7/31/2019 Progressive income tax: Money grab disguised as tax reform

1/22?

Kaw( ?4% 34?3)

Tsknsjbvj bhak`j wo|9 @khjr nsoc gbnzbjg o wo| sjfks`cr jg Gocsk~mb% Vbaj Tsjbgjhw k Tkebar ohg Eo~sjhaj I( @a_zbeeoh% TlG Albj Jakhk`bw

Wlj tskcej`Bh oh bhwjsvbj~ ~bwl Lzhnwkh Tkw% Nkv( Tow _zbhh obg wlow Beebhkb hjjg o tsknsjbvj bhak`j wo|(? Wowkhj k `r nkoe cjksj B wkt csjowlbhn ohg B zsj lktj ~j aoh njw wlow gkhj bh Beebhkb( Qkkhjs sowljs wloh eowjs%lj wkeg wlj bhwjsvbj~js(

Wj o`j ksaj wlow ljetjg _zbhh eohg wlj nkvjshkslbt bh 34?4 ohg sobj bhak`j wo|j bh 34?? osj eorbhn wljnskzhg~ksm ks lb tsknsjbvj wo| bhbwbowbvj( O tsknsjbvj bhak`j wo| ,oek aoeejg o nsogzowjg bhak`j wo|" wo|jbhgbvbgzoe bhak`j ow jvjs-lbnljs `osnbhoe wo| sowj o bhak`j sbj(

Qwowj Qjh( @baloje Fsjsbal ,G-Alo`tobnh"% M~o`j Sokze ,G-Albaonk" ohg kb Lzwalbhkh ,G-Albaonk Ljbnlw"lovj owwjhgjg jvjhw bh zttksw k o tsknsjbvj bhak`j wo|(3 Oek bh ovks k o tsknsjbvj bhak`j wo| osj QjhowjTsjbgjhw Iklh Azeejswkh ,G-Albaonk" ohg Sjt( Hok`b Iomkckh ,G-Zscoho"( Mjbwl Mjeejljs% tsjbgjhw k wljQjsvbaj J`tekrjj Bhwjshowbkhoe Zhbkh ,QJBZ" Ljoewlaosj Beebhkb ohg Bhgboho% ohg Ljhsr Corjs% j|jazwbvj gb-sjawks k wlj O`jsbaoh Fjgjsowbkh k Qwowj% Akzhwr ohg @zhbabtoe J`tekrjj ,OFQA@J" Akzhabe 1?% wlj eosnjwzhbkh sjtsjjhwbhn wowj nkvjsh`jhw j`tekrjj% oek zttksw o tsknsjbvj wo|(1

Ckwl wlj Beebhkb Jgzaowbkh Okabowbkh ohg wlj Beebhkb Fjgjsowbkh k joaljs om tkebwbaoe aohgbgowj ~lk

womj wljbs 34?3 aohgbgowj qzjwbkhhobsj b wljr ~kzeg zttksw o akhwbwzwbkhoe o`jhg`jhw kh wlj coeekw wkb`tej`jhw o nsogzowjg bhak`j wo|( Ohg bh Iohzosr 34?3% wlj ebcjsoe oawbvbw nskzt Abwbyjh Oawbkh+Beebhkb tkwjgo ikc ogvjswbj`jhw wlow sjog9

Beebhkb `oiks tsknsjbvj ksaj% bhaezgbhn bw ejogbhn abwbyjh oawbvbw nskzt% lz`oh jsvbajogvkaowj ohg eocks zhbkh% osj ak`cbhbhn jksw wk ~onj o `zewbrjos cowwej ks wo| izwbaj% aze`bhowbhnbh o akhwbwzwbkhoe o`jhg`jhw sjjsjhgz` bh 34?7( ^j osj jjmbhn o ( ( ( gbsjawks k ]oP wowj~bgj% wlsjj-rjos ejnbeowbvj ohg sjjsjhgz` ao`tobnh wk o`jhg wlj Beebhkb Akhwbwzwbkh ohg jhoaw o nsogzowjg wowjbhak`j wo|(7

Wb ikc tkbwbkh ~o eejg bh Otsbe 34?3(

O zhbkh-zhgjg nskzt bh Albaonk% wlj Ajhwjs ks o| ohg Czgnjw Oaakzhwocbebwr ,ACO"% lo ks`oebyjg o teohks o tsknsjbvj bhak`j wo|(

Bh Fjcszosr 34?3% wlj ACO sjejojg o sjtksw wbwejg Wj Aoqj fks Asjowbhn o Nsogzowjg Bhak`j o| bh Beebhkbq% ~lbalaeob` o nsogzowjg bhak`j wo| sowj wszawzsj akzeg sjgzaj wo|j ks 27 tjsajhw k Beebhkb wo|torjs ohg sobj owejow '3(7 cbeebkh `ksj bh sjvjhzj wloh wlj azssjhw vj-tjsajhw ow wo|( : Czw wlj wszwl b wlow o tsknsjbvj bhak`jwo| ~bee `joh lbnljs wo|j ks `bggej-aeo Beebhkboh ohg gjwskr hjjgjg ikc ks wlj tkks ohg ~ksmbhn o`bebj(

)Wlbq totjs ~oq ztgowjg kh Kawkcjs ?6% 34?3 wk ak`tosj wlj AWCOq tsknsjqqbvj-wo| qalj`j wk ckwl wlj qzhqjw ohg o sjtjoe kf wlj 34?? wo| lbmj(

7/31/2019 Progressive income tax: Money grab disguised as tax reform

2/223

Cjksj Beebhkb ow bhak`j wo| akzeg cj akhvjswjg wk o tsknsjbvj wo|% wlj Beebhkb Akhwbwzwbkh ~kzeg lovj wk cjo`jhgjg( Wb b cjaozj bw Sjvjhzj Oswbaej wowj9 O wo| kh ks `jozsjg cr bhak`j loee cj ow o hkh-nsogzowjgsowj( Azssjhwer% Beebhkb lo o ow wo| kh tjskhoe bhak`j k : tjsajhw% ~lbal ~o bhasjojg cr 6> tjsajhw bh 34??sk` wlj tsjvbkz sowj k 1 tjsajhw( Zhgjs azssjhw eo~% wlj bhasjoj ~bee cjnbh wk zhjw kh Ioh( ?% 34?: cr oeebhnwk 1(>: tjsajhw% ohg wljh oee onobh wk 1(3: tjsajhw kh Ioh( ?% 343:(

Wj ACO ohg bw oeebj osj lktbhn wk njw ottskvoe ks o tsknsjbvj wo| cr wlsjj-fl `oiksbwbj bh ckwl alo`cjsk wlj Beebhkb Njhjsoe Oj`cer 16 jhowks ohg >? sjtsjjhwowbvj wk tzw wlj qzjwbkh wk vkwjs bh o njhjsoejejawbkh( Eo~`omjs ~kzeg lovj wk ottskvj o tsknsjbvj wo| o`jhg`jhw cr joser @or 34?7 wk cj bhaezgjg khwlj Hkvj`cjs 34?7 coeekw( Wj josebjw wlow o tsknsjbvj wo| akzeg nk bhwk jjaw% wljsjksj% ~kzeg cj 34?:( Czwzttkswjs osj oesjogr eorbhn wlj nskzhg~ksm ohg cjnbhhbhn wlj ao`tobnh wk njw wlb `jozsj kh wlj coeekw bh34?7 ohg ottskvjg cr jbwljs 64 tjsajhw k wlkj vkwbhn kh wlj qzjwbkh ks o oiksbwr k wlkj vkwbhn bh wlj jejawbkh

Wj ACO tsknsjbvj wo| teoh absazeowbhn oskzhg wlj wowj ~kzeg b`tkj jbnlw jvjs-lbnljs `osnbhoe wo| sowj%wkttbhn k ow ?? tjsajhw ,jj ocej ? cjek~"( Wb ~kzeg wbj Beebhkb ~bwl Lo~obb ks lovbhn wlj lbnljw wkt bhak`jwo| sowj(

Wocej ?( Wlj AWCOq tsknsjqqbvj wo| qwszawzsjBeebhkbq ~kzeg wbj fks lbnljqw wkt `osnbhoe sowj bh wlj Z(Q(

@osnbhoe wo| sowj Coqj bhak`j sohnj Tjsajhwonj k sjwzshq wlow ~bee torjoal `osnbhoe sowj

4(4* 5'4:%444 ?7(:7

:(4* ':%44??44%444 >3(73

>(:* '?44%44??:4%444 6(

: tjsajhw sowj( ACO wo| sowjoek osj lbnljs wloh wlj sowj bh Lkzj Cbee ?>:% o cbee zttkswjg cr 7? ejnbeowks bh wlj 2>wl Njhjsoe Oj`cer wlow~kzeg sjtjoe wlj 34?? wo| lbmj ohg sjwzsh wlj tjskhoe bhak`j wo| sowj wk wlj 34?4 ejvje k 1 tjsajhw(

http://bit.ly/Rxwrlrhttp://bit.ly/Rxwrlrhttp://bit.ly/Rxwrlrhttp://bit.ly/Rxwrlr

7/31/2019 Progressive income tax: Money grab disguised as tax reform

3/221

O o sjzew k wlj 34?? wj`tksosr wo| lbmj cjbhn `ogj tjs`ohjhw% wlj ACO teoh ~bee oawzoeer sobj wo|j cr '6(7-

7/31/2019 Progressive income tax: Money grab disguised as tax reform

4/227

Wb sjtksw j|tkj wlj `rwl zhgjserbhn wlj tsknsjbvj wo| ohg lbnlebnlw bw tskcej` ohg tbwoee bh wlsjj `obhjawbkh9

,?" Wj howbkhoe wo| jhvbskh`jhw ohg ak`tjwbwbvjhjqq

O tsknsjbvj wo| ~bee jhg Beebhkb oesjogr lbnl wo|j jvjh lbnljs

O tsknsjbvj wo| b cjbhn sjijawjg cr kwljs wowj bh ovks k ek~% ow sowj

,3" Lk~ wlj tsknsjqqbvj wo| lzswq rkz

O tsknsjbvj wo| ~bee asjjt bhwk wlj `bggej aeoj

O tsknsjbvj wo| tzhblj zaaj ow OEE bhak`j ejvje

,1" Lk~ wlj tsknsjqqbvj wo| lzswq wlj jakhk`r ohg qwowj czgnjwbhn

O tsknsjbvj wo| lzsw ikc asjowbkh ohg jakhk`ba nsk~wl

O tsknsjbvj wo| b `ksoeer zhobs% tsjgowksr ohg tzhbwbvj

O tsknsjbvj wo| b o sjabtj ks czgnjwbhn gbowjs

7/31/2019 Progressive income tax: Money grab disguised as tax reform

5/22:

,?" Wlj howbkhoe wo| jhvbskh`jhw ohg ak`tjwbwbvjhj

O tsknsjqqbvj wo| ~bee qjhg Beebhkbq oesjogr lbnl wo|jq jvjh lbnljs

Wj tzstkj k wo|owbkh b wk hohaj akhwbwzwbkhoeer-tsjasbcjg nkvjsh`jhw oawbvbwbj( Bh o sjj kabjwr% wo|j

lkzeg bhzjhaj tsbvowj-jawks gjabbkh o ebwwej o tkbcej( kgor% lk~jvjs% wo|j bhzjhaj jvjsr `oiks o`bergjabbkh sk` ~ljh ohg ~ljsj wk czr wlj o`ber aos ohg lk`j% wk ~lbal ikc wk oaajtw% wk lk~ `zal `khjr wkovj ks albegsjh jgzaowbkh ks tosjhw sjwbsj`jhw% wk ~ljwljs khj aoh oksg ljoewl bhzsohaj(

Wj ACO ~ohw wk bhasjoj wo|j kh losg-~ksmbhn Beebhkboh( Czw Beebhkb b oesjogr o lbnl-wo| wowj(

ocej 3 lk~ wlow Beebhkb lo wlj ?1wl lbnljw ak`cbhjg wowj ohg ekaoe wo| czsgjh howbkhoeer( Wj o|Fkzhgowbkh% o ^olbhnwkh% G(A(-cojg wo| sjjosal nskzt% ossbvjg ow wlj sohmbhn cr aoeazeowbhn wlj wkwoe o`kzhwk wowj ohg ekaoe wo|j tobg cr sjbgjhw bh joal wowj% ohg wljh gbvbgbhn wlkj wo|j cr wlj wowj wkwoe bhak`jwk ak`tzwj wlj wo| czsgjh( O wrtbaoe Beebhkboh tor '7%:26 joal rjos bh wowj ohg ekaoe wo|j% ks ?4 tjsajhw k

bhak`j( Hk hjbnlcksbhn wowj tor `ksj wo|j tjs tjskh% ohg kher ^bakhbh sjbgjhw tor o eosnjs losj k wljbsbhak`j wk wo|j ,?? tjsajhw"( Beebhkb b < wl lbnljw ~ljh akhbgjsbhn izw wkwoe wo|j tobg wk wlj wowj k sjbgjhaj,wlj lk`j wowj"(

Wocej 3( Wkwoe qwowj ohg ekaoe wo|jq tobg tjs tjsqkh bh Beebhkbq ohg hjbnlcksbhn qwowjq% 3442Beebhkbq sohmq ?1wl lbnljqw

QwowjTjsajhw

kf Bhak`j

Sohm,? bq ljovbjqw

czsgjh howbkhoeer"

Wo|jq tobg wklk`j qwowjtjs aotbwo

Wo|jq tobg wkkwljs qwowjq

tjs aotbwo

Wkwoe qwowj ohg ekaoewo|jq tobgtjs aotbwo

Bhak`jtjs aotbwo

Beebhkbq ?4(4 ?1wl '1%7?< '?%?>> '7%:26 '76%4>2

Bhgboho 2(: 3:wl '3%:4? '6>Bk~o 2(: 37wl '3%6:> '?%41? '1%6 ' '1%73: '1>% Tjktej ohg kwljs bhak`j-njhjsowbhn ojwlovj ejf Beebhkb bh josal k lbnljs ofjs-wo| sjwzsh(

Wj 34?? bhak`j wo| lbmj `ogj Beebhkb bhak`j wo| czsgjh nsjowjs ak`tosjg wk wlj kwljs wowj( Beebhkb sohmbhnk wkwoe wowj bhak`j wo|j tobg `jozsjg jbwljs cr tjs aotbwo ks o o tjsajhwonj k tjskhoe bhak`j ~ksjhjg cr?4 teoaj sk` aoe rjos 34?4 wk aoe rjos 34??(< Wb lost ?4-teoaj oee kaazssjg jvjh wlkznl wlj wo| lbmj ~jsjbh jjaw ks kher loe k wlj 34?? aoe rjos% sk` Iohzosr 34?? kh~osg(

Beebhkb b o lbnl-wo| wowj( Wj tsknsjbvj wo| bhasjoj bh 34?: ~kzeg czsgjh Beebhkb wo|torjs jvjh `ksj ohg`omj wlj wowj o ej owwsoawbvj teoaj wk ebvj% ~ksm ohg wosw o hj~ czbhj(

Qkzsaj9Wo| Fkzhgowbkh% `kqw sjajhw gowo ovobeocej

http://bit.ly/JVHwaHhttp://bit.ly/JVHwaH

7/31/2019 Progressive income tax: Money grab disguised as tax reform

6/226

O tsknsjqqbvj wo| bq cjbhn sjijawjg cr kwljs qwowjq bh ovks k ek~% ow sowjq

ocej 1 lk~ wlj hbhj wowj wlow gk hkw wo| tjskhoe bhak`j( Wjr osj aowwjsjg oskzhg wlj akzhwsr(

Wocej 1( Qwowjq aeoqqbjg cr tjsqkhoe bhak`j wo|% 34?3

Hk wo| ,2" Feow wo| ,>"Feow wo|

tjsajhwonj sowjTsknsjqqbvj wo|

,17"Wkt `osnbhoe

wo| sowjHz`cjs kf

wo| csoamjwq

Oeoqmo Tjhhqrevohbo 1(4>* Hkswl Gomkwo 1(22* :

Feksbgo Bhgboho 1(74* Osbykho 7(:7* :

Hjvogo @balbnoh 7(1:* Hj~ @j|bak 7(24* 7

Hj~ Lo`tqlbsj) Akeksogk 7(61* Oeoco`o :(44* 1

Qkzwl Gomkwo Beebhkbq :(44* @bqqbqqbttb :(44* 1

Wjhhjqqjj) Zwol :(44* Kmeolk`o :(3:* >

Wj|oq @oqqoalzqjwwq :(14* @osreohg :(>:* :* 7^rk`bhn Klbk :(23:* 2

Slkgj Bqeohg :(22* 1

Njksnbo 6(44* 6

Mjhwzamr 6(44* 6

Ekzbqboho 6(44* 1

@bqqkzsb 6(44* ?4

Mohqoq 6(7:* 1

^jqw Vbsnbhbo 6(:4* :

Akhhjawbazw 6(>4* 6

Gjeo~osj 6(>:* 6Hjcsoqmo 6(

Osmohqoq >(44* 6

Qkzwl Aoskebho >(44* 6

Hkswl Aoskebho >(>:* 1

^bqakhqbh >(>:* :

Bgolk >(74* >

@bhhjqkwo >(

7/31/2019 Progressive income tax: Money grab disguised as tax reform

7/22>

Qjvjh wowj wo| tjskhoe bhak`j% czw ow o zhbks` wowzwksr sowj ,o ow wo|"( Tjhhrevohbo lo wlj ek~jw owsowj ow 1(4> tjsajhw= @ooalzjww lo wlj lbnljw ow :(1 tjsajhw( Beebhkb azssjhwer lo o ow sowj k : tjsajhw ofjsbhasjobhn wlj sowj cr 6> tjsajhw bh 34??% zt sk` wlj tsjvbkz sowj k 1 tjsajhw( Cjksj wlj wo| lbmj% Beebhkb logwlj ek~jw ow bhak`j wo| sowj bh wlj akzhwsr(

Wbswr-kzs wowj b`tkj o tsknsjbvj tjskhoe bhak`j wo|( Lo~obb lo wlj `kw `osnbhoe wo| csoamjw ~bwl ?3%keek~jg cr @bkzsb ~bwl ?4 csoamjw% ohg Bk~o ohg Klbk ~bwl hbhj( Lo~obb oek lo wlj lbnljw wkt `osnbhobhak`j wo| sowj ow ?? tjsajhw% keek~jg cr Aoebkshbo ow ?4(1 tjsajhw ohg Ksjnkh ow 2(2 tjsajhw( Jhaotzeowbhn~low wrtbaoeer lottjh bh tsknsjbvj wo| wowj% Aoebkshbo Nkv( Ijssr Csk~h ~ohw Aoebkshbo vkwjs wk bhasjojwlj Nkegjh Qwowj wkt sowj wk o lbnljw-bh-wlj-howbkh ?1(1 tjsajhw wlb oee(

Wj `kw ak``kh hz`cjs k csoamjw b wlsjj ,jvjh wowj lovj wlsjj csoamjw"( Qb| wowj lovj b| csoamjw ohgb| kwljs wowj lovj vj csoamjw(

Wj ACO ohg bw oeebj ~ohw Beebhkb eo~`omjs wk jhoaw o tsknsjbvj tjskhoe bhak`j wo| ~bwl jbnlw jvjs-lbnljs`osnbhoe wo| sowj% wkttbhn k ow ?? tjsajhw( B jhoawjg% wlb ~kzeg `kvj Beebhkb sk` lovbhn o zhbks` wo| wk o

wjjter tsknsjbvj bhak`j wo|% ~lbal b bskhba bhaj k`j tsknsjbvj wo| wowj osj akhbgjsbhn asottbhn wljbsbhak`j wo| oewknjwljs(

Bh 34?3% Moho% @bkzsb ohg Kmeolk`o akhbgjsjg `jozsj wk ockebl wlj tjskhoe bhak`j wo|( Joal k wljjwowj cksgjs o hk-wo| ks o ow-wo| wowj% wlz ak`tjwbwbkh b tsjzsbhn tsknsjbvj wo| wowj wk asot wljbszhak`tjwbwbvj bhak`j wo|(

Kmeolk`o Nkv( @osr Foeebh lo tsktkjg azwwbhn ohg zewb`owjer jeb`bhowbhn wlj bhak`j wo|( Ljs teoh ~kzegek~js wlj wowj bhak`j wo| wk 1(: tjsajhw sk` :(3: tjsajhw bh 34?1% ohg wljh tloj bw kzw ak`tejwjer cr bhasj`jhwk 4(3: tjsajhwonj tkbhw o rjos kvjs ?7 rjos(

Beebhkb wo| ekccr ~ohw wk b`tkj o wjjter tsknsjbvj bhak`j wo| ~ljh kwljs wowj osj wsrbhn wk jaotj wljbstsknsjbvj wo|(

,3" Lk~ wlj tsknsjbvj wo| lzsw rkz

O tsknsjqqbvj wo| ~bee asjjt bhwk wlj `bggej aeoqqjq

Qzttkswjs k o tsknsjbvj wo| oe~or aeob` wljr kher ~ohw wk wo| wlj Tosb Lbewkh k wlj ~kseg( Czw jvjhwzoeer

wljr ak`j ofjs wlj `bggej aeoj cr asjjtbhn gk~h wlj bhak`j eoggjs ~bwl lbnljs wo| sowj(

Aoebkshbo b o aeoba j|o`tej( Bw lo wjjter tsknsjbvj ohg j|ajtwbkhoeer lbnl tjskhoe bhak`j wo| sowj( WjNkegjh Qwowj wo|j tjskhoe bhak`j ow jvjh bhasjobhner-lbnljs sowj bhaezgbhn o wkt sowj k ?4(1 tjsajhw% jakhgkher wk Lo~obb(

Czw Aoebkshbo jakhg-lbnljw `osnbhoe sowj k 2(1 tjsajhw mbam bh ow kher '7

7/31/2019 Progressive income tax: Money grab disguised as tax reform

8/22

Alsbqwbho Sk`js ohg Govbg Sk`js9 Bh 344>% wljr j|o`bhjg wlj jjaw k ?47 jtosowj qzoswjser tkw-~os wo| alohnj sk` ?27> wlskznl 3446 kh nsk gk`jwba tskgzaw ,NGT" nsk~wl% ohg wljr akhaezgjgwlow wo| alohnj lovj vjsr eosnj jjaw kh kzwtzw(?< O wo| bhasjoj k ? tjsajhw k NGT ek~jsjg kzwtzwo `jozsjg cr sjoe NGT cr skznler 3 wk 1 tjsajhw( Wjr oek kzhg wlow wo| bhasjoj ~jsj ebhmjg wklost gjaebhj bh bhvjw`jhw% ~lbal `ogj wlj NGT sjgzawbkh k eosnj ohg tjsbwjhw(

Iklh @zeejh ohg @oswbh beebo`q9 Wjr j|o`bhjg Z(Q( wowj ohg ekaoe wo| rwj` ohg ak`tosjg wlj`wk wowj jakhk`ba tjsks`ohaj(?2 Zbhn wowj gowo sk` ?262 wk ?2> wk ?221 ohg kzhg wlow wowj ~bwl tsknsj-bvj wo|j log bnhbaohwer ek~js jakhk`ba nsk~wl sowj kvjs wlj jhwbsj tjsbkg(3? Wj sjzew ~o gsbvjhcr wlj lbnl nsk~wl sowj bh wowj wlow cjhjwjg sk` wljbs wo|-lovjh wowz ogioajhw wk tsknsjbvj wo|wowj(

Cossr Tkzeqkh ohg Izejq Nksgkh Moteoh9 Wjr j|teksjg wlj b`toaw k wo| tkebar kh jakhk`ba nsk~wlbh wlj Z(Q( wowj sk` ?267 wk 3447(33 Wjr kzhg wlow lbnljs `osnbhoe wo| sowj log o hjnowbvj b`toawkh jakhk`ba nsk~wl( Qwowj wlow ljeg wlj sowj k nsk~wl bh sjvjhzj cjek~ wlj sowj k nsk~wl bh bhak`j

7/31/2019 Progressive income tax: Money grab disguised as tax reform

12/22?3

oalbjvjg lbnljs sowj k jakhk`ba nsk~wl( Oek mjr% wowj wlow b`tkjg oh bhak`j wo| wk njhjsowj onbvjh ejvje k sjvjhzj j|tjsbjhajg ek~js sowj k jakhk`ba nsk~wl ak`tosjg wk wowj wlow sjebjg khoewjshowbvj wo|j wk njhjsowj wlj o`j sjvjhzj wlj ak`tosowbvj gjog~jbnlw akw `jhwbkhjg josebjs(

Oswlzs Eofjs9 Lj j|o`bhjg lk~ wowj ~bwl wlj lbnljw bhak`j wo| sowj tjsks`jg sjeowbvj wk wljbs

yjsk bhak`j wo| akzhwjstosw sk` ?222 wlskznl 3442(31

Fbnzsj : lk~ wlj sjzew(

Fbnzsj :( Ak`tosbhn qwowj jakhk`ba tjsfks`ohajLbnl-wo| qwowjq vq( hk-wo| qwowjq ?222-3442

Tjsajhwonjnsk~wlsowjq

Lbnl-wo| qwowjq

Hk-wo| qwowjq

Ikc nsk~wl Tktzeowbkh nsk~wl Kzwtzw nsk~wl

4(7>6(7(>:

77(2?

6?(31

@joqzsjq kf qwowj jakhk`ba tjsfks`ohaj

Qkzsaj9 Nsotlba gjvjektjg cr Eo~sjhaj I( @a_zbeeoh fsk` gowo bh Oswlzs C( Eoffjs% Qwjtljh @kksj ohg Ikhowloh ^beebo`q% Sbal Qwowjq% Tkks QwowjqOEJA-Eoffjs Qwowj Jakhk`ba Ak`tjwbwbvjhjqq Bhgj|% 7wl jgbwbkh ,^oqlbhnwkh% G(A(9 O`jsbaoh Ejnbqeowbvj J|alohnj Akzhabe% 34??"% t( 3:

Eojs kzhg wlow wlj hbhj wowj ~bwl hk tjskhoe bhak`j wo| log% kh ovjsonj% az`zeowbvj ikc nsk~wl

`ksj wloh ?: wb`j nsjowjs( Tktzeowbkh nsj~ ??3 tjsajhw `ksj bh wlj hk-wo| wowj ohg nsk wowjtskgzaw nsj~ 16 tjsajhw `ksj( Hk-wo| wowj kzwtjsks`jg lbnl-wo| wowj oask oee `jozsj(

Eojs% ~lk `kvjg lb czbhj sk` tsknsjbvj wo| Aoebkshbo wk hk-wo| jhhjjj cjaozj k wlj wo|ovbhn% akhaezgjg9 Wj j|wjhw wk ~lbal wlj wowj ~bwl wlj lbnljw wo| sowj lovj zhgjstjsks`jgwlkj wowj ~bwlkzw bhak`j wo|j b lkambhn(

Wj wowbwbaoe jvbgjhaj b kvjs~lje`bhn( Kvjs wlj ekhn loze ,~lbal b wlj kher obs ~or wk `jozsj jakhk`batjsks`ohaj"% jakhk`bj ~bwl lbnl `osnbhoe wo| sowj% tsknsjbvj wo| rwj` ohg ljovr wo| czsgjh lovj ek~jsjakhk`ba nsk~wl% ej jhwsjtsjhjzslbt% ohg j~js hj~ ikc cjaozj k gbbhajhwbvj jjaw ohg wlj ej tskgzawbvjzj k sjkzsaj cr nkvjsh`jhw ak`tosjg wk wlj tsbvowj jawks(

Bw tkbcej wk aoebcsowj wlj Sk`js hgbhn wk wlj Beebhkb jakhk`r( Aoebcsowbkh b o wjalhbqzj zjg cr jakhk`bwwk womj njhjsoe sjzew sk` o wowbwbaoe ohoerb ohg otter wlj` wk o tjaba aoj zal o o Z(Q( wowj( AlsbwbhoSk`js ~o Tsjbgjhw Kco`o albj jakhk`bw ohg b o tskjks ow wlj Zhbvjsbwr k Aoebkshbo% Cjsmjejr% k ljajswobher hk akhjsvowbvj(

Aoebcsowbkh sjvjoe wlow wlj ACO tsknsjbvj wo| bhasjoj ~kzeg azw jakhk`ba kzwtzw bh Beebhkb cr o wonnjsbhn'?1 cbeebkh wk '36 cbeebkh wkwoe kvjs wb`j(37 k tzw wlb bhwk tjstjawbvj% o '36 cbeebkh ek bh kzwtzw b ak`tosocejwk ekbhn Beebhkb jhwbsj akhwszawbkh bhgzwsr ohg `ksj( Wb tezhnj bh kzwtzw ~bee% ow o `bhb`z`% mbee cjw~jjh6:%444-

7/31/2019 Progressive income tax: Money grab disguised as tax reform

13/22?1

Ohr sjgzawbkh bh jakhk`ba oawbvbwr wrtbaoeer lzsw wlj tkks `kw( Sjjosal lk~ wlow wowj ~bwl lbnljs wo|johg ej jakhk`ba sjjgk` lovj lbnljs tkvjswr sowj(36 O tsknsjbvj wo| lzsw wlj tkks ohg `bggej aeo `kw crgjwskrbhn hjjgjg ikc( B wlj ACO ~jsj lkhjw% bw ~kzeg or9 ^jee azw wo|j kh wlj tkks ohg `bggej aeo crmbeebhn wljbs ikc( Hk bhak`j% hk bhak`j wo|j/ 3>

Beebhkb lkzeghw keek~ wlj ekjs ohg ogktw o tsknsjbvj bhak`j wo|( Bhwjog% Beebhkb zewb`owjer lkzeg ikbh wljhbhj wowj ~bwl hk bhak`j wo|% jhgbhn o wskhn `jonj wlow bw sjijaw wlj los`ze jjaw k wlj bhak`j wo| ohgwohg ks wskhn nsk~wl ohg ikc ks wlj tkks(

O tsknsjqqbvj wo| bq `ksoeer zhobs% tsjgowksr ohg tzhbwbvj

Qzttkswjs k o tsknsjbvj bhak`j wo| oe~or or bw b `ksj obs% ohg `omj wlj sbal tor wljbs obs losj( CzwBeebhkb ow wo| oesjogr b obs(

Azssjhwer% Beebhkboh ~bwl oh ohhzoe coj bhak`j `ksj wloh '? `beebkh tor oh ovjsonj wo| 7> wb`j lbnljs wlohwlj ovjsonj hkh-`beebkhobsj sjbgjhw(3< Jvjsrkhj tor wlj o`j sowj% ohg wlj sbal tor `ksj cjaozj wljr osj wo|jgow wlj zhbks` sowj kh lbnljs bhak`j( Jqzoe wsjow`jhw zhgjs wlj eo~ b obs ohg khj `jozsj k o `ksoe kabjwr(

Czw bh Aoebkshbo ks j|o`tej% wlj wo| akgj b tzhbwbvj ohg tsjgowksr( Wj ovjsonj wowj bhak`j wo| cbee ks `beebkh-obsj b '3>>%444( Wj wrtbaoe Aoebkshboh tor '3%4?>% `johbhn lbnl joshjs tor ockzw ?1> wb`j `ksj wo|j joalrjos wloh wlj ovjsonj wo|-torbhn Aoebkshboh% ohg ow sowj zt wk ?4 wb`j lbnljs( 32

Lk~ `zal b jhkznl; ?:4 wb`j% 344 wb`j% ?%444 wb`j; O tsknsjbvj wo| oeek~ bhak`j nskzt wk tsjr khjoal kwljs b`tkbhn lbnljs wo|j kh kwljs ~lbej tosbhn wlj`jevj( Iklh Qwzosw @bee aoeejg wlj tsknsjbvjwo| o `beg ks` k skccjsr(14 Ohg ~ljh rkz skc Tjwjs wk tor Toze% rkz aoh oe~or akzhw kh Toze zttksw% wk

tosotlsoj Njksnj Cjshosg Qlo~(

O tsknsjbvj wo| jhakzsonj ~bgjtsjog aeo jhvr% aeo ~ososj% ohnjs o`khn nskzt ohg `ksoe gjaor o tjktejzj wlj tsknsjbvj wo| wk wjoe sk` wljbs hjbnlcks( o| wlr hjbnlcks hkw wlrje cjak`j wlj akeejawbvj wlbhmbhn(

Bh akhwsow% o tzsj ow wo| rwj` gkjhw oeek~ aeo ~ososj cjaozj ~ljh o ow wo| b lbmjg% jvjsrkhj bh oeebhak`j aeoj njw lbw( Jvjsrkhj b lzsw cr o wo| lbmj( Jqzoe wsjow`jhw b obs(

Oek bh Aoebkshbo% ks jvjsr `beebkhobsj wljsj osj `ksj wloh ?7 tjktej ~lk osj omjg wk tor ebwwej ks hk wo|j( Wbmj~jg rwj` asjowj o tjs`ohjhw ekccr ks jvjs-eosnjs wowj tjhgbhn cr tjktej ~lk gkhw lkzegjs `zal k wljakw( Wb gsbvj gjabw mr~osg( Wj ektbgjg Aoebkshbo wo| rwj` b zhgo`jhwoeer zhobs ohg gbwkswbkhosr( Bw

akhajhwsowj wlj wo| czsgjh o`khn o `oee zcjw k tjktej% ~lbal sjzew bh gohnjskz czgnjw bhwocbebwr ,`ksjkh wlb bh wlj hj|w jawbkh"( Bh Aoebkshbo% wlj wkt ? tjsajhw k ejs tor 7: tjsajhw k oee tjskhoe bhak`j wo|j(Bh ow-wo| Beebhkb% wlj wkt ? tjsajhw tor 3: tjsajhw o `ksj coeohajg ottskoal(

Qzttkswjs k o tsknsjbvj wo| oek osnzj wlow bw hjjgjg cjaozj ofjs oaakzhwbhn ks oee wowj ohg ekaoe wo|j tobgbh Beebhkb% wlj tkksjw 34 tjsajhw tor ?1(> tjsajhw k wljbs bhak`j kh wowj ohg ekaoe wo|j% kh ovjsonj% ~lbej wljsbaljw ? tjsajhw tor :(1 tjsajhw(1? Tsknsjbvj wo| zttkswjs osnzj wlow bhak`j wo|j lkzeg cj `ksj tsknsjbvjwk kjw kwljs wo|j bh wlj wowj wlow osj sjnsjbvj( Czw wlb osnz`jhw b ztbgj-gk~h(

7/31/2019 Progressive income tax: Money grab disguised as tax reform

14/22?7

Wj cjw ~or wk ljet wlj tkks ~kzeg cj wk jeb`bhowj wlj bhak`j wo| oewknjwljs k wljr aoh mjjt ~low wljr joshohg gjabgj ks wlj`jevj ~ljh% ohg wk k`j j|wjhw% lk~ `zal `khjr wljr oasbaj wk wlj nkvjsh`jhw zhgjs oakhz`twbkh-wo| rwj`( Zhgjs wlj ACO teoh% k`jkhj joshbhn o coj bhak`j o ebwwej o ':%44? o rjos njw lbw~bwl o : tjsajhw bhak`j wo|( Wjr lkzeg cj ocej wk mjjt ~low wljr josh ohg hkw cj wo|jg kh bw ow oee(

Ockeblbhn wlj bhak`j wo| jwoceblj wlj tsbhabtej wlow oh bhgbvbgzoe k~h wlj szbw k lb ks ljs eocks ohg wljrgjabgj b ohg ~ljh wlj nkvjsh`jhw njw ohr k bw cr alkkbhn lk~ `zal wk tjhg(

Tjktej ~lk ebmj wlj nkvjsh`jhw wosnjwbhn nskzt ks tjaboe tzhbl`jhw ohg tjaboe ovks% ohg ~ohw wlj nkvjsh-`jhw wk gbasb`bhowj ohg jhnonj bh tsjgowksr aeo ~ososj% ~bee ekvj o tsknsjbvj bhak`j wo|( O tsknsjbvj wo|b gbasb`bhowksr cr bw vjsr howzsj cjaozj bw tzstkjzeer wo|j k`j tjktej% ohg k`j gkeeos% ow o gbjsjhw sowjwloh kwljs(

Tjktej ~lk cjebjvj bh jqzoebwr zhgjs wlj eo~ ohg wlow jvjsrkhj% ohg jvjsr gkeeos% lkzeg cj wsjowjg jqzoeer crnkvjsh`jhw wo|owbkh% zttksw wlj ow wo| ks hk bhak`j wo| ow oee( Wj alkbaj b aejos(

Beebhkb lo o ekhn wsogbwbkh k ow wo| jqzoebwr bh bw tjskhoe bhak`j wo|( O tsknsjbvj wo| ~bee akgbrgbasb`bhowbkh% ~lbal b ~skhn(

O tsknsjqqbvj wo| bq o sjabtj ks czgnjwbhn gbqoqwjs

O tsknsjbvj bhak`j wo| j|onnjsowj ckk` ohg czw bh wowj sjvjhzj( Gzsbhn nkkg wb`j% sjvjhzj zsnj ckwlcjaozj bhak`j bhasjoj ohg tjktej osj tzljg bhwk lbnljs `osnbhoe wo| csoamjw( Fezl ~bwl aol% eo~`omjsaohw sjbw wlj wj`twowbkh wk tjhg `ksj ~bwl hj~ tjs`ohjhw tsknso`(

^ljh wlj bhjvbwocej gk~hwzsh kaazs% wlj tskaj sjvjsj( Sjvjhzj gskt osj `onhbjg ohg gjabw j|tekgjcjaozj bw b oe~or `zal jobjs wk j|tohg nkvjsh`jhw tjhgbhn wloh wk sotbger akhwsoaw bw(13 Tkks tjktej% ~lkak`j wk akzhw kh nkvjsh`jhw tsknso`% osj kfjh sw wk cj los`jg cr ohr cjew wbnlwjhbhn% losger o `kgje kobshj( Zewb`owjer% wo| sowj osj sowaljwjg zt wk | wlj gjabw ohg wlj araej sjtjow(

Wb sjvjhzj skeejsakowjs b j|wsj`j bh tsknsjbvj wo| Aoebkshbo ,jj Fbnzsj 6"( Z(Q( Ajhz gowo lk~Aoebkshbo bhak`j wo| sjvjhzj sbj `ksj qzbamer gzsbhn nkkg wb`j% ohg oee `ksj jvjsjer gzsbhn cog wb`j(

Oeoh Ozjscoal% o tskjks k wo| jakhk`ba ow wlj Zhbvjsbwr k Aoebkshbo% Cjsmjejr% ohg ekhnwb`j kcjsvjs kAoebkshbo wowj hohaj% z` bw zt9 Wj tskcej` k vkeowbebwr b toswbazeoser jvjsj bh Aoebkshbo% ~lbal sjebj`ksj wskhner wloh `ohr wowj kh wlj bhgbvbgzoe bhak`j wo| o sjeowbvjer zhwocej kzsaj k sjvjhzj ( ( (11

Wb vkeowbebwr% hk~ akhajgjg cr Aoebkshbo Nkv( Ijssr Csk~h% `omj oaazsowj wowj czgnjwbhn b`tkbcej cjaozjtjom% wskznl ohg wzshbhn tkbhw bh wlj czbhj araej osj b`tkbcej wk tsjgbaw(

7/31/2019 Progressive income tax: Money grab disguised as tax reform

15/22?:

14*

3:*

34*

?:*

?4*

:*

4*

:*

?4*

?:*

34*

3:*

3446

344:

3447

3441

3443

344?

3444

?222

?22

Ohhzoe

nsk~wlbhbhak`jwo|sjajbtwq

Aoebfkshbo

Ovjsonj kf Z(Q( qwowjq

14*

Fbnzsj 6( Aoebfkshboq sjvjhzj skeejsakoqwjsTsknsjqqbvj wo|jq osj vkeowbej

Qkzsaj9 Skcjsw T( @zstlr% Jhgbhn wlj Sjvjhzj Skeejsakoqwjs9 Wlj Cjhjwq kf o Wlsjj Tjsajhw Feow Bhak`j Wo| fks Aoebfkshbo ,Qoh Fsohabqak9 ToabaSjqjosal Bhqwbwzwj% 344

7/31/2019 Progressive income tax: Money grab disguised as tax reform

16/22?6

Fbnzsj

7/31/2019 Progressive income tax: Money grab disguised as tax reform

17/22?>

Hkwbaj wlow b sjvjhzj log akhwbhzjg nsk~bhn bhaj 344< ow wlj tsj-sjajbkh wsjhg ,wlj goljg tzstej ebhj"%wljsj ~kzeg cj o `oeejs czgnjw gjabw wkgor( Akhwsosr wk wlj aeob` k wlj ACO% o ek~ ow wo| ~kzeg lovjtskvbgjg zabjhw sjvjhzj% b hkw ks wlj Nsjow Sjajbkh ohg kvjstjhgbhn( O tsknsjbvj bhak`j wo| b hkw hjjgjgcjaozj k o lbf bh bhak`j gbwsbczwbkh kvjs wb`j% o wlj ACO aeob`(

Czw jvjh b sjvjhzj ~jsj ow wlj ekhn-wjs` wsjhg ebhj% wlj czgnjw b wbee bh wskzcej ekhn-wjs` cjaozj kkvjstjhgbhn( O `jhwbkhjg ockvj% wljsj osj '< cbeebkh k zhtobg cbee% ohg wljj gkhw lk~ zt bh wlj tjhgbhnhz`cjs zhwbe wlj cbee osj tobg( Wjsj b '3 cbeebkh ~kswl k zhtobg @jgbaobg cbee oekhj( Qbhaj 3444% @jgbaobgjhskee`jhw bh Beebhkb hjoser gkzcejg wk 3(> `beebkh tjktej sk` ?(7 `beebkh( 16 Ohg wlj zhzhgjg ebocbebwbj kstzceba j`tekrjj tjhbkh ohg sjwbsjj ljoewl aosj o`kzhw wk o wonnjsbhn '?1> cbeebkh(

Wjsj osj hk ak`tjeebhn sjokh wk ogktw o tsknsjbvj bhak`j wo|( @kvbhn wk zal o wo| ~kzeg cj jhwbsjer o`khjr nsoc wk jhocej `ksj nkvjsh`jhw tjhgbhn ohg wk sjgzaj zsnjhar wk sjks` tzceba tjhbkh% @jgbaobgohg kwljs tsknso` wlow ktjsowj tjstjwzoeer bh gjabw( Tsknsjbvj wo| zttkswjs osj zbhn wlj sjajbkh o ohkttkswzhbwr wk osnzj ks o tsknsjbvj bhak`j wo| wlow b hkw hjjgjg( Bw ~kzeg kher jjg o obejg rwj`(

Kzs kezwbkh

Fbsw% Beebhkb lkzeg gbaosg ohr hkwbkh k jhoawbhn o tsknsjbvj bhak`j wo| k ohr mbhg( Bhwjog% bw lkzeg `omjbw wo| rwj` `ksj ak`tjwbwbvj cr sjtjoebhn wlj sjaksg 34?? bhak`j wo| bhasjoj( Kh Ioh( ?% 34??% wlj wowjbhgbvbgzoe bhak`j wo| sowj bhasjojg 6> tjsajhw wk : tjsajhw% sk` 1 tjsajhw( Wb wo| lbmj% oekhn ~bwl wlj akstksowjbhak`j wo| bhasjoj oek tojg bh 34??% lkzeg cj sjtjoejg% sjwzshbhn hjoser '> cbeebkh ohhzoeer wk losg-~ksmbhnBeebhkboh( Wj sjtjoe lkzeg cj gkhj bh akhizhawbkh ~bwl `oiks tjhgbhn sjks` bh tzceba tjhbkh% @jgbaobgohg kwljs tjhgbhn tsknso` o gjwobejg bh Czgnjw Qkezwbkh 34?1(1>

Ekhn wjs`% wlj wowj lkzeg wosw o gbazbkh ockzw lk~ cjw wk ockebl bw tjskhoe bhak`j wo| ikbhbhn hbhjwowj wlow gk hkw wo| tjskhoe bhak`j(

Fks `kw k wlb howbkh lbwksr% bhak`j wo|j ~jsj zhakhwbwzwbkhoe( Wj ?6 wl O`jhg`jhw wk wlj Z(Q( Akhwb-wzwbkh% sowbjg bh ?2?1% novj wlj Z(Q( Akhnsj wlj sbnlw wk ejvr oh bhak`j wo|( Wj sw Beebhkb bhak`j wo| ~obnhjg bhwk eo~ cr Sjtzcebaoh Nkv( Sbalosg Knbevbj bh ?262( Cjksj wljh `kw wowj zhgbhn ao`j sk` o wowj~bgjtsktjswr wo|% ockebljg bh ?213% ohg o zcjqzjhw oej wo|(

Ockeblbhn wlj bhak`j wo| gkjhw `joh o eoam k nkvjsh`jhw sjvjhzj( Kvjs wlj tow gjaogj% wo| sjvjhzj bh wljhbhj wowj ~bwlkzw oh bhak`j wo| lovj nsk~h w~k wb`j `ksj wloh wlj hbhj wowj ~bwl wlj lbnljw bhak`j wo|sowj ,oh ovjsonj k ?37 tjsajhw vjsz 63 tjsajhw"(1(

33 Cossr ^( Tkzekh ohg Izej Nksgkh Moteoh% Qwowj Bhak`j o|j ohg Jakhk`ba Nsk~wl% Aowk Ikzshoe% vke( 3% oh bhasjoj bh wlj wo| czsgjh k ? tjsajhw k NGT sjzew bh o 3 wk 1 tjs-ajhw sjgzawbkh bh NGT( Ak`tosjg wk o zhjw k wlj wo| lbmj% wlj ACO teoh ~bee sjzew bh o '6(7 cbeebkh wo| lbmjks Beebhkb( Wow ~kzeg bhasjoj wo| sjvjhzj o o tjsajhw k Beebhkb '6:? cbeebkh NGT cr 4(2< tjsajhw( Wj lbnljswo| czsgjh rbjeg o oee bh Beebhkb NGT k cjw~jjh ?(2> tjsajhw ohg 3(2: tjsajhw% ks '?1 cbeebkh wk '?2 cbeebkh(

Ak`tosjg wk o sjtjoe k wlj wo| lbmj% wlj ACO teoh ~bee sjzew bh o ' cbeebkh wk '36 cbeebkh(

Mjjt bh `bhg wlow wlb b wlj gskt bh kzwtzw gzj kher wk wlj bhasjojg wo| czsgjh( Wjsj ~kzeg cj oh oggbwbkhoegskt bh kzwtzw ohg ikc ekj gzj wk tsknsjbvbwr ohg bw nsjowjs gbbhajhwbvj jjaw(

3: Wb jwb`owj ak`j sk` otterbhn Kmzh Eo~wk Beebhkb9 Wj zttjs eb`bw k wlj oee bh Beebhkb NGT cojg khwlj obezsj wk zhjw wlj wo| lbmj b 3(2: tjsajhw( Szhhbhn wlb hz`cjs wlskznl Kmzh coba eo~ rbjeg oh bh-asjoj bh zhj`tekr`jhw k 4(2< tjsajhw% ~lbal `zewbtebjg crBeebhkb wkwoe abvbeboh eocks ksaj k 6%:23%144 rbjeg67%

7/31/2019 Progressive income tax: Money grab disguised as tax reform

21/223?

Wj zttjs eb`bw k wlj oee bh Beebhkb NGT cojg kh wlj obezsj wk sjtjoe wlj 34?? wo| lbmj b 1(22 tjsajhw( Szh-hbhn wlb hz`cjs wlskznl Kmzh coba eo~ rbjeg oh bhasjoj bh zhj`tekr`jhw k ?(11 tjsajhw% ~lbal `zewb-tebjg cr Beebhkb wkwoe abvbeboh eocks ksaj k 6%:23%144 rbjeg %6>> ekw Beebhkb ikc(

Wjj osj akhjsvowbvj jwb`owj cjaozj wljsj ~kzeg cj oggbwbkhoe ikc ekj gzj wk tsknsjbvbwr ohg bw nsjowjs

gbbhajhwbvj jjaw(36 Eo~sjhaj I( @a_zbeeoh ohg Skcjsw T( @zstlr% Wj Qbyyej k Jakhk`ba Fsjjgk`9 Lk~ Jakhk`ba Fsjjgk` LjetRkz ohg ^lr Rkz Qlkzeg Gj`ohg @ksj ,Qoh Fsohabak9 Toaba Sjjosal Bhwbwzwj% 3442"% t( ?>(

3> Wj ACO b khg k orbhn wlow Ogo` Q`bwl% wlj owljs k jakhk`ba abjhaj% ovksjg o nsogzowjg bhak`j wo|Lj gbghw% ohg wlj tsk-wo| ksnohbyowbkh b `bsjtsjjhwbhn lb bgjo sk` Wj ^joewl k Howbkh ,jj ozwlks cekntkw kh wlb wktba"( Bhwjog% wlj ACO lkzeg qzkwj ohkwljs aeobaoe jakhk`bw% Mose @os|( Bh Wj Ak``zhbw@ohbjwk% ~sbwwjh bh ?

7/31/2019 Progressive income tax: Money grab disguised as tax reform

22/22

Nzosohwjj kf qzoebwr alkeoslbtWj Beebhkb Tkebar Bhwbwzwj b ak``bwwjg wk gjebvjsbhn wlj lbnljw qzoebwr ohg `kw sjebocej sjjosal kh `owwjs ktzceba tkebar(

Wj Bhwbwzwj nzosohwjj wlow oee ksbnbhoe oawzoe gowo ,bhaezgbhn wzgbj% vbj~tkbhw% sjtksw% cskalzsj ohg vbgjk"osj wszj ohg akssjaw ohg wlow bhks`owbkh owwsbczwjg wk kwljs kzsaj b oaazsowjer sjtsjjhwjg(

Wj Bhwbwzwj jhakzsonj sbnkskz asbwbqzj k bw sjjosal( B wlj oaazsoar k ohr `owjsboe oaw ks sjjsjhaj wk ohbhgjtjhgjhw kzsaj b qzjwbkhjg ohg cskznlw wk wlj Bhwbwzwj owwjhwbkh bh ~sbwbhn ~bwl zttkswbhn jvbgjhaj% wlj

Bhwbwzwj ~bee sjtkhg( B oh jssks j|bw% bw ~bee cj akssjawjg bh zcjqzjhw gbwsbczwbkh( Wb akhwbwzwj wlj ak`-tejwj ohg hoe sj`jgr zhgjs wlb nzosohwjj(

1> jg Gocsk~mb% O`ohgo Nsbh-Iklhkh ohg Ikhowloh Bhnso`% Czgnjw Qkezwbkh 34?1 ,Albaonk9 BeebhkbTkebar Bhwbwzwj% 34?3"(

1