of 272
Developments of Tools Focused on Production Simulation to Improve
Productivity in Shipyards Workshops
!"#$
$%%&
"$'&
()
*+,&
*-+$
#*."
/0/1
Acknowledgments ! " " #$%
!&!'
("&)*+
,!)-.&
,&
!!'
(!'
& +/-*/.
+#0-1
2'
3
&4!25667
Abstract
!"
# $
$ %
& '
"&
"#()
"
"'
*()
+
%
"
%
Rsum ,'-..&
* .
*!/ !"
,.$#.#.$
/ .- ,
.$+
$ ( . .
. - / ,' . .0
0 1 & & -/ &
,.......&..
.&
( . .+ #() .. ..
,&
..+
*2.'
+. ( . . ..
. & #() ..
..&
- .
. - .
( .. &
, ..3/
& 4
.&
( .. ...
-.
Table of Contents
! "#
! "
#$%
$ %# &'(#) !!
&
& '!()* &
& &
&& ! +
&+ ,-*!!( +
!"# $
! $!
! *+#%%(,- $$
&&
!*! &+
++
& ! .
+ !//0, 1
%(! .
!! ./#+ 0
.1
%!!-*! 12
!$ !
$ %&''%%()
"# *+
$ %12#,& 3
& "+
& 3* # "
& #( "1
&& 4/5 ""
&+ 6 ""
$ 44
& 22
& !! 2
& !
2
$! #%%(,- 0
& ,#( .
& %/5
& '
+ %) *
3
3 5# !
+
+
+ (!! &
+& %!! +&
3! 30
, +*
6 5 3
6 2 3
6! 64
6$ % 6
-. ,
')(/ ,+
& 01
Chapter 1 Introduction
1.1 Context situation - - !# !
! ! !## ! % * ' 7!8
((9:*!*#
*#;8
((!(!8#(
#!!(!
5
$!*!!
! @!# *! !(
@ # !
?
!#
4#!
=(
! # !(
#
#((*!?
6
! !
4A*6 %
/ # 8
!(*!8
- !@((#
#@!!!(0!
!*!
( ( !( ## 8 *
A!
5
/5
! *!!!
!#(!#*!
'!+(!(!>!
!D!(
!(
! ! '=( ! !
!( *! B
( ! ! ( #
!(
# # ! % # !( # !D
E # !
! # #(
!(!!!!
*! # !(!#(
((!#(
4!#
!
Chapter 2 State-of-Art and Overview of the Industrial
Environment
2.1 Introduction
0( ! # >
B!(!B#
##'!!
!
7 5!
%#=4I:)J;(!#
(#!
E8 ! (
!@8((!@!
!8(
@ ! ( ! 8 #
!!@ # #
(
! !!
(,(#(#8
!*8#8#((8#(8
8
8 #(
8 ( ! 8 #8
8!@!#(
0@!8!((#(!
8*!((F8
!(
! =8 8 !(8 ! =!8
! !( 8 #
(!!!(
((!*#
#(K5 8"""L
( 0 @!8
#>
,#(?
/(>
E'?
,(?
35?
!(?
'(?
$5*8 4#
5(?
4!
##?
0
!
#?
'!(!?
## B@B
!!>
(+(
( 2,
7 53
(!#.)2#*7+8
($#,,)##)
(3+
65*8 4#
))
(8 ( ! (
(%(#!#
#!
!##%@!
! ( # 8 ! !8
*!(#(!#=(
%((#
#(#
(K$8".1L#(8(
(((!
!!(
( (8 @!8 #
( () !
E8!!(8
! (! !
(*#!((8*(8
(@!0(#
*8 # !( (
(*#(88#
(*#!(
! )
(
7 50
$ 5&
3 # !
(#
4 > 8 (
( # ?
8 (#(0
*#((8
(( # !8
8!
9:>(
8!!(
#=
>
% #
(
# @!> (
@(?!0
#8 %
( (
!@:;
,>*!8
!( # ! ! !
*GH
8 # %### 6 /
:%6/;8
: ;8 E# 6 % :E6%;
##%:3%;
3 ##)#
!!73"&2
#!!8##8
#(
*,'(#
! @(8
5*8 4#
(M3(
#
(@!!(
'! : ;!"+2
! ## ! $ ( 9
$
$/#:$/;(#!
$
'!5K5 8"""L
6 -#)9
-((((
( # (
# ( : ( =;
#>
;(!@(#!?
;(#!?
;?
&;!8 !
#B((B
@=#((#
G# *H
!!!
%!!=
! (-
!!8
(!!((%!
* ( # ( !! #
0 @!8## ( (
!
(!
(
8;7&
7 5
0
!!###>
- ( ( ! ( !
#>!8!8
-(8
#!K/#""+L>
3!8!#!
88 8#
45*8 4#
5
- # #
*#>
(@!(
! :# =8 !(
# (8 ; ( # @
!B(!8(
(( % =8 (
! ! (
:( ( !;8 (
(!?
, # = ! #
# @! 08 ( *
8 ((8 #(*( (
(
(!(
( !!5 ( @( !@
!
###
8
(
! ( !
K5 8"""L?
%((
= !
! #
7 5
(!B8B
?
( !8
! !( #
=#
8#8#>
,*(!#!*#
(!!##
GHG!H?
,( !! ! ! ( !
!*#!#(#(?
! ( ((8
!!#
(!*#0@!8
( ( #
#**8(8#?
' ( !@ (
!
:
! !(
E@!#>
#>
()@!?
(
#>
8?
(?
5*8 4#
(!
?
!@#!?
(#=!?
(#?
*?
E8(!E
*
! G- !! FH *
##(!(
# ! % ! !
*(
##*(!!(
( # !@(
(#(!=(
! @( =( #
(# #
(
( !(
# ! #( ! 0 #
(!(!!
!##*#
#((
!
! ( #
-(
* #
((
, #
7 5!
N(#=(!8
!8*8#
(#(
#!
2.2.2 Object oriented software :; K4
8 ""L = !(
(=##(0@!8
'OO P ! :/; ## # #
(###(
=*
%
$5*8 4#
(6;#.,
88
,
# 8 @!8 ( ! (! #
!!08(!(!##*
!8(#(8(!
#(8! (!#8(##
8@##(!#
A#
C ## #8 (
##!##(#(
7 53
- # ( ##
((!((
(-88(
8 ! 8
!#
!!
#(8
65*8 4#
# 8 ! (
#
(
(
,*#!
##
2/
!
!!>
/@#!
7 50
( ! @ !(
(-!8
@@!
!( !
!!
!
(051
0#.@,0%#
! @
* ! *!
@!#@
( ( ( ! !
$(!
!(
@!0#.8
@(0#1(!
B@!B8!
@!
5*8 4#
(:=
> (!:88'8;?
> @?
> ,###?
> 5###
-*@8
@:(;8
@ B 0# " !! (
#!
(:
>5
3!#
! ( !(
!!0#",
!#
2.3 Genetic algorithms
2.3.1 Description
'!!96BCB:8D96BBC:8
!45*8 4#
!(8!!
!( # #
!(!
( 8 ( #
! # %
#8 ! ( !
#(!
! +
(!>=
##08#=
##
(+&
%!@#(#
!*
(#,
! ##@#!(#
!(@##(#@#
>5!
!
.
'( !8 ! !!
@#((#
!#!@#
(!
,
N# ! #
!( #
# ! ! ##
-(!!
!(!
- ' :R; ! ! :# ;
/( , ' :/,R;
! 8(R8#!
*! #/,R! ! !
!! %
-!> 5
08!(
#
:;0#
!#@#4
!
0 8 %
*
!
!$ .
!(@#-
!
!5*8 4#
(
:;?
N!:&;?
N ! !(
!!!=(:/;?
* # #
:5;
!3 (
% # # 8
!#@#
!!(
>###
' > ! 8
#!?
(!>!
#5!!
%!!
!!!
! !
( % !( !!
#(-#
#( !! =
! # #
(
2.4 Presentation of the Aker Yards France shipyard
2.4.1 Introduction
# ! G, * &H * (
8#(G
!$5*8 4#
!
#5!3
%
*&+2#"2?
#
*&22#?
52222((
2.4.4 The production
%*C0!
/# ! :8 !@ !!@;
228%*C0'EB
G$ ! 4/'
!65*8 4#
(4
,)>
,*!!(#>
,#!:N0N;?
,#!:N/';?
,#!!:N/;?
0!:/5;?
-*!##?
-*!//0:##;?
/6:#;?
2-*!:#
#5!0
8#8# ! :*#; !
##
(+#
$3! +##7?%8
*!8 # * > # (#
!
*!> ! :*#; /
#:;
!5*8 4#
(+##
$3$ +#7?%8
*!8#*>
/####?
-###
(!+#
$33 (,7%28
*!8#*>#:;
# # # # #
!#(###
#5!
($(,
$36 -
*! # > 8
:222;8!#
(3-
$30 -%%(,
*!*!>GH//0
:#( ; GH//0*!
GH//0*!
*!
*
B'!,#!
$45*8 4#
(6-%%(,
$3 %:7%(,8
*!:;
#*>#!#
#####
> # !# # #
##
(0%:
$3 4-%+8
*! # *
* *!
1:;8#:;
*!'!+
!!
!
#5$
(4-
$34 4-%+8
*!2-*!
$5*8 4#
(4 %+
Chapter 3 Development of a Virtual Workshop
3.1 Introduction
* !
!!!@#(
(!!
- !!( !*! 3
//0*!!>
!(*!?
!?
!!(*#! @! (
*!/!!!@!A*D
! !
$$5*A 4;H
'! & !
8 !
; !
8 8+ !
*!0(((#!!
% !! * !
*!!%//0-*!
( '! !
/*!!
B0#03
$65*A 4;H
()
,
Very small assemblies
Formed assembly
Insert
(@,
,
;!((#
*#(>
N/> G=. . .+H # G! H
!#N/:V;N/?
N/':%4;>G=..H#GH
!#N/':VN/'%;
N/':N/'4;3N/':N/'%;
#!!?
/5>G#...H#G-
H
/#>#:$BG>KH
#G4#!H;!:/BG#&.H;3
(!*
% ! *! ((-
*! @ ! (
! ! ! ! = @
((>@
*(!(###B
! ! B ! *!
###4(
## ! % @ #
!D(!=!>*
!*!D
*!) > # : ;8*8 #
$5*A 4;H
(!*#%%(,-
*!*#:;
!B *! ! :
;#!=>*#B#B#%
*!#0#&
!! ! ! = !
(#=!
*!#!
# ! *# # !
((*
345*A 4;H
'##!#(!#!!
# ! +*#8 * (
; ##
! !*#!
#!
#!!
3**!#
! # *
!# * (# ## # B
(!
;-#5
(
*!
!(
8! *
( (
35*A 4;H
08=*!#!
G*!=H8G=H
*!=8##=*:
;!!*%
8@*
*
*/* (
:/,;
#=#(!=
##(#*!!/,!(
! ( ! *N(
! # #
! # ( !
-=(!(#
=8* :;
( !* # (
!( # ! ##
* ! ( 8 #(
!(@!*!(=!
( (! = # #8
!#
4(*:#*###8
##;(:9
; !! *# : !8W; ! #
!:(*;8(#((/,-
(!8##!#8!(
*
; /! :; B *# :; B-# :; B
0# :&;B'#( :+;-* *
:*#(#;#8
( # B !
@!#!>
(6
#,
= !! 4 !
* ! @(> * B # B *
#8(*##*@*D%
#(#!*#GH*
#((
##G@H**
3$5*A 4;H
# %* * G@HD
! > !
3 ! *!! * = !
(!*#*@(
* (#@*
GH*(G@H*!(*
##
!(:@;
!>
!!(:;?
!8!8
#?
!8!8
;
'% B'!% #>*
# #?
/ ,B / ,#> ! # 8
! / ! ( #
?
'%, B '! % ,#>
# B @! # 8# 8#
8?
5/ B ! 5 /#> ( # !#
#
# #( *
*=FE#
*=0*!D-*#
!!>*#8!
#8*8 !(
#'%,
( !# ( '%,
###!D
*! 8
#/##'%,
/E6BG#D,H0!##
( ( ! -
365*A 4;H
=( ! '%,
!= !
!+1
( ! *!
! = ! $ =D
N(!@(
!A(##0
* # ## *
#!D!!!#(
( *! %
E#((#!>*!
! 8 * # !
- #!
@!!
#5/
==!#!
>#
!- =( B * !
**
5/0*!8*
4 5.%/E6@(!=
! '=( ! !
+1
!@!*
((%
=
#%*C0!(
# # ,%5 , *!
(@#
*!0 //0*!
!D
,%5
L()#
35*A 4;H
(01A,
S#>
D!)N%4>!?
!ONM>*?
(, ( % (
( 6,X3 ( E35X 83/%38
3 8%8%& # (
?
D!)N%4>!?
!O#!>!(?
%!4> !!
(?
A> ( E
!#((-6,X3?
P>( *!(
( %& !
?
QN,O*,N,O*,>/(*#
#
(?
O=4> *# ( !#
!#(#
/E6
;)O=#(>@!?
!?)N)?> 0 * ! #
?
M%N**#
!ONM
%!##$5N/#
!=*!=#(
(#!*!
=E*!>!
!*!!*!
*(88!!(
*
!=*#!#!
@##!*#!
( = $5N/ *
#!
((!
3 !
**#B
!!(
!!! 11:+1%2,
>
!8#8#8$( /5
#6,!!B
3 8 %8 %& 3
( B @!@! #
->,NM%N?,(
! ,/
!*B9B#
645*A 4;H
4(U61=M4%
"!0
(#!
#(@!0#1
(#
!
- U6 M4%! !# ( #
!(!
!=!@!@
!!$ #':BAB;:5>
=C6X9X%46,NM%N*D%,4=
=!=#=>
1U(6##
"M4%!!
;
@6,6*
##>
65*A 4;H
(!4##':B11:+>
= @ # 6,
!!6 #':B1%2>
@/56*
##>
;
=#(*>
(!(#':BAB+1
'#!9BN
=###(#
!>
,X6#!:$8/%(;?
,X4!?
6$5*A 4;H
!*!!!#!
-#7CD3444D8
, )##
), ) - (
/ $ ?4%
;$%
,-
), *
/(# *
%A5 * 2.+
6** *& 22&
! *+ 2
#!; +2:A;E!*&*+
#0(*
!! #':BAB E:1
-9!
# !
!
! *#90
(#>
0!#(
!(?
0!!!
) (! ! =! = B
#!!8(8#8#8#8
' ! ( ! !
(?
0#(%#8#
!!@(()
*# !( (!
665*A 4;H
!8#*#(
#*#!?
0 ! !0 # !
#*#%
!!
9 ( ! %
! @# D
!@##('/N
*#
!! #
!=
8 = @ ! * @
B 0# = =8 !
*!
(!!2>
@ C6X9X%46!#
9 # ( %
#
B0#&
;
$!:#!;?
,##!##A
!#?
5#?
! 0#?
!%(!!?
4@!#?
!
65*A 4;H
,@ A',#:6808;?
%?
5#?
@!:#8,/$!
!;?
'!?
%?
!'% #?
E @ !*# > Z598 %#5*8
%(8%(6#8%8%,8%% 848'
#
:' ;8 '( 4 /8 ', "8 #( !
8 ! (8 @!08 @8 0@8 0 8 $8
$/AE8 # / ,# :/,;8 6,8 6,8
,%8 ,, !
;
,0?
5?
0?
N?
,N2?
@
!$ +(.,
045*A 4;H
(
,#
#
(
., 4#?
> 4,N?
> M#?
> 4A888?
> ,(
(*
(
;[V>[V>[V (8 8
:!A2222;#(@#(
#
1
.,88#8/8$848
0 ! **0 8 !
#
!8!(#-
!
(!
8!#*#8#8
*#:!(
;8
(
08 8
#
!!(#(#@(#
% :,N;@
! ##
05*A 4;H
(!B##!
!#
#
%
.,
##>##!
##
:,N; ! !! ##
#/
!
#-(
!8##!#,N
!(!!,N
,N!
8!
> #! !8
@!
( #!
,N - ( !
= 8
#=#!
4>4#!
,N,N
#//0*!
0$5*A 4;H
#
5
.,
;
*,N
#?8*@%
#
,N 8 @
#?
*
* ,N 8 *
#,N
!# !#,N @8 *@
%
#
- ( !
# #? 8
!
#=(#8
!
#2!
,N2
#
%E
.,
065*A 4;H
*
#
($#.,#?8
#8*
,N8/4!
#/
!
*,N
($!1)
%!(,N,N(
/4
;!#-#0
0 8 G/H ,N
!###B@
!#*!@!-(,N
%,N#!
(4,N#,N
(##?B0#&
05*A 4;H
($6##
%((!!
* ! ,N - (
# ( #? (
@ ,N 0
#0#&.#?
($0#)
! ! ! 8 #
B ,N B (#
# ( - #8 @!8
45*A 4;H
,/* ! (
!(#!(!(+H#
?
?*
!(+%#8
##884
? # =?
#(+88(=
%8 = % =
(
?=%8(!
#(+#?
#8(!
= ? *
*,/!=(+
?(=8(+#=
(8?
?!!!8
?#==!(+
(+8##@!
((+
(+
(+ @! *
! 4*
%#8##84
(+!%
%#?#(+#%%(+
!# 8 ## ?8
#%
=
H#
-*H#-*!0
/! 4*%
@!!
5*A 4;H
%*## *8
H#H##
*
*HH#H#!
!6##
,/ #
$5*A 4;H
end;
#*()
(!(>
self.execute(n-1)
@(#-
=@#
!8(3#
) % # ( %
( B *
(*)B
* ) '
!
;
; #
#
-#8@!8 @!
#8!8#8
!$$ ?
#((>* #
*
*#!(!(,/#
->
88@!
! 8 ((
4
- # # ,/
!4>
/ ! !@
*
;(8*
(
(#!!(
#!((+
65*A 4;H
%(E,6!
3.2.5 Development of the PrePreFabrication Model
!3
*!((?:G%H;
#:G4H;(*8
%##!4
GH(( *!G !!
(#
@ *'=( ( (
:G0H;#G!(H#
*! A (
#
%0*!#>
! 0 "
(
($#(#%%(,
;
4*D> # #
5*A 4;H
#)> # # ! ! 4(
#
*> # !
*!#
*>!*!&
D *> ( 0
> MBB0
#:0=*
( # ! *! 3 ( !8
(#8(*
-**#8
(B(
)>#!#
#B(
#>#! #
!!
%>'#@(,
/%!#(
)>-*(#
> % !
((
=*#
)> (
(!BB(
,>B!8!!8
B##
;(
! # #B 8 !8
3 > G#H
*##:(* ( @ /, : 'E ;8
!#*#!(!!!
##
45*A 4;H
0G%H@ 'E8GH8G,%H8
5%4G/H0#+
8
8
!G#H8
((#!!#
* ! #
B(
B1.D-(#
#!
1.B@!
0
##!
# D ! ( !##
1.8 !(
B((
!!@!
8
G%H8!
GH : ; ! G X%H :; ! G9XH :
;
:(;#B
0#+B ! !# (B!(
(3.
;
Contents of the Workshop Frame
%8#
#
Contents of the Machine Frame
-,!*!
#/
>
5*A 4;H
!
,N
#/
;
N/
#
( ! ,
/(>
G4N/H8
!N/
$5*A 4;H
G\H>
( ( !
:*8;
(!,/(>
?8 !
4
N/'>
N/'
*! *
!>
#!
!
(!,/(>
G4N/'H /
N/'% :
#;N/'4:;
G,/5H>
G,/5H ! :G#. . .+H 0 B ! #;
N/!,/(>
G!=]H>
0!#*!(*
! ! # ( /, G/=]H (
8 !(#3
65*A 4;H
#*
!!( #
*?*
*?,
!*#!#*
(!(*!!
! #
*
(
! !#? B @!?=#
N/ ! !#
#
3 * !A
!,N,/
@>
(3$+?#
!!= !
!#>
!!:!8;
5*A 4;H
@
!#-(@
!(* # *
! #&.N/'>EB
!(#&N/'
# :%=#8 %8 ;
!(
!3$ #+ (
%98,%*!
*!0!#/,*
/>
'/>
(33%
( # *
!>/5#N/
/( '/ *! ( 'E ( : 'EX
#/,;!*,%
'/
(!,/(>
(36%#
%&>
( //0*!:
;#(!
;
(30#+ (
( 9
3 9
*!'/#*
-!#B(*!B!(
@ !( '/!
(@!(!M
R#/5!8#
N/%*! #
(!/,*
!( (# @ /,%
!=(
445*A 4;H
00
*! :#6#8;8 #
/,('/X/58'/XN/%&
0(*?*
!!(*!!
*?
(>#(NM#
#*!*!#
!*
*&/!
*
*#
#'/
'/ ! * 5 * @!
G*?H#
! ! '/ : %& ; # (
*?4!#
'(9
( 0 !
#N/8/5%&
(#B##
! R : @!
Y'/XN/8 YX'/X/5; ! !#
0(!% 9 !!
: ;!##
(>
!
4!#,
%@!!(!!#=#;
;
!! @( ( M >
! 8 # # 8 ! !
!#!#!BR
45*A 4;H
!33 #5;
!#
4$5*A 4;H
8/,Y/,X#
3 #(* (
!( *! !
(!
4!#
((/,(
,%>!8#
465*A 4;H
@!B!*B((
!!@#!
( *
@!
! * (
# @
O#B 'E
%#(%
/##
!
O
(64#5;(
!36 #2 E(
#//,(
#(* ! ! (B
!!#*##
!%!#(/,
;
(6#2 E(
! (
!#%!!
!
! ( *
#(*'=((
(#!!!
!> @
45*A 4;H
!!!!>
-!5%4#
(!
-#!(G/5%4HB@
# ! ( ( 5%4 @
#)?B#68#88#A8#P8#I#J(
0#!(
@!E @!
!!!##)?
*!>
#N4>B=?
#NO>
!B=?
#NO>!?
#N>#NO
/,B#!
/,?
#N,>3#)?
*>#B%4
,(@!#
%
)
5
4!"
%@!!
(#
4
! ( ! #
! (
# #)? #)? !
!( HN !
;
(6#G%2 EG(
%
!
BGH
O
G)H*##
##*
)O
G)H*#
###**-*/
45*A 4;H
#N)
,!%#
#!-!*
*#
! @! (
#(#!#
!3 #FD(
#
!
>#
! !
#
#>
; (NM
# !**#4(*#
!
!
!+N(NM
! (N
( *+N(NM !# (NM B
#B@(NM*+N(NM
##
5*A 4;H
(6$#
(NMN6(NMNP@(,**
-*G(NMH(*
@(8((
#*!-*#
*#B
( 0# & (
N?(NM-*!
*#*#!D
#*
#@X9
*(*#-!*
##**#%!>
*#B#B#
*+N(NM
%# ( !( (NM 0 *#
*#* *
!*#0(*N(NM
!>(NM*
*N(NM
,((N#(*0
!NM(NM*
54NB@!!#
;
$5*A 4;H
(63#GB5G(
#9B9X9X
9X# @*# 9X
#*#
!34 #F1BAD(
-*#*##!
!(%*
B 8 ! (8 ! *8
!8
##>
;,#88#8
(!!#*>#
(!(*3!!!*#
#(#*#!>
*8
65*A 4;H
4Q
!
*#B
B ( #
; * ! !#
#(*?
!(#
#>
(60#G%
G(
)## ! *#!
5*A 4;H
/*4##4#
@)###@):
(
45*A 4;H
! *# ! : ! ! !;
##
0!#!*
!!,N!(
3X98RX6
8CX6
83/%38 3 898
X65/#%
! B(
*!8 @ 8 - ( !
5/ @
(
,N
@ ( @ ( !( 4# 4(
( ( #! *B
((
@!(,N*!*>
UN%3C#8
!!#-
!( ! * #
(>
4!O*!
%!*
(62
((NM
*B# (NM
G%#$/XH #! !B?>#
(#(G#$/XH!*
;#G#XH-#(G#XH
#
@ ( B
#-((>
%(B#
%(
(042
,)
((NM#
#((
!3 #F%D(
#*!-
#(*!
#!%#!!
E !(8 #8 ! #
(>
,(!(,%B
/,?
4#!#*#B!
*# ! ,%
!!(?
4#%&*#?
,(
N'/,%?
4#!#!
#
#*!(:8
##!(
#>
5*A 4;H
(0#G%G(
:;D;!*
!##?
+>!?
>
:R;
*#*#
?
.>
: C ;
*#*#
?
1>!(:;
##Q
# :R8 C; ! '
#
!%@(
O (
;#
*!(!##
,N # # ! <
##*
!(#
,N#D
;!,N
65*A 4;H
( #> # 8 # 8 ! :##
#;/, 'E
!>
- # ! # -
*
( !
##=!#
#BG(H08#
#%
;Q(#
4
5*A 4;H
*##!*#
B(?>#!#(!
* '=( * ! !
( O @
#!*#
0!>
*!(*,%
##*!/,*!
#*#
!>
* ! /,*%#*
!!!
%#
#@
;#(/,(!#B
!!B!/,
'(/,!#(
(!:@((;-
*
#%!((#:;/,
/,O
/,!
*/,
(/,/,
!(
/,!#!
#%(#(/,G
!H
#( ! #% #
!:(#;!!/,
! @ ( /,
G/H3(!/,
!(
* /,
(!
#B!(
* #
;!(
(/,#(
-/,#
,%/,D-!#O
#
# :!(; # * #
OB!#!(
!( # #
:!88;O
!( #!
!#(
-@!(# !
O ! !( #
!
!45*A 4;H
!3! #F%D(
%N4 # #
(0!#G%#G(
( >( * :D;
!5*A 4;H
(03#G2,G(
##
#
##(#
( (#0
(D
3
;
##!
(062#,
)7
%
),ND!
)
,N
>Q
#!
!
!>Q>Q!(
###
D
,N(!!D
(*
# # # #
(%
!33 #(
!-*!>
# !
# ! (!
!!B
!#*#(?
!$5*A 4;H
!
! ( 0
!!
0
!
!(#
! =*( # #
@ * ( '=(
(
*#
#>
(00#GG(
# !
(>
'(8*!
B0#..B!#@0#.1
; 4! %
?
> 4!?
> 4
!?
> 4*!?
> 4
O*!(
!-!B(*#B!#
*!
#!#*
*%
B@!
!(8
!
'*#
!65*A 4;H
(0#,,
> 6@!?
> 6@!?
> !4 5/E6?
> '*@/E6?
> =!4 5?
> %!?
> !#@*!#!?
> !
#@(!#!0
! G6 H# B
@B@B@4!
4 5 /E6( ! !
'*@&*
:;/E6
!(
#!
!*!#
!!!*!-*
:+;!((#B
#4 5B! @:; (2
@(
!5*A 4;H
(,
> 6*!?
> 6*
! !( ( * ( !
#( ! *
((
410#."!
!
#
! 4 !
#@0#1
(%,
> !!#?
> !!*#!?
> !!#!?
> !!#!?
; !!#!B#8 !!5B*?
> !!
*#?
> !!
4!##@>
(!5,/,
!/,!!
!#!:(;*
(
:G,#H; ( !
(!#
#:G#H;! (
# :( ( # 8 # ! *#
;
4:G%##H;0#1!#@!
*#!>
$45*A 4;H
($%#&
0 * ! :N/8N/'8 ; *#
!@(!**%&:(;
!##@!(
4! #@! ##@
! @! . 3 #
:%
;!
!!#@
#
4&!#@#!B0#1+
(3%##
#!!@*!
( # * (# >
* # * #
$5*A 4;H
*!#!!
#
0
(0-&%
4.!#@(*#B
0#11
(%
,H)&
!*#(#
(# !
;
8!!8*#8##0#1"
*#!%@!(
**(!
(3#
0#(!>!!8
0*>
/(88
!!!(-
!!!#
!#
!!
0 !! *# (
!!*#*
*#!B*!8!8
!8#
$$5*A 4;H
#B*!:##;8 !8
!8
;
'*@ B
?
> '*@!:;?
>
'*@!:;!*:.;
?
>
*## B(
*@?
> !*
* !*
*
*
* 4!#
- & 8 1 *# #
!(!(*!BB8*#8
>*(:(;!B#
*###
4&-*!#@B
0#"
(
*@ - !!
!(
*B8#
*!8
$65*A 4;H
(
**#
@##*
3 ( # @ B *# 8
#!(
#@B0#"
(
#
!
* ( ! ( -#
##
E,6 ! !
#!8 88 (
! # !8 8
! % B 0# .. B
( ! ! >
(*4 #8*@8
@8!
!!
* ( A 0
!*@#@0#."
!36 #&(
(!#**!
(
#>
3-*/
;
(!#G2G(
-H#
?
(#%68%88%A%P
**#!#
#>)N
)N?*##
3 ! > * B 0# "&
*(!
$5*A 4;H
($##.,#:5%4;
!(,/
-*8N!
8(Q)8!
8!#N!@
#=
!
!*
-S
*#2S
*
#8@!8 !S
*S
*!
S
*S
*##
- * 8 =
8!8
!!
#!
345*A 4;H
!30 #')(
'#
@%
BB
#
#>
(6#G,G(
,#!#>
%8)8(+?
,#>8*NN?
; *)
** *O *># *)# *,N
*)N*4O?
, #
#>,N(E=(!*(8*&
*)@
( !
!B#
@!
=!@!>
&> 4
*
*!#*M
%N4?
N:N?;>#(*
%:4;NN?&
4NN :4NN?;> -
N:N?;
NN :NN?;> -
! % : 4;
(
35*A 4;H
(0
< ! !#!
( B #(
(
>NB!@!
;
C6X9X%46>!((%
?
9X%46> ! C6X9X%46 *! (
3X98UN%3C8/%5385%3/5864%'3 ?
C6X9X,>@(%
(3X98
6,X38RX6'%68CX6'%68N ,?
9X/,>@ C6X9X,(!#
(/,*?
9X'/X/5> @ C6X9X, ( /5
!*?
3$5*A 4;H
9X'/XN/>@C6X9X,(#N/
!*?
9X%&>@C6X9X,(%&!
*?
/X%X# : /X4X#;> @ %
/X%:/X4;
!>!((%
?
/>(%
?
/(>(%
0(#!%8!%88
!4#!
%@!@(
M4% # $
#- *! ( !
(,/!$#
3 ( ( ! ( !! /5
# B '! & @ M4% $
#(!,/
$#@$@
!(,/!
!BB!##@>
(5,#"
66;?
68>
'
365*A 4;H
(
:*!#8!(8;
B # !
( # ( B @! G(H
G*NH%@!
GH#D
0@!
!(B
!B(
(+N#%
#%N#%N?!
B ? (
@*)
*NN
*,NM!!
# 4% 5 !
#*NN#
*! # '6X9 #
NNNNNN?
**
*!#!*
*)*
!>!!8*#88#8#
#
!#!%@!0#22
35*A 4;H
(4.
*>#
)>##
!#
(#-#>#
*#0#2
(4.,
*)#
)#
! #
645*A 4;H
(4$-
#*#
8 *8
*#
*,NM
,NM*
(4%-*)N
B*B#)NM@
)!*-@
:#,NM;)NM*
#N
*)N
%@!8@) *#,N
)NM**NM#
!*##!
*@*%@!0#2+
; (+N#%
** *O *># *)# *4O *,N
*NN
!#,/ 68T?P
@$@!4(
!(,/!#
@ ( M4%
$#*!
3 )
( *
65*A 4;H
(46.#,#
*N,N(E=(!*(
,N(E=(!*(:,NMNN%;
# = ,NMNN%
*!=-
!B#*8B
((
C6XUN3'
(
*&
& !# > >
>N>>#!
B*##!B%4
$!X9(#!*-
!=
(!=
&
*Q
6$5*A 4;H
(40#G2B:G(
%,
!4 54 5
!(*
@4 5B@@
!!'!
!G0H##!0
!(!!4 5
%
B#B
!!!%
@
! *! '=(8 (
( %
! 4 5
!D
(*!
( !4 5 !( ,
/
%N#D,
665*A 4;H
(#B
,NON4*DN68,NON4*DN
65*A 4;H
( ! *!
N( G( ! H
%G#(HG!#H#
!**!#(4!
# #
( # ( #
8
! *! *
!(!?*!
.22*N(6#D%
(((##*!
! !# ( #(
!!!*!#
(
%@!8=0
-* (! (
(#!(* ( #G#H
* ! ) #( #
#3#(*#
(5(
#!!
*! # #! (*
#>9B#,%
#
!
!#6,/5B@!
> 98 6, /5
@%
=!
B0#2"B#*8!
G9H46,/58*
G36,/5H
9 C6X9X%46 %
!
045*A 4;H
(4%#/
0!*!0#
(#
*#(
!(#>
*3(#
05*A 4;H
##
( @! ! 0# #
#!(
(*##
%@!(#>(
! 8 # ( *8 #
* # =!
!#
0*!#>
Side A Side B& + ." +
+1 + .1 +
++ + .1" +
++2 + .2& 2&
+2& 2 +2&
+2+ 2 12 +
++. 2 .2&
12 + 121 +
.2& + +2+
; ##
*#*#!(
@*#*!*(=
#
= #
! B !( ! B ! (
%@!
*
8 *! *!
! ( ! *%
!!*40#>
&(8&?
*
*(!!
* & (- * (
!= *
! 8
#*!*#-!!*#(
!0=*
1(+! = (
8"(.D'(!!
=#*
*)
%/5#(!*
*/5
!B'!
&
0$5*A 4;H
#=!##
=-(
!
!6! )
%! ( !
(#!!!(
!#=(!
!*
! 8 !#
#D%!
!
!#( !(0
#!-
#!!%
!!!
-!(##
#(!!
#FM(!@!
'=(8
!@(!-
! ! ! ) #
5 * * @
(#B
!! !
#B((4
!(!!*
! ( (
((D(
(*!!(
(##-
8# (
D
065*A 4;H
050000
100000150000200000250000300000350000400000450000500000
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5Multiplication Factor
Tota
l Pro
duc
tion
Ti
me
(3#(##%#
3 # ! (
####(
T!(#((TD
*!>
0!(
!!#!*(!
!?
(#!
!(!(*!
-!(#(
**(0!
*# ( 8 ( #
'=(!!
# ! 3 # ! # B
(
##-#*
( *#! # !
(!!
05*A 4;H
@! ! ( ##
( ! !
#*#(
4#(B@*(**#(
! B *# # * (
##
% 8 ( ( ! ! !#
8!
3.3 Optimization of the Model
3.3.1 Introduction
-@!!!
! % (!
*! * ! # ! !
*! 8 * ! !
3(('=(
( !
* ( !
!(D(#!(*
!
O" ! 8
8?
# > = @ B
*#
#!=*
#(
!*!!*
!(B(*!#
!
! # *
>*!
**( ( ! = #
E#*=!
!
45*A 4;H
G# /H #
# #
( (
@!#!!###(
!=!!
5*A 4;H
E!!)B#BF
! ( !!( %
# #!#
# 8
#
#(!%
=#>!=*!
! ( = #
3 ## B
(#*!
! @( * ! @!
!#!B!=4
!
*!-#(#>
%(#*?
9 (# ! :
*!;?
*!!
O"#
# @( =8 # #
=@(D(8#8(!(
!!
'?
':;?
% @! # # $%8 (
#
! @! = - (
#
$5*A 4;H
#
* %!
'/N!=(
!
O"/,R
,
5,>2
! #! !
65*A 4;H
!
8#!8##!
B ( 8 !8 B
!
!
O"3?
!#>&?
0'!,:5;/:5;,8!
2$E
5*A 4;H
'>/,R?
,?
5,>2
(2/)>/
!!&H! (!
!!
=#>
0 ! !! @
#BO!?
0
!
#B#!?
! # B (
!?
=##
3 !! ( - !
!@!#
45*A 4;H
!B!8!B(
(
(3(.)##
- ( (
0#0#
(6(
#
- ( !)
!! # ! 2 ! B
B 2 B 0# +%# &2
#%!O
! !( ! ! !
-(@!!
*>
(
:68;?
N!:6P;?
5*A 4;H
(2#
!
*5!
=
$5*A 4;H
08!(#*!-
#!8!:!!;
*!8
! *8
*!4#*
**!8*#8
Chapter 4 Development of a Specific PERT Tool and
Application to the PrePreFabrication Workshop
4.1 PERT: Theoretical background
4.1.1 Introduction
#()&:/5;*
(!/5!"+2N
3(S/!8!
=!!!
!.((((/5#B
75555'5
#!
*!!#(#!B
@!##! ^U,(_
0(/5*#((
!*(!!
/5*
#
8 '/N! !(!
65*P 4#()##H
B!B/5#
B *!B ( ! #
!! *! % @! ! (
! !
(! **! B* B
*# B B *# =
8
F !
/5 # 4 /5
(>*
*D
((*(
B/5#B!(=
# M ( ## /58
/5(
4.1.2 The Network Diagram
!8 * ! ( : ;
*#!%(8
=:88!8(;8
!# 8 8 =
4(#8!#!
/ * ! ( /5
#((*8!
%! *!
* 8 * !
*8GH#
!
(#>
%(:*;
0%(
:*;
#()750
0 ! B
!*
/58>
> #
*#
#
)*!
/5(!!#(*##
(!@!/5#>
(1%12&
9: *8 #
##(!*
(8
9: *8 #
#@*(
(8
((
:#;-(*
!*(#(!*B
5*P 4#()##H
%(%4
4 ( % = (
!%((( !(
! ( ! =
!
4.1.3 Terminology
#
#(B
75555'5>
% > ( !
(#(=(
%> ( (
#(=(
O :.;> ! =
! *8
#(#!
(@!
# :%;> @ ! =
! *8
#(###:@#!;
=
! *8
#(#!
(+ :1;> =
! *8
#(#!
:!#@!
# * = * !
@!;
1I:.O$+O%; `6
,>(!
! ! /5
#!
, > ( ! /5
>&@
# % &7I8 ?
&?/&
#()75
>!#!
*>#
*!*(
# ( = * B :; / '! B
:;
4.1.4 Benefits of PERT
/5!#>
@!!!
/(!!
!(!!
*!
%(
4.1.5 Limitations
/5S*#K9%8221L>
( ! #
@! !#(8 (
(# 8 !#!!#(
(
( 8 /5
8(
!*8/5 *(
! ! !
4 ! !
(8/5(@!!!
! ! ! #
!!8,'
!*!@!
!!B
75555'5
445*P 4#()##H
4.2 Tool developed
4.2.1 Introduction
#!(@
!!(
//0*! !!
8
#88#!
( ! ! !)
( ( ! ! !
#!*!!
#
>
6:'
(( (*! !
=*( A 8 8 (
# ( !
:;#(
(
!((
08!!
D
# ( ! !)
*#!
8:O"'9":
0 (8 !( #
54
(!4#)
((*
! ( !! ! (
!
$( !!@( # # #
!!@ @! > ( B =
( B #
!B!!
#
#
@
45*P 4#()##H
6(!>!(
!D%
#!*
/(#!8
@!
6* 8 @ ! (
( !(!
B@!(#(
* !
54!
-((#(>
'I + ''' +M
!(:8';:0#2;
*
!
:; @8
>
(b
GH@
0!8 !@(@)I@B*!
# ( ( Q #! !8 *!
#
9 !
4$5*P 4#()##H
#!()!%!
(!8(@!@
!@ !! !( ( :# (
(;:D8@@6;( !@,
: ; @! 5 !@
,!
!#
#
!@(##!@
8 ( @ ! 8
# !
% (! !## !
((#>
,@
543
@OIW
@O
K 8LI,V2
(@84O
C@@!#:8!(=
=(;>
O
465*P 4#()##H
! :'/0 ; % :40;
# '/0 ( !
: 40 '/0 ; *
0 ( 8 !# !
!((#*
*( !@ (
40 (#$
8#=
K 8LI,
O
=
540
4 W 4
EI W W W
4 W 4
(# !#
K 8L:8,88E(!
!@@;
!@(E8E
(@8E,I,8!!(E
>
EE,IE
,
EEI8
,IE,
6, :#
45*P 4#()##H
,E2,E
,
4E,E
,
YI I
4!#!#
!8 @ ! # #
!!(#'=(8
,E4,E
,E
4E4 2E
E
8
I
@&
,E ,E
2E E
Y
I
,E,
E,
(!!
%">
40>*
%>
! > # 0 8
@! Y # :
(!;#
!> #0=
# (! :V2;8
# #
=#
!> 40> E,IE
,
O>
54
( * ! # 8 !
0 ! (8 !( !
(B@O(b
(B@O(B@)))I
@)))!@)))a2
N(8 !@ = *
(8(>
(B@O(B@)))O + I
+ + a2
I ( ) ''' +
45*P 4#()##H
()a2
3!:!;(!@
>
,@ ( ) ''' +
!
5
* ! 7 0
! @ !##!?
>
# A( :8 8
88;?
>
# : (; *
'*#!
>
/5*'! :8!8
%:;*(?
(?
5*P 4#()##H
:;?
!#:;?
:;
/&((!
5!
(!! ),
-#(!>
!>(G%(HO(#8
#BG-#H?
!N8!N8*N*N?
>!#B0#2?
>(:;?
*>(
%((#(
-:(;8#>
(!$@,
E#(!>
!> ( G3HO ( #8
#BG-#H?
$5*P 4#()##H
>(:;?
4>(0
!8#:!;4
!
:0#+;
*>'(?
NN+>?
NN N+N>
!(
(!3##
0 8 NN N+N # #
(!E#((
(#(
D#(!
53
(!6./&
% D #> (
8!
65*P 4#()##H
7
(!1K
7
(!)#
0 #! 8 ! :8 '; ( !
:XX!8 '; ! :X@X!8 ';
(!
4(#!#!B(#!0
@!8#.+8
(4.++8(#
!#4(+8(
#
)>
##H50
(
'
5*P 4#()##H
($4(,&%12&
8
*8
@*#4@*(
0*/5#>
($2
&
3.!1
(*0
/5 # * ( #
#*#!>
## # #
#0#&
##H5
($2
3/5##!!
*(:I(+;#
:I(;
!(-(!!(#(
!-#>
($!(
#/5#(
*
(
! *!D*! !( *
!(*#*>!*
(*!!!
G!H(( !*
(*(%!(
! !0
(
45*P 4#()##H
($$ 7$&8
0#&&!(
/5!=*B4(
#( ,!(
# * !#
!8*D
(##0#
&+#(GH*
%4B=%(+
($3####
-#(
!(#!%##
# #= /5#
- ## =(
! !( !
(R,6
##H5
4.3.2 Automatic creation of the PERT
# !
!*/5
((/5
-
R,6
R,6(!>
($6L+:)%12&
0#!:%;#
! :Q ; (
:4%;8!:@!;
* * R,6 /5 *
% * 8 *# :;8 ! :;8
-#:;80#:#;(:(;
/!!
!#
(#@!#
*!4 # /5 #
*!!
5*P 4#()##H
## * !4 (!GH?
H>GH?
>!GH
!
'(,?
'(
$! #+
% :; ( 8
!*#>
=*?
!
- !3 !
0 ( *
!#(!
=*!!@
(04(9
##H5!
*!8,/8R,6
#(/50#&.
($01%12>%%-
# ! ( ## GH
!-*!:;8#
8&!!!*!:%;
#:4;
% G-!%(H(
!(*! :2
)*;!(*
:2
* ;
!!*%=8
(*#(
((#
0!*#0#
&.#!(4848
%%&
(#
=(
!#
#!
!
$5*P 4#()##H
#( (
# !
!(D
0!!(B
0#&1
($##!
%!!//0*!(@
##H53
$! #,
%/50
##(*#
* ( !!@ * (
**#E#
*#/5
0 # ! (
> /E6: ; ( !
##
0 -
!!@*
(*
0 ! # :4 (; *
# *
!
#%:;
=
# ! ( #
=(-
!0**
# # ( # #
##
#D
= 8 (
B#8!(
(
=#,/R,6
( B ,
%
B *
=5 #!
:!###R,6;
!,/
% = ,/ R,6
!>
65*P 4#()##H
N#?
N#(
(
$!! ###
%!!#(/5
# # /5
(
8 # *#8
!8 # # ( # # *
*(3
!8 #8* B
B##>#8
!#*(
- @!0#&.&+*# #
>
5 5/5
/:; &"":; &&2:;
,,%12
&T%@!!#(
/5
#(
!:!!*; /5#3
(!(!
4.3.3 Conclusion
%#/5#*!#
(*(##
3!
##H50
%#'/N#!(
/5(
!!@!/5#
B # '/N
(*!
5*P 4#()##H
/5
* //0-*!# !!(
#
*#*
Chapter 5 Development of a tool to solve Space
Allocation Problem
5.1 Introduction
% ! B !( !# B
!
!4#!=!(#
#(!(#3#
!(##!*!8
# !
!45*I 4#
% #! ( :$N; # *!
#?
%!
45!
-!!(
*!32 B!(2
*!B12 B!( 12 *!
*!((!
!#!
5.2 Development of the tool
5.2.1 Introduction
-@(!F#-
*!*# !%(
>#
*B*!
!(**(=
#!*!
*
!##!>
(
*
!( # (
#3
* (
!!@((#
!!! #
!**#
*(8
!*@(@
*#
(!#8*#
!
!5*I 4#
>(
*A(
##
-(@(F!
!( # !#
'=(##
0( !*!
#B #(
(#
(# @!
*! !
8 !# !
*!!!
*D
#
*!D #!
!!#
*#
*8!(
#((*!
(!
45!!
! !( *! - !(
!4
* !( #N(
!-
# (
* # #
*!B0#+
(3;###
*!!
!#*!0#+
(3!#
'=(8
* !# (
(!(@B0#+&
!$5*I 4#
Overhead view of the Workshop Timeline view of the Workshop
(3$(&,&
#!*!)!(
( ! ! D
(*!D
4 # !
=
*
1
450B!
*A(B#!>
3
*=
*
!?
#?
6#?
=
*B?
$>#8#
( !#E
!#!*!0
12*!8#!((
*@>
*
( # ( @ ( * ! * !
(*!
*
(!
# 450
6C*;$$
45!3
3 = !
**! !
@(
- ( *!
!*!R,6"
#>
*!>
% @! (8 !
-?
- *# *!
!=!0!#
( ! '=( *# >
88!*!##
!!@
*
*
(-*#!*#
*!*##
*8!(!
! ( !(>
8!*!?
>@
!*!0@(
3 !(
!65*I 4#
-*#(*8@
*
#
*
3
*
*! !(
!8*!!(
*
-*
*!#@!B0#
++ ! #8 3 !(
##
*!(!
*@
0
*-@
@(8@*#@#D*
!
45!0
(33E&H
(
*(!#
!B0#+!*(0@
*#
*8(#*!(
!
(36+,&
-!
*(##B0#+1
3 ! !! ( ! !
!( (('=(
*
! !
#
!B0#+.
(30.
!5*I 4#
%#
*#*8!(
!#
*D
! !( #
*
! *# ( B !(
8 -
* !
* B ! B
#
*!B
0#+1
##( !
* (
*!
* !( @ 0 ( (
!(!
Normal Block
Fixed Block
Fictive Block Overlapping Blocks
(3:,&
!8
*
! ( ( *
#(!(
**!
*
-
*!#
- ! # - !
!#!
*!(
!
*
* (
#D
**
= ( D - !
*8 *
8 !8 # !8 * #
(!#
*)
!0#++B4.-!
(#
*%#
*
86
45!
!!
*B0#+"
*
*
( *!
* #
*
*!
(3
,&,&
#
*8* !
*(#8
*D4
!
*!(
B
*B
!(!(#!(
* ! #
# #
*-#
(>
*!D#
##(
!
!
*-*!
*!
*( ,
*
*
*
(BBD
%@!%#
*
*@
!#
# #
* (
*
$45*I 4#
(D!@
*-
!((!=*(%(
! %#
;88
* ! 0# ++-
*
*!(#
*%
# # *!> #
#) # #
* 8
*
*! @
* (
!(@
*
3 !(*!
* #B
(A@
**
450#
*>
*#
#D
B
450
*>
*#
*#?
'
!!
*)!*#?
*?
#
3@
*!0@!
#
* 0 #
@
*(0@-
* 450 - #
* +8 4?)( @ # #
(!!(
%!!%#(
*!
((D#
*
*(*#*!%
!(##-!(((
88(&Y(+Z
45$
(*#(((
! ( ( > *
(!#(*!!#(
= *!!# *# ( B ( (
E #(!
%
*#
#
0 0#++ B
(AA(B
)B
#>
5B(!
*?
,#
*B0#2?
5
B! !
!?
/(#!
*@
4
*(?
!
!#
*?
$5*I 4#
(64;#
3!(*!
0#
(6!5#
!##!
)*
45$!
5.2.3 Theory developments of the optimisation
N!!(
!!#8!#!(
#(((!#0
#
*
##
*B
*(@%!
!
!
$$5*I 4#
#
*!8#@
*>
!Ic28d#
*!?
Ic8W8%d
*!?
@(
8!#!!!
*
?
Ic28d:
*:@a2@OKO:;LbH;
*#:(a2(OKO:;Lb,;
*:aOb';
'
!
*
%!8(!
*
!!#
-@
*(#8
!Ic88d
@! #! !8
= #( ! (
= (! ( ! 4?
# # B 0# - ! !
(8#
*8
#
8AH
45$3
(6##,&,
/. 7%%
4 /*# / : 4//;8 #
#! 8
$65*I 4#
E0!8(!!#!
# ( #
8## !
*#(
0P !! 22 e!D A4 ?##e
##@(!
!((!!8
e
e
(/)
"#
!! (
(?8#(!
*8!*
!
45$0
%(!
!
!
(#R!
##R!Og:R!;!
( (! ( 08 (
18%#:%P9"1";
:$""2;8@*#
!
(8 #
(#(= # :
8 * @8 ( ! !!; 8
@!##
!((!#
8!!!>,:$6;
8
!(# #
,
:06;
"#
$6
E:$6;
33*
$38 ! (-# # :"";8 !!
! * * # $6 8
!(# 068 ( M :"".; M P #
:"".8""";8(!! 4//(0P:22;
4(8$6!!(
8 #8
$5*I 4#
!!8#!(
!
45$
#
g:R; #
(8 ( #
06
( #
@
R #
g:R; :R;[:R;8 R
R? !! #
!
#!#8-
#
8 06!
!!R8 8
$60!806
8#!(88
8(!@8
4(#8
!(!
!
345*I 4#
- 06 ! ( !
8 #
( 6
,O:R; ( ( $68 ! #
!#
%#
!
8
*8!#!
453
!# 8 ( ( ! !!# 8
#
*
4!! > ( *(
#
* 8!!!##
!
*88
*#(!!8(
!# 8
*
!8 ! ##!
*
8 # ! ! :# ( *
!
#!!;3!
08!#(
* ! # SS( #
kk R8
ROI>O:RS;( # :RRS;
#8!
!
*#
#
*
4(##8!
! * !!
! $6 !
!+-( ( E8 !
! ( #8
*( ( # 8 ( ( (
!(@!#(8!
35*I 4#
#"##
>!##!(
@%8(@(:#';
!(!!#!8
(#
8#((
*!
#%8#
*(8@!8
8
*
#!-
( ! 0 # Q8
:Q;
#@>
:Q;I:Q;O(+#:R;I< '
':Q;Oi' 8
!:Q;O(+#:Q;
(+#:Q;8
!#8!
#
453!
% 8 #(- !!#
*
*#(!
%# !!#
*
*-
!
!
*#
6(
**!
-
* F E #
!!(
*(!
0@!(##
!
9(
3$5*I 4#
= !(#!
* @
?
>
# " 9)((:>
!!(
*
!#8!!!#
((#!?
> ,>(!##)?
>
(+ 9#O!4()%O!NO)%(:> ## # @
!%@!8(!! ! @
*(!8(
#
*
F!#!
*
:;
3!(#*#
!
4533
(6$#4
*!GH!#@
! @
! B #8
# 8 !# B
(###%#*
8!
'!+(
#(
!!
#
(#
-(!!(#*!0
!(!#!
!! # D(@( *!
> ! # !
64A*J *
(!*!B//0*!B
88(!!
#((!
0 @! ! !# (
!#
'!&'!+@!!
6.3 Conclusion ##!#*!#
! *!(## '!(
!@(*-*#!@*!B
B#
#(#!@!#!
(*!!(B#(
!(
B
! !
#A6
!'=(!
//0*!# # (*
!((#!
'!&!!/5
!
!
('!+!
*!!0
#*!!
(D
M
!# *!
# # ! 5 !@ ,
!!(((
*(#
(#!!(
## !(
*! 4 *# # 8 !( (
'=( *!) # #
!! !( B
!B!(*
!
! B !,#
*!(#!
( B B !
6A*J *
((D%8!!!!
!(D
/5
!
!!!
#!
!!
!!
0 !
( !! !E #
((!!!
#!!%@#
6!
Glossary E!%@!
#(
A>!!(E(%%&
(?
P>!!(E(%&%+
%?
I> ! ! ( E( %+
?
?4)O>5/(%*C!(?
*>'!M!B
(B!(!(
?
4?)(> ' #
* !
!?
4*D> % //0 *! /,
?
()#> ! 5 /# 9 !#
#?
% //0 *!
*
!(!8##?
!> !
6$
#D,>0G#D,H/
!#
# (% !
)
*=#*?
#':(!;//0*!##!
?
#)>!##//0*!?
)?> % //0 *! #
!?
M> % //0 *!
!?
> # # ! % B
# //0 B #! !
(#?
*#>//0*!###?
=#*:N/'%N/'4;>#//0*!?
=#>#//0*!?
;7=(?
;?7M4%!!?
Q @,*! 6## # * # (
@(!?
63
Table of Figures 67
66
AB74O' LP
P@7O' LP
P67#?O' LI
P87%*O' LJ
PA7(+ LJ
PP7 LL
PI7$
60
LB7
6AJ
C@7, 6AL
C67 6AC
C87#+ 6AC
CA74+' 6AB
CP7# 6P@
CI7# 6P@
CJ7D 6P6
CL7H# 6P8
CC7# 6P8
CB7 6PA
B@7%"H 6PP
B67* 6PI
B87 6PJ
BA7 )` ` 6PL
BP7*O' 6PC
BI74' 6PB
BJ7 ` ` 6I@
BL7 6I8
BC74+>
+ 6IP
BB7>
##H 6II
6@@7> 6IL
6@67O 6IC
6@87O 6IC
6@A7O" 6IB
6@P7H 6J@
6@I74 6J6
6@J7O 6J8
6@L7 )`N, ` 6JP
6@C7 )` ` 6JL
6@B7 6JB
66@7#%" 6L@
6667% 6L@
6687; 6L8
66A7, 6LA
66P7%# 6LI
66I7%# 6LJ
66J7%
6
66B7D" 6CA
68@7! 6CP
6867)"7&" 6CC
6887) 6CB
68A7, 6CB
68P7(+ 6CB
68I7 6B@
68J7 6B@
68L7% 6B6
68C7) 6B8
68B7(+#() 6BL
6A@7* 8@6
6A67%#()! 866
6A87 868
6AA7
86A
6AP7!
86A
6AI7* 86P
6AJ7O" 86I
6AL7)# 86I
6AC7(5* 86J
6AB7% 86J
6P@7#() 86C
6P67)8 86C
6P87) 86B
6PA7 86B
6PP79P: 88@
6PI7 88@
6PJ7Q
6
6IB7 8AB
6J@7D 8P8
6J67A4 8P8
6J87 8PI
6JA7#O" 8IA
6JP768@ 8II
6JI76C@ 8II
6JJ7#
04
References Papers/Journal/Books:
%%5 %3 95 7? :"1";8 ?"
, '222
'00,%3$8$(,57 ?:"".;8+
7 8 E
8 + !# D
#8/-/#'!(4
'6C8 %?:""";8%>(8
-8#!
0%58/3$5 %3 Y%'E%5%3,?:22;8>,
4? ##8 305,7'!#8M+838!!
.1
$%5C,5%3 7E33 ? :".";8* %7 >
!# *8-E083C*
$6M50?:""2;788M283&8!!.&"&
$6 45$?:"1";>"
$5 38/?6 378:"12;8 8 7-( P 8
83C*
E665?645,%3?:22;%8
,%E58/3$5 %3 M$ ?:222;8%
!%!!,
/(8$
89(
9%558 $?4589/?3%8?5$8/?:22;8
7!!8!!&
0
9-%5%8 958 ,% ENN E%3% M58 M5%4E% 5% /8 N,3 5 ,58
5NMN5NM%%39%5E%5%E?:221;8O#()+
'87'37'!3*
(8M613
6%3$5C84%5084%C,?8'%/5%'78'5%,%C%3 5$/?:22+;8O"
8',/22+8E#
68?3$87?:"";8
7!!8!!"
666C8 ? $5%-8 9?-%6638 5? :22;8 4
7
!!8!!
,%3890?%3$89?9-3$?:""";8>8!#M#86
,%566 8 /3$5 %3 M$ ? :222;8
8305,!58M&1838!!+.
,N5%% E8 0N7CE 98 3%9%%9 %3 9%7%3 C? :"";8 ;,%
0
MN N5'%3 %3$?:"".;8
? 8 ! 5
628!!".
MN N5' %3 %3$? :"".;8>
8!7!5838!!&"
&""
-%3$'7%3 %3$:"";8
8 /
# ' % 3
3*8!!"+""
Websites:
755X
755X
75555'5X
75555#N(NN)N&X
755X
Other references
# DL@66