Date post: | 04-Jun-2018 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | anders-anderen |
View: | 225 times |
Download: | 0 times |
of 13
8/14/2019 Problematizing Human Milk
1/13
PROBLEMATIZING HUMAN MILK
The case of Bogotas Food and Nutrition Security Policy1
Breastfeeding has been the subject of social policy, concentrating on the bodies of women and
infants and the ways they interact between each other and the greater social space. Although
concentrating its effort with an ideal of the productive body, it goes beyond economic spheres in its
search towards adequate and secure livelihoods, although also as a space where social and
economic development converge, where tensions between individual decision-making and
household/community interests arise, where boundaries between the natural and the modernly
artificial are debated, and coming along an imagination of a hygienized, fit and healthy citizen
subject. This has meant the development of a system that frames human milk as a public/social
good. However, given its particularities it conflicts with other provisioning systems that imaginegoods as the result of an industrializable production process.
This is first paragraph is not clearyou need to make a the statement that breastfeeding appears a
natural private process but within the modern state / economies/ breastfeeding has become the
subject of public interest and concern in relation to biopolitical concerns around security hygiene
food
breastfeeding is subject to different imaginaries and policies around the modern citizens
You need to position yourself and your interest in it theoretically and politically
Is this your introduction to the RPyour problem statementcan you clarify that
Use some quotes, pictures, get some interest in here from the start
Food and nutrition policies, and food and nutrition security (FNS) policies in particular, have become
the space in which breastfeeding (BF) policies are currently locatedin Bogata?. The extent of which
such a statement is true will be illustrated through certainexplored in an analysis of debates
embedded in the 2007 FNS of Bogota (the capital of Colombias capitalColombia) and its historytime
frame?. The RP looks at how the concerns of security are played out in public policy and the
resistances and tensions between global worries about risk and the local responses and challenges.
Security has become a major concern of public policy, especially at a global level, where risk and
probability have become the new lingua franca. However, the global power transmission
mechanisms are met with local power networks that incorporate their messages only partially and
with resistance. The implementation of securitization of human milk poses a gendered resistance
where spaces of possibility [outside the neoliberal loci] emerge.
This RP will explore relevant policy-making of global governance institutions (which are?) and the
conceptualization of [the political economy of] the baby food market (defined by big business,
consumers, governments. It will then ask how the promotion of a universal body (what do you
mean?) came to play a role in such a context. With insights from teratology and the perverse I will
8/14/2019 Problematizing Human Milk
2/13
argue that the body was framed to incorporate risk narratives into the natural body, leaving out
other bodily accounts. With this framework in mind, the discursive translations from the global into
the histories of F(NS) policy at the local (Bogota) will be traced. In particular, it will focus on the
exclusions and resistance during implementation that lead to the incorporation of local resistance inlocal policy.(the actors ?)
This text will continue by analysing whereRP will map out howBF policies are placed into Bogotas
FNS policy, then exploring the conditions of BF policy as biopolitics of BF in Bogato and in the globall
market. and finally the insertion of BF inside the globalized market. The BF policies tend towards
discrimination but not necessarily to individuation or essentialization. They are less deterministic
due to the dynamic framing of metabolism and hormones, also connected to the fluctuating
conception of the female. These last sentences are not clear what are you referring to
conceptualising bodies? Female essentialism? The mapping of individual body onto the social? Vice
versa?
Refer to your theoretical framework what inspired and interested you, why you chose this approach
NOTES ON METHODOLOGY
THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
[I]
BRIEF FRAMING OF BF IN BOGOTAS FNS POLICY
Before discussing the problems behind the juridical appropriation of breastfeeding inside the
spheres of policy and its relevance for the debates such action entails, this is the core of the RP?
Then it should be explained what does juridical appropriation of breastfeeding mean? Which policies
made by who, who resists etc -let me review briefly a history of BF policy of Bogota departing from
the current locus of policy and venturing into an imagined past.
The current Bogotas FNS policy dates from March 2007 when it appeared in written form by the
Inter-sector District Committee on Food and Nutrition (CDIAN 2007), the citys administrative
organism created with the purpose of creating a framework to deal with FNS issues. The document
frames the policy in terms of the right to food resorting to a definition of foods as double natured
(economic) goods: merit and of public interest (p. 18). Food-as-merit-good appeals to food as a need
for individual and social life2, and complementing and not restricted to the UN rights framework.
The second category, goods of public interest, reveals an intention that sets it apart from mere
public goods. The policy goes further and remarks the social, cultural and ecologic values that food
entails (aside from exchange value), even claiming it part of the local immaterial cultural heritage
(CDIAN 2007:19).
This policy text solidifies an effort to bring together in practice life-cycle, gender and environmental
adequacies. When distinguishing the policy dimensions of food, availability, access, consumption and
use3 it makes the case that this last one is fundamental for enjoyment4 (CDIAN 2007:22). It is in
2Merit good is a term revived from 1970s debates after the coining of the term by Musgrave (1957). Thedevelopment of de/merit distinction of goods contributed significantly to the justification of policies suchas food stamps, although the 1970s would marginalize the concept for some years to the neoclassicalschema of externalities.3These categories are shared with the dominant FAO food security framework although Colombiasnational policy differs in the last terming using utilizacin while in Bogotas it is aprovechamiento. A
Formatted:Highlight
8/14/2019 Problematizing Human Milk
3/13
this dimension that the policy places BF, broadening nutrition to the cares during pregnancy and
early age.5 This framing sets an epistemic (?) change with a history of local policy making that
privileged medical discourse. In contrast with policy from a century ago, the emphasis is now on the
pleasurable instead of centring on the avoidance of death.
A HISTORY OF BREASTFEEDING IN BOGOTA (OR TAKING VS. GIVING LIFE)
With the construction of the Colombian nation at the dawn of the twentieth century, productive and
scientific changes were associated with social, cultural, and environmental ones, where hygiene and
eugenic discourses were central to the constitution of social/moral hierarchy through race (Castro-
Gmez 2005). Milk was incorporated into such dynamics following French policy discussions on
vulnerable women and their children (but also the motherless adopted by the state), particularly
with the establishment of milk-stations, Gotas de Leche[Drops-of-Milk6], places created to combat
infant mortality. Centred on the child, mothers are not perceived primarily as birth givers but rather
are depicted in relation to three moral images of potential degeneration or abandonment, nurture-
providers, baby-killers and illness-vectors in relation to breast milk, infanticide and vertical
transmission respectively.
Two works from Bogotas first half of the 20thcentury will serve to illustrate this. They are Troconis
(1912)Apuntaciones sobre la mortalidad infantil en Bogotand Pardo (1920) Consideraciones sobre
las Gotas de Leche. The first one makes the case for the creation of the French devised institutions
in Bogota. The second one is the first study of them after their implementation and which would
contribute to the emergence of the local (and national) public policy in terms of law for its support
(Consejo Municipal de Bogot 1919) diffusion (Congreso de Colombia 1924) and funding (Congreso
de Colombia 1928).
broad distinction can be made turning to their latin roots: the first goes back to profectomeaning truly,really, indeed, while usussignifies use, experience, skill, advantage, profit.4The word in used in the Spanis original is goce from the Latin gaudeo: to rejoice, take delight(University of Notre Dame 2013)5 Los cuidados durante la gestacin y la edad temprana entre otros, son aspectos que modulan elaprovechamiento de los alimentos y determinan el estado de nutricin de los individuos (CDIAN2007:22)6In England these institutions were namedMilk Depots. In some respects, these places resemble currentmilk banks.
Comment [AS1]: Can this be interpretedan hedonistic turn of the time-space
compression in the age of Empire? The use
translation strategies to resist or even
overturn powers from the macro only arise
from within its own possibility space.
Comment [AS2]: The focus of current
reproductive policy anxieties has changed
towards giving life, debating pre-birth comi
into-being leading to debates around
abortion.
8/14/2019 Problematizing Human Milk
4/13
Figure 1. The front pages of the works by Troconis (1912) and Pardo (1920)
The first municipal agreement concerning infant feeding was named By which aid is given to the
Drops-of-Milk institution established in Bogota (ConsejoMunicipal de Bogota 1919) and based its
first consideration on the high infant mortality rate of the nation (Art. 1). The first estimates of infantmortality rates in Bogota appeared at the dawn of the 20th century inside the medical (academic)
establishment. One such early estimate comes from Troconis (1912)7. In a pre-demographic
transition society8, addressing lactation as a strategy towards modernity was a novel import, adding
to the hygienic and eugenic discourses prevalent in the Colombian medico-political establishment9.
They imported the French anxieties of declining and (re)vitalizing populations (as motivated by late
19th century depopulation concerns10). Comparing local statistics to French ones, Troconis affirms
that Bogotas are insufficient and makes the case of the quantitative importance of infant mortality
affirming that the latter ones prove the point for the former case.
7These are the earliest estimates I have found. Further archival work could be useful, especially the citysofficial statistical bulletin Registro Municipal. Troconis (1912:13) complains about the lack of official data,especially by emphasizing available ones elsewhere. His permanent references are, notwithstanding,French.8According to CEPAL (???) Colombia reached the phase of demographic transition near the middle ofthe 20thcentury. Standardization of life/death statistics through the consolidation of measuring systemsare a basis to the current understanding of the demographic transition. The French Loi Rousselof 1874implemented the first efforts to make infant mortality statistics uniform and national, as a response toearlier estimates of declining birth rates. It is through the Law 48 of 1924 (Congreso de Colombia 1924:art.10) that infant birth and mortality statistics become mandatory at the municipal level an centralized atthe national.9 Castro-Gomez (2007) shows how hygienists, physicians and lawyers positioned these advances inscience in the policy-making sphere and how they shape the (capitalist) production of subjectivities duringthe years 1910 and 1930, the time he considers Colombias industrialization beginnings took place.10Declining birth rates during the second half of the 19 thcentury in France became a matter of concernthat as were materialized in the 1874 Loi Roussel. Jacques Bertillon, physician turned statistician andincubator of an international system for the classification of the causes of death, was a founding memberof theAlliane National pour lAcroissement de la Population Franaise.Offen (1984) links geopoliticalchange, mainly the decline of France as world power during the Ancien Regime, to the ordering ofhegemony in terms of population at the interior of patriarchal medical and political discourse to theframing of debates on womens reproductive role or the French thought on the woman question(p.652).
Comment [AS3]: The recurrent use of
French (medical) scholarship and policy in t
early stage is an example of the coloniality
power. Check on Castro-Gomez
8/14/2019 Problematizing Human Milk
5/13
Figure 1 Estimates of infant mortality in Troconis (1912:15-16), Bogotas are presented on the left and French ones on theright.
These types of comparisons are recurrent in Troconis text. His analysis will lead him to state misery
and ignorance are the two overarching factors of infant mortalitys etiologyaetiology(p.37) similar to
(BertillonXX?). After discussing infant mortality and depopulation by cause of death he reaches four
main conclusions (p.37) of which I will centre on two 1) that respiratory infections, gastroenteritis
and stillbirth are the main contributors of infant mortality and 2) that food related illnesses follow.
On his section on illegitimacy (p.16-17) he compares the municipal laws that deal with
(unsupported claims of raising11) infanticide to the French Roussel Law of 1874. In pages 26-27 he
stresses the importance of breastfeeding practices with the irrefutable arguments of Variot . He
also makes claims about Bogotas mothers with syphilis (mothers as vectors) and stillbirths based on
the statistics reported by Fournier, Julien and Le Pileur (p.23-24).
Infanticide
Legitimacy is the moral context by which infant mortality is first understood. Generally, Troconis
argues, the mother and the child are both abandoned by the father, thus forcing the former to work
for both their cares. Illegitimacy thus derives in either the absence of a natural food source or in
infanticide. This is said to be the consequence of mothers taken away from a natural conditionand
from their natural duties, further suggesting that governmental response should be framed into
paternalistic institutions. Private charity, the also private Hospital de la Misericordiaand the public
Hospicio(poorhouse) are presented (p.37-39) as the sole institutions that address infant mortality. It
is the third one that the author considers to implement prophylactic measures against infanticide
(p.38)12.
It is the public institution that faces the heinous crime (p.17). Despite a positive stance about
saving many children from death, [it also acquits] adults from their responsibilities, it does not
tackle the root of evil and Troconis does not doubt for one moment of the powerful influence of
illegitimacy on infant mortality (p.17). Calderon (1920:20) frames the problem similarly referring to
the mothers perverse feelings resulting from a cruel misery that drowns maternal sentiment and
11Being a question of the quantitative kind, the author states later (p.17) that the information is underreported and lacking. He again assumes the universal nature of foreign (European) estimates to state therelevance of infanticide in accounting infant mortality.12It is to be noted that local newspapers reporting on infanticides moved the municipal government intopolicymaking. However, Pardo (1920: 20) also notes the media fixation with these deaths eight years later.Studying the rhetoric of such press articles is outside the scope of this text.
8/14/2019 Problematizing Human Milk
6/13
resorts to institutional response, this time making the case for the already existing Drops-of-Milk. It
is in this last text where the class component is made most explicit, when Calderon exalts the
importance of these places as corrective of the perverse and criminal behaviour of poverty. It is
the misery they find themselves in, he continues, what drives women (and not their agency) toattempt abortion and infanticide, because the hunger and nakedness that threatens them entails an
uncertain future.
Calderon (1920:24) is convinced that a majority of Bogotas women are capable of concupiscent love
only, which lead him to conclude that the love they can profess as mothers is only selfish; professing
only amoral manners, they can only consider their child as disrupting their liberty. The nature of
woman is therefore wicked and in need of re-education.
Such an account denies women as active subjects and marginalizes them from any public debate
This contrast with infanticide as recounted by Spicker (2000), where feminine slaves in the
Viceroyalty of New Granada practiced it as a means of resistance.
Figure 3 Classification of infant deaths according to cause (Troconis 1912).
Gotas de Leche
Troconis deploys all his knowledge in pediatrics as learned in Europe to explain infant mortality,bringing infant feeding as the central theme. A mothers breast milk is argued as the best baby food
of the lot, over artificial feeding and wet nursing.
The Drops of Milk, a private initiative of individual doctors and associations of them, were
inaugurated throughout the country (as was the Latin American trend) and funded initially through
(the higher class and clerical) charity, and with national government support since Law 48 of 1924
(Congreso de Colombia 1924). The Colombian Congress (1928) decreed the (financial)
8/14/2019 Problematizing Human Milk
7/13
encouragement of these centers at the national level13. The national example followed Bogotas
transposition of the French invention.
They were perceived by the public as promoting bottle feeding in the absence of motherly care
(which was indeed done), but to inform, protect, and invigilate (pregnant) women onbearing/rearing normal and healthy organisms, specially through breastfeeding, was their prime
goal (Pardo 1920:18).
Vicious milk
Syphilis is portrayed as a sub registered cause of infant mortality due to the moral stance that
sexually transmitted diseases had (Troconis 1912:23-24). The discussion, however, does not end
there. Pardo (1920:48) comments on the cases which, like this one, breastfeeding is contraindicated.
Milk coming from a non-healthy/non-hygienic body becomes a matter of concern.
Degenerate bodies here are linked once again with the consumption of the poor. Of all things,
physicians and politicians converge on the problems of consuming chicha, a fermented beverage
made out usually from maize. Blood impurity was and race degeneration were transmitted through
the milk of degenerate mothers.
The discussion on substitution is brought up. The slave origins of the nutrix. Wet nurses as evil and
giving classist-racist value to breast milk.
Distances between breasts and milk
The value of distancing a mothers breast form her child as incarnated by wet nurses and/or through
wages would be accelerated by the technology and capital intensification. The conception and
subsequent production of breast milk substitutes would expand the policy space so that the policy
should have a say on what is best.
The introduction of pasteurization techniques and the commercialization of baby formula, (both of
francophone origins) swiftly navigated the global space from the enlightened centre to the
ex/colonies, this time with less help from the medical establishment.
The popularity of pasteurization plants among urbanizing and modernizing projects was rising. In asimilar way hospitals with maternity wards [hospitales materno-infantiles]. The rise of the child at
the centre of the policy agenda as the nations future was materialized in Nestles powder milk
infant formula. Redefinition of the public/private space in terms of child rearing being inserted into
the public spheres of medical and mercantile logics14.
13Artculo 2 Auxliase con la cantidad de veinte mil pesos ( $20,000) anuales, durante el trmino de tresaos, la construccin del edificio destinado al funcionamiento de la Gota de Leche de Bogot, queproyecta llevar a cabo en esta ciudad, en el lote que ha comprado para el efecto, la institucin denominadaPatronato de Gota de Leche de Bogot.La cantidad asignada le ser entregada al Patronato de Gota de Leche de Bogot, previo el visto buenodel seor Director Nacional de Higiene.Artculo 3 Aumntase en tres mil pesos ( $3000) el de la Salacuna que funciona en el barrio de LasCruces, de la ciudad de Bogot(Congreso de Colombia 1928).14Cows as the mayor input for Bogotas consumption worked both for the meat and for the milk market.The former was widespread while the latter was destined primarily for small cattle-raisers. Stateintervention was needed to associate small milk producers into a supply force capable of coping with theincreasing demand for cow milk. Also from the State were the hygienic processes of standardization thatshaped consumption practices. (Brigitte Baptiste et al Carne????? 2009???)
Formatted:Font: (Default) Garamond,
English (U.K.)
Formatted:English (U.K.)
8/14/2019 Problematizing Human Milk
8/13
Technical betterments in production and consumption of cow milk intensified earlier disdain for
human milk. At the same time it did also with in the opposing breast milk side. Cow milk was
becoming a symbol of nutritious and hygienic and therefore physically and morally desirable. Bad
food and nutrition habits of mothers, especially when their work environments were related to anti-hygienic (dirty) or anti-ethical (poor and symbolizing socio-economic failure).
More generally, the way in which corporal fluids were perceived was changing due to the social,
cultural and environmental consequences of technical and scientific imports, in particular from the
biology-medicine discourses that supported the European expansionist project. Human milk, as
other practices of human reproduction, was inserted into a public practice as caption through
nationhood where once it was part of private/communal ideals.
If global commerce as pioneered by Europeans in the 16 th century compressed time and space
through their particular risk-taking inclination as suggested by Sloterdijk (2005), milk-banks propose
a risk alleviation strategy by establishing a market economy free of debtor/creditor binomials
(disregarding state-led investments). But can it be rendered global, the materiality of human milk,
transported, distributed, exchanged outside the volunteers communitte?
THE INCORPORATION OF BREASTFEEDING BY FOOD AND NUTRITION SECURITY
The current international legal framework
The rhetoric of rights introduced through the second half of the 20 th century by global governing
institutions. UNICEF, FAO and WHO as main players of baby food international policy. Other
organizations outside the UN system such as Save the Children, WABA and IBFAN. Joint WHO-
UNICEF 1989 Declaration (Baby Friendly Hospital Initiative), Innocenti Declaration, the International
Code of Marketing of Breast-milk Substitutes and absence of UNIFEM/ONUWOMEN.
Interactions with the national
Bogotas breastfeeding policies (and not peculiarly different from elsewhere) have centred their
actions in two main subjects: children and their caregivers15
. However, there is one caregiver who is
given major importance. The adoption of the above mentioned vitalizing and populating aspirationsin the dawn of the 20
thcentury raised the child to the centre of policy attention. However, a century
later the stance doesnt seem as clear. It is mother- focused up to the sense where all others are
taken as mother-substitutes. This is best acknowledged by the fact that breastfeeding is most
referred as motherly (lactancia materna). It is also diffused from the executive government, which
engages the most of public advocates (and more times than not, the only public actor addressing the
subject16), as for example in the making of consecutive Ten Year Plans of Maternal Lactation after
UNICEFS 1990 World Summit for Children.
The relational definition of caregiver implies the childs reign over the former and in particular over
the mother. This has been raised by various anti-breastfeeding (promotion) feminists that consider
women interests subjected to those of the child, the idealization of the unconditional life-bearer. It
15 This is not to say there are no others, as is the case of health institutions and their personnel,employers, firms, schools, police and military forces, and so on. However, they are all subjected to theexistence of the infant/caregiver dyad.16This is not a unified stand. For example, consider the Instituto Colombiano de Bienestar FamiliarICBF. As a semi-autonomous part of the Ministry of Health in charge of provisioning services includingbreastfeeding promotion, has held views at odds with those of the regulatory entity (the Ministry) andinside its internal structure (e.g. local vs. national discrepancies). Decentralization is the source of evengreater incongruities between entities such as public hospitals, that coming from the central,departamental and municipal jurisdictions that coexist within the city boundaries. Political interests andpriorities vary, as well as information and engagement.
8/14/2019 Problematizing Human Milk
9/13
also associated with the (patriarchal) medicalization of the maternal body (but also of the infant
body). The building of the female and infant body by medical discourse admitted the breast-feeding
as the best practice (for infants, not the mother) although diminished motherly/female knowledge
on how to realize it, it emphasized the difficulties of breastfeeding without scientific appropriationand ended up creating disincentives for lactation in a time when bottle-feeding was more readily
available (Van Esterik 2002). Other discourses overtly proposing other diets as better than
breastfeeding also became available inside medical institutions. There are undocumented histories
of resistance and compliance that helped shaped medical practice.
This has been accompanied by a shift from the communal to the individual practice, especially
through a modern hygienic imperative, as it is best exemplified by the ghost of AIDS and the vertical
transmission problem. The use of wet nurse services became a rarity as other cheaper substitutes
became available, such as access to water, milk, certain foods, but also the use of commercialization
strategies by the growing industries.
Although the objects addressed by breastfeeding policy are named all over, there has not been a
wide focus on what they, the objectified subjects want. Certain psychoanalytic works and from child
psychology have tried addressing the question of what pre-spoken language babies experiment and
desire. Anyhow, this is not usually the case with policy. What mothers, caregivers in general, and
women in general want is usually not put into consideration for what social policy has to say about
them.
The case has been (briefly) made that breastfeeding policies have primordially focused on women as
a subordinate of the child as the future-productive-entity. The policies rely on a small set of policy-
making disciplines (such as nutrition, medicine, especially obstetricians and pediatricians, public
health, clinical nursing, health education, epidemiology, and economics) which have traditionally
preferred quantitative over qualitative research. A set of measurements have been constructed
seeking to govern subjects.
The only national level indexes have been measured according to initiatives from international
organizations, by Profamilia, an NGO promoting sexual and reproductive rights (the most important
one of its kind), through the Demographic and Health Surveys sponsored by USAID and whose
purpose is to gather quality information to plan, monitor and improve population, heath, andnutrition programs(Measure DHS ).
Since the 1990 to the 2010 surveys there have been changes in the way maternal lactation has
been termed. While in 1990 breastfeeding was understood as an important variable for reduced
exposure to pregnancy due to postpartum amenorrhea and was measured through three indicators
(initiation, complementary foods, and duration), the 2010 survey frames the practice as relevant for
babies and its immunologic properties and other health related benefits and now compiles seven
sets of indicators. It must be said that government entities now participate importantly with funding
and that ICBF now funds a new survey on nutritional status that also includes lactation indicators.
Although these are not the only actors in the debate and recognizing breastfeeding has gained
complexity in its depiction, breastfeeding as policy has not been usually framed as a complex process
shaped by environmental and sociocultural forces. Breasts, children, breastfeeding rates,
complementary feeding, child and maternal mortality and morbidity, infant and maternal health,
mind-motor development, and so on appear throughout lactation policy documents. What social
policies address is concerned with life, death, and productivity.
Translating policy
The adoption of enlightened French policy-making in the beginning of the 20th
century was in line
with the celebration of a century of independence from Spain, the expansion of water supply and
sewerage services, innovations in milk pasteurization and the emergence of a milking and baby-food
industry, developments in pediatrics and immunology. The nascent state was willing to enter
8/14/2019 Problematizing Human Milk
10/13
modernity and the policy-making elites sought English/West-European fashions. As noted,
transpositions from the French medical establishment were made adamantly in regards to vitalizing
and populating concerns.
Embedded in broader biopolitical government practices of the early 20th century, milk wasinstrumentalized for the maximization of national fitness through hygienic and eugenic strategies.
The former consisted on adding an individualized attention to the habits of subjects to the earlier
hygienic concern with securing the external conditions of health through town planning, sewage
systems and the like while the latter meant to improve the body politic and to relieve it of the
economic and social burdens of disease and degeneracy in the future by acting upon the
reproductive decisions and capacities of individuals in the present (Rose 2001:3-4). Following
Pedraza (??Zandra), the hygienization of milk is in line with the pursuit of moral cleanliness starting
through physical and social hygiene.
The biopolitics of the first half of the 20th century, both in its ne/hygienist and in its eugenic form,
involved more than the idea that, other things being equal, healthy individuals were more desirable
than those who were unhealthythe political rationalities of our present are no longer inspired by
the dream of taking in charge of the lives of each in the name of the destiny of all in this new
configuration, the political meaning and salience of health and disease have changed.
In this domain as in so many others, the images now are of the enabling state, the fa cilitating state,
the state as animator. On the one hand, the state retains the responsibility that it acquired in the
18th or 19th century / the precise timing varying across national contexts / to secure the general
conditions for health> regulating the sale of foodstuffs, organizing pure water and sewage disposal,
sometimes mandating the addition of health-promoting elements into the diet vitamins, fluoride in
water and the like. On the other hand
From the places where breastfeeding is enunciated there exists a tension in translation, from an
organ-based framing of a practice to one centered in a fluid, from breast to milk, breastfeeding vs.
lactation. From the international multilateral organizations, where global policies take shape, to the
national framework, where they are brought into the local and from where they are contested with
other policies at other levels, different actors are putting policies into practice and making the
former out of the latter. In Colombia, the disparities describing the connection between the bodies
of women to those of babies are framed in the tension between English-dominant international
multilateral organizations or NGOs and a Spanish-speaking government/activism, and their particular
administrative narratives. Of course, there are translation problems other than [written] policy-
making English-Spanish to the [spoken], everyday practice of not-necessarily Spanish-speaking
practitioners (e.g. indigenous communities).
From the latin lac, milk, and lactare, to contain or give milk, (University of Notre Dame 2012)
Colombia's policies term the practice referencing a fluid, while international policies appeal to a
[usually non-implanted women] breast. This is not to say it is a Colombian initiative. UNICEF, WHO,
and FAO spoke/wrote of lactancia in their own Spanish versions of policy-recommendation/making,
and it is also from such inheritance that Colombian policies speak.
The epistemic order seems to be always English first, Spanish second. For Malaysia-based World
Alliance for Breastfeeding Action (WABA) Latino members, the translation of the English spokenyears slogan into the Spanish/Latin American version is always an end-of-the-year email-based
discussion consolidated in Costa Rica. However, Spanish has its own inner struggles. In an intent to
capture left out meanings, certain Spanish-speaking lactivism has retermed lactancia as
amamantamiento, turning the focus from physiology to mama, not just a mammalian gland, but the
mother, to women and to love. This gives space to breastfeeding/lactation as a biocultural process in
a more complex fashion than the one depicted by strictly medical engineers. A shift from mothers
8/14/2019 Problematizing Human Milk
11/13
milk to human milk, although both used as medical jargon, has been used by social movements as a
decentering of infant nutrition from the mother-as-unique-caregiver17
.
The creation of a web-based Spanish speaking breast-milk promoting community began as a
consequence of the connectivity already fostered by international/regional conferences.
The particular take of the FAO (1996) FNS framework into Bogotas policy. Decoding global and local
lactivism infiltrated into
TRANSLOCATIONS OF BREASTFEADING POLICY
How does the story of BF given here relate to its framing inside the current FNS policy of Bogota?
The fear of death is still present although its form has changed. Infanticide has moved from the
degenerate to the insane, appropriated by psychiatric discourses, the mother-as-vector is leaving the
immoral into the prophylaxis of virology and toxicology, and the medical enclosures for human milk
feeding have intensified in communality in the form of milk banks.
Psychiatrization of infanticide
The fear of infanticide was ever present in a thread of emails I started receiving on Sep 9, 2013, thatgave me a first-hand example of the relation between monstrosity and food security and the
different policies that mediate among such poles. The imprint of motherly instability in the
likelihoods of postpartum depression (PPD) and postpartum psychosis, and the risk of infanticide.
The puerperal state as a moment of instability of motherhood blurs the divide between the
psychological and the physiological. Drug administration, from Biperidene to Oxytocin-substitues.
The life-giver/life-taker monstrosity of this mater potestas is inscribed into a legal instability
framework that contrasts with the Roman patricius held pater potestas. The Colombian Penal Code
recognizes/legally frames infanticide as a crime in its article 328 with a lenient penalty, in at least
the sense that it is made comparable as less in the amount of years of incarceration. The killing by a
mother of an offspring resulting from violent sexual intercourse, abusive or non-consented artificial
insemination, given that it occurs during the eight days after birth, will be penalized with arrest of
one to three years18. This taxa of homicide does not name the crime as infanticide (as is the case in
other Latin-American law) and restricts the unmotherly to three horror-images. This sets it apart
from the previous shame rhetoric used to justify infanticide, where dishonour was the prevalent
motive, as an inheritance from French/Helvetic law.
The monstrosity of the molecular
Vertical transmission19and its manipulation (usually to prevent an undesirable trait) refers to (non-
genetic) inheritance and selection. Risk rhetoric has veiled the social anxiety of monstrous/de-
naturalized motherhood due to the low incidence rates of psychiatrically framed phenomena. It has
instead centred on the tragedy of the unintended. AIDS and risky choices: the prevalence of HIV in
vertical transmission through lactation. Human milk biomonitoring and the imperfections of
toxicological assessments of the risk for nurser/nursed.
17The term leche(milk) has been depicted as both materna(maternal) and humana(human), while lactanciagoes along with materna and natural. In both cases the terms have been incorporated occasionally intowritten and practiced policy.18La madre que durante el nacimiento o dentro de los ocho das siguientes matare a su hijo, fruto deacceso carnal violento o abusivo o de inseminacin artificial no consentida, incurrir en arresto de uno atres aos19
Comment [AS4]: Check if it does not
distinguish it from parricide (meaning that t
same considerations are made even if the
killing is of a child not her own)
8/14/2019 Problematizing Human Milk
12/13
Partial/partitioned bodies and zoomorphisms
On October 22, 2010 I received an email from [Lactared] asking me to sign a petition against an
article published by El Mundo, a Spanish journal that pictured the breastfeeding mother as a cow.
The horned image of the cow-mother, bringing with the analogy of the sensuous devil, the antithesisof the Christian Mary-mother-of-God offended many and deserved considerable amount of blogging
and other social networking. The monstrosity of the horned woman concerned the inhumanity in
which breastfeeding mothers were depicted. In terms of the sender of the petition, the article is a
threat even against humanity20.
In Haraways (2008) words , fears here can be understood in contrast to the long dominant Western
fantasy that all that is fully human is fallen from Eden, separated from the mother, in the domain of
the artificial, deracinated, alienated, and therefore free the way out of *cultures+ deep
commitments to human exceptionalism requires a one-way rapture to the other side of the divide.
To return to the mother is to return to nature This is not only a return to a pristine natural, but to
the commoditized and industrialized characteristics of 2010 nurturing technologies and strategies
that by hyperbolic means makes the apparently gruesome figure of babies suckling a cows udder.
The divide
Figure 4 Left side: Cover of October 22, 2010, Magazine of El Mundo. Right side: Fouquet (1452)
Madonna Surrounded by Seraphim and Cherubim
Recap on distancing between production and consumption. Milk banks vs commercialization. The
framing of milk banks in Bogotas policy. The incorporation of the International Marketing Code of
Breast-milk Substitutes in the text through programmed (budgeted) surveys of its violation. The
holes of the Code, The Icecreamists human milk ice cream, the neoclassical take on incentives for
a human milk market (Waldek 2002) between Roman Charity and galactophilia.
20Original text in Spanish: dicho artculo atenta contra la salud pblica y contra organismos oficiales tanserios como la OMS y el UNICEF e incluso contra la humanidad
8/14/2019 Problematizing Human Milk
13/13
CONCLUSIONS
Food and breastfeeding policies share the common in their origins the fears of death throughingestion and nutrition, the constitution of a fit citizen-subject of a nationalist endeavour towards
productively machinic. However, the discourse has shifted into what Rose (2001) calls risk politics.
REFERENCES