www.dnvgl.com/UofF2015
Join the conversation about Utility of the Future on Twitter. #UofF2015
DNV KEMA is now DNV GL
SAFER, SMARTER, GREENER
JOIN THE INNOVATORS AT THE ENERGY INDUSTRYS LEADERSHIP FORUMWashington Marriott at Metro Center in Washington DC
Hosted by DNV GL (formerly DNV KEMA)
Meet our View from the Top Panel:
UTILITY OF THE FUTURE
LEADERSHIP FORUMJUNE 2-3, 2015
The future of energy is happening now. Be a part of it!
Register today to reserve your seat at the Forum. REGISTER NOW!
Tuesday, June 2 - 9:20 AM
Jim Rogers Retired Chairman of the
Board, Duke Energy
Wednesday, June 3 - 8:45 AM Gerry Cauley President and Chief
Executive Ofcer, NERC
Keynote Speakers:
Gordon van Welie President & CEO, ISO New England
Stephen Whitley President & CEO, NYISO
Jim Avery Executive Vice President, Sempra Energy
Peter MolengraafCEO, Alliander
Kim Greene Chief Operating
Ofcer and EVP,
Southern Company
DNVGL_PGdec_1505 1 4/13/15 2:33 PM
16 Best Practices to Mitigate Data Exfiltration
18 Who Owns the Data?
21 Utilities and Digital-savvy Customers
T H E O F F I C I A L P U B L I C A T I O N O F
YOUR POWER DELIVERY MEDIA SOURCE
PO
WE
R-G
RID
.CO
M
: M
AY
2015
The Missing Element for Physical Security
1505pg_C1 1 5/5/15 4:56 PM
To learn more about our smart solutions, visit sensus.com/reach.
You never know what youre capable of
until you reach for it.
Thats why were continuously anticipating and responding to your challenges. Delivering the metrology,Thats why were continuously anticipating and responding to your challenges. Delivering the metrology,
communication systems, analytics and services to help you do more with your resources and infrastructure.communication systems, analytics and services to help you do more with your resources and infrastructure.
All to improve ef ciency, responsiveness and the quality of life in your communities. So when youre readyAll to improve ef ciency, responsiveness and the quality of life in your communities. So when youre ready
to reach farther, you can count on us to be there reaching right along with you.to reach farther, you can count on us to be there reaching right along with you.
Nothings out of reach.Nothings out of reach.
+
++
+
+
1505pg_C2 2 5/5/15 4:56 PM
Go to pgi.hotims.com for more information.
1505pg_1 1 5/5/15 4:51 PM
PowerGrid International: ISSN 1547-6723,
is published 12 times per year (January,
February, March, April, May, June, July, August,
September, October, November and December)
by PennWell Corp., 1421 S. Sheridan Rd., Tulsa
OK 74112; phone 918.835.3161. Copyright
2015 by PennWell Corp. (Registered in U.S.
Patent Trademark Office). All rights reserved.
Authorization to photocopy items for internal
or personal use, or the internal or personal
use of specific clients, is granted by PowerGrid
International: ISSN 1547-6723, provided that
the appropriate fee is paid directly to Copyright
Clearance Center, 222 Rosewood Dr., Danvers,
MA 01923 USA, 978.750.8400. Prior to pho-
tocopying items for educational classroom use,
please contact Copyright Clearance Center,
222 Rosewood Dr., Danvers, MA 01923 USA,
508.750.8400. Distributed to executives and
engineers in electric, water/wastewater and
gas utilities and pipeline companies around the
world. Periodicals Postage Paid at Tulsa, OK
and additional mailing offices. Subscription: $85
per year (U.S.), $94 (Canada/Mexico), $225
(international air mail). Back issues of PowerGrid
International may be purchased at a cost of
$13 each in the U.S. and $21 elsewhere. Copies
of back issues are also available on microfilm
and microfiche from University Microfilm, a Xerox
Co., 300 N. Zeeb Rd., Ann Arbor, MI 48103.
Available on the NEXIS Service, Mead Data
Central Inc., Box 933, Dayton, OH 45402; (937)
865-6800. Postmaster: Send address changes
and other circulation information to PowerGrid
International, P.O. Box 3264, Northbrook, IL
60065-3240. Return undeliverable Canadian
addresses to P.O. Box 122, Niagara Falls, ON L2E
6S4 PowerGrid International is a registered
trademark of PennWell Corp. We make portions of
our subscriber list available to carefully screened
companies that offer products and services that
may be important for your work. If you do not want
to receive those offers and/or information, please
let us know by contacting us at List Services,
PowerGrid International, P.O. Box 2280, Tulsa
OK 74101.
Member American Business Press.
BPA International.
Printed in the
U.S.A. GST No.
126813153
Publications Mail
Agreement No.
40052420
2 | May 2015www.power-grid.com
CAN STOCK PHOTO INC. / FASTFUN23
MAY 2015 VOLUME 20.05
12Your Physical Security
System is Missing a Crucial Element
Bert Williams of ABB Wireless explains the
advantages of wireless networks over wired
networks and why utilities prefer them to
deploy in substations.
21 The Benefits, Challenges of Integrating Consumer-driven Technology Into Utilities Jay Cadman of Ubisense shares how smart devices and 24/7 Internet access is changing utilities, a sector that historically lagged behind others in rolling out the newest technologies.
24 The Steady (but Speedy) Technology March of Demand Response Schneider Electrics Phil Davis writes that Newtons safety net is crumbling as new power sources with little to no mass become significant. The result? Software is replacing rotating mass.
28 How Electric Utilities Can Compete in the Digital Consumer Economy Satya Ramaswamy of Tata Consultancy Services writes that if electric utilities can harness five digital technologies effectively, the benefits will be enormous.
30 Tree Service Fleets Use GPS Tracking Technology to Solve Common Problems Jenny Malcolm of GPS Insight shares how GPS tracking can improve customer satisfaction, eliminate unauthorized usage, reduce fuel costs and improve driver behavior.
35 Calendar/Ad Index
36 Products
From the Editor 4
Notes 5
What We Learned 16From a Data
Exfiltration Incident at an Electric Utility
Del Rodillas of Palo Alto Networks comments on a case study from his favorite
conference session at DistribuTECH and provides best practices and technologies that might have
mitigated the event.
18 Who Owns the Data? EnerNOCs Kevin Tate writes that big data brings big concerns, including how to use secure customer data to better engage customers and delight them with improved communication.
32 Case Study: Electric Cooperative Switches Rural Lighting to LEDs David Tanonis of Evluma tells how a switch from HPS to LED rural lighting came about at Inland Power and Light Co. in Spokane, Washington.
30
1505pg_2 2 5/5/15 4:51 PM
FEBRUARY 911, 2016 + DISTRIBUTECH.COMORANGE COUNTY CONVENTION CENTER - WEST HALLS A & B + ORLANDO, FL
Owned & Produced By:
Official Publication of DistribuTECH:
FOCUSED ON
THE FUTURE
CONFERENCE MAJOR TOPICSDetailed topic descriptions are available online at www.distributech.com.
+ Advanced Metering
+ Big Data and Analytics
+ Customer Strategies and Technology
+ Defending the Grid
+ Demand Response
+ Distributed Energy Resources and
Renewables
+ Energy Efficiency
+ Energy Storage
+ Enterprise Information and Asset
Management
+ Geospatial and Mobile Solutions
+ Grid Communications
+ International Smart Grid Projects
+ Smart Distribution Management
+ Smart Grid Operations Solutions
+ Substation Integration and Automation
+ Transmission and Energy Storage
+ Water Utility Technology
SUBMIT YOUR ABSTRACT OR UTILITY UNIVERSITY PROPOSAL
DEADLINE IS MONDAY, JUNE 8Submit online at distributech.com
Go to pgi.hotims.com for more information.
1505pg_3 3 5/5/15 4:51 PM
4 | May 2015www.power-grid.com
FROM THE EDITOR
EDITOR IN CHIEF Teresa Hansen
918.831.9504 [email protected]
SENIOR EDITOR Kristen Wright
918.831.9177 [email protected]
ONLINE/ASSOCIATE EDITOR Jeff Postelwait
918.831.9114 [email protected]
GRAPHIC DESIGNER Deanna Taylor
918.832.9378 [email protected]
CONTRIBUTING EDITOR TransmissionHub Senior Analyst Corina Rivera-Linares
BUSINESS ADMINISTRATOR Angie ODea
918.831.9431 [email protected]
VICE PRESIDENT-AUDIENCE DEVELOPMENT & MARKETING
June Griffin
AUDIENCE DEVELOPMENT MANAGER Linda Thomas
918.832.9254 [email protected]
SUBSCRIBER SERVICE P.O. Box 3264, Northbrook, IL 60065
phone 847.763.9540 [email protected]
SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT, NORTH AMERICAN POWER GENERATION GROUP
Richard Baker 918.831.9187 [email protected]
PENNWELL CORP. IN EUROPE PennWell International Limited
The Water Tower, Gunpowder Mill Waltham Abbey, Essex EN9 1BN, United Kingdom
phone +44.1992.656600 fax +44.1992.656700
CHAIRMAN Frank T. Lauinger
PRESIDENT/CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER Robert F. Biolchini
CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER/ SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT
Mark C. Wilmoth
1421 S. Sheridan Road, Tulsa, OK 74112 PO Box 1260, Tulsa OK 74101
Phone 918.835.3161 Fax 918.831.9834 [email protected] www.pennwell.com
POWERGRID International is the offcial publication of
EDITOR IN CHIEF TERESA HANSEN
The U.S. energy delivery infrastructure needs a lot of work, according
to the first Quadrennial Energy Review (QER) released April 21 by the
Obama administration. President Obama commissioned the report when
he announced his Climate Action Plan in June 2013. A White House press
release states the QER was commissioned to examine how to modernize the
nations energy infrastructure to promote economic competitiveness, energy
security and environmental responsibility and take full advantage of American
innovation and the new sources of domestic energy supply that are transform-
ing the nations energy marketplace.
The QER looked at more than just electricity delivery infrastructure. It
includes oil and gas and transportation infrastructure, too. Im not sure if the
QER uncovered anything surprising in those areas, but the electricity infra-
structure-related findings were no surprise.
The report concludes the obvious: Our energy landscape is changing dra-
matically, and the electricity delivery business is transforming quickly. The
decline in coal-fired power brought on by environmental regulations, includ-
ing the Clean Power Plan; the tremendous increase in the use of renewable
energy sources, especially solar, which the report says has increased 20-fold
since 2008; the need for a more resilient and reliable grid in light of increasing
extreme weather events; the need to combat cyberattacks and cyberthreats;
and the influx of new technologies require changes to the way we deliver
electricity and the way we monetize and regulate it. The QER recoginzes these
challenges and states transformation will not be easy or cheap.
The QER identifies some obvious challenges and emphasizes the adminis-
trations stand on climate change: It is a threat and the challenges it creates are
serious and must be addressed.
The QER goes beyond identifying vulnerabilities and challenges associated
with grid transformation. The document recommends the federal government
invest in the transformation by providing states with up to $350 million over
five years to improve the electricity infrastructure. In addition, the QER rec-
ommends the federal government create policies and programs to increase
cooperation among states to improve grid reliability.
In addition, the Department of Energy has requested $3.5 billion in federal
funds over the next 10 years to support technology development, enhance
grid security and provide technical support to facilitate the evolution toward a
more flexible and modern grid.
Given that several recent studies predict the U.S. electricity grid will need
$1.5 trillion to $2 trillion in investment before 2030 to continue to operate
safely and reliably, a few billion dollars isnt much.
The bright spot in the QER could be the conversations and actions it initi-
ates from regulators and lawmakers, but will that be enough?
Will White Houses QER Matter?
1505pg_4 4 5/5/15 4:51 PM
NOTES
Go to pgi.hotims.com for more information.
leidos.com/activate
Access domain knowledge.
Leverage data science.
Leidos is transcending commoditized engineering with solutions that combine expertise in system planning; transmission, substation, and distribution engineering; protection and control; information technology; and data science. We help utilities use data to optimize system design, improve reliability indicators, and enhance shareholder value.
Activate Tomorrow, Today.
medium- and low-voltage distribution net-
works in an integrated software platform.
By efficiently managing their distribution
assets, utilities can cope better with the
continual changing world of distribution,
improving reliability and efficiency and
reducing the impact of outages.
Collaborating with companies like
ABB allows us to automate the grid
and improve the way we operate, said
Kenny Mercado, senior vice president
of electric operations at CenterPoint
Energy. Last year we saw power reliabil-
ity improve by more than 28 percent,
and we expect this trend to continue.
The Department of Energy (DOE),
CenterPoint Energy and power
and automation technology group
ABB recently completed an initia-
tive to advance the reliability of the
Houston power network by deploying
an advanced intelligent grid system.
The deployment includes ABB enter-
prise software solutions composed of an
advanced distribution management sys-
tem (ADMS) integrated with a mobile
work force management system and an
advanced outage analytics package that ties
the systems together.
Five years ago, CenterPoint Energy won
a $200 million Smart Grid Investment
Grant to deliver benefits to consumers
and the environment through the com-
panys Advanced Metering System (AMS)
and Intelligent Grid (IG). The IG, which
includes the ABB software solu-
tions, is designed to improve
service to the utilitys 2.3 million
metered customers and includes
installation of 31 substations and
771 intelligent grid-switching devic-
es on 188 distribution circuits, making
this deployment one of the worlds largest
ADMS systems in operation.
Leveraging the ADMS software, this
intelligent self-healing grid can identify,
isolate and restore power outages more
quickly.
Since 2011, it has helped customers
avoid more than 100 million outage
minutes.
ABBs Network Manager DMS provides
real-time monitoring and control, net-
work analysis, network optimization and
outage management for subtransmission,
CENTERPOINT ENERGY TEAMS WITH DOE, ABB TO IMPROVE POWER RELIABILITY
C
AN
ST
OC
K P
HO
TO
IN
C.
/ Z
QF
OT
OG
RA
PH
Y
1505pg_5 5 5/5/15 4:51 PM
6 | May 2015www.power-grid.com
NOTES
and dispatch of the microgrid distributed
energy resources (DERs), allowing the sys-
tem to maximize renewable energy usage
and storage while minimizing energy costs.
DSOs platform makes this possible by
leveraging market pricing signals, weath-
er and forecasting information, historical
energy usage data and real-time building
information.
To help educate and demonstrate
the benefits of microgrids to residents,
students, policymakers and businesses,
S&C and Schneider Electric were asked
to develop a microgrid demonstration
facility on the SOSF campus. That facili-
ty will be known as Oncors Technology
Demonstration and Education Center
(TDEC) and consists of two exhibits:
an immersion room and a demonstration
center. In the immersion room, the Oncor
microgrid story is brought to life on seven
screens for a full cinematic experience.
The microgrid story highlights the history
of the electric grid and the changes Oncor
has made.
The center, which also serves as the
SOSF microgrid control center, displays
the new technology that Oncor is using
on its system. The demonstration room
features a fully functioning supervisory
control and data acquisition (SCADA) rep-
resentation of the microgrid to show how
the system reacts to a loss of power event
such as extreme weather. Once an event
is created, the switching devices respond
accordingly, clearing the fault, isolating
the faulted section and restoring service
from an alternate source. The switching
devices, controls, communications and
software shown are all real and completely
functional. Tours of Oncors microgrid may
be arranged by e-mailing microgrids@
sandc.com.
S&C Electric Company and Schneider
Electric have announced the unveiling of
one of the most advanced microgrids in
North America for Oncor, an electric trans-
mission and distribution company with 10
million customers across Texas.
The microgrid is engineered to max-
imize newly installed energy storage,
renewable generation and improve reliabil-
ity. S&C teamed with Schneider Electric
to combine new hardware and soft-
ware technologies for the facility, which
includes an integrated demonstration
center for Oncor to showcase the micro-
grids advanced capabilities and custom-
er benefits.
S&C and Schneider Electric built the
microgrid at Oncors System Operating
Services Facility (SOSF) near Lancaster,
Texas. The system consists of four intercon-
nected microgrids and uses nine distribut-
ed generation sources, including two solar
photovoltaic arrays, a microturbine, two
energy storage units and four generators.
To turn these diverse generation assets into
a microgrid, S&C and Schneider Electric
developed a distribution automation
scheme that leverages intelligent grid solu-
tions from both companiesenabling the
four microgrids to operate independently
or as one larger microgrid.
Improving power reliability and opti-
mizing generation assets requires disrup-
tive technologies that allow customers to
work on and off the grid, said David
Chiesa, director of microgrid business
development at S&C. Oncors microgrid
is showing the world how utilities can help
their communities in the future.
During a loss-of-power event, a com-
bination of S&Cs advanced distribution
automation equipment and Schneider
Electrics Microgrid Controller (MGC) use
high-speed communications and distrib-
uted grid intelligence to detect a prob-
lem automatically on the grid. It starts
with S&Cs IntelliRupter PulseCloser fault
interrupter, which detects an interrup-
tion in power, tests to see if the issue
is temporary or permanent, and if it is
permanent, dynamically islands the facil-
ity. The system then uses S&Cs Scada-
Mate CX Switches and Vista Underground
Distribution Switchgear to reconfigure the
distribution system automatically while the
MGC autonomously switches to alternative
distributed power sources.
The energy storage systems are the back-
bone of the microgrid and include S&Cs
PureWave Community Energy Storage
System. The on-site energy storage, which
stores energy from either the utility feed
or any of the facilitys generation sources,
provides the voltage signal for the site,
enables renewable integration, controls the
microgrid frequency and is the first gener-
ating source to respond during unexpected
power loss.
The microgrid system also benefits
from advanced grid technologies devel-
oped by Schneider Electric, including the
PowerLogic load preservation system, the
microgrid controller and a new technol-
ogy called StruxureWare Demand Side
Operations (DSO). Schneider Electrics
DSO model delivers economic optimization
S&C, SCHNEIDER ELECTRIC AND ONCOR COMPLETE DER MICROGRID
C
AN
ST
OC
K P
HO
TO
IN
C.
/ O
XY
GE
N64
1505pg_6 6 5/5/15 4:51 PM
DATABASE &WORK FLOWCONSULTING
Keeping you connected and compliant with mission-critical software and services
TRAINING
SYSTEM
PROTECTION
DATABASE
PROTECTIVE
RELAY TESTING
SOFTWARE
Visit www.enoserv.comA DIVISION OF DOBLE
Go to pgi.hotims.com for more information.
will investigate avenues that improve the
scalability and economic feasibility of these
communities across the state.
Meritage Homes designed the houses
in the development. The dwellings
feature such items as high-effi-
ciency solar panels, HVAC sys-
tems, water-heating equipment,
heat pumps and integrated
fresh air ventilation.
In addition, each
will have spray foam insulation, highly
insulated windows, energy-efficient light-
ing, smart chargers and smart appliances.
With these technologies, the homes are
projected to curb energy use as much as 60
percent compared with a house built to the
latest California Energy Code.
The model houses range from 1,936 to
2,915 square feet.
The Electric Power Research Institute
(EPRI) will lead an effort by three com-
panies, a utility and the California Public
Utilities Commission (CPUC) in evaluating
the energy use and grid integration of a
new community of at least 20 zero net
energy houses, the first development of a
community of highly efficient houses in
the state.
Results from this project support EPRIs
work with utilities in the U.S. and abroad
on a more integrated power system while
propelling the CPUCs objectives to increase
energy efficiency and renewable energy in
California.
Meritage Homes, BIRAenergy, Itron and
Southern California Edison (SCE) will
work with EPRI and the CPUC in build-
ing and evaluating the project, which will
help California meet its big bold goal for
all new houses in the state to be zero net
energy by 2020 and meet the states stricter
limitations of carbon emissions.
Zero net energy houses, with help from
the grid, are designed to generate the same
amount of energy that they consume. They
have been a central goal of California strat-
egies aimed at increasing energy efficiency
and reducing carbon dioxide emissions;
however, they were neither cost-effective
nor available for most homebuyers until
recently.
Zero net energy houses still rely on the
grid, both to absorb excess solar generation
during the day and to deliver power at
night. During the next several years, the
project team will study how these hous-
es and their advanced technologies can
be integrated effectively into the utilitys
electric grid. Simultaneously, researchers
20 ZERO NET ENERGY HOMES TO BE BUILT IN CALIFORNIA COMMUNITY
C
AN
ST
OC
K P
HO
TO
IN
C.
/ O
XY
GE
N64
C
AN
ST
OC
K P
HO
TO
IN
C.
/ S
ER
MA
X55
1505pg_7 7 5/5/15 4:51 PM
8 | May 2015www.power-grid.com
NOTES
EYE ON THE WORLD
C
AN
ST
OC
K P
HO
TO
IN
C.
/ Z
HU
ZH
U
C
AN
ST
OC
K P
HO
TO
IN
C.
/ A
LM
AV
IVA
Locamation B.V. recently signed a memorandum of
understanding (MoU) with Liaoning Construction of Power
Transmission & Transformation Project Co. Ltd. (Liaoning) during
an official ceremony in Shenzhen, China.
The MoU confirms exclusive cooperation for the supply
of substation automation and smart grid technology for the
Shenzhen Low Carbon City Project. The MoU was signed
during a trade mission led by Dutch Prime Minister Mark
Rutte, who facilitated the ceremony and witnessed the signing
of the agreement.
The agreement covers the supply and installation for the
Berlin Technical University and Dresden University of Applied
Sciences, among others, are working under the lead management
of Siemens on developing a new gas-insulated DC transmission
line known as the DC CTL (Compact Transmission Line for Direct-
Current High Voltage) for laying underground.
The new line is designed to transmit up to 5
GW of power per system. The German Federal
Ministry for Economic Affairs and Energy
(BMWi) is providing 3.78 million euros in this
development project.
The DC CTL will be based on the technol-
ogy of the existing gas-insulated transmission
line (GIL), which consists of two concentric
aluminum tubes. A mixture of gases is used
as the insulating medium. Until now, the GIL
has been available only for alternating current.
The challenge for the DC CTL is posed by the
special design of the components, taking into account their specific
properties at high direct voltages. Because of its significantly higher
current carrying capacity of up to 5,000 amperes (A), the DC variant
of the GIL would not only be able to transmit the required amounts
of electrical power more efficiently compared with cable in the
future grid upgrade; it also would make power transmission routes
more environmentally compatible and cheaper.
Expansion of the transmission grid is necessary if 80 percent
of demand for electrical energy in Germany is to be covered by
renewable energy sources by 2050. The power generated by wind
turbines in the north of the country and off the German coast will
need to be transported as efficiently as possible to the load centers
in southern Germany. Direct current transmission is the method of
choice for doing this because of its low electrical losses compared
with alternating current transmission. Developing the grid using
high-voltage direct-current (HVDC) transmission technology with
Locamation BV signs MoU with Liaoning Construction of Power Transmission & Transformation Project Co.
Siemens develops gas-insulated transmission line for high-voltage DC
Shenzhen Low Carbon City Project, where both parties have
agreed to take part in an innovation consortium. The MoU
was signed by Jia Wu of Liaoning Construction of Power
Transmission & Transformation Project Co. Ltd. and Locamation
B.V Chief Operating Officer Pascal Bleeker.
The Shenzhen region has been earmarked by the Chinese
government as the countrys most innovative region. Locamation
is proud to have its products installed in this region.
We are happy with the backing of our prime minister,
who provided personal support to allow the partnership with
Liaoning to succeed, Bleeker said.
overhead power lines and gas-insulated DC transmission lines bur-
ied underground over certain sections could be implemented using
considerably less resources than three-phase technology.
The underground DC transmission line is of significance for
Germanys transition to a new energy mix because its development
will initially take place in Germany, said Denis
Imamovic, who is responsible for gas-insulat-
ed transmission systems at Siemens Energy
Management Division. Later on, inquiries
from other countries in the EU or elsewhere
in the world would be quite possible. In any
case, with development of the gas-insulated
DC transmission line, Germany will play a
pioneering role in the design of future energy
transmission systems.
Integration of renewable energy sources in
existing power transmission and distribution
systems challenges Germanys energy transition. The continuation
of overhead power routes sectionwise underground in the form of
a gas-insulated transmission line represents a key piece of the route
planning mosaic, since possible corridors for new overhead lines are
restricted because of existing buildings. Gas-insulated DC lines can
handle the power from an overhead line with the same number
of conductors. This means that the substations and transmission
corridors can be designed to take up less space, which makes them
more cost-efficient.
Use of the DC-GIL also will allow the advantages of gas-insu-
lated transmission technology to be exploited for the new HVDC
multiterminal systems and networks, as well. This would make
the vision of a transmission grid with superimposed DC a reality.
HVDC systems in conjunction with gas-insulated DC transmission
lines routed sectionwise underground are perfectly suited as a key
technology for this.
1505pg_8 8 5/5/15 4:51 PM
May 2015 | 9 www.power-grid.com
Cost Effective Easy to Install
For more information, call 1-877-848-9682
1800 Shames Drive, Westbury, NY 11590 electroind.com
Automation begins with Power Meters
The Heart of Any Automation Solution
SHARK 2OO
Go to pgi.hotims.com for more information.
C
AN
ST
OC
K P
HO
TO
IN
C.
/ Z
HU
ZH
U
C
AN
ST
OC
K P
HO
TO
IN
C.
/ A
LM
AV
IVA
EVESA, the operator responsible for managing the street
light and traffic control systems in Paris, has expanded its
relationship with Silver Spring Networks Inc. to deploy a
citywide canopy network that connects the above-ground
and subterranean cabinet-based controllers for street and
traffic lights across the city, including such iconic neighbor-
hoods as the Louvre, Hotel-de-Ville, Palais-Bourbon, Elysee,
the Bourse and remaining arrondissements, Silver Spring
Networks announced.
With more than 2 million citizens and 16 million annual
visitors, modernizing the public lighting infrastructure for the
city of lights while preserving its world-renowned aesthetic
is a crucial undertaking, said Scott Lang, chairman, pres-
ident and CEO of Silver Spring Networks. We are excited
to now complete the first phase of our project and extend
our relationship with EVESA to deploy a smart city canopy
network across Paris. EVESAs diligent planning and intense
technology testing help ensure the citizens of Paris receive
a globally proven, highly reliable and secure smart city
solution.
Silver Springs smart city platform helps municipalities
deploy intelligent lighting systems that improve system
reliability, increase energy efficiency, lower operational costs,
extend equipment life spans and enhance citizen safety
and quality of life. The open, standards-based solution also
enables cities to establish a platform for future smart city
applications and services such as traffic management, envi-
ronmental sensors, smart parking, electric vehicle charging,
Silver Spring Networks wins comprehensive smart city deployment in Paris
electricity metering, water conservation and
many others.
In addition to Paris, Silver Spring recently
has been selected by Florida Power & Light
for what is believed to be the worlds largest
connected lighting project with nearly 500,000
networked street lights across South Florida.
Silver Spring also is connecting critical infra-
structure in Bristol, Chicago, Copenhagen,
Glasgow, Melbourne, Miami, Sao Paulo, San
Francisco, Singapore and Washington, D.C.,
and has delivered more than 20 million IPv6-
networked devices for critical infrastructure
networks on five continents.
1505pg_9 9 5/5/15 4:51 PM
10 | May 2015www.power-grid.com
NOTES
CAN STOCK PHOTO INC. / ARNAU2098
EYE ON THE WORLD : CONTINUED
Swiss battery manufacturer Leclanch will play a key role in the
renewable energy project being developed in Graciosa by Younicos,
a German-American specialist in renewable energy integration.
Leclanch will provide the complete Battery Energy
Storage Solution (BESS), using its industry-leading lithium-ion
batteries, which will be combined with Younicos Energy
Management software. In addition, an affiliate of Recharge
ApS, one of Leclanchs largest shareholders, will provide 3.5
million euros in convertible debt financing to the projects
operating company Graciolica, a wholly-owned subsidiary of
Younicos. Both announcements are milestones that will help
accelerate implementation of the project in the coming weeks
and will ensure substantial progress during 2015.
The worlds first megawatt-scale renewable energy plus
storage system, being built on the island of Graciosa in the
Azores (Portugal), will set new standards for islands worldwide.
Furthermore, by stabilizing the grid without the rotating mass of
a conventional thermal engine, the system will enable the grid to
be fully powered by wind and solar energy. The centerpiece of the
system is a fully automated, intelligently managed 2.8-MW battery
Leclanch joins Younicos in delivering renewable energy-powered microgrid to Graciosa
park integrated into the intelli-
gent energy management system
developed by Younicos. In addition,
the system will incorporate wind
(4.5 MW) and solar (1 MW) power
resources and intelligent inverters.
The renewable energy-powered
grid will boost the islands annual
share of renewable energies from
a previous limit of 15 percent to
up to 65 percent and allow the island to reduce its dependence
on fuel imports.
This is an exciting partnership on many levels, said James
P. McDougall, CEO of Younicos. We have long been intrigued
by Leclanchs BESS and are confident that, coupled with our
software, it will provide an extremely stable backbone of a funda-
mentally new energy system. At the same time, working with an
industry-leading battery manufacturer such as Leclanch, and with
Recharge as financing partner, underscores the ability of Younicos
to lead microgrid projects worldwide.
LINCOLN ELECTRIC SYSTEM EXPANDS ITRON CONTRACT TO COMPLETE METER REPLACEMENT
Lincoln Electric System (LES), a
publicly owned, municipal electric util-
ity that serves some 135,000 custom-
ers in and around Lincoln, Nebraska,
recently expanded its contract with
Itron to continue installation of auto-
mated meter reading (AMR) technolo-
gy across the remainder of its service
territory, Itron announced.
Itrons technology is an import-
ant component of our Mobile Meter
Reading Project and is enabling LES to
streamline its meter-reading process,
achieve system efficiencies and address
business priorities, said Lisa Hale,
vice president of customer services
at LES. LES will use Itrons solution
with mobile collectors to improve day-
to-day meter-reading operations and
reduce vehicle trips to the field.
As part of the contract, Itron distribu-
tor the Dutton-Lainson Co. in Hastings,
Nebraska, will provide LES with more
than 100,000 Itron electricity meters
during the next 12 to 18 months.
C
AN
ST
OC
K P
HO
TO
IN
C.
/ Y
UR
KA
IMM
OR
TA
L
1505pg_10 10 5/5/15 4:51 PM
New Generation of Outdoor
Sensing Solutions
Pole Mount Transformer MonitoringOverhead/Underground Fault MonitoringRemote Terminal Unit of Distributed systemSub-Metering & Monitoring Accurate MeasurementESS(Energy Storage System)Building Energy Management System(BEMS)Factory Energy Management System(FEMS)Digital Fault Recorder for Power & Sub-stationElectrical Vehicle(EV) & EV Charging Station
Tel: 847.299.5182 Fax: 847.965.3336
www.taehwatrans.com
Pole-Proble Rogowski Coil Outdoor Split-Core CT Clamp-on Rogowski Coil
Flexible Rogowski Coil Outdoor Solid typed CT
with voltage measurement
Split Core CT
Go to pgi.hotims.com for more information.
The Industrial Energy Consumers of
America (IECA) congratulates CalPortland,
Eastman Chemical Co. and Saint-Gobain
for receiving the 2015 Energy Star Partner
of the Year-Sustained Excellence Award
and Bristol-Myers Squibb and Corning Inc.
for receiving the 2015 Energy Star Partner
of the Year Award for their voluntary pub-
lic-private partnership work to manage
and improve energy efficiency.
This is an outstanding accomplishment
that few companies achieve and says a lot
about leadership and the relentless com-
mitment in pursuit of energy efficiency
improvement that benefits competitiveness
and the environment, said Paul Cicio,
president of IECA.
BRISTOL-MYERS SQUIBB
The Energy Star program helps compa-
nies actively assess their energy programs
and obtain graded feedback from the EPA
on several different categories of energy
management, said Carol Powell, global
head and vice president of environment,
health, safety and sustainability. In select-
ing us for this recognition, the EPA and
DOE considered not only the companys
measurable energy savings but also the
effectiveness of its overall energy man-
agement program, including policies and
management support. We gain tremen-
dous value from benchmarking and collab-
orating on best practices and energy strat-
egy both within our industry and across
industries, including through the Energy
Star Pharmaceutical Focus Group, which
includes more than 15 peer companies.
CALPORTLAND
CalPortland has been an Energy Star
partner since 1996, said Allen Hamblen,
president and CEO of CalPortland. For
nearly two decades, that relationship
has been instrumental in the continuous
improvement of our energy program. We
BRISTOL-MYERS SQUIBB, CALPORTLAND, CORNING INC., EASTMAN CHEMICAL CO., SAINT-GOBAIN WIN EPA ENERGY STAR PARTNER OF THE YEAR AWARDS
have established a core culture of energy
management that includes all levels of the
companys operations. Our employees are
very proud of their accomplishments to
improve energy efficiency, reduce emis-
sions and contribute to the protection of
our environment while reducing cost.
CORNING INC.
Were honored to be named an Energy
Star Partner of the Year for the second
consecutive year, said Wendell P. Weeks,
chairman and CEO of Corning. We com-
mitted ourselves to ongoing improve-
ments, and this award demonstrates that
we are making terrific progress in our
energy journey. This is also a great example
of how we can do well by doing good.
Responsible energy management helps us
maintain the trust of our stakeholders, con-
trol costs and compete more effectively in a
global economy. In other
words, we are investing
in Cornings future as
well as the health of our
planet.
EASTMAN
CHEMICAL CO.
It is an honor to be
recognized once again by
the EPA with the Energy
Star Partner of the Year-
Sustained Excellence
Award, said Mark Costa,
chairman and CEO of
Eastman. This achieve-
ment is a testament to
the hard work and com-
mitment of the men and
women at Eastman who
continue to chart new
territory for our industry
in sustainability. I could
not be more proud of
our worldwide energy
team and deeply appreciate the tremen-
dous effort required throughout the com-
pany to drive improvements and achieve
this recognition.
SAINT-GOBAIN
Saint-Gobains 350-year history is root-
ed in the innovation and manufacturing
of building materials that enable people
across the globe to live in more efficient,
comfortable and healthy environments,
said John Crowe, president and CEO of
Saint-Gobain and its North American con-
struction materials subsidiary, CertainTeed
Corp. As Saint-Gobain looks to the future,
we believe that a sustainable habitat is with-
in our reach and will continue to develop
innovative, effective methods to reduce the
environmental impact of our solutions,
plants and processes across our entire fam-
ily of companies in North America.
C
AN
ST
OC
K P
HO
TO
IN
C.
/ Y
UR
KA
IMM
OR
TA
L
1505pg_11 11 5/5/15 4:51 PM
12 | May 2015www.power-grid.com
CAN STOCK PHOTO INC. / FASTFUN23
1505pg_12 12 5/5/15 4:55 PM
May 2015 | 13 www.power-grid.com
Your Physical Security System is Missing a Crucial Element
BY BERT WILLIAMS, ABB WIRELESS
During the past two years, dozens of attacks have been reportedincluding trespassing, vandalism, theft
and sabotageon critical utility infra-
structure in the U.S. that posed dangers
to life, property, reliable grid operation
and utility worker safety.
These attacks included shooting at a
security guard, crippling a substations
service for a month and a complete power
outage that affected 10,000 customers.
This is serious busi-
ness. Utilities are los-
ing millions of dol-
lars from assaults on
substations and other
critical utility infra-
structure. Equipment
damage, material and
equipment theft, as
well as fines and lost
revenue from power outages, are affect-
ing utility reliability and safety.
Physical security can be a signifi-
cant factor in minimizing or deterring
Bert Williams is global marketing director
for ABB Wireless. He brings 30 years of
experience in leading the marketing
organizations of networking companies.
Williams has a Bachelor of Science with
University Honors in Electrical Engineering
from Carnegie Mellon University and an
MBA from Harvard Business School. Reach
him at [email protected].
Utilities are losing millions of dollars from assaults on substations and other critical infrastructure.
1505pg_13 13 5/5/15 4:55 PM
14 | May 2015www.power-grid.com
to respond to verified incidents.
IS A WIRELESS
NETWORK RELIABLE?
Physical hardening, battery backup,
IEEE 1613 compliance, etc., are standard
reliability features of todays wireless net-
works; however, access to radio frequen-
cy (RF) spectrum, automatic interference
avoidance software and mesh routing
software are key elements to assure net-
work reliability.
When wireless networks have more
access to RF spectrum, they have more
available channels to use to avoid interfer-
ence. Additional spectrum also makes it
much more difficult for saboteurs to jam
the wireless communication network.
If the wireless network cant dynam-
ically use the RF spectrum, however,
its of little use. By deploying automatic
interference avoidance software, a wire-
less communication network can find
and use a clean chunk of spectrum in
real time, mitigating interference, whether
from other legitimate spectrum users or
malicious jammers.
threats. Conventional security measures
such as walls, fences and locks are
coupled with surveillance and thermal
imaging and night vision cameras, gun-
shot location sensors, door alarms, key-
pads and biometrics for access control,
motion detectors and intrusion sen-
sors. This 24/7 centralized monitoring
provides early awareness and visibility
into incidents, enabling timely utility
response.
MODERN WIRELESS NETWORKS
VITAL SECURITY TOOL
Multi-application communications
among security devices (cameras,
sensors, keypads, lights, etc.) require
reliable, secure, broadband networks.
Wireless networks offer many
advantages over wired networks and
are preferred by utilities because they
are much easier and more cost-effective
to deploy in substations; they require
no trenching.
Its vital to consult multiple systems to
determine how a security breach might
have occurred. One example is to use
streaming or captured video to confirm
what triggered a substation motion sen-
sor. This approach enables utility secu-
rity employees to screen for and ignore
false alarms. It also better equips them
to dispatch the correct personnel (e.g.,
security, maintenance, police, fire, EMS)
Mesh Networks Enhance Substation Communication Resiliency
An advantage of using wireless mesh networks for substation physical
security system communication is that mesh networks can maintain
connectivity with a substation even if the landline and point-to-point/
point-to-multipoint (PTP/PTMP) wireless links to the substation have
been disabled. Figure 1 shows a mesh network that covers part of a utility
service territory served by three substations. At each substation, landline,
PTP/PTMP or both wireless links provide backhaul to the mesh network,
as well as connectivity for other data and voice services.
Figure 2 shows that if the landline and PTP/PTMP wireless links
are disabled by cutting wires, shooting equipment, etc., the mesh
automatically will reconfigure to provide connectivity to the substation
under attack via backhaul points in other substations.
NORMAL OPERATIONS SUBSTATION FRONTHAUL 1
Wired Backhaul
Optimal Routing Paths
Backup Links
1505pg_14 14 5/5/15 4:55 PM
May 2015 | 15 www.power-grid.com
of bandwidth, added together, the band-
width can be substantial.
CAN IT SUPPORT ALL OF YOUR
SECURITY APPLICATIONS?
Another consideration when operat-
ing multiple substation physical secu-
rity applications on a single wireless
communication network is support for
virtual LANs (VLANs) and quality of
service (QoS). With VLANs, each appli-
cation gets its own logical network
that is configured with appropriate
security and QoS settings. Using QoS
and VLANS, a utility can, for example,
ensure that latency-sensitive applica-
tions get priority over applications with
less stringent latency requirements.
BEING PROACTIVE
CAN THWART ATTACKS
Many benefits come with deploying
and operating network-enabled remote
physical security monitoring, from pro-
viding an audit trail of authorized per-
sonnel entering and exiting the facility to
substation motion sensor trips. Remote
video monitoring quickly can determine
if an intruder set off a motion sensor or if
it was just a curious animal. Having real-
time intelligence allows personnel to be
dispatched for only serious alarms. Also,
quick, appropriate response to physical
attacks, coupled with audible alarms and
warning lights, can cause attackers to flee
before they are able to vandalize, steal or
damage property at substations. If they do
stick around, archived video evidence can
aid in the apprehension and prosecution of
perpetrators.
The best attack is the one that doesnt
happen. If potential thieves and sabo-
teurs are aware that a facility is well-se-
cured, they likely will give up and move
along.
Mesh networking provides another level
or building block to thwart attacks quick-
ly. Mesh routing software enables wireless
communication networks
to be self-healing, enabling
fast recovery from equip-
ment failure and damage.
Mesh routing can restore
connectivity even if sab-
oteurs cut fiber-optic and
copper cables at the sub-
station. Because mesh
routers are small and easily
disguised, they are more difficult for sab-
oteurs to take out than wireless point-
to-point (PTP) or point-to-multipoint
(PTMP) systems, which generally must be
mounted on a mast or tower.
BUT ARE THEY SECURE?
Physical security and cybersecurity
are interdependent. Physically break-
ing into a substation is an easy way
to launch a cyberattack. Conversely,
a cyberattack can support a physical
attack by taking remotely monitored
security systems offline.
Wireless communication networks,
like all networks in
substations, come
with potential vul-
nerability to cyber-
attacks. Deploying a
multilayer, defense-
in-depth securi-
ty architecture that
extends all the way
to the networks edge
can mitigate vulnerabilities.
WHAT ABOUT PERFORMANCE?
Its all about broadband. Critical security
applications such as video surveillance and
thermal imaging are bandwidth-intensive
and require high resolution and frame rates
for optimal display. In addition, broadband
is required for supporting physical secu-
rity applications at multiple substations
concurrently. Although individual security
applications might not take large amounts
FAILED OPERATIONS AT SUBSTATION BACKHAUL 2
Wired Backhaul
Optimal Routing Paths
Backup Links
If all backhaul to a substation fails, the mesh network automatically reconfigures touse backhaul at other substations.
Wireless communication networks, like all networks in substations, come with potential vulnerability to cyberattacks.
1505pg_15 15 5/5/15 4:55 PM
16 | May 2015www.power-grid.com
(IT)-OT perimeter, whether direct
employees or third-party workers,
could be assumed as trusted and
not be subject to as much auditing as
traffic coming from, say, the business
network. But many threats originate
from within, so a zero-trust approach
involving micro-segmentation of the
OT network and the mindset that no
networks can be assumed safe must
be employed. Surely there is a point
where there could be over-segmen-
tation, for example, creating security
zones for each engineering worksta-
tion in the development environment
where all employees are internal,
but often OT networks are closer
to being too flat vs. having enough
points of segregation and inspection.
VPNs help provide authentication and
encryption for the allowed insiders
and segment off the outside world;
however, VPNs do not guarantee the
security of the traffic carried within
the private tunnel. Organizations also
One of the most inter-esting talks during
DistribuTECH Conference &
Exhibition was a case study involv-
ing sensitive data exfiltration from the
operational technology (OT) environment
of a North American electric utility.
We often hear about the dangers of a
cyberattacks taking down the grid, but sel-
dom is public information available about
the loss of sensitive information, particular-
ly from the OT. The confidential informa-
tion in this case was the utilitys smart grid
and metering R&D knowledge base, which
is intellectual property and information
that attackers can use to compromise the
smart grid.
The utility was short on engineers, so it
hired third-party resources from East Asia
to augment its work force. These supple-
mentary employees were segregated in
an off-premises enclave that had a virtual
private network (VPN) connection into the
operational network where the main R&D
was conducted.
One day, the utility noticed computers
in the OT randomly were sending unusual
traffic to the network. This activity contin-
ued for months, and based on its initial
analysis, the utility concluded it was in the
midst of a targeted attack by an advanced
persistent threat (APT). There was a grow-
ing suspicion that the third-party workers
had something to do with it, but no hard
evidence supported this belief.
The utility employed a range of security
devices to gather forensics information
over months. Eventually, and consistent
with suspicions, the traffic was traced back
to the third-party enclave. A 4-G puck
was found that the spies used to transmit
sensitive information back to the Far East.
These actors were caught, but only after the
loss of confidential data and a lot of time
and resources were expended on forensics.
Analysis shows that the attackers were
exploiting open ports and using a legacy
high-speed token ring protocol, encapsu-
lated in Internet Protocol, as a means for
stealthy communications. We dont know
all the details and cant make full conclu-
sions, but lets look at some best practices
and technologies that possibly could have
prevented or at least mitigated this event:
1. A zero-trust model must always
be in force. Organizations that
operate critical infrastructure often
focus on defending against exter-
nal, Internet-borne threats. Insiders
behind the information technology
What We Learned From a Data Exfiltration Incident at an Electric Utility
BY DEL RODILLAS, PALO ALTO NETWORKS
C
AN
ST
OC
K P
HO
TO
IN
C.
/ Y
UP
IRA
MO
S
1505pg_16 16 5/5/15 4:55 PM
May 2015 | 17 www.power-grid.com
might have helped stop this attack is
the content inspection technology, or
Content-ID. The classification engine
looks at applications, users and the
payload of the traffic. All three param-
eters are inspected in parallel to ensure
high performance, low latency and
shared context. Content-ID enables
users to implement policies that
reduce the risks associated with the
transfer of unauthorized files and data.
The latest version of NERC CIP stan-
dards includes CIP-011-1 Information
Protection, whose purpose is to
prevent unauthorized access to BES
Cyber System Information by speci-
fying information protection require-
ments in support of protecting BES
Cyber Systems against compromise
that could lead to misoperation or
instability in the BES. The capability
to inspect and control content at the
detailed level will be helpful in being
able to address the requirements with-
in CIP-011-1.
One thing that wasnt covered in the
DistribuTECH session or that I might
have missed is the role of malware and
exploits in this breach. If exploits and mal-
ware were part of the attack, cloud-based
threat intelligence can stop known and
unknown threats that traverse the network,
and Advanced Endpoint Prevention tech-
nology stops threats at endpoints such as
HMIs, automation servers and engineering
workstations. Access control reduces the
attack vectors, but utilities need threat
prevention to stop malicious traffic that
might have gotten into the control systems
over valid traffic or directly at endpoints via
removable media.
need to put points of inspection and
access control to even the traffic that
traverses a VPN connection as part of
a zero-trust approach.
2. Application-layer visibility is
no longer just a nice-to-have.
Stateful-inspection firewalls that pro-
vide visibility and access control sim-
ply at the port level remain com-
mon in many industrial automation
environments; however, as this and
other high-profile APT attacks such
as Havex and Stuxnet have shown,
attackers are exploiting applications
and even industrial control proto-
cols in several ways from gaining
the initial foothold into organizations,
establishing command and control
infrastructure and communications,
payload propagation, to data exfil-
tration. Application visibility, which
is a core value proposition of our
enterprise security platform, is crucial
for being able to definitively identify
network traffic. Any traffic that is not
positively identified will show up as
unknown TCP or unknown UPD and
must be analyzed further to assess its
validity.
3. Reduce the attack surface
by controlling applications.
One point that was repeated often
during the DistribuTECH cybersecu-
rity track is that compliance to the
North American Electric Reliability
Corp. (NERC) critical infrastructure
protection (CIP) standard is a good
baseline posture but doesnt guar-
antee security. NERC CIP mandates
the creation of electronic security
perimeters (ESPs) where inbound
and outbound access permissions are
enforced, denying all other access by
default. This enforcement is simply at
the port and service level; however, as
was the case with this attack, todays
advanced attacker likely will know
which ports are open and stealthily
exploit this open vector to conduct
his or her attack. The attack foot-
print would be reduced dramatically
if traffic could be constrained at the
application level vs. just the port level.
The custom application used by the
attacker likely would have shown up
as unknown TCP or UDP and stood
out as an anomaly vs. the positive-
ly identified applications. As men-
tioned, such suspicious unknown
traffic should be investigated further
and blocked if deemed malicious.
Sometimes, however, unknown traffic
ends up being valid, as we saw in one
of Palo Alto Networks free application
visibility and risk report (AVR) assess-
ments for a South American utility
that was encapsulating a serial IEC
protocol in TCP/IP. A useful feature
of our next-generation firewall is the
ability to create custom application
signatures. This capability can be used
to conclusively identify custom appli-
cation traffic then apply policy to pos-
itively allow this traffic. In that case,
the utility created a custom App-ID to
ensure it was able to identify this valid
application vs. being left to guess.
In addition to whitelisting protocols
and applications, an additional layer
of segmentation based on user or
user group could be applied to fur-
ther reduce the attack footprint. This
concept of role-based access con-
trol is a critical concept that can be
implemented on Palo Alto Networks
next-generation firewalls using User-
ID technology.
4. Implement content inspection/
blocking for sensitive data and
file types. Another capability that
Del Rodillas is senior security manager,
SCADA and industrial control systems, at Palo
Alto Networks.
1505pg_17 17 5/5/15 4:55 PM
18 | May 2015www.power-grid.com
We live in a world ripe with tech-
nological advancements that
make our lives better, or at least more
efficient. With many applications being
used by millions of people every day
comes an immense amount of data. And
although the free collection and dissem-
ination of data might be the norm in
many industries, in the energy industry
its a topic that is growing in complexity
by the year.
THE CURRENT STATE
OF AMI DEPLOYMENT
There are nearly 50 million smart
meters deployed across the U.S. and
millions more worldwide, according to
the Edison Foundation. This gives util-
ities and energy retailers access to a tre-
mendous amount of customer data
and includes a number we can
expect to grow. Thirty of the
largest U.S. utilities have
deployed smart meters
to their customers, according to the
Institute for Electric Innovation (IEI).
And global penetration is expected to
reach 800 million installed smart meters
by 2020, according to Telefonica.
The bulk of smart meter deployment
Who Owns the
BY KEVIN TATE, ENERNOC
1505pg_18 18 5/5/15 4:55 PM
May 2015 | 19 www.power-grid.com
CAN STOCK PHOTO INC. / SIELEMANN
Kevin Tate leads EnerNOCs Utility Solutions
Product Development team. He has been
in the software industry more than 30
years and has extensive experience in
UX, agile methods and the development
of energy solutions for utilities, computer
networks, operating systems, 3-D graphics
and computer animation.
Utilities are getting better at communicating with their C&I customers.
is focused on residential; however, utili-
ties are ramping up deployment to their
business customers to provide better
insight and value-added service to their
heavy energy-consuming customers. In
the U.S. alone, smart meters have been
deployed to 4.6 million commercial and
industrial (C&I) customers, according to
the Energy Information Administration.
This represents only 11 percent of
the total deployment, but these smart
meters serve nearly 340 million mega-
watt-hours (MWh), making up 49
percent of all energy served by total
advanced metering infrastructure (AMI)
installs.
INCREASING ROI WITH
CUSTOMER ENGAGEMENT
With these extensive deployments
comes a high cost. Total capital costs
per meter, including
installation, range from
$81 to $532, according
to Siemens, and when
multiplied by a million
or so meters, costs
quickly inflate. One
way utilities are accelerating their
smart meter ROI is by using the AMI
data to deliver shared utility-customer
value, particularly for C&I customers.
JD Power announced in January that
electric utilities have achieved the high-
est level of business customer satisfac-
tion since 2009.
When a utility highly satisfies its cus-
tomer base, there is a quantifiable pos-
itive impact on profitability and credit
ratings for the utility, according to JD
Power.
One way utilities can delight custom-
ers is by improving communications, a
tactic enhanced by the insights utilities
can draw from their customer data,
accessed through smart meters.
Consider these stats that show
improvement in utility communications
to C&I customers: Overall communi-
cations satisfaction among customers
who recall receiving a communication
from their utility is 74 points higher
than among those who do not recall
any communication. And the percent-
age of business customers recalling a
communication from their utility has
increased to 55 percent in 2015 from 51
percent in 2014, according to JD Power,
demonstrating that utilities are getting
better at communicating with their C&I
customers.
Having access to the AMI data that
can help utilities better engage their
customers is a great place to start,
but many utilities struggle to use data
in new, different and innovative ways.
Building customer rela-
tionships and improv-
ing satisfaction rates can
be challenging without
an obvious starting
point, and many utili-
ties reach out to third
parties such as EnerNOC to help them
make the most of their data.
CYBERSECURITY
IN THE 21ST CENTURY
Although the improved utility access
to customer data can mean only good
things for the evolving customer experi-
ence, utilities and third-party providers
still have a responsibility to protect
sensitive customer information. In our
daily lives, we tend to be more relaxed
about others having access to our data,
with many of us freely sharing our infor-
mation on Google or Facebook without
understanding the implications.
1505pg_19 19 5/5/15 4:55 PM
20 | May 2015www.power-grid.com
without access to good, clean customer
data, utilities cant perform on-demand
analyses that help add value for their
customers.
In other instances, energy retailers
face issues in open markets where they
have access to customer data but are
restricted from using it for what could
be construed as marketing purposes
because it might offer them a competi-
tive advantage.
Educating customers is an important
step here and will help reinforce the
message that their utilities are trusted
energy advisors.
HOW ENERGY INTELLIGENCE
SOFTWARE COMPANIES HELP
BRIDGE THE GAP
EnerNOC works with utilities to help
them achieve all of their C&I demand-
side goals, from customer engage-
ment and energy efficiency to demand
response and operational effectiveness,
with energy intelligence software.
Both utilities and third parties should
protect customer data by following
industry best practices in security
such as using demilitarized zones, data
encryption and privacy by design prac-
tices to prevent infractions.
Whether implementing an existing
third-party system or starting anew
with an internal system, utilities must
remember that data security can help
avoid potential issues.
Although the 100 percent breach-
proof system might be the result of
wishful thinking, utilities and third
parties can make it much more dif-
ficult to obtain data when a breach
occurs through simple practices such as
encryption and data separation, protect-
ing customer data and avoiding major
issues.
We desire to share, and definite value
exists in sharingour Internet experience
is that much richer and more tailored
because we share our data with Google
and othersbut what works for social
media doesnt work for the energy industry.
Customers expect their utilities to deliver
on three critical items: reliable energy, low
prices and emergency communications,
according to E Source. To achieve these
three deliverables, grid security is essential.
Regulators continue to beef up securi-
ty rules. The Federal Energy Regulatory
Commission is working with the North
American Electric Reliability Corp. to
determine how to best
protect essential sub-
stations and facilities
critical to the opera-
tion of the electric
grid, according to
Security Magazine.
Not unique to North America, grid
security is a global issue. The grid is
critical infrastructure no matter where
in the world we are, and a massive
security breach that causes a wide-scale
blackout would devastate the economy.
Security breaches have occurred, and we
can expect them to occur again. Last year
researchers demonstrated Nest thermostat
vulnerabilities, and the Department of
Homeland Security confirmed a brute
force attack had occurred on a public
U.S. utility. No harm was done in either
instance once access was acquired, but it
is a sobering reminder that threats occur,
and we must be prepared for them.
HOW UTILITIES ARE APPROACHING
THE OPPORTUNITY
Security focuses on where the data is
stored and how it is transmitted.
Whether the data is hosted by the
utility or a third party, its ideal to keep
data in the same country from where it
was sourced to avoid legislative barriers
surrounding privacy laws.
The way data is transmitted also is
important. When files are sent from one
server to another, encryption is crucial,
as is only transmitting essential data
(avoiding credit card information or
other tempting data sets) to avoid disas-
ter should a breach occur.
Some utilities around the world are
building their own systems to host and
analyze energy data, but many others
are outsourcing to third parties that
have expertise in the area.
Working with a
third party is becom-
ing more popular as
utilities become more
open to using cloud-
based solutions, which
move away from bulk-
ier, more complicated desktop software.
This is often a favorable solution
when different software applications
dont play nicely with others. Solutions
that easily are integrated into legacy
systems ease the burden on a utilitys
information technology team and enable
greater visibility into data across the
organization, crossing silos and internal
barriers.
Where some utilities encounter prob-
lems, however, is in the disconnect
between what they can deliver and what
customers assume they can deliver.
In the Internet of Things, especially
when smart meters are involved, cus-
tomers expect that utilities can access
and analyze their data on demand,
which frequently is far from reality.
Challenges also arise when utilities
dont have good customer databilling
address, floor area, operating hours,
etc.at the outset. Energy data aside,
Grid security is critical for reliable energy, low prices and emergency communications.
1505pg_20 20 5/5/15 4:55 PM
May 2015 | 21 www.power-grid.com
careful, measured approach to rolling
out new technology and an intense reli-
ance on proven methods.
CONSUMER TECH AND UTILITIES
This reliance on proven methods
might fuel the adoption of consum-
er-driven technologies. Take, for exam-
ple, a recent consumer technology
disruption in the geospatial industry:
C onsumer-driven technologies are influencing the development of enterprise hardware and software,
enterprise information technology (IT)
operations and how enterprises conduct
business internally and externally.
Historically, government research
and large enterprises drove technology
innovation, which then trickled into
the consumer market. During the past
decade, a profound shift in this phe-
nomenon has occurred largely because
of the proliferation of smart devices and
omnipresence of Internet access. This
trend is weaving its way into the utility
sector as we see some utilities begin
to adopt consumer-driven innovations.
They see the benefits: significantly
enhanced asset management, proven
compliance, improved safety and more
reliable service to their customers.
Utilities typically have lagged behind
in rolling out new technology solu-
tions compared with other industries
because they provide services critical
to daily life. Service disruption must
be minimized. In addition to pure crit-
icality, utilities face several operational
challenges depending on the areas they
serve. For instance, large amounts of
geographically dispersed infrastructure
typically require manual labor to inspect
and maintain. Combine this with con-
stantly changing demand, increasing
environmental volatility and aging infra-
structure, and the challenge to maintain
safe, reliable service becomes more dif-
ficult. These challenges mean a more
The Benefits, Challenges of Integrating Consumer-driven Technology Into Utilities
BY JAY CADMAN, UBISENSE
Jay Cadman is vice president of industry
marketing for utilities and telecommunications
for Ubisense, a global location intelligence
systems company. He has more than 20
years of sales and marketing experience
in the location intelligence sector, having
worked at Smallworld and GE Network
Solutions before joining Ubisense in 2003.
Reach him at [email protected].
With access to enterprise data in a simple mashup tool on a smart device, field personnel can quickly communicate what they see with those who need to know.
1505pg_21 21 5/5/15 4:55 PM
22 | May 2015www.power-grid.com
Body copyGoogle Maps and the subsequent release of associated products such as
Google Street View and Google Traffic.
The ease of use and availability of
this data has created many time-saving
advantages for utilities. For example,
gaining the ability to see satellite imag-
ery of a site and investigate assets using
Google Street View prior to an on-site
visit can reduce the number of site vis-
its for repair. Efficiency gains multiply
exponentially when these types of con-
sumer-based technologies can be inte-
grated into daily operations and with
enterprise data such as the geographic
information system (GIS), outage man-
agement system (OMS) and work man-
agement system (WMS).
Then there are the advances in mobile
hardware and software, which are driving
the use of smart devices in the field. For
many years, field-based technology meant
mounting a laptop inside a truck and
transporting an office environment around
in the field. That was game-changing at the
time, but it did not replace most traditional
paper-based processes because functional-
ity was limited and data in the field was, for
the most part, read-only. Now utility field
crews can employ smart phones and tab-
lets with integrated GPS and cameras and
log specific location-based data that is tied
directly to back-office systems, all in near
real time, thanks to the wide availability of
network connectivity. This sophistication
means a huge shift in how utilities can
manage their operations.
USABILITY: SIMPLE BEATS
FUNCTIONALITY
Utility employees have become
tech-savvy users, thanks to the sim-
ple, easy-to-use technology available to
them everywhere, and they are bringing
their expectations to work. They expect
applications and solutions to be simple
and efficient. IT is working to comply
with this expectation to foster compa-
nywide adoption.
Leading utilities are looking at new
Web mash-up tools to fulfill applica-
tion requirements in a rapidly changing
technology environment with a new
user base. These tools use lightweight
integrations, combining different types
of data into actionable
information for users to
make rapid decisions
(think current outages
overlaid on GIS data with
a Google Maps base map
showing crew locations
and live radar). The enter-
prise systems still do all
the heavy lifting of man-
aging complex business
rules and data integrity, but casual users
neither know nor care what happens on
the back end; all they get is exactly what
they need: the information, in a simple,
familiar interface. They dont have to
learn myriad disparate, complex enter-
prise system interfaces; they only need
and use the Web mash-up.
These Web mash-ups have an added
benefit of presenting as different apps to
answer a specific question rather than a
single, powerful interface that can answer
any question posed. In this way, the apps
evolve to meet the needs of the types of
users, but its all the same tool. This focused
way of developing interfaces creates great-
er user acceptance and follows the same
model as modern consumer applications
that people use every day.
EXAMPLE: AN ACCIDENT
AND A MASH-UP
A utility receives a call from a police
department that a pole has been
knocked down in an auto accident.
Using a smartphone, the police can
send a georeferenced photo of the sit-
uation to the utility so it can view and
assess the damage quickly. The utility
restoration team responds; they see a
pin appear on their Google Maps base
map, which is linked to that photo.
Because they have integrated GIS data
with Google Maps, they can select the
pole and see it is record-
ed as a 45-foot class 4
pole that was installed in
1997.
When they check
Google Street View to
confirm this is the same
pole, they notice there
are cable and telephone
attachments on the pole,
so they send a link to the
field supervisor. She is in the field but
receives the link on her smartphone.
She can click that link and see what
they see: the map, pole data, location
information and photo from the field.
She calls the appropriate telephone and
cable companies, streamlining an effi-
cient restoration effort.
The restoration team also notices that
the pole is located on a busy street. They
use this information and other images they
have received to record an estimated time
for restoration (ETR), which is higher than
their average restoration time. That ETR is
entered into a Web mash-up form, which
goes to the OMS because that, too, has
been integrated.
The customer service center
automatically receives the list of
customers from the OMS with
the ETR and begins to call, text or
email customers based on their
communication preferences. Customers
are kept informed proactively.
Leading utilities are looking at new Web mash-up tools to fulfll application requirements.
1505pg_22 22 5/5/15 4:55 PM
May 2015 | 23 www.power-grid.com
CEOs of the Year and Projects of the Year will be recognized in Electric Light & Power and
POWERGRID International magazines, at North Americas largest annual T&D event,
DistribuTECH, and at the Electric Light & Power Executive Conference.
Visit www.distributech.com to submit your nominations! DEADLINE: SEPTEMBER 15, 2015
NOW ACCEPTING NOMINATIONS FOR:
CEOs OF THE YEAR AND PROJECTS OF THE YEAR
CEO of the Year awards will be given in two categories:
Small Utility CEO of the Year (fewer than 400,000 customers)
Large Utility CEO of the Year (400,000 customers or more)
Projects of the Year will be awarded in the following categories:
Smart Grid Renewable Grid Integration
Demand Response / Energy Ef ciency Customer Engagement
Go to pgi.hotims.com for more information.
In the meantime, the dispatch center locates on the
map the crew in the field closest to the site and that
has the necessary equipment to make the repairs. (All
crews have GPS-enabled devices so their locations can
be determined easily.) The assigned field crew receives
all of the available information including the photos of
the scene and the links to the asset location, all accessed
on their smart devices. And because the accident has
caused significant traffic congestion, the crew uses the
real-time traffic feed in Google Maps within the mash-up
to determine the optimum driving route to the scene.
EXAMPLE: EFFICIENT
DAMAGE ASSESSMENT
A storm has passed through and the power is out in
hard-hit areas. Damage assessors are deployed to gauge
the scope of the damage so crews can be dispatched and
power can be restored. Their marching orders are deliv-
ered by the storm center directly to their smart devices,
assigned based on proximity and with the route already
determined based on current traffic conditions.
As assessment points are completed, the details are
transmitted back to the storm center where information
is displayed as soon as it is received. All the while, the
assessors are watching real-time weather patterns to
make informed judgments in the field about how to
manage their progress safely.
Decision-makers in the storm center see data aggre-
gating, the number of customers affected and the pattern
of the damage. Crews are dispatched accordingly, and
this one appears manageable; they wont need mutual
assistance this time.
SUMMARY
With the increasing ubiquity of real-time data com-
munications, smart devices and cloud-based data (such
as Google Maps, live traffic and real-time weather) and
the power of simple Web mash-up tools, it is easier than
ever to integrate disparate, complex enterprise systems
and drive efficiencies in day-to-day operations. More
utilities should consider how their existing systems must
evolve to leverage proven, consumer-based innovations
as a way to optimize their service performance, improve
safety measures, meet compliance and provide better
customer service.
1505pg_23 23 5/5/15 4:55 PM
24 | May 2015www.power-grid.com24 | May 2015www.power-grid.com
response exists today; not as a custom-
er-reactive program, but as a coordinated
virtual power plant (VPP). This VPP pro-
vides portfolio management capability that
stratifies resources according to energy
characteristics, thus giving the dispatcher
all the buttons to press for reliability, econ-
omy, safety and environmental impact. As
utilities break apart silos, demand response
becomes the generic name for the discipline
of managing control center to customer.
As technology advances, so do the busi-
ness processes that depend on it. Demand
response has become active load man-
agement. Just as demand response before
it, active load management has distinct
applications.
Closest to home and most appealing
is volt-VAR control (V-VC) and its off-
shoot, conservation voltage reduc-
tion. Utilities can use these tools,
which have the same impact
Large, rotating masses are the unsung
heroes of reliability on the electric grid.
Loads come and go, but our Newtonian
friends, Momentum and Inertia, make
order from chaos. They provide precious
seconds for dispatch to react to large load
excursions while smaller ones disappear as
noise, swallowed by the flywheel effect and
some really smart automated controls.
With the prospect of strong
Environmental Protection Agency action
under section 111(d) of the Clean Air
Act, nuclear issues and renewable sources
growing at an unanticipated rate, Newtons
safety net is crumbling as new power
sources with little to no mass become
significant.
The result? Software is replacing
rotating mass.
Inconveniently, software cannot pro-
duce electrons, so it must use synthetic
equivalents. Key among these is demand
response. Demand response started as a
fairly straightforward method of adding
capacity by inciting many customers to
curtail load when asked. Then it became
a strategy to extend existing energy sourc-
es (energy markets); and lately, demand
response has gained some currency as
spinning reserves and frequency regula-
tion resources (fast demand response)all
fine, but not breakthrough stuff, or even
mainstream, in professional energy circles.
Its even become fashionable to refer to this
just like software (i.e., v1, v2, etc.).
That habit has spread to nearly every
corner: Utility 2.0, Smart Grid 3.0not
the best analogy. As Silicon Valley inves-
tors discovered, advancements have bee