Proving Grounds_On Nietzche and the Test Drive

7/26/2019 Proving Grounds_On Nietzche and the Test Drive

1/18

Proving Grounds: On Nietzsche and the Test Drive

Authors(s): Avital Ronell

Source: MLN, Vol. 118, No. 3, German Issue (Apr., 2003), pp. 653-669

Published by: The Johns Hopkins University Press

Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/3251940Accessed: 27-03-2016 10:47 UTC

Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at

http://about.jstor.org/terms

JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted

digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about

JSTOR, please contact [email protected].

The Johns Hopkins University Pressis collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend accessto MLN

http://www.jstor.org

This content downloaded from 134.58.253.30 on Sun, 27 Mar 2016 10:47:49 UTCAll use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms


2/18

Provng Ground

On N ch nd h T Dr v

A v R on

0 1 O n h v n n g o f 9/ 11 W f r h ou r o f h d n g

c m ou o y Th w

n n n rv w h b r h N ch n d h Mch n

D r r d d d r h h y p r h c p ro c du r o f g n o gy 1 L nk n g

ngu r h xc d h ruc ur of h n on h ob rv

h for N ch h r of dmocr cy o r

of chn c on 2 Fo ow ng h c r ogr ph of po c u r

n c d r wn up b y h p h o op h r D rr d fo rh p r u gg

h h n m of N ch cou d rv n nd x o r of

q u on h h v b com h m or p r ng nc h nd of h

C od W r 3 Co nc r n dw h h k o f d m oc r cy o c om o

h for r c n c o oqu um n C r y S 2002 o rg n d

r ou nd h p o c h ou gh o f J c qu D r r d h o ff r T od y

h c c r o no f c hn c o nc on c rn h b ord r of h n o n

4 Th u n d o b c omp y r con d r d n o n ord r

o o un d h d h k n o f d mo cr c y b u o r h n kd m oc r cy

from w h n h cond on 5 H on f no og h r p oc y p c

Jc qu D rr d N g o on n r v n o n nd n r v w 1 971 20 00 E b h

R o n b rg d S n f or d S n f or d Un v r y P r 2 00 2

2 b d 2 45

3 b d 2 53

4 b d 2 51

5 bd

M LN1 18 2 0 0 3 6 5 3 6 69 ? 2 0 0 3 byT h J o h n H o pk n U n vr yPr

This content downloaded from 134.58.253.30 on Sun, 27 Mar 2016 10:47:49 UTC

All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms


3/18

AVTAL RONELL

r m n mph c b ou h k h nd h r h nk ng mu

no b p o pon d mm d nd urg n 6 Wh n h m r y

m md nd urg n p ck up h c No d u dd h n

K fk Abr hm nd h r f h c w r m n f or m 7

An wr ng h c w n o n kwh h c h r of

d m oc r cy o h n m of N c h n o h r n m f or n nd f

n y un f d u c nd o h m ng of h d moc rcy for

wh ch h c h d m oc rc y o com m rk d n h m ov m n

h w y crr h pr n b yond f m k n dqu o

f 8 F or N c h o r fo ro n or w o of h g n or n

N ch h wh ch x mp r y c rr h p r n b y ond f

c n c n h or N ch m k u k bou h r on hp

b w n c n c n d c on m po r r y fo rm o n o f p ow r m o r

p c f c y b ou h u p c ou p r n r h p of o c d d v nc d

d m oc rc n dh gh c hn oog y Wh m k h f orc m c h up

w h ch o h r? Wh ow h ruc ur mu u y o ho d up?

L u b rng our focu o n p c o f c n c h N ch m or

or d c ov r d m p m n d p o d nd wh ch h nk o n

f fr mb d m oc rc y m r f rr ng o h x p rm n c u ur

f ro m wh c h h w or k k o ff T hu v n h ou gh N c h c n b

c on d r d n n d m oc r r g y u np ro b d d m n o n of h

h ou gh p r ov d r g or ou g r d f or v u n g po c f or m o n

n d x g nc T h con du f or b h ng p ro gr v p o c

c n c n N c h c rc u d h rou gh h u nd r nd ng of

c n fc r uc ur nd h r m r mp c o n N ch up

b n B y on d Go od & E v r h r x p c y A n u mb r o f h o h r

work p v o r ound h xp r m n d p o on nd r h m

v xp rm n ffor N ch x n corpor h

h o ry of b cu u r wh ch n k d o po c n no v o n Ev r

n c h E r o fCo rk p n h ow nc n 16 60 o b u d h f r

b n n x y o v r h d mocr c m p c o n of n w n ur

p h o op hy w f E v nw om n w r n v d o r y ou n dr p

6 bd

7Th r f r nc h r o K fk p r b Abr h m bou w hch h v wr n n

S u p d y U n v r y o f n o P r 2 002 K f k m u p A br h m n o n um b rof

hypo h c ch r c r on o f whom h d umb k d n h c S uck n h b ck

r ow c d m c d h row h h nk h h r h n m c d ou o n Co mm n c

m n D y w h n h p r for h m r p up bou o b h nd d ou H r ng h

n m c d h r o cc p h pr W f h h nk m n for hm m yb

T h u K f k k n g do wn h u rp r r c h

8 b d 2 52

654




4/18

MLN

x p rm n r u h n c for h d p nd d up on r p b y of

r c or d d v n u nd r n y c r cu m n c n d by n y on S c n c f

h ch m c o nd Rob r B oy h on of h E r of Cork

p ro du c d h c on r ov r h c o f m od y 9 F ro m no w on c n f c

u r nc wo ud b u bm d o p roo f h y c ou d b r c nd d

n y m b y ny on T h y p of c n f c r f orm o nr c

D rr d r d n g o f H rm n n Co h n w ho p u h p r o b c k n

Pro n m by m n o f h h yp oh c mp r v 1 0 w n o pu

h b ck n Pro n m Th r v w p roc for wh ch c n c

c d hd dff r n f form n h rn h or of d mocr c

n n on A n n o gou c n d o h op n ng f or wh ch Bo y

w r p on b w promp d n h gh n h c nury b y h

c r o n of h o ur n A h n du m Su dd n y n y on c ou d

u bm r c h w ou d b r v w d fo rp ub c o nb y c om m

nc ud ng h Sc h g b ro h r F ch C r o n n d h r o f

h m T h d m oc r c n no v o n o f h o w h o w r p r c c n g h r

L b n p h o o ph u nn d v r yo n W h ? A n yo n c ou d u b m n

r c ? wou db u dg d on m r on ? S od y h c for

pp r n u d b y h d o r b o rd of h A h ndu m h n o v d

up o po c po n Bu u v h m r of c d mc

p o cy d f or now n d m py no h b o ng o og c of

r v w n h f orm of ng Fr dr ch Sch g xp c y d

T h A h nd um w op n o x p rm n on w

Wh n N c h r d h nk ng b ou c n c n d h w y

wou d rpor f h o p n d n c coun h nc ud h r on

o f c n c o p h rm c u c o m d c n dr p rod uc v c hn oo

g w o w Argu by N ch op nd h do r h

c on n R h n b rg r m pr v w r u po fD rr d n dp ro n

y nh of ub g rmm o ogy n d h f on g r v w

wh con u v d n r y b y? How do DNA r d cr b g

d c o n? Who x p r n ou gh o u d g ? Wh r h c om p c

or u b v r o n n v o v d n h r o n of w n d c hn o og y? W h n

N ch r d cr p ng p r of xp rm n c u ur n

BG&E h o ff r n n vn ory of n n rn v n com

m ndm n nc ud ng h h r d mu on occurr d n h

9 S S v n S h p n n d S mo n Sc h ff r L v h n n d h A r P u mp H ob b B oy

n d h E xp r m n L f P r nc o n Pr n c o n Un v r y P r 1 98 5

?J cqu D rr d n r pr on W r K n h J w h G rm n n A c o f

R g o n G A n d r d N w Y or k Ro u d g 2 00 2

655




5/18

AVTAL RONELL

p c n wh ch w h nk n d v n wh ch w m r k po c

dh r nc or d o c on G v nh mu p r u nd h m ny

v n c h c cr u o d m oc r c f or m o n d m o cr cy f

b com r m ndou y vo h cou db ff rm d by

N ch on y o h x n h u n d ch rc r of

p rm n n hypo h v r pron o f co p w k n

br k do wn

0 2 T h P r om c u y o f T n g

O n cou d rgu h now d y nc h f fu dv n o f h G y

Sc n c b u p rh p n o o y b c u o f h r no h ng h

n o d or ub c o ng W x und r w y omuch o

h on c ou d r h c hno og yh n ow r n f or m d h w or d

n o o m ny Among oh r hng h m n h v ry

h ng w do gov rn d by og c h nc ud n c ry m

prob b y c cu on f d ruc o n n d n r mn b r A n w

f o d n m p hy c ng h h y p o f r dn h f

und r h rm r no h r og c of r u h

Th c v of ng r hown o b r pon v o n d

g n n g h g r ow h of n w n n c W h h p ro v nn c of h

n d ? A k nd of qu on ng r uc u r of n c n r r ch

p rh p mod y of b ng ng c n h w of x pr nc

m u rng p ro bng d rm n ng h wh of h v d wor d A

h m m bu m or f und m n y h v ry ruc ur of

n g n d o ov r k h c r n y h b h wh nob yng

h c of op nf n ud N ch m rv c nc h k

w rr or c n go ou nd f r p d y

Th r n oh ng u ch og h r n w b ou h d r b ou nd up

n h y h xp n v f d of h h r prom cu y of ng

po nov prob m nd comp c h n r ry of c m w

m k b ou h w or d n d c on r c o n h h rd o f m m n nc

n d r n c nd nc h b r E vn our con r c w h Y hw h

wh h r p o u y ob r v d or b om n d nv ov h m u p c on

of Shor y f r comp ng h T hrd Cr q u K n n

r pon o p ub c qu onn r x m n d h p rob m of ng

h f h of h oogy u d n C n f h b d or no h

nc o ff h o r fu h o go o ng p r c y o n b nd

f h w h ou g r ou nd o r gr d ? O r g n p r h p h A m g h y

H m f h p rov n m nd g n o b dd c d o h x g nc of

656




6/18

ML N

ng f God c nb d o h v for ny hng h n m y

w b n h ncon rov r b n c y of h No on no

d by God by h God of h O d T m n w ho h ow d

w o p rp u pur u p rp u rup ur Ev n h S n c

b o v d w ho g o w y o r w k c k d ou d p n d ng o n wh h r y ou

r r d n g h S n c v r o no fG o h o r God b c m

ub d r y ng d v c for h p r d c dm on p o cy n

G rm n V ruch un w h mp on m n c mrg r of

wh ch N ch m k g ood u Th d v h v b m rk of

p rm n n ng p pr u on n m for n op r o n h

ng g h u b c n r dc w y

Th f gur of h om h ng h p rm mod rn

x nc bu ck d rm n on b ong o wh N ch

w our g o f xp rm n on Sc nc f nv u o r d h

c n of x p rm n on fr c ur d prom nd r c u d

proc dur h h or c r n w or qu on m rk wh ch

h xp r m n d p o on h g n r d O f n w r ncour

g d o k n w r p rov o n or r gu v n rm h h v

b n r d o n y r r v d fo r r ry h o ry or h or yof g nf c

on Bu h r r o conc p u nd nc rg y u nch ng d

h k h rm n u c p ro dd ng W h h r w r c n v ng h

n r n m o f c n f c gr m m r or c n n ng f f c o fd c v

dr f h d c r b n o u r dom n of gn fc on h w y c nc

p rod uc h r r ch c c hm f f c v r yw k o r u mb of f

Wh h nk h r c ond b h v or o f b cu u r o d rug

xp r m n on xp r m n h r hough xp r m n po

c c or wh N ch f o h p rv v n of n xp r

m n d p o o n? h m br c d f of h h r d gn f r

m r c on cd n c or do b o k n m or r ou g gr v on of

c on m n v n dc om mu nc v d p on ?

Th w y w ob r v c n c h f d of nqu ry bu o h

g n o nof v u N ch work c nb n o w v round

d ff r n p propr on of ng nd for h r on h w n

o o ok m or c o y wh r c kn g h p h nom n on h

p p r o h v f o wn b n h ph o o ph c r d r E v nw hr

n g m n o n d d o n o b c om n ob c of n qu ry or

f d of d c ov r y g n o f n xou d c r p nc y Hu r p o n

h b rk mom n wh n h qu on of ng m rg n h

r f c o n on c n c n n yc h w rv round N ch

n r y h ng h mbu v ng h mu nm rk d n h Cr N c h

657




7/18

AVTAL RONELL

for h p r n roduc h x pr m n urn n h mo p r on of

h b ook h G y Sc nc S h ph o oph r onc n

no un c n dd n ou nc h m r g nc W m u n v r o g h of

h N ch n mb v n c ow rd x p rm n on W h h fu

ur ng ngh gogg nd h n v r dr r h n d

h wou dm k h w nd grow nd for w h

conc n r o n c mp h m o u nr r c d x p r mn bor

o ry n m od r nh o ry p r o f h w o c n f c k now d g

A h m m hough m h ood f know dg

N ch h op d w ou d no b b b d o r on or form of

u r bu w ou d m br c d n g r v c or h ro c f n g N c h

n o d c n c c p c y f or m k ng m m n g x o f oy f r u p

So f r h o w v r c n c d p r v d m n o f h o y m k n g h m co d r

mor k u o c N ch ddr h mo pr ng

d m nd o h c n c of h fu ur H k h ccoun f or

p cu r p ro du c o n of m n n g f or p c n d p c n h um n

x nc n n N ch ou o f nd ruc ur of

po b y h r ch b y ond f wh wh m n n ng h

rr fr g b nv m n n h w or d mp or n o r m mb r h

N ch h d no g w y c r h w ou d k h m o my f d

E w h r h ou gh h r v r d o h d r n g n d d h n g rh y hm o f

mor x nc f r c nn dby h Gr k S h d dno b h

h r g h o f wo rd b y on do r pp f or cr d o r n c nd n

o n h rk Wh v r h f u h d d no h rk h n of

r p on b y o h w or d h r n d no w wh ch n v d r ou b o n

m ny v nd n d ff r n r L k Hu r f r h m hou gh

h y b y no m n f or m d p r n r h p h u r g nc y h o ug h o

d dr c on c rn n o h c n f c ch r c r o f h c n c b u

r h r wh h y or wh c n c n g n r h d m n nd cou d

m n f or hu m n x n c m n c h ch D n 12 n o rd r o h nk

h w or d r g o ro u y o n c n n o o n g r u r n on f c f ro m h

p r u r p o n o f c n c n om r how n v b r c on d or

u v h r m pr on r R d n g nd con ng H d gg r

F r dr ch N c h T h G y Sc n c W r K uf m nn r n N w Yor k R nd om

Ho u 1 974 T rn o nof D f r oh c h W n ch f K r S ch c h d F r nk fu r m

M n B r n U n V r g 1979

1 2 Ed mu nd H u r T h C r n E ur op n S c n c n d Tr n c n d n P h no m no og y

E v n on N or h w r nU nv r y P r 1 970 C hp r f v ? 2 T h p o v c

r du c on of h d of c n c T h c r of c n c h o of m n n gfor

f

658




8/18

MLN

m n h c nc f hor of h nk ng d W n ch f d nk

n c h D r r d n k c n c o m o ur n ng n d m m or y 13 L c n

b u d h E h c o f P yc ho n y u nd r h h or o n of c n f c

n cro chm n w y h r r dy o r up m or b ow you

w y ho d w y b u of n n h m od o fd n f on c ou d

w k o r u rn w y f ro m h w y of h c n f c pr g v n n o fo ur

mod rn y Y wh r ? Wh ? How do N ch c on r u

h p o b y of c nc h o b r h f orc of n r mn b

r nc ?

03Provng Ground

wr from ph o oph c n d u ch n d x o r p ond

o h qu on of ng Th prob m h h h n o y

b c om qu on ho ug h b o ng o n v r m u n gf orm of

qu o nn g A h w hc h g m nd c or rob or or c on

v r y h wh ch c rr h c on d r b bu rd n of d g m ng

u m d fo rm o f k no w d g o r g p h rm c u c c r n n d

o h r dc v c m of n p mo og c o r pro c v ord r h

o nc f f rm n d d pr v h w o r d of c on f d nc b o n g

o p c f c q u n c of for c h n o o m uc h nn h

d qu f Th c on u n of n n v b bord r n h nd of

ng on S n on of form h m nf h u xury of

d r uc o n L m h o d of fon h f or no w w g h r o on

nough Un h n h nk of h h wh ch d vnc h

c hno og c g f no h ng w r

A cc or d ng o N c h c n c o n f or b dd n b y Go d h

A m gh y m nf d m nd g n H m or rror of c n c

F h v o g n c nc

A on p on N ch h xp r mn fr d om from h

con r n of r f rn ru h Sc n c m h m h oug h r c

v nd ncy o r duc f o c cu v ff ccy nd qu r y n

h r p ro r of u on d mb ng n r pr on nd m k H

r d r c c n c o r g u r ng n nc n comp c y

F or my p r m n h r v r o nor ob d by c n c

op on h m u f h w gh h pr upon our

bod our m b rr d n of prom nd m p n nd

13 n M m o r f or P u d M n N w Y o rk C o um b U n v r y P r 1 98 6 n d

whr

659




9/18

AVTAL RONELL

conn c o n o wor d h o wh ch m pu nd o h r h v o

ndur by wh ch h b n g g gd hum n n ow d y

r c v d f n on On h v ry rgh n f c du y o k of

c nc f c p b o f d vo n g f o cur ng h cond on f or

h nk ng oy ou n n d h f fr m o n of f T ho c on d o n r

n o o b c on r u d mp c or r gr v u o p n nyon w ho

h b n c rcu d h rough p ycho n y r Or c n c

r y on y b n h n d opromo h g c on h r

on h y c c u v g rd of h chno og c d om non d

w h h p r n m n c o f wor d o nd mon y ng

pr v g ?On do n o h v o b M rx o h h r r

o o f w c n f c c v n ou rm d n o n ou gh c r r ou nd

f fu on Y c nc m m

For ong wh con mp d ub o h y Th Pr c

W A r P yng for Sc n c ong h n of N ch m n

h p rc w r p y ng for W gn r h v o um h h p rc

g r how ng dr v hrou gh h b ckro d of c n f c

x p rm n on n d d v r c r o gr ph o fru p ur A om o f

h nf c o n n d fo d n d c ng mu b p u n c ommun

c o n w h h r h o r c f g u r o f r on y h v n o f ou nd m uc h n

h p h o o p h o f c n c o r n c n f c d c ou r o n r o ny

d c v r h o rc c b r on for h f of h Ev n h ou gh

n g d d r ou p r for m nc c n b u nd r o od o r y on

dv n c d h or o f ron c v o c w ho f on b ur nou r

v ry b d d y no m r co nc d nc h N ch upr m

ron d h n v g on n oour x pr mn cu u r or h

R om n c r on g h r d r ou nd h Sc h g b ro h r d

n d d m oc r c y wh n u nc h ng h r o ur n h A h n d u m B o h

ron y nd n g nv ov c r n o r nc f or r k k ng n d fu

h w r p n g d g o f m p or n g o n Bo h p ro du c n ov

x p r n c o f br k d ow n n d d r up o n O n c n r y o p u h

b r k n d r cu p r r on y u np r d c b c on q u n c h r nk n g

b ck from n w r n of d ruc v p rop n h wh

P u d M n w rn g n n h c of P r S ond nd W yn

B oo h4 or on c n r y o r d k rod o b u n o n

h rown off d h d k pu n c ry o r n h hypo h

h n h nd rony k ng b ow u w y

14 P u d M n T h Co nc p o f r on y n T h A h c d o o gy A nd r W rm n k

d M n n p o U nv r y of M nn o P r 1 99 8

660




10/18

ML N

04 Uchron

Th r w m w h np h oophy n d c n c w r n o ch o h r

bo u n d o n c h o h r T h o n c ou d n o d o o rb w h o u h

o h r p on ff r of fu on d r T h r r commun

c on c u ody b v on h r dho d y n r work nd

on c d m c p n Bu h o d comm m n h b n b rok n n

w y h n rud u pon h cour of r ou v ng Hu r of n

y T h you ng o nof h r m m b r du no n Hu r w

p rh p h o n mo fr k d ou b y h h or c p For h p r

H u r u r g d c u o n wh n c m o d v oc n g r p pr oc h m n

of h v rd p r m k h wro for h hum n c

d c p n o rugg w h h n ur c n c for qu r g h A

o on h y conc d o h r h r ob c v y f u ff c ncy

h y h m v f p r y o ob c v m 15 L r r y nd p h o op hc

ud r nd r cr c m r k g ng u ck d n by h ru n g

c n f cc m h n n g u hor y of wh Hu r c ob c

v m Th ud h c nc gv u h E n ung f

d p ng n d ur pp ng h f ox c r d u of un n r rog d

p o c n ow b co m d c v Th d u o n of f u ff c n cy

m rk of h f v c r on of h c n c d ch d from h r

r f c v g rou nd n d b y d ng r ou f or u b oc kn gv o n

n d c p n g fu u r y S oHu r m or o r Up gr d d by h or c

y Th o h r on N ch cr d Th w nd grow 16

H r h qu on mrk h br ng o h b Why h h

h ro ug ho u h o ry b u p r h p m o p r v v y o d y c om o

d f n o ur r o n o qu on o f r u h kn ow d g n d v n

r y? no m r of choo ng b w n c n c of f c nd

c n c o f n c b w n n c co un o f wh y h ng r c u

r h r h npo b Nor mp y m r of chno og c f

u nd r nd ng f h c n f c r f c o n on ow np ro c du r

n dp r m c ou d fy p h o op hc hu ng r T h rm u b c

po on w ou d no c ov r h c m y o f h f d h nc om p

h w o A m m y d u b c po on m r duc d o

h of h v r ng r bb o r g m or ou y f r g of r p rod d d

n dp ro b d c o n d n d co rn r d by h c hn oog c f r A

1 5 Hu r T h C r n E ur op n S c n c n d Tr n c n d n P h no m no og y C h p r

f v ?2

16 S p c y H d gg r d cu on of h chno og c mp c on o f h

u r n c n W h C d T h nk n g? N w Y o rk H r p r & R ow 1 96 8

661




11/18

AVTAL RONELL

r c por o h nv v d m nd my r bb r r h kng

f gu r con ur d by H d g g r o x m p ry n ng d on o

know f my n ng d v c x mp r y nor do n on u n ng

h p h o h prop h m g g h r d n h p c L k good

N ch n r c p or m u nd o h c onf c n g v u o n o f

h p h nom n u nd r con d r on m no n n v o h

b r o ry p o n of n gon g ro und w h ch o y o f

r c n n g on c r n hrow ng off h cur y b n k of m

n d h o ry T hr om h n g bou h r on h p o r uh h

dp nd on h Why for x mp h h mo pr ng

h c nd po c u of our d y ncr ng y m o h v m or

o do w h ng h n w h o h r nm for qu on ng h on

o r v n c r n y ?

T h d rv c ov r o o f gr ou nd n d p of f n o df f r n

houg hr d m n c f d Y of n h r r m om n of o c

o rfu nc o n r d u p c on o v r p n d u pp or On d o f n g

r v n f nd ng h o h r vu n r b w hn coun n g

o Th r h h nd ground nd rd d nd

qu pp d w h rr fu b r u So c m nd o nd T h r

h o h r h c r h g n w co p c r ud nd

v by f u r v by dy ng or d roy ng A or of u

c om o h for nc ud ng h o h d w h norm h

b h n g bo un d r n nor m v y n d h o h r y o n x p r

v n n cour o f w o n xp r w n Th o n r g r of

n g of f r r u c r u d b y wh ch o c c u nd c ou n on

h o h r A no h r rg r con n y d ch from roo d n

n r u h f d o v ng n d v r p ro b ng d p n d o n bo un d ry

cro n g f nd h c o p of hor on mp c po c o f

r k h N c h h hown o non p g o b nk d o conc p

of fr d om O n h n x p g h c h r c r c y co nr d c

h m f p on ng o h g r v r k cr bb o h c u ur of h

V ruch h or r Th wo pr nc p r g r r m u p d b y

o h r n c rp o n n d mp y on no h r v r c ru c u nc u r

Suppo w k h mp qu on of x pr mn ng

w h ch o u ch v r y h ng f ro m w rf r o u rb n p n n n g m r y

r gy n d n o n cur y p c m d c nd r produc v

ch no og h p or o f h c d ru g nd po yg r ph n g h

r od of Oymp cG m nd h v r ou m n of

m ur ng n d ng h u ppor mong o m ny o h r p o c

r g ou nd duc o n n u on no d ff cu o h

h m od o f n g n vo v h or ou gh go n g r co n u o n n d

662




12/18

ML N

r conc p u on of h ub c Th h v ry h ng o d ono

on yw h h w y h po c ng of po c nd bod k p c

n ou rm od r n y bu o w h o ur x p r n c o f r y n g n r

pc y n c h p c c rcu h n ow h b n b h d

b w n ng n d h r of n w ork o c nc h d ff r nc

b w n h wo dom n

E v r n c F r ud n r od uc d h c ru c c on c p of r y n g

h u hor y of r y h n o o ny b n und rm n d bu u

h b n u bm d o v rou ng p pr u who con u on

nd gn f cnc n d o b n v g d F r ud c u y work d

on wo on of wh ch w o o u h R d p rfung n d h

A k u p r fung w hch p p r o d ng u h b w n r y n d

m md c y Th p ych c k prov d d h b for h bor

o n of V r n n u n g n d w r c ru c n h h n k ng o n m ou rn n g

L c nh nk d ng o h ub c cr on of f r ou d

p c h no ong r h m r y

T o r g d g r m o v d b y h c c on d r on m y con c rn

w h h c om pu o no rd rv o m or ov r x p or h w y n

w h ch h c om o r q u r n u n pr c d n d c o oq uy o f

w n v dnc r b y nd n n r n w ork of pp r u

m n o nforc h nd f nd ng 17 Wh h r c r y d or

r g y d v o w d mod o f n g nf orm d v r y p o f o c

org n on g m ng cruc nd of n r r v r b d cur v

nd nc nd m nd ng d c o n n rm o f h p o c mp c

on o f n g on n d on y co n d r h w y w r r w g d o n

m r nd ob c nd h wy h k p o on of

h b od y pr u mp v y o n dr ug T n g m n m on g o h r h n g

h your p b ong o h or o n y n u o nor p pr u

h hr v o n h n w c v cr d b y my du y o br ng u b ck

o h m or or gn g b y o fyour ur n mp or f

m un b o r o r your p o prop r p c o r c h

c on o ur o f h c om p c d h g m on y of n g

05 P r o o y p T h G y S c n c

T h m n n gof c n f c y h conc rn N ch mbr c h

q u b oh of d r uc v nd r c mod of p ro du c on O ur

17 For h h or c u o f v d nc cf R d g r C mp B Ev d n B gr ff

u nd F g ur v on E v d n n B u m g r n A h k n D u c h Z c hr f f r P h o o ph 4 9

2001 243255

663




13/18

AVTAL RONELL

b n g h b n mod d by h v r ou chno og n w y h

hv b g un f r y rc n y o r c v r ou n o n n h d om n

of on o og y h c p o c h ory c yb r n c c r c h ou gh n d

r f c n g nc Y wh conc rn N ch b o ng n h r

r y n d nor ou d ny of h dom n b u h non h

n f r d h r v ry cor om h ng n d d h N ch G y

S c w f r o r c u u cc nc y b f or fo r n n c P op p r

H mp C rn p n d o h r o ok u p N c h v r ou y m o v

h c n f c pr m of h w ork by rm h nd c h c v

of n g wh ch for h m n cu d x p r m n on r h yp o h c

p o ng r r nd mor ng f ny hng G y Sc gn o u

o d y h x n o w hc h ou r r pp or o h w or d h u nd r go n

co n d r b m u o nb ym n o fou r dh r nc o h m p r v

o f n g Th c on q u nc of h g rd r c on d r b n vo v ng

o y h our r on o x p n ory nd d cr p v ngu g

ru h conc u v n r u prob b y c cu on p roc nd

d n y T ng m or ov r m p for N ch v r y p c fc m po

r nf c o n H n c for h v ry h ng w h v o nd h of

m w hch o y h v rprov o n h ng w conc p

m u b r d n dp rov n n d r uc u r y r g u d b y h d r uc

on of h h yp oh h ho d h m o g h r

W h f n y h n ur of h ? Do h v n nc ?

pur r on y? How do p r c p n N ch gr

d b on or promp h n h c d of v u ? Why od y

ou r n o f c ur y w h h r o rn o w r p r p r d o d m h

b d on b y? W wn v ryon nd v ry hng d m

no u n wr o f h n r r on nc o f h o b r v o n Bu nc

wh n h d r gn d by hum n y no b n pu d b y n r

u nd r o w? T n g w hc h ou r D n n co un r v r y d y n h

m u p c y of fo rm r n g ng fr om Q o co m c n gn r

nd r m ng 12 3 bro dc y m no o m n on ng

y ou r ov n gy ou rf r nd h p ng m yp n c n wo rd

ng h br k w oc d by N ch m n y n h rn oy

o f b co m ng B c o m ng n v o v h f f rm o n of p n g w y n d

d ro yn g h d c v f u r of D on y n p h o op hy n h

f r p c ng m rk n v r n w r on m ong forc C ng

o r o n f n y or f n u d o r o m on o r m c co rd ng o h

pu of G rm n d m mpo h c our of un m d

f n n Th h mpor y w now common y oc w h

h r d g n r o n m ch n c yb r n c n d n fo rm o n c h no og y

n w y c hn oo gy n u r v ov ng p r p u on b yqu y

664




14/18

ML N

po ng o p urpo n nf n r of ng v n v rd

fro m ny m p r c f un c on T hu n p c c rc u h b n

b h d b w n ng nd h r c rcu o rd c y

n d rr vr b c nc h n d ff r nc b w n

h nd wh w um d ob r A h po n o mwh r

b w n Fr ud nd N ch no o much h c h r y

b ng d bu h ng con u v of wh c n b

d gn d w h h prop rpr cu on r c u m r y

nb d Th wh ow for h m rg nc of r y o

r f Th r on of o r y my hv ood ground

nc P r f Bu on y n c N ch h w k wh h r

c v y or ob c h d cov r xpo b h or prh p

v n n v n h g r ou nd o n wh c h w w k h w k

T ng w h ch w r d on o f h p r v ng f gu r o f ou r

mod rn y m k c m of b ou n om h ng h b n

d n dprov d w h v r u bu o ny n rm of

mpor ry o d y op n up h h occur N ch ug

g f r Chr n y h f d r rv ng og h r w h c r n

h r o nh p of n r pr on o x p r nc N o ong r

qu on of n rp r n g on ow n xp r n c p ou p o p h v

on g nou gh n rp r d h r n m y h ou gh w r p rov d n

h n d g nd n d ord n d for h k o f h v on of h

ou h ov r now 1 8Now w g od on w r gorou y

xp rm n W r h C hr n con c nc r n d nd u b

m d n o c n f c con c nc Conv r d o c n f c y w

h ow v r c rr y r c o f Ch r n y b c u w h r um ph d ov r

h Chr n god w C hr n mor y f h c onc p o f

r u hf un h w u nd r o od v r m or r g or ou y 1 9A b

c m mor r f n d Chr n y forc d n c u c n n upon

u c m c n by pu hng c n c h ub m on of own

m urk n Now m n con c nc g n Chr n y

c on d r d n d c n n d d h on b y v r y mo r r f n d c on

c n c 2 0T h Chr n go d n u m p o ff fr om Ch r n mor y

wh ch nc r y w n down r n v u n gp h r v d nd

u rn d g n r c c r n o r gn T h n w r u h r um r qu r d

Chr n mor y o gv up h god Wh n r m h

dd o n w of r n v u o n h N ch h dow h o ry

18 T h G y S c n c 3 07

1 9 b d

2 0 b d

665




15/18

AVTAL RONELL

k c h n m y w h n h v u u rg ng r u h co nv r n o h

curr ncy of ng H nc for h n r c y N ch n rm r c

v p o ng w h v o nd up o h cru n y of r cur v ng

T h xp r m n d p o on nd h p rov o n og c of ng

h n cr bd by occur n chno og c n n v n

f r h d h of God do no rr v on h c n b rb r n

co nq u ro r b u p p ro c h m o d y f o r o nc m o r m od

h n n y h ng C hr n y h d p r op o d p ro c d n g n m y b y

h m od y of hy po h w hc h r w y o v r ur nb n dm or

d c d dy d rng T hu h r n of mod y h r d by h p r o f

ud c y w d ng r ng h c p b of r k k ng n d r m n dou

cour g g h r r ng h on m r u n h G y Sc N ch

po n g h D ony n ph o oph r wr h m or m ru h

mor p h o op hy 2 1A m n o fm ru p rf c y con n

w h h x g nc of ng o h x n h nc or

n cr p on nh b h p o ncy of con v n n c wh ch

m r y r p ond o w h h r o rn o o m h n g r u or f

D ony n p m m m n of m ru n h r ru nor

f r h r n h n ur of p rm n n hypo h

0 6 Pr o o yp L r u r n d To r ur

T n g wh ch cou d b n h hr own n of c hn oog y

r v r m ny c or o f x nc nd do no b g n x p c y

ch no og c f f o rm W h h r w r p k n g of b n do n d

b ng b ndon d n h d r on h cro hom or on h

r or d cur v y bo r d b ng o c y p nn d g y n

cr b d po c y c v d or wh r h form on m nd

n r c h k d mrk o n h p h o fb com ng nd o um

h c hr c r of V ry of n r u r und r n d h d m m

of d b n g on wh ch b o m of m o h r ro wn gn rr

on K fk c on r uc d h w h r kng n of urg ncy

From h n rr v Th T o h n r mn b T r nd h

P n C oo ny o r v n G r go r ry ng ou h g h h ung r

r w gh ng n n d K ng h m of n g b y n h

C rr o ry o h c on d m d c g n A C oun ry Doc or

nd h f h r p op qu h n do f Th J ud gm n K fk

2 1 b d

666




16/18

ML N

ubm d n gu g o h of m h f g ur prob d for

r f r nc o f n un d r or ur T h r of h m n fro m h

c ou n ry h n ur ff r d ch b m m h b n r d b y D rr d

n r m of u p n d d g p ro oc o nd o r ur d n r y x m 2 2

Th nk b w n ng n d or ur g v n mp con d r on n

K fk work bu b g n w h h Gr k no o nof b no

r ng r u h o o rur r c y con d conf u nc o f c

qu y r oub n g o Ar o nd Ar oph n L u r m mb r

oo h n h U S or u r h b n r n r od uc d r c n y

g m m n o f c n g ru h by non o h r h n f n ng

g dvoc A n D rhow Ar o qu on h r g nng

G r k ump o nwh h r r u h n f c n d by o r ur o r

wh h r h f b c u h or ur d body w y n yh ng u

opu n n d o h r

For N ch ng now c r p c h f r h Gr k w

b oc k db y mor p r ud c H v w m or p r ud c g n c n c

h c on p r cy g n d v n ur n dd r g u d kn ow d g

m po d o n u c on c y b y h c ou p F u n dM p h o ph

r u r or o h c u o f god c nc urn ou h F u w

pu o n hor h pupp r d n h nd by God M ph o

d f d nd c r d by h d v n v o o b w h

mor b A h pp n G od c nno o r h xp rm n or

p ro of D ou b c ro d M p h o n u m w m d o fu nc o n n

nh b or o h c n f c d v n ur nd h r rch on h cr ur

m n w rm n d w h ou d u p roc N ch b ow h w h

on h c om c u b r fu g T h h m c r pr oc hr p r n o n of

h v ry fw w p h N ch k Go h n r m of h

m h k om wh of r ng mom n for N ch

ck h r ry Go h f or c n f c rror A h m m

cou d b r gu d h h cr h ro of N ch c n f c n v

g on h G o h of h T h or yof Co or wh o b o d x p rm n

p u h x pr m n r on h n G o h p on r d h mom n

wh n h b od y b c m h n dn o c on d ry p rop fo r

r n cnd n ng con cou n Th h Go h h N ch

r pr w hn h g o f r h G o h wh op rod uc d h d r m of

v o f c F u brup d c h x of c n c

22 Fr n K fk Vor d mG Av Ron r n n Ac of L r ur D r k

A r d g d N w Y or k Ro u d g 1 99 2

667




17/18

AV TALRONELL

0 7 Ju c

Un now h nk d o k nd of gho fu ur y off r no

pr n h r Th xp n p rh p why N ch n m h g y

c n n h m b r h h convok w who r h om 23

N c h k no w h ow o f f rm h u nh n g ng o f ho m h

p r p r o n fo r n o h r fu u r o n n o r oo d n d o o g o f h

hom fron For N ch h r good hom n d r c

n on of b und nc w r nd b d hom n b urd n d

d u chron c y f gu dw h h r h h om n of

d p on Th og cof h h w h v no y und r ood

conc rn p rc y h r on of h o f w know on y

h ow o v h un nh b b m pp ng v r mor d r

co w nd un xp od d r n r d r r n d n on c n

r h o c d h rd wor d Th qu on h N ch p r

u o n h r for n v r m r y on o f f f rm ng hom n f r

m phy c bu o fr nd r ng p c h b b mu p y ng r c o

r for f nd h v ng r f gur ng h of x p rm n on n

uch w y o n ur h no r dy h n omb dr rv of

h v ng d d n o h r wo rd w hy h v w n o y h ou gh h

on h d of f ? mpor n o no h N ch no n

h ph of h hough h xub r n d o c n o fo d Th

N c h wh o h nk h x p rm n h c om b c k fro m h d d

v r m ov r h formu ng h h ory of h g r h h h

h r u rn d onc g n o h h n d k gr conv c n

o ok f w h om wh gho y r h d o v o ny gr du y

S h on h mov g n n dhom n b com n

x pr on of r n wd v y h o v rcom ng of r d u o n

Th hom n h N ch po n vr m p yr c v

h r f or b u p u u p b od fr on o ok ow rd h f u ur

A m on g p ro mn n f u r h b om n o nof r c m n g gr

v d n rc m r nk h gh R mb n g mom n h c r wof S r

Tr k w who r h om r oo m nfo d nd m x dr c y W

r n o mp d o p r c p n m nd c ou f d m r o n nd

r c nd c ncy 2 4R c nd c ncy N ch ugg v ry

wh r h b nc of h un d pr ump on pr

2 3 b d 3 38

2 4 b d 3 40

668




18/18

M LN6 6 9

x c n c h d o g h r b y p u do pr c p h w ou d n v r ho d

c n f c w y R c nd c ncy n d f d m r o ngo d y

o g h r f or on f d h o h r w h x pu ng ng o h rn n d

r f u ng h m ov m n o f f ov r com ng w h ch o y c

f corr c o n N ch how v r b yno m n ng up

po c corr c o n f c y n rn v p c f or hum n u b c

w g h d d own by p un h n g ch n S om h n g h o g v b r n g

h h v n h p r y h mov mn of rc u c r c

u c wh ch for N ch nd for u rv h r h on d

m onymy for p o b u c

N w Y or k U n v r y

Date post:	13-Apr-2018
Category:	Documents
Upload:	pc-ar
View:	219 times
Download:	0 times

Proving Grounds_On Nietzche and the Test Drive

Documents