EE8407 Topic 7
1 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
Power Converter Systems
Graduate Course EE8407
Bin Wu PhD, PEng
ProfessorELCE DepartmentRyerson University
Contact Info Office: ENG328Tel: (416) 979-5000 ext: 6484Email: [email protected] http://www.ee.ryerson.ca/~bwu/
Ryerson Campus
EE8407 Topic 7
2 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
Three-Level NPC Inverter Based MV Drive
Topic 7
Multilevel Neutral Point Clamped (NPC) Inverters
Courtesy of ABB (ACS1000)
EE8407 Topic 7
3 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
Lecture Topics
• Three-level NPC Inverter
• Space Vector Modulation• Neutral Point Voltage Control
• High-level NPC Inverters
Multilevel NPC Inverters
EE8407 Topic 7
4 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Inverter Configuration
Clamping diodes: DZ1 and DZ2 (Phase A)
1dC
1S
2S
3S
4S
A
B
CZ
2dC
1D
2D
3D
4D
1ZD
2ZD
E
E
ZidV
LOAD
Ai
OBi
Ci
Three-Level NPC Inverters
EE8407 Topic 7
5 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Switching State
Complementary Switch pairs:
S1 and S3; S2 and S4;
Device Switching Status (Phase A) Switching
State 1S 2S 3S 4S
Inverter Terminal Voltage
ZAV
P On On Off Off E
O Off On On Off 0
N Off Off On On E
Three-Level NPC Inverters
EE8407 Topic 7
6 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Gate Signal Arrangements
Inverter phase voltage vAZ has three levels: E, 0 and –E
ONONONOPOPOPO
0
1gv
2gv
3gv
4gv
AZv
E
E
Three-Level NPC Inverters
EE8407 Topic 7
7 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Inverter Output Waveforms
2
EAZv
BZv
CZv
ABv
0
0
0
0
t
t
t
tBZAZAB vvv
E
E2
E2
E
Three-Level NPC Inverters
EE8407 Topic 7
8 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Space Vectors
• Three-phase voltages
0)()()( tvtvtv COBOAO
• Two-phase voltages
)(
)(
)(
3
4sin
3
2sin0sin
3
4cos
3
2cos0cos
3
2)(
)(
tv
tv
tv
tv
tv
CO
BO
AO
• Space vector representation
)()()( tvjtvtV
(2) (3)
3/43/20 )()()(3
2)( j
CO
j
BO
j
AO etvetvetvtV
where xjxe jx sincos
(3)
(1)
(2)
(4)
Space Vector Modulation
EE8407 Topic 7
9 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
Switching state [POO] on-state switches:Phase A: upper two switches [P]Phase B: middle two switches [O]Phase C: middle two switches [O]
dBOdAO VtvVtv6
1)(,
3
1)( dCO Vtv
6
1)( and
Substituting (5) to (4) gives a space vector
(5)
(6)01 3
1 jd eVV
• Space Vectors (Example)
from which
Total switching states: 27Total space vectors: 19
Space Vector Modulation
EE8407 Topic 7
10 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Space Vectors Diagram
19 space vectors:
Zero vector: V0
Small vectors: V1 – V6
Medium vectors: V7 – V12
Large vectors: V13 – V18
dVV
3
213
6/
3
37
jedVV
3/
3
214
jedVV
0V
3V
2V
4V
5V
8V
6V
15V
18V
12V
11V
10V
9V
17V
16V
3/1 dVV
Space Vector Modulation
EE8407 Topic 7
11 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
Space Vector
Switching State Vector Classification Vector
Magnitude
0V [PPP][OOO] [NNN] Zero Vector (ZV) 0
P-type N-type
PV1
[POO]
1V
NV1
[ONN]
PV2
[PPO]
2V
NV2
[OON]
PV3
[OPO]
3V
NV3
[NON]
PV4
[OPP]
4V
NV4
[NOO]
PV5
[OOP]
5V
NV5
[NNO]
PV6
[POP]
6V
NV6
[ONO]
Small Vector (SV)
P-type Small Vector (PSV) N-type Small Vector (NSV)
dV3
1
• Switching States and Space Vectors
Redundancy: Zero vector – three switching statesSmall vectors – two states per vector
Space Vector Modulation
EE8407 Topic 7
12 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
Space Vector
Switching State Vector Classification Vector
Magnitude
7V [PON]
8V [OPN]
9V [NPO]
10V [NOP]
11V [ONP]
12V [PNO]
Medium Vector (MV) dV3
3
13V [PNN]
14V [PPN]
15V [NPN]
16V [NPP]
17V [NNP]
18V [PNP]
Large Vector (LV) dV3
2
No redundant switching states for medium or large vectors
• Switching States and Space Vectors
Space Vector Modulation
EE8407 Topic 7
13 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Sector Definition
1V
13V
7V
14V
0V
3V
2V
4V
5V
8V
6V
15V
18V
12V
11V
10V
9V
17V
16V
refV
Sector I
Sector II
Sector III
Sector IV
Sector V
Sector VI
Vref : Reference vector, rotating in space at a certain speed;
All other vectors are stationary.
Space Vector Modulation
EE8407 Topic 7
14 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• SVM Principle
• For a given length and position in space, Vref can be approximated by three nearby stationary vectors; • Based on the chosen stationary vectors, switching states are
selected and gate signals are generated; • When Vref passes through sectors one by one, different sets of
switches are turned on or off; • When Vref rotates one revolution in space, the inverter output
voltage varies one cycle over time; • The inverter output frequency corresponds to the rotating speed
of Vref ; • The inverter output voltage can be adjusted by the magnitude of Vref.
Space Vector Modulation
EE8407 Topic 7
15 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Dwell Time Calculation
4
bT PNNcT
bT
3
PON
PPN
PPO
OON
1
aT
ONNPOO
2
cT
39
13V
7V
1V
14V
0V
2V
refV
aT
• Use volt-second balancing principle
• Select three nearest stationary vectors
721 and, VVV
Sector I
scba
srefcba
TTTT
TVTVTVTV
271
Four Regions
Dwell time is the duty-cycle time of selected switches during the sampling period Ts .
(a)
Space Vector Modulation
EE8407 Topic 7
16 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Dwell Time Calculation
])3
(sin21[
]1)3
(sin2[
]sin21[
asc
asb
asa
mTT
mTT
mTT
Ta , Tb and Tc – dwell times for V1 , V7 and V2
d
refa V
Vm 3 – modulation index
From equation (a)
Space Vector Modulation
EE8407 Topic 7
17 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Switching Sequence (Seven-segment)
General Design Requirements
a) The transition from one switching state to the next involves only
two switches in the same inverter leg, one being turned on and
the other turned off; and
b) The transition for Vref moving from one sector (or one region)
to the next requires no or minimum number of switchings.
Note:
The switching sequence design is not unique, but the above
requirements should be satisfied for switching frequency
minimization.
Space Vector Modulation
EE8407 Topic 7
18 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Switching Sequence (Seven-segment)
Voltage Vector NV2
7V
14V
PV2
14V
7V
NV2
Dwell Time 4cT
2bT
2aT
2cT
2aT
2bT
4cT
Phase A O P P P P P O
Phase B O O P P P O O
Switching
State Phase C N N N O N N N
,0]O[,]P[ E E]N[ .
Assuming Vref is in Region 4 of Sector I,
three vectors are selected: V2 , V7 and V14
Space Vector Modulation
EE8407 Topic 7
19 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Switching Sequence (Seven-segment)
2aT
BZv
AZv
CZv
0E
4cT
2bT
sT
0
0
ABv0
E
E
E
2cT
2bT
4cT
NV2
OON7V
PON14V
PPN PPOPV2
14V
PPN7V
PONNV2
OON
2aT
Switching sequence requirement a) is satisfied.
Space Vector Modulation
EE8407 Topic 7
20 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Switching Sequence (Seven-segment)
Space Vector Modulation
EE8407 Topic 7
21 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Switching Sequence (Seven-segment)
14V
15V
17V
18V
13V
16V 2a
1a
2b1b
3
4SECTOR I
SECTOR VI
SECTOR II
SECTOR III
SECTOR IV
SECTOR V
refV
2a2b
1a1b
4 3
refV
ExtraSwitching
3
4
2b
2a1a
1b
Switching sequence requirement b) is satisfied.
2/2/ 1, fff spdevsw
ssp Tf /1
Device switching frequency:
Sampling frequency:
Fundamental frequency:
1f
Space Vector Modulation
EE8407 Topic 7
22 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
AZv
ABv
0
1gv
4gv
0+E
-E
+2E
-2E
2 3
• Simulated Waveforms (Seven-segment)
f1 = 60Hz, Ts = 1/1080 sec, ma = 0.8, fsw = 570Hz
vAB is not half wave symmetrical; and
contains both even- and odd-order harmonics.
Space Vector Modulation
EE8407 Topic 7
23 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Simulated Waveforms (Seven-segment)
f1 = 60Hz, Ts = 1/1080 sec, ma = 0.8, fsw = 570Hz
0
0.05
0.1
dAZ VV n /
0.15THD = 69.8%
0
0.05
0.1
dAB VV n /
0.15THD = 41.0%
n1 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60
n1 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60
14 16 20 22 26 28
Space Vector Modulation
EE8407 Topic 7
24 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
dnAB VV /
(a) Even order harmonics
(b) Odd order harmonics
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
20n = 2 4 8 10 1416
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8
n =1
am
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
n = 19 17 13 11 7 5
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 am
dnAB VV /
n =1
0
50
100
150
200
THD(%)
THD
201610
20
16
14
10
19
17
• Harmonic Content (Seven-segment)
Space Vector Modulation
EE8407 Topic 7
25 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Laboratory Prototype at Ryerson
Space Vector Modulation
EE8407 Topic 7
26 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Measured Waveforms
AZv
ABv
Waveforms (2ms/div)
Spectrums (500Hz/div)
18
3
9
35 54
3537
17 47
77
7761 65
Waveforms (2ms/div)
Spectrums (500Hz/div)
18
3
14 16 222029
35
4771
61 65
35 5471
8.0)a( am 9.0)b( am
9
3729
d
n
V
VAB
d
n
V
VAZ
0.1
0.1
Space Vector Modulation
EE8407 Topic 7
27 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Measured waveforms (with even-order harmonic elimination)
Waveforms (2ms/div)
Spectrums (500Hz/div)
3
15 21
2735
45 57
17 19
3537
29 47 61 65 77
AZv
ABv
315 21
3527 45
57
1719
353729
47 61 65
71
13
71
Waveforms (2ms/div)
Spectrums (500Hz/div)
8.0)a( am 9.0)b( am
77
d
n
V
VAB
d
n
V
VAZ
0.1
0.1
Space Vector Modulation
EE8407 Topic 7
28 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Neutral Point Voltage Deviation
The neutral point voltage vz can be controlled byP- and N-types of small vectors
ZLOAD
dVLOAD
dV
LOAD
dVLOAD
dV
(a) Zero voltage vector (b) P-type small vector
(c) N-type small vector (d) Medium vector
1dC
2dC
1dC
2dC
1dC
2dC
1dC
2dC
Zv
Zv
Zv
Zv
Zi
Zi
Z
ZZ
A
B
C
A
B
C
A
B
C
A
B
C
Zv]POO[affectednot]PPP[ Zv
Zv]ONN[ definednot]PON[ Zv
LOAD
dV
(e) Large vector
Zv
1dC
2dC
Z
A
B
C
affectednot]PNN[ Zv
Neutral Point Voltage Control
EE8407 Topic 7
29 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Neutral Point Voltage Control
aNaPa TTT
tT
T
tT
T
aaN
aaP
12
12 11 T
Neutral Point Deviation Level
Motoring Mode 0di
Regenerating Mode 0di
ddd Vvv )( 21 0t 0t
ddd Vvv )( 12 0t 0t
ddd Vvv 21 0t 0t
V maximum allowed voltage deviation ( 0 dV ).
Neutral Point Voltage Control
EE8407 Topic 7
30 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Neutral Point Voltage Control
R is used on purpose to make the dc voltage unbalance.
0 0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.052600
2700
2800
29001dv
(sec)t
)(V21, dd vv
2dZ vv
Without Neutral PointVoltage Control
With Neutral PointVoltage Control
A
Z
2dv
ZidV
1dv
R
(a) (b)
(5600V)
Neutral Point Voltage Control
EE8407 Topic 7
31 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Inverter Topologies
1S
2S
3S
1S
A
1D
22 D
2D
E
E
dV E
E
E
dV
E
E
A
(a) Four-level (m = 4) (b) Five-level (m = 5)
2S
3S
21D
1S
2S
3S
4S
1S
2S
3S
4S
1D
X
22 D
33D
31D
22 D
3D
X
Y
Y
Z
dC
dC
P
N
ANv ANv
N
P
Ai Ai
High-Level NPC Inverters
EE8407 Topic 7
32 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Switching State
Switch Status
Four-level Inverter
1S 2S 3S 1S 2S 3S
ANv
1 1 1 0 0 0 3E
0 1 1 1 0 0 2E
0 0 1 1 1 0 E
0 0 0 1 1 1 0
Five-level Inverter
1S 2S 3S 4S 1S 2S 3S 4S ANv
1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 4E
0 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 3E
0 0 1 1 1 1 0 0 2E
0 0 0 1 1 1 1 0 E
0 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 0
High-Level NPC Inverters
EE8407 Topic 7
33 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Component Count
Voltage Level
Switches Clamping Diodes*
dc capacitors
m 6(m-1) 3(m-1)(m-2) (m-1)
3 12 6 2
4 18 18 3
5 24 36 4
6 30 60 5
* The clamping diodes have the same voltage rating as other switches.
Note:
The number of clamping diodes increases substantially with the voltage level.
High-Level NPC Inverters
EE8407 Topic 7
34 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• IPD Modulation (four-level)1.0
-1.0
3gv2gv
1gv
0
ANv
0
ABv
1crv
2crv
3crv
3E
3E
n1 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60
0.05
0.10
dAB VV n /
0
0
THD = 25.2%
THD = 25.2%
High-Level NPC Inverters
EE8407 Topic 7
35 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Harmonic Content (four-level, IPD Modulation)
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 am
0.1
0.2
00
n=1 n=13,17 n=11,19n=7
dAB VV n /
n=5
vAB = 3-level vAB = 5-level 7-level
High-Level NPC Inverters
EE8407 Topic 7
36 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• APOD Modulation (four-level)
1crv
2crv
3crv
1.0
-1.0
0.05
0.10
0 1000 2000 3000 f (Hz)
0.15
ABv
0
0
Ai
13
23rd29th
47th
n = 11 19th
37th
17th
53rd 61st
3E
2 3
dn VVAB /
High-Level NPC Inverters
EE8407 Topic 7
37 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• Harmonic Content (four-level, APOD Modulation)
0.2 0.4 0.6aM
0.1
0.2
0.3
00
x
y 612.0
x
y
n=1
n=13,17n=11
n=19
0.8
d
n
V
VAB
High-Level NPC Inverters
EE8407 Topic 7
38 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006
• The 3-level NPC inverter widely used in MV drives
Main features
- Low device count
- No switches in series
- Suitable for medium voltage operation
• The practical use of 4- or 5-level NPC inverters not reported
Main reasons
- Difficulties in dc capacitor voltage control
- Large number of clamping diodes
Summary
EE8407 Topic 7
39 Textbook: Bin Wu, ‘High-Power Converters and AC Drives’, Wiley - IEEE Press, 2006