Proper Orthogonal Decomposition and Wavelet Analysis of SloshingFlows
T. Pagliaroli∗, F. Gambioli†, F. Saltari‡, J. Cooperz
∗Niccolo Cusano University, †Airbus, ‡Sapienza University of Rome, zUniversity of BristolB [email protected]
EASN–Italy–2nd/4th September 2020
Overview
Introduction
Material and MethodsData processing strategiesExperimental setupTest cases
ResultsData prequalificationAcceleration wavelet transformWavelet–based dampingMathematical modelProper Orthogonal Decomposition & WaveletWavelet Coherency
Tiziano Pagliaroli EASN–Italy–2nd /4th September 2020 2
Objective
Sloshing and structural dynamics coupling is important in the design phase, modeling, andcontrol of several aerospace systems: rockets, satellites, and aircrafts.
Figure: Example of coupling between sloshing and structural dynamics: an integral tank within a wing.
The aim of this work is to develop a data analysis technique able to highlight theinteraction between fluid and structure.
Tiziano Pagliaroli EASN–Italy–2nd /4th September 2020 3
Data processing strategy (1)
The main idea is to combine Proper Orthogonal Decomposition (POD) andWavelet Transform (WT) to analyse an image time-resolved sequence.
I (x , t) ≈N∑i=1
ai (t)φi (x) ≈N∑i=1
M∑j=1
aψij (t)φi (x) (1)
Decomposition characteristics:
I φi (x) coherent in space
I aψij (t) coherent in time
Tiziano Pagliaroli EASN–Italy–2nd /4th September 2020 4
Data processing strategy (2)
Tiziano Pagliaroli EASN–Italy–2nd /4th September 2020 5
Data processing strategy (3)
Tiziano Pagliaroli EASN–Italy–2nd /4th September 2020 6
Data processing strategy (4)
Tiziano Pagliaroli EASN–Italy–2nd /4th September 2020 7
Experimental setup
x
l = 0.70m
L = 2.35m
y
root tip
H-beam
static load andrelease mechanism
y(L, t)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
camera FOV
water tank
Instrumentation and acquisition details:
I Accelerometer – isotron model 65L-100, S = 102.7mV /g , f ys = 1 kHz ,T y = 6 s
I Fast camera – photron fastcam SA1.1, f Is = 3kHz ,T I = 10 s
Tiziano Pagliaroli EASN–Italy–2nd /4th September 2020 8
Test cases
x
l = 0.70m
L = 2.35m
y
root tip
H-beam
static load andrelease mechanism
y(L, t)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
camera FOV
water tank
Water volume ratio:α = Vw
Vtot
Test Cases:I Test case 1: α = 0, dry;
I Test case 2: α = 0.3, wet;
I Test case 3: α = 0.5, wet.
Tiziano Pagliaroli EASN–Italy–2nd /4th September 2020 9
Data prequalification
Tiziano Pagliaroli EASN–Italy–2nd /4th September 2020 10
Wavelet Transform of the Acceleration
Structural dynamicsMode freq. [Hz] Description
f ′1l 7.4 1st mode and 1st harmonicf ′1h 7.9 1st mode and 1st harmonic
f ′′1 13.9 1st mode 2nd harmonic
f2 50.2 2nd mode
H–Beam modes characteristics:I First mode is affected by an abrupt drift in frequency
from 7.4 to 7.9 Hz;
I Second mode has the frequency weakly time dependent.
Tiziano Pagliaroli EASN–Italy–2nd /4th September 2020 11
Wavelet Coefficients of the Acceleration
0 1 2 3 4 5
-5
0
5(a)
=0
=0.3
=0.5
0 1 2 3 4 5
-10
-5
0
5
(b) =0
=0.3
=0.5
Tiziano Pagliaroli EASN–Italy–2nd /4th September 2020 12
Wavelet–Based Damping
1 2 3 4 5
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.1(a)
2 4 6 8
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.1(b)
Wavelet–based damping1:
ζψ(τ) = − 1
ωn
∂ ln |w(f ′1 , τ)|∂τ
(2)
I Test case 2–3: damping is higher andappears before than case 1 (see fig.a)
I Test case 2–3: damping is higher for allacceleration values (see fig.b)
I Damping is a function of the acceleration→ ζ = f (y)
[1] Chen et al., Wavelet analysis for identification of damping ratios and natural frequencies, J. Sound Vib., 323(1-2), 130–147.
Tiziano Pagliaroli EASN–Italy–2nd /4th September 2020 13
Fourier Transfrom of the Wavelet Coefficients
2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20
0
0.5
1
The frequency of the second mode oscillates with a frequency f ′1 , equal to the frequencyof the first mode:
f2(t) = 〈f2(t)〉+ c sin (2πf ′1t) (3)
Tiziano Pagliaroli EASN–Italy–2nd /4th September 2020 14
Simple Mathematical Model
From the experimental evidences, we have a preliminary idea of the mathematical model:
I for the first modey + 2ζ(y)ω1y + ω2
1y = 0 (4)
I for the second modey + 2ζ(y)ω2(t)y + ω2
2(t)y = 0 (5)
Tiziano Pagliaroli EASN–Italy–2nd /4th September 2020 15
Proper Orthogonal Decomposition & Wavelet
Tiziano Pagliaroli EASN–Italy–2nd /4th September 2020 16
Test case 3: stabilised Spectra
Structural dynamicsMode freq. [Hz] Description
f ′1l 7.4 1st mode–1st harmonicf ′1h 7.9 1st mode– 1st harmonic
f ′′1 13.9 1st mode– 2nd harmonic
f2 50.2 2nd mode
Fluid dynamicsMode freq. [Hz] Description
f ′1l 7.4 Coupling between φ1 and yf ′1h 7.9 Coupling between φ3-φ4 and yf ′1cl 3.7 symmetric sloshingf ′1ch 4.0 symmetric sloshing
101
102
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
101
102
10-4
10-2
Tiziano Pagliaroli EASN–Italy–2nd /4th September 2020 17
Wavelet Coherency
Fluid dynamicsMode frequency [Hz] Description
f ′1l 7.4 Coupling φ1 and y (all the time)f ′1h 7.9 Coupling φ3 and φ4 (coherent regime)f ′1cl 3.7 symmetric sloshing (no coupling)f ′1ch 4.0 No coupling φ2 and y
Tiziano Pagliaroli EASN–Italy–2nd /4th September 2020 18
Summary & Conclusions
1. A novel technique to decompose the hydrodynamic flow field in coherent modes in timeand space (aψij and φi ) is developed and tested on an experimental database.
2. A wavelet–based damping ratio calculation is applied and it appears to be promising.
3. Water contributes to increase the damping ratio.
4. The frequency of the second mode of the beam is not constant in time and oscillateswith the same frequency as the first mode.
5. A simple mathematical model for the first and second mode of the beam is proposed
6. Strong coupling between structural dynamics and hydrodynamics is detected:I φ1 oscillates at the same frequency as the beam for all the time;I φ3 and φ4 oscillate at the same frequency as the beam only during the coherent regime;I φ2 no linear coupling with acceleration.
Tiziano Pagliaroli EASN–Italy–2nd /4th September 2020 19
Future Work
-10
-5
0
(a)
-5
-10 5-5 0
0
5
5 (b)
500 1000 1500 2000
Time, samples
500
1000
1500
2000
Tim
e, s
amp
les
0
5
10
15
(b)
Tiziano Pagliaroli EASN–Italy–2nd /4th September 2020 20
K,Q, p, C À, h, a, j, !, #, %, $, L, T,B, r,K,Q, p, C À, h, a, j, !, #, %, $, L,T,B, r,K,Q, p, C À, h, a, j, !, #, %, $, L, T,B, r,K,Q, p, C À, h, a, j, !, #,%, $, L, T,B, r,K,Q, p, C À, h, a, j, !, #, %, $, L, T,B, r,K,Q, p, C À, h, a,j, !, #, %, $, L, T,B, r,K,Q, p, C À, h, a, j, !, #, %, $, L, T,B, r,K,Q, p, C À,h, a, j, !, #, %, $, L, T,B, r,K,Q, p, C À, h, a, j, !, #, %, $, L, T,K,Q, p, CÀ, h, a,j, !, #, %, $, L, T,B, r,K,Q, p, C À, h, a, j, !, #, %, $, L,T,B, r,K,Q
Thank you for your Attention
K,Q, p, C À, h, a, j, !, #, %, $, L, T,B, r,K,Q, p, C À, h, a, j, !, #, %, $, L,T,B, r,K,Q, p, C À, h, a, j, !, #, %, $, L, T,B, r,K,Q, p, C À, h, a, j, !, #,%, $, L, T,B, r,K,Q, p, C À, h, a, j, !, #, %, $, L, T,B, r,K,Q, p, C À, h, a,j, !, #, %, $, L, T,B, r,K,Q, p, C À, h, a, j, !, #, %, $, L, T,B, r,K,Q, p, C À,h, a, j, !, #, %, $, L, T,B, r,K,Q, p, C À, h, a, j, !, #, %, $, L, T,B, r,K,Q
Tiziano Pagliaroli EASN–Italy–2nd /4th September 2020 21