Date post: | 23-Apr-2018 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | truongkhuong |
View: | 224 times |
Download: | 4 times |
Preliminary Information Memorandum – Early Market Sounding for the Proposed Availability PPP Road Project: Salatiga - Solo
9 June 2016, Jakarta
2
Agenda
1) Purpose of this Preliminary/Early Market Sounding Meeting
2) Availability PPPs (AP) used to Deliver Major Roads
3) Key features of AP Contracts
4) Regulations for AP Projects
5) Opportunity: Proposed Pilot AP Road Project
6) Key Project Features
7) Proposed Risk Allocation Matrix
8) Proposed Commercial Structure
9) General Outline of AP Payment Mechanism
10) Market Sounding Questions
3
• Information received from this early market sounding exercise will be used by the GOI to inform the development of a pilot AP road project
• In this context, this PIM does not purport to be all-inclusive or to contain all of the information that a prospective participant may consider material or desirable in making its decision to participate in the tender
• Also, this is not the formal commencement of a bidding process
• This is a high-level presentation…technical detail will be covered later when formal bidding documents are released
Purpose of this preliminary/early market sounding meeting
4
Availability PPP used for delivering major roads
• Canada, United States, Australia, New Zealand, Spain, Portugal, and the United Kingdom use APs to deliver road projects
• The real benefit is emphasizing whole-of-life approach to road delivery, maintenance and performance
• 25 to 30 year concessions, involving design, build, finance, operate & maintain
• Government makes annual payments….private sector agrees to meet specific performance standards
Canada: South Frazer Perimeter Road
Australia: Peninsula Link Road
5
Key Features of AP model versus conventional procurement
Capital cost
estimateDelay
Cost overrun
Maintenance and renewal cost estimate
Cost overrun
Design & Construct
Operating
Pa
ym
en
ts
Conventional
• Payment only starts when project commissioned – constructor and rest of PPP consortium bear construction risk
• Contractor and O&M partners work at the same time, allowing integration of whole of life efficiencies
• Contractor and O&M partners have equity at risk for term of concession – all parties incentivised to perform and take a “long-term” view
• Lenders focus on quality construction to minimise potential downstream loss due to poor performance of an asset
• PPP Consortium responsible for handing over the asset in a fit-for-purpose condition
• Constructor receives payments during construction
• Contractor and O&M partners work at different phases
• Contractor and O&M partners do not have equity at risk
• Inputs-focus, mainly construction phase
• In traditional delivery, contractor not responsible for residual life of asset
No payment until the project is
delivered according to public sector specifications
Availability-based payments
Performance-based payments
Availability PPP
6
The regulations provide that an AP contract shallat minimum include:
Regulations for AP Projects
• an objective and measurable specification andperformance indicators;
• a formula for the calculation of availabilitypayments;
• an effective monitoring system on theperformance indicators; and
• for the payment from the government to thebusiness entity to be initiated upon theinfrastructure having been built and beingready for operation.
7
• The GOI is proposing that the planned expressway roadbetween Salatiga – Solo (approximately 32 kilometres) bedelivered as an Availability PPP project by DGH, through BPJT
Opportunity: Proposed Pilot AP Road Project
• This Salatiga – Solo segment forms part of the proposed 72 kilometre Semarang to Solo national road project
9
Proposed Risk Allocation Matrix: Pilot AP Road Project
Risk Allocation
GOI Private Shared
Design Risk
Construction Risk
Commissioning Risk
Land Acquisition Risk
Site Risk
Demand Risk
Availability & Performance
Risk
Operating Risk
Financing Risk
Default & Termination Risk
Residual Value/Handback
Risk
Legislative Risk
10
Proposed Commercial Structure
Availability payments will be
made from the GCA
(represented by BPJT) to the
Availability PPP
concessionaire. Deductions
will be made for non-
performance.
The GOI, through IIGF, will
provide a guarantee regarding
the payment by the GCA of
availability payments to the
Availability PPP concessionaire
(i.e. project company).
The project company will ensure
there is a minimum debt to
equity structure consistent with
Availability PPP contracts (most
likely 90/10).
The GOI may
implement a
separate tolling
agreement for
the collection of
tolls.
11
Project Status
• The pilot AP road project is currently at the PPP Preparation Stage
• An OBC is in progress, with view to seeking approval by the 3rd Qtr 2016
12
Availability Payments - General Outline
•Availability Payments by the Government to the Project Company commence after the infrastructure has been built and ready for operation
• Service Availability Payments in AP Agreements are usually:
- made in quarterly instalments (i.e. “Quarterly Service Payments”);
- indexed for inflation; and
- have a high-level Payment Mechanism formula linking payments to (i) service availability and (ii) performance.
13
Availability Payments - General Structure & Mechanism
• In a typical road AP project, the service standards (or KPIs) in the payment mechanism are broadly structured around:
- lane availability;
- traffic volume/usage (i.e. cars, light commercial, and heavy commercial);
- road safety;
- O&M detection, response time and rectification;
- asset maintenance and refurbishment.
- traffic monitoring and communication systems; and
14
Service Availability Payment Mechanism –example of high level payment formula
• The exact detail of the payment mechanism is yet to developed, but using recent AP road projects the high-level payment formula for calculating Quarterly Service Payments is expected to be similar to the following example
Quarterly Service Payment (QSPq) = BQSPq– UAq– PAq
where:
BQSPq = Base Quarterly Service Payment for the relevant Quarter;
UAq = Unavailability Abatements for the relevant Quarter; and
PAq = Performance Abatements for the relevant Quarter.
• Note in the above example: - The “Base Quarterly Service Payment” is a separate formula detailing
capital cost, O&M, lifecycle cost, etc; and- “Abatements” usually means reductions in service payments due to
lane unavailability or not meeting KPI/performance service standards.
15
Market Sounding Questions
•A Preliminary Information Memorandum is available which outlines the project opportunity, and seeks market feedback on key questions
• Your answers to these questions will help inform the development of the OBC and AP procurement process
16
Market Sounding Questions – Key Questions
• Is the project considered an attractive opportunity from your perspective?
•Are there any factors that would influence your decision to participate in the proposed project?
•Are there opportunities or concerns surrounding your membership in a project consortium?
•What is a realistic time frame for the proposed project?
17
Market Sounding Questions – Key Questions for Construction Members of an AP Consortium
•What types of challenges and risks do you foresee during the construction period of this project?
•Do you perceive any constraints/limitations for participation by construction contractors? If so, how could these be solved?
•Are there any specific conditions that the GOI should consider prior to the project being tendered out?
18
Market Sounding Questions – Key Questions for Finance Members of an AP Consortium
•What key factors will drive your interest for extending funding assistance to this proposed pilot AP road project?
•What is your likely financing approach for this project?
•How would you manage foreign exchange risk?
19
Market Sounding Questions – Key Questions for O&M Members of an AP Consortium
•What types of challenges and risks do you foresee during the operating period of this project?
•What is your preference in terms of length of time for the operating term?
•Would you be comfortable with a contract structure that allows for both the GOI and the AP consortium to conduct 5-year benchmarking reviews with regard to services, costs, and impact on the annual service payment?
20
Market Sounding Questions – Key Questions for Advisors to an AP Consortium
•Do you feel that there is sufficient capacity and capability in the advisory market to support consortiums to bid and implement a pilot AP project? What are your suggestions about solutions?
•What role do you think international advisors could play in assisting capacity building of local members in an AP project?