Privileged and Confidential
Strategic Approach to Asset Management
Strategic Approach to Asset Management
Presented to
October 2004
2004Urban Water Council
Regional Seminar
Privileged and Confidential
Infrastructure Needs / PerceptionsInfrastructure Needs / Perceptions
Need to be cost competitive
Aging Infrastructure
EPA Reports
Accounting Changes
Privileged and Confidential
Common Asset Management MythsCommon Asset Management Myths
Regulatory Issue
Information Technology Issue
Preventive Maintenance Issue
Who is Responsible
One-time Event
If You Ignore it – It Will go Away
Privileged and Confidential
Myth 1 – Regulatory IssueMyth 1 – Regulatory Issue
GASB 34 is the answer - If you comply with the regulations you are practicing good asset management.
Privileged and Confidential
Myth 2 – Information TechnologyMyth 2 – Information Technology
IT is the answer
Software – it is just a matter of having the right software
Privileged and Confidential
Myth 3 – Preventive MaintenanceMyth 3 – Preventive Maintenance
A preventive maintenance program will take care of your asset management needs
Privileged and Confidential
Myth 4 –ResponsibilityMyth 4 –Responsibility
Asset management is the responsibility of:
Engineers
Accountants
IT
Management
Privileged and Confidential
Myth 5 – One-time EventMyth 5 – One-time Event
An asset management report is the solution!
Privileged and Confidential
Myth 6 – Ignore itMyth 6 – Ignore it
Asset management is just another fad – it too will pass
Privileged and Confidential
Defining Asset ManagementDefining Asset Management
“an on-going process which enables managers to optimize the investment in their assets resulting in reduced operating and capital costs and improved business sustainability”
AM is the alignment of a utility’s business processes to provide for a more efficient and effective operation.
An effective program will turn the reams of data that today’s utilities generate with their customer information systems, GIS, preventive maintenance, financial and related systems into meaningful information, with which managers can make informed decisions, resulting in cost savings for operations and capital expenditures.
Privileged and Confidential
Asset ManagementGoals and ObjectivesAsset ManagementGoals and Objectives
Identify, develop or enhance business processes that cut across all business units
Identify the critical business areas that will create value and illustrate the probability of success.
Production Distribution
BusinessFunctions
InventoryProcurement
PreventativeMaintenance
GIS
FleetMaintenance
MeterReading
Billing
NewConnections
Production Distribution
Va
lue
Ch
ain
Su
pp
ly C
ha
in
CustomerService
ValueValueCreationCreation
A & G Support Functions
Management
Asset Management Program
Production Distribution
BusinessFunctions
InventoryProcurement
PreventativeMaintenance
GIS
FleetMaintenance
MeterReading
Billing
NewConnections
Production Distribution
Va
lue
Ch
ain
Su
pp
ly C
ha
in
CustomerService
ValueValueCreationCreation
A & G Support Functions
Management
Asset Management Program
Only Issues with an impact of more than X million dollars to the 10 Year NPV are integrated.
Organics Legislation
Water Supply Prices
Weather Impacts
Operator retirements
Main Distribution Pipeline upgrades
Customer Growth
Dam Inspections
0 20 40 8060-80 -60 -40 -20
NPV, ($ millions)
Only Issues with an impact of more than X million dollars to the 10 Year NPV are integrated.
Organics Legislation
Water Supply Prices
Weather Impacts
Operator retirements
Main Distribution Pipeline upgrades
Customer Growth
Dam Inspections
0 20 40 8060-80 -60 -40 -20
NPV, ($ millions)
Privileged and Confidential
Asset ManagementGoals and Objectives
Provide effective monitoring capabilities which allow decision makers to manage identified opportunities
Prevent value destruction by stabilizing and positioning the organization for integration and implementation
StatusQuo
Step 1 Situation Analysis
Step 2 Feasibility
Review
Step 4 Implementing and Anchoring
Step 3 Planning and
Design
Resource Commitment
Resource Commitment
Resource Commitment
Resource Commitment
Situation Executive Review
Feasibility Executive Review
Planning Executive Review
Closure Executive Review
StatusQuo
Step 1 Situation Analysis
Step 2 Feasibility
Review
Step 4 Implementing and Anchoring
Step 3 Planning and
Design
Resource Commitment
Resource Commitment
Resource Commitment
Resource Commitment
Situation Executive Review
Feasibility Executive Review
Planning Executive Review
Closure Executive Review
Privileged and Confidential
Major ElementsMajor Elements Strategy - Develop a robust program within strategic framework.
Business Review - Implement with respect to critical business needs and without impact to scheduled operations.
Technology Review - Implement technology that can support processes at the business unit level but that can also be supported at the enterprise level.
Implementation Planning - Identify an implementation schedule based on the program and corresponding costs.
Pilot Implementation - Implement in a critical business area for near term benefit and optimize implementation aspects.
Monitoring - Provide enterprise level tools and processes to supervise and examine the on-going success of the program
Change and Knowledge Management - Establish Change and Knowledge Management processes to build executive sponsorship, support management decisions, and empower staff.
Privileged and Confidential
AM Typical Work PlanAM Typical Work Plan
Three Stages
Strategize
Develop
Implement
ImplementationPlan
Enterprise AM Plan Development
Current Technology Review
Current Monitoring Capabilities
Current Business ReviewDevelop StrategicDirection
GapAnalysis
ImplementationServices
ImplementationPlan
Enterprise AM Plan Development
Current Technology Review
Current Monitoring Capabilities
Current Business ReviewDevelop StrategicDirection
GapAnalysis
ImplementationServices
Privileged and Confidential
Typical Strategizing ActivitiesTypical Strategizing Activities
Conduct Management Interviews and Planning Sessions
Develop Organizational Assessment Objectives
Develop IT Systems Assessment Objectives
Develop AM Targets
Develop AM Plan Gap / Needs Analysis Objectives
ImplementationPlan
Enterprise AM Plan Development
Current Technology Review
Current Monitoring Capabilities
Current Business Review
Develop StrategicDirection
GapAnalysis
ImplementationServices
ImplementationPlan
Enterprise AM Plan Development
Current Technology Review
Current Monitoring Capabilities
Current Business Review
Develop StrategicDirection
GapAnalysis
ImplementationServices
Privileged and Confidential
Typical Business ReviewsTypical Business Reviews
Customer Service
Financial Planning and Forecasting
Organizational Alignment
Failure Analysis / Risk Management
Financial
Budgeting
Privileged and Confidential
Typical Technology ReviewsTypical Technology Reviews
Financial Systems Supply Chain/Asset Procurement Maintenance Management Condition Assessment AM Training GIS HR CIS
Privileged and Confidential
Typical Monitoring CapabilitiesTypical Monitoring Capabilities
Performance Measures
Asset Inventory / Registers
Life Cycle Management
Optimized Decision Making
Data Collection and Reporting
Asset Valuation and Depreciation
Capital Budgeting
Life Cycle Costing
Privileged and Confidential
Gap AnalysisGap Analysis
Planning
Operations
Information Systems
Accounting
Privileged and Confidential
Typical Implementation ActivitiesTypical Implementation Activities
Strategy
Functional Requirements
Operational / Tactical Requirements
Supporting Technology
Monitoring Requirements
Business Case Analysis - Value Creation
Enterprise AM Plan Development
Current Technology Review
Current Monitoring Capabilities
Current Business ReviewDevelop StrategicDirection
GapAnalysis
ImplementationServices
ImplementationPlan
Enterprise AM Plan Development
Current Technology Review
Current Monitoring Capabilities
Current Business ReviewDevelop StrategicDirection
GapAnalysis
ImplementationServices
ImplementationPlan
Privileged and Confidential
Development of meaningful internal and external strategic and financial plans.
Incorporation of the financial measures, determined in the Evaluation and Integration steps, into a cohesive strategy for the client’s business strategies. The integrated strategy links each of the business areas into a cohesive, consistent, meaningful strategy.
The key to building an effective strategy is to reduce downside exposures in order to operate closer to an expected value.
Development of a comprehensive “move forward” plan optimizes the trade off of key NPV drivers and the limited resources that are available.
The final stage of develop is a meaningful communications plan that incorporates the measures identified and the corporate-debit-shareholder impacts.
Value CreationValue Creation
Privileged and Confidential
Identifying a risk profile is critical to maximize value.Identifying a risk profile is critical to maximize value.
The utility that understands the major impacts on an asset, and executes a meaningful corporate strategy, will achieve maximum value for their asset.
$10 $15 $20 $25 $30
NPV, millions
Pro
ba
bil
ity
Reduction inExposure
Reduction in benefit
Expected Value
Initial Distribution
Risk Managed Distribution
Privileged and Confidential
Performance MonitoringPerformance Monitoring
Management Challenges
How to see the ‘big picture’?
How to link day to day actions to strategy?
How to easily communicate performance to the Board?
Could you expand on “Oops, looks like
something bad happened”
Privileged and Confidential
Balance ScorecardBalance Scorecard
‘Balanced’ Scorecard – Measures the entire organization and provides feedback to help in implementing strategies and objectives.
Privileged and Confidential
Performance ManagementPerformance Management
Immediate and Comprehensive way to manage and maximize consistent improvement within the organization,
Linking day-to-day actions with the overall vision, mission, and strategy of the Utility
Privileged and Confidential
Change ManagementChange Management
Change Management Process Organizational Assessment
Face-to-Face Communication Strategy
Develop Transition Plan
Launch Change Management Teams
Define New Roles And Responsibilities
Establish New Learning Channels
Align Leadership Teams
Build Partnerships StatusQuo
Step 1 Situation Analysis
Step 2 Feasibility
Review
Step 4 Implementing and Anchoring
Step 3 Planning and
Design
Resource Commitment
Resource Commitment
Resource Commitment
Resource Commitment
Situation Executive Review
Feasibility Executive Review
Planning Executive Review
Closure Executive Review
StatusQuo
Step 1 Situation Analysis
Step 2 Feasibility
Review
Step 4 Implementing and Anchoring
Step 3 Planning and
Design
Resource Commitment
Resource Commitment
Resource Commitment
Resource Commitment
Situation Executive Review
Feasibility Executive Review
Planning Executive Review
Closure Executive Review
Privileged and Confidential
Change Management Change Management
Change Management Outcomes
No-decline in productivity, profitability and operational excellence
Readiness for next step
Key Management processes in place