HNTB Corporation 610 Crescent Executive Court Telephone (407) 805‐0355Infrastructure Solutions Suite 400 E‐Facsimile (866) 205‐1648 Lake Mary, FL 32746 www.hntb.com
Date To August 8, 2014 Beata Styś‐Pałasz, PE, FDOT
Kacia Monts, FDOT
PROJECT CORRESPONDENCE
FromLuis E. Diaz, PE, HNTB
SubjectEE Williamson Road Direct Connect Ramps to I‐4 Express Lanes
Purpose As part of the Interstate 4 (I‐4) “Beyond the Ultimate” PD&E Reevaluation Study in Seminole County, the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) has been asked by Seminole County to review the impacts of providing a direct connection from the proposed Express Lanes to EE Williamson Road. This connection would be provided only to and from the south (west) and would only be available to patrons using the proposed Express lanes on I‐4. A graphic showing this connection is provided in the attachments to this document. Analysis This traffic analysis was based on traffic data developed as part of the I‐4 Systems Access Modification Report (SAMR) update that is being prepared to support the (I‐4) “Beyond the Ultimate” PD&E Reevaluation Study. The 2012 FDOT Project Traffic Forecasting Handbook and the Project Forecasting Procedure Topic No.525‐030‐120 were used to develop the Design Traffic for this project. For the purposes of this EE Williamson Road evaluation, the traffic volumes provided for the facilities located within the study area (SR 434, Markham Woods Road, Lake Emma Road, EE Williamson Road and Lake Mary Boulevard) were adjusted to reflect growth patterns and travel behaviors in the area. Using the methodologies provided in the Project Traffic Forecasting Handbook, daily traffic volumes (from the Design Traffic Report) were converted to hourly traffic volumes (for both travel directions) for the morning and afternoon peak hours. Projected intersection turning movement traffic volumes were developed from the hourly volumes and were analyzed using the latest version of the Highway Capacity Software (HCS) to determine the projected intersection delay and level of service for the intersections. Attached are three figures showing the projected 2040 traffic for the different roadway intersections within the study area. The first shows the traffic without the connection between the Express Lanes and EE Williamson Road, the second shows the traffic with the connection and the third shows the difference between the two scenarios. The information provided in these figures shows that the direct connection from the proposed Express Lanes to EE Williamson Road does not provide significant relief at either SR 434 or Lake Mary Blvd while adding approximately 25% more traffic to the east side of EE Williamson Road (where Woodland Elementary School is located) in the AM peak period. The largest reduction in traffic can be expected at the EB off ramp at SR 434, at approximately 6% reduction in the same AM peak period. Also found in the attachments to this document is a table providing results of HCS analysis that was performed at the different intersections impacted by the proposed connection. This table shows that there are no significant reductions in intersection delay or improvement in overall intersection level of service.
ATTACHMENTS
3 32
3
3
2 3
3
2
3
1
3
1
4
3
22
1
3
22
3
4
1
4
1
4
3
3
2
1
1
2
3
3
E. E. William
son Road
Lake MaryBoulevard
International
Parkway
Lake Emma
Road
DouglasAvenue
RaymondAvenue
Markham Woods Road
Rangeline Road Lincolnwood Lane
4
4
4
4
21
434
NNot to ScaleNot to Scale
Sheet 1 of 3Segment 2 - 2040 No Connection to EE Williamson - DDHV
1,472
2,250
725
1,192
2,024
717
1,345
1,302
2,062
717
911
14
163
136435 14
1815 17
14
590 754
474
18
136
163474 17
1414 14
15
754 590
435
11
13
15706 393
9191 442
240
21
551
92421
15
13551 442
11240 393
191
24
706
1,030
2,208
725
1,525
LEGEND2,8702,310
AM Peak DDHVPM Peak DDHV
Number ofDirectional Lanes
1
I-4 SAMR UpdateDesign Traffic
472
594
479
334
522
346
4142,622343
4722,778380
472
522
414
380
594
343
4792,778346
4722622334
1,258
1,214
1,745 1,016
2,4101,192
1,226
1,045
2,010 994
2,3491,030
173
754
69276 1,022
17319 884
17
34 38
66
173
692
75466 884
17317 959
19
38 34
76
1,030
994
1,726 1,045
2,398 1,226
1,192
1,016
2,038 1,214
2,136 1,258
185
7
31
407
5
74
272,43974
1682,734429
168
5
27
429
7
74
312,73474
1852,439407
578
221
363526
715
195
3201,703526
4461,627742
446
195
320526
742
221
3631,627526
5781,703715
1
4
3 32
3
3
2 3
3
2
3
1
1
3
1
4
3
22
1
3
22
3
4
1
4
1
4
3
3
2
1
1
2
3
3
E. E. William
son Road
Lake MaryBoulevard
International
Parkway
Lake Emma
Road
DouglasAvenue
RaymondAvenue
Markham Woods Road
Rangeline Road Lincolnwood Lane
4
4
4
4
4
21
434
NNot to ScaleNot to Scale
Sheet 2 of 3Segment 2 - 2040 With Connection to EE Williamson - DDHV
1,472
2,187
715
1,258
1,214
1,745 920
2,4101,142
472
594
429
334
522
346
3742,622343
1,142
1,901
707
1,302
4722,778380
990
911
1,726 1,045
2,398 1,226
578
221
363539
680
195
3201,685544
4461,614711185
7
31
407
5
74
272,39774
1682,651429
1,302
2,009
707
1,226
1,045
2,009 911
2,349990
472
522
374
380
594
343
14
179
148473 14
1815 17
14
590 754
518
18
148
179518 17
1414 14
15
754 590
473
14
13
15706 511
11209 548
268
21
551
112421
15
13551 548
14268 511
209
24
706
149 644
60 642
50
126
126 642
50 644
60
149
4292,778346
990
2,062
209176
176209
715
1,472
4722,622334
1,142
920
2,038 1,214
2,136 1,258
446
195
320544
711
221
3631,614539
5781,685680168
5
27
429
7
74
312,65174
1852,397407
LEGEND2,8702,310
AM Peak DDHVPM Peak DDHV
Number ofDirectional Lanes
1
I-4 SAMR UpdateDesign Traffic
173
754
69276 960
17319 841
17
34 38
66
173
692
75466 841
17317 906
19
38 34
76
3 32
3
3
2 3
3
2
3
1
1
3
1
4
3
22
1
3
22
3
4
1
4
1
4
3
3
2
1
1
2
3
3
E. E. William
son Road
Lake MaryBoulevard
International
Parkway
Lake Emma
Road
DouglasAvenue
RaymondAvenue
911
Markham Woods Road
Rangeline Road Lincolnwood Lane
4
4
4
4
4
21
434
NNot to ScaleNot to Scale
Sheet 3 of 3Segment 2 - 2040 With Connection to EE Williamson - Difference
-53-10
-96
-50
-40
-40
-123
-10
-43
-40
-83
+13
-35
-96
-83
-43-10
-40
+16
+12+38
+44+12
+16+44
+38
+118
+106
+106
+118
149
60
50
126
126
50
60
149
-50
-50
-146
209176
176209
-10
-53
-50
-96
+18
-30
-83
-96
LEGEND2,8702,310
AM Peak DDHVPM Peak DDHV
Number ofDirectional Lanes
1
I-4 SAMR UpdateDesign Traffic
-83
-10
-10
-10
-10
-40-50
+18 +28
+28 +18 -30
-35-13-18
+18+13
-18-13
+2+3
+3+2
Intersection Delay (s)Intersection LOS
Intersection Delay (s)Intersection LOS
Intersection Delay (s)Intersection LOS
Intersection Delay (s)Intersection LOS
Intersection Delay (s)Intersection LOS
Intersection Delay (s)Intersection LOS
Intersection Delay (s)Intersection LOS
Intersection Delay (s)Intersection LOS
2040 LOS and Overall Intersection DelayEE Wiliamson Road Express Lane ConnectionTraffic Analysis
31.4
12.4 12.9 - -
B B - -
Lake Mary Blvd at Lake Emma Rd
With E.E. Williamson Road Connection Without E.E. Williamson Road Connection
AM PM AM
85.7 80.6 67 55.7
Lake Mary Blvd at Intl
Pkwy
With E.E. Williamson Road Connection Without E.E. Williamson Road Connection
AM PM AM PM
F F E E
32.7 31 33.4
46.6 54.2 41.6 46.3
E.E. Williamson
Rd at Lincolnwood
Ln
With E.E. Williamson Road Connection Without E.E. Williamson Road Connection
AM PM AM PM
PM
D D D D
E.E. Williamson Rd at I-4
With E.E. Williamson Road Connection Without E.E. Williamson Road Connection
AM PM AM
98.4 113.4 108.1 124.7
E.E. Williamson
Rd at Markham Woods Rd
With E.E. Williamson Road Connection Without E.E. Williamson Road Connection
AM PM AM
F F F F
PM
SR 434 at I-4 EB
With E.E. Williamson Road Connection Without E.E. Williamson Road Connection
AM PM AM PM
31 30.9 31.6 31.5
C C C C
SR 434 at I-4 WB
With E.E. Williamson Road Connection Without E.E. Williamson Road Connection
AM PM AM
With E.E. Williamson Road Connection Without E.E. Williamson Road ConnectionSR 434 at
Douglas Ave AM PM AM PM
228.3 233.2 234.2 241.2
PM
F F F F
F F F F
PM
C C C C
131.8 125.1 137.4 134.1