PRESENTATION TO
SELECT COMMITTEE ON FINANCE ______________________________
20 NOVEMBER 2008
CONTENTS
1. Introduction
2. Budget performance
3. Revenue collection
4. Performance of conditional grants
5. Intergovernmental relations
6. Alignment of IDP and PGDP
7. Compliance with MFMA
8. Service delivery
9. Other key projects
10. Assistance to the Poor Scheme
11. Capacity constraints
12. Credit rating outcome
13. Conclusion
1. INTRODUCTION
• Population - 1,1 million• Households - 289 000• Area covered - 1950 km²• Capital Budget - R1.9 billion• Operating Budget - R5.2 billion
Ratios as at 30 June 2008
TARGET ACTUAL
Personnel Costs as a percentage of Total Operating Income 30.00% 25.3%
Repairs and Maintenance as a percentage of Total Operating Income 9.00% 9.50%
Capital Budget Spending 95.00% 98.67%
Net Debtors to Annual Operating Income 15% 12.5%
Annual Debtors Collection Rate 98.00% 98.59%
Creditors Turnover (from date of receipt of invoice) 30 Days 27 Days
Debt Servicing Costs to Annual Operating Income 12% 1.3%
Loan Debt to Income 12% 10.4%
Current Ratio 1.54:1 1.43:1
Own Revenue Generation 88.00% 84.8%
2. BUDGET PERFORMANCE
2. BUDGET PERFORMANCE (continued)
SOURCES OF REVENUE AS AT 30 JUNE 2008
ORIGINAL BUDGET 2007/08
ACTUAL 2007/08 % Actual/Budget
Property rates 607,878,660 587,886,646 96.7
Service charges 1,777,599,780 1,795,795,795 101.0
Interest earned - external investments 128,293,700 183,781,377 143.3
Interest earned - outstanding debtors 62,005,230 89,638,612 144.6
Fines 32,825,840 19,433,557 59.2
Licenses and permits 6,762,390 7,141,521 105.6
Government grants and subsidies 1,143,812,410 760,337,059 66.5
Rental of facilities and equipment 13,899,730 12,952,898 93.2
Income for agency services 1,028,200 1,092,774 106.3
Other income 198,329,670 186,484,726 94.0
Gains on the disposal of property, plant and equipment 22,020 482,231 2,190.0
Contributions: Other 872,160 0 0.0
Total Revenue 3,973,329,790 3,645,027,196 91.7
OPERATING REVENUE 2007/08
Int. earned - ext. investments
3.6%
Other Income33.4%
Gov. Grants and Subsidies15.2%
Property rates11.8%
Service Charges36.0%
2. BUDGET PERFORMANCE (continued)
2. BUDGET PERFORMANCE (continued)
PLANNED OPERATING EXPENDITURE VERSUS ACTUAL BY ITEM AS AT 30 JUNE 2008
ORIGINAL
BUDGET 2007/08ACTUAL 2007/08
% Actual/ Budget
Employee related costs 1,162,623,990 1,264,406,907 108.8%
Remuneration of Councillors 42,118,450 37,824,627 89.8%
Bad debts 41,314,240 60,820,880 147.2%
Collection costs 2,885,880 2,234,944 77.4%
Contracted services 68,888,540 78,206,801 113.5%
Depreciation 254,222,820 283,294,864 111.4%
Repairs and maintenance 302,406,110 330,013,395 109.1%
Interest paid 67,147,150 65,070,931 96.9%
Bulk purchases 726,478,390 719,787,933 99.1%
Grants and subsidies paid 45,424,640 56,253,937 123.8%
General expenses 795,929,510 559,924,336 70.3%
Loss on disposal of property, plant and equipment 0 44,881,698
Total expenditure 3,509,439,720 3,502,721,253 99.8%
OPERATING EXPENDITURE 2007/08
Depreciation, 8.1%
Contracted services, 2.2%
Other, 7.7%
Repairs and Maint., 9.4%
General Expenses, 16.0% Bulk purchases,
20.5%
Empl.related costs, 36.1%
2. BUDGET PERFORMANCE (continued)
2007/08 CAPITAL BUDGET/PROGRAMMES
CAPITAL SPENDING COMPARED TO BUDGET - 30 JUNE 2008
Amended Total % Spent
Directorate Budget Expenditure 2007/08
Budget and Treasury 84,586,840 84,576,549 99.99
Environment and Health Service 59,167,710 56,544,493 95.57
Economic Development and Recreation and Culture 75,418,820 75,729,026 100.41
Housing and Land 20,021,840 14,079,407 70.32
Electricity and Energy 229,038,800 227,425,483 99.30
Infrastructure and Engineering 560,299,390 566,056,818 101.03
Roads, stormwater and transportation 345,839,210 348,280,288 100.71
Sanitation service 100,052,850 99,265,800 99.21
Water service 114,407,330 118,510,730 103.59
Safety and Security 35,351,320 34,301,393 97.03
2010 World Cup Office (Stadium) 790,520,000 787,199,565 99.58
Executive Mayor 11,555,060 304,016 2.63
MURP Projects 3,420,020 1,434,749 41.95
Corporate Services 52,815,590 48,892,830 92.57
TOTAL 1,922,195,390 1,896,544,330 98.67
2. BUDGET PERFORMANCE (continued)
ACTUAL CAPITAL SPENDING BY IDP PRIORITIES - 2007/08
Municipal Transformation and Development
2.8%
Good Governance and Public Participation
2.8%
Financial Sustainability and Viability
36.0%
Local - Economic Development
3.9%
Service Delivery and Infrastructure Development
54.6%
2. BUDGET PERFORMANCE (continued)
CAPITAL BUDGET BY SOURCE OF FUNDING - 2007/08
AMENDED BUDGET 2007/08 ACTUAL 2007/08
Capital Replacement Reserve 444,644,979 432,304,842
Contributions from Current Income
450,552 403,455
Grants and Subsidies - National
893,972,405890,800,248
Public Contributions 22,414,800 25,783,102
Grants and Subsidies - Province
54,725,00049,626,079
Municipal Infrastructure Programme 93,592,100 95,492,701
Provincial Housing Board Subsidies
2,901,750 2,023,876
Department of Minerals & Energy - Subsidy
22,477,85024,090,233
Housing Revolving Fund 500,640 499,897
Levies Replacement 170,341,444 172,625,619
Equitable Share 36,083,536 24,757,645
External Finance Fund 100,000,000 100,709,687
Restructuring Grant 76,753,560 75,712,880
European Union Funding 3,336,774 1,714,067
1,922,195,390 1,896,544,330
2. BUDGET PERFORMANCE (continued)
CAPITAL BUDGET BY SOURCE OF FUNDING - 2007/08
Grants and Subsidies-National47.0%
Levies Replacement9.1%
Capital Replacement Reserve22.8%
Grants and Subsidies-Province
2.6%
Public Contributions1.4%
Contri from Income0.1%
European Union Funding0.1%
Housing Revolving Fund0.1%
DME Subsidy1.3%
Restructuring Grant4.0%
External Finance Fund5.3%
Equitable Share1.3%
PHB Subsidies0.1%
MIG5.0%
2. BUDGET PERFORMANCE (continued)
3. REVENUE COLLECTION
• Accurate account database.
• Improved monitoring and maintenance of meters.
• All Assistance to the Poor households on prepaid meters.
• Improved Customer Care.
• Prepaid holders in arrears - % of their purchases offset against arrears.
• Continuous monitoring of water leaks.
CONDITIONAL GRANTS AS AT 30 JUNE 2008
Name of Grants
Name of organ of
state
Total funds received
Total expenditure
Reasons for delay
Did Municipality comply with
grant conditions?
Financial Management Grant NT 500,000 758,807 N / A Yes
National Electrification Programme DME 15,657,000 16,822,253 N / A Yes
Municipal Infrastructure Grant DPLG 152,750,230 114,556,875 N / A Yes
Restructuring Grant NT 100,000,000 79,925,096 N / A Yes
Effective disaster management DPLG 1,500,000 1,424,760 N / A Yes
MSIG - Project Consolidate DPLG 0 3,675,756 N / A Yes
FIFA 2010 World Cup (Construction of Stadium) NT 730,495,896 798,293,056 N / A Yes
FIFA 2010 World Cup (Transport or PTIF) NT 132,000,000 75,882,975 N / A Yes
Motherwell Urban Renewal Programme DPLG 16,768,205 10,563,329 N / A Yes
TOTAL 1,149,671,331 1,101,902,907 96%
4. PERFORMANCE OF CONDITIONAL GRANTS
4. PERFORMANCE OF CONDITIONAL GRANTS (continued)
Reasons for over-/underexpenditure
• Financial Management Grant – increased spending due to training courses attended and improvement of financial systems, covered by the underspending of the grant in the previous financial year.
• Municipal Infrastructure Grant – Additional allocation received for flood relief (R57 m). On track with spending in 2008/09.
• Restructuring Grant – has been fully utilised. Grant ceased end of 2007/08.
• MSIG – Expenditure for 2007/08 financial year relates to grant received in the 2006/07 financial year. Assist in implementing E Learning, Attorney and Query Management systems.
4. PERFORMANCE OF CONDITIONAL GRANTS (continued)
• World Cup Soccer (Stadium) – Funds received in the 2006/07 financial year, utilised in 2007/08.
• World Cup Soccer (Transportation) – Delay in the awarding of certain contracts as a result of redesign. Five contracts have now been awarded (G Mbeki, Kempston, Harrower, Heugh, New Brighton and Fettes/Theale Roads) and construction is in progress.
• Motherwell Urban Renewal Programme – Underspending due to unresolved land ownership issues for the Xhosa Village, land to be acquired for Motherwell Golf Course.
ACHIEVEMENTS
• Financial Management Grant – Employed five interns, who are being rotated in all sub-directorates within Budget and Treasury.
• Municipal Infrastructure Grant – Bulk Sewer and Water services installed, water reticulation and sidewalks, all in previously disadvantaged areas.
• Restructuring Grant – assisted in implementing the General Valuation, new Billing System, fixed asset register.
• MSIG – Interface with the new billing system, e.g. E Learning and Attorney Management system.
• Motherwell Urban Renewal Programme – Upliftment of previously disadvantaged areas by providing essential services.
4. PERFORMANCE OF CONDITIONAL GRANTS (continued)
5. INTERGOVERNMENTAL RELATIONS
• The Municipality participates in intergovernmental relations structures, such as:
Premier’s Co-ordinating Forum Technical Support Group Munimecs (close liaison between municipal directorates and their counterparts) Departmental Forums
• Sector departments participate in the IDP process. • Further interaction is also taking place in the following areas:
2010 FIFA World Cup− Provincial Co-ordinating Committee− Stadium costs
− Transportation infrastructure − Operational hosting funding
• Work with DBSA, especially with regard to MURP Project Management. Possible external funding from DBSA will be pursued.
5. INTERGOVERNMENTAL RELATIONS (continued)
• Intergovernmental relations challenges:
Unfunded mandates − Libraries − Health − Provincial roads
− Housing delivery and lack of multi-year housing budget allocation
Delay in processing of EIA’s.
Delay in receipt of DWAF invoices for bulk water purchases.
Payment of outstanding service charges (Government debt) (current amount due: R53 million).
Electricity tariff increase by ESKOM and threats to investment.
6. ALIGNMENT OF IDP AND PGDP
The IDP and PGDP are aligned in terms of key performance and focus areas, as reflected below:
Municipal key performance areas Provincial key performance areas
Service delivery and infrastructure development
• Fighting poverty• Infrastructure development
Municipal transformation and organisational development
• Public sector transformation• Human resources development
Local economic development • Manufacturing diversification and tourism
Finance financial viability and management
• Same
Public participation and good governance • Same
7. COMPLIANCE WITH MFMA
• The Council complies fully with the 14 key MFMA priorities set by National Treasury. • The Council’s Supply Chain Management Policy was adopted in October 2005. • The following Bid Committees are in place:
Specifications Committee Evaluation Committee Adjudication Committee
• Annual Financial Statements were submitted by 31 August 2008.
• Audit Steering Committee is in place and operational.
• The Municipality has a functional Internal Audit Division.
• Audit fees to the Auditor-General are paid fully and timeously.
7. COMPLIANCE WITH MFMA (continued)
• Audit qualifications reduced from 17 in 2005/06 to 1 in 2006/07.
• 2007/08 Audit complete and awaiting Auditor-General’s report (no basis for qualification has been identified as yet).
• Annual reports and the Council’s Oversight reports that comply with legislation are produced annually.
• Positive feedback was received from National Treasury regarding the Municipality's oversight and annual reports for 2006/07 financial year.
• Cluster System was adopted by Council to ensure integrated and co-ordinated service delivery.
• Quarterly financial and non-financial performance reports are produced through SDBIPs.
• Budget Performance Reports are submitted quarterly to the Council’s Budget Performance Monitoring Forum.
7. COMPLIANCE WITH MFMA (continued)
• Integrated IDP/Budget Process Plan is annually developed and implemented, taking into account stakeholder involvement and timelines.
• Section 71 reports are submitted timeously.
• Budget and Treasury Directorate structured as per the MFMA.
• Performance agreements are in place for the Municipal Manager and other Section 57 employees.
• Annual risk audits were performed and risk registers developed in line with annual audit plan.
Type of service Sept 2008/
09target
Annual target
Sept 2008/
09actual
% of households with access to electricity
97% 98% 97%
Number of erven connected to electricity
N/A 5 222 3 155
% electricity losses in line with NERSA
8% 7,1% 6,32%
Number of people connected to hot water load control
27 500 55 000 27 500
Three renewable energy projects are under implementation. The Municipality is working with Coega to find other alternative sources of energy.
8. SERVICE DELIVERY
Type of service Sept 2008/09target
AnnualTarget 2008/09
Sept 2008/09actual
% of households with access to electricity
97% 98% 97%
Number of erven connected to electricity
2 000 5 222 3 155
% electricity losses in line with NERSA
8% 7,1% 6,32%
Number of people connected to hot water load control
27 500 55 000 27 500
Total number of households in the Metro – 289 000 households
• Electricity provision
Type of service Sept 2008/
09target
Annual target
Sept 2008/
09actual
% of households with access to electricity
97% 98% 97%
Number of erven connected to electricity
N/A 5 222 3 155
% electricity losses in line with NERSA
8% 7,1% 6,32%
Number of people connected to hot water load control
27 500 55 000 27 500
8. SERVICE DELIVERY (continued) Water and sanitation provision
93% of households have access to a basic level of water.
100% of households in the Metro will have access to water within a 200 m radius
through the installation of standpipes in informal areas.
- On target to meet December 2008 deadline.
91% of households have access to basic level of sanitation. Alternative sanitation methods are under investigation for use in the informal
settlements, to meet the 2010 target. December 2007 target met for the eradication of buckets in the formal areas. 100% of formal households have access to sanitation, except in two areas,
namely -
Kuyga and Kleinskool, where contractors abandoned sites.
- Kuyga: Contractor on site due for completion in April 2009.
- Kleinskool: To commence in January 2009 due for completion in
October 2009. Currently, 15 000 buckets are still in circulation in informal settlements as a
means of sanitation (will be addressed in conjunction with housing delivery
programme).
Type of service Sept 2008/
09target
Annual target
Sept 2008/
09actual
% of households with access to electricity
97% 98% 97%
Number of erven connected to electricity
N/A 5 222 3 155
% electricity losses in line with NERSA
8% 7,1% 6,32%
Number of people connected to hot water load control
27 500 55 000 27 500
• Refuse removal
Approx. 99% of residents have access to a basic level of refuse removal.
Illegal dumping remains a challenge. Ward-based cleaning programme has been introduced in 24 wards and will
be expanded to cover 30 wards during the current financial year.
8 Co-operatives are also assisting in litter-picking and street sweeping. Educational programmes are being implemented, as well as identified
official dumping sites.
8. SERVICE DELIVERY (continued)
Type of service Sept 2008/
09target
Annual target
Sept 2008/
09actual
% of households with access to electricity
97% 98% 97%
Number of erven connected to electricity
N/A 5 222 3 155
% electricity losses in line with NERSA
8% 7,1% 6,32%
Number of people connected to hot water load control
27 500 55 000 27 500
• Roads
Road maintenance backlog (subsidised roads)
8. SERVICE DELIVERY (continued)
NO DESCRIPTION
LENGTH
(KM)
BACKLOG
(M)
1 Resurfacing tar roads 462 R54
2 Rehabilitation tar roads 57 R81
3 Rehabilitation concrete roads 6.4 R18
4 Rehabilitation bridge structures 95 R204
TOTAL 525.4 (excl. BDGS) R357
Type of service Sept 2008/
09target
Annual target
Sept 2008/
09actual
% of households with access to electricity
97% 98% 97%
Number of erven connected to electricity
N/A 5 222 3 155
% electricity losses in line with NERSA
8% 7,1% 6,32%
Number of people connected to hot water load control
27 500 55 000 27 500
• Roads (continued)
Roads maintenance backlog (unsubsidised roads)
8. SERVICE DELIVERY (continued)
NO DESCRIPTION
LENGTH
(KM)
BACKLOG
(M)
1 Resurfacing tar roads 2112 R 131
2 Rehabilitation tar roads 164 R197
3 Rehabilitation concrete roads 68 R 63
4 Rehabilitation bridge structures 15 R 18
5 Tarring of gravel roads 400 R1.0 billion
TOTAL 2744 (excl. BDGS) R1.4 billion
Type of service Sept 2008/
09target
Annual target
Sept 2008/
09actual
% of households with access to electricity
97% 98% 97%
Number of erven connected to electricity
N/A 5 222 3 155
% electricity losses in line with NERSA
8% 7,1% 6,32%
Number of people connected to hot water load control
27 500 55 000 27 500
• Roads (continued)
Progress with regard to roads during first quarter of 2008/09 financial year are as follows:
Type of service Sept. 2008/09target
Sept. 2008/09actual
Explanation of variance
Km of roads tarred 10 km 5 km
Locating position of existing underground services and relaying same, on some major contracts, has delayed implementation. This situation will improve in the following quarters.
Km of sidewalks tarred 3 km 3,7 km
Km of roads resurfaced 10 km 1 kmAnnual resurfacing tenders are now awarded and the situation will improve in the next quarter.
Km of roads rehabilitated/ reconstructed
2 km 0 kmEIA delay the process, however, Contracts are now in process of being awarded.
Km of roads graveled 20 km 20 km
8. SERVICE DELIVERY (continued)
• Upgrading of various sports facilities:
The Municipality has set aside R120 million over a three-year period to provide and upgrade the following sports facilities:
(a) New facilities:
- New multipurpose centre, Despatch - R4,5 million
- 2 informal sports fields, Despatch – R5 million (2009/10)
- Versatile sports ground, KwaNobuhle – R4,5 million
- Multipurpose Sports Facility, Northern Areas – R3,5 million
- Develop new multi-purpose centre, Northern Areas – R4,5 million
- Develop new multi-purpose centre, Missionvale Area – R4 million
- New multi-purpose centre, Wells Estate – R4,2 million
- New swimming pool, KwaNobuhle – R3,5 million
9. OTHER KEY PROJECTS
(b) Upgrading of facilities:
- Jubilee Sports Field – R3 million
- Finnis Street Sports Field – R2 million
- Gelvandale Playing Fields – R50 000
- Kleinskool Sports Field – R2 million
- Gelvandale Swimming Pool enclosure – R2,5 million
- Gelvandale Stadium – R3 million
- Reinstatement of Zwide Swimming Pool – R300 000
- Zwide Stadium – R1,5 million
- Veeplaas, upgrading of changerooms and concrete seating – R2 million
- KwaDwesi, new changerooms, soccer and cricket fields – R2,5 million
9. OTHER KEY PROJECTS (continued)
• Inner-city regeneration and urban renewal.
• Establishment of municipal Police Service and exploring funding models.
• The Municipality is on course to meet all 2010 FIFA World Cup requirements.
• In addition to the stadium, the Municipality is currently implementing other major related projects focusing on roads and transport.
• Bulk Services to support the Coega IDZ.
9. OTHER KEY PROJECTS (continued)
10. ASSISTANCE TO THE POOR SCHEME
• The Council adopted an Assistance to the Poor Policy.
• An Outreach Programme focusing on the unregistered indigent took place from April 2008 to August 2008:
− 10 000 new customers registered for the Assistance to the Poor Scheme
• Total ATTP: currently 106 682 out of a total of 289 000 households
• ATTP Scheme currently provides the following:− Free 8 kl water (monthly)− Free 75 kwh electricity (monthly)
• Total budget for Assistance to the Poor Scheme – R365 million
• 81 unemployed people were trained as plumbers and are repairing water leaks in indigent households throughout the Metro.
11. CAPACITY CONSTRAINTS• FINANCIAL
Unfunded mandates; e.g. provision of health services, roads, libraries and housing. Funds to provide for Coega Bulk Services (Water & Sanitation).
FIFA 2010 World Cup Budget [capital and operations]. Sustain the Capital Replacement Reserve [CRR].
• HUMAN RESOURCES
Technical skills shortage (especially civil and electrical engineers). Balancing staffing requirements with personnel expenditure target.
• SERVICE DELIVERY
Lack of adequate funding for maintenance backlogs. Secure and sufficient energy requirements for both domestic users
and investors. Cost of electricity. Lack of external contractor capacity. EIA delays in project approvals.
• Aa3.za – Long-term issue rating with stable outlook.
• Issued for both 2007 and 2008.
• Rating based on Municipality’s strong financial performance, good liquidity and cash management.
• Multi-year budgeting clearly reflects goals for next three years.
12. CREDIT RATING OUTCOME
Issues that require assistance from Government:
• Government debt to municipalities.
• Unfunded mandates.
• Zero rating on agency fees.
• Hosting Costs for World Cup.
• Exemption on import duties for World Cup related goods.
• Housing delivery allocation to be gazetted timeously and on a multi-year basis.
• Consideration of funding the tarring of gravel roads from housing subsidy programme.
13. CONCLUSION
THANK YOU