[Presentation Title Goes Here – Type it in the Master Slide] 0
PRSA Counselors Academy Webinar
PROPOSED NEW FEDERAL OVERTIME REGULATIONS AND WHAT THEY MEAN FOR YOUR FIRM
Thursday, March 17, 2016
Michael C. Lasky
Partner/Co-Chair Public Relations Law 212.468.4849 [email protected] © 2016 Davis & Gilbert LLP
Jessica Golden Cortes
Partner Labor & Employment 212.468.4808 [email protected]
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
2
PREPARING FOR THE CHANGES:
BEST PRACTICES
Projected release date for Final Rule
By July 2016 if not late Spring, with
implementation by the end of 2016
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
3
PREPARING FOR THE CHANGES:
BEST PRACTICES
Begin preparing NOW – Employers may
have as little as 30 to 60 days to comply
before new regulations go into effect
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
5
CURRENT LAW
»To qualify for “white collar” exemption (executive,
administrative and professional employees)
- Predetermined and fixed salary not subject to
reduction due to variations in quality/quantity of
work performed (salary basis test)
- At least $455/week or $23,660 annually (salary
level test)
- Employee primarily performs executive,
administrative or professional duties (duties
test)
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
6
CURRENT LAW
»To qualify for highly-compensated employee (HCE)
exemption
- Total annual compensation of at least $100,000
- At least $455/week on a salary or fee basis
- Perform office or non-manual work
- Regularly perform at least one of the exempt
duties of an executive, administrative, or
professional employee
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
7
SUMMARY OF PROPOSED CHANGES
»Issued on July 6, 2015
»“White collar” exemption
- Salary level increased to $970/week, or
$50,400 annually
- Will automatically increase based on percentiles
of earnings for full-time salaried workers or
changes in inflation with the purposes of
remaining at 40th percentile nationwide of
weekly earnings for full-time salaried workers
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
8
SUMMARY OF PROPOSED CHANGES
- NO specific change to duties test disclosed
• However, DOL requested comment on
whether the duties test appropriately
distinguishes between exempt and
non-exempt employees
- NO change to tests for outside sales
employees, teachers, lawyers and doctors
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
9
SUMMARY OF PROPOSED CHANGES
»Highly-Compensated Employee exemption
- Total annual compensation estimated to be at
least $122,148 (including commissions and
non-discretionary bonuses/compensation)
- Will automatically increase annually based on
percentiles of earnings for full-time salaried
workers or changes in inflation
• Meant to reflect the 90th percentile of full-time
salaried workers
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
10
SUMMARY OF PROPOSED CHANGES
»DOL requested and received comments on
- Whether incentive compensation and
non-discretionary bonuses should be considered
to satisfy salary level test
- Whether commissions should be included as part
of incentive compensation and non-discretionary
bonuses to satisfy salary level test
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
11
SUMMARY OF PROPOSED CHANGES
- Modification to duties test
• E.g., Should employees be required to spend a
minimum amount of time performing exempt
duties to qualify for exemption?
- Mechanism for updating salary level
• Fixed percentile of earnings of full-time
salaried workers vs. inflation
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
12
POTENTIAL IMPACT
OF NEW REGULATIONS
Overtime is poised to become an even bigger issue for employers…
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
13
POTENTIAL IMPACT
OF NEW REGULATIONS
»Approximately 5 million employees may no longer
qualify as exempt
»Employers in states with wage-and-hour laws that
are more restrictive than FLSA will need to
determine how the new regulations affect
employee classifications in those states
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
14
IMPACT ON PR INDUSTRY
» PRWeek March 2016 Salary Survey (http://www.prweek.com/us/salarysurvey)
- Nationwide median salary by title
• Account Executives (AE) - $48,800
• Assistant Account Executives (AAE) - $40,750
• Account Coordinators (AC) - $37,500
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
15
IMPACT ON PR INDUSTRY
»The Official Public Relations Salary & Bonus
Report 2015 Edition (based on 2014 comp) (http://www.springassociates.com/salary-bonus-report.html)
- Data break down by
• 8 key metro areas, e.g., New York, Atlanta,
Chicago, Los Angeles, Boston, Houston,
Washington, D.C., San Francisco
• Area of PR specialty, e.g., consumer,
corporate/financial, health/med/pharma, tech,
public/gov’t affairs, social media
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
16
IMPACT ON PR INDUSTRY
»The Official Public Relations Salary & Bonus Report
2015 Edition
- Most junior position reviewed is Account
Executive (AE) /Account Associate (AA)
- Potential for different classifications for AE/AAs
based on region
- E.g., AE/AA concentrating in Health/Med/Pharma
- New York: Range $55,000 - $68,000
- Atlanta: Range $48,000 - $58,000
- Washington, D.C.: Range $40,000 - $55,000
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
17
IMPACT ON PR INDUSTRY
»The Official Public Relations Salary & Bonus Report
2015 Edition
- Senior Account Executive (SAE)/Senior Account
Associate (SAA) compensation should also be
reviewed
- Data reflects that in the Southeast, Midwest and
Southwest companies are paying SAEs/SAAs a
salary range of $45,000 - $60,000
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
18
NEW YORK AND CALIFORNIA
»New York already requires at least $675/week
($35,100 annually) to executives and
administrative professionals
»California already requires at least $800/week
($41,600 annually)
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
19
PREPARING FOR THE CHANGES:
BEST PRACTICES
»Analyze your workforce to determine which
employees will be affected
- Track employee hours to assess options for
compensation under the new regulations
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
20
PREPARING FOR THE CHANGES:
BEST PRACTICES
»Consider whether to
- Increase salary and bolster qualifying job duties
to maintain exemption (one-time fix may not be
enough)
- Reduce salary to balance anticipated overtime
payments (consider impact on morale)
- Maintain salary and reassign certain duties to
an existing or new employee to ensure that the
affected employee does not work more than
40 hours/week
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
21
PREPARING FOR THE CHANGES:
BEST PRACTICES
- Convert the affected employee to non-exempt,
and pay overtime when incurred
• Note: Hourly rate may be modified to match
employee’s current compensation level
- Remember to disseminate new WTPA forms in
NY and CA
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
22
PREPARING FOR THE CHANGES:
BEST PRACTICES
»Consider impact on flexible working arrangements
and/or limiting remote connectivity for affected
employees
»Revise job descriptions to minimize non-exempt
duties for EAP and HCE employees – and make
sure descriptions are followed in practice
»Consider adjusting workweek periods for certain
groups of employees
- E.g., Thursday to Wednesday instead of
Monday to Sunday
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
23
PREPARING FOR THE CHANGES:
BEST PRACTICES
»Review, and if necessary, revise policies
addressing overtime, proper time reporting, off-
the-clock work and acceptable use of work-related
devices, so that they are ready to distribute to
affected employees when new regulations go into
effect
»Consider feasibility of adopting fluctuating
workweek pay method
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
24
PREPARING FOR THE CHANGES:
CONSIDER THE FLUCTUATING
WORKWEEK METHOD
»Permits employers to pay non-exempt employees
a fixed salary – even if the employee’s hours
fluctuate from week to week
»Overtime then paid at an additional one-half the
regular rate of pay
»May allow employers to continue paying affected
employees on a salary basis and also minimize
overtime costs
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
25
PREPARING FOR THE CHANGES:
CONSIDER THE FLUCTUATING
WORKWEEK METHOD
» Requirements
- Hours must fluctuate from week to week
- Fixed salary that does not vary with number of
hours worked during the week (excluding
overtime premiums)
- Fixed salary results in regular rate that is equal
to or more than minimum wage
- Clear mutual understanding between employer
and employee that fixed salary is compensation
for the workweek, regardless of number of
hours worked
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
26
PREPARING FOR THE CHANGES:
CONSIDER THE FLUCTUATING
WORKWEEK METHOD
»Other considerations
- Employers need to track hours for FWWM employees
- Certain states, such as California, prohibit use of
FWWM
- Payment of shift differentials, commissions and
performance bonuses may invalidate FWWM
• NY - Performance bonuses held not to invalidate
FWWM
- Employee morale
- Risk of miscalculation
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
27
RISK OF OFF-THE-CLOCK CLAIMS:
TRAIN YOUR MANAGERS
»Newly non-exempt employees may be entitled to
overtime pay for “off-the-clock” work (e.g., time
spent answering calls and emails after regular
work hours)
- DOL has turned its attention to off-the-clock use
of electronic devices by non-exempt employees,
particularly with rise of use of portable electronic
devices
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
28
RISK OF OFF-THE-CLOCK CLAIMS:
TRAIN YOUR MANAGERS
»Possible defense – De minimis exception
- Employers do not have to pay for de minimis
(negligible) amounts of work performed outside
of working hours that are infrequent and
insignificant and cannot be practically recorded
for payroll purposes
• E.g., Occasionally answering an email/call, or
monitoring a device
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
29
RISK OF OFF-THE-CLOCK CLAIMS:
TRAIN YOUR MANAGERS
- But if it is the employee’s regular practice to
respond to calls/emails, employer expects
response off-hours, and doing so is part of
employee’s job – exception does not apply
- Test: (1) Practical administrative difficulty of
recording such time; (2) size of the claim in
aggregate; (3) whether work was performed
on regular basis
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
30
RISK OF OFF-THE-CLOCK CLAIMS:
TRAIN YOUR MANAGERS
»Possible defense – Incidental preliminary and
postliminary activities
- Employers not required to pay for activities
which are preliminary or postliminary to
employee’s principal activity and occur before
or after the employee’s usual working hours
• E.g., Downloading/reading emails regarding
next day’s work assignments
- Such activities are compensable if they are an
“integral and indispensable part of the
employee’s principal duties”
The Proposed New Federal Overtime Regulations
and What They Mean for Your Firm
31
RISK OF OFF-THE-CLOCK CLAIMS:
TRAIN YOUR MANAGERS
»Possible defense – Lack of actual or constructive
knowledge
- To be compensated for off-the-clock work,
employees must show that the employers had
actual or constructive knowledge that they were
performing such work
- Email/phone records may be relevant,
especially if employer regularly reviews such
information for productivity or verification
purposes
Special Issues for Apps Relying on Advertising to Generate Revenue 32 Basics of Advertising and Marketing Law 32 32
QUESTIONS?
Michael C. Lasky
Partner/Co-Chair Public Relations Law 212.468.4849 [email protected] © 2016 Davis & Gilbert LLP
Jessica Golden Cortes
Partner Labor & Employment 212.468.4808 [email protected]