining birth rate / low death rate• child-bearing age groups are
replacing themselves• middle is roughly the width of the
bottom• usually indicates core or new core
countries
14.2 POPULATION PYRAMIDS
Contracting population
• population is decreasing
• low birth rate / low death rate
• child-bearing age are not replacing themselves
• bottom more narrow than middle
• usually indicates core or new core countries
21/11/2017
16
14.2 POPULATION PYRAMIDS
Pre-transition Early Transition Late Transition Post Transition
14.2 POPULATION PYRAMIDS
Complete “Population Pyramids” activity and place in in your folder as part of your portfolio mark.
21/11/2017
17
POPULATION ISSUESIn this outcome we will…
• 14.1 explain the relationship between population, carrying capacity, and
technology
• 14.2 explain the theory of demographic transition
• 14.3 explain the challenges and possible responses associated
with high population growth rates
• 14.4 explain the challenges and possible responses associated with low
population growth rates
Why is it important that less globalized countries reach post-transition as quickly as possible?
• It is important because if the transition is not made quickly a country can stay in Stage 2 of the DTM and continue to have high birth rates and low death rates. This causes a very rapid increase in population.
• The term for a country remaining in Early Transition Stage with a high birth rate and a low death rate is called the demographic trap.
14.3 OVERPOPULATION
21/11/2017
18
“Trapped” in Stage 2
• Before 1970, Periphery countries were poised to make the transition to the next stage thanks to economic growth.
• Since 1970, economic growth has not keep up with the increases in population in these regions.
• High birth and low death rates have resulted in explosive population growth.
• This causes a downward spiral in standard of living (lower quality of life).
14.3 OVERPOPULATION
• Country cannot reach post-transition.
• The increase in population leads to a growing strain on food supply and services (including medical and educational).
• With the need for more money to provide people with food and services, there is less money to support development that lowers the birth rate.
• When the demands of a growing population exceeds the country’s carrying capacity it is experiencing overpopulation.
14.3 OVERPOPULATION
21/11/2017
19
Insufficient employment
What are some of the challenges that can affect a country that that experiences overpopulation?
Food insecurityProblems providing healthcare
Problems providing education Insufficient infrastructure
Overall, a decreased quality of life for the citizens of that country
14.3 OVERPOPULATION
A country experiencing overpopulation will have:
1. Food insecurity
• Not enough food
2. Decreased education and literacy
• Too many people to educate
3. Increased unemployment
• Not enough jobs for uneducated rural farm people
• People move to the cities but lack skills for urban
technological economy
• This results in a negative feedback loop – the original
condition gets worse because of the outcome.
Need to supply
more food
Large families in agricultural
regions
Increasing Population
A feedback loop showing an ever increasing in population.
14.3 OVERPOPULATION
21/11/2017
20
• This example of a feedback loop shows how a shortage of skilled workers slows demographic transition, making a demographic trap more dangerous.
Complete “Population Control” activity and place in in your folder as part of your portfolio mark.
14.3 OVERPOPULATION
21/11/2017
21
Population control – limitation of population growth through such measures as
contraception, sterilization, and abortion.
India’s Approach to Population Control1. Clinics encouraged family planning.
2. Targets were set for vasectomies and contraception distribution.
3. Men were paid to have vasectomies.
4. Men were forced to have vasectomies, family planning was compulsory, families
restricted to 3 children, and officials who did not meet targets were punished.
5. Emphasis put on education, voluntary sterilization and child-survival programs.
Female sterilization most prevalent.
6. Adopts health services to reduce fertility level to 2.1 children.
14.3 POPULATION CONTROL
Overall, India’s approach has only had moderate
success. Why?
1. Did not focus on things that would keep birth
rate down including: improving the role of
women in society, increasing education, and
improving health and economic development.
2. Forced male sterilizations made it unpopular.
3. Some birth control measures are mistrusted by
people.
4. A preference for males has caused a high
number of females to be aborted.
14.3 POPULATION CONTROL
21/11/2017
22
China’s Approach to Population Control1. One-child per couple policy introduced.
2. People should marry later to reduce child-
bearing years.
3. All pregnancies should be approved by the
women’s work unit.
4. Unapproved pregnancies may bring a fine
or forced abortion.
5. Female sterilization sometimes required
after a second child.
6. Couples are rewarded for following policy.
7. Programs to improve women's education,
health care, and jobs are encouraged.
8. Sex-selective abortion is not allowed.
14.3 POPULATION CONTROL
Kerala’s Approach to Population Control1. Focus on education (people have fewer children.
2. Elevated status of women and empowerment in the
workforce.
3. Improved healthcare (lower infant mortality and
access to birth control).
4. Land reform (better ownership of land encouraged
efficient self ownership).
5. Progressive government policies led to above points.
6. Expatriate workers work in oil-rich countries,
bringing back money to increase quality of life.
14.3 POPULATION CONTROL
21/11/2017
23
Overall, there are two models of population control that countries can use:
• Structural change model: In this model, governments adopt measures to force, or
strongly encourage people to change their behaviours. (e.g., India and China).
• Change by diffusion model: In this model the spread or diffusion of new ideas and
social norms occurs through various forms of social interaction and the influence of
mass media (e.g., TV, news, magazines, etc.). People are influenced, but not forced
to adopt change (e.g., Kerala).
14.3 POPULATION CONTROL
Videos
14.3 POPULATION CONTROL
https://youtu.be/FACK2knC08E
Complete “Don’t Panic – The Truth about
population” as you watch the video.
21/11/2017
24
POPULATION ISSUESIn this outcome we will…
• 14.1 explain the relationship between population, carrying capacity, and
technology
• 14.2 explain the theory of demographic transition
• 14.3 explain the challenges and possible responses associated with high
population growth rates
• 14.4 explain the challenges and possible responses associated
with low population growth rates
14.4 POPULATION IMPLOSION
Remember the
Demographic Transition
Model?
In the last section we
saw how countries can
experience difficulties if
they cannot progress to
stage 4.
But what happens if
countries pass stage 4?
21/11/2017
25
14.4 POPULATION IMPLOSION
Countries entering “Stage 5” are Old Core countries today. Since this stage is new
to the world, no one really knows exactly how it will influence people’s lives.
What problems might a country face that is entering stage 5?
Problems Facing “Stage 5” Countries
• Low birth rates lead to a declining population
• Less need for child care and education funding
• Smaller families, new family structures
• Aging populations will put great strain on healthcare system
• Lower tax base means less money for services
• Labour shortages as more people retire and fewer enter
workforce
• Less influence in the world, smaller military
14.4 POPULATION IMPLOSION
What benefits can a declining
population provide?
Benefits of Declining Populations
• Higher employment rates (fewer
people are available to fill jobs, so
most people should be able to get
work)
• Reduced use of resources meaning
there should be less environmental
damage (e.g., less carbon released
into the atmosphere)
• Reduced loss of wildlife habitats to
make way for human expansion
This decline in population in the Old Core is referred
to as population implosion.
21/11/2017
26
14.4 POPULATION IMPLOSION
Complete “Population
Implosion” activity and
keep it in your folder as
part of your portfolio mark.
14.4 POPULATION IMPLOSION
The total fertility rate for any
country refers to the average
number of children a woman
will have in her life time.
When a country’s fertility rate
is low enough to cause a
natural population decline,
that country is said to be
experiencing a birth dearth.
Which parts of the world are
at greatest risk of
experiencing this problem?
21/11/2017
27
14.4 POPULATION IMPLOSION
Implications of the Birth Dearth
There are five major effects of the birth dearth that can cause concern for countries:
1. Family Structures
2. Aging Populations
3. Labour Shortages
4. Economic Effects
5. Shifts in World Power
14.4 POPULATION IMPLOSION
Implications of the Birth Dearth
1. Family Structures
• Small families with few relatives
• “Little emperor” effect – a single
child, may be spoiled by parents and
grandparents.
• One child has to care for older
parents and grandparents
• More DINK couples – Double Income,
No Kids
21/11/2017
28
14.4 POPULATION IMPLOSION
Implications of the Birth Dearth
2. Aging Populations
• Population dominated
by the elderly
• Governments need to
spend much more on
pensions and healthcare
• Younger people may not
want to pay for needs
of elderly
• Older workforce
14.4 POPULATION IMPLOSION
Implications of the Birth Dearth
Pension Plans – private or
government strategies to provide
income for people during their
retirement years.
In Canada, like other Core countries
there will be fewer working people
for each person receiving a pension.
Where will the money needed
come from?
21/11/2017
29
14.4 POPULATION IMPLOSION
Implications of the Birth Dearth
Possible solutions to pension problem:
1. Reduce pension benefits – pay seniors less or require
them to work longer before collecting pensions.
2. Increase contributions to pension plans – increase
premiums or taxes.
3. Restrict number of people who collect pensions – people
with higher incomes receive less pension.
14.4 POPULATION IMPLOSION
Implications of the Birth Dearth
3. Labour Shortages
• Demand for workers
exceeds the supply
• Great % of people will
be over 60
• Have to allow more
immigration
• May be world shortage
of skilled workers
• Cultural intolerance may
be a problem
This graph shows the predicted labour force for Ontario.
21/11/2017
30
14.4 POPULATION IMPLOSION
Implications of the Birth Dearth
4. Economic Effects
• The economy grows because people
get richer and can afford more things,
and because growing populations
demand more things.
• As populations start to decline the
demand will decrease and the
economy will decline overall.
• We’ve already seen how this can
affect labour shortages as well.
5. Shift in World Power
• U.S., Russia, China, France and U.K.
are permanent members of the United
Nations Security Council and can veto
resolutions.
• By 2050 the Core population could
decline to only 12% of world population
• As other countries populations,
economies and military grow, will the
Old Core continue to have this much
power?
The global balance
of power may
change in the
coming decades as
New Core and Near
Core Periphery
countries gain more
prominence.
14.4 POPULATION IMPLOSION
21/11/2017
31
14.4 POPULATION IMPLOSION
Responses to help avoid a population implosion
Pronatalist strategies – ideas or approaches that encourage people to
have more children.
• Cash payments to parents (baby bonus)
• Tax benefits for parents (child tax credits)
• Inexpensive day cares
• Longer paid parental leave
• Employer provided on-site day cares
• Reduce cost of higher education for students
However, there is little evidence that pronatalist strategies encourage
higher fertility rates.
If increasing birthrates is problematic, how can countries increase
their populations?
• Quebec has the lowest
fertility rate and oldest
population in Canada and
that its population is
expected to start to
decline by about 2020. It
has proposed childcare
funding as a pronatalist
strategy.
• South Korea, which has
the lowest total fertility
rate in the world—1.12 in
2007—is embarking on a
US$35 billion program of
pronatalist policies.
15.0 MIGRATION ISSUES
In this outcome we will…
• 15.1 explain the causes of migration
• 15.2 explain the consequences and possible responses associated with positive
net migration
• 15.3 explain the consequences and possible responses associated with negative
net migration