1
Prescription Drug Overdose Mortality Surveillance Review
Len Paulozzi, MD, MPHDivision of Unintentional Injury Prevention
National Center for Injury Prevention and ControlCenters for Disease Control and Prevention
Core VIPP State Training Mtng Pre-Session, April 21, 2013
National Center for Injury Prevention and ControlDivision of Unintentional Injury Prevention
2
Motor vehicle traffic, poisoning, and drug poisoning (overdose) death rates,
US, 1980-2010
NCHS Data Brief, December, 2011, Updated with 2009 and 2010 mortality data
1980 1982 1984 1986 1988 1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 20100
5
10
15
20
25
Motor Vehicle Traffic Poisoning Drug Poisoning (Overdose)
Year
Dea
ths
per
100,
000
popu
lati
on
3
Drug overdose deaths by major drug type,
US, 1999-2010
CDC/NCHS National Vital Statistics System, CDC Wonder.
1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 20100
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,000
12,000
14,000
16,000
18,000
Opioids HeroinCocaine Benzodiazepines
Year
Num
ber
of D
eath
s
16,651
4
Outline of presentation Death certificate Death certification systems Defining underlying cause Pitfalls with underlying cause Defining multiple causes Pitfalls with multiple causes Guidelines for opioid death certifiers Using CDC WONDER
4
5
Death Certificate Information entered by the medical certifier
determines the cause of death Text converted to numeric codes largely by
computer.
CAUSE OF DEATH (See instructions and examples) Approximate interval: Onset to death32. PART I. Enter the chain of events - - diseases, injuries, or complications - - that directly caused the death. DO NOT enter
terminal events such as cardiac arrest, respiratory arrest, or ventricular fibrillation without showing the etiology. DO NOT ABBREVIATE. Enter only one cause on a line. Add additional lines if necessary.
IMMEDIATE CAUSE (Final disease or condition resulting in death) a. MULTIPLE DRUG INTOXICATION
Sequentially list conditions, if any, leading to the cause listed on line a. Enter the UNDERLYING CAUSE (disease or injury that initiated the events resulting in death) LAST
Due to (or as a consequence of):
b.
Due to (or as a consequence of):
c.
Due to (or as a consequence of):
d.
PART II. Enter other significant conditions contributing to death but not resulting in the underlying cause given in Part I.
33. WAS AN AUTOPSY PERFORMED? Yes No
34. WERE AUTOPSY FINDINGS AVAILABLE TO COMPLETE THE CAUSE OF DEATH? Yes No
35. DID TOBACCO USE CONTRIBUTE TO DEATH?
Yes Probably No Unknown
36. IF FEMALE: Not pregnant within past year Pregnant at time of death Not pregnant but pregnant within 42 days of death Not pregnant but pregnant 43 days to 1 year before death Unknown if pregnant within the past year
29. MANNER OF DEATH Natural Pending Accident Investigation Suicide Could not be Homicide Determined
38. DATE OF INJURY(Mo/Day/Yr)(Spell Month)
39. TIME OF INJURY 40. PLACE OF INJURY (e.g., Decedent’s home, construction site, restaurant, wooded area) HOME
41. INJURY AT WORK?
Yes No
42. LOCATION OF INJURY: State: City or Town: Street & Number: Apartment No. Zip Code:
43. DESCRIBE HOW INJURY OCCURREDDRUG INGESTION
44. IF TRANSPORTATION INJURY, SPECIFY Driver/Operator Passenger Pedestrian Other (Specify)
To B
e C
ompl
eted
By:
ME
DIC
AL
CE
RTI
FIE
R
X
7
What is an underlying cause? The single factor that caused death. Not recorded in a certain place on the death
certificate. Theoretically the last line in Part I of the cause of death
section Derived from the cause of death information
in aggregate
8
Definition of a drug overdose death Death certificate indicates underlying cause
of death was “overdose,” “poisoning,” or “intoxication” with a drug The word “drug” sufficient More specific drugs categorized using a standard table. Alcohol and organic solvents not drugs. OTC, rx, and street/illicit drugs included.
9
Accuracy of death certificate codes for drug overdose deaths
New Mexico study* for 1995-1998 Gold standard: state medical examiner files
• 1,046 poisoning deaths Underlying ICD9 cause codes for death certificates
• 1,046 poisoning deaths In both: 987 deaths Sensitivity: 94.4% of ME’s total Predictive value positive: 94.4% of death certificate
count Differences in definition possible Results possibly different in a coroner
systemLanden MG, et al. Am J Epidemiol 2003;157:273-278
10
ICD10 Codes for Drug Poisoning
Drug Type Unintentional
Suicide
Undetermined
Homicide
Nonopioid analgesics, antipyretics and anti-rheumatics
X40 X60 Y10
X85
Sedative-hypnotic, psychotropic
X41 X61 Y11
Narcotics and psychodysleptics (hallucinogens), NOS
X42 X62 Y12
Other drugs acting on CNS
X43 X63 Y13
Other and unspecified drugs
X44 X64 Y14
11
Comparability with ICD-9 Ninth Revision of the ICD (ICD9) coded
mortality data from 1979 through 1998. Comparability ratio between ICD9 and ICD10
for poisoning is good: 1.9% more deaths due to poisoning if the same mortality file is coded by ICD10 rather than ICD9.*
ICD9 codes for drug poisoning: Unintentional: E850-E858 Suicide: E950-E950.5 Undetermined: E980-E980.5 Homicide: E967.0
* Source: Nat Vit Stat Rep, vol 52, no. 21, June 2, 2004.
12
CDC “Drug Poisoning” Definitions Synonymous with drug overdose or drug
intoxication NOT the same as “drug present”
Essentially same as “Acute poisoning due to effects of drugs” from ISW 7
Does not include the chronic poisoning included in “Acute or chronic poisoning due to the effects of drugs” from ISW7
Does not include drug-related disease included in “Drug-induced deaths” concept developed earlier by NCHS.
13
Death Investigation Systems In relation to data quality,
coroners, who are elected officials, versus medical examiners, who are physicians qualified by
training and appointed. Centralized state medical examiner systems
advantageous for surveillance OK, MA, RI, OR, MD, NC, UT among core states with drug
overdose priority
County-based coroner OfficesCounty-based mixture of ME and Coroner OfficesCounty/District-based ME (physician) OfficesCentralized State ME Office
Sources: National Institute of Justice, Scientific Working Group on Medical Death Investigation, Death Investigation Systems, 2011Bureau of Justice Statistics, Census of Medical Examiner and Coroner Offices, 2004
MT
WY
ID
WA
OR
NV
UT
CA
AZ
ND
SD
NE
CO
NM
TX
OK
KS
AR
LA
MO
IA
MN
WI
IL IN
KY
TN
MS AL GA
FL
SC
NC
VAWV
OH
MI
NY
PA
MDDE
NJ
RI
MA
ME
VTNH
AK
HI
Death investigation systems, 2004
*
*
*CT
*
*
**
*
*
*
*
*
*
**
* *
*
*
**
*
*
* State ME
15
Pitfalls in reporting underlying cause of death
Unknown cause (R99 or Pending) Mental and behavioral disorders Intent
Pending certificates Death certificates with “pending” cause of
death section when the mortality file is finalized.
About 80% of pending certificates have underlying cause: R99 Other ill-defined and unspecified causes of mortality 4,800 in 2010
Drug poisoning deaths Lengthy investigations Initially submitted as pending Over-represented among pending deaths
Annual variation in percentpending certificates
In 2009, about 2% of all certificates pending in OH, WV, NJ and DC
Percent pendings higher than normal CA in 2000-2001 NY in 1999-2005 WV in 2005 DC in 2003, 2005, 2007-2008 GA in 2008
NCHS working hard to reduce pendings
Drug poisoning death rate and percent final non-pending certificates
California, 1999-2009
Source: NCHS, data from the National Vital Statistics System
1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 20090
2
4
6
8
10
12
97
97.5
98
98.5
99
99.5
10099.9
98.9
97.5
99.8 99.8 99.899.6 99.7
99.9 99.8 99.9
Drug poisoning death rate/10_5
Percent non- pending
Drug poisoning deaths recorded as unknown-cause (R99) deaths, 15-54 years
old, California, 1999-2006
99 00 01 02 03 04 05 0602468
101214161820
Rate
per
100
,000
Unknown Cause
Unintentional Drug Poisoning
Unintentional motor vehicle traffic
Opioid analgesic overdose deaths and unknown-cause (R99) deaths, West
Virginia, 1999-2010
1999 2000 2001 20022003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 20100
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
Num
ber
of d
eath
s
Unknown Cause
Opioid overdose
Overdose deaths all ages and unknown-cause (R99) deaths 15-64 years old, Ohio,
1999-2010
1999200020012002200320042005200620072008200920100
200400600800
100012001400160018002000
Num
ber
of d
eath
s
Unknown CauseOverdose
Source: CDC WONDER
Recommendations on pending deaths
• Work with your vital statistics office to encourage timely submission of deaths with a final cause assigned
• Check your state mortality file for annual changes in percent pending or percent poisoning
• Check your state mortality for variation in percent pending by county
Be cautious in interpretation if variation is noted
23
Deaths assigned to mental and behavioral disorders
1,732 deaths in 2010 attributed to “mental and behavioral disorders” due to drugs Underlying cause F11-F16, and F19
204 deaths in 2010 attributed to “mental and behavioral disorders due to use of opioids.” Underlying cause F11
If word such as “abuse” or “misuse” or “addiction” appear on the death certificate cause of death section.
Use of this category varies by state. Heavy use underestimates drug overdose
rates.
24
Mortality rate for mental/behavioral disorders due to drugs, US, 2007-2010
Map produced by CDC WONDERAge-adjusted rate per 100,000 for F11-16, F19
25
Acute intoxication from a mental and behavioral disorder included in some
definitions
ISW7 included [F11 – F16] (.0), and F19.0 in “Acute poisoning due to effects of drugs.” Sounds like “poisoning.” Zero deaths with these underlying causes in the
national mortality files since 2008
26
The issue of intent of injury Dangerous drug use often done among
people with mental health problems Poisoning deaths more likely to be difficult
to assign to unintentional versus suicide intents
The use of “undetermined” intent one way to address this uncertainty
Use of undetermined varies by state and by region within state. Interstate or county comparisons best done with all
intents combined
27
Undetermined vs. unintentional drug poisoning crude mortality rates by
state, 2006
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 200.02.04.06.08.0
10.012.014.0
Unintentional drug poisoning mortality rate
Unde
term
ined
inte
nt
drug
poi
soni
ng m
orta
lity
rate
UTMD
ARIN
Percent of overdose deaths with undetermined intent, selected core
states, 2009-2010 State Percent
State Percent
AZ 7.9 OH 4.3CO 7.9 OK 6.6HI 19.9 OR 10.8KY 8.3 PA 5.1MA 5.6 RI 0.0MD 80.5 TN 6.7NC 4.6 UT 35.7NE 12.1 WA 5.9
States with centralized medical examiner systems shown in red.
Recommendations on reporting overdose mortality by intent
Make death certifiers who are using “undetermined” at rates beyond the norm aware of this fact
Use “all intents” combined when possible Be wary of interstate or intercounty
comparisons of rates by intent categories.
31
Defining Contributing Causes of Death
32
Drugs as contributing causes Drugs involved in overdoses found in Part I
or II of death certificate NCHS directory of drug names
corresponding to specific ICD10 poison codes
Drug poison codes in range T36-T50 Such deaths can have up to 20 contributing
causes Specific drug information from these contributing causes Drugs merely present but not contributing not supposed
to be listed. “Record axis” variables used for analyses
33
Defining illicit and prescription drugs in ICD10
Prescription Drug Category ICD10 T codes
Illicit drugs (heroin, cocaine, LSD) T40.1, T40.5, T40.7-T40.9, T43.6Opioid analgesics T40.2-T40.4--- Other opioids (semi-synthetic) T40.2--- Methadone (synthetic) T40.3--- Other synthetic narcotic (synthetic)
T40.4
Benzodiazepines T42.4Antidepressants T43.0-T43.2All prescription drugs T36-T39, T40.2-T40.4, T41-T43.5,
T43.7-T50.8
Definitions of opiates and opioids
opioids
opiatespharmaceutica
l opioids
heroinopium
semi-synthetics:
codeine morphine oxycodone
hydrocodone
synthetics:
methadone,
fentanyl, tramadol
35
Distinguishing “opioids” and “opiates” in mortality
Opioid analgesics and heroin both in 965.0 in ICD9
Opioid analgesic poisoning not important enough to assign special code when ICD9 developed.
Thus opioid analgesic deaths not countable prior to 1999
Why all mortality trends for opioids start at 1999
36
Pitfalls in reporting contributing causes of death from overdose
Causes of undercounting specific drugs Causes of overcounting specific drugs Assigning responsibility among multiple
drugs
37
Lack of drug specification Drugs not well specified
“drug overdose” not otherwise described “multiple drug intoxication”
Roughly 25% of all drug overdose deaths NO drugs specified.
Percent varies by state (and possibly county).
Some ICD10 T codes not specific for illicit versus rx drugs, eg, T43.6, (psychostimulants)
Percent of overdose deaths with 1+ drug specified, core states, 2008-
2010 State Percent State PercentAZ 80.2 OH 71.6CO 70.5 OK 96.2HI 82.9 OR 90.7KY 65.3 PA 46.2MA 96.7 RI 96.7MD 97.7 TN 78.2NC 92.4 UT 94.0NE 69.4 WA 92.4
States with centralized medical examiner systems shown in red.Source: Unpublished analysis by Margaret Warner of NCHS
39
Percent of overdose deaths with 1+ drug specified against mortality rates
by state by type of overdose, 2008-2010
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 10005
1015202530
Overdose Linear (Overdose)Opioid overdose Linear (Opioid overdose)
Percent with drug(s) specified
Mor
talit
y ra
te/1
00,0
00
Opioid overdose deaths coded only as
“drug overdoses” with drugs unspecified• Adjusting each state total by the percent
unspecified • Result: estimated 22,229 opioid analgesic
deaths in 2010• 5,578 more than the official count.
41
Some opioid-related deaths NOT included
in opioid overdose totals Opioids lost if coded to T40.6 (other/unspec
narcotics) (2,039 such deaths w/o opioid codes in 2010) Use for opioid analgesics might vary by state
Deaths due to the acetaminophen component of opioid-acetaminophen combinations, eg, Vicodin
Other injury deaths where opioid sedation might have contributed to death, e.g., motor vehicle crash deaths
The “true number” of opioid analgesic overdose deaths, US, 201016,651 recorded as such+ some of 488 listed as mental disorders+ some of 2,039 attributed to “unspecified
narcotic”+ estimated 5,578 where drug not specified+ some of 4,800 assigned to “unknown cause”---------------------------------------------------------------= Way more than 16,651
43
Possible contributors to over-counts of opioid analgesic overdose deaths
Opioids produced by clandestine laboratories sold as illicit drugs Roughly 1,000 opioid overdose deaths in 2006 from
fentanyl* Occurs episodically and rarely produces so many deaths.
Some heroin overdoses recorded as due to morphine, its metabolite.
Opioids implicated when other drugs involved were causative Most overdose deaths involve multiple drugs Opioids most commonly paired with benzodiazepines,
which infrequently cause death by themselves.*See Jones. S et al. MMWR 2008;57:793-796
44
Multiple drugs contributing to an overdose death
Partitioning responsibility not possible Deaths counted more than once States vary in number of drugs coded per
death
45
Percentage of overdose deaths for specific psychotherapeutic and CNS pharmaceuticals that involved only a
single drug class, US, 2010
Jones CM, et al. Pharmaceutical overdose deaths, United States, 2010; JAMA 2013;309(7):657-659.
Opioid
Pain R
eliever
s (n=
16651
)
Antie
pilepti
c and A
ntipa
rkinso
nism Drug
s (n=17
17)
Benzo
diazep
ines (
n=64
97)
Barbi
turate
s (n=
296)
Antid
epres
sants
(n=38
89)
Antip
sycho
tic an
d Neu
rolep
tic Drugs
(n=1351
)
Other Psy
chotr
opic D
rugs (
n=24)
05
101520253035 29.4
6.2 3.79.1 10.5
6.4 8.3
Psychotherapeutic and CNS Pharmaceuticals
Perc
ent
46
Recommendations for reporting drugs as contributing causes of overdose
death Note possible causes of undercounts and
overcounts in limitations Cautious of annual changes by specific drug
due to changes in specificity Geographic comparisons of rates for drugs
risky Note that drugs sum to more than total Be clear that drugs “caused” deaths and
were not just “present.”
47
Using CDC WONDER See CDC Users Guide for access instructions Data usually two years out of date Multiple “by” variables available State and county specific Age-adjustment, mapping and chart
construction Contributing drugs available in WONDER
Multiple Cause of Death Data Numbers might differ from state files Drug poisoning deaths cannot be identified
in NCIPC WISQARS.http://wonder.cdc.gov/http://wonder.cdc.gov/mcd.html
48
“Recommendations for the Investigation, Diagnosis, and
Certification of Deaths Related to Opioid Drugs”
National Association of Medical Examiners and American College of Medical Toxicology recommendations
Includes scene investigation and drug testing guidelines
Useful to distribute to your coroners and/or medical examiners
Davis et al, Acad Foren Path 2013; 3(1): 62-76 and 77-83.
Additional Information
http://www.cdc.gov/HomeandRecreationalSafety/pdf/PolicyImpact-PrescriptionPainkillerOD.pdf
http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm6126a5.htm?s_cid=mm6126a5_w
http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm6043a4.htm
Len Paulozzi, MD, [email protected]
The findings and conclusions in this report are those of the author and do not necessarily represent the official position of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention/the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry.
Acknowledgement: Thanks to Dr. Margaret Warner of NCHS for allowing use of some of her slides.