Progress towards Superlattice-Source Vertical Nanowire III-V MOSFETs
Jesús A. del Alamo and Xin Zhao Microsystems Technology Laboratories
MIT
E3S TeleseminarSeptember 26, 2013
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
joyuenTypewritten Text
2
Outline
1. Device concept
2. Simulations
3. Nanowire FET fabrication technology
4. Electrical characteristics of InGaAs NW‐MOSFETs
5. Next steps
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
1. Device conceptNanowire FET with Superlattice Source
3
joyuenTypewritten Text
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
High‐energy tail of electrons at source of FET responsible for subthreshold current
Why S=60 mV/dec at best in FETs?
4
∝
High energy tail Subthreshold current
High‐energy tail of source electrons
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
5
Key idea: suppress electron tail at source by engineering DOS
Empty miniband
Partially filled miniband
Minigap
Source DOS engineered to eliminate high‐energy electrons subthreshold current suppressed
DOS at source
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
60 mV/dec
VGS
log ID
Steep S!
0
Source Channel Drain
Subthreshold Characteristics
6
A
AB
C
C
B
Three regimes of operation:1. Steep slope regime: limited by source to drain tunneling2. Subthreshold regime: thermionic emission of tail
electrons (minimized for narrow miniband)3. ON state: ballistic transport
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
How to create Miniband/Minigap DOS at Source?
7
Two essential ingredients:1. Superlattice source: to create miniband/minigap
structure in longitudinal direction2. Nanowire geometry: to impose transversal quantization,
create 1D subbands and open a true minigap
Esaki, TSF 1976
1D‐DOSBand structure of SL
Gnani, IEDM 2011
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
8
2. Simulations: Nanowire SL structures
Expected 1D subbandstructure
In0.53Ga0.47As NW, D=4.5 nm
• Nexnano• Start by calibrating simulator with simple nanowire structures
In0.53Ga0.47As NW, D=15 nm
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
9
SL source with lateral confinement: minibands split into subbands
3 nm In0.53Ga0.47As/1.2 nm In0.52Al0.48As SL, D=15 nm
• In NW configuration, SL minibands split into subbands• For wide diameters, subbands overlap in energy
Same miniband, different subbands
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
10
Tight transversal confinement:Minigap appears in all k directions
With NW diameter
11
Minigap widens as NW diameter shrinks
For small D, minigap between 1st and 2nd miniband
Same minibanddifferent subbands
Eg=0.23 eV between 1st and 2nd miniband
3 nm In0.53Ga0.47As/1.2 nm In0.52Al0.48As SL, D=4.5 nm
different miniband
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
Transmission coefficient of standard NW
InGaAs nanowire (D=4.5 nm)
1st subband
2nd subband(two‐fold degenerate)
Expected plateau structure
DOS
12
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
Transmission coefficient of SL NW
3 nm In0.53Ga0.47As/1.2 nm In0.52Al0.48As SL NW (D=4.5 nm,10 periods)
1st miniband
2nd miniband230 meV
Transmission coefficient clearly reveals minigap in SL NW DOS13
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
T(E) suppressed by >two decades in minigap14
3 nm In0.53Ga0.47As/1.2 nm In0.52Al0.48As SL NW (D=4.5 nm,10 periods)
Transmission coefficient of SL NW
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
• Dielectric/semiconductor interface:• Interface traps with allowed states• Roughness
• Sharpness of miniband edges:• Finite number of periods of SL• Imperfection of the crystal lattice:
• Doping• Phonons• Intermixing• Crystal defects: dislocations, etc
• Non‐uniformity of nanowire diameter
15
Non-idealities
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
16
3. NW MOSFET fabrication technology
• Nanowire MOSFET provides ultimate scalability• Vertical Nanowire uncouples footprint scaling and gate length
scaling can achieve excellent SCE on a tiny footprint
Gate‐All‐Around Nanowire MOSFET: ultimate CMOS device!
Kuhn, TED 2012
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
17
Vertical NW MOSFET fabrication technology
Key elements:• In0.53Ga0.47As source, drain and channel• Top‐down approach based on RIE (a first!)• High‐k dielectric by ALD, wrap‐around‐gate
Device vehicle: InGaAs NW‐MOSFET
Zhao, IEDM 2013
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
joyuenTypewritten Text
InGaAs
Adhesionlayer
HSQ
ALD‐Al2O3
ALD‐WN
SOG
Top View Side View
Starting substrate
Step 1Mask definition by EBL
Step 2RIE and cleaning
Step 3Digital Etch
Superlattice
Contact
Fabrication technology
18
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
Step 4High‐K/Gate metal depositionand patterning
Step 5Planarization andetch back
Step 62nd planarization, etch back and G/D contact opened
Gate
Gate Drain
Step 7Metalization Gate DrainSource
n+ InGaAssource
InGaAschannel
19
InGaAs
Adhesionlayer
HSQ
ALD‐Al2O3
ALD‐WN
SOG
Superlattice
Contact
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
20
Key enabling technology: RIE etch by BCl3/SiCl4/Ar Chemistry
• In compounds hard to etch• BCl3/SiCl4/Ar RIE chemistry used for III‐V optical devices• Never used for nm‐scale features• Substrate temperature during etch is key!
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
21
Key enabling technology: RIE etch by BCl3/SiCl4/Ar Chemistry
No notching in the etching of complex heterostructures
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
22
Nanowire RIE followed by digital etch
• Shrinks NW diameter by 2 nm per cycle• Unchanged shape• Improved sidewall roughness
Digital etch: self‐limiting O2 plasma oxidation + H2SO4 oxide removal
before after 10 cycles
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
23
After 1st planarization
Nanowire arrays Contacts
50 nm
5 µm5 µm
50 nm
40 nmGate metal
30 nm
After 2nd planarization
Nanowire
Gate
Source
Drain
Gate metal
Pictures along the fabrication process
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
24
4. Electrical characteristics of InGaAs NW-MOSFETs
Single nanowire MOSFET: D= 30 nm, LG= 80 nm, 4.5 nm Al2O3 (EOT = 2.2 nm)
At VDS=0.5 V (normalized by periphery):• gm,pk=280 μS/μm• S=200 mV/dec• Ron=759 Ω.μm
0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.50
5
10
15
20
I d (
A)
Vds (V)
Vgs=-0.6 V to 0.8 V in 0.1 V stepRon=759 m(at Vgs=1 V)Lch=80 nmD=30 nm
0
50
100
150
200
Nor
mal
ized
I d (
A/m
)
-0.6 -0.4 -0.2 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6
10-8
10-7
10-6
10-5
Vds=0.05V
I d (A
)
Vgs(V)
Vds=0.5VIg< 10-9 A
DIBL=195 mV/VS(Vds=0.05V)=145 mV/decS(Vds=0.5V)=200 mV/dec
10-7
10-6
10-5
10-4
Nor
mal
ized
I d (A
/m
)
-0.6 -0.4 -0.2 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.60
50
100
150
200
Vgs(V)
0
50
100
150
200
250
300gm, pk(Vds=0.5 V)=280 S/m
Vds=0.5V
Nor
maz
lied
I d (
A/m
)
Nor
mal
ized
gm (
S/
m)
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
joyuenTypewritten Text
25
D=50 nm InGaAs NW-MOSFETsSingle nanowire MOSFET:
D= 50 nm, LG= 80 nm, 4.5 nm Al2O3 (EOT = 2.2 nm)
At VDS=0.5 V:• gm,pk=730 μS/μm• S=305 mV/dec• Ron=310 Ω.μm
0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.50
20
40
60
80
100
Vds (V)
I d (
A)
Vgs=-0.6 V to 0.8 V in 0.1 V stepRon=310m(at Vgs=1 V)LG=80 nmD=50 nm
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
Nor
mal
ized
I d (
A/m
)
-0.8 -0.6 -0.4 -0.2 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.810-7
10-6
10-5
10-4
I d (A
)
Vgs(V)
DIBL=360 mV/VS(Vds=0.05V)=210 mV/decS(Vds=0.5V)=305 mV/dec
Ig< 10-10 A
Vds=0.5V
Vds=0.05V
10-6
10-5
10-4
Nor
mal
ized
I d (A
/m
)
-1.0 -0.8 -0.6 -0.4 -0.2 0.0 0.2 0.40
100
200
300
400
500
600
Nor
maz
lied
I d (
A/
m) gm, pk(Vds=0.5 V)
=730 S/m
Vds=0.5V
Vgs(V)
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
Nor
maz
lied
g m (
S/m
)
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
26
Impact of nanowire diameter
30 35 40 45 50
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
Nanowire Diameter (nm)
DIB
L (m
V/V
)
30 35 40 45 50
100200300400500600700800900
Nor
mal
ized
gm (
S/
m)
Nanowire Diameter (nm)
Vds=0.5 V
30 35 40 45 50200
400
600
800
1000
1200
Vgs=1 VNorm
aliz
ed R
on (
m
)
Nanowire Diameter (nm)
D↓ S↓, DIBL↓, gm↓, Ron↑
30 35 40 45 50
150
200
250
300
350S
(mV
/dec
)
Nanowire Diameter (nm)
Vds=0.5V
Vds=0.05V
Error bars indicate distribution of ~10 devices
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
27
Impact of digital etch
InGaAs NW‐MOSFETs with D= 40 nm (final diameter)
For same final diameter, digital etch:• Improves subthreshold swing• Improves peak transconductance• Reduces gate leakage current
-0.6 -0.4 -0.2 0.0 0.2 0.4
10-8
10-7
10-6
10-5
w/ digital etchw/o digital etch
Vgs(V)
I d (A
)
Vds=0.5V
Vds=0.05V
10-7
10-6
10-5
10-4
Nor
mal
ized
I d (A
/m
)
-1.0 -0.8 -0.6 -0.4 -0.2 0.0 0.2 0.410-6
10-5
10-4
10-3Vds=1 V
I g (A
/cm
2 )Vgs(V)
w/ digital etch
w/o digital etch
better sidewall interfacial characteristics
-0.5 -0.4 -0.3 -0.2 -0.1 0.0 0.1 0.20
100
200
300
400
500 w/ digital etch w/o digital etch
Vgs(V)
Nor
maz
lied
g m (
S/
m)
joyuenTypewritten Text
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
Benchmarking against bottom-up InGaAs NW-MOSFETs
• Fundamental trade‐off between transport and SCE• Top‐down NW‐MOSFETs as good as bottom up devices
28
Persson, DRC 2012
Tomioka, Nature 2012
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
29
5. Next steps
1. Refine nanowire fabrication process• Make more robust• Reduce gate leakage current• Scale to D~20 nm
2. Study InGaAs Nanowire MOSFETs• Build simple models (ballistic transport, electrostatics) and compare with measurements• Study transport at low temperatures
3. Fabricate InGaAs Nanowire MOSFETs with SL source• Experimental observation of SL filtering
4. Simulations of SLS‐NW MOSFETs• Dispersion relations, DOS, transmission coefficient, etc.
5. Fabricate Nanowire Tunnel FETs• In collaboration with Theme I colleagues• Initially, follow Intel’s heterostructure design
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.
30
Intel’s InGaAs Tunnel MOSFET
Dewey, IEDM 2011
joyuenTypewritten TextFor E3S Internal Use ONLYThese slides may contain prepublication data and/or confidential information.