Preserving Cognitive & Mental Capital in Our Knowledge-Based Economy
Husseini K Manji Global TA Head, Neuroscience Janssen Pharmaceuticals/J&J
OPINION | October 28, 2010
MORE MEDICAL RESEARCH IS NEEDED TO DEFEAT
ALZHEIMER'S DISEASE BEFORE IT'S TOO LATE TO
HELP THE BABY BOOM GENERATION.
Op-Ed Contributors: The Age of Alzheimer's
By Sandra Day O'Connor, Stanley Prusiner and Ken Dychtwald
“Alzheimer's disease,
an illness that is 100
percent incurable and
100 percent fatal”
“Starting on Jan. 1, our 79-
million-strong baby boom
generation will be turning 65
at the rate of one every eight
seconds. That means more
than 10,000 people per day,
or more than four million per
year, for the next 19 years
facing an increased risk of
Alzheimer's”
• 100 % incurable today
• 100% fatal today
• Numbers are going to
triple because of the
aging population
• >$1Trillion for care in
USA alone by 2050
Report from the Lewin Group, commissioned by the Alzheimer’s Association, Washington DC, 2004
Critical Need to Prevent Cognitive Decline
TODAY
TOMORROW 3
CSF Tau/Aß42 ratio predicts progression from MCI to AD over 5 years
Low Tau/Aß
High Tau/Aß
Ch
ance
of
no
pro
gre
ssio
n t
o A
D
Time (months)
Mood Disease Area Strategy
2.96
3.01
3.07
3.07
3.65
4.08
6.76
10.3
0 5 10 15
8. Cerebrovascular
Disease
7. Alzheimer's &
Other Dementias
6. Hearing Loss; Adult
Onset
5. Trachea / Bronchus
/ Lung Cancer
4. Chronic Obstructive
Pulmonary Disease
3. Alcohol Use
Disorders
2. Ischaemic Heart
Disease
1. Unipolar
Depression
0 10 20 30 40
Mental Illness*
Injuries, including self-inflicted
Alcohol and drug use
Malignant neoplasms (cancer)
Cardiovascular disease
Respiratory disease
Musculoskeletal disease
Sense organ disease
Digestive disease
Serious Mental Illnesses are Major Causes of Disability Worldwide: Global Burden of Disease
(U.S., Canada, and Western Europe 15-44 years old)
Disability-Adjusted Life Year (DALY)
Leading Individual Disease (DALY)
Disability-Adjusted Life Year (DALY)
Leading Disease Categories (DALY)
> 38,000 deaths by suicide annually in the US
Mental Illness*
1. Unipolar Depression
4
5
7-year follow-up of
6176 elderly women
< 6 depressive
sx
> 6 depressive sx
• Incidence of CV disease
• Outcome after CV disease
• Type II Diabetes
• Osteoporosis
• ? Risk of Dementia
• Mortality in Elderly
• Nursing home admission
Children of Depressed Moms are…
More likely to have poor academic performance
More likely to have behavioral problems
More likely to have a psychiatric illness
More likely to be hyperactive (boys)
More likely to have insecure attachments with their Moms
Hrs
pe
r n
igh
t
Sleep Duration Time Trends in US Adults
Highly Confidential—for discussion only
0.1% 1%
2%
6%
8%
9% 10% 10%
9% 9% 8% 8%
6% 6%
4%
3%
2% 1%
1% 0.3% 0.1%
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
PSQI Total Score: All Respondents PSQI Range: 0-20
Source: Sleep Study Maternal Health, April 2014, Total n=2,427
(Good) Sleep Quality (Poor)
Good Sleep Quality
25%
Poor Sleep Quality
75%
3 in 4 Women Report Poor Sleep During
Pregnancy
***
*** *** *** *
*
Prevalence of Comorbid Psychiatric Disorders in Individuals with Insomnia (Benca and Peterson, Sleep Med, 2008)
CV Disease Cancer Hypertension Respiratory Neurologic Urinary Diabetes Pain GI0
20
40
60 Insomnia (n=137)
No Insomnia (n=401)
Pre
vale
nce o
f M
ed
ical P
rob
lem
(%
)
** *** ** ***
***
*** ***
* **
Comorbidity of Chronic Insomnia with Medical Problems (Taylor et al, Sleep, 2007)
So we clearly need to D the Paradigm from Diagnose & Treat to Predict & Preempt: many challenges…….
• Need to be able to quantitate physiological/pathophysiological parameters, and intervene before transitions into more severe disease states
• Clinic visits are time-limited evaluations based on subjective observations of both the patient and the HCP
• Changes in disease state for each of these diseases can occur on timescales much shorter than the interval between clinic visits
• Through technological advances over the last decade it is now possible to objectively, remotely, and continuously measure aspects of patient physiology, behavior and symptoms
10
Emerging Technology for Continuous Patient Assessment
11
Symptoms
IVR
Smartphone Symptom assessment
Physiology
ECG HR/HRV Respiration Skin temp Activity/Sleep O2 sat
Behavior
GPS Talk patterns Text patterns Activity/Sleep
Escalating Data Challenge: How the types of data we collect is evolving…..
‘Point–of-Facility’ Discrete, Structured, Information Events Controlled Populations (clinical trials, longitudinal disease studies)
Physician Notes, EMR
Caregiver Reports
Literature Patents Epidemiology
E-mail,
‘Point-of-Need’ Real-Time Multiplexed Read-Outs (Diagnostic, Prognostic, Drug Monitoring) Distributed Populations in Clinic Settings
Semi-Continuous Semi-Structured data Multiple sources
Theranos
Discrete Centralized Discrete Decentralized Non-Discrete Decentralized
Diagnosis/ Prognosis
Drug Monitoring PK
....So Data is Evolving to Continuous Streams of Information ‘Quantified Self’
On-Patient
- Actigraphy
- Speech
- Eye movement
- EKG, HR, HRV
- EEG
- Sleep
- Galvanic skin
response
- O2 Sat
- Skin temperature
Off-Patient
- Fixed cameras
- Bed embedded
sensors
- Computer usage
- Phone usage
- Refrigerator
usage
- Motion sensors
Social Media
Brain Fitness Centers
Mobile Computing
Devices
Remote Monitoring
Sensors
New Data
Types, New
Tools for:
Information
Extraction,
Knowledge
Representation
Integration
Mining
14
EWSQ 10 Patient Version Potential Technology Correlates
Has your sleep worsened since the last evaluation? Sleep EEG Actigraphy
Has your appetite decreased since the last evaluation?
Has your concentration, e.g., ability to read or watch TV, worsened since the last evaluation?
Eye tracking Computer tracking
Have you experienced fear, suspiciousness, or other uneasy feelings while being around people since the last evaluation?
Skin Conductance Heart rate / variability
Have you experienced increased restlessness, agitation, or irritability since the last evaluation?
Actigraphy Galvanic Skin Response Speech Analysis
Have you noticed that something unusual or strange is happening around you since the last evaluation?
Have you experienced loss of energy or interest since the last evaluation?
Actigraphy Cell phone location
Has your capability to cope with everyday problems worsened since the last evaluation?
Have you experienced hearing other people’s voices even when nobody was around since the last evaluation?
Have you noticed any other of your individual early warnings signs since the last evaluation?
As we derive signatures of disease/relapse from the new continuous data types, we don’t have to start from scratch
these technologies use prior clinical knowledge, as well as the known history of the patients
Case Study I: Brain Health Registry Digital, Distributed Longitudinal Assessment of Cognition
Case Study II: Remote assessment of maintenance of treatment response in MDD patients
Behavioral assessment
Motor activity, sleep via actigraphy devices
Speech, voice via phone
Track trends
App collects and tracks
behavioral data
Assess self-report
Validated questions / scales (e.g., QIDS-SR)
administered via smartphone
Threshold level of decline
prompts alert to physician
Transmit information to clinician
a. Identify patients who may be at increased risk of near term relapse
b. Enable measurement-based changes to maintenance regimen
STAR-D: Subjects w/ greater number of residual symptoms after remission of MDD had a greater probability of relapse Nierenberg et al., 2010
Few studies have addressed predictors of near term relapse or onset of relapse prodrome in MDD
Preserving Cognitive & Mental Capital is Critical not only for
Individuals & Families, but also for Society
• Mood Disorders: very disabling
• Mood Disorders: associated with absenteeism, &“presenteeism”
• Societal productivity driven by quality of workforce; critical role of
cognitive & mental function
• Rapidly aging populations in Europe, US, Japan, and soon, China
equates to fewer working people per retired person
• We need people working later in life, but that requires preservation
of cognitive & mental capacity
Lake Nona may represent an ideal setting to undertake, integrate
& quantitate the impact of various interventions
Identification of at Risk & Early Diagnosis
Preserving & Restoring Cognitive & Mental Capital at Lake Nona
Computerized Cognitive Remediation
Cognitive & Mental
Function
Medical Nutrition
Therapeutics targeting Disease Pathology
Therapeutics targeting Neural & Synaptic Plasticity
Exercise