+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Printed circularly polarized wire antennas with DC grounded stub

Printed circularly polarized wire antennas with DC grounded stub

Date post: 10-Oct-2016
Category:
Upload: song-wang
View: 212 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
7
of the microstrip line and the misalignment of the via arrays in the substrate ought to be examined. Simulation results indicate that the performance of the proposed transition can tolerate fab- rication and assembly errors to a reasonable amount. For a microstrip line fabricated on a substrate thinner than the gap, solder on the via arrays is required to prevent sideward leakage through the additional air space above the substrate within the gap. Thicker substrates are not discussed here because they usu- ally are not considered for high-frequency applications. The new connector is also proved to be suitable for the transitions between various coaxial cables/connectors and different planar transmission lines, such as K-to-microstrip, semi-rigid cable-to- microstrip, and SMA-to-CPW transitions as well. 5. CONCLUSION A new SMA connector designed for coaxial-to-microstrip transi- tions is presented. The connector is combined with two via arrays embedded in the substrate of the microstrip line to facili- tate the transformation of the field distributions of the two trans- mission lines. Hence, the high-frequency performance of the transition is improved significantly. The design offers reasonable amount of tolerances for the fabrication errors of the new con- nector and the via arrays. It can apply to the transitions between other cables/connectors and planar transmission lines as well. These features make the proposed design most suitable for high- frequency applications. REFERENCES 1. R.L. Eisenhart, A better microstrip connector, In: Proc IEEE-MTT Symp, 1978, pp. 318–320. 2. J. Chenkin, dc to 40 GHz coaxial-to-microstrip transition for 100- l-thick GaAs substrates, IEEE Trans Microwave Theory Tech 37 (1989), 1147–1150. 3. J.-C. Cheng, E.S. Li, W.-F. Chou, and K.-L. Huang, Improving the high-frequency performance of coaxial-to-microstrip transitions, IEEE Trans Microwave Theory Tech 59 (2011), 1468–1477. 4. HFSS (High frequency structure synthesizer) ver. 11, Ansoft Cor- poration, Pittsburgh, PA, 2007. 5. F. Shigeki, Waveguide line, (in Japanese) Japan Patent 06-053 711, 1994. 6. R.A. Soares, P. Gouzien, P. Leguad, and G. Follot, A unified mathe- matical ap- proach to two-port calibration techniques and some appli- cations, IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory Tech 37 (1989), 1669–1674. V C 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. PRINTED CIRCULARLY POLARIZED WIRE ANTENNAS WITH DC GROUNDED STUB Song Wang, 1 Ka Ming Mak, 2 Hau Wah Lai, 2,3 Kwok Kan So, 2,3 Quan Xue, 2,3 and Guisheng Liao 1 1 National Laboratory of Radar Signal Processing, Xidian University, Xi’an 710071, China 2 State Key Laboratory of Millimeter waves (HK), City University of Hong Kong SAR, China 3 Shenzhen Research Institute, City University of Hong Kong, Shenzhen, China; Corresponding author: [email protected] Received 13 March 2012 ABSTRACT: Two new printed circuit board types double-folded inverted-L antennas (DFILAs), which are the horizontal printed DFILA and the vertical printed DFILA, have been proposed. By taking advantage of the printed circuit technologies, the manufacturing processes of the DFILAs can be simplified. The proposed antennas are low profile, lightweight, and simple in structure. Both antennas perform right-hand circular polarization with center frequency of 2.4 GHz. Both antennas have impedance bandwidths of over 7% (S11<10dB) and axial ratios of 2.5% (< 3dB). The gains of the two antennas are higher than 6.4 dBi. One of the designs has a simple feeding network with a DC grounded stub, which can improve the impedance matching and provide static discharges for the DFILA. V C 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Microwave Opt Technol Lett 54:2719–2725, 2012; View this article online at wileyonlinelibrary.com. DOI 10.1002/mop.27181 Key words: wire antenna; printed circuit board; circular polarization 1. INTRODUCTION Circular polarization has the advantages of reducing multipath effect, inclement weather, and suitable for line-of-sight between a transmitter and receiver. Therefore, it is suitable for satellite communication, global positioning system, radar tracking, and RFID. For wireless communication, the use of a circularly polar- ized antenna with the same corresponding hand is necessary to optimize the quality. Wire antennas, such as helix [1–3] and spi- ral [4, 5], are some classical examples of circularly polarized antenna. Patch [6, 7] and dielectric resonator antenna [8, 9] can be utilized to produce circularly polarized radiation; however, they, respectively, have the weakness of narrow band and Figure 7 Phase and group delay responses of the back-to-back con- nection of two proposed coaxial-to-microstrip transitions Figure 8 Frequency responses of a single proposed coaxial-to-micro- strip transition DOI 10.1002/mop MICROWAVE AND OPTICAL TECHNOLOGY LETTERS / Vol. 000, No. 000, December 2012 2719
Transcript

of the microstrip line and the misalignment of the via arrays in

the substrate ought to be examined. Simulation results indicate

that the performance of the proposed transition can tolerate fab-

rication and assembly errors to a reasonable amount. For a

microstrip line fabricated on a substrate thinner than the gap,

solder on the via arrays is required to prevent sideward leakage

through the additional air space above the substrate within the

gap. Thicker substrates are not discussed here because they usu-

ally are not considered for high-frequency applications. The new

connector is also proved to be suitable for the transitions

between various coaxial cables/connectors and different planar

transmission lines, such as K-to-microstrip, semi-rigid cable-to-

microstrip, and SMA-to-CPW transitions as well.

5. CONCLUSION

A new SMA connector designed for coaxial-to-microstrip transi-

tions is presented. The connector is combined with two via

arrays embedded in the substrate of the microstrip line to facili-

tate the transformation of the field distributions of the two trans-

mission lines. Hence, the high-frequency performance of the

transition is improved significantly. The design offers reasonable

amount of tolerances for the fabrication errors of the new con-

nector and the via arrays. It can apply to the transitions between

other cables/connectors and planar transmission lines as well.

These features make the proposed design most suitable for high-

frequency applications.

REFERENCES

1. R.L. Eisenhart, A better microstrip connector, In: Proc IEEE-MTT

Symp, 1978, pp. 318–320.

2. J. Chenkin, dc to 40 GHz coaxial-to-microstrip transition for 100-

l-thick GaAs substrates, IEEE Trans Microwave Theory Tech 37

(1989), 1147–1150.

3. J.-C. Cheng, E.S. Li, W.-F. Chou, and K.-L. Huang, Improving the

high-frequency performance of coaxial-to-microstrip transitions,

IEEE Trans Microwave Theory Tech 59 (2011), 1468–1477.

4. HFSS (High frequency structure synthesizer) ver. 11, Ansoft Cor-

poration, Pittsburgh, PA, 2007.

5. F. Shigeki, Waveguide line, (in Japanese) Japan Patent 06-053 711,

1994.

6. R.A. Soares, P. Gouzien, P. Leguad, and G. Follot, A unified mathe-

matical ap- proach to two-port calibration techniques and some appli-

cations, IEEE Trans. Microwave Theory Tech 37 (1989), 1669–1674.

VC 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

PRINTED CIRCULARLY POLARIZED WIREANTENNAS WITH DC GROUNDED STUB

Song Wang,1 Ka Ming Mak,2 Hau Wah Lai,2,3 Kwok Kan So,2,3

Quan Xue,2,3 and Guisheng Liao1

1National Laboratory of Radar Signal Processing, Xidian University,Xi’an 710071, China2 State Key Laboratory of Millimeter waves (HK), City University ofHong Kong SAR, China3 Shenzhen Research Institute, City University of Hong Kong,Shenzhen, China; Corresponding author: [email protected]

Received 13 March 2012

ABSTRACT: Two new printed circuit board types double-folded

inverted-L antennas (DFILAs), which are the horizontal printed DFILAand the vertical printed DFILA, have been proposed. By takingadvantage of the printed circuit technologies, the manufacturing

processes of the DFILAs can be simplified. The proposed antennas arelow profile, lightweight, and simple in structure. Both antennas perform

right-hand circular polarization with center frequency of 2.4 GHz. Bothantennas have impedance bandwidths of over 7% (S11<�10dB) andaxial ratios of 2.5% (< 3dB). The gains of the two antennas are higher

than 6.4 dBi. One of the designs has a simple feeding network with aDC grounded stub, which can improve the impedance matching andprovide static discharges for the DFILA. VC 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

Microwave Opt Technol Lett 54:2719–2725, 2012; View this article

online at wileyonlinelibrary.com. DOI 10.1002/mop.27181

Key words: wire antenna; printed circuit board; circular polarization

1. INTRODUCTION

Circular polarization has the advantages of reducing multipath

effect, inclement weather, and suitable for line-of-sight between

a transmitter and receiver. Therefore, it is suitable for satellite

communication, global positioning system, radar tracking, and

RFID. For wireless communication, the use of a circularly polar-

ized antenna with the same corresponding hand is necessary to

optimize the quality. Wire antennas, such as helix [1–3] and spi-

ral [4, 5], are some classical examples of circularly polarized

antenna. Patch [6, 7] and dielectric resonator antenna [8, 9] can

be utilized to produce circularly polarized radiation; however,

they, respectively, have the weakness of narrow band and

Figure 7 Phase and group delay responses of the back-to-back con-

nection of two proposed coaxial-to-microstrip transitions

Figure 8 Frequency responses of a single proposed coaxial-to-micro-

strip transition

DOI 10.1002/mop MICROWAVE AND OPTICAL TECHNOLOGY LETTERS / Vol. 000, No. 000, December 2012 2719

expensive. This makes them not popular for circularly polarized

application when comparing with wire antenna.

Circularly polarized wire antennas, such as helical and spiral

antennas, have the advantages of simple in structure, low cost,

wideband, and ease of fabrication. They have good radiating

performance. Most importantly, their design procedures can eas-

ily be found in antenna textbook. However, their sizes are too

large and not suitable for portable devices. Even though there

are some wire types antennas with smaller size proposed in the

literature [10–13], all of them need a balun or a height of quar-

ter wavelength. The above configurations make the structures of

these antennas becoming complicated and high profile.

A low profile and miniature small circularly polarized

antenna is proposed in 2010 [14]. The antenna, with two dou-

ble-folded inverted-L arms, has good performance and is simple

in structure. However, this design has a disadvantage of difficult

to solder the two double-folded arms and the feeding probe

together. It is noted that the soldering point is sensitive to the

axial ratio (AR) of the antenna. Even they can be jointed to-

gether by soldering; the performance of the antenna may not be

repeated due to the phase of the two orthogonal modes changed.

It is not convenient for mass production due to its vulnerable

structure. The radiation pattern of this antenna at yz-plane (/ ¼90�) is not symmetric enough along the boresight direction.

In this article, we demonstrate that the double-folded

inverted-L antenna (DFILA) can be constructed by using the

printed circuit board (PCB) technique. The production simplicity

of the presented antennas is slightly significant. It is also demon-

strated that a more symmetrical radiation pattern can be

obtained when comparing with the original wire antenna in Ref.

14. Two fabrication methods, which are named the horizontal

printed DFILA (HP-DFILA) and vertical printed DFILA (VP-

DFILA), are studied. The polarizations of both antennas are in

right-hand direction. For the VP-DFILA, it has been proved by

Figure 1 Geometry of the HP DFILA

Figure 2 Measured and simulated reflection coefficient of the HP-DFILA. [Color figure can be viewed in the online issue, which is available at

wileyonlinelibrary.com]

2720 MICROWAVE AND OPTICAL TECHNOLOGY LETTERS / Vol. 000, No. 000, December 2012 DOI 10.1002/mop

both simulation and experiment that by introducing a simple

matching network, the impedance matching of the antenna can

be improved effectively.

2. HORIZONTAL PRINTED DFILA

2.1. Antenna GeometryThe geometry of the HP-DFILA is shown in Figure 1. It shows

that the antenna has two square PCB layers, two pins, a feeding

probe, and a ground plane. The material of the PCB is FR4 (er

¼ 4.4) and its thickness is 1.6 mm. There are two strip lines,

which have widths of 1.5 mm, printed on the top and bottom

surface of PCB layer 1. They, respectively, have length La4 ¼29.5 mm (0.236 k0) and La3 ¼ 25 mm (0.2 k0), and they are

located along y and x direction. There is a V-shape strip line

with arm lengths La1 ¼ 25.5 mm (0.204 k0) and La2 ¼ 25.5 mm

(0.204 k0) and width 1mm (0.008 k0) etching orthogonally on

the bottom side of PCB layer 2. The strip lines on PCB layer 1

are connected to this V-shape strip line on PCB layer 2 by sol-

dering the conducting pin-a1 and pin-a2. Both conducting pins

have diameter of 1 mm (0.008 k0) and their lengths Da1 and Da2

are 6.9 mm (0.0552 k0) and 8.5 mm (0.068 k0), respectively.

The lengths of the two square PCBs are the same and equal to

45 mm (0.36 k0). These PCBs are supported by plastic spacers

and fixed by plastic screws. For the excitation, there is a feeding

probe linked between a SMA connector and the intersection

point between La1 and La2 of the V shape strip line. The length

of the feeding probe is Ha and is equal to 9 mm (0.072 k0). It

can be seen in Figure 1 that the feeding position is the center of

the circular ground plane. The diameter of the circular ground

plane is 130 mm (1.04 k0). The total lengths of the double-

folded inverted-L lines at the x direction and y direction are,

respectively, 0.53 k0 (¼ Ha þ La1 þ Da1 þ La3) and 0.58 k0

(¼ Ha þ La2 þ Da2 þ La4).

2.2. Simulated and Experimental ResultsThe performances of the two antennas (HP-DFILA and VP-

DFILA) were modeled and validated by a commercial finite-ele-

ment analysis software HFSS. The measured impedance match-

ing is obtained by a VNA E5071C; while the gain and radiation

pattern of the antennas are measured by the Satimo STARLAB

near-field measurement system.

Figure 2 shows the simulated and measured reflection coeffi-

cient of the HP-DFILA. Results show that the simulated fre-

quency range for reflection coefficient below �10dB is between

2.26 and 2.52 GHz, which is 11%; while the corresponding

range by measurement is between 2.27 and 2.49 GHz and has a

bandwidth of 9.24%. In Figure 3, it is shown that the simulated

and measured AR bandwidths (less than 3dB) are 3.74%

(�2.36–2.45 GHz) and 2.7% (�2.4–2.465 GHz). The frequency

with minimum AR is 2.4 GHz by simulation and is 2.43 GHz

by measurement. The percentage error between simulation and

experiment is 1.25%. Figure 3 also shows the simulated and

measured gains of the antenna in the boresight direction. It is

noted that the gain is 6.8 dBi at 2.43 GHz. The simulated gain

is around 0.4 dB less than the measured gain. The difference

between theoretical and experiment is only 5%.

In Figure 4(a), the simulated radiation pattern of the antenna

at 2.4 GHz is plotted. It can be seen that the antenna is right

hand circularly polarized as the right-hand circularly polarized

radiation is much stronger than the left-hand circularly polarized

radiation. The simulated 3 dB beamwidth is about 74.5� in / ¼0� plane (xz-plane) and 69� in / ¼ 90� plane (yz-plane). In Fig-

ure 4(b), the measured radiation pattern at 2.43 GHz of the HP-

DFILA is shown. The radiation pattern at this frequency is

shown because minimum AR is obtained by measurement. The

measured 3 dB beamwidth is about 80� in / ¼ 0� plane and

74� in / ¼ 90� plane. The LHCP level is 14 dB lower than the

RHCP level and the back lobe level of the antenna is below

16 dB across the operating bandwidth. The results show that the

Figure 3 Measured and simulated gain and AR of the HP-DFILA.

[Color figure can be viewed in the online issue, which is available at

wileyonlinelibrary.com]

Figure 4 Radiation pattern of the HP-DFILA (a) simulated at 2.4 GHz and (b) measured at 2.43 GHz

DOI 10.1002/mop MICROWAVE AND OPTICAL TECHNOLOGY LETTERS / Vol. 000, No. 000, December 2012 2721

3-dB beamwidth of the antenna is stable in both 0 and 90�

planes across the operating bandwidth.

3. VERTICAL PRINTED DFILA

3.1. Antenna GeometryThe geometry of the VP-DFILA is shown in Figure 5. The

antenna has three PCBs, a feeding probe, and a ground plane.

As shown in Figure 5, the material of the two vertical PCBs is

FR4 with thicknesses of 1.6 mm. The two PCBs, which are

PCB-X and PCB-Y, are intersected together orthogonally and

form a ‘‘X’’ shape structure. Both FR4 PCBs have a double-

folded inverted-L strip line etching on one surface. A bended

portion is designed at Lb3. It is bended downward with e ¼ 2

mm to prevent the two double-folded inverted-L lines overlap-

ping together at point E; while the two metal lines are soldered

together at point ‘‘C’’. The widths of the lines are 1 mm. The

total length of the double-folded inverted-L lines at x and ydirection are 0.48 and 0.52 k0, respectively. Their detail lengths

are clearly shown in Figures 5(c) and 5(d). The size of the VP-

DFILA is the same as the HP-DFILA in Section 2

Even though the AR bandwidth of the VP-DFILA has been

optimized, its impedance cannot be matched to 50 X at 2.4

GHz. It is because when the two double-folded inverted-L lines

are located vertically, the resistive impedance reduced and the

reactive impedance increased. The impedance matching of the

antenna cannot be optimized to 50 X by tuning the parameters

of the two double-folded inverted-L lines on PCB-X and PCB-

Y. To optimize the impedance of the antenna, an extra matching

network printed on MN-PCB is used. The thickness of the MN-

PCB is 1 mm and its dielectric constant is 2.65. For the resistive

impedance, a microstrip line with quarter wavelength is used to

increase the resistive impedance. The width and length of the

quarter wavelength are, respectively, 3.5 mm (0.046 kg) and 21

mm (0.27 kg). While to reduce the reactive impedance, a short

circuit stub is introduced. The width and length of the short cir-

cuit stub are, respectively, 2 mm (0.026 kg) and 7.5 mm (0.098

kg). The microstrip line with quarter wavelength transform has

one end connected to the DFILA at point ‘‘J’’ and one end con-

nected to a SMA connector by a feeding probe.

3.2. Simulated and Experimental ResultsFigure 6 gives the simulated as well as the measured reflection

coefficients of the VP-DFILA. It can be seen that the measured

impedance bandwidth (reflection coefficient < �10dB) is 7.6%,

which is from 2.345 to 2.535 GHz; while the corresponding

simulated result is 8.8% and the range is between 2.34 and

Figure 5 Geometry of the VP DFILA. [Color figure can be viewed in the online issue, which is available at wileyonlinelibrary.com]

Figure 6 Measured and simulated reflection coefficient of the VP-

DFILA. [Color figure can be viewed in the online issue, which is avail-

able at wileyonlinelibrary.com]

2722 MICROWAVE AND OPTICAL TECHNOLOGY LETTERS / Vol. 000, No. 000, December 2012 DOI 10.1002/mop

2.555 GHz. Both of them can cover 2.4 GHz. Figure 8 shows

the 3-dB AR bandwidths of the VP-DFILA by measurement

and HFSS simulation. It can be seen that the measured and

simulated AR bandwidth is 2.5 and 2.9%. The minimum AR is

achieved at 2.4 GHz by simulation and at 2.415 by experiment.

It is demonstrated in Figure 7 that the VP-DFILA has meas-

ured gain of 6.5 dBi and simulated gain of 6 dBi at the þzdirection.

The simulated and measured radiation patterns of the VP-

DFILA are illustrated in Figure 8. For a fair comparison, the

radiation patterns with minimum AR are studied. The simulated

radiation pattern at 2.4 GHz and measured radiation pattern at

2.415 GHz are plotted. The difference between simulation and

experiment in percentage is 0.625%, which is very low. The

data show that the polarization of this antenna is right hand,

which is same as the HP-DFILA in Section 2.

From the simulated radiation in Figure 8(a), it shows that the

antenna has simulated half power beamwidths of 81.5� at / ¼0� plane and 77.5� at / ¼ 90� plane. The measured half power

beamwidths at / ¼ 0� and 90� plane are both 74�, which is

shown in Figure 8(b). The measured LHCP level is 16 dB lower

than the RHCP level and the back lobe level of the antenna is

below 18 dB across the operating bandwidth. Results show that

the 3-dB beamwidth of the antenna is stable in both 0� and 90�

planes across the operating bandwidth.

Figure 7 Measured and simulated gain and AR of the VP-DFILA.

[Color figure can be viewed in the online issue, which is available at

wileyonlinelibrary.com]

Figure 8 Radiation pattern of the VP-DFILA (a) simulated at 2.4 GHz (b) measured at 2.415 GHz

Figure 9 Prototype of the HP-DFILA. [Color figure can be viewed in the online issue, which is available at wileyonlinelibrary.com]

DOI 10.1002/mop MICROWAVE AND OPTICAL TECHNOLOGY LETTERS / Vol. 000, No. 000, December 2012 2723

4. DISCUSSION

By using PCB technique, two simple and practical circularly

polarized antennas are fabricated. They are the HP-DFILA and

VP-DFILA. Their prototypes are shown in Figures 9 and 10,

respectively. It is commonly known that fabrication by PCB is

very suitable for mass production as the manufacturing process

becoming simpler. By using PCB to fabricate antenna, the per-

formances can also be repeatable.

Other than having several advantages in manufacturing, the

results in this article also show that the performance of the

DFILA [14] can be improved, which is mainly in the radiation

pattern. Figure 5 shows the radiation pattern of the HP-DFILA.

It is noted that the radiation pattern is very symmetric at / ¼ 0�

plane; while there is a two or three degree rotation toward the

anticlockwise direction at / ¼ 90�. Figure 8 shows the radiation

pattern of the VP-DFILA. It is demonstrated that the symmetric

radiation pattern has been obtained at / ¼ 0� plane. However,

there is a one degree rotation toward the anticlockwise direction

at / ¼ 90�. Even though no perfectly symmetric radiation pat-

terns have been obtained by both HP-DFILA and VP-DFILA,

they are already very symmetric when compared with the origi-

nal DFILA. The data of the DFILA in Ref. 14 show that the

radiation pattern in the xz plane (/ ¼ 0�) is symmetric along

the þz direction. However, the radiation pattern in the yz plane

(/ ¼ 90�) is not symmetric enough along the þz direction,

which has an angle of eight rotation toward the anticlockwise

direction. Results show that the use of PCB can produce a more

symmetric radiation pattern than the original wire version.

Both of the two proposed antennas have good performance

and suitable for mass production. VP-DFILA is more preferable

than HP-DFILA if we have to choose a better one among them.

First, the numbers of soldering points of the VP-DFILA are

lesser than the HP-DFILA. It is commonly known that the more

soldering points, the more errors appear. In addition, the struc-

ture of the VP-DFILA is more robust and the numbers of sup-

porting spacers are lesser.

The VP-DFILA also has DC grounded stub. It can provide

impedance matching to the antenna and can help to control

static discharges from the antenna. The other advantage of add-

ing DC ground is for safety issue. If the antenna were to come

into contact with a live overhead power line, the DC ground can

help to prevent damage of the RF circuitry or other equipment.

5. CONCLUSION

In this article, two printed wire antennas are proposed for mass

production in industry. The impedance and AR bandwidth of

both proposed antennas are over 7 (S11 < �10dB) and 2.5%

(AR < 3 dB). The gains of the two antennas are higher than 6.4

dBi. The antennas are ease of fabrication and have a symmetri-

cal radiation patterns. As the proposed antennas have center fre-

quency of around 2.4 GHz, which is suitable for RFID or WiFi

systems.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

This project is supported by the National Natural Science Founda-

tion of China (Grant No. 61002005) and the Shenzhen Science and

Technology Planning Project for the Establishment of Key Labora-

tory in 2009 (CXB 200903090021A).

REFERENCES

1. C. Gerst and R.A. Worden, Helix antenna take turn for better,

Electronics (1996), 100–110.

2. H. Nakano, Y. Samada, and J. Yamauchi, Axial mode helical

antennas, IEEE Trans Antennas Propag 34 (1986), 1143–1148.

3. J.M. Tranquilla and S.R. Best, A study of the quadrifilar helix

antenna for global positioning system (GPS) applications, IEEE

Trans Antennas Propag 38 (1990), 1545–1549.

4. H. Nakano, K. Nogami, S. Arai, H. Mimaki, and J. Yamauchi, A

spiral antenna backed by a conducting plane reflector, IEEE Trans

Antennas Propag 34 (1986), 791–796.

5. C.H. Liu, Y.G. Lu, C.L. Du, J.B. Cui, and X.M. Shen, The broad-

band spiral antenna design based on hybrid backed-cavity, IEEE

Trans Antennas Propag 58 (2010), 1876–1882.

6. J.H. Lu, C.L. Tand, and K.L. Wong, Single-feed slotted equilat-

eral-triangular microstrip antenna for circular polarization, IEEE

Trans Antennas Propag 47 (1999), 1174–1178.

7. H. Wong, K.K. So, K.B. Ng, K.M. Luk, C.H. Chan, and Q. Xue,

Virtually shorted patch antenna for circular polarization, IEEE

Antennas Wireless Propag Lett 9 (2010), 1213–1216.

8. B. Li, K. K. So, and K.W. Leung, A circularly polarized dielectric

resonator antenna excited by an asymmetrical U-slot with a back-

ing cavity, IEEE Antennas Wireless Propag Lett 2 (2003),

133–135.

9. K.W. Leung and K.K. So, Frequency-tunable designs of the line-

arly and circularly polarized dielectric resonator antennas using a

parasitic slot, IEEE Trans Antennas Propag 53 (2005), 572–576.

Figure 10 Prototype of the VP-DFILA. [Color figure can be viewed in the online issue, which is available at wileyonlinelibrary.com]

2724 MICROWAVE AND OPTICAL TECHNOLOGY LETTERS / Vol. 000, No. 000, December 2012 DOI 10.1002/mop

10. R.L. Li and V.F. Fusco, Circularly polarized twisted loop antenna,

IEEE Trans Antennas Propag 50 (2002), 1377–1381.

11. R.L. Li and V.F. Fusco, Printed figure-of-eight wire antenna for

circular polarization, IEEE Trans Antennas Propag 50 (2002),

1487–1490.

12. V.F. Fusco, R. Cahill, and R.L. Li, Quadrifilar loop antenna, IEEE

Trans Antennas Propag 51 (2003), 115–120.

13. Y. B. Zhang and L. Zhu, Printed dual spiral-loop wire antenna for

broadband circular polarization, IEEE Trans Antennas Propag 54

(2006), 284–288.

14. X. Yang, Y.Z. Yin, W. Hu, and S.L. Zuo, Low-profile, small circu-

larly polarized inverted-L antenna with double-folded arms, IEEE

Antennas Wireless Propag Lett 9 (2010), 767–770.

VC 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

JITTER IN ANALOG OPTICAL LINKSUSING A QUADRATURE-BIASEDMACH–ZEHNDER MODULATOR

Jong-Dug Shin,1 Young-Min Yoon,1 Jaehee Park,2

and Ray T. Chen3

1 School of Electronic Engineering, Soongsil University, 369Sangdo-ro, Dongjak-gu, Seoul 156-743, Korea; Correspondingauthor: [email protected] Department of Electronic Engineering, Keimyung University,Sindang-dong, Dalseo-gu, Daegu 704-701, Korea3Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, theUniversity of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX 78758

Received 13 March 2012

ABSTRACT: Characteristics of jitter have been investigated in a 10-GHz analog optical link using a quadrature-biased Mach–Zehnder

modulator followed by an erbium-doped fiber amplifier (EDFA) and aPIN photodiode. For the case of low optical input power, jitter variesinversely with input power, indicating the thermal noise limited

characteristic. For high input optical power, jitter saturates at aminimum for different RF power levels for the configuration without

EDFA. For the configuration using EDFA, jitter is also inverselyproportional to EDFA gain but shows different minima for differentinput optical power with output power fixed by adjusting EDFA gain

because of amplified spontaneous noise noise. VC 2012 Wiley Periodicals,

Inc. Microwave Opt Technol Lett 54:2725–2727, 2012; View this article

online at wileyonlinelibrary.com. DOI 10.1002/mop.27196

Key words: analog optical link; erbium-doped fiber amplifier; jitter;quadrature bias; Mach–Zehnder modulator

1. INTRODUCTION

Analog optical links operating in the intensity-modulation and

direct-detection mode have many applications such as in signal

distribution systems and antenna remoting systems [1]. The

transmitters in these links have a common configuration consist-

ing of a Mach–Zehnder modulator (MZM) followed by an er-

bium-doped fiber amplifier (EDFA). For broadband applications,

the MZM is quadrature-biased to have the maximum linearity

by eliminating second-order distortion [2]. The EDFA is used to

generate high optical power for better link performance such as

loss compensation and higher dynamic range.

In general, analog optical link performance has been consid-

ered in terms of gain, bandwidth, noise figure, and dynamic

range. Short pulse transmission such as ultrashort optical clock,

optical sampling pulse, and signals for broadband phased array

antennas is increasing in analog optical links. Timing accuracy

is an important factor for these cases. For example, the main

beam direction changes due to timing error caused by noise in a

phased array antenna system controlled by a true-time delay

beam-former [3]. Therefore, we need to consider the link per-

formance at a different perspective, jitter. Jitter is a random dis-

turbance of signal from an ideal timing position in a short period

of time and a function of noise, slew rate, bandwidth, and so

forth [4]. The noise sources contributing to jitter are phase noise

around the carrier frequency, spur, and broadband white noise.

Noise in electronic circuits is generally modeled as a random

Gaussian process and jitter is linearly proportional to the root-

mean-square noise and inversely proportional to the slew rate if

the noise power is much smaller than the signal power [5]. As

signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) is inversely proportional to noise

power, we can relate SNR with jitter. It has been known that the

SNR of an optical receiver using a PIN diode varies as the square

of input optical power in the thermal noise limit, which is the

usual case. However, at higher optical power the relative intensity

noise (RIN) of optical source sets the maximum SNR [2]. EDFA

induces the phase noise due to the amplified spontaneous noise

(ASE), resulting in the main beam jitter around a mean direction

in an optically fed phased array antenna [6].

In this article, we investigate jitter characteristics for broad-

band analog optical links consisting of a laser and a quadrature-

biased MZM followed by an EDFA at the transmitter, and a

PIN photodiode at the receiver. In Section 2, we examine how

RF power and optical power input to the MZM would influence

jitter characteristics in a 10-GHz optical link. Second, the effect

of EDFA gain on jitter has been studied for different optical

power levels. Finally, Section 3 summarizes the article.

2. EXPERIMENTS AND DISCUSSION

The experimental setup for measuring jitter is shown in

Figure 1.

A distributed feedback laser diode operating at a wavelength

of 1554.93 nm with an output power of 8 mW is intensity

modulated by a MZM. The RIN of the laser is �145 dB/Hz,

typ. A variable optical attenuator is used to adjust the optical

power level at the MZM input. The MZM is a LiNbO3-based

modulator operating at 1550 nm with a typical insertion loss of

about 8.2 dB, Vp of 3.6 V, and an offset voltage of 2.5 V. The

MZM was quadrature-biased at 4.3 V and driven by a 10-GHz

RF carrier signal. Because the 10-dB electrical bandwidth of the

modulator is about 16-GHz, an electrical low pass filter with a

cutoff frequency of 10.2-GHz was inserted in the RF gain block

to limit the system bandwidth. The overall gain and noise figure

of the RF gain block were measured to be about 36.3 and 8.8

dB at 10-GHz, respectively.

Jitter was measured in both frequency and time domain. An

Agilent E4440A PSA series spectrum analyzer was used for the

frequency domain measurement. As the frequency range of the

system is 10 MHz–10.2 GHz, we have to separate the spectral

range into two regions to obtain jitter, that is, one in 9.9–10.1

GHz where the frequency dependent components are present

and the other for the rest spectral region where only white noise

is present. The phase jitter rDtu ¼ 12pf0

ffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi2R fhflLuðf Þdf

qin 9.9–

10.1 GHz region is directly measured utilizing the phase jitter

measurement option of the spectrum analyzer from the lower

offset frequency of 10 Hz (fl) to the higher offset frequency of

100 MHz (fh) around the center frequency of 10 GHz (f0) [7].

Lu(f) is the single sideband phase noise. For the rest of the fre-

quency range, the jitter due to white noise rDtn was calculated

using the measured RF signal power and noise floor with the RF

signal turned off. As the jitters at both regions are independent

each other, the total jitter was then calculated using the

DOI 10.1002/mop MICROWAVE AND OPTICAL TECHNOLOGY LETTERS / Vol. 000, No. 000, December 2012 2725


Recommended